My REACTION to Abhinav Chandradhud (CJI's son) on CAA | Citizenship Amendment Act | Barkha Dutt

#caa #citizenshipamendmentact2019 #chandrachud
www.misfits.bet
I can tell you firsthand that many who started preparing for the UPSC Exam with the dream of becoming IAS/IFS officers in 2024 have now dropped their plans to even appear in 2024. Why? Because they think they are not 'adequately' prepared, and they will give their best shot in 2025 now. Please do not make that mistake, and do not take a gap year. You will ruin your life!
If you are eligible to write the exam in 2024 and can dedicate around 10 hours per day to your preparations, please do not postpone your plans. Please do not make UPSC a 5-year plan.
The following should be your go-to strategy now. Just stay consistent, and you will crack the Prelims. Dedicate 10 hours per day, and here is how you should go about it.
NEETU SINGH
1. January & February:
Complete History (Ancient, Medieval, Modern) + Economics + pick up any test series to solve 30 questions daily (from February onwards). Dr. Jahnavi recently uploaded it on the LinkedIn Alumni Group.
Watch 2 episodes daily on the MisFits Learning Portal on Economics and History. How will this help?
After completion of these modules, you would have developed an innate ability to make better conjectures.
You will be better positioned to read through current affairs (via newspapers), or when you are making notes while solving the tests.
At least for Economics, you’d see more than 90% accuracy. It could reach even 95-100% if you watch the lectures twice. For history, it should be around 60%, but if you can make diligent notes from the Test Series, and revise those notes, that accuracy should reach around 80-85% (which is actually pretty good).
Manuj Jindal
Don’t worry about the Mains at this stage. Inadvertently, you’d be prepared for the Mains - we took a lot of effort to make sure that these video lessons cover things comprehensively. The only difference in Mains vs. Prelims preparation is how you go about solving test papers, and the focus on remembering certain specificities.
Please watch through the session before Episode 19 (under the Geography heading) for my thoughts on Prelims 2024, and how you should make the best use of MisFits Episodes + Tests.
2. March & April:
Complete Geography, Environment, Science and tech.
Watch 2 episodes daily on the MisFits Learning Portal + Solve Test Papers (as shared on the LinkedIn Alumni Group). How will this help?
A large part is static & conceptual - if you have learned those concepts well, you should get good accuracy in these subjects.
You would have logically solved many UPSC Prelims & Mains questions and will be well-positioned to solve potential questions from this part.
Aspects of mapping would also be covered via this.
3. Last Week of April + May (until the 2nd week):
Watch through Polity and Governance Episodes on the MisFits Portal.
• Is India becoming a DI...
Watch 2 episodes daily on the MisFits Learning Portal. The reason for covering Polity at the end is so that some factual data checked in the exam are fresh in your mind as/when you write the UPSC.
Polity for Prelims is very predictable; 20% effort here would yield 80% returns. By this time, you will be adequately prepared to better grasp Polity (because you can see the interconnections I have made across Geography, Environment, Economics, etc., for all of you).
If you had followed the above methods, you would have completed the following things by the 2nd week of May:
1. Foundations of History, Economics, Polity, Governance, Geography, Science & Tech, and Society.
2. Current Affairs via solving around 30 Contemporary Test Papers. (Retaining information via these current affairs would be much easier for you because your foundations
3. Past 14 years of UPSC official papers.
But, wait. Cracking Prelims is not the only thing. You won’t get medals for this. The next stage is extremely critical. Focus on cracking the exam in one go. How will that happen?
After your Prelims - take a 1-week break. And then do the following:
Step 1: Watch through the Playlist on Foreign Policy Classroom with Amb. Anil Trigunyat.
Step 2: Watch through the Playlist on Essays (250 Marks).
Step 3: Watch through the Masterclass on Structures.
Step 4: Watch through the Playlist on Ethics (250 Marks).
Step 5: Revise Economics until your UPSC Prelims Result is out!
• Video
Keep attending special sessions - where I will cover some issues from scratch.
Be part of answer writing communities at MisFits (after your Prelims Result).
Additionally, your Mains GS is done along with the above episodes. Focus your 3 months on Optionals.
After your Mains - There will be a series of around 7-10 lectures that will help you in getting 200+ in the interviews.
Stop watching Free KZbin Videos and crash Courses. Many of these are sub-standard resources. Minimize your resources

[@Modric-nk9oq]

"Only in the KZbin comment section there is a democracy " - well said 😂

[@sau-bittu]

KZbin should add an algorithm to suggest counter POV videos of current video being watched by its user to get the full picture of any topic, for the benifit for lazy people who hates researching facts. That will be true democratization of KZbin feed itself😅

[@proudhindustanihindu2725]

Jewish are not included in CAA because in Israel there is a policy according to which any Jewish around the world residing in any part of the country can become the citizen of israel by directly coming to Israel

[@EPFOEXAM]

In Our neighbouring countries there are less than 1 dozen Jews collectively. And some who living in Bangladesh have citizenship of Israel.

[@user-qv6sk8hv2v]

So what

[@trueindian3573]

Jews dont gave to struggle for citizenship in any country because Israel will be there for them

[@Freespeech5257]

So? Bro, in a secular country religion is not a mandate for such things. If they are facing persecution, then they can apply for it, if it's found that they are facing such prblms, then it can be granted. This is all becz of religion becoming a birthright. If choice of religion was a right then what this wouldn't have been an easy decision

[@trueindian3573]

@@Freespeech5257 Don't talk rubbish, pls read about origin of caa why it 2as introduced...religious persecution is the criteria and it was Introduced to help the struggling minority community which had to suffer due to partition...why are u going to all other religions on earth when the reason for caa introduction was to help hindus and minorities who got stuck at islamic countries

[@pritish3484]

Why they (Al Jazeera) are not calling CAA anti Hindu or anti Buddhists (Bhutan/ Sri Lanka) ? Anything that doesn't promote the interest of Islamism is anti Muslim for them.

[@googletranslatesongs6042]

but according to Al Jazeera Muslim are being prosecuted in India so why they want other Muslim to go India to be prosecuted

[@try_dc6366]

​@@googletranslatesongs6042persecuted.

[@TransgirlsEnjoyer]

just click on three dots and select dont recommend channel for al jazeera videos

[@user-qz3to7gd5l]

@@googletranslatesongs6042 If Muslims are persecuted in India then why Muslims want citizenship in India through CAA??

[@meerahmed12345]

@@user-qz3to7gd5lIf a Muslim is persecuted in his own home, is the solution for him to disown the home? How ridiculous.... Are you even educated? Education and sense of Logic is the weakest link of India...

[@taylor114e]

This is how an educated self-made person speaks. Hats off to you, Naman Sir! You and Sai Deepak are some of my favorite people

[@akashamruthe9557]

Sai Deepak is not a neutral guy.....he's right wing spokesman

[@Anandssr2114]

Tho apko kya dikkat hai bhai sahab aur ek hai anand ranganath and poonewala ❤

[@Leo-hd5dz]

Sai Deepak!! You have to listen to him more to understand his agenda and bias. Listen to him on the free temple movement and reservation, and you will get a clear picture. He is the Sadguru of political analysts."

[@akshaysharma7595]

​@@Leo-hd5dzwhats wrong on free temple movement?

[@bharathsy]

Sai Deepak really? He is jus a religious idiot who speaks shit and only has myopic view

[@bhaskarjyotiborah2023]

because we Assamese don't want t o see these vote bank politics anymore. Congress made Bangladeshi muslims as their vote bank and BJP is doing this. You see, the naturalisation process is always there, but when these EXISTING BANGLADESHIS or these religious Minorities, will get the voting right, will also compete for job etc, what will happen to a state like Assam which is burdened with influx since ages. Don't know about rest of the country, but in Assam we want the safeguard of the Clause 6 of historic ASSAM ACCORD, that's it, that's what we want. The Northeastern states except Assam has ILP system, why not in Assam ? Why these legislatures shows reluctancy in implementing such provisions ? We don't care what has Chandrachud's son said, we're concerned about the future of Assamese community, that's it.

[@ankurjyotisarma7202]

question is of accommodation more than legality of CAA.Bcz In Assam indegenous culture is badly diluted in many of the districts, assam has been accommodating more than other states, govt shall come up with just distribution policy, they must not be dumped in few states otherwise encroachment./riots may follow

[@bhaskarjyotiborah2023]

@@ankurjyotisarma7202 true

[@adwaitvedant3297]

I am a bengali, If u cannot accommodate bengali Hindus...plz send them to west bengal and we will accommodate them Via CAA...end of debate

[@EPFOEXAM]

All India shall share the burden not alone Assam. Your concerns are genuine because of your past experience & dirty politics of Congress and Gan Parishad. Just be brave & push for more & more funds & organised rehabilitation at Centre level for coming prosecuted people. I am from Haryana. During partition our state host all prosecuted Punjabi caste cum community. And a person of this community Manohar Lal Khattar is CM of Haryana. This community is almost 8% population in Haryana. But there is not any kind of hostility or enmity between this community & local people of Haryana Most of Sindhi people are living in Maharastra and are now Integrated part of Maharastra identity They shall be settled in organised way so that no unnecessary political bank emerged Govt of India shall make liberal provision of fund for these person. And these people are not hostile to our culture so they shall easily assimilate

[@halokdebbarma9342]

We don't have ILP system in Tripura too.

[@ballabhjyotiroy4026]

Everyone who is opposing caa is talking about violation of article 14 but none is talking about violation of The Assam Accord.why?? Only about discrimination of Muslims but nothing for The Assamese.

[@ashishkoge9325]

Your CM is not speaking on it

[@WashimAkram]

what's your CM doing?

[@pikachue602]

​@@ashishkoge9325 he said,"none outside NRC will be allowed" Apparently NRC Assam was done in early 2022

[@user-qz3to7gd5l]

How Indian constitutional Article 14 is applicable to foreign refugees in India??

[@sohailansari8027]

We should not accept anyone no refugees . There is not enough resources for the indian citizens , why should be accept any refugees. Be it from any community or any religion . Totally in support of nrc but not in support of caa.

[@all30254]

Pakistan and Bangladesh must implement CAA for Muslim in India🎉❤🎉

[@thisisprayag4172]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@vish6618]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@all30254]

@@vish6618 kahe huss rahe ho ye Muslim ka huk he

[@reiilym]

Please I beg,

[@NidzShah-ps6kr]

They did... It's called partition and it worked out well for them 🙄

[@user-ho3ty5bn5f]

When a religiously persecuted Hindu flees Pakistan to seek shelter in India, after being forced to relinquish his home and property there, asking him to bring full documents and papers to seek citizenship is like rubbing salt on his wounds. It makes him vulnerable to face corruption and further exploitation at the hands of lower level clerks and officials in both countries. Son of Chief Justice educated at Harvard may not have any experience to feel their pain. Please leave these bookish arguments for people like him keen to project his lernedship.

[@HrishabhJoshi-me3xv]

Why hasn't the nepotism (Collegium) in the court system changed? There will be plenty of talented lawyers and judges who can be CJI. Since Ahmediya chose Pakistan, now they should reap the benefits of it, we are not responsible for them.

[@pranjalahluwalia9115]

? Pakistani Hindus

[@chinmaya021]

@@pranjalahluwalia9115Pakistani Hindus did not choose Pakistan but it was imposed on them. Many able to come to Bharat through blood shed and many could not.

[@pranjalahluwalia9115]

@@chinmaya021 agreed no body choose partition making distinction that somebody remained in pakistan or India is their choice is fools falacy

[@anushkasharma7334]

​@@pranjalahluwalia9115nobody chooses partition,are you a fool . 99% of Indian Muslim voted for a separate Islamic nation ,it's a fact 😂😂

[@pranjalahluwalia9115]

@@anushkasharma7334 sure miss you can share the link where I can read and increase my knowledge. we had a communal electorate at that time which meant Muslim voters would vote exclusively for Muslim seats. provinces from current day India -places like Bombay and Madras, which had zero chance of being part of a future Pakistan - gave a 100% mandate to Jinnah. Muslims voted for Muslim league by your logic everyone voting for bjp is voting for hindutva?

[@RahulKumar-eq8bu]

Sir if CAA is unconstitutional . Then waqf act , minority commission, 1991 worship act, haaz subsidy is not unconstitutional. If country divide on basis of religion then why not for giving citizenship on basis of religion. Muslim is persecuted on basis of sect or caste in Muslim community. But Muslim, Sikh Hindu is persecuted on basis of religion. If we citizenship to Muslim thy why we given two countries Bangladesh and Pakistan to Muslim. But Jews should be in CAA according to me.

[@EPFOEXAM]

Parliament need to recognise the fact that India was divided on the basis of religion. We need to get our basics right first.

[@sohailansari8027]

Though the waqf act is totally unconstitutional i agree on that should be removed. Though monority commission is not constituitional , haaz subsidy was unconstitutional and has been removed, and the 1991 places of worship act is also not unconstitutional.

[@foodwithbenefits5169]

right

[@mjgaming7603]

​@@sohailansari8027what place of worship act is not unconstitutional , I mean how can't a temple of past which have been demolished and a mosque have been build so I can't take it back what non sense 🤔 It is 100 % unconstitutional

[@dipeshpal9428]

​@@sohailansari8027Can't agree, place of worship act is 1000% unconstitutional, this kind of one-sided acts are the main reason for violence and riots in India.

[@Abhyuday__14]

THE SHIYA AND AHMADIYA WHO DOESN'T HAVE GUTS TO FIGHT FOR THEMSELVES IN THEIR OWN COUNTRIES ARE FIGHTING IN INDIA😁😁😁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@tanzil_khan001]

Hindus in pakistan have guts?

[@koteswar009]

and Ahmadiya is one of the main forces in formation of Pakistan

[@PP-eg3fc]

@@koteswar009 Even now Shia Owaisi asking to remove police for 15 minutes

[@VivekKumar-kn8du]

​@@PP-eg3fc Then again they will play victim card.

[@pakshimitra-friendsofbirds9965]

They should not do these kind of things here

[@VivekTiwari-dq2sz]

Sir i am not upsc aspirant but still i watch ur video because u tell ground reality

[@user-qz3to7gd5l]

The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is a brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity. - Said by Baba shaheb Ambhedkar

[@sachinkumar-ty8gu]

Sir, what I think is we are forgetting the intention of law passed by the Parliament. It's not at all about granting citizenships. That can be done under Part-2 of the constitution and under Citizenship Act. The present discourse on CAA is about restituting the ill effects on those who were not the cause of the Partition in which Ahmadias do not come in. It's civilizational duty too to correct the mistakes for those to fought for their beliefs system against Islamic Fundamentalism which took 2 pieces of the land.

[@starrysky1128]

Its just votes .all your Mps children's live are tooo SUPER RICH. observe around you. U chose Gundas

[@reiilym]

Ho gya? Toxicity in its peak​@@starrysky1128

[@DeepakSharma-dc4gd]

I am not UPSC aspirant but well educated 45 Yr old. I have lived in US for many years. The real question is How can we help minorities of other countries WHEN our own citizens are under threat. What are we able to do for our own countrymen? Just publishing fake GDP numbers doesn't mean India is progressing - 80cr people are living on 5kg ration from govt. This CAA is purely to bring on poor from other countries and get thier votes. Indian citizens and democracy is hijacked by BJP and they are playing this game just for votes. Every sensible country only importing well educated top line people into thier country. We are exporting all our top talent because people are fed up of the system in India. CAA will make it worse.

[@jeanette_suzanne]

😂 Humare yaha aisa hi hota h. Apne rog ko chhod hr kiska ilaaj h

[@ajaypalvai]

This is what happens when people believe that they are well educated because they have lived in USA , they may write Sharma in their name but wrap janyu around their Genitals, and comeup with logics like these 👏👏

[@priyeshmishra1425]

We are exporting all our top talent because of freebies and reservation and our oldest party congress say if Congress come in centre then they remove 50% reservation criteria they increase reservation so what we general students do???

[@Aratiii06]

Why don't you speak of the huge illegal migrants, mainly muslims who have migrated to India and tmc and congress have made them their vote bank?

[@antrikshkumar239]

Well educated and "fake gdp numbers", selectively criticizing one particular party doesn't make sense. Just having an overview of issues makes your statements baseless

[@thinkaskandlearn9685]

Wow sir amazing, pls react on waqt board act too 😊 otherwise viewers will say you are paid. Common sir 😊

[@shubh8100]

Thank you Naman sir , since 2 days i have been reading various articles and editorial about this topic but the clarity and an unbiased perspective about CAA which i got from this video is unmatched. Thank you once again for this video !! Jai Hind!!

[@lovemsoni1844]

Abhinav's logic - Even if there are no Jews in Pak BD then also jews should be written. I mean then what is this CAA left for?

[@yushpi]

He wants CAA to either solve all the world's humanitarian problem or not exist at all!

[@SachinSingh-mf5eu]

Any jew living anywhere in the world is a citizen of Israel under Israel's laws, so why would any jew live as a refugee in india for 6 years when he can go to Israel. That's the reason they've not been mentioned

[@somnath2453]

Abhinav Chandrachud is entitled to make his point, but I do not subscribe to his views. I think he is immature.

[@abhinavsisodiya617]

article 14 also has doctrine of reasonable classification as an exception

[@Mersey0810]

I love this channel very much ...thank you sir for being here !!!❤❤❤❤

[@priyankadas7853]

Thank you so much sir. whenever i have any doubt or m confused to form opinion you are my go to person. The way you explained things in simplest way with facts is astounding.

[@thisismyuser_name]

You should do your own research and listen to both side of the arguments , know both sides of the coin and then form your OWN OPINION .

[@samisamisps]

Dear , Not everyone's opinion is totally right....all have different opinions with some good and some bad sides.... But in this video many point are absolutely right...but some are very wrong...like BCCI chairman..... I agree that Hindu tourched in Pak and Bangladesh ....but what about Muslim and Sikh in there own country... Muslim are also tourched by Hindus to chant Jai shree ram....and They called Muslims of India are also terrorist and Sikhs are khalistani.....what that fuck this is...... So think with open mind and then react on that particular situation or statement...

[@gauravthakur9634]

Man I wish we could get this whole conversation❤❤❤ #zeher 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@Muleslover]

We are spokes person of India🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳.❤❤ Beautiful line and i will remmenber till my death. God bless you sir. You are enlighting everyone .

[@surbhijindal3741]

Can we please get the full version of this video ?

[@bve8155]

Naman sir your" dynastic " Politics, judiciary ......explanation In India , Give me another level of belligerence. Thanks🙏

[@amitmani2464]

Sir i heard this thing started from nehru liyakat pack is that true please cover that also.

[@ak.1780]

Every new video gives me a new perspective of thinking. Thanks a lot Sir ✨️

[@bhanupratapchoudhary5187]

Why people don't understand that anyone can get citizenship through registration but govt made special efforts to grant citizenship to religious perscuted people in pak afg and ban.

[@ashonvills]

Because instead of clearing citizenship doubts your modiji do maan ki baat which is bare propaganda and all other bjp mps only do blame game rather than answering simple questions when asked. And the rest confusion is created by congress party the seculars whose sole purpose is to spread fake info about all acts.

[@SarojSingh-nq5ql]

​@@ashonvills Tell me I haven't seen a single interview of HM without telling me.🙃

[@ashishpandey8537]

​@@SarojSingh-nq5ql are nahi bhai har notifications ko ake khud pm ko samjha nahi chahiye baki Sare log to pagal hai na jo cabinet me hai sb modi ki krle 😂😂

[@mayanksingh4121]

Because common sense is not common.

[@starrysky1128]

Census ho ni raha aur addition dekiye. Dimag se socho.kholo use. Persecuted ko hi deal krna h 2 desh ki innumerable women jo prostitution m phasi h unhe rescue krte. Kothe bnd krvate. Mps jo unko back krye h unko presecute krte.

[@ashutosh2824]

You are showing the world how to do in-depth research and analysis, firstly when i saw chandrachur video i thought wow he is so right about CAA but when you gave your response a new dimension opens up, thanks for sharing your thoughts 💭 Naman sir😊😊

[@kumarsaurabh4127]

Sir is there option of emi, we need your guidance please help, can't afford at a time

[@aravinddnivara803]

The problem with this CJI’s son’s argument is that he has no clue what this laws root cause was… he is ill informed. Congress under Nehru / Gandhi did not wanted India to split into multiple countries of afghan Pakistan or Bangladesh till the day of partition.. simply because Gandhi was a eccentric man who had more power to decide on what’s good for Pakistanis of partition time because of Congress treating him like god. If Gandhi was ready to work with British around 1943 before end of world war 2, British wanted to work with Nehru and Jinnah to plan, border decisions , knowledge transfer and training of Indian and Pakistan bureaucrats before partition was announced so that the transition will be smooth… since Gandhi s adamant nature did not allow British to plan the drawing of borders as well as training of Indians / Pakistanis over the course of 1943 to 1947, British had to forcefully send Mountbatten to decide border and hastily announce independence which lead to blood bath. Gandhi unknowingly was reason for millions of Hindus Muslims Sikhs being massacred… since in this hasty sudden migration, many( Hindus Christian’s Sikhs jains) in villages and remote places who were unaware of how evil a Muslim majority country will become and stayed back. Today their population is almost wiped out and they have come to India and been living as undocumented for decades in India because India does not give them citizenship… In Pakistan once cannot declare themselves as atheist after being a Muslim. If India gives citizenship to atheists in Pakistan , ISI can send spies in the name of atheists.. also the moment these people announce they are atheist in Pakistan, they will be either 40% lynched by fellow citizens or jailed by Pakistan law. Forget about they getting a chance to come to India… this is a stupid argument from a kid who has lot to learn about India history..: Plus why not Jews and others ? These people never were having any rivalry during partition and were also free to move where they wanted… most likely there will be 6 to 8 Jews who has zero cognitive skills comparable to yours who think they will be able to live in Pakistan where Islamists are waiting ti slay them because of hate that comes from times of 6 th century of Islamic rise.

[@KarunanKannampoyilil]

Article 14 is for Indian citizen not outside 😀😀😀😀😀

[@Upanishadicsaint]

They want that this should not come so that a 13 year old Hindu girl can continue into a forceful marriage with 60 year old man in pakistan.

[@starrysky1128]

Hindu m rkha kya h .bharat m jo girls h agar gareeb h to konsi safety h unki? Unka b sbbb forceful hi hota h sir. INSANIYAT rakhiye HEVan na bano .jo hain yahan unko safe rkh ni paye .aaj b koi aurat shaam ko safely akele nahi ja sakti .STOP THIS HYPOCRISY ON NAME OF WOMEN. you men dont deserve women

[@starrysky1128]

Upanishadic seriously! Upanishad padh hi liye hote

[@yashrathod9685]

@@starrysky1128 milord who the hell are you to give certificate of civilization here, how can you prove that women in india is not safe because of the person commented, and by seeing your action and half knowledge I think you are the person molesting women in real life and being champion of civilization of internet

[@user-qz3to7gd5l]

@@starrysky1128 The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is a brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity. - Said by Ambhedkar

[@PMcse]

​@@user-qz3to7gd5l okay, but how is it relevant to the girl's question ? Be relevant with your arguments.

[@sarvantiwari7662]

Nailed it. What an articulation. What a great profound knowledge. What a n holistic approach to an issue. Just cannot get better than this. Huge respect for you sir.❤

[@indiratalaulikarnarvekar9997]

Absolute clarity and precise analysis....Thank-you for making things crystal clear

[@vaibhavraj3376]

Sir your opinion is correct but the legality of any matter is a different aspect. The amended act doesn't mention Religious prosecution any place. So the ground itself becomes challengeable . Also if they mention about religious prosecution proving the fact that they are doing religious prosecution is close to impossible. India will not even think of losing its only friendly neighbor Bangladesh by dragging them and accusing them of religious prosecution. Also your reasoning that Ahmadiyya betrayed us in the past and called for division is a vague one. It is right for gaining popular support but not valid in the court of law.

[@jyotiradityapradhan6490]

Most underrated comment

[@AmicableAgnostic]

It doesn't mention religious persecution bcoz it doesn't matter. Whoever wants to come will just say he or she is religiously persecuted so will u go to Pakistan to check whether he was really persecuted? That's why any Hindu can come bcoz everyone knows what happens to minorities in those countries. That can be proved in court as well so ground is not challengable at all bciz it doesn't go against constitution.

[@AmicableAgnostic]

Ahmedia wanted an Islamic nation but that is not the reason for not including them in CAA. Looks like u didn't understand anything from the video.

[@Enigma_Male]

Sir, do you think the concern of people of Assam regarding CAA is valid???

[@onlineaakashvani6145]

Sir i am Bca student but always watching your video. It give us more clearity and amzing viewpoint. Thanx naman sir ❤ love from Bihar

[@academia5618]

I am from Bihar too

[@ashwinisingh5920]

I would love to see both of you (Abhinav and you) on a debate sir. Both the arguments are very compelling and intriguing🔥

[@atkinsvijay]

Only three years after our Constitution was adopted, its chief architect, BR Ambedkar, publicly disowned it in Parliament. In an astonishing admission in 1953, he blurted out in the Rajya Sabha....several acts had British & American relevance..updation is a must to suit the prevailing era , we support CAA .

[@vishwaspaikra795]

if everyone can become citizens then why they need CAA? enter the border wait 10-11 years and volla. if they suffered persecution mentally and physically how CAA helps them better than traditional route? by creating CAA aren't we creating unnecessarily drama ? why do they want voting rights just by living 5 years? is 5 years enough for them to take decision for the country? What benefits do they get through CAA? why even wait 4-5 years? why not immediately if citizenship is that necessary for them?

[@sourabhkalita2990]

With due respect I request u to study Assamese version of opposition of so called CAA. Cutoff date from 1951 to 1971 to 2014 now. Why would Assamese people take the burden of religiously persecuted people from erstwhile East Pakistan alone. If govt giving them citizenship through CAA, every state should take some of them.

[@haha4341]

Yup

[@ananyapandey1338]

23:30 I understood your point that terrorist can send their children claiming atheist and there is no way to verify that by India. Can you explain how the Hindus and other allowed-religions will be verified? I mean is there a chance that the terrorist would train their children to look like Hindu to get Indian citizenship?

[@animalrecapped]

He tries to show having unbiased opinions while simply being a B-grade influencer of BJP.

[@reiilym]

Says someone with pure hate no logic, probably a Muslim or whoever you are. Hindu's can be verified, based on their birth certificate or some other certificates. The loopholes are surely taken care of. Rather than a logical positive answer you are only here to spread rumours and hate to a guy, who is atleast saying something true for this country. Such a shame you are​@@animalrecapped

[@reiilym]

​@@animalrecapped say me you are a Muslim - without saying me you are. Get a life, get out of your majhids, your madrasa, full bs. Chi

[@niteshchaturvedi1544]

We can actually... By physical observation of body, or medical checkup

[@user-ug5ki3sn3n]

Thank you very much for this video ❤

[@bharathpj6155]

Excellent, Excellent, Excellent. Proud to have an Indian citizen like him. It's not a mere prepared speech but it's serious and from the heart. Such people are needed to rule out Nation who can be challenging and knowledge. Rahul Gandhi should learn and give way for such people for a brighter India. Rahul Gandhi if he is serious abt India's future he should come out of Congress bond and incorporate all the mighty people with knowledge and skills to bring down the hogus bogus rule in India, even to the extent of sacrificing Prime Minister dream. The ruling party is comfortable with Congress as long as they are INCOMPETANT. He has to seriously think abt it and unite all the competitive people who are really for the welfare of the country from all over India and form a stronger party.

[@ramsharansahani8441]

it was nice sir but . I want to know your views on collegium system if govt inter in this then u know it will be puppet of govt so what's the solution. So what u think sir 🤔🤔

[@abhisheksinha632]

The line of thought, the depth and the way of arguing makes you more respectable. Hats off to you Naman sir

[@mvproduction2077]

Sir can you please make video on this Norcet (conducted by AIIMS) nursing officer vacancy (Pay scale 90k+ per month) In this exam from last 3 years se 80:20 rule h sir reservation ka on the basis of sex(gender) For female there are 80% seats reserved only 20% seats are for male and in that 20% we have cast wise reservation also Last year total 5000 seat were there only 379 seats for male only 120 general seats 💺 for male sir how we can survive sir this level of competition. I scored 66% Mark's in mains but still not got selected... But students with have less then 45% got seat in AIIMS Which have lesser knowledge then me less capable then me is going in AIIMS he will assign patients... This establishment why this is still legal and why AIIMS don't have this policy for doctors. Why only nursing officer post why no other post have this type of reservation. Is this legal? Why this discrimination is allowed, AIIMS is already facing issues of not getting skilled personal AIIMS director admitting it because of 80,20 rule Yhe tho hona hi tha i don't know why they want to continue this illegal policy kzbin.info/www/bejne/hmXbgYaPib-isKcsi=uI57IylIi-dL-Ktp Where is equality 1st in this matter I am Indian citizen where is equality, AIIMS is center funded by central government..... Why male facing discrimination just because I born male why I have face this problem 80.20 remove please

[@mohitgurjar9277]

I agree with you I am Indian why I am still facing discrimination just because I born male 🐏 Why nobody taking about this do you want you go to AIIMS and you admitted in hospital nurse is carrying you is not capable or knowledgeable,she just selected just because she is gril shy this discrimination

[@MohitGurjar-zv4hv]

No body will talk about this real issue pr koi baat nhi krtha tho common hard working ko affect krthi h sab bs views chaiye so I think if influential log baat krnege tho kch hoga is rule ka

[@ammyfernandis5093]

Knowledgeable , brave teachers make responsible , aware leaders .. great work

[@vikastulsi]

Good insight... But to best of my understanding - at least in India - the protest against CAA started mainly with Amit Shah and BJP started stating that CAA along with NRC and NPR will be used to get rid of illegal Muslims immigrants in India.. HE linked both these - CAA and NRC ..

[@satveersihmar3258]

Sir ,Do you also watch AIM and Sai Deepak. Also Carvaka Podcast.

[@kvapower3925]

12:27 correct me if my hearing better: did u say years in lieu of months?

[@priyanshuanand6919]

interesting discussion, but i have question sir, if u would answer it would clarify my doubt. since article 14 is available to anyone within the territory of India including even companies, since these prospective citizens are yet not residing in India (they ought to live here if they choose), then how come is it violative of article 14?

[@priyanshuanand6919]

because article 14 applies within the territory we cannot say that it is in violation if it affects something outside the territory, isn't it?

[@nileshkumar-vv1bh]

Thank you, Mr Naman. We need more people like you in this rashtra who serve the great mother.

[@abhisheksainani]

Thank you for this nuanced understanding of CAA without any political or religious biases. I hope more people watch this video and learn to analyze such policies without their political or religious biases.

[@Sun-tb1rj]

💯💯💯💯 Completely agree! Intent of CAA 2019 is far more important than technical details!

[@venkateshab5423]

How can we solve the after-independence problems by using pre-indepence Acts ? There are many pre-independence time laws still in force here.

[@jayeshmhatre5954]

Hey Naman, completely agree with your views on this. I have just one question with respect to the exclusion of Sri-Lankan Tamils to apply for Indian citizenship via this expedited route. Don't you think they make a strong case for expedited citizenship if we are considering atrocities committed on religious minorities in our neighbouring countries?

[@gohilarjunsinh1743]

CJI >>CJI>>> potential CJI? We are Talking About Judiciary.... what's your thoughts on that sir? Isn't it harmful for India?

[@devendra...1208]

Persuing ca but still love to absorb your opinions. and fun fact is that only people from outside INDIA can give unbiased opinion.

[@TumhariBuaKiLadki]

Why isn’t he talking about whats happening with the people in assam because of NRC and CAA… why isn’t he talking about detention camps… people in Assam are in detention camps for 3 years and then it’s proven that oh sorry you are a citizen of India…. Look at both sides of the coin

[@pixel9419]

He is Sangi

[@combinedstudy6427]

Then go to your original country Bangladesh or Pakistan.

[@TumhariBuaKiLadki]

@@combinedstudy6427 😂🤣🙏🙌 every andhbakt fr bro 🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂

[@divaskumar2632]

I am not an UPSC aspirant but I watch you it’s empowered me . Thank you

[@shubhs_arts1776]

Whole video sir ?

[@ayushverma9145]

Whenever I have to form an unbiased view, I desperately wait for ur vedio..Now I can say there is one channel which is absolutely unbiased...thank you sir. We all need people's like you.

[@abhijeetkumar2204]

No one is absolute unbiased 😅...get educated first

[@RajendraDave-zp2jl]

I aporeciate your knowledge against sudo lefitst educationalist. U r not bius. U are loved for your honesty. I admire being Indian . I support ur courage to speak against so called stalvert who became by their position deminishing the indian culture. I respect u .

[@user-cg2xr8ly3c]

Golden content. And eye opener. End to all non sense debate. Thanks naman for bringing truth and objective facts to support your argument

[@yashr285]

Some say why aren't the tamil refugees from sri Lanka, settled in TN covered in these laws

[@hardlife25]

I honestly want everyone to watch this video. Plz share it as much as you can . People should have reasonable grounds to make their views .

[@s.12330]

This video is tight slap on the face of caa haters.

[@parameswarbarik6482]

which examination is required to clear to become a judge in High court or supreme court or cji. Has he topped the examination. What was his Rank Does UPSC Conduct such Exam

[@anuragpandey6774]

Sir how to join these live classes?

[@eraanjum9195]

There's a link in description ig

[@ahadziyan8619]

What is your opinion about CAA including NRC, if it is enacted?

[@SUMITKUMAR-hl4vl]

Rahul be like : Bhai Naman mujhe kyon dhoya...

[@Gabbar.0801]

Dear Naman, Though I agree with you on a major ity of the points, I am skeptical regarding the coverage of the CAA amendment 2019. It fails to include the persecuted tamil speaking hindus in Sri Lanka for reasons unknown to me. In that context I believe it does violate the article 14. Can you please explain your views on the same?

[@AmicableAgnostic]

Tamil speaking Hindus in Sri Lanka are persecuted not based on religion. There is a voilent history behind that. It's a separate issue. They are not religious minority.

[@AmanRaj-gu7ce]

CAA is notified just to get political mileage as of now. Cutoff Date is 2014, around 9.5 yrs has passed already, not much of the use, If they don't modify the cutoff dates. The main Issue is It will act as a bedrock for future bad policies like NRC, if current government feel threatened about their Central seats, not in 2024, but maybe in 2034, to take advantage of communalism .

[@deepakkumarmishra9238]

😂 o my god. Your sense of logic is just pathetic

[@barkhauttwani119]

Thank you for making it easy to understand CAA

[@sukanyasharma3729]

Thats what a well read well informed person is supposed to speak .... Great words 👍

[@trenfa4371]

but if they do this then we should do the same is the only option for us sir? what is difference between them and us sir if our decisions are made with same mindset? am I missing something?

[@AmicableAgnostic]

Yes u r missing a lot. Doing same means what? Giving citizenship to only few religions is same as persecuting minority religions? What are u talking bro. Don't you see the difference.

[@comedyclub366]

Aman sir I'm not your follower I'm your fan , but here I'm not agree with you...... because (1). If any one get Indian citizenship through traditional method than why CAA , you don't think it is only for political gain (2) citizenship through citizenship act 1955 , is this law only for Muslim, (3). Sir what about article 14, (4) Why we share our resources with other, first we need to empower our citizens , we all know our unemployment rate in our country 5). If it is not political gain stand, if this law was really good, than why mr shah was waiting for 2024 election. I have many other concern if you permit than I will share my concern... .

[@surajrazz963]

Because there is a large protest in 2019

[@bv6168]

Even it is done for political gain. Why you worry after all politics is power. We want power in our hand.

[@pro_fessorJD]

EXCELLENT ANALYSIS NAMAN SIR

[@mvproduction2077]

Sir can you please make video on this Norcet (conducted by AIIMS) nursing officer vacancy (Pay scale 90k+ per month) In this exam from last 3 years se 80:20 rule h sir reservation ka on the basis of sex(gender) For female there are 80% seats reserved only 20% seats are for male and in that 20% we have cast wise reservation also Last year total 5000 seat were there only 379 seats for male only 120 general seats 💺 for male sir how we can survive sir this level of competition. I scored 66% Mark's in mains but still not got selected... But students with have less then 45% got seat in AIIMS Which have lesser knowledge then me less capable then me is going in AIIMS he will assign patients... This establishment why this is still legal and why AIIMS don't have this policy for doctors. Why only nursing officer post why no other post have this type of reservation. Is this legal? Why this discrimination is allowed, AIIMS is already facing issues of not getting skilled personal AIIMS director admitting it because of 80,20 rule Yhe tho hona hi tha i don't know why they want to continue this illegal policy kzbin.info/www/bejne/hmXbgYaPib-isKcsi=uI57IylIi-dL-Ktp Where is equality 1st in this matter I am Indian citizen where is equality, AIIMS is center funded by central government..... Why male facing discrimination just because I born male why I have face this problem 80.20 remove please

[@ramansbedi97]

How can i join your team

[@deekshasharma-qz8tu]

I appreciate you saying very directly that we are overly complicating practical realities with theory just to frame arguments…. That’s what we do, we create arguments , we frame narratives not to address what needs to be achieved but what we as biased human being want to achieve… we bend facts and data to achieve want we want rather than what is needed… and we think of ourselves as intelligent human being… the fact in this whole debate is no one is denied citizenship in India but CAA has another purpose altogether which tries to address a particular problem… it has lacunas but tries to solve which is appreciable…

[@eraanjum9195]

Sir do you give upsc classes

[@opensource_analyst]

Kindly release the full video on this !!!

[@minimalnomad7936]

Pakistan has apostasy and anti blasphemy laws. India has gone down that route with some states(UP for sure) passing anti-conversion laws and ghar wapsi. Frankly India is regressing to depths Pakistan has fallen to. Also, why hasnt the CAA included Tamils from Sri Lanka.

[@himanshuvikramsingh3391]

Its not unconstitutional. its only a one way of giving citizenship not the only way .....

[@kmokashi]

Good explantion. Those who are opposing CAA are objecting to why some groups are *excluded*. But what about those who are *included* - are they not prosecuted minorities in the neighbouring countries? Also if some other party comes to power, they can always amend and add other groups to existing list.

[@hariharabarik3726]

Sir we need a detailed discussion on the collegium system of Indian Judiciary.... Your words making me knowledgeable at every aspect ❤ ସାର୍ ଆମକୁ ଭାରତୀୟ ନ୍ୟାୟପାଳିକାର କଲେଜିୟମ୍ ସିଷ୍ଟମ୍ ଉପରେ ଏକ ବିସ୍ତୃତ ଆଲୋଚନା ଆବଶ୍ୟକ ... ତୁମର ଶବ୍ଦ ମୋତେ ପ୍ରତ୍ୟେକ ଦିଗରେ ଜ୍ଞାନବାନ କରେ |❤

[@ranadityapandey4458]

Then my question is simple why do we require an amendment for the same purpose of giving citizen .... coz even if they are here before 2014 they are short of just 1 more year to become a citizen. this act will not give citizenship to only those who have come before 2014 then what is the difference?

[@rajahya]

How does this CAA affect NRI with OCI ....can they get naturalised in 3 years please... Can they get preference if they bring significant amount of resources especially from UK say £1000000 of assets or cash including UK state pension and work pensions income

[@anamitradasgupta2608]

Exquisite, sir. Accept my warmest felicitations for taking the bull by the horns.

[@gohilarjunsinh1743]

Such immaturity BY CJI's son how can only reference of single Article Is correct ....you have to consider the Constitution as a whole and not just refer 3 lines as per your need. As Article 14 treats everybody as equal, it not about percentage wise Equal,you can still classified by categories and provide the special Treatment/law/acts. Even there are so many special treatment already in Practice which affects Much larger population than the CAA act.

[@fasilkareem2525]

Sir,how can u jistify the problem of fear of NER People about lossing their land right

[@baljitsinghtomar]

The shame India does not have a credible opposition leader, it's devastating for our democracy.

[@abdullahadil7426]

Only one question giruki y caa has not validity like open for 2 years only bcz cut off date is 2014.....give citizenship to eligible person under caa nd then repeal it

[@neelmanisahu4785]

your thoughtful arguments gained you a sub👍

[@harshverma3548]

Sir, what about those Muslims who will temporarily convert themself to Hindus to get Indian Citizenship and will follow their Muslim belief after getting Citizenship?

[@Real982ax]

How can you know .

[@akshaysharma7595]

Bro muslims can't do that, they cannot accept a kafirs faith.

[@deepakkumarmishra9238]

Arrey bhai tou convert hoga tou sarkar nahi dekhenge ki kab convert hua hai. Matlab sarkar ko chutiya samjhe ho kya. They do thorough inspection before acting. This is not congress , ki mumbai blast hote rahe aur yahan hindu terror par book launch karne mei Home minister busy ho.

[@gohilarjunsinh1743]

That's happening with reservation As well from long time.

[@adwaitvedant3297]

There is no way to quantify it

[@IffuRangrej]

Well said Naman. Would like to know your views on chronology explained by Mr. Amit Shah in reference to CAA and NRC. Exclusion of Rohingyas and Tamils of Srilanka.

[@debanjanchattopadhyay6930]

18:14 loved the way you exposed the nepotism 😂 great analysis sir