Myths of Karbala (Ft Sayed Mahdi Modarresi) | After Maghrib Podcast - EP55

After Maghrib Podcast🎙| EP 55 - Misconceptions about Imam Hussain (as) & Ashura
💡 SUBSCRIBE → / @aftermaghrib
In this enlightening episode, our co-hosts are joined by the esteemed Sayed Mahdi Modarresi as they explore common misconceptions surrounding the events of Karbala during Muharram. They address questions about the alleged involvement of Shia in the killing of Imam Hussain (as), the significance behind Shia's expression of grief and tears on Ashura, and an examination of potentially fabricated stories from the Battle of Karbala. These misconceptions often arise in online discussions, dialogues, and literature. This conversation seeks to offer historical, spiritual, and factual insights to dispel any confusion from the minds of the believers.
KZbin Series Referenced by Sayed Mahdi Modarresi -
Ashurology - (Short course on the historiography of the events of Ashura and the reliability of its sources): • Ashuralogy
Maqtal Book Referenced by Sayed Mahdi Modarresi -
A Day Like No Other: The Saga of Hussein and History's Greatest Tragedy: www.amazon.co.uk/Day-Like-No-...
🔻 Listen to the podcast online 🔻
🎧 Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
🎧 Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/3rzqcJN...
🔻 Follow our official platforms 🔻
📱 Instagram: / aftermaghribpodcast
📱 TikTok: / aftermaghrib
💌 Email the podcast on: [e-mail]
After Maghrib "The Late Night Buzz" 🌙
Shia Muslim podcast featuring co-hosts Sayed Ali Radhawi & brother Ahmed Abbas discussing issues that matter most in the community. Be a part of the conversation and delve into some of the most contentious and pertinent issues with laughs and debate along the way.
The views and opinions expressed on the After Maghrib Podcast belong solely to the hosts and guests, and they may not align with the views or stances held by After Maghrib Media. We assume no liability for the ideas presented in this episode, and any information discussed should not be interpreted as an endorsement or approval. *Please exercise caution when listening.
An After Maghrib Media production
#AfterMaghribPodcast #Muharram #imamhussain
00:00 Intro
04:33 Hussain & pollical power?
10:47 The Shia killed Hussain?
19:21 Details from the Maqtal important?
36:58 Qasim Ibn Hassan wedding fabricated?
42:07 Why do Shia always cry for Hussain?
Sayed Mahdi Modarresi: Dispelling Karbala Misconceptions
Debunking Myths: Did Shia Kill Imam Hussain (as)?
The Power of Grief and Tears: Shia's Expression on Ashura
Examining Fabricated Stories: The Battle of Karbala Unveiled
Unraveling Historical Truths: Imam Hussain's (as) Sacrifice
The Battle of Karbala: Fact or Fiction?
Sayed Mahdi Modarresi: A Scholar's Insights on Muharram
Rediscovering History: The Truths of Ashura Traditions
Honoring Imam Hussain (as): The Message of Sacrifice
Ashura: Mourning and Remembering the Martyrs

[@raziaahmadi9498]

The episodes with Islamic scholars are the best episodes. So much knowledge, so much wisdom and depth in the discussions.

[@alismohsen2133]

Lebbyaka Ya Hossein ❤️❤️❤️

[@YaShaheed]

صلوات الله وسلامه عليك يا أبا عبد الله

[@alismohsen2133]

Mashallah a very informative episode and discussion that is overdue. I wish this was aired before Muharram however, for me it’s Muharram every day! May Allah Khoda and Mola Hossein bless Sayed Modarresi for the way he speaks and answers the great questions asked by the hosts. I wish more questions had been asked and request if you kindly make a part 2 for the ridiculous accusations that come our way.

[@farisshah4517]

Allah huma salle alaa Muhammad wa Aale Muhammad

[@tahreemnaqvi222]

As always a really informative & enlightening podcast, Shukran 🙏🏻

[@zainabmirza8671]

The question of the Hazrat Qasim and the answer were soo informative, Jazakallah!

[@alismohsen2133]

100%! Radhawi was brave to ask this I’m scared to ask my own circle if this actually occurred 😅

[@muhammad5272]

@@alismohsen2133 Not really it is only a issue in subcontinent community he Iraqi they don't accept anyway. It no big issue for him

[@syedmahsoomabbasshah5179]

sayed out of this world

[@user-ml4zn6uj9d]

jazakallah

[@alirizvi7143]

I have a heartily request. Please do a podcast completely dedicated to Abul Fadhl, Qamr e Bani Hashim.

[@nal7267]

سلام الله عليه

[@Zainabsart_]

So beautiful ❤️

[@vasimabas]

MashAllah. Such an informative and heart opening podcast. keep up the good work.

[@Umarislayer]

Sayyid mehdi Modarresi 🐐🐐🐐🐐 the ultimate Umari slayer he keeps the sons of Aisha up at night time

[@AmeerMuawiyahAS]

You mean the AAAH AAAH imam😂😂😂😂

[@hamidnajafi2239]

mashallah

[@Alchemista110]

Please when you quote Qur'an - it is considerate and also in good format to give the Surah and Ayat.

[@alihammoud83]

Ahsantoum Shabab

[@FarisSyed-bg4ln]

😢😢

[@mahmoodvisram1739]

Salams, the sheikh talked about a KZbin series called ashurology which u can’t find. Please can anyone who knows help with a link?

[@AfterMaghrib]

Salam, I have added the link to the series to the description of the video.

[@user-bl8lt1fp2g]

kzbin.info/aero/PLuq6JMEktvIkZGyK2cZ3E6GXSxWK9woNM

[@rabbannibey1128]

​@@AfterMaghribMasha'Allah. Jazak'Allah Khairun for the assist.

[@bobbob-zl6fe]

18:23

[@victoriaagm4215]

If i say something about karbala batle..you will feel hurt about me,, coz i really hate the way they cut the human head..that mske my angers come . thats one of my angers to whole worlds ....i hope its will end soon snd all leave in peace from now

[@AmeerMuawiyahAS]

Aaah aaah aaaah😂😂😂

[@yahussainmazloom1]

لعن اللہ آل ابی سفیان و آل مروان الی یوم القیامہ

[@farisshah4517]

After Kerbala there are no Shias and Sunnis , Either you are with Imam Husayn ( A.S ) or with his enemies.

[@paramahansayogananda6719]

There is no need to blame the killing of Hussein (RA) on someone who was in a different country. The killers of Hussein are Ibn Ziyad and his soldiers.

[@syedrizvi6858]

Obama is not to blame for anything that had occurred in the Middle East

[@paramahansayogananda6719]

@@syedrizvi6858 False equivalency. Obama was the most powerful man in the world. This wasn’t true for the caliph.

[@YaShaheed]

It’s like saying “only the hitman is to blame, not the one who hired him”

[@paramahansayogananda6719]

@@YaShaheed The hitman was Shimr ibn Dhil Jaushan, and the contractor was Ubaydullah ibn Ziyad.

[@youtubeviewer4171]

​@@paramahansayogananda6719and who appointed ibn Ziyad was it not Yazid? For whom was ibn ziyad taking allegiance was it not Yazid? and why do you write RA with imam Hussain's name, why not A.S??