Netaji's Family Under Surveillance - The Newshour Debate: Subhas Chandra Bose's kin snooped upon?

[@selvarajuulakanthan9651]

I am a Singaporean born in singapore of tamil origin in late 50s.My grandfather settled in Singapore before the Japanese occupation of Singapore.Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose recruited my grandfather in Singapore together with his friend to join INA to fight the british for the Independence of India.However my grandfather died in the war in Burma and my family never recovered his body.My father always told me that the Father of India has always been and will always be Subash Chandra Bose.I am 58 years old now and never visited India.I now feel like visiting India because Congress dynasty is not in power and I hope truth about the greatest Indian hero"s death is unearthed.I still have a big portrait of my hero in my living room.ALL INDIANS MUST REMEMBER THAT IT WAS NETAJI SUBASH CHANDRA BOSE WHO GOT THE INDEPENDENCE FOR INDIA AND INDIA WOULD NOT BE DIVIDED IF NETAJI WAS AROUND DURING INDEPENDENCE.I know I have no say in Indian politics because i am not local but I have the right to know the truth because my grandfather died fighting for India.

[@vasanthkumar39]

selvaraju ulakanthan you have all the rights

[@chandrasekharj6604]

selvaraju ulakanthan, the story of your grandfather is moving; there were several unsung heroes like your grandpa! But the corrupt and selfish dynasty never allowed any genuine leader to get recognition. Look at the way the family awarded Bharat Ratna onto themselves, Nehru and Indira when alive and Rajeev by Sonia ! Shameless corrupt dynasty

[@vasanthkumar39]

selvaraju ulakanthan don't come here ,if you will come it will be Tamil nadu ,where dravidian parties philosophy converted all national hero of TN in to caste heroes , Nationalist like me in difficult in converting them again National heroes

[@selvarajuulakanthan9651]

Vasanth Kumar In any murder investigation the most important factor is MOTIVE .Who will benefit the most? if the congress was sincere this matter, would have been thoroughly investigated 70 years ago.

[@vasanthkumar39]

selvaraju ulakanthan congress only benefited now it is time to throw out them

[@srbhanja]

Anuj Dhar- amazing &outstanding!!!

[@ashwanikumar-zs4nn]

Art N Click really

[@Subrata7878]

Hats off to Gen Bakshi.

[@bundelavinay3039]

Subrata7878 Sala gaddar nehru chaprasi banne ke kabil bhi nhi Tha pm bna ke thop dia Bharat pr Varna sardar patel ji hote hamare 1st pm.

[@senjoseph4455]

Anuj Dhar should have been allowed at least 5 minites more to speak as he speaks out of documentary evidence, which none others profess

[@PradeepKumar-jn2cb]

AFAIK, two most unfortunate events which took place in India were that 1. Jawaharlal Nehru was born here and 2. He became the prime minister (and that too first) of India.

[@FunnyVlogsVillege]

Yes bhai

[@mukeshdak]

Really very shameful act on part of Congress !!!!!! It is worst that can be done to a martyr who dedicated his whole life to the nation

[@anshumanrath9313]

Iam heart broken, the greatest hero of India and his respected family being treated like criminals, shame to congress, congress party needs to be wiped out of India....

[@raghumujje2639]

Shameless nehruian historian pig-Mrudula mukerjee

[@senjoseph4455]

I have read Anuj Dhar's book, INDIA'S BIGGEST COVER-UP, it impressed me a lot, as it carries scanned images of more than 300 so far de-classified documents by GOI and by Govts of U.K and U.S, the Historians of India should have a copy of the same at the earliest to do a home work before appearing in any live TV show on the subject matter

[@anshumanrath9313]

Nothing can be more sad than this...Iam as a citizen of India is feeling ashamed...Thanks General...Thanks Bose's grand son...For Mr Tom, I better don't use my feelings, Arnab thanks we know the reality now. Sad Sad Sad...

[@Gogolye]

All these years went past, Congress never declassified these files.. Shame!

[@Nikhil-qd2qg]

"Nobody has done more harm to me more than Jawaharlal" if this statement of Netaji is run only one time before voting, congress will lose every election, congress will never see its sun all over life

[@genius0173]

Netaji the great liberator and revolutionary. RIP Netaji his memory will always live on!

[@NETAJI910]

Abe gando rip mat likh

[@aryankedia5504]

its utter disgrace, the person in whose temples should have been created and made the father of nation, his family had to face snooping

[@kukkidagar]

Totally disgusting comment by Congress saying that the General served his party....... how can he even say that n not apologise. It shows the mentality of congress that all govt employee and armed forces work for the congress president and not the nation.

[@sakkshi12]

I am hurt and broken, my hero has been insulted......why should i love this country when people r so pathetically hypocrites, ungrateful. The greatest leader of this country Netaji has been treated like this..people of this country do not deserve independence ....bloody low life. There loyalty is towards a political party not to the bharat...

[@ayushmandas4321]

Congress ko sirf sarkar banane mein interest tha....azadi mein nahi....jai hind

[@padmajsheth]

It is high time the Netaji Files are declassified. If it means that we have to re-write history textbooks, so be it. One thing is clear, unless this Govt does it, it will never happen. Congress knows it will be in a world of shit when the truth is out in the open.

[@legendrams548]

Bhagavat Gita teaches us fighting against injustice is our duty/karma. Don't know how people before independence were made to believe that they were supposed to follow nonviolence.

[@chandrowtiesingh137]

Think what is non violence? To spy on others is also violence. To give sorrow and to make others upset is violence, making others unhappy is all violence..

[@legendrams548]

@@chandrowtiesingh137 you are talking about hurting an individual. I was saying in regards to freedom of a country, for it's people who the land belonged to already.

[@gani999]

Nehru would have had a lot to lose if Netaji had returned to India. Netaji was more educated, erudite and charismatic than Nehru. He would have mounted a serious challenge to Nehru's leadership. It is very plausible that Nehru got the help of his friend, Stalin, to keep Netaji in prison in the USSR. Coming back to this debate, who is this fool of a Congress Spokesperson? He can barely talk! It would have been much more interesting to have someone like Jaiveer Shergil, Sanjay Jha or Jyotiraditya Scindia representing the Congress on the panel.

[@AuravWalden]

According to Dr Subramanian Swamy, who says he has reliable information, Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi were receiving payments from the KGB. One can go figure what that implies. Other than this, it is suspected that Lal Bahadur Shastri was murdered by the Soviets. Who benefited by Subhash Chandra Bose' and Lal Bahadur Shastri's murders by the agency that was paying Nehru and Indira Gandhi? Were the two parties, along with the British, one cabal of convenience?

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

Both Congress and Gandhi dynasty are a curse on this nation.

[@unkalpaddy481]

Can't believe that Congress stooge Tom-the-Dhakkan was allowed to get away with that cheap remark against General Bakshi. In an earlier debate on separatists in Kashmir, a Kashmiri politician from Congress did a similar thing. These thugs need to be fixed

[@nit23sharma]

Who will fix them......people are busy watching Bigg boss and pappu is going to become PM in 2019 ....and then the whole cycle will continue....I am sure these secular goons will kill Anuj dhar

[@SamvedIyer]

@@nit23sharma No I really hope Pappu doesn't become PM in 2019. We need Modi, no one else!

[@user-ve6lr1vn4n]

I hope this Congressman will take 'Maunabrata' with many others of his party men after the general election 2019 .

[@DaSnipy]

I AM AGHAST .. WHAT EXACTLY HAPPENED IN RUSSIA ?NETAJI SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSS ZINDABAAD..IF SUCH HAS HAPPENED, RUSSIA MUST GIVE AN UNCONDITIONAL APOLOGY TO HINDUSTHAN AND ERECT A FULL STATUE OF NETAJI IN FULL MILITARY HONORS. CONGRESS TREACHERY AGAINST OUR BELOVED NATIONAL HERO NETAJI... IF ANY WAS DONE MUST BE EXPOSED... JAI HIND.

[@kaustavadhikary8940]

DaSnipy The last statement is the most important one " Indian National Congress Gave India Her Freedom" All this was done to create and maintain this narrative... Nehru (God) Congress religion and the plan worked the family is still in power of the party and till last year was in power of the country.. Netaji and the INA were the real hero who gave us our freedom.. but slowly slowly he was wiped out from our history.. only I paragraph on netaji in our history books.. from airports to stadiums its nehru gandhi ki jai.. Nehru knew if netaji comes back india will make him our first prime minister and netaji was anti British.. and Nehru was pro british.. thus resulted all the so called plain crash drama..which every body knows did not happen..and netaji ended up in Russian jail..

[@victor256in]

DaSnipy Will an unconditional apology for murdering Netaji bring him back?? Also Putin is not responsible for Stalin's crime …this is Russia and that then was the USSR…different countries. The real culprits are not the Russians but our own…traitors like Nehru. I don't believe in conspiracy theories..but if one can add 2 and 2 one can clearly see that the great man was killed mercilessly in a Soviet gulag… possibly at someones behest.

[@sakkshi12]

DaSnipy apology? seriously u think that is enough....no

[@DaSnipy]

sakshi tewari With newer and newer information coming out, USSR would have had its hands tied as it was allied with the british fighting to save its own motherland .. it seems .. koi gaddar hamare hi safo me khada tha ..

[@MrJojo2335]

DaSnipy Russia was angry about netaji making an allaince with hitler. Netaji was betrayed by the communists during the world war 2 he had earlier confided many things about the INA to them.. They leaked it to the british. Latest documents reveal that as well.. Some Agent Silver real name Bhagat Ram Talwar who was Netaji's aid in his escape to Russia from there on to Germany revealed all the spies and agent which Netaji sent to leak the information about the INA which brtish were filtering at that tym. So the communists were betraying Netaji which he was not aware of. What happened to Netaji in Russia might be a part of it.

[@HariYellapu1]

Tom Vadakkan should opologise to Major.......... Army always stands first.

[@Roon96]

I totally support what G.D Bakshi and Anuj Dhar said . The facts laid down by them are reality .Being a die hard Netaji Follower ..i appreciate what Arnab has put up on the show... And moreover speaking of that congressman and the historian ... how can being silly they deny the truth and support Nehru ... and argue deliberately without giving points ...they are simply baseless on their fields.

[@MrJojo2335]

The video from 37.06 to 45.26 is not available. Having watched the debate live, this debate has really moved me . Siddhartnath Singh mentioned during the debate that he being the Grandson of Lal Bahadur Shastri is in the same boat as Netaji's grand nephew . To sum it up it is not just about Netaji, but it is also about all the national heros we lost because of this cheap dynasty politics. Also our freedom fighters shld be accorded their due honor. It was never gandhi.. but a very bloody struggle that was carried out by the INA and many other freedom fighter before them that led to India's Independence. It is their history that has been erased from our history book. Netaji's presence in India was of utmost importance to our national interest when India was being partitioned. He was the natural leader of this country and his presence would have saved this country. Not only that Netaji was also a firm believer of an industrialized India with strong army as its backbone. This is wat India lacks even today. So let us build in this nation based on these ideals netaji and other freedom fighters led down. That will be the best tribute we can give them.

[@atultripathi9545]

Anuj Dhar is savage 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥👍👍

[@bkgajendrakurubagaja9336]

corropt congress...............

[@SamvedIyer]

With all due respect, I do not buy General Bakshi's point that Netaji was killed on the behest of British at the Soviet Union. (1) If he was, why was Nehru spying and snooping on the Bose family to the point of paranoia? (2) Netaji's personal relations with Stalin were good and Stalin wasn't exactly a fan of Nehru. Why would Stalin kill Netaji at Nehru's behest? (3) As said by Anuj Dhar, no intelligence agency hunts for dead bodies. If Netaji had died, all this spying made no sense. It means Nehru knew Netaji was alive. He was scared that Netaji could return and single-handedly bring the Congress down, and he made a fool out of India for nearly two decades.

[@vishakhranade749]

Whenever Tom Vadakkan starts speaking, feel like he is about to break down and cry....!! :))

[@SOURABHCHATURVEDIazad]

I've seen almost all categories of Spokspersons of Political parties, . . .but this Tom Vadakkan is just Pathetic. Shameless, foul-mouthed, full of bad manners & stupidity. Every youth of this great nation knows who gave India her Independence, and who truly loved her. Netaji was one of them. Jai Hind !

[@kaustavadhikary8940]

SOURABH CHATURVEDI The last statement is the most important one " Indian National Congress Gave India Her Freedom" All this was done to create and maintain this narrative... Nehru (God) Congress religion and the plan worked the family is still in power of the party and till last year was in power of the country.. Netaji and the INA were the real hero who gave us our freedom.. but slowly slowly he was wiped out from our history.. only I paragraph on netaji in our history books.. from airports to stadiums its nehru gandhi ki jai.. Nehru knew if netaji comes back india will make him our first prime minister and netaji was anti British.. and Nehru was pro british.. thus resulted all the so called plain crash drama..which every body knows did not happen..and netaji ended up in Russian jail..

[@SOURABHCHATURVEDIazad]

Kaustav Adhikary I really applaud Mr. Anuj Dhar and his NFP "Mission Netaji", both his works and his elaborate points on Late Netaji are abbsolutely brilliant, correct & justified !en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anuj_Dhar

[@kingshukjana5351]

I am feeling shame that mridulla mukherjee is a bengali "histrorien" cause i am born as bengali. biggest joke on india that such fool lady is histrorien.

[@UmaChakraborty-kq9dr]

Hats off to Anuj Dhar

[@legendrams548]

Very sad to know the way how our greatest freedom fighter died.

[@NitishKumar-yj6yo]

Gd bakshi is amazing he always speaks with heart

[@naturebeauty5037]

Anuj dhar very nice and super se bhi upar

[@arunkumarmukherjee9466]

Not to be treated political issue.Sorry why dear congress men take defense for put surveillance for Netaji's family after independence by Govt.of India. It was great mistake no doubt.It is a fact our contemporary were very afraid for their political carrier if Bose come in picture. Very simple question if man died by Plane Crash, why surveillance was required ?

[@fathimakhatun637]

Congress spokesperson does not know that IB directly reports to PM. No role of home department.

[@makemycv]

Hero of this debate... Anuj Dhar and Arnab Goswami

[@Lone_Forest]

Long Live ( Subhas Chandra Bose ) ji :- " PeoPle Can Hide Sun With Hand fr.. While , But Nt Fr Ever " ,,.. & i Wish To See Currency Relesed with Netaji Picture ,...

[@mirasarkar.3904]

We must know about Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

[@nash666avi]

Netaji is the real father of our nation

[@saughatabasumatary1072]

Jai Hind Jai Bharat

[@joshiaman653]

hats of you bakshi sir . jai INA who really bring independance in india.

[@gl4834]

Jawaharlal Nehru was puppet of Britisher and he has obeyed and passed all critical information to them. It was not Gandhi but Bose who was the reason of Indipendenc.

[@swarnadeepchowdhury563]

Hats off to Sir Gen GD Bakshi and what a disgrace for the Indian National Congress spokesperson Mr Tom to have said those words of misery at the end of the debate. The nation now wants to know what actually happened. Let us be a part of the free world and give the greatest freedom fighter all the respect and honor he deserves.

[@AnirvanSenguptaoriginal]

Each time Tom Vadakkan opened his mouth... my head involuntarily went "M@#$%Ch@#"...hehehe

[@xMARSxVENUSx]

His video isn't complete! Did the Cong guy Apologize to JD Bakhsi?

[@aniketaggarwal1224]

Before taking political sides , i was a student who was interested in reading ncert history but it seemed dull to me learning from class 6th onwards only about Mughals and the British . Even the freedom struggle section is full of congress leaders or is very boring , whereas it should be such which gives us patriotic goosebumps on how British did atrocities and how Indian freedom fighters fought it years passed . Now learning history myself since the end of Covid and getting some astonishing revelation about realities of big personalities , culture through the timeline , religious practices , geopolitical history , ideological clashes , ideas , identities and scale and scope of influence , about esteemed and determined strategists , warriors , thinkers , explorers , emperors of the Greater India and their associations , reflection of inspiration and influence on each other every day , every week that many things are told disproportionately and hidden deliberately and even told falsely that i become furious at the writers of history and their followers and preachers today or at those innocent public who shuts their mind against listening to our arguments as some false premises have been rockified in their minds now that they can`t listen something contrary to it or accept that they may have been deliberatly taught wrong or incomplete things in their whole school life .

[@arunkumarmukherjee9466]

It is amazing to note how Congress Party blindly supported the surveillance carried out by Neheru against Bose's family! Neheru was very much afraid as he was unable to do what Netaji did . He was compelled to take defense in INA trial : not for support Azad Hind Fauz ! only to restore the political carrier..

[@sujataroy4733]

Anuj great work ... Keep it up

[@PremKumar-ke5oy]

Mr. General Baksi say totally right , why Pt. Neharu no required soldier NIA to Indian army .

[@souvikroy4823]

That historian lady is an acute fool.

[@digambardas6203]

Jai hind 🙏💕🌺💯 Jai netaji 🙏💕🌺💯

[@aniketaggarwal1224]

33:00 She repeatedly says that she doesn't know this know that and then hesitates when someone counter questions her

[@indianzionist2012]

Why were the KGB implants like Nehru, Indira, Rajiv and Sonia Gandoos NEVER spied upon?!

[@jayrammaths5935]

I bow to Netajee. He was a greatest man in India

[@senjoseph4455]

General Bakshi's emotions are to be deeply respected, but his contention that Netaji was choked o death in Siberian Yakutsk prison is baseless, in fact let all files be de-classified and investigated first, and then let a report be published by GOI in all media

[@sayantandasgupta9605]

Shouldn't there be a court case initialized against Congress?

[@debasishchakraborty4196]

I can see 7 dislikes.. 116 likes so far.. it proves the general sentiment of people of india may be in a micro level, I really take pity on dislikers.. unfortunately harsh truth is harsh eventually...congress what way left.. to be decimated more...70 years around...such a shameful party.. they don't even hold the heritage of being called india's old significant party

[@Arkas13011]

why mridulla mukherjee close her eyes whil etalking ? can't she watch the truth or she is blind ? PLS DON4T INVITE SUCH RIDICULUS HISTORIONS FOR DEBATE WHO DON'T KNOW ANSWER

[@swarnamohanty3121]

looking for lost treasure of INA.

[@fusionweldingtechnologies2193]

May be in swizz bank !!!

[@Nikhil-qd2qg]

What a demon congress spokesperson is this, when senior respected army person G D Bakshi was speaking was laughing sarcastically was shameless like Rahul Gandhi

[@parkashmehta9118]

Honorable nephew of N. S. Boss.and at the same time I pay best respects to sh G.D.Bakhshi for their passionate and thunder in their speech in favour of Netaji ji 's family.I request sh bakhshi to send .me a copy of the book "The Last days of Neta ji Subhash Chandra bose.

[@lsenthil92]

Nethaji was true hero, who sacrified everything for his motherland, its Only Bcoz of INA tat we got our freedom, and certainly not bcoz of nehru and gandhi, its a shame tat nehru snooped on d family of a grt freedom fighter

[@buddhadebmookerjee5986]

Look at the charisma of Netaji. He was kept away from public attention for more than 60 years by successive Congress Party. Even then his image as a political leader hasn't diminished one bit. As a matter of fact his image has become several times bigger. So much so that he remains the dreaded opposition to other parties including Congress. Nehru must be turning in his grave at the thought of his return, if possible. The nation needs him more than any other leader.

[@himanshubansal8495]

There should be a IQ test done of panelists before joining Arnab's debate. It should be atleast higher than Arnab's.

[@saughatabasumatary1072]

Our National Icon: Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose

[@babumajoomdar5940]

Do not understand in which regard coward Nehru was " pandit". The word Pandit does not suit such person.

[@IamNemesisYT]

Mr. Arnab Goswami, can I have any sort of contact with Mr. Anuj Dhar? I would like to work with him at this matter.. if it could be possible plz.

[@DrGorachandGhosh2710]

Netaji gave our freedom not by the real indirect war criminals Gandhi and Nehru. They were puppet and slaves of the British Raj throughout their lives and claimed that Netaji was a war criminal hiding in Russia under the protection of Stalin. The fact is published by Amazon worldwide since 18Sept2017 in English and by Notion press since 22June2022 in Bengali. Jai Hind.

[@rahulghosh3878]

Mridula mukherjee jaisa bengali k liya hi him bengali ka nam kharap hota haun

[@salmankafan1182]

Respect General G.D.Bakshi

[@jaihindu7105]

major general

[@TejaswiniRavi]

'Are we challenging a historian...' - lol Such a daft question!

[@rahulghosh3878]

Shame mrodula mukherjee

[@tusharsirohi5792]

ohh you gotta love G.D. Bakshi! top marks!

[@aniketaggarwal1224]

Patel Ji was a true patriot who committed a sin of convincing those in the 1946 Naval Mutiny to stop it when sent by Gandhi . Same with Shastri Ji being presided over by Nehru when Nehru was Pm and therefore Shastri had to let Bose family spy . I would even question Patel and Shastri over these issues but then i don`t find any other work of them which is up for scrutiny while there are dozens for Gandhi and Nehru .

[@maalaipozhuthu]

And the best performance for the most melodramatic performance goes to them Gen. Bhakshi.

[@ratulmajumdar8779]

Jai Hind

[@pintunag]

Mridula Mukherjee and Sharmistha, you both should not be proud of yourself, shame on your intellect...

[@OO11OO11OOO]

Last section of the video is corrupted. Please upload again.

[@arunkumarmukherjee9466]

I watched on the TV ( ABP- Ananda) as blindly supported by Mr. Sugata Bose & his Mother that Pd. Neheru was not responsible for taking surveillance the our family! Who is responsible for that ? Let me give answer

[@badgergirl8202]

Congress says that SCB was a part of Congress more than the nation (what a joke!). They also think that the army serves the party and not the country. Sadly enough, this mentality of the Congress makes sense: no wonder Nehru and Gandhi thought that they owned Bose/army; no wonder Bose left the Congress. As for the prof, Mridula Mukherjee needs to act more like a historian. She is denying facts that are being PRESENTED on the show. All she said is that she does not know anything. Smart move Prof. Arnab, save us time and don't bring brainwashed panelists like her to waste all of our time. She said nothing of any importance tonight.

[@Ravikumarpinninti]

this lady is rahul baba's history professor, you all remember rahul baba says Italy is bigger then Europe ... hahaha .. RIP nehur's Family .. because of bose we got independence and its true ..

[@parthjoshi111]

After long time very interesting show Arnab. We need more jurno like you who dare to question .

[@BertandRussel]

JAI HIND AZAD HIND FAUJ ZINDABAD NETAJI SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE ZINDABAD

[@janardhanamp8380]

A person like Nehru who had no moral values in life certainly should have felt insecure obviously to safe guard his throne.

[@asingh5641]

Gen.. G.D Bakshi telling truth..🙏

[@chetubvsc]

Chutia congress

[@s.g3452]

look at that congress man smiling like a villain.

[@hirannyakpodder6933]

every indian should watch this video!!

[@swarnaushachandra5568]

It is the biggest shame the Nehru family. It is so sad Subhash Chandra Bose gave and sacrificed his life to free India but so much bloodshed happened because of rivalry. Men of this land died

[@mohitpatel7565]

Look at Tom Vadakkan's face. He is not even serious. So it is clear that he isn't respecting Subhash Bose nor fucking Congress. Great general G D Bakshi get him best from 21:16 . He fucking deserved it.

[@freethinker-educateagitate2252]

Mridula mukherji like are 10 jan path slaves

[@englishlearner3179]

Nation of father is "Netaji subhas boss".

[@kiranmore1365]

please re upload the same video... its not working on last few minutes

[@anweshapalchaudhuri3351]

May God save us ! we have let true patriots die and be tortured to death but have worshiped traitors as our leader from the inception...

[@shivshankarswamy4057]

Professor Mukhargee cannot qualify herself HISTORIAN. She confessed that she talking on the base she read the book.

[@ManasBhagoliwal]

The footage is ruined and appears to be incomplete...please try to fix or re-upload.

[@das375]

Why the video is not complete?

[@imdeep5839]

@@sharanankit18 there's nothing in the link u fool