NEW Anastasia Rose Metals | Is It Too Smokey?

[@kathleens1708]

I think it would be fun to watch you do more outside of your comfort zone. You create such pretty looks and inspire me. I did not think your final look was at all something that was only night time appropriate. I sometimes get the most compliments when I have a darker color on my lids - probably because I am very fair and the contrast works to bring out my eyes.

[@jslilimauve]

I agree about darker colors. Not too deep but deeper colors when put correctly all over the eyes (not a la Panda) they do make eyes bigger too because of that depth as opposed just to light colors on the eyes. I loooove smokey look, ugh its so sexy and pretty ! Also so many people on youtube dont get this : smokey is a technique of blending an eyeshadow in a certain way hence smoke(y) and any color can be blended in this smokey way even lighter or colorful shades. Its technique. Not description of colors.

[@taramama6658]

I wear what ever I’m feeling for the day!! I also get the most compliments on darker shades during the day!!

[@mandyarostegui9198]

I am a smokey eye look girl… daytime or nighttime 😂 so this palette is a dream for me! I had not even thought of putting these colors together, so you’ve inspired me! Thank you! I think you will surprise yourself with all the looks you create with this one… such a fun palette to have for the holidays!

[@maeganfindley3542]

Gorgeous Mandy! Not too smokey on you at all! But definitely understand the lighter daytime looks as a preference. I have a hard time creating a lighter look with my SG Enduring Love palette, but it's still one of my all time faves. I've been curious how the SG EL palette compares to the new ND palette... some of the shades look so similar (without a direct comparison). Could you compare them? This ABH palette is gorgeous on you though & I envy how well you pull together a beautiful eye look!!

[@amymoore2408]

I have both the ABH Sultry and Nouveau palettes. With those palettes I think you can achieve many of the looks you’d get from Rose Metals.

[@kellycastillo241]

I first discovered your channel from your abh videos and rankings so something about you and abh palettes just makes me happy

[@ReneeMartin]

Thank you for the review!! You helped me decide to pass on buying this. It's really pretty but I would probably regret it since I prefer simpler, lighter looks.

[@maiden411]

Woohoo! FINALLY, a palette with a different color story that will work on my tanned skin! I’m definitely going to pick it up. Thank you so much for showing it

[@mandy81841]

This look is beautiful. I have a date on Thursday and I am going to do this look! Thank you for taking the time to create and post this look, much appreciated. Mandy x

[@jennifermolina4396]

I have threatened to buy this ABH pallet many times! It’s gorgeous!!!!! Allie Glines' video…. Oh my goodness, such a beautiful look! Best she’s ever looked! And yours, wow! Can’t go wrong with this pallet. Brilliant video idea with going from day to night look. Those shimmers are insane! UPDATE! I just received this pallet in the mail last night (I couldn't help myself) and immediately used it. Holy moly, this is my all time favorite pallet. It was my love at first sight pallet. The mattes are so smooth and blend like a dream. The shimmers are exactly what I've been looking for in shimmers. ABH nailed it. I will never get rid of it.

[@KS95x]

The two new Anastasia palettes have really caught my attention. I hadn’t picked up an eyeshadow palette from Anastasia since Modern Renaissance in 2016, which was my first eyeshadow palette ever and I fell in love with makeup. After that I started exploring other brands and formulas and felt like I was in a rut with Anastasia. There is something that looks so special to me about their new palettes. The color stories, the textures, I am soooo intrigued 😭😍❤️ your looks are beautiful!

[@beverlynelson599]

Mandy, You are definitely an Artist! I would not know where to begin with these dark shades but your eyes turned out beautifully.This is a very flattering look on you! I do appreciate that you tell us which brush you are using, where you are putting color on your brush, and which side of the brush you are using. I also feel that you have a knack for combing colors that would not be evident to me. You give an informative and fun tutorial! Have a great day!

[@Tishoopaper]

The smokey look is absolutely gorgeous on you! I understand the need for a lighter day look-I think you can come up with a lovely fresh look with this palette. You accomplish so many pretty looks!

[@sandywilkerson1843]

I love dramatic looks usually go all out for my eyes. Day or night. Beautiful look.

[@tina_smt]

I love the two eye looks that you created ❤ This is a really pretty palette for the holiday season. I will add it to my loves list.

[@louannearcher9729]

I think the 2nd look is beautiful, even for daytime ❤

[@luvsephora55]

😮😮 I think I’ll get this palette instead of the last one. I like how dark it is. That doesn’t make it a bad palette, more people can use it ❤

[@taramama6658]

I have the first one but I think the two would work well together.

[@lorrainewhitlock5377]

I really liked the light look better than the dark one. You always look so beautiful to me. Thank you 💖

[@jo4vt]

The colors you used, and all the colors in the palette, look lovely with your skin tone and hair. So pretty.

[@melissaluvsplease1664]

Babbeauty nailed the type of look this palette gives and that is 'grungy'. It truly is stunning, but grungy she is.

[@vickimajercin7100]

I got mine today. Can’t wait to see the looks you create.

[@ginnyburley9552]

I never wear smoky eye looks. I look for palettes with a predominance of mid tone shades with a couple of deep tones and a couple of very light shades. I’ve bought beautiful palettes I end up not reaching for because the shades are too dark or bright for me. I actually now find myself quite often combining mini palettes so I can get shades that work for me. Your eye looks are always gorgeous!

[@lindamack7184]

Not planning on getting this pallette but the 2 looks you did were beautiful!

[@troopicalsands]

Hi Mandy! Have you done the five minute makeup tag yet? You just time yourself 5 minutes to do your makeup. That would be fun. Your hair is amazing! Have you done a hair video yet? All your favorite products?

[@jancollier8653]

I like your nail polish 💅

[@kerriwright4593]

I really like the dark berry outter corner while still just having the very light shimmer on the lid.

[@monicaleong7231]

Mandy, could you compare and share your thoughts abt this palette vs. Natasha’s Dream palette? Is the Dream palette lighter? Thanks! Love love your videos and so lovely to see you reviewing Natasha’s palettes as well. Great work!

[@janabloomfield4151]

I rarely wear eyeshadow, but I wanted it for my occasional use (currently it’s bronzer 😂) I watched many of your videos. This palette is one I had looked at, and Color Pop, before eventually landing on Natasha Denona mini Glam and mini Glam Retro. I’m super fair completed, and the beautiful ABH palette would have been way too much for me. You helped confirm my decision. Thanks!

[@jerianderson3003]

I liked the look so much, I may have to buy the new ABH pallet. It’s unique to my collection. Thanks for sharing!

[@MistyVine]

I had the same shade that was shattered when I received my palette. But it did press back together flawlessly. I love love love this palette.

[@bobbi5523]

return the palette for a new one, every time i "fix" one thinking it'll be okay, it's a mess :( I love the Nouveau) my Lily shade (beautiful shade) from first day had a problem but thought it would be okay. Getting worse & been a while as I bought it when it came out. Concerns me others had a problem. Absolutely Love it though, best palette in forever. I'm concerned Rose Metals is too dark/warm not sure what for me as I'm pale brick browns/reds don't look good on me. Just a matter of preference. Sometimes Nouveau is a bit light, perhaps they tried to adjust or just together they go well. I like Smokey but just too many for me. Thanks, you always give the best reviews. My deal breaker sometimes is if a palette doesn't have a shade like Paloma in the other palette because if I have to go to another palette for brow bone I use it less than say the ND Glam that I thought would be way too nude for me but I love. Also has a nice pale silver/green shade. The shade Electric in Subculture made me an Anastasia fan... true confessions. Thank U

[@maltzumom468]

Can’t wait to hear how the mascara wore! I’m so curious about it, but have the hardest time finding a mascara that doesn’t smudge. I🙃

[@maudeboucher4010]

Thank you Mandy!! I feel like this video was meant for me, since it made me save big bucks! Not because your reviews is bad, but rather because it is right on point. I was going to buy this because many people are raving about it, but I realized it will be way too dark for my own taste. Thanks again!

[@tonyasullivan1164]

Mixing metallic color is very beautiful and is a soft Duo chrom

[@kcloveonaleash]

Always love seeing your new videos!! You are the most entertaining 😂👏💕

[@annlara5688]

I find that the new pallet works well with the nouveau pallet. The new pallet is on the dark side but the 2 together brings light beautiful eye looks. The new one alone is a little dark but add shades from other pallet and it brings light to the looks.

[@sherylbeamer7189]

What nail colour are you wearing? It’s stunning! Please share!💕💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻 I think this palette is gorgeous!

[@mariejoseepitre409]

Just for fun and play with makeup, it would be nice to see you challenge yourself to do a darker look using a darker shade on the mobile lid! Would be very pretty as well, I am sure of it!!

[@LorraineParis1]

I’d have pair this palette with lighter shimmers and use dark shimmers outer corner of eye and lower lash line. For me it’s just makeup and it washes off. I’m going wear any color and depth or light whenever where ever. I’m hairstylist so that helps too. 💜🌈💜Being almost 62 I use dark shadows to get my cat eye. I can’t Dothan with liner anymore. I work in fluorescent lights that wash out makeup too.

[@kerriwright4593]

I typically like light shimmers. I rarely use dark shimmers. I like darker mattes and even more mid depth mattes and mid depth, light shimmers if that makes sense.

[@jslilimauve]

I personally like a more or less even spread in a palette too. Some lighter shades, some deeper, midtone shades, mattes and shimmers so that I have many options to create many looks with just one palette and have all I need and no too similar shadows (hello, Natasha Denona). And since rarely such a palette exists I definitely prefer to build my own one with the singles. Way better. 🥰

[@Diana-yk7sp]

I've got to get this palette. I love smokey looks. This palette can absolutely work for more natural looks. A lot of those shadows can be one and done looks. I prefer the more glamorous looks. Thank you for the review.

[@reneebertram2365]

Very pretty. I just bought this pallette.

[@sandisteko9067]

Thank you so,so much Mandy .Your opinion was just what I needed. I am more of a neutral girl but I did not know which one of these two ABH to buy. Both seem so pretty.

[@serenityct2]

Thanks for reviewing saved me from buying. Like you light colors look best on me.

[@SigourneyVanaerde-Wiznitzer]

You're making me want this palette 😂 it looks so good on you!

[@natashajazmeen6174]

I bought this pallette and dont know how to use it but thank you for the video !!

[@jolanda.c]

I'm pale, so I need light shades to transition or turn down when it gets too deep. But I can always get a shade, settingpowder, highlighter, blush or bronzer to help with that out of my stash if I need to make it daily soft instead of night smokey. So for me this would be a smokey or companion palette but if you are midtone or deeper in skintone the use will be different. I wonder only if it is enough for me to buy it. I like it as a twist/update on Modern Renaissance and Soft Glam. It gives me fomo because it is limited and maybe this is a gem like Sultry, even for me...

[@kerriwright4593]

You could probably use the lightest shimmer over the darker shimmers to just lighten then a bit.

[@UnpurrfectRobyn]

Hmmm...I don't usually go dark, but this is a beautiful palette...may have to put in on my wish list and maybe I'll get gift cards for Christmas... Oh and I'm going to have to try that mascara because my lashes need all the help they can get to hold a curl!

[@kathipoplar7024]

Can you please do a couple of looks using both abh palettes together? That might be really pretty

[@ginag2176]

Glad I watched this as I wanted palette but due to the colours being deep just not my thing but it is a stunning palette xx

[@linneaburns9893]

I love the matte shades in this palette but I wish there were a few more light/mid toned shimmers, I don’t often use dark metallics! Thanks for the review

[@birdamanda76]

Hey Mandy! I really enjoyed your video and your artistry. What color is on your nails? It’s gorgeous!

[@gingergirl8797]

Stunning looks! You pulled this off perfectly.

[@donnawindham3507]

Beautiful eye look!!

[@sandylay5831]

What about using a light hand with the shades. Light on the brush. Will it still be dark Love the looks. I’m a mature 65 old old. I just don’t know if it will work for me. Like the last one.

[@ivanavaskova9458]

You look beautiful in both styles. I watched Allies video and fell in love with this palette. Thank you Mandy❤️❤️❤️

[@maryburns6248]

Beautiful on you!!❤️

[@melindagenitempo2359]

I LOVE this pallette absolutely stunning.

[@tracyfrederick5606]

You're lashes are ridiculous 😭😭😭💚💚💚 lucky ! Beautiful curls, great lashes. 💜💜💜

[@mariestopa]

How are you liking the mascara ? I don’t like clumpy mascara . I am passing on the palette because I have very deep set eyes .

[@jslilimauve]

Not interested in this ABH palette (liked Nouveau color story better)- it can be easily duped by Sydney Grace shadows which I own a lot of. Love the second look you created, Mandy ! Its stunning !

[@jancollier8653]

Gorgeous Palette 🎨🙋🏻‍♀️

[@mainecoonmomma3]

Thanks for your review on this! Really looks beautiful.

[@cfsfibromom]

That ABH palette along with the new Huda and the new Natasha Denona palettes are all too deep for me. I haven't been interested in many new palettes.

[@TheFlowMind]

Very interesting palette. Definitely should have gotten this one instead of Nouveau.

[@oxh973]

Day glam!

[@hissonggirlmoni5706]

Mandy can you please make 9 looks for the tiny marvels And the nouveau pallets?

[@scrunchmika]

Could this palette be ABH's replacement for the ICONIC Sultry palette? But this seems even more dark and smokey. Love the looks Mandy, suit you really well

[@Brego100]

Please tell us if you find a Sydney Grace dupe for that pewter shade! That’s the one shade in this palette that’s really drawing me, and I don’t want to spend $55 for one shade.

[@mistichristensen7088]

You created 2 stunning looks. So far I’ve resisted buying this one. That might change. 😉🌻💛🌻💛

[@nonam741]

I got my palette in Mail today haven't dipped fingers in it yet can't wait tell morning!!

[@lynnbogan4852]

I love that look on you! 🔥

[@TurquoiseKat]

You have just sold it to me :D The shades are exactly what I love in an eyeshadow palette!

[@evamcclellan598]

I love mid and deep tones. I would never buy a pastel pallet. I'm very fair and pastel colors don't show up on me. My daytime look is usually bronze or orange tones.

[@MyCleverHandle]

My gosh gurl! Just when I think I've seen everything you have to offer, you pull a gorgeous rabbit out of your hat and come up with a look that is so perfect for you! I love a good smoky eye, day or night. My eyes are very dark brown, but my complexion is very fair with definite cool undertones, so I can wear just about any color scheme - and I often wear the dark smokies, even behind self-darkening glasses and even in the daytime. I don't lust for this palette - it's too expensive! - but I know I have these shades and lots of darkness within two or three others, so I can be an artiste too! Thanks for the inspiration! And you do look so beautiful, please give us more!

[@wplants9793]

Not going to buy this palate - I’m not a berry red mid pink gal - but I LOVE LOVE watching you apply eyeshadows. Someday I’ll buy a palate (I’m not much of a makeup fan) and follow along :)

[@laurac86]

I absolutely love the color story in this palette but I think it might be too dark for me 😫 I have reallyyyy deep set eyes and dark tones don’t look good on me

[@kcloveonaleash]

That is made for blue eyes -;) gorgeous. Sigh. All my money goes to gas and groceries at the moment😭🤪👁️💘

[@gailschaefer-guajardo6731]

You always create such lovely 👀 eye looks. I don't think this palette is for me. Thanks for the great review. Love my ABH Nouveau palette.👍👁️❣️✔️❗👁️👁️✔️

[@bomanhansson]

I think I need the deeper colours. But why ALL metallic? I want mattes and maybe one or two shiny ones.

[@pushpins926]

I desperately want this palette....but I hate the price tag. lol

[@mikimonique5267]

This palette looks very gorgeous on you!

[@PinkStapler]

This was meant to be a retro 90s grungy palette. It's meant to be super smokey.

[@lisamattzela2589]

Beautiful!

[@cdiannethornton]

You look beautiful! What happened to your finger???

[@angie_moments]

Great video . Thank you

[@djelzinga2634]

I wonder if the shades would appear less deep if applied with a brush 🤔

[@sherrypettit5552]

I like midtones

[@jancollier8653]

You look Gorgeous 🥰🥰

[@jkom5902]

🧡🧡🧡 both looks!

[@bobbi5523]

ps.. I'm buying the mascara WOW

[@maaikeb75]

I liked the colour story of this palette and was interested in getting it. But after seen a couple of reviews I think this is to dark for me.

[@indigoangel258]

Have no idea why it's called 'Rose Metals' since I see no 'rose metals' in it!! LOL!! Maybe ONE if I'm being generous...

[@jancollier8653]

So pretty 😍

[@abbybarger7656]

You said the mascara is not a tubing mascara??

[@jt9058]

I’m not getting this palette. I have dark brown eyes and dark colors just don’t look good with dark eyes. I like the look you created though.

[@TheFlowMind]

Where did you read that? Dark colours go with any eye color 😂😂😂

[@jt9058]

I didn’t read it anywhere. It’s my experience with my eye color. 😂

[@aubreyengelbrecht8956]

What's on your nails?

[@jeanninet.5010]

To me the palette presents as muddy and nothing unique. I'm interested in the Tower 28 mascara.

[@hissonggirlmoni5706]

Tomato Tomahto. Lol you say red I say cranberry. 😘