NEW BENEFIT THEY'RE REAL MAGNET MASCARA | Best Mascara EVER?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi guys, so the mascara did not flake or smudge at all throughout the day and was actually quite a bit easier to remove with my usual oil cleanser than many of my others!! X

[@pinkTonya24]

Def gonna try this out when I'm out of my sky high mascara

[@nadiadncr]

I always watch your review when a new mascara comes out because we like the same style mascaras. Great video 💕

[@janasewaiseh8793]

Thank you Charlotte! Love your channel and all your videos. Mascara looks awesome. Is this a tubing mascara?

[@bratsj1]

Thank you! Did you notice if the lashes "fell" during the day? Or did you maintain the lift and curl? Looks really good on you *lashenvy*

[@yarerimartinez1917]

Thank you Charlotte, just I am not sure, is it waterproof? :)

[@seaswan6]

Gorgeous lashes. Would love to see a comparison between this and the Lancôme Msr Big!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you! X

[@shiprarai1122]

Yes please

[@NikkiCFO]

Makeup brands need you to be their mascara model! Amazing transformation!

[@mk6455]

I now realize I don’t put enough mascara on lol. I go whip, whip done

[@christinaluna713]

I was wondering about my own mascara game. I just watched Charlotte go over her lashes like 13 times and call that, “one coat!” Perhaps I’ve been counting coats wrong, all along 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@hannahv123]

Lol I have never seen someone put on that much mascara, she must go through it so quickly! Is this what we are supposed to do?!

[@melissakessler77]

This mascara looks right up my alley, even though I wasn’t super interested in it when I first saw it came out. I normally prefer a natural bristle brush,but I do love Roller Lash and Bad Gal Bang, so I think I will give this one a go!

[@beckyc.5743]

I haven’t been a subscriber for long and I’ve never seen you do a mascara review. I really appreciate that you showcase a mascara when you are reviewing one. I’ve never seen anyone I subscribe to provide such a thorough dialogue about mascara. Thanks Charlotte!

[@pinkTonya24]

The They're Real mascara is my FAVORITE high end mascara so naturally I am super excited about this!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ooooh I bet!! X

[@lottiem9483]

I was sold in the first 10 seconds 😂 I have piss poor lashes & get excited over new mascara.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🤣🤣🤣 I love a new mascara!! X

[@joannab1007]

I have to say I've been on the hunt for mascaras lately and i happened upon a couple of your videos and LOVE LOVE LOVE you. I have the opposite of my lashes - mine are short sparse and straight however i have tried a few of the mascaras as well and have the exact same outcomes as you so i know you're on the same page as me. THANK YOU SO MUCH for being honest and doing these videos. HELPS A LOT I am now on the hunt for more of your videos and i think i found all of them. Thanks much beautiful

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you!! x

[@KingKikikoi]

you do the best mascara review on KZbin!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ahhh thanks so much! X

[@kathrynp8080]

I've always used an eyelash primer under my mascara. I find it really gives my lashes extra oomph! This one looks good on its own though.

[@melaniestark7446]

Hi Charlotte, that's a minimal eyeshadow for you 😉It almost looks 1940s like. Just lovely.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you x

[@Jaiden137]

I always come to your reviews first as I know I will always get an honest opinion from you no BS xx

[@Silviaexcuchuflus]

Hi Charlotte!!! Thank you for the review!!! 😘😘😘 I’ve already bought the mascara in the mini size, it makes my lashes look quite impressive just with one coat, the lifting is amazing, but, sadly, it transfers to my under eye very quickly. I’ve tried with no makeup on and also with concealer set with powder but no... At least I bought the mini 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@bronyk7997]

Roller lash what a fabulous mascara l use that for length then Charlotte Tilbury for volume....I have long lashes like yours so people always accuse me of wearing false lashes...I’ve worn fake eyelashes before but like you I really don’t need too.....I love the red lip ♥️🇦🇺💋💋

[@stephaniesparks9153]

They’re real is my favorite mascara so I can’t wait to try this one

[@chrissymoss514]

Oh yes! I really like this. It definitely gives length and volume, without being "clumpy" - I'm not a fan of clumpy mascara because I have short/medium length lashes and I love the elegance of a more separated look. I'd be interested to know how it wore and if it was a nightmare to remove. Gawd, I'd love to have your super long/full lashes, they're amazing! 💗💗

[@sarahweaver7808]

I just bought the new Bite one, and it arrived yesterday. I’ve been seeing great things about this one. Might grab it when I need a new one!

[@Queenofcats36]

I'm going to have to pick the small one up, maybe even splurge on the big one!

[@DM-eg6ow]

Your lashes look great. I’m quite intrigued!

[@foxymama2003]

Grabbing this one! The lift is amazing and I love the way it built with no mess! Thanks, Charlotte, you are my go to for mascara and never let me down! ❤️

[@cdegangedc]

I just bought the Charlotte Tillbury Pillowtalk on your recommendation. I do love it. I want to know how long you wait for the product to dry between coats.

[@allisonburt5611]

Monsier big is my top mascara..i dont think anything will ever beat it.iv been using dark star..but its a 2nd to mr big for me!!xx

[@laritalovesmakeup]

Charlotte you always have the best lashes with all mascara. I love the CT push up but I might have to try this one too. 💖💄💋

[@mistytells]

Wow! I ordered this yesterday. I like feathery lashes but I have like four lashes so I wanted to try this out.

[@shiprarai1122]

Lovee your mascara reviews. I have the same mascara preference as you. So maybe ill pick this one up.. ❤

[@deborahmalpass7985]

Love it on you. So glad you liked it. I ordered it from Feelunique U.K. this morning. The only research I did was on price. The cheapest here in the UK is £19.98 and free P&P on QVC UK. You are so right Benefit definitely know how to do a mascara. I thought I had found my true love in Charlotte Tilbury push up lash but I am not sure now may be mine is getting a bit old. Only just purchased The By Terry twisty one to try as well. Hopefully find my true love of all mascara's soon x

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you! X

[@veronicamcminn7775]

Ohhh I just saw this today! Sephora is offering sample with 25$ purchase. So when I ordered I added it!

[@EstherNathalie190]

Thank you Charlotte,i like like i go buy it.georges,have a nice day.

[@sarahhollowayshore7141]

Thanks for reviewing this! I am pretty tempted with it! How would you say it compares to the Benefit Roller Lash mascara? I am quite a big fan of that one! X

[@katemakeuplooks]

Ooh, this looks like it could be a replacement for my Hourglass Unlocked, which is my current favourite but I can’t bring myself to buy it again for obvious reasons 😠. Thank you very much for this great review! 💋 💋 xxx

[@lynnhom6915]

Great review. What is your nail polish?

[@JR-md9rz]

I just swore off any mascara buys after the newest Lancome one. But I can not resist, this is going to be mine. It looks great on your lashes. My lashes are not as grand as yours, yes you should be doing mascara commercials for sure! But I have decent lashes and high hopes for this new formula. They got me 😆, no you got me, lol....

[@cmontrave1755]

Loved this review. I'm usually a one coat of mascara kinda girl but the three coats of this mascara looks gorgeous on you. I'll have to try it 😊

[@bobbymorgan7482]

Thank you for the review Charlotte! Have a good day!

[@kjay8069]

Hey! Try tarte smoothie mascara (new) from QVC uk. Honestly you will LOVE ! Plus if you don’t you can send it back . But you won’t do that. It’s amazing 🤩

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@deboraspolaor474]

When I'll need a new mascara I think I could buy It! I've got so many mascaras that are new!!!

[@inaayaxx3298]

Love the red lip x

[@deniseaukerman]

Hello Charlotte! Do you feel that the magnetic version of They're Real! mascara gave you more length than the original They're Real?

[@iriaalves9426]

Hi. Usually what is the oil cleanser that you use to remove your makeup?

[@PattyAlonso]

You’ve got spectacular lashes! 😍😍

[@savannahkillinger5406]

I love the maneater mascara by tarte

[@BriannaMW]

Sheesh girl! This makes me want to actually spend more than $7 on a mascara if I'm gonna get all that lash!!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@baybutterfly76]

The lashes look stunning on you! 🥰 Thank you for your review on this Benefit mascara!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you! X

[@pinkTonya24]

Yesss it's totally my desert island item also!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

😍😍

[@mpoxon9109]

Wow your lashes look amazing!

[@Tricia_K]

When it comes to my mascara game, I was immediately grabbed by the mini "They're Real" that once came with a Benefit kit, and have never looked back! But this looks *awesome* - and just that first coat, had me sold already! As I've got older, my lid space has become prime real estate, so although I'm a lengthening-mascara kinda girl, I can't be doing with one that diminishes the area even more - also, I've found that getting my lashes to fan out properly without depositing the black stuff everywhere from nose to brow, has become a daily struggle, so yeah... I reckon this one might have "future holy grail" written all over it! Which might have been an infinitely better name than all this "magnet" business, which at first glance I mistook for one of those products to be used with *actual* magnetic lashes? But that's probably just me, lol - and it certainly won't stop me from looking to buy it, like, right now, so ttfn and I'll be seeing ya!🤗🤗

[@gabeluvsmakeup]

I was about to miss one!! Love it!!!

[@larinadorca5781]

My all time fave is Hypnose by Lancôme (the classic one) , also like Esteé Lauder volum...can't remember the name 😂 it's the gold one. Have you tried them? I would really love to see you trying them

[@meganburbage1232]

Hi Charlotte do you recommend any tubing mascaras?

[@naasiraamin3241]

I’m on the look out for a new mascara so this is perfect timing from the mascara queen ❤️

[@sunnyhollowjill]

I am so excited! I have needed a good mascara for a while now. I have soft, sparse lashes and this looks so fabulous on you, I will give it a try. You always look so beautiful though. Stay safe and thanks for sharing.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you so much! You too lovely! X

[@Jewels_8404]

You have absolutely gorgeous natural lashes. Do you do anything to make them so full and long?

[@JayneNicoletti]

Wow that is amazing. I think I may get because mine are long and volumous but droopy. Thank you for reviewing.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You're so welcome! X

[@sarahtimney8416]

OMG your lashes look stunning ❤️

[@conniejones9832]

I'm such a mascara junkie. I have been trying to use up what I have...but now I must buy this mascara. Great video !

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I love trying new mascaras! X

[@karenmcalley1191]

Wow ur lashes look amazing. Ill add these to my shopping list😘 x

[@preetibhatia9795]

Hey charollet u look gorgeous as u do..❤️👌great reviews 👍benefit is easily available in India.. so m getting it👌❤️thanks for urs reviews 💗💗

[@carolchadwick3580]

WoW! on my way to Ulta to buy this.... Thank you ❤️

[@jenniferbreeden8171]

I find that mascara gets better after a couple of weeks. Wondering what you’ll think after you’ve had some time to play with it. Thanks for another great video! Hope you and your family are well! ❤️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Some do definitely! Others rapidly decline....🤣🤣 x

[@corinadawn3414]

Was waiting for your thoughts on this!! Might just add it to my cart after all!!! Hugs to you and your family Charlotte!!! ❤❤❤❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you my love! X

[@beebeautiful1]

Hi lovely, oh this looks very impressive! I will have to try this out when I need new 💕 Jo xo

[@pamelahewlett1750]

Omg, I've been eyeing this!, I can't wait to hear what you think!!!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

😘😘😘

[@daniellemeservey312]

I'm so buying this when I get paid!!

[@meganryan9945]

Beautiful Charlotte!❤️

[@LoveKeebuu]

this is the BEST MASCARA EVER! PERIOD. ❤️️

[@mistytells]

Omg! I missed you so much!

[@maritzachavez8967]

First, I need to have your luscious lashes to achieve such gorgeous effect on my bitty eyes! 😁 Second, that mascara gives you lift, length and instant tight lining action as well! I am very tempted to try this one. Besos Charlotte! 😘🥰

[@rachelunderhill5908]

They look good, just checked on qvc 19.98 with free p and p at the moment, plus if u did not like it u can send it back xxx take care xx

[@christinaluna713]

Did you put eyeliner on or is this all just the mascara we’re seeing?? It totally looks like you’ve got liner on.

[@meitalkabeli509]

I was wondering if you would try this, when I saw this I was so curious about it. I used to love the original They're Real before my eyes became more sensitive. The length is amazing, it does lift a little too. I'll have to research the formula to see the difference and if my eyes can tolerate this one.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Fingers crossed!! X

[@bridgetmartinbm]

How is it compared to the benefit roller lash?

[@marielleaxelsson2755]

How do you make it? This mascara smudge extremely when I use it. Even if I only use one layer on the upper lashes it smudge all around my eyes... very, very black under the eyes.

[@krystalbaker9251]

That lip colour! 😍🙌

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@cherylt5818]

Thank you for this, I am going to try this one as long as it is as easy as you say to remove because the original is insane to get off! AND......I will forgive you for your perfect dang lashes. ;)

[@pamelahewlett1750]

Yay! I get to try a new mascara!, thanks Charlotte 😊❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You're so welcome! X

[@BrookelynnesBeautyCorner]

Love the lash look this mascara gives 💖💖💖

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Me too! Xx

[@footyfan101ful]

There was an ad for this mascara just before I watched this video!!

[@monikagrundova9657]

Your most beautiful look of all time.

[@karenliseberg8122]

Yes I am going to buy this one

[@PoppyBryn2013]

I misread it as magnetic and had visions of your lashes sticking together every time you blinked. I then wondered why Benefit considered it such a good selling point. Oops, lol. I'll shortly be in the market for a new mascara and will add this to the 'under consideration' list.

[@raquelfreeman81]

I can't wait to get this

[@jianniemarcellin9873]

Please answer can you please tell me what type of mascara should an 11 year old put on and also can you tell me an washable one too and easy to take off and also how to take it off

[@veil693]

Have you tried the Bite Upswing mascara? I hear it slaps

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I haven't! Bite beauty isn't available here x

[@veil693]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft oh 😭😭

[@sukhilatif5431]

This looks great, also looks like your top lashes are lined with eyeliner but it's the mascara, so dramatic!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Right up my street! X

[@dolleeeh]

Why nobody's mentioning armani's mascaras?! If you're a mascara person like me you should try them!

[@laurelkinsley]

Now I must own this mascara.

[@KBellaBeauty1]

What an interesting concept!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Isn't it?!! X

[@dianaa.8270]

did not work for me. I am happy it worked for you

[@leahmiranda8359]

Gorgeous! I'm definitely going to try! Read the pinned comment.....great news! Thank you for the review❤😘

[@DanielaBoard72]

Yay. Mascara....my fav. 😊

[@dailystruggle2762]

What have you done...????

[@taigahilliard619]

Was this a hard one to remove?

[@sanitasanita9279]

I love it 😍

[@chloecarson46]

Looks so gorgeous!!! As do you x

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ahhh thank you! X

[@lindaliffers9690]

Your eyelashes are amazing!! Curious, Do you use any serums??

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you! I don't but I've been thinking of trying one! X

[@sharontodd7761]

Wow that was really good. I may have to get that one. Blessings XOXOXOXOXO

[@bigbertha8657]

It’s weird that the only people I know who wear mascara anymore are older.

[@MetteMai75]

🙏❤ saphora here we come😂

[@conniemelvin6727]

WOW