MAC STACK MASCARA | NEW HOLY GRAIL?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovelies, little update as promised! The mascara did not flake or smudge at all and was indeed easy to remove, I'd say one of the easiest I've tried to get off with my oil cleanser 🙌🙌

[@nadiadncr]

Wearing today from a sample I got! I’m so happy you reviewed it if it’s Charlotte approved it’s a good one! 💕

[@ashleyw5774]

What are you wearing on your eyelids? Beautiful!

[@angelabenigno]

If only you could try the Italian brand Mesauda Milano! They released a new mascara called Big and Thick Lashes. Wonderful!

[@chrissymoss514]

So good to know, thank yooooooooooo 👌

[@fudebooty]

How does this compare to the Bite mascara?!

[@TheMiikka34]

I work in a hot kitchen in a factory canteen. I've worn this in black for approximately 2 weeks (I had a sample). By far one of my new favs. No flaking, no wierd racoon eyes half way through my shift, and came off super easy.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks so much for sharing! X

[@beckaj2775]

What other mascaras work for you please? Can you list them. I work in a hot environment too

[@TheMiikka34]

@@beckaj2775 I also use the MAC Haute and Naughty waterproof. I usually hate waterproof because it tends to be a pain to remove but that one melts right off. Before that I used an mlm mascara for years. You could also try your favourite mascara and the Patrick Starrr one/size on til dawn setting spray. Legit I stand over an 8 burner flat top and 4 basket deep fryer (204c and 180c respectively) for 8 hours with a mask and my makeup does not budge when I use it. Spehora sells a trial size.

[@sarahroot3650]

I haven't been interested in a MAC mascara in a long time, but for some reason this one caught my eye. Lord knows I love to "stack" my mascara..

[@lesliehatch-herman9325]

Hmm…I think I would be Team Micro. I’ve always had a bit of a shorter lash, but evidently with age comes a touch of sparseness, as well 😑 (aging is the gift that keeps on giving, am I right, ladies?! 🥳). I’m truly looking forward to trying this formula!! Thank you for your thorough review, Charlotte!

[@gigi-fc4hm]

i highly recommend grande lash serum. it’s a little bit more on the pricey side about $60 for one bottle but it lasts 3 months and it makes your lashes longer and thicker!! if you want to make the investment it’s very rewarding. there’s also a $30 half size if you want to just test it out!

[@lesliehatch-herman9325]

@@gigi-fc4hm thank you…sounds like a must-try!!

[@meitalkabeli509]

When I saw this was coming out, I didn't understand the whole brush part of it, now I see it's two different types of brushes. Both sides look amazing, but I agree the Mega one gave a slight more lift to your lashes. This mascara looks really good and might be something to try.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I was really surprised how amazing it was! X

[@pamelahewlett1750]

Love both but the more dramatic side is definitely the one for me! 🥰😍🤩

[@martinemissiaen4692]

hi charlotte, the big brushes on your upper lashes and the small brushes on your lower lashes that's the perfect match, thanks for the review

[@goldiemarkowitz9300]

Can I just say that your lipstick and liner combination is absolutely stunning 🤩

[@AC-px9md]

I like the two coats of the Mega brush mascara on top and micro brush on the lower lashes.

[@gypsysnickerdoodle4354]

The wand ball seems like a brilliant ergonomic pivot point that could add a lot of dexterity & fine precision

[@caienateichert9840]

I love the micro brush and how it looked after you aplied 3 times. I prefer the more natural mascara look 😍

[@fionabanyai4971]

I think this is the best review ever on this product. Thankyou 🌟🌟

[@graceleathers5970]

The mega is my fave! I love a chunky lash

[@courtneycullen6289]

OOH! I was so hoping you would review this mascara!

[@thegoodlife6061]

I will try your method in applying more than 1 mascara coat which I never have thought about doing that. great video

[@donnahalstead531]

Just bought it and love it!! All about the drama for me too!!🥰

[@jocelynbowers6965]

Cannot wait to try on my sparse lashes! Luv ur hair curled, very pretty! 😉💕

[@tammyvaught2210]

I’m so excited to try this!! You and I are basically lash twins and I want my lashes to look the same, the more drama the better. I’m happy when people think I’m wearing falsies lol. The last thing I need is another mascara but I’ve got to try this one. I kind of have a mascara problem 😂😂. My lower lashes are also super long and I have to wear tubing mascaras on the lowers or I will get smudging. I definitely prefer the mega brush although the micro brush looked good as well 😊.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🙌

[@lubazak636]

Just ordered the Mega. My favorite is Dark Star, so will see how this compares. My lashes are similar, thanks to Latisse. Tried the Mac Stack on one eye and the Dark Star on the other eye, with one light coat of Kill Lash Superproof waterproof mascara underneath, after curling my stick straight lashes. After wearing a mask, for an hour or so, the Pat McGrath Dark Star side fell, while the MAC Stack side stayed curled. My new Holy Grail.

[@jennifermorrison229]

I would have to have both brushes. Mega for upper lashes and micro for my lower.

[@Kayce62]

Both eyes look amazing. I just ordered the micro as that style seems to suit me a little more

[@217makeup7]

Both looked beautiful on you as always! I think having both would be beneficial for many people. The mega side is everything on you! Thanks 😊

[@gsplady50]

I bought this after seeing your review. LOVE it. It has not flaked or smudged and I have long lashes again.

[@samnicol9388]

Thank you for doing this my fav mascara is mac in extreme dimension 3D. It has huge amount in the tube and lasts a whole year, I know it shouldn’t. The straight brush makes it easy for lash line upper rim stamping just by blinking on it. Excited to try the new one.

[@twoleftfeet9626]

I don't normally get on with non waterproof mascara, but took the plunge with this one. It is EPIC! No racoon eyes!

[@barbiturat1562]

I really did not expect that this mascara would be that WOW. I bought it a few days ago and I love it! (mega brush / straight lashes with a normal lenght)

[@MsBNoodle]

There's a mini size of the mega brush one if people wanted to try before committing to the bigger size

[@gabrielanoll9078]

Looking forward to your updated top five mascaras list...always check you out for mascaras, as you are my mascara requirement twin...and you are undoubtedly the queen of mascaras...in fact that's how I discovered you 💗

[@debbieotoole1072]

This looks like a good one 👍, I have eyelashes like you, Charlotte; I don't have to wear false lashes, so I like big and bold

[@emiliebova]

Ooh! My mascara was running low. I love the fat brush side! More is more is me too! I am up in the middle of the night watching in Florida, USA. Thanks for your good review.

[@dluelmo]

I'm definately macro. Though micro would probably work better on my lashes. Thanks for the review! I think I'm going to pick this up when I buy my next haul!

[@denise11726]

Love Mac mascars! This looks beautiful on your lashes. I'm Team Micro for the day at least because my eyes are deep set and Im in my mid 50s.. I find with more drama on the lash, my eye lid's eye shadow isn't as visible. I can definitely see using the mega brush at night to stand out more. Your video will have me buying this next. Thank you!!

[@gbtink]

I’d give this a try! The results look so similar to my beloved volume de Chanel. I’m so picky about my mascara, I have lashes like u - i have nice natural long lashes and I don’t wear falsies bc I can get my natural lashes to look full & amazing.

[@Donna-cc1kt]

You have Scheherazade eyes. I’ve never thought or said that before. Beautiful. BTW, Gemma from Pampered Wolf says to say hi and send you love. Done! I’m definitely going to try that MAC mascara💕

[@JenniferHRoss]

I'm with you 100% of the way - bigger brush on top and smaller brush on the bottom. I might have to actually get this one. (Technically, these ones....) Thanks for sharing.

[@BlingyBea]

Oh my your lashes, just ordered the mini mega size👏👏 I use the MAC Extended Play Gigablack Lash Mascara for my bottom lashes, will have to try that micro one when I finish this one. Would have been genius if they were both in one container.

[@chloecarson46]

Looks amazing! Definitely want to try this. Sorry if I’m being dumb Charlotte but I can’t see in the description box what eyeshadow you’re wearing? Looks so lovely!🥰

[@GlamgirlJ]

This video was a pleasant surprise! I wanted this mascara the second I saw it online, lovely review - it sold me! I will defiantly be picking this up!! 💖💖

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@unmellowyellow]

Just last night, I was wishing that you could buy mascaras with different wands. I tried the Rare Beauty mascara, and the brush is freaking gigantic and I hate it! Same with EVERY Pat McGrath mascara. I have short Asian lashes, and if the mascara has a huge bushy brush, I am usually gone and out the door. Even if I like the formula of a mascara, if the brush is huge, I usually cannot use it. I will definitely buying the micro brush!

[@misssjw]

Hi - just liking/commenting to get the algorithm to notice this vid so brands can see its doing well and you can keep shimmying on those PR lists girl! Love your content, you’re my go to for all things makeup 😀

[@deejohnson827]

You look absolutely stunning, Charlotte! I prefer the micro side, but maybe that's because I'm jealous of your beautiful natural lashes. 😅🥰

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🤣🤣🤣 SABOTAGE!!!

[@deejohnson827]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft 😁😁😁🥰

[@monicaearl6700]

Love the mega brush mascara! I'll have to try this one - looks terrific! X

[@rosierose4452]

I have both, best mascaras ever❤

[@shelleymalone4427]

I think they both look great on you. I like the mega on you. For me, the micro. I have short lashes, so I will give it a try when I need a new mascara.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you! X

[@jenniferasigno7010]

I love the look I love mascara and big lashes so just ordered both lol . Thank you for you thoughts 😊

[@allisonwhisler4149]

I ordered this from the Mac website and can’t wait to get it. I did order the mini in case I didn’t love it. I am super excited to try it.

[@gwenrybeck3794]

I also have super long bottom lashes. I have dark thick hair/brows/lashes, but I am super pale. I got made fun of when I was younger for having spider leg lashes on the bottom, so I rarely use mascara on them.

[@donnaholland5156]

Thanks Charlotte, just got the mascara today in the mega brush it’s amazing! Really volumising and separating, loving it a lot!

[@marielle7505]

Oh dear, I'm afraid I'm going to have to try this one. Looks so gorgeous on you! I think I would opt for the mega brush. Thanks, this was a very helpful review. I was just trying to decide wich mascara I should try next. Tried the Bite beauty upswing, but I'm not loving it. Too clumpy, too little lenght.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@terrymurphy5586]

I prefer the mega lash. It is good to have a beauty influencer talk about Mac products as they do have some excellent makeup items, including their eyeshadows. Your hair looks beautiful in this video.

[@kellyy1833]

Oooooh I am definitely a micro fan! I think I might have to go get one now! 😃

[@renatarosa8163]

I ❤️both on you !Great application!

[@peninalipkin2974]

i really like the micro brush look but for sure for the lower lash it needs the micro brush

[@robinchugg9062]

Had to order as soon as I saw it on your lashes! Can’t wait to receive them. Your lashes look amazing!

[@dorisstevenson8526]

I really like both but I prefer the mega side lol i’m definitely gonna pick one up 🤩💞😉

[@sherrypettit5552]

I love both. Mega on top. Micro on bottom

[@AlexaCBrown]

💌Thank you💌!! I am so looking forward to trying both of these. Both sides, are absolutely beautiful, on you 💝 I like the fine for bottom, but would use both, on myself, for the top lashes, depending on the day, or night. I am all about mascara, as you say that you are... I've never had any good experience with false lashes. Stunning 💝🥰 Thank you, again 💌💝

[@kulkulbelle]

Team Micro I think. I’m ordering today. Thanks for a wonderful review xxx

[@Teyshi]

Great review, I know which one I want now 😍🙌

[@sallyg9183]

I ran out and got this mascara right away and love it too!

[@tiger-lilyketellapper6722]

I trust your opinion, and i bought it this morning!! i absolutely love it!! you have similar lashes as me as well as the same wishes in a mascara, so could not go wrong!!💕💕

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I'm so glad you love it! x

[@kohk79]

I wish that I had lashes like yours 😭 Mine are sparse, straight af and stubborn, they only hold a curl with waterproof mascara. I would love to find a non-waterproof mascara that holds the curl on my stubborn lashes, but haven’t found that yet… any recommendations from people with straight and stubborn lashes are welcome! As for which side is my favorite, when it comes to lashes, MORE is MORE ❤️

[@SmileLC100]

Looooove it! Thank you so much! I am just wondering if this is a tubing mascara?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You're so welcome! No its not x

[@emmalcm]

I'm so excited to try this! I managed to get a travel size of the megabrush version for free, decent size for a sample. I'm using Charlotte Tilbury pillow talk at the moment because it came in a set but honestly it's just OK for my lashes, not amazing

[@ninajones6622]

I love your mascara reviews, I get so excited when I get the notification. Thanks Charlotte, I have just ordered this from Boots following your video, now I'm looking forward to trying it myself xx

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

My favourite type of review to do! X

[@veronicarobertson3663]

Try the Mac gigabyte mascara... it's fab for lower lashes

[@UnboxLili88]

I agree that the mega on top and micro on the bottom seems like the best combo. I love the look of the mega lash most though and I very often struggle with getting my lower lashes to show, so I think the mega all around might be best for me! When I'm no longer on a mascara no-buy, I'm going to buy it!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ooooh sounds perfect!

[@cynthialees2760]

I say go big or go home!! Love your gorgeous lashes!! Love the volume!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yasssssss!!

[@sleepinglabradors]

Oh these are interesting! Do you have naturally long lashes or do you use something to get those gorgeous lashes?

[@Littlen80]

🤩 wow 🤩 wow 🤩 wow 🤩 I am sold! And look at this crazy amazing packaging!!!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

So cute!

[@charlenejensen3559]

Another great mascara review. I loved both sides so I can't decide. ❤️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@gayleromano3986]

Love it! I am definitely going to order it! Ty Charlotte

[@NinaJacksonTLC]

OMG these are totally stuuuuuuuuuuunnnnnnning - Charlotte you look faaaaaaaabulous with the new MacStack. Thanks so much for this video. 🙂

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you my love! X

[@christineshadya5741]

Is it a tubing mascara? Those are my FAVORITE. I also picked up the cosmic black version of Lash Sensational Sky High and it’s somehow even better than the blackest black. Not only the colour but it performs better!!!

[@gabeluvsmakeup]

Omg!! The queen of lashes!!! 👑 is back!! And some MAC PR!! So excited for you my love! I saw this in store when I was working for Dior at MAC. They were preselling it. I was waiting on a review from someone first and of course my Goddess of Lashes has spoken☺️🤗 they look amazing!! I’m so glad you did this review!! My lashes are super short so this may work really well on me;) you look so gorgeous😘💕💕

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Awwww you can always count on my for mascara reviews! Thank you so much my love Xxx

[@laurahodgson6531]

Thanks Charlotte - in the market for a new mascara and the micro brush version looks perfect for my short lashes

[@24kzumbagoldwithsaleemah32]

Saw these today at Nordstrom and was definitely intrigued. I’m so glad you reviewed them so quickly and now I know which one to choose. I’m going to start with mega. Love a fat lash and love to achieve it in minimal time. Love your channel❤️

[@melanierice9655]

Thank you so much for this review! I was hoping you would try the product❤ Both sides looked great but I'm definitely going for the micro because it seems like you have more control over the application.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@strictlystarlight]

I want to try this looks good on you. MAC were annoying they sent me an empty sample package

[@seaswan6]

I caught this mascara sneaked into your IG pic the other day and have been waiting with excitement to hear your take on it. We are lash twins both in actual lashes and mascara preferences!!

[@kristenpotter7100]

Charlotte, what on earth is on your eyelids? It’s the most beautiful shimmer!

[@Notperfecttonya]

OMG!! I think I’m in love!!!! 🥰 I love both on you. I think I will buy the micro bc I do have sparse lashes but I want that mega brush badly! 🤣 I can’t wait to buy this!!! Thank you for this review! And again, I love your total look today! That sweater (jumper) color is smashing on you!!! 🔥❤️

[@MsBNoodle]

Saw your lashes on your Instagram and thought they looked amazing! didn’t twig it was a new mascara until I saw this video.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@MsBNoodle]

Update to say I bought it! Anyone who is planning on buying both so they can use it on their lower lashes I would just get the mega one and see how you get on with that on your lower lashes first, the wand is a really good shape and I was able to do my short stubby bottom lashes using the thinner end of it. It's really good formula, I am now converted to MAC as I like their tubing one for every day and now this for when I want oomph. Thanks Charlotte!

[@jshaw5671]

I'm a mascara maximalist. I have and wear mutiple formulas for different things. I have decent upper lashes so more is more is more and is more deletible. But my lower lashes are the thing. I find I have just a few products that I can wear that keep the smear at bay. The 50 yr old in undereye doesn't need any help looking darker. I like both sides. If I buy this, I would probably have to buy both to deal with the lower lash situation. You know, a new mascara countdown would be pretty swell. It is, after all, the product we buy most often.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🙌🙌

[@macha0385]

Have you tried the mac extended play gigablack lash for lower lashes? Its my HG for 10+ years, nothing beats it! But I gotta try these new ones

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I have! X

[@oceanbird.]

Congrats on getting Mac PR! The side with the mega brush almost looked like your lashes were a bit more even, like the bigger brush was coating more lashes at once in an even row. It's nice to see you apply the mascara actually! And to see how you get the inner and outer corner lashes and lowers, those are the tricky parts :) I'm a fan of the micro brush! I have similar natural lashes to you, but I like a more natural look and I think I'd be happier using the micro brush. I somehow always poke myself in the eye if the brush is too big and get wet mascara all over my face 😅

[@stephaniepfaff3648]

Definitely Team BOTH...😄😉🙃Thanks, Charlotte!Just the video I needed regarding this MAC Mascara!😘

[@reganszczepanowska8272]

I think both pascals have a place in a collection just as you stated. I will definitely be checking the larger or maybe even both of them out for myself. Wanted to ask if you’ve done something different with the color of your hair it’s absolutely stunning

[@danielletrue1027]

Danget when did this drop because ULTA is OOS so I’m SOL however they do have the bigger option just not the smaller wand ERRG !! This sounds amazing, not often do I go right over to purchase a product but looking at this I just know it’s going to WORK !! Reminds me of my Huda legit wand but it dries up quick like so need another option and this might be it ,) I will try once the smaller version is available as my lashes need all the help they can get…. I just can’t do falsies want to but just to hard and whenever I do try they always fall off to get embarrassing comments asking what’s on my cheek we’ll it’s my false lash ERRG

[@lisalovesphotography]

I’d prefer the micro version for myself, but damn! The mega version lashes are huge-and very ‘you’!! Wow!

[@GazeldaS]

Mega for the upper, micro for the lower....and 3 coats always.

[@minilea144]

The MACscara (they missed an oppertunity with that name. You're welcome, MAC) looks great on you BUT you have AMAZING lashes so, I can't tell if it's actually good or not.

[@elainebines6803]

Wow... Mac is back! I like them both but if I had to choose, I'm a micro fan 🤔

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🙌🙌

[@lucycarpenter6694]

Wooow 😅 I’m actually looking for a new mascara so this could be a potential for me! You look lush in this video as always

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you so much Lucy!! x

[@leahmiranda8359]

Did you mention Twiggy??? I definitely lived in, and thoroughly embraced, the Twiggy lash era. I still draw thin lower lashes on... in the sparser areas! 😁 My first makeup love was Yardley of London. 💛💛 Have I neglected to mention how much I love your hair color? It's gorgeous and makes you look same!💜

[@the6.23enigma]

Hi Charlotte ✨I am excited for the micro brush as I have decent length however, my lashes are so blonde! I think it going to be perfect! Thank you for the review you lash goddess👑

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🙌🙌

[@sharonyoung4445]

Charlotte, honestly, I can't tell a difference. Much love to you

[@nicolasbikic2861]

It's a typical exemple of how fashion conveys messages : the microbrush says : " I am here, I am audacious and I will take my place with subtlety and strenght because I want to make things right ." while the megabrush is more like "screw you, here I am" lol. I may be exagerating a little bit, but what I mean is it's the same message but even more daring and bold or flamboyant while the microbrush is more precise, delicate and subtle but still powerful. Choose your team 🤚

[@EstherNathalie190]

Hi Charlotte,i think u always look georges and beautyfull.Learn a lot of tips from you.Thanks 💖💝

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you!

[@leighaparker8798]

Yayyyy so happy for a new video! I clicked SOO FAST!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰

[@karenplunkett4400]

You look stunning!