NEW BYD Seal review - is this Chinese EV REALLY better than a Tesla? | What Car?

[@noodlefoo]

Different countries, different prices, different perspectives. In Australia, the prices of Seal are unbeatable, cheaper than Model 3. Also here in Australia the indicator stalk is the correct way, unlike Model 3 which has no stalk at all. Plus Model 3 has the stupid ways of changing gears (on the screen or overhead buttons).

[@BendeVette]

What do you mean with "Plus Model 3 has the stupid ways of changing gears ". I'm not aware of any gears on a Tesla, so I think you mean something else. The BYD Seal is about $3000 less expensive than a Tesla Model 3. So that's a thing indeed. Whether or not this is an unbeatable price difference? In overal, the Model 3 is a better car with (probably) a higher sale price after 5 years and cheaper to run (less kWh per km). The Model 3 has a better ride quality and seriously more boot space. So, it really depends if those stalks are worth the difference. p.s. I like the looks of the Seal better, but the new Model 3 is not an ugly car either.

[@cai0]

​@@BendeVette probably means by "gears" changing to drive, reverse, etc. The Seal in Australia is $51k on-road (in QLD) and the Model 3 is $65k on-road. That's a little more than $3k difference ;) However, the $51k is the "dynamic" version, which is one level lower than the one shown in this video. Not even worth considering. If you compare the Seal Premium, which is equivalent to the one from the video, then you're talking $5k difference. About resale value, it's hard to tell, but I would bet on Tesla holding the value better than BYD. Both would still be bad though. One thing not covered in the video is the "safety" features of the BYD, which tries to send you to oncoming traffic, and the "auto pilot" that can't even keep you in the lane. Features you have to disable on every single drive so the car doesn't try to kill you.

[@theflightclub7969]

I just had a test drive of a Seal Premium and Dolphin top range today. Seal has very attractive exterior when I see it in person. Nicely designed interior feels like traditional car interior with all the buttons so those who like physical buttons will like it. However, the deal breaker for me was the flimsy infotainment system and the lag of one pedal driving. Also the dash screen was not designed in intuitive way so even though it displayed a bunch of information, none of them is useful while driving. Their hardware looked pretty good, however, they need to work on the software way much more. With the price gap of $3k from Tesla Model 3, I would go and buy a tesla Model 3. Seal has a value for people who don’t want many features from a car but for me Tesla is way more advanced in terms of feature wise. My conclusion is, BYD’s hardware almost matches Tesla’s one but the software and the features are far less advanced at this stage. No netflix, no KZbin, no browser, no sentry mode, no pin to drive, no pin to glove box, no auto hold on a steep road, having to start and stop the car and etc. are what it’s missing compared to. Tesla. Dolphine was quite good but the price range of over $45k AUD is not really attractive for what the car is.

[@sargfowler9603]

The new Tesla model 3 Highland is a non-starter for many people as it's too minimalistic. This car looks great and is more conventional to suit buyers moving to an EV.

[@SpankeyMcCheeks]

Have you tried the new Model 3? I was VERY sceptical towards the indicators in the wheel, but it took me only half my 30 min test drive to get completely used to it. Not a problem at all. And changing "gears" through the screen is very easy. The car can even choose for you if it detects an obstacle in front of you it'll assume you'll want to go backwards.

[@birdmanmarbella]

I prefer the styling of the Seal, exterior and interior, compared to the Tesla. I do want to see instrumentation in front of me and not just in a central position.

[@natepolitics1490]

I went yesterday to see the car and sit inside and it blows telsa out of the water. I was very pleased with the car.

[@IceW4ve]

Looks are subjective, Tesla is more streamlined, BYD takes a more additional approach in my opinion. Front looks better than TM3 Highland, the back worse than Highland (BYD looks far too asian for my taste). Tesla gives a spaceship vibe, BYD standard car vibe, nothing good nothing bad. Software design, UI structure, translations, animations, service mode, games, native built-in apps, mobile app integration, driver profile synchronization and portability between cars, as well as screen computer performance are 500 times better in the Tesla obviously, same as with Autopilot, BYD Seal autopilot can't keep it in lane centered on European roads in recent testing, Tesla does it no problem. BYD on the other hand offers Android Auto integration for example, while Tesla uses completely own OS. Interior BYD has traditional design, Tesla again most things on the touchscreen. BYD offers premium upgrade to get a Heads up display, Tesla does not. Personally, having driven the Highland, I did not miss any display in front of me, but that is subjective and everyone definitely should test drive both! Personally I don't like the glossy surfaces in the BYD interior, but this is personal taste. Storage space is more in the Tesla, and frunk is bigger in the Highland. In the Model 3, the rear seats folded down do present a much flatter surface than in the BYD, making camping in the Tesla vastly superior. (plus camp mode in Model 3 is very nice). Model 3 also comes with Matrix LED adaptive headlights at no additional cost in Europe, which is a HUGE plus, especially driving long windy roads or on the freeway at night, BYD does not offer any such feature. According to a review by an actual EV mechanic, BYD uses a legacy approach for the ABS sensor design at the wheel axis, which means it will be broken 100% in less than 8 years requiring extensive repairs. Additionally, BYD is heavier and bulkier than Model 3, with tires being too small to support it when doing erratic maneuvers, when compared to Model 3 the ESP had to engage every single time on BYD to keep it on the road. Maintainability is far easier on the Tesla, because on the BYD, a mechanic needs half an hour to only unscrew the underbody shield (70 to 80 small screws) to even be able to diagnose any problem if such occurs. Model 3 uses like 5 big screws, done. Tesla service centers are far more present here in Europe, I don't even know where I could take the relatively new BYD for repairs. BYD has average working auto wipers, Tesla still has a problem with the wiper speed in rain (got better but still needs work). Sound system definitely superior and louder in the Model 3 having listened to both. Model 3 is more efficient than the Seal no question, need to charge less electricity as a result and saving money. Fast charging speed is faster in Model 3 than BYD Seal What I noticed is BYD is faking pictures of their car on the website, in real life the gap between wheels and chassis is bigger than on the pictures, but many Chinese car brands are doing this practice to make it look slightly better on marketing images. Tesla images seemed normal for me. Cheers!

[@nobodyli6543]

your taste is quite unique @@IceW4ve

[@BOULDERPUNCHER9000]

Teslas have a boring and ugly interior.

[@natepolitics1490]

@@IceW4ve Great job breaking that all down. Thanks

[@nikkipedro]

Come on Doug, wiper and light stalks the wrong way around is a negative? Surely the bulk of the Japanese cars you get in the UK are the same, no one seems to mention it when reviewing them.

[@kenzohkw]

You're correct, the Seal is the correct way round for a right hand drive car, we have been driving LHD converted euro cars and the manufacturers can't be arsed swapping the stalks so we have accepted it as standard. We need to be less stupid and ignorant. Nearly all Japanese cars in the UK are setup as the euro style with indicators on the left. They are probably laughing at us all the time.

[@vasil7410]

Indeed, this reviewer must be a bit slow, because I swap between left and right handed stalk cars in my garage and have adapted just fine by the first corner. Try swapping between stalks and NO stalks - now that is a problem. Clearly this guy is heavily biased.

[@dyemanoz]

Japan is RHD country and stalks the same side as other rhd countries like aus and UK.

[@sithabelamandlawenkosiwodu6298]

​@@vasil7410reviewer is a petty Tesla Fanboy.

[@Mexxx65]

@@kenzohkw And most Japanese cars in America have their blinker stalks on the left.....

[@chujon9]

A lot of car reviewers said that the rotating screen is a gimmick. I think it is useful to use portrait view for navigation. isnt that what we use in our phones??? Why is it when is something new is offered and because they dont understand its use, it is branded a gimmick???!!! I rest my case.

[@weizheng7885]

If that was gimmicky, then Model 3 must be gimmick king!! From the door handle, dash dashboard, to the turning light switch, touch screen shift!!! that's crazy!

[@sithabelamandlawenkosiwodu6298]

​@@weizheng7885so true but you'll never hear them mention all that gimmicky stuff on the model 3. Just because they don't understand it doesn't mean it's gimmicky.

[@maxi12715]

Some people just wanted to act smart over everything smh

[@coolskool1.061]

100%

[@TareqMahbub]

The camera captured the beauty of the car 😍 This guy is obviously biased against BYD or China. Or maybe he is a Tesla share holder . With an MG umbrella, he was very attentive and took every opportunity in mentioning some made up reasons to prove how Tesla and competitors are better. But took no effort in mentioning where this car is better.

[@davout5775]

Because there are not a lot of areas where it is better than TM3

[@magnusborneo6264]

A biased review, clearly not a worthy watch review. There are many more credible reviewers out there

[@davout5775]

@@magnusborneo6264 Clearly you consider only the reviews that say the BYD is better. Thankfully there is not a single review where the final conclusion is that the Seal is better than the new Model 3

[@juliozandamela]

You are right, i just watched a review were the guy pointed out alot of things that's are better than Tesla model 3

[@kevinkusuma9002]

@@davout5775 no one cares about your TM3 . cry more

[@ateiviz]

Reviewers back at it again 😂 I've had one for 4 weeks so here we go: Aircon controls are on the steering wheel and center console. The kwh figure is not annoying as anyone driving should be looking at the road. The issue with not seeing the screen can be easily solved by moving your hand or your head to check whatever you want to check. Strong smell of plastic is a what everyone else calls the "new car smell". I've had multiple passangers in the back and have had no complaints about the seat comfort, it's actually the opposite. You can open the boot with they key or using a button on the door if you didn't want to touch the boot. My indicator is on the left. Design version is plenty fast and super fun on the back roads. Stick it into eco mode and it's a super comfortable cruiser.

[@stevehodgson7487]

Hi there , with having your car for your weeks, I’m wondering where you live. Mine gets delivered around 20 March and was wondering if the uk seals have been altered on the stalks of the steering column, Thanks !!

[@ateiviz]

@@stevehodgson7487 I'm in Ireland, I placed my order late last year so was able to get one of the early lots coming in. I believe the very first few cars that landed had the indicator on the right.

[@stevehodgson7487]

Thanks for your early reply. I’m hoping my indicators are on the left, but if not I suppose I’ll get used to it eventually. The garage has confirmed it has arrived at the dock, but last week they got a design model in and the stalk was the opposite way round, Guess I’ll have to wait and see. Anyway, enjoy your new car and happy motoring.😎😎

[@ateiviz]

@@stevehodgson7487 personally it wouldn't have been an issue for me, we have a Japanese car as well and that has right hand side indicators so I'm just used to having to make that mental switch fairly quickly. Thanks and you too! It's a lovely car you won't regret it.

[@onceafiend]

I love a right hand indicator

[@stephen546]

It's is exactly the review I expected from this guy unfortunately. Constantly going on about what he thought the cars weaknesses were with very few positives, he mentioned the cars name multiple times negatively etc etc. I remember him saying the Hyundai Ioniq 6 wasn't that good in a previous review!!. The reality is, unless it's a Tesla or an Apple phone (which he mentions) it'll always be second best in his eyes!!. That's why I take whatever he says with a pinch of salt...

[@LittleBoobsLover]

yeah I noticed that brits are crying that this car is not a tesla/rolls/porsche. Tbh if chinese could make car which looks the best in my opinion (check latest electrify with shadow green seal) in so short time, with good build quality - they are on good path to make much better cars.

[@benjaminsmith2287]

I agree. After all the negative nonsense he said about the Polestar 2 vs. the Model 3 this is what I expect from him. Nothing can live up to the Model 3 where he just doesn't see the many shortcomings it has.

[@benjaminsmith2287]

@@Crusde Electrifying picked the Seal over the (Highland) Model 3, however. Nicola, reviewing the Model 3, called it a "robot."

[@MrStian78]

@@benjaminsmith2287they didn’t try to fast charge it then.

[@CNSPACE2030]

Just like many British still likes to buy Range Rover.Although it is no longer a British thing😅

[@DougHolmes]

So, about the name... If Tesla had released the Tesla Seal, people would be ooh-ing and ahh-ing about how clever it is. Anyone does it - it's a silly name, pick a random set of letters and numbers next time. About the price, how much would a Model 3 be if specced up to be as similar as possible (lets say you choose a paint colour other than white)

[@presterjohn71]

Literally no one would be doing that.

[@DougHolmes]

​@@presterjohn71They added farts and people went nuts. Of course they'd think that Seal was a great name - if Elon did it.

[@LittleBoobsLover]

yeah that name issue of this youtuber was... weird. It s simply name. Maybe for english people might be 'meh, but for international customers is ok. To be honest ABCD class or id3/4 -mg4, Tesla X means nothing , feel empty. The idea of giving normal names of animal was interesting, refreshing.

[@kman_34]

If if if

[@sithabelamandlawenkosiwodu6298]

He's just a petty reviewer. Clearly a Tesla fan. How did he explain the Seal's boot release button? Petty much!

[@sayaIbnuFajar]

BYD forgot to give you an umbrella

[@anemeth9281]

It's not a Rolls...

[@ateiviz]

I got one with my car 😂

[@anemeth9281]

Doug is an MG fanboy 😅

[@stephen546]

@@anemeth9281 As if

[@zzZHua]

😂😂😂

[@sa34w]

if Tesla is like apple BYD is like Samsung. it would be in the best interest of automakers to work on their software and battery manufacturing capabilities in-house. BYD is originally a battery maker as their USP is their great battery chemistry and manufacturing.

[@TB-up4xi]

If Tesla is apple BYD is Vivo or Oppo not Samsung.

[@benjaminsmith2287]

Tesla is not Apple. They don't have the quality or style of Apple.

[@EmreIskenderoglu]

Tesla is nothing compared to byd. American propaganda for junk.

[@Micco321]

But, but, but...thanks for review but it felted a little nitpicking...I've been in both this and TM3 highland and for me this feels lot more premium. Tesla has supercharging network, but very many other things is better in seal than in TM3. Anyway, competition is good for customers 👍

[@wolfgangpreier9160]

I see it the other way. BYD feels cheap. I know it is not cheap, costs +/- about the same, but i would only take it into account if they sell white seats, a working Software and App, working heatpump and lower their prices.

[@Micco321]

So I believe you have drove both if you can say BYD feels cheap? White seats, sorry what? Working heatpump? What's wrong with app. I have droved many teslas and software is good, but other softwares can be good too, different but good. It's same with phones that some say IOS is best when others say android. Here's one from me, Seal is way better looking inside and out than TM3!! If you think otherwise, you are wrong.

[@wolfgangpreier9160]

@@Micco321 "but other softwares can be good too" Yes they can. BYD is not one of them. And that is objectoively the case. I could point out every single point where BYD Software is worse than Tesla, Nio, even VW in most parts. The material inside feels cheap. It smells like cheap plastic. Teslas do not smell in any way. IOS or Android is roughly the same. I prefer IOS because it has advantages for my company vs Android - which i have to maintain and install for my customers so i know both well. BYD Software is about as far as Tesla's Software was in 2012. I don't really care for looks, but still Model 3 looks much better without stalks. It's a clean and efficient workspace. Again i do not care for the outside looks. Wifey says she prefers Model 3 - so a Model 3 it is. No i am not wrong. And you are not wrong too. That is my opinion. If you have a different one that is perfectly ok.

[@Micco321]

​@@wolfgangpreier9160 how lucky we are there is a car for everybody 👍 What was problem with heatpump and app?

[@Micco321]

@@Crusde I was only talking about cars, not politics. That topic is endless so I don't comment about it more here. Btw, could you tell me a car brand from Europe without any Chinese parts?

[@Emjackson89]

BYD also gives us the London Bus lol sneaking in everywhere without anyone seeing

[@kanding3369]

It has to sneak in to provide public service. Whos the joke on?

[@savedfaves]

BYD has made buses for decades.

[@pereldh5741]

Geely that is

[@directxxxx71]

​@@pereldh5741 Geely is cab not the bus

[@jamesdawson3123]

Test drove both the Tesla and the Seal and ended up going for the Seal Performance, loving it!!😊

[@مرواریدمشرقزمین]

BYD has proven to be the best EV car out there

[@bradhuf]

What are you even talking about

[@davout5775]

Nope, by no means is it better than TM3

[@valorien1]

China has proven to employ the dumbest bots out there.

[@juliozandamela]

I agree

[@edwardgongsky8540]

Lucid beats this out of the park

[@anemeth9281]

BYD European factory will be built in Szeged, Hungary

[@LittleBoobsLover]

any news are they going to sell cars in Poland?

[@Anderus14]

​​@@LittleBoobsLoverhalf of this year, most likely August

[@ciybersal3499]

It's much better than Tesla you Tesla shareholder

[@juliozandamela]

Yeah! I agree with you

[@Andydwyer99]

Shortcut button on steering wheel to adjust fan speed and temperature.

[@alcoyne3333333333333]

Very nitpicking review 😢😢😢

[@kamstube]

My thoughts exactly especially how the west is running scared that china becoming the top ev producer. Seems like a very biased review

[@1984929]

Hahahaha. Nitpicking is the core of English style review

[@theroadrunner8300]

in Australia we have Dynamic, Premium and Performance versions

[@BT54-40]

Yes, spoke to an elderly gentleman who could not praise his enough, it was the suv style one with the funky interior finishes 👍

[@mattlamb8]

No way a model 3 is better than a seal this guys is nuts

[@hermanstokbrood]

The model 3 is better from which point of view? Looks? Nope. Performance? Nope. Interior? Nope. Price? Well.... not where I live when you don't want a dime a dozen color or wheels. I drove both, the seal design and M3 Highland. I like the driving better in the Seal.

[@alexshepherd]

Yes, Model 3 performance is far ahead of the Seal - top speed of the Model 3 Performance is 162mph, top speed of the Seal (all versions) is 112mph. Charging rate, 250kW vs. 150kW. The Model 3 is a minimalist design with very little clutter, not even steering column stalks on the latest model. The Seal is a lot more ornate, with two screens, quilted seats, various strange features outside like the gills under the doors and the swage line that leads nowhere. When you sit in both of them, you see how much more spacious and comfortable the Model 3 feels. The beauty is more than skin deep. It extends to things like putting in a destination far away and knowing exactly where and for how long to charge, as the car works out elevation, speed, temperature changes so you don’t have to think about any of that. Making things simple is a hallmark of good design

[@thomas20021234]

​@@alexshepherdagreed i just got a model3 highland and i didt think to buy a seal at all

[@hermanstokbrood]

@@alexshepherd So, you are still in the fase of comparing numbers huh? I don't need your over the top post to understand that the BYD Seal is the better car by driving both myself. By the way, there is no Highland performance and I'm not buying an old model especially when the front is ugly as hell.

[@alexshepherd]

@@hermanstokbrood you did ask the question “the Model 3 is better from which point of view?” - and the numbers I offered seemed to make it clear. Feel free to enlighten us on how the driving is better in the Seal. You’re right, there are people that won’t be interested in the numbers

[@hermanstokbrood]

@@alexshepherd I don't have to judge a car by a specsheet. If I drive one I know. I drove Highland RWD and the Seal RWD. The Model 3 is no match for the Seal for me personally. But you still may think so.

[@mascness_gaming]

The price for this (Extended Range Premium ) in Hong Kong is around GBP 34500.

[@PsychedMedia]

33k GBP for the Performance AWD here in Malaysia

[@darrenbodfish4591]

Yeah I'm right in thinking you don't pay inport duty on your cars, also the tax is calculated differently to the mainland? Hence cheaper prices.

[@mascness_gaming]

@@darrenbodfish4591 i think mainland china is even cheaper, i think in HK we still need to pay the import duty coz it is 2 different system, and we also drive on the right in HK (same as UK).

[@Mr_Chow_Man]

If you scrap your old car for new ev I think there are more than 10 thousand gbp discount in hk

[@wolfgangpreier9160]

BYD Seal Excellence AWD 51.280,-- Euros. 434.391 HKD, 43.815 GBP here in Austria

[@Alberto-mq7gw]

Referring to base prices is not very informative. Tesla and BYD offer everything as standard. The others offer most things on higher trim levels and as options. Configure a Polestar 2 or an Ioniq 6 to match the Seal and you'll be paying at least 15K more. They are not direct competitors price wise. Tesla and BYD are in the same bracket, but the rest are far more expensive.

[@petzibar9958]

not sure, but it feels really cold

[@MichealCoin]

I personally don't think this review is fair, although I do agree with his comments on the center screen. I'm not a fan of the Seal, nor of the Tesla Model 3. My work requires me to split my time evenly between the UK and China, and I don't own cars in either place. However, I recently completed an EV tour in China, and I was spoiled for choice. If I ever need to permanently relocate back to the UK, I would struggle with buying an EV here for one reason: the price comparison. Knowing how much they cost in China, I find it hard to justify paying £46,000 for a Seal. For that amount, I'd be considering a Zeekr 009 in China, which is superb. Alternatively, if I wanted to indulge in my childhood dream, I'd be looking at the Xiaomi Su7 for half the price. :)

[@GDM22]

Why is the indicator considered to be on the wrong side, is it just what you are used too. How did the indicator work on the left hand side when you were driving a manual. Having owned manuals with the indicators on both the right and left side I can tell you the right side is better. Rather than just complain about it, tell us what the issue is with the indicator being on that side, I can't see what difference it makes, other than a slight adjustment which would take about a week.

[@sithabelamandlawenkosiwodu6298]

He's just being petty. He refers no stalks at all. Steering wheel nonsense of Model 3.

[@sithabelamandlawenkosiwodu6298]

He's just being petty. He prefers that Model 3 junk steering wheel button.

[@souldester0]

I like how BYD puts the indicator stalk on the right for RHD cars, even in the UK, unlike Japanese cars that have them on the left in RHD just to meet the ISO standards.

[@drxym]

I drove a Seal with a head up display and it was only a test drive so I didn't fiddle around with the settings but I thought the HUD was very bright. Hope there is a way to dim it. I also found having the indicators on the right side of the wheel was very annoying. It's still better than having no indicator stalk at all like the Tesla 3 which is safety nightmare. Driving wise it seemed quite refined but it rolls rather than being 1-pedal. I think the infotainment screen is too big imo and the rotation is just a stupid gimmick. Should just fix it a bit lower in the vertical config and for android auto / carplay, split the screen so aircon and other controls appear below them.

[@GDM22]

In Australia, we also drive on the left hand side and the indicator on the right side of the steering wheel is considered the correct side. This meant when you drove a manual, you could indicate as you were changing gears. The European cars with the indicaor on the left hand side in considered incorrect there, interesting what you get used to and I heard no justification from the journalist as to why the indicator is conisdered to be on the wrong side and what difference does it make other than what he is used too.

[@Mobile_Dom]

the problem with the two versions of the SEal is that whilst most people should just buy the base model, when the top spec model is only 3 grand more, on a lease you're not really going to notice the difference

[@DBGE001]

The top spec Seal is the one to get, you get real soft Napa leather seats and an amazing torque vectoring system that seems to defy the laws of physics (and is a top notch active safety aspect also). The 500 hp is not to shabby also.

[@jeffreywyatt6425]

I saw a review of the Model 3 and the Seal in which the Model 3 was like driving a robot, compared to the Seal.

[@cpandsooz]

Does the LFP in this mean like a Tesla 3/Y LFP RWD you can and are advised to charge to 100% (rather than the usual EV 80%) if so, cool.

[@weizheng7885]

BYD are supplying battery pack to Tesla， so，they r basiclly the same.

[@honesty_-no9he]

@@weizheng7885 BYD only supply the Blade Battery to the German TESLA made entry level MODEL Y. Shanghai made TESLAs sold in UK use CATL LFP.

[@honesty_-no9he]

100% as much as you like.

[@davout5775]

@@honesty_-no9he if you want to kill the battery faster

[@yggdrasil9039]

Wow so expensive in the UK. This car is very popular in Australia, but it's about half the price of the UK price!

[@pallettowngangster9297]

Yep. I’m fully expecting the price to come down significantly over the next 12 months or so.

[@TB-up4xi]

It's not 1/2 the price... the $51k Aus version is not the same base version as the UK - their base is our Premium ($59k). Australia also has no import tariff (UK=10%) a lower GST / VAT (10% Aus v 20% UK) , 1/2 the shipping costs (East coast Aus v Grimsby UK), a direct selling model (dealer model in the UK they need to recoup dealer margins).

[@koolstup]

Asian cars have always been cheaper in Australia as it's closer to ship then!

[@directxxxx71]

​@@koolstupI think it's because of RCEP free trade agreement

[@karycooper1]

In China it’s like 26000usd But because of anti dumping byd has to raise price

[@dafyddthomas7299]

Extremely impressive BYD Autocars have come in a short period of time

[@lammiwinks3775]

Finally a reviewer who actually calls out the annoying features!

[@Joe-ud2hb]

Agree with you totally bout the consumption figure on the screen - far better just to have range up there than lower down in smaller display. It's some car to drive tho & soooo quiet

[@iantelinside]

I think it's nice to have both, but I personally use the consumption figure more in my daily drives. The calculated range is very much an estimate which many folks never get to hit

[@aerox69x]

@@iantelinsideI agree, I rarely look at the range figure when driving, it’s interesting to see but no real use after you’ve had the car a while

[@cokyrobes]

Great video - really perfect summary from my own experiences

[@felixjw4655]

with a MG umbrella. wink wink. LOL

[@ianrobson3713]

Just noticed that as well, do you think it’s deliberate, I certainly do, too much of a coincidence not to be.

[@hansrama3485]

whats MG

[@chujon9]

Well done What Car for an interesting review.

[@Clarioner1]

This car needed to be a hatch... then it would truly have an edge on the Model 3. the BYD Seal U (SUV) is a bit uninspiring and performance is poor. On rear seats, it seems to be at a factor in a lot of EVs - model 3 rear seats offer equally little under-leg support, so not sure taht would be any better.

[@manasssalunkhe]

Bro, if this screen you think is not responsive then what is? name one can whos screen is of this quality? feels like an ipad! i thinks is great!

[@alanrutland4424]

Obviously the Chinese don’t think Tesla is better as BYD sold more ……😊. Perhaps they are really cheap in China though. Was surprised to see the price differential in UK between Tesla and BYD. Suspect Tesla can increase their prices now 😅

[@jamesinglis8021]

Could you please tell me if any electric car makes a noise at slow speeds to warn people of it's approach.I am coming to the end of my motability lease and it seems like I must choose between being green or hating driving in built up area's?

[@juliozandamela]

Yeah! This one has that feature and also you can turn it off

[@ipb1966]

Jeez - are you still doing “better than Model 3”, “Tesla killer” videos?

[@peakproofuk]

What’s wrong with comparing it to its main rival?!

[@brianallan9035]

Did you not watch until the end?

[@BendeVette]

@@peakproofuk Nothing wrong with a comparation. But the comparation is a bit so-so. There are rivals which are better? The i4 and Model 3 are a bit better, faster, etc. It's not objective enough. I like measurable differences, not a kinda opinion.

[@peakproofuk]

@@BendeVetteI get the frustration of “Tesla killer” comments and reviews - car companies need to join Tesla, not kill them - but this objectively doesn’t do that!

[@mikedavies4387]

It's nicer looking than a tesla

[@yggdrasil9039]

Actually a dial would be better, like on the older EVs, the old Leafs and Ioniqs I believe, as that helps conserve energy and moderate your usage. Very helpful if you are running low on battery.

[@HansPeterDoorneweert]

Maintenance? BYD told me to get a service every 20.000 KM to check "all things.."? Is that required to ensure warranty?

[@CThienV]

ventilated seats. does that mean with airconditioned air? or just fan air?

[@Joel-tm3yj]

it means there is air blowing out from the perforated fabric on your seats. It is really nice feature especially during a hot day.. your back wont get sweaty!

[@alisonburgess345]

do the backseats fold forward to fit golf clubs and buggy into?

[@petzibar9958]

yes they do 60/40

[@hyiux]

@4:36 When you are so desperate to find faults in this car that you complain the trunk button is too low and catches dirt.

[@cszuhan]

The overall performance has made it one of the best choices for people in countries with normal tariffs.

[@anemeth9281]

MG umbrella in a BYD test? You are funny Doug... 😂

[@the1onlynoob]

Is the byd as prone to randomly bursting into flames or getting recalled?

[@supernovaHZ]

Bring BYD to the Us to compete with Tesla and force all other cars to cut price! Why not ? good for all the consumers

[@KrishivBhama]

whats the difference between 2 wheel drive and 4 wheel drive please explain that as well

[@javieruriel]

link to buy

[@bremember]

Still costs £40k in the UK, too expensive for working class people like me, I live in a terrace house, how do you charge your car in this situation?

[@dafyddthomas7299]

That is the rub with EV; lack of charging infrastructure, range limitations, time it takes to charge, repair costs - especially if battery develops a fault or needs replacing and also UK's sky high extremely obscene energy bills.

[@1ycan-eu9ji]

blame tariffs, it costs $10k in china

[@gmc1887]

For the kw odometer I didn’t notice it while driving the car

[@bananarepublic8951]

It is sour grapes for all these people, because it is Chinese high-tech. They are very happy with TESLA cheap build, panel gaps, cost cutting buttonless low resolution screen, no android auto, no Lidar take these guys reviews with a bucket of salt

[@StevenCavill-s9f]

For the European market they are both made in China and apparently Tesla now use BYD battery packs, basically ALL cars will soon be Chinese imports within a few years.

[@anomad6314]

pretty sure it's made in Hungary

[@GM-lq7sw]

Not sure if your review is impartial since there is no car out there with more plastic than the Tesla

[@goodboyjojo]

If you can buy this car at the price of 18K from China, then all comparisons will be a joke at such a low price. In addition, I really don’t understand why. The American brand Tesla is much more expensive in North America than in China. Model 3 only costs 30k USD in China.

[@definitelyno601]

it starting from 20,000 us dollars in China. Why is it so expensive elsewhere? tarriff is over 100%? this is insane

[@asgan28]

What other battery that don't catch FIRE IN ACCIDENTS? LFP is the best so far that is most important 😊

[@siddesh2104]

Price in UK?

[@Helloitskovo]

Does this car make the "Bluetooth connected" sound when you start it?

[@jdee4763]

i can't find the POD POINT link he talks about??

[@neilwhit1]

No physical controls, no interest

[@Chris-oz9qx]

£33,7000 (according to current exchange rate) here in Thailand for the AWD version

[@Damo699]

Negative review? Haven't watched it yet but this is a regular electric vehicle review from these guys

[@bahamter]

So, in the UK, standard BYD Seal's price is higher than Model 3. Interesting. In China, Model 3 is 10000 US dollar higher than Seal.

[@princeberno]

Now that's something I find quite interesting when comparing the Seal with a Model 3, in Brazil the Seal is the cheaper choice and by a long shot, here the seal is around R$ 300.000 while the model 3 goes for R$470.000, and just to make sure R$170.000 is enough to get you a really good car by itself. A difference in market objectives definitely, but just interesting to note.

[@pankajt1986]

Does it comes with MG umbrella 😅

[@Kurdisheboy2009]

How many miles an hour you can drive?

[@FrunkensteinVonZipperneck]

5:35) Seal does NOT have a “front boot.” It has a Frunkin’ FRUNK!❤

[@ianmusy8603]

Didn't the 190 merc have that as well

[@masonkanterbury3007]

Bring it here!!!!! Love from Colorado.

[@anomad6314]

BYD buses are sold in the US... not their cars.... not sure why

[@godblessusa2724]

Self-ignite feature as shown on videos? No thanks

[@Youtubestar14]

Looking at the range on your phone is not a downfall is it ? If you’re sat in the car waiting for it to charge, the chances are you’ll be on your phone anyways

[@leemace9638]

Probably not but it’s better looking

[@virgin1958]

Indicators are correct for Nz and Australia Get used to as we do with euro models

[@_nosikeuzoma1456]

What model do you own ?

[@StevenCavill-s9f]

LFPs are a far safer chemistry than a lot of the other types, way less chance of battery damage causing a fire. Coupled with the fact they don’t suffer from being left at 100% state of charge this far outweighs the lower energy density .

[@lukewormholes5388]

never thought about it before but the worst part about driving on that side of the car for most people must be that you have to use your left hand to manipulate the touch screen / controls

[@sithabelamandlawenkosiwodu6298]

No issues there. Left handed people have to deal with a lot of stuff designed for right hand use too. Nobody complains.

[@johnmull59]

I'd hazard a guess that most drivers who get cars with 'tons' of equipment don't use it.... Let's hope the new Renault 5, which looks about the coolest EV so far is a sensible price with fewer unnecessary gimmicks.

[@chriss4949]

Shame about the clickbait title…but a fair review

[@sullivanrachael]

So we have a car that has fantastic acceleration, mildly communicative steering, comfortable ride on battered UK roads, a big touchscreen, massive depreciation, and quite a high up front cost. But one if you like it, but I’ll keep my existing car, it’s entertaining to drive and doesn’t annoy me.

[@Joel-tm3yj]

I have sat in the BYD Seal's rear seats, and they are by far the best I have sat in at this price point. Seats are body hugging and its more reclined compared to its rivals, not to mention the legroom! Also I have driven it, and its throttle response is immense to say the least. I dont think he is giving a very honest review, very biased towards giving Tesla the crown as the "ultimate EV brand"

[@teentechnology9855]

Recently test drove a model 3 and a byd seal. The back seats of the seal are lovely, not problematic as the reviewer says, and the suspension was so much nicer than the tesla, which I found crashy and fidgety.

[@crazygambler920]

Looks like Tesla wins with interior tech and Charging…. but the interior and cabin - BYD has them beat by a mile.

[@onceafiend]

Isn't the AWD version less expensive than the equivalent Tesla? Didnt mention that

[@davidbullen1966]

I rented a Tesla, a BYD and a Polestar for a variety of road trips. As per this review (10:12 to 10:38), the BYD ride is not good, and on a long trip it made us all feel a bit unwell.

[@alexroc172]

UK price is literally TWICE the price in Australia ! We get ripped off in the UK

[@1234540270]

I'm interested to know how well they'll do after 3-5 years

[@cklam8722]

Quite a good review with useful information on this particular EV.

[@juliozandamela]

He lied, BYD is way better than TM3 and cheaper

[@camilstoenescu]

Tesla Model 3 killer? Or not really.

[@honesty_-no9he]

Seal is a much nicer car. All this guy does is moan and BS.

[@kbz3140]

The car has been reduced from $30,000 to $22,000 in China, which is a very competitive market, and Tesla is getting ready to reduce the price, how much does it sell for in your country? There's also news coming from the battery supply chain already, the mineral resources related to batteries have been drastically reduced in price, and a 100 degree battery will be reduced to $5,500 as well

[@user-ts8xr9fp6c]

Britain hasn't even bulit it's first EV, so it seems a bit rich for a Brit to talk negatively about an EV, just because it's not a Tesla! Get building your first EV, Lad, then we can talk!

[@Crawfish411-Vlog]

Luxury inside. V2L charging. So much more. So much bang for your buck.

[@fatphoca5009]

What is "jewel" zone air-conditioning?

[@peakproofuk]

It’s how most us brits pronounce ‘dual’ - but I think you knew that.

[@Jose-ue3bu]

Why is this even a question? BYD is the number one right now and the leader in the EV industry with the most advanced tech there is.

[@Techning]

I like the looks but that's where it ends for me. I would buy a Model 3 instead because I trust their software (& updates) more and it's more refined. I think the Seal needs a facelift first to catch up. Repairability is also a highly questionable point as other videos have shown.

[@tiborurban7615]

bullshit :D

[@Ksivakaran]

Comparing with according to my knowledge, this is gonna be the best car in the future they’re using plate battery❤❤❤❤

[@helipeek2736]

Is the umbrella logo a bit of an on the nose dig at BYD?