New! 🍁Too Faced Pumpkin Spice palette: Review/Swatches

Hey, it’s Mo!☘️ I was pretty jazzed about this new Too Faced Pumpkin Spice palette. I've been using it for about a week and given it a good ‘go’ so I can do this comprehensive review with swatches and such for you. As always, I hope this is helpful. Enjoy!💕
☀️Filmed in natural light. Always.☀️
📸 Daily makeup and other fun-nery on Instagram:
motildamulgrew
✨ no pr/no sponsorships/no affiliate links/no kidding!✨
Today's Makeup:
Foundation: Colourpop Pretty Fresh Hydrating Foundation 55N
Concealer: Colourpop Pretty Fresh Concealer Light 40N
Eyes: Too Faced Pumpkin Spice Palette ('A La Mode' transition/crease, 'You Spicy' inner and outer third of lid, 'Oh My Gourd' center of lid, 'Whipped Cream' brow bone)
Cheeks: Colourpop Gumdrop Pass
Lips: Hourglass Unreal Lipgloss in Canvas
Nails: Essie polish in You Do Blue

[@RoyalDiadem62]

Natural lighting is the way to go 🙌🏼

[@helpfulnhappy]

I actually love my scented powder products! To me, it adds to the experience.

[@motildamulgrew]

That’s cool, helpfulnhappy-I’m glad you like that experience. Always glad to have you here.

[@HMMMakeup]

Same here.

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m really glad you enjoy the scents, HHM-I certainly enjoy this one!

[@poetrychick1275]

Hi Mo! Thank you SO much for the review! I just never could bring myself to purchase the Gingerbread Spicy and Extra Spicy palettes. The Pumpkin Spice palette is just what I like! I'm going to purchase it from Ulta. I love your videos and reviews so much! They always make my day. 🙂

[@motildamulgrew]

As always, poetrychick, you are so very welcome for the review. If I helped you decide the Pumpkin Spice palette was ‘for you’ then I feel very helpful, indeed. I hope you absolutely love it! You are very kind, and I consider you compliment to be high praise.

[@KarenLawana]

Hi Mo! I've enjoyed seeing all the looks from this palette that you've shared on Instagram, so I was looking forward to seeing this review. This palette does have a beautiful color story, with some nice surprises. It seems almost like a "best of" Too Faced palette, with its mix of super warm and neutral shades. Very pretty. I hope you're having a wonderful weekend. ❤️

[@motildamulgrew]

Hi Karen! I’m so glad you enjoyed he looks-I tried to keep them different and interesting each day. Yeah, exactly-kind of like a ‘best of’. Thank you very much-I hope you’re having a wonderful weekend, too.

[@nitasa6346]

You are so beautiful! like HUMAN beautiful not plastic and fake. enjoyed your review, thanks. I will definitely susbscribe.

[@motildamulgrew]

Thank you for the kind compliment, Nita. I’m very glad you enjoyed the review and I’m happy to have you here.

[@zoek3420]

really helpful review thank you!

[@katjones4840]

I bet the super limited edition means they made less of them. The other two ended up at tj max. I’m sure they just made less of these to avoid that. :)

[@motildamulgrew]

That’s a good point, Kat! I do think this ‘theme’ has a bit more longevity than ‘Gingerbread’, but you may be right about that.

[@andreac5724]

Girl!!! I was waiting to see a review of this palette!!!!

[@motildamulgrew]

I hope it was helpful, Andrea! Always glad to ‘see’ you here.

[@kathie_nj]

Another fabulous video! Thanks so much for the swatches. I was on the fence but since you mentioned it has a lot of mattes that sold me. I used to be an all shimmer all the time gal but I am liking mattes now. Don't get me wrong I will always lover shimmers but everyone's taste evolves. Just like I am jonesing for a nice olive shadow! I have a god majority of TF palettes including the Natural Matte and Natural eyes but while they are great neutrals they just don't do it for me. I like the Christie Brinkley Authentic Beauty 5 pan palette in rosey colors (really neutral shades). But this Pumpkin palette feeds my love of PSL and I love the array of colors!! Thanks for the review!!!

[@motildamulgrew]

Hi Kathie! You are very welcome for the swatches. It’s interesting that the ‘mattes’ sold you on this one, but I agree that tastes change. Mine certainly have-sometimes the even change ‘back’ again. 🙂

[@lindamihalic9897]

Too Face has never interested me as a brans, so I don’t have any of the other tin palettes. This one has a tempting color story, I gotta say. 🤔 “I hope you are at peace today” is a lovely outro. Very glad I stumbled across your channel. 💕

[@motildamulgrew]

If you like the color story, Linda, I tend to think you’d enjoy the palette-the formula is quite good. Oh, thank you for that thoughtful compliment. I’m very glad to be stumbled upon.🙂

[@zoek3420]

really helpful review thank you! can’t wait to pick up this palette

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m so glad to be helpful, Zoe-thank you for letting me know that. Let me know if you get it!

[@cgretam1594]

I’d so glad someone who’s not a huge youtuber is reviewing this because I’ve been wanting a fall/neutral palette and I’d always wanted to try too faced eyeshadow

[@abigailsmith2856]

Really enjoyed this review. Thank you!!

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m so glad, Abigail. You are very welcome!

[@biankita8245]

You made me want this palette so bad, I'm ordering right now =D . Great review!

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m so glad the review was helpful, Biankita-and I really hope the palette brings you joy!

[@ReginaCordoba]

New subscriber! I have been wanting that palette!

[@motildamulgrew]

Hi Regina! I’m very happy to have you here-did you get the palette?

[@ReginaCordoba]

@@motildamulgrew I got 2. I have a video on my channel!

[@ReginaCordoba]

@@motildamulgrew I hope you will subscribe to my channel!

[@dianereiser6417]

Oh my gosh, you got a Too Faced palette, lol..I haven’t bought anything from that brand in a couple of years. It’s nice to see you having fun with it though.

[@motildamulgrew]

It has been fun to play with this one, Diane. Thank you!

[@RoyalDiadem62]

Your review is very thorough I really appreciate it 👍🏻❤️

[@motildamulgrew]

Oh, you’re so welcome, Royal Diadem.

[@coriculp]

This is the first I’ve seen this palette. Thanks for sharing!! 🥰

[@motildamulgrew]

You’re so welcome, Cori.

[@poshbarbie24]

Im not sure how they could've made it fit, but having the palette look like a triangular slice of pie could've been super cute! Ive ordered it but it hasnt shipped yet. 😞

[@motildamulgrew]

I hadn’t even thought of that, poshbarbie, but I really like that idea! I hope yours gets to you very soon so you can start enjoying it!

[@BlessedLifeLoveandFaith]

I believe I'll buy this palette when I save money for it. It's such a good palette, give all the colors that's included. (: Thank you so much for the information and quite sorry you were missing the lip product. That is one of my favorites. God bless and have a great weekend! 💛

[@motildamulgrew]

You’re so welcome! It was a bit frustrating, it’s true, but I’m certainly glad the palette arrived safely. You have a great weekend, too!

[@savanah1407]

I can’t believe HSN did that! Ohmygoodness the Gingerbread palettes DO smell like play doh! I never heard anyone else say that but that’s exactly what I thought! And it’s weird because I like the chocolate bar scent. 🤷‍♀️ Thank you so much for the thorough review! I wish the shimmer green swatched greener. I feel like it swatches darker than it appears in the pan, just like the green in their chocolate gold bar does. I ordered mine yesterday, can’t wait to play with the foiled shimmers. I think I’ll either hate or love them. If I hadn’t already bought it, your live swatches would’ve sold me! The purple and pink looks are soo Soo gorgeous on you!

[@motildamulgrew]

It was frustrating, I won’t deny that, Savanah, but I’m hopeful things went more smoothly for other people. Yep-I get Play Doh every time, too. You’re very welcome for the review. I have a hunch the foils will be a ‘love it or hate it’ formula. I’ll be very curious to see what you think.

[@savanah1407]

motilda mulgrew You’re so sweet for saying that! I’ll make sure to report back here! I’m also planning to share my thoughts on IG. Do you have an IG account? I’d love to follow you there too.

[@savanah1407]

motilda mulgrew I know you just bought this palette but are you interested in the new Natasha Denona Glam palette? I’d love to see a review from you but I know it’s not going to be for everyone, no pressure!

[@AngelandDevil]

great review

[@motildamulgrew]

Thank you!

[@AngelandDevil]

@@motildamulgrew it would mean a lot if you checked out my channel no pressure though

[@clairethompson4736]

Hi, Mo! I wasn't going to buy this palette (only because I've purchased too many other new eyeshadow releases) but now... I'm having second thoughts. It really is a pretty color story. I have my eye on the Urban Decay Stoned Vibes palette, too. The only thing better than combining makeup with food is pairing it up with gemstones. Take my money! LOL! Thanks for the review.

[@motildamulgrew]

Hi Claire! It is a pretty color story and I’ve really enjoyed it. Do you have either/both of the gingerbread palettes? I was looking at the Urban Decay palette yesterday-I haven’t decided about that one yet. Your food/gemstones comment made me laugh! As always, you are most welcome.

[@clairethompson4736]

@@motildamulgrew Every year I am drawn to them but, I haven't purchased one. This may be the year. They're so festive and I'm one of those "Pumpkin Spice - Everything" kind of people.

[@motildamulgrew]

I’ve enjoyed all of them, but I think this is my favorite. If you decide to get it, do let me know what you think.

[@clairethompson4736]

@@motildamulgrew Will do.

[@julieg_quebec-julesselivre8641]

I need this! Your swatches are amazing!

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m so glad this was helpful, Julie!

[@abigaeld]

Do you have the previous years’ pumpkin spice palettes that were exclusive to HSN? I’m curious to see how this one is compared to those pumpkin spice palettes.

[@motildamulgrew]

I don’t have those, Abi. I wish I did so I could compare them for you!

[@abigaeld]

motilda mulgrew OMG I could have sworn I found you through one of those reviews! LOL thank you for reviewing this one!

[@motildamulgrew]

I reviewed a lot of holiday sets last year-maybe that’s how you found me. 🙂

[@katjones4840]

I just got mine! I am in love with the color story.

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m so glad, Kat.

[@witchywandaweasley6428]

love your video. you are naturally beautiful as well

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m so glad you enjoyed it, Geeky Guru. Thank you for the compliment!

[@justagirl871]

Ordered this for $25. So excited

[@motildamulgrew]

It's a great palette. Justa Girl--and how great that you're getting you got it for $25! I hope you love it.

[@syvannahlopez804]

Just subscribed today 👍

[@motildamulgrew]

I’m glad to have you here, Syvannah. Thank you.

[@RoyalDiadem62]

I’m so sorry that happened to you with hsn that makes me so mad 😡 they totally screwed up that’s terrible customer service 😡 thank you for sharing your experience though because I know I won’t be giving hsn my business ever again I’ll purchase it from ulta or Sephora . Xoxox ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@motildamulgrew]

As I said-hopefully just an anomaly with customer service. I’m sure other people have had much better experiences than I.

[@irmabeadles3739]

Hi Mo! 👋 Such a bad customer experience 😡 like wtf! The answers they gave you are...🤬 I love this color story because it’s not so warm and I don’t have the other ginger palettes. I was waiting for your review, love the looks on your IG stories. Thanks you! I think I’m getting it because it has variety! 😃 happy weekend 🌻 good vibes

[@motildamulgrew]

Hi Irma! As I said, it was unfortunate, but hopefully just as anomaly. I’m glad you like the IG looks, I enjoyed creating them. You’re very welcome, as always! Happy weekend to you, too!!

[@MelissaKY]

I bought this palette today and am excited to begin playing with it. I’m so glad to have found your video! You are so informative, detailed, LOVED your swatches and how it isn’t rushed through. The lighting is fantastic. You are well versed & I appreciate that you don’t repeat same old catch phrases. In other words, thank you and I am happy to subscribe and look forward to more of your videos. :-)

[@motildamulgrew]

Melissa-thank you so much for this very kind comment. I saw it on a busy morning and didn’t want to rush a response to you. I am very glad to be found. I specifically appreciate your mention of swatches-while I was filming this I was actually wondering if I was lingering on swatches too long, so it’s really good to hear that my ‘method’ is useful to you. I’m very glad to have you here, and I hope my upcoming videos live up to these lovely compliments.

[@CrankyKat4106]

Thanks for this thorough review! I wish Fall Vibes was a little greener, but I love the purples and those warm-toned neutrals! That’s a shame you had a negative experience with HSN. I felt incredibly frustrated just listening to your story; I can’t imagine how exasperated you felt. I hope you’re having a great weekend!

[@motildamulgrew]

You’re very welcome, KatieBeth. I always love purpled, so I had a hunch this palette would be a winner for me. It was a bit exasperating, yes. I’m having a very nice weekend, thank you. I hope the same for you!

[@lipbalmqueen]

Great video

[@motildamulgrew]

Thank you.

[@suzannebracker8219]

Nice eye look!

[@motildamulgrew]

Thanks very much, Suzanne.

[@staceyclark5020]

Thank you for the review! Mine came in yesterday and I can't wait to play with it. I love the color story!❤

[@motildamulgrew]

Hi Stacey-you’re very welcome. It’s been quite fun to play with, I hope you really enjoy it!

[@catherinekasiewicz8683]

Great review! I have a ton of points at Ulta and I think I’ll be using them on this palette. 💕💕

[@motildamulgrew]

Oh, thank you, Catherine. Oooh-points! That makes the palette even more appealing!

[@MinaLobo]

Thanks so much for your review and swatches! The "foiled" shades you mention--I wonder if their formula is similar to Too Faced's Tutti Frutti Razzle Dazzle Berry palette. There are a few shadow pans in it with these gorgeous shimmery shades that are curiously creamy, and when you put your finger in to pick up color it's almost like you put a dent in the shadow.

[@motildamulgrew]

You’re very welcome, Mina. I don’t have any of the Tutti Fruitti line so maybe it is the same formula--that’s interesting. Thank you for mentioning it.

[@savanah1407]

I hope it’s not like the Tutti Frutti, I didn’t like how the shadow caved in like that! It was weird. lol

[@RoyalDiadem62]

Yes live swatches are so necessary thank you !!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@motildamulgrew]

You’re very welcome!

[@KayLilia]

Been waiting for this video

[@KayLilia]

Great video TFS

[@motildamulgrew]

I hope it was helpful, Kay!

[@KayLilia]

Can you give me more of a description on the scent?

[@motildamulgrew]

It’s sweet, not overly ‘sugary’, though. There a bit of cinnamon, too. Perhaps like a subtle ‘pumpkin pie’ candle. Does that help, Kay?

[@KayLilia]

Thank you so much for responding I just don’t want it to smell like buttered rum palette thank you