kuro knows geshulin is one of them most antecipaded characters and i dont think they waste the character to be scar dont get me wrong i love both characters but discard geshulin to be playable is bad i hope this theroy turns out to be not true
@BoredDior4 ай бұрын
could still get both even if they are the same person somehow
@joaomarcoscosta46474 ай бұрын
@@BoredDior Yeah, character alts are not unheard of. That said, I've never heard of using different voice actors for the same character, in the same language, for the same game. (Unless there is a significant age gap, or the original VA is no longer a part of the team, or something like that.)
@jester19244 ай бұрын
Camu and Kamui in PGR are technically lore wise the same person, but at different instances in time. And both of them are playable. Then you look at Honkai 3rd and that doesn’t need an explanation. Point is, they can be the same person and still both be playable
@pinkpeonies3236Ай бұрын
2 different VA's. Scar on lip isn't on the character scar. Their tacet discord marks are in slightly different places and they look differently. (The peaks at the end of the mark are different.) They aren't the same. If they were I'd be shocked.
@Rielle52894 ай бұрын
Firstly tacet marks aren’t different for everyone and around the time geshu Lin was the general scar already existed, and there is no way Kuro would just throw away geshu Lin like that and make them into one cause kuro gotta get that bag 💰 Yk?
@zenoafro4 ай бұрын
I mean pretty much every playable characters have different echo marks whether it's the location or the size(and if you look at both Scar and Geshu, they are almost identical in location and size).How did you know Scar existed back then because all information about Geshu Lin was from the past when Jiyan was just a normal soldier and there was no info regarding Scar in that preview too. And second they can still release multiple version of same characters like in PGR and other hoyoverse games(they don't have to go with the Genshin route with One character gets one version of them in game). Although it's the most absurd theory but somehow makes sense(at least to me😂😂)
@alan_naive13224 ай бұрын
From what source can you say that Scar already existed?? Or as Geshu Lin? 💀💀
@Sandbeard4 ай бұрын
@@alan_naive1322scar already existed because scar was talking in the village with the girl while geshu lin was general lol
@anyaforgors4 ай бұрын
Their tacet mark are not even placed the same...Whoever thought of this bs is delusional. They don't even have an ounce of similarity in their personalites
@Sapphie.Cannon3 ай бұрын
@anyaforgors it's called going crazy my dude
@dedsec_blaqmaru65414 ай бұрын
Tbh this would be a massive L if this is true.
@scarletHerbst4 ай бұрын
I don't think Geshulin is Scar because their eye shapes look different. Even though they both have tacet marks on their necks, if you look closer the marks are different. Geshu has more star diamond shapes while Scar's are thicker and have more waves If tacets marks cannot be on the same place on different resonators than either Scar is either a shadow or mirror of Geshulin but definitely not him
@yayu4144 ай бұрын
I was about to agree but the last part is contradicting to each other, the mindset of Geshulin and Scar is completely different. Like by far. - Geshulin wants to stop the lament no matter what it cost either [losing midnight ranger] or [losing friends, foes and family] no matter what happen, his desire to get rid the Tacet Discord, Threnodian, Overthrax is immaculately insane, his objective and goal to defeat the enemy is giving me Kawaki vibe, only the mindset but not the characteristics because Kawaki is a bit selfish and fraud while Geshulin is not, but interms of Objectives, Goals and Plan, both of them is so eager to fulfill the goal no matter what. - (On the other hand) Scar mindset is different, Scar used to be the Black Lamb in the story but along the line, he became the Sheppard. He doesn’t want to stop the Lament, he is the one who causing it, Phrolova has an ability to summon Tacet Discord and also she is the cause of reviving the Threnodian which is the dreamless, you can see her showing up before the Threnodian and Overthrax got revived and you can also see her in the background when Rover and Jiyan finally defeated the Dreamless. Now i think about it, i think Scar is more like Madara to me because Madara and Scar do care about other people before, but due to evil of this world, they become one, Madara and Scar wants to use the power of enemy and changes the shape of the world into their selfish desire, to a world that they called “Paradise” but in their own way. So what im trying to say is Geshulin and Scar may have a similarity before because both of them want to stop the Lament (if Scar used to be member of blackshore) but Scar changes his desire and become the enemy he disguise himself to lure other sheep into his trap, manipulating them so he will receive a praise that look like he is the Savior but he’s not and then fall into the darkside while Geshulin (even his fanthom) is the one who courage Jiyan to push his limit as a Commander General to stop the Threnodian (this is the reason why you shouldn’t skip dialogue) Geshulin even stated that “Are you gonna stay here waiting for Retroact Rain to stop just because of some panthom?” Indicating that he is pushing Jiyan to be brave and act like a Real General and set a side the emotions and feeling for the death of fallen soldier. So Geshulin desire is to stop the Lament while Scar and Phrolova keep reviving the Threnodian, Overthrax and take advantage of the Lament to push their agenda.
@danielw.24564 ай бұрын
Good summary. One area i'd say differently is your comparisons. Geshulin is more like Kawaki over Boruto. Bc Kawaki is so obsessed with killing the Ootsuki that he is willing to toss away every bond he has to acheive that goal. He is even crazy enough to off himself in the end bc he is also technically part Ootsuki. In that, it is similar to Geshulin's hate towards TD's. Bc Geshulin is also willing to sacrifice anything in order to kill them all. Both are consumed & blinded by their hate. Scar is probably closer to Code. In the way Code worships the Ootsuki & wants them to reign supreme, Scar also wants to create a world where the Lament happens & TD's are on top. The similarities stop there though as Code is more like a serious & religious zealot & Scar is more like a crazy & happy lover of chaos.
@yayu4144 ай бұрын
@@danielw.2456 Oh yeah, that’s one way to go too, i only input Boruto characteristics to Geshulin because he is hatred by friend and sees him as a villain while Boruto is so focused to his objective but yea, that’s also correct too, i forgot that. Yea he is more like Kawaki because of how driven his goal to get rid the enemy and he will not waver eventho it’ll cost the life of his friend and family. Also Scar i think more like Madara coz both of them want to change the world into their own selfish desire, anyway thanks for correction i might edit my comment so it’ll not create confusion.
@danielw.24564 ай бұрын
@@yayu414 Anytime! & i can see the Scar & Madara comparison too. Good point.
@Memsandro4 ай бұрын
@@danielw.2456 I think its pretty apparent that Scar and rest of the Fracsidus don't want "TDs on top", they want to live together with them, to the point where the Lament just becomes part of life. And to do that you pretty much have to overthrow all authority and implant TD tissue into all living humans, since those who survive the procedure, like the Fracsidus members - are no longer attacked by TDs, they're recognized as their own by the TDs. It's all about joining together with someone you can't beat and learning to live with them. TDs aren't "evil" per se, they just instinctively seek to merge with anyone whose frequencies aren't discordant like theirs.
@jaerys88234 ай бұрын
Please no, Geshulin is this badass Swordsman general who is honed in combat, commanded an army and is charismatic. Then theres scar, probably a drug abused junkie who talks like a mental patient, fist fights and throws damn cards like he on sun crack
@bluerie4 ай бұрын
Tacet mark placement is not unique to a person Also doesn’t look like mechanical arm Their faces look different from each other
@hrishavdas69994 ай бұрын
geshulin has a small cut mark on his lips, which scar dont have. A new cut can appear But the old cut wont disappear . I doubt they are same person, maybe they are brothers and after lin vanished scar decided to go down a different path.
@JayceRustia4 ай бұрын
I feel attacked with this one Since im saving for scar and gasoline
@lucario67274 ай бұрын
Now you get a two at the cost of one bundle. What a bargain!!
@s0lar1a_ir1z44 ай бұрын
GASOLINE???? 😭
@Morax0244 ай бұрын
come to think of it, they do look alike.. holy crap... anyways, imma pulling for Geshu lin no matter what xD
@zeeshanhussain68914 ай бұрын
I want geshu lin🔥
@AzA6094 ай бұрын
He can Geshu my Lin... 👁👄👁
@zeeshanhussain68914 ай бұрын
@@AzA609 Dude seriously what are u?😅
@AzA6094 ай бұрын
@@zeeshanhussain6891 I am him. 😎
@zeeshanhussain68914 ай бұрын
@@AzA609 ooo I thought u are something else sorry for that
@WayneZvidza-qh2dp4 ай бұрын
Your points are valid but i would prefer to play them separately
@BlackXief4 ай бұрын
This theory has so many holes it's almost funny 😂
@Heshu-i2t4 ай бұрын
that person got no content to do that day 😂
@ambearyyeet4 ай бұрын
Can u name some, im literally unable to think of any holes in this theory, Im interested 👀👀
@Heshu-i2t4 ай бұрын
@ambearyyeet Geshu is literally based on an existing character. same thing with Scar. Plus, tacet mark have limited placement design wise. Both Jiyan and Jinshi had theirs on their back. it doesn't mean they're the same person for that yk
@ambearyyeet4 ай бұрын
@@Heshu-i2t yes, jiyan and Jinhsi have it on the same place, but they have different shapes still. Jiyan's covers almost all of his back, meanwhile Jinhsi's is smaller, like most of the other characters. Jiyan's is a different shape. Scar and Geshu Lin have the exact same tacet mark, no differences in size or placement. So I kinda fail to see your point :/
@Heshu-i2t4 ай бұрын
@@ambearyyeet girl if you're gonna strike back then try harder
@aayush32674 ай бұрын
What if scar/geshulin are multi element able to switch havoc and fusion? That would be a must have character.
@oygir14674 ай бұрын
About the tacet mark they can share jinshi & jiyan both of their marks are on their back, not to mention that scar uses cards and we saw that while genshu uses claymore and we saw that in jiyans trailer
@casmartle4 ай бұрын
Wait, I don't think Scar's arm is mechanical? Where was it told or clearly shown? Upd. I mean it looks simply as his costume and he wears gloves so can't tell if it's really mechanical. I suppose it's just costume design
@DisappointedJynxzi4 ай бұрын
I feel like this dude gonna be released at version 2.0 and I hope his Resonance Skill/Liberation is "Voice" related
@Hindalzarooni20193 ай бұрын
O. M. G. My two favourite characters... are actually THE SAME CHARACTER!? 🤯 Goddammit! Now I wish I could do the black lamb story again!! 😫 I am not about to make a WHOLE NEW ACCOUNT, just to do a quest... yet..
@Aeroph4 ай бұрын
Ain't no way I've been loving the 2 same ppl in the same game
@nightstar4754 ай бұрын
Not this theory again 😂 Chronologically it doesnt make sense, not only that both characters are anticipated, Kuro is not going to waste them like that 😅
@TerreneitorPlusUltra4 ай бұрын
weakest idea ever ... the voice is already proving them to be different people and more importantly Sanhua *who see's people's resonance* saw Scar and didn't recognized Geshu Lin tell that redditor to never cook again please!
@amaria70723 ай бұрын
Geshu Lin has yellow/golden eyes, not grayish. But also Scar is seen to be more interested in a character’s thoughts than Geshu lin is
@mwx53144 ай бұрын
Scar is Geshulin.. but release them as DIFFERENT characters with diff elements.. Scar as Fire, Geshulin as Havoc.. both 5 stars!!!
@reaseypinnorak44834 ай бұрын
Noticed this for a long time now. And finally some talks about it
@Vaincia4 ай бұрын
Idk why but Cronwless could also be a character/human. Scar's iddle animation or when he "holds" his head crownless do the same could he be idk... ? geshulin? Crownless uses a spear and a "claymore", like jiyan does so idk... im just yapping maybe xD
@kikionichou9214 ай бұрын
I like the theory! it was also nice to hear someone elses veiw of some of the overal lore in the game.. sense im still not too familer with it
@Baoban_Sith4 ай бұрын
That's it you're my favorite Wuthering waves leaker
@jessikaparker59634 ай бұрын
thank you for talking about it. i started wondering about them being the same person ever since i saw them th first time. i don't know if this makes sense, but in my mind it does
@bariajaynish69434 ай бұрын
I was going to skip their weapons but if this goes according to the leaks then I don't have to worry about pulling them both.
@ICantTakeAJoke4 ай бұрын
geshu lin has a scar on his mouth while scar doesnt. Maybe the plot twist is that they are twins, but it is almost impossible that they are the same person
@winkythepooh4 ай бұрын
still prefer Scar over Geshu. although this theory is quite interesting. let's wait and see what Kuro is planning for the future. meanwhile, Camellya might be released earlier than Scar so i'll pull her for now. :3
@Im_yourko4 ай бұрын
To me I think this theory is false since they look totally different and isn't geshulin dead? Also if scar and geshulin were the same person then kuro would lose lots of money since geshulin is a very anticipated character
@Morax0244 ай бұрын
bruh the story never said he died, just missing
@alan_naive13224 ай бұрын
@@Morax024 fr the skip button is showing
@flow2flow3204 ай бұрын
Very good théorie ! I think this sirinswish guy is the one who deserve your lunites give away !!!
@infj-tguy62752 ай бұрын
If geshu lin isn't gonna be a playable character then i'm uninstalling this game, he's the only character i'm willing to drop money on just to get him to max along with his sword Kuro will lose tons of players if they make that massive mistake, count on it
@edwardphantom8854 ай бұрын
SO was I the only one who immediately thought that those 2 were the same person? I mean the white hair and the statement of being wronged or betrayed, as well as both being a little nuts, one more than the other. To be fair 2 characters being similar yet being totally different people does happen, so honestly Koru can decide to go either way, depending on what story they want to tell, or just simply from the fact that I know most people will want to get both in the game
@mohammadtaqi94873 ай бұрын
I am waiting patiently for them both cuz I like them both but Nah , I don't want this to be true I want them seperately but if I get to choose just one it will definitely be the fallen general
@velWW4 ай бұрын
if geshu is scar then, it make sense why scar entered jinzhou city 2 times no sweat😅
@neanahidden4 ай бұрын
Two must pulls in one? Humans have only so many places where you can have a tacet mark. So two out of maybe millions is not that groundbreaking 😅 And since Scar and Geshu Lin are both very very awaited and would potentially make a lot of people pull for both banners… = profits… it’s very unlikely Kuro would pull a Firefly and delete one whole character by making it just an mecha outfit. Or in this case an earlier version.
@Itcangetbetteronestepatatime4 ай бұрын
If scar is geshu im rolling for scar
@alan_naive13224 ай бұрын
love this theory. I'd like to see how Scar came into being.
@Sapphie.Cannon3 ай бұрын
I dont think people get what youre saying. Scar is geshu lin after he went and did the thing. Making Jiyan general just before. We might get a version of geshu lin if we can "unscarify" him somehow. These arguments really cant be ignored. There are similarities. They could be brothers. (The arm not counting In this theory.) Im inclined to believe this theory. But also id really like both
@darkknight47144 ай бұрын
I like the theory very much but i want them both not one
@owl1904 ай бұрын
That theory came up in my mind a few days ago. But I‘m not sure if I would like this to be true or not 😅
@snehasissarkar65994 ай бұрын
I KNEW FROM BEGINING WHEN I SAW THEIR RESONANCE MARO
@klismam17924 ай бұрын
Great video!!! Waiting for more content
@LlamaM22884 ай бұрын
So... was this purely just a theory or also a leak? Cause I really don't like any kind of story leaks
@gxzerr41994 ай бұрын
#oot guys is it true that wuthering waves income rate was decreased by zzz? If it's true where can i check it
@rosaleenstark91873 ай бұрын
Doesn't geshu lin have a scar on his lip? Scar doesn't have that same scar in his lip
@Firoo_3 ай бұрын
When will the character Geshulin be released?
@spicyice22504 ай бұрын
I want my greatsword boi. If this is true and it makes it so that we wont have geshu lin with his greatsword i will be sorely dissapointed
@KalKharo4 ай бұрын
We're already at 4k where's my lunite for my "BAD COMMENT"
@yinlinwaves4 ай бұрын
I've already chosen winners which I'll be displaying in next video! That is today
@Kindawgs3 ай бұрын
I need them to be separate characters
@khunneth35144 ай бұрын
Jiyan and jinshi the same person too i just know that
@painkiller81013 ай бұрын
I really really would hate that
@admiradorderubis4 ай бұрын
tem tudo pra ser verdade, mas quero que seja mentira, só pra eu poder jogar com o geshulin do jeito que ele apareceu nos flashbacks
@willho54934 ай бұрын
Huge hopium for that to be true
@lenasyhx4 ай бұрын
No offence, but this theory is so ass and makes no sense to me.
@wongsgh25484 ай бұрын
Scar --> ghesulin maybe he traveling to thailand and make surgery become keypop.. 😄 Good job kuro many people already curious obout the story.. thts the point kuro money always coming when they are greedy.. thirsty Hope kuro doesnt read it😂
@juliaf93934 ай бұрын
They could also be siblings 🤔
@levenundag97233 ай бұрын
Is scar and geshu lin playable?
@yinlinwaves3 ай бұрын
In future yes (geshulin is playable according to his record)
@ALIEN笑4 ай бұрын
Bro trying compare gas with patroleum coz both can be lighted firw.
@rajeshwariwaphgaonkar104 ай бұрын
i want both 😭🤧 i have to pull double time i am fp2 how am i suppose to do this
@kingsky98134 ай бұрын
No way scar is geshulin…😮😮
@Tarepoborpojekkkka4 ай бұрын
This theory makes sense
@emmazichtenstein18553 ай бұрын
Oh my...
@buttman129544 ай бұрын
nah geshu lin too buff and scar is slim build
@kingsky98134 ай бұрын
Gimme geshulin
@nevlc70154 ай бұрын
Imposible😮
@秘密-d2j4 ай бұрын
Ge shu is pronounced as (gerr- shoe)
@neanahidden4 ай бұрын
Good to know 😊
@ashutoshsingh-ur4dk3 ай бұрын
lamp and goat are defferent animals 🫡he is sheep not he-goat so stop simping over some lowlife enemies those with an unknown past
@dalhaval2834 ай бұрын
not even close
@Nghe-gi-hay-zay4 ай бұрын
wow if this is real...wow awful🤔
@akinkunmiakoni57844 ай бұрын
chill stop this shit better not happen bro i want geshu lin not fucking scar its waste to not make him playable