NewJeans Emergency Live full VIDEO 11-09 ALL ENGLISH SUB ALL KOREAN SUB 뉴진스 긴급라이브방송

[@pulwilwi]

NewJeans Live Translation Modified Scripts Version #1 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qZnadYWgn5mkj5o NewJeans Live Translation Modified Scripts Version #2 kzbin.info/www/bejne/oHacfWd8o9t6sMU NewJeans Live Translation Modified Scripts Version #3 kzbin.info/www/bejne/g5m0Za1snLSYbdU NewJeans Live Translation Modified Scripts Version #4 END kzbin.info/www/bejne/qKHVmn2YgruVmcU Thanks for letting me know 6:53 실례하는 (Excuse me) ❌ → →→ → →⭕신뢰하는 (Trusted) 8:20 어두워 (It's Dark) ❌ → →→ → →⭕어도어 (ADOR) 18:25 let us be anxious the excuse thay is was fo the sake of it work (저희가 불안해하는 걸 "맡기" 위해서라는 핑계를 "되" 시는데 ) ❌ You're making an excuse to "stop" us from getting anxious (저희가 불안해하는 걸 "막기" 위해서라는 핑계를 "대" 시는데 ⭕ 23:58 새력 new power❌ → →→ → →⭕세력 (influence , power, strength) 24:46 돼❌→ →→ → →⭕될 It's similar in context 26:23 들기끔 ❌→ →→ → →⭕들게끔 It's similar in context 31:14 프로듀"칭❌→ →→ → →⭕"프로듀싱 It's similar in context I translated the Korean word as soon as I heard it It might not be a perfect translation Therefore, to prevent mistranslation The original Korean text is also expressed in subtitles as you can hear it 한글단어가 들리는 대로 번역했습니다 완벽한 번역이 아닐수도 있습니다 따라서 오역을 방지하기위해 한글 원문도 들리는 그대로 자막에 표현하였습니다 Members' comments don't break off constantly. Words keep stopping and stopping The word order is completely different between Korean and English That's why I used a translation application, but it's hard to translate Korean and English smoothly. So I'd appreciate it if you could just watch the video to understand the context 멤버들이 멘트가 일정하게 끊어지지 않습니다 계속 단어가 멈추었다 이어지고 멈춥니다 한글과 영어는 어순이 완전히 다릅니다 그래서 번역 애플리케이션을 사용했는데 한국어와 영어를 원활하게 번역하기가 어렵습니다. 영상을 단순히 문맥만 이해하는 정도로 봐주시면 감사하겠습니다. and Progressive opinions are good, but let's refrain from violent language and indiscriminate criticism. 그리고 진보적인 의견도 좋지만 폭력적인 언어와 무분별한 비판은 자제합시다

[@MoonstoneStarChaser]

@@pulwilwi 🤔🤔🤔

[@gbae636]

How about just opinions are good.

[@dazymangang9694]

This happened coz new jeans became the biggest ⁴th gen group ...and their CEO wants to go seperately but first of all y she joined HYBE???

[@pulwilwi]

@@dazymangang9694Min Hee-jin officially joined BigHit Music on July 1, 2019.

[@TheShadowsFearX]

@@dazymangang9694 This happened cos their Shaman Btch CEO got greedy and selfish. Shes the sole reason for this and those 5 dmb gurlies just brainwashed with zero IQ now

[@aac10131]

This is a huge move in Kpop especially since Kpop groups like to be silent about certain issues and changes

[@lockdownfc24]

Newjeans are savage That why they are the 🐐

[@goldenotaqu]

they werent silent from the beginning thats why they got hate too

[@igagyatt]

​@@goldenotaquAnd stans wanna make fun of them for standing out for themselves

[@majicweather4890]

Prepare for a lot of manufactured hate coming their way. Hybe will release the bot farms. This is unprecedented signal to the industry as a whole. Once these girls do this, I'm sure others will be bold and speak out when they have to. That's not the status quo cuz by industry standards, the talent "must be silent and obey and do what they're told 👿"

[@Khampong_yumlam]

And people really need to understand and support them fr

[@prophecyrain6419]

They already know the ending to this and they accepted it already. They just wanted to talk about it instead of being silent. Its their 1st hand experience. They are really are brave. Mad props.

[@Anonymous-v8s2s]

This is beyond ridiculous...They are either being manipulated by MHJ or they are this naive. You shall never ever ever speak bad against your employer PUBLICALLY not matter what. And secondly, you should never pick side in your managment political fight. This is just workplace surivial 101. They are demanding MHJ to be reinstated which is impossible considering there are 2 lawsuits against her already.

[@Aroda-ra]

​@@Anonymous-v8s2s "You never know unless you walk in my shoes" -BlackPink You are not the one passed through all this so shut up.

[@pop7292]

​@@Anonymous-v8s2s Did you even watch the live, they said they were being mistreated under the new management.

[@codeone8195]

@@Anonymous-v8s2s You are a boot licker, If the company is treating you bad you should stand up for yourself 100% of the time.

[@slk..]

@@Anonymous-v8s2s”never ever speak bad again your employer” please shut the fuck up. you clearly have never worked a day in your life before, so just shut up. harassment, abuse and mistreatment in the workplace is NOT something you should just stay quiet about. people get SA’ed at work (even tho its not related to NWJNS) so just fuck off

[@KpopStan-TMF]

This has never happened like this in kpop before. I am worried for them.

[@DxModel219]

The music industry is ruthless… especially in the US. I hope they’ll be ok

[@KpopStan-TMF]

@@DxModel219 me too

[@missluna___]

Being a K-pop fan for over a decade now, my heart hurts for these girls because the industry is so tough, confusing, and now they're navigating it seemingly unprotected. I hope that whatever happens, they'll be okay as not only artists but as human beings. They poured huge portions of their childhood into becoming NewJeans and having that unique identity. The very least that the company can do is communicate with them and listen and come to some sort of middle ground. I worry so much about these girls.

[@Maavieeee]

This situation is just fifty fifty. Where they sided w/ another ceo who's now in jail & fought against their ceo atracc. Now, let's just wait if who's really the villain of this issue.

[@kingxricky_uncharted8519]

Fattest L I've seen. Mhj has a bad rep and bc they sided with her they're gonna disband and be sent to the shadow realm.

[@feliperoberto4870]

Correct translation for Hanni’s story: Hanni: Something happened to me recently. The 4th floor of the HYBE building is where we get our hair and makeup done, so a lot of other artists and staff come and go there. One day, I was waiting alone in the hallway, and another artist team with their manager passed by. The artists and I greeted each other, but when they came back out a bit later, I heard their manager say, “Ignore her,” right in front of me. He said it loud enough so I would hear. To this day, I still don’t understand why I had to be subject to that. Minji: When I heard about this from Hanni, I was shocked. How in the world could the manager of another team tell the members to just ignore her, and make his words loud enough so that she would hear it? He said such words that we wouldn’t even believe, and refused to acknowledge that this happened or even apologize for it. We have no idea how many more incidents like this will happen to us going forward and have anyone who will protect us from things like this. We’re worried about how we will continue to be ostracized here. Hanni: All I wish is for things like this to not happen to anyone. But because this has already happened once, now I fear that this will happen again. In fact, I told the new Ador CEO about this incident, but she told me that I have no evidence and that it was too late anyway. Experiencing that, I realized there is no one here to protect us. There is no one here who truly cares about us. Instead, I was treated like a liar. Prior to this, Min Hee Jin would always fight for us. The new leadership staff said they would be there for us, but for months all they have done is make excuses without solutions. And when I finally brought up an incident that directly happened to me, they instead put the blame on me. It makes me worried and scared about the future. PS: THIS TRANSLATIOIN IS NOT MINE

[@RazgrizDavion81]

honestly as sad as it may be, complaining of this kind of thing is really show how petty NJ girls are. Its a work place, nothing will ever be fair. Toughen up and perform better above those who mistreat them let the end result speak for it self. This is just whining, sorry to say.

[@umar5138]

@@RazgrizDavion81 this treatment is bad and unprofessional. The manager who did this to hani has no moral value especially for a team manager who should have leadership. "Toughen and perform better" Literally a braindead statement from you because that has nothing to do with the issue. The CEO should question the behavior of that manager instead of falsely accusing Hani for lying.

[@Fifi-ec3bu]

Kurang kerasa ya manager nim , seharusnya ngmong depan mukanya , " jangan di sapa anak gak tau diri "

[@kwamebrownofficial]

@@RazgrizDavion81 true. Not that I expect the girls to act maturely.

[@Kung_fu_panda_918]

No matter how much money they earn majority of it is going to hybe anyway...they can't possibly be called whiny....they are kids...they had never expected something like this to happen to them after all the success they've had since their debut​@@RazgrizDavion81

[@cidack]

They're not used to seeing idols standing up against their company, they're so used to mistreatment. Go my NewJeans!!

[@K1nah_taa-me6mc]

Yes that’s soo true!

[@uiz__189]

yeah, but your girlies gonna disband. won't have the rights to their name, songs, etc. they probably will redebut

[@tueur3369]

They prolly already know they gonna end up disbanded by hybe anyway​@@uiz__189

[@hmj3547]

​​​@@uiz__189Good For them & Us fans too....NJs made an Impact In K-pop & worldwide with their Music already!!! & Only for these 5 girls...no one would question about MHJ or Hybe being the Mastermind or anything(except those Hybe brainwashed fans/other Hybe group stans)...So Fighting NEWJEANS!!! Hyein,Hanni, Danielle,Hyerin,Minji 💗

[@uiz__189]

@@hmj3547 brainwashed fans or brainwashed idols? they sure made impact worldwide, but u can't survive the industry without back up honey. We've seen it from other groups and idols before. I pray these girlies get through this though. Too young to be involved into adults mess.

[@collie7703]

nah 'cause that was very brave of them, that's a huge company they're calling out but they stood their ground, mad respect to u newjeans

[@powbobs]

They ended their careers unfortunately.

[@disgustedbyyourstupidity9895]

​@@powbobs fr

[@tomieeeeeee]

​@@powbobs Hybe is already ending it slowly though. That's why they're speaking up.

[@powbobs]

@@tomieeeeeee How are they doing that. They just performed a couple days ago.

[@yudhasetiawan1220]

​@@tomieeeeeee hybe will return when BTS is back as a whole next year..groups like new jeans can be replaced at any time by the industry

[@enigmaohawaii]

5:10 is where they stop waiting around and start talking you are welcome

[@deliBenDeCruz]

You are welcome again

[@zenjayden7648]

ty

[@dindssdonggss]

Tysmmmmm!!

[@choidarks]

Why are they waiting for so long to begin?

[@tahiti1264]

​@@choidarks for enough viewers to come into the live

[@blinkunajs]

NewJeans did the right thing, but it will affect their future. If they had followed in Min Hee Jin's footsteps and given NewJeans a good working environment, nothing would have happened. I see a lot of people saying NewJeans are ungrateful but look at that? Since Minji's drama when she was a trainee, we all know how unfairly NewJeans are treated. Not only NewJeans, other artists too. I don't understand what the hell HYBE is doing. **Bunnies will always support NewJeans!**

[@jkvmaibebe3680]

Min hee Jin only cared of the girls she lied Dragging other artists and use Shaman on BTS

[@shio5186]

I wanna give credit to the girls for speaking out their opinions (if this live is 100% their idea) but it's like employees demanding your big boss not to fire your ex-boss who's supposedly committed a corporate crime & also is getting sued from a SA victim plus all the other labels (& also has a reputation of being too obsessive with teenagers.) just because she treated them well. I understand their sentiments but it's not gonna happen. And MHJ is not even "fired" exactly. She's still NJ's creative director.

[@missluna___]

I'm proud of them for speaking their minds but I would be absolutely lying if I said I wasn't terrified of what's next for them given how absolutely no one is protecting them. I feel so horrible for them and hope that there's some resolution that allows NewJeans to continue not only as a group but with the identity they started with. My heart goes out to these girls. This must be incredibly scary for them.

[@rokaram8619]

That impossible hybe isn't a charity company they're a multinational corporation after all the money they spent for their group now they want to get all the benefits demanding shxt like get back our groomer to the ceo position when it's not their business bc they employees they can demand better treatment but they can't tell the board directors what to do and who should the put as a ceo in their DXMN subsidiary like girls I love you but that's not you f work like don't let the fame make you think that you're in any position to demand things like that quite idiotic

[@eclairs0909]

A lot of this just sounds like children whining because everything isn’t sunshine and rainbows anymore. They clearly don’t understand how business works. please don't make them delusional. I request/beg you to not make them do such stupid things. I like their music very much but after this they are over. please I really beg you not to say such things and give them a false sense of support. This is grooming 101.

[@Siblubru]

@@eclairs0909So when you're mistreated by your boss and your coworkers you just have to shut up because it's expectable to be "harrased / ignored" in your work place? 😅 The way hybe ask them to hiatus aka they wont be able to earn any money for a year in their peak season is just pitiful 😅

[@SWATSANOWILLFINDU]

​@@Siblubru exactly, I'd do the same thing if I were new jeans

[@blusky6388]

@@eclairs0909the sounds they made will change the K-pop scene to another level. It has been already a start of revolution against the system totally distorted let’s see what will happen

[@Dussthedog]

Everyones eyes look so tired and dead. Minji looks really upset, Danielle looks lifeless for once, Hyein is ashamed but brave enough to share her thought, Hanni and haerin are just..not there(?)

[@mlungan7717]

They made their own miatakes by being min jin pawns in this battle. Due to their greedy parents! They forsake integrity over money !

[@Yukitopia14]

​@@mlungan7717shutup Man id u want to just hate them then y coming here at the first place

[@mlungan7717]

@@Yukitopia14 its not about hate! ITS COMMON SENSE!! U better grow up and see the games of that old mjin cunt!

[@luanquang-e9s]

@@mlungan7717 I bet 100 dollar. No matter side they chose, Hype or MHJ, they still be criticized the same thing by you.

[@ChonWang247]

@@mlungan7717 What's considered integrity to you? Towing the company line above all else? Keep in mind, these five girls have a deeply personal relationship with MHJ considering she hand-picked them and oversaw their development and rise into a prominent group. Is it really surprising to you that they feel some sense of loyalty to her and are willing to speak out for her?

[@akshayaravi7680]

Kpop celebs dont speak. This is HUGE. These girls are incredibly brave. I hope they didn't baned, i hope hybe treats them fair. Knowing how kpop companies work I don't see this ending well or anytime soon. I hope the girls are safe

[@eclairs0909]

A lot of this just sounds like children whining because everything isn’t sunshine and rainbows anymore. They clearly don’t understand how business works. please don't make them delusional. I request/beg you to not make them do such stupid things. I like their music very much but after this they are over. please I really beg you not to say such things and give them a false sense of support. This is grooming 101.

[@verasambience]

@@eclairs0909hybe bot

[@elenagonzales2417]

The newjeans members have obviously been left in a vulnerable situation. We can only listen to their personal accounts, but their art and music and the environment they work in is obviously completely shifted and even erased, they’re not being protected by the company even, just because Hybe decided to turn them into a husk of the creation and vision they were initially meant to be. They’re doing this obv bc of MHJ and the adults’ fight affects the kids the worst. The big company obviously does not gaf about their dreams or their concerns or their own visions for their music, all Hybe cares about is putting MHJ out of power, silencing NJ to further them into the hole of just pumping out content and music with no substance or message or care for it’s creation or art. Hybe cares about their money so bad and we should all already know this and it’s insane some ppl think they would care about newjeans or treat them better as oppose to ‘old Ador’. Theyre literally speaking out now, we should listen

[@yudhasetiawan1220]

There will be 2 possibilities that will be experienced by new jeans. 1: they will be fined by contract, 2: they will be kept by hybe until their contract expires

[@kingxricky_uncharted8519]

Tbh mhj should've been fired ever since she shitted on bts. She's the reason why njs is gonna disband it's a shame but it is what it is. All blame goes to mhj. Let's not forget she got Kim garam and youngseo kicked out of their groups and tried to take chaewon out too. This is all karma.

[@bernadettepalmer6407]

@@yudhasetiawan1220😢😮

[@RazgrizDavion81]

@@yudhasetiawan1220 most likely the latter one. The company can easily pull "if I can have it, no one can" moves. And guess what, time a commodity these idols can't afford to loose.

[@sorntrash]

@@kingxricky_uncharted8519Is all that even confirmed?

[@binhminhtran7942]

This live had been deleted now and you guys cannot watch again anymore but now someone can repost it again

[@masqueradeee]

Where was it posted?

[@nikhilrana1237]

Why did it got deleted ?

[@lydiachan8624]

They opened a channel without the stuff knowing and got deleted after it​@@masqueradeee

[@AnkitaSahoo-iw6eu]

​@@nikhilrana1237Bcz it was unannounced live and obviously their company wouldn't sit quietly

[@stayinneverland]

​@@masqueradeee it was posted in a now deleted channel under the nametag "nwjns"

[@Lotify1234]

Kpop stans cry about line distribution bad styles bad hair colour as mistreatment but when the group actually talks about the mistreatment they are ungrateful ? Bullies? Spoiled ? Like bruh why do you all even think it's normal for an idol to face this when it shouldn't be EDIT: I'm not gonna reply anything to anyone from now on i said what i said i can't change your opinion nor you can change mine so let's just stick to our own opinions without the need of telling the other side you are WRONG! you are right in your place i'm right in my place , nwjns is right in their place , mhj might be right in her place, hybe must be right in their own place it's all about the perception that we have. BYE and i don't hate any of the people saying they are being stupid their career is over i see why you say that as well , but the people pretending as if hybe is innocent are the worst 👥️

[@lilabouabbache5241]

❤👌 true !

[@acdc222]

The point here is they supporting who they shouldn't. MHj did horrible things to other groups, her staff and even to the company that put her as ceo and provide with everything.. She even said that NJ is stupid and whiny lil girls. So I don't understand how their support should be praised

[@alagalagololababa6648]

​@acdc222 alot of that was debunked. and btw hybe is a big ahh corporation just imagine how much they can fabricate stuff and bribe ppl w/o getting caught bec of the power they have?

[@Lotify1234]

@@acdc222 MHJ might be wrong but people pretending as if hybe is innocent is ridiculous! asking for their rights and standing against what feels wrong is then idk what kind of mentality people hv these days! MHJ did what to other groups aren't even sure shot true hybe is a powerful company with media power MHJ is not innocent true but her doings are villanised too much as compare to hybe ! And these girls standing up against mistreatment is a huge step in kpop so instead of just hating support who stands for themselves. No MHJ no HYBE just new jeans !

[@thomassssss]

@@Lotify1234fixed your grammar MHJ might be wrong, but people pretending as if hybe is innocent is ridiculous! Whiny lil girls you say, if asking for their rights and standing against what feels wrong is termed as whiny then idk what kind of mentality h these days! (what does this mean man) The things MHJ did to other groups aren't even sure shot true. Hybe is a powerful company with media power. MHJ is not innocent, true, but her doings are villanised too much compared to hybe! These girls standing up against mistreatment is a huge step in kpop, so instead of just hating, support who stands up for themselves. No MHJ, no HYBE, just new jeans!

[@annieisnotok]

I’m so proud of them for speaking up. Many idols do not speak up and share their experiences, and that’s problematic. I am so proud that they are voicing their concerns.

[@NoOne-dd3nn]

It's weird how the company's stans are slandering them for speaking up abt their toxic work environment. Some of them even say that everyone in Hybe is miserable so NJ should just shut up bc they're being entitled. Like wtf?

[@NoraTheAlora]

Watching this was so painful for me. The girls must be in so much distress with all this going on. They don’t deserve this.

[@sugaisasuga6740]

Bunnies have to understand min heejin basically raised these girls and made them who they were. So even tho we might not understand why they are defending we also gotta realize their bond with heejin. Both parties arent right especially hybe and how they treat the girls. Newjeans doesn’t deserve to be called stupid for standing up for them and the person who helped and made them basically. Its called respect

[@Randomnesss525]

She groomed and brainwashed these girls in other words, disgusting get these girls far away from that weirdo who talks sht abt them behind their backs

[@finnlinnsone]

I think people above all need to understand that HYBE's mistreatment that has specifically targeted NewJeans the past year shouldn't go unpunished just because Min Heejin was demoted. HYBE literally faced no consequences publicly for being the ones who leaked the NJ members personal information because people were too fixated on MHJ, which is unacceptable imo. People can't preach that they disagree with both sides and then only criticize the side they like the least just because MHJ is an easier target.

[@powbobs]

@@finnlinnsone What mistreatment? Be specific and site evidence.

[@aerineu]

More like she groomed them. They drove themself into a pit they won’t be able to escape.

[@이안-x4t]

@@finnlinnsoneHybe go unpunished??? MHJ has always been putting Hybe against public opinion with her media play and manipulation. It is MHJ rather who is unpunished. Why is no one even Newjeans themselves not saying a thing how MHJ dragged other groups into this mess just to cover up her selfish agenda. If anyone is to be blamed and punished, it’s MHJ. And since these girls sided with MHJ, I believe they are aware of the consequences.

[@Ryujiniee27]

I’m so proud of new jeans for speaking out on this situation this shows that kpop companies should change when it comes to their idols

[@thesanctuary225]

Boycott Hybe

[@rokaram8619]

They missed up by bringing and praising minhejin cause everyone knows that the creep started the feud and their script look like something minhejin wrote

[@alagalagololababa6648]

def not. research more. ur embarrassing ​@@rokaram8619

[@_Lavanya_Mishra]

​@@thesanctuary225 and what about mhj?

[@Liyserii_]

@@thesanctuary225 nty

[@potatonian]

This is why boss and employee relations should be kept professional. I applaud the members for their bravery, theyre right to defend themselves against Hybe, but their arguments advocating for MHJ is biased at best. MHJ should be ashamed, though, for using the girls as ammunition against Hybe. I really hope Newjeans can come back from this unscathed.

[@summer-plumeria]

Agreed! Yes yes this!

[@Anonymous-v8s2s]

They say they are mistreated and abused by HYBE with herasay ? How much is their aparemnt again ? What about those brand deals ? MV shots ? These are all from HYBE not Adore. HYBE employees had to work their asses off for NJ's debut MV.

[@fujimamoru]

Those are staff's job desk tho. Now NJ is facing discrimination, what'd you do in that situation? You'd have spoken too, right?

[@godfromthemachines]

@@Anonymous-v8s2s never defend a corporate agency in the name of the image they hold. you don't know what's going on behind the scenes. blaming idols for their own mistreatment as if it's so unbelievable that a massive music label can mistreat them is insane to me, as a kpop fan you should be aware of these happenings. HYBE isn't a small indie label that's struggling and relying purely on underpaid interns to carry their finances. frankly speaking, it is both the selfish fans and big companies' sense of entitlement and constant complaints that lead idols to feel so trapped in these situations. it is the job of HYBE employees to set up sets, it is their job to arrange brand deals, it is their job to liaison between ADOR and HYBE communications. it is not their job to pick on NewJeans members and ignore them, create a toxic culture for idols and rip them away from any sense of familiarity they have. people like you who blab mindlessly on the internet and complain about every single thing which ruins the image of a perfect Kpop world are the issue. Grow up.

[@kazkaz614]

​@@Anonymous-v8s2scan u explain to me how is it a hearsay when the actual members themselves are talking about it in the video. They speak on what theybare experiencing regardless if it was biased or not.

[@Rinakami]

Some of y’all are new K-pop followers but I want to remind everyone that once HYBE bought Gfriend’s company. (Source music) Gfriend ended up disbanding after a few come backs. I’m sure they can’t talk about it but they hinted that it was against their will. The people defending HYBE just because their fav is with the company needs to do some critical thinking. Your favs are just products to HYBE. The whole destroy aespa thing as well. Imma bring up black swan as an example. They were the original “global group” but notice how all the bigger companies are now releasing their own “global groups” now. HYBE is shady. I’m not saying the artists under them are, they’re just following what HYBE wants of them. I understand this is an unpopular opinion. I won’t be responding to anyone who comments under me. I just want y’all to do some critical thinking.

[@exogen9428]

Wasn't Gfriend's disbandment because of mhj in the first place?

[@raphaeljung1034]

@@exogen9428@ exogen9428 Gfriend's are from source music. Ador has nothing related to source music except both being in HYBE. G friend's disbandment was because of the debut of lessarafim.

[@tuesdayjanae3676]

@@exogen9428uh no. They were disbanded because of lsfm. Hybe is just a bad company

[@Dandaylion]

Considering the success of gfriend hybe probably won’t hesitate to disband NewJeans too 💀

[@jkvmaibebe3680]

Yup but don't include big hit music artists and bang pd they're different

[@lingth]

They ask Chairman Bang to return ADOR to it's original state, but he will say "Or Else What??" There is nothing they can do about it as they signed the contract with ADOR not Min Hee Jin.. so if ADOR change it's CEO, their contracts are still tied to ADOR. With all the lawsuits and issues, no big brands will want New Jeans as their endorsement models also.. when their CF contracts expire I doubt new ones will be signed.. they would probably be neglected by the new management.

[@rollingthelia]

The members can report mistreatments by their company to terminate their contract. Maybe they have more accounts on Hybe’s mistreatments that made them speak up confidently. And I hope Hybe would just let them go, for the peaceful for everyone really. The value of New Jeans is still huge, their fandom is also strong, and with all these tragedies those could only strengthen the bond of their fans and the group itself. Even casual fans of them are now supporting the girls, so it will still be a fortune for any company / person that could acquire them and MHJ.

[@Chungmyungalchol]

You may think that buy Hybe is the biggest kpop agency in the world. If they blacklist njw their will be no future for them lol. Also i doubt any of the other big companies would take them in either, their only real option is to start a company with Mhj.​@@rollingthelia

[@Lim-678]

대략적으로 정리된 글을 퍼왔습니다. 꼭 한번씩 봐주시고 좋아요 눌러서 위로 올려주세용 ㅜ 1.민희진이 sm의 시스템에 한계를 느끼고 새로운 것을 하고싶어 퇴사 2. 방시혁은 그간 걸그룹은 못한다는 이미지를 깨고 싶어 민희진영입 3. 빠른 그룹런칭을 위해 쏘스 연습생, 오디션을 모두동원했으나 민지, 하니 외에 캐스팅할만한 멤버 못찾음 4. 개별 캐스팅을 통해 나머지 멤버 영입. 당시 이들 캐스팅을 위해 하이브의 첫번째 걸그룹으로 전폭적인 지원이 갈것임을 내세웠음. 5. 초반에는 방시혁과 민희진의 니즈가 맞았기에 조금씩 어긋나는 부분이 있어도 맞춰가며 진행했음. 그러나 코로나로 뉴진스 데뷔가 미뤄짐. 6. 그 사이 에스파, 아이브가 대성공을 거둠. 7. 쏘쓰에서 에스파처럼 강렬한 컨셉, 아이브같은 인기멤버 보유로 기존팬덤을 확보한 르세라핌을 기획함 8. 하이브에서는 전원신인에 실험적인 데뷔곡을 준비한 뉴진스보다는 르세라핌을 첫그룹으로 밀기로함. 하이브입장에서는 첫 걸그룹이 성공해야 이후 걸그룹도 성공가능성이 있는데 뉴진스는 너무 모험이라 경영적 관점에서 결정. 9. 민희진 강력반발. 뉴진스 캐스팅부터 약속된 내용인만큼 하이브경영진에 대한 반발 수위가 거셌음. 10.하이브 측은 경영자 관점을 이해못하는 민희진에 대해 불만이 커지고 민희진은 아티스트적 관점을 이해못하는 사측에 불만이 커짐. 11. 뉴진스 대성공거둠. 12. 민희진 더더욱 기세등등 13. 방시혁 민희진이 아니꼽기 시작 14. 민희진 자기는 지원하나없이 뉴진스로 엄청난 돈을 벌어다줬음에도 성과별로인 다른사람들이 받는 인센티브와 별차이 없는 부분등을 보며 불만폭주 15. 민희진 본인에게 불리하다 여겨지는 계약조건 수정을 요청했으나 잘 안되던 상황. 특히 뉴진스 홍보 등에서도 자율권이 확보가 안되던 경험 등을 고려, 회사 내 본인의 레이블 대표로서의 입지를 확보하기위한 요구들이 었을 것으로 보임. 16. 하이브는 멀티레이블체제기는 하나 그들을 장악하기위해 인사, 재무 등이 레이블 상위에서 그들을 지휘하는 체계를 만들었음. 그래야 그룹이 원하는 방향으로 레이블통제가 가능. 따라서 민희진측의 자율성 확보를 위한 시도가 더욱 불편함. 이것이 받아들여지면 추후 그룹내 지배권이 약해질 가능성이 있음. 17. 아일릿 데뷔 컨셉을 보며 불만이 극에달한 민희진 하이브측에 강하게 의견개진함. 18. 하이브 컨트롤이 안되는 민희진을 손해를 감수하고 쳐내기로하고 사내 pc압수등으로 감사시작 19. 민희진측은 사내 친한직원들과 카톡등으로 이러한 불만을 공유하며 하이브로 부터 어도어의 독립성확보를 하고싶다는 취지의 이야기들을 나누고있었음. 주식확보 등이 거기서 나온이야기. 20. 민희진측 주식확보, 경영권 확보 를 위한 계획들은 실현 가능성이 거의 없다는 점과 진짜 경영권찬탈을 위한 계획이라면 텔레그램도아니고 사내pc로 카톡을하고 문건을 작성한다는게 말이 안된다는 점 등을 미루어보아 불만이 있었던 것은 사실이나 찐계획까지는 아닌 것으로 보임. 0. BTS 성공에 지분이 높았던 최유정 부사장, 윤석준 전 하이브 아메리카 CEO 토사구팽 (160억, 260억, 5년간 경업금지) 0. 2019년 민희진CBO, 방시혁의 음악(ㅋㅋ), 쏘스뮤직의 매니지먼트 합작으로 빅히트 첫번째 걸그룹 런칭 예정 (방시혁 : 제가 걸알못이라) 0. 2021년 5월 18일 걸그룹 여자친구 해체 (음방 1위 횟수 71회 탑티어급 걸그룹, 방시혁과 소성진은 친구임, 당시 쏘스뮤직에 대한 하이브 지분 80%) 0. 2021년 12월 2일 에스파가 AAA 어워즈에서 3관왕 (방시혁 : 에스파 밟으실 수 있죠?ㅎ) 1. 방시혁이 어텐션, 하입보이, 그룹 컨샙을 좋게 평가하지 않았음. (밋밋하다, 대중성 없는 스타일, 그런 음악으로 1등 못 해요) 2. 민지를 제외하고 멤버들 민희진이 캐스팅했는데 쏘스뮤직 측에서 민희진과 멤버 못 만나게 했음 (쏘스뮤직 오디션 하에 민희진이 캐스팅) 3. 하이브가 먼저 배신 (민희진 걸그룹이 하이브 1호 걸그룹으로 런칭될 것이라는 약속을 깨고 곡과 컨셉에 의문을 가진 방시혁, 소성진이 다른 걸그룹 런칭 계획, 연습생 부모님에게 설명x) 4. 민희진이 반발 (너네 양아치냐, 나 회사 나가겠다, 이후 하이브 지분 100%라는 조건으로 뉴진스 멤버 어도어로 이전, 민희진 놓치기 싫었던 방시혁이 쏘스뮤직에 위로금 20억 내줌) 5 민희진에게 뉴진스의 적극적인 홍보를 금지하였음 (유퀴즈에서 전원신인, 전원10대 언급금지, 박지원 : 복수는 성공해서, 민희진 : 시혁님 안챙피한가? 졸라 챙피한 일인데) 6 방시혁 뉴진스 인사 안 받음 (무시 당한 것이 무안해서 엘리베이터 안에서 멍하니 서있음, 방시혁이 못 본 척 하거나 일부러 피해감, 멤버들은 고작 중고등학생의 나이) 7 박지원이 OMG MV로 민희진을 협박함 (민희진 : 애플 오버리액트 사과했죠? omg뮤비로 나 협박해서 애플행사 뜯어낸거 참나..어이가없는데 -> 어떤 협박이 이루어졌는지 아직까지 공개x 무슨 이유에선지 애플행사는 뉴진스와 진행됨 팀쿡 : 애플 강남점 축하 뉴진스도 함께해 기뻐요) 8. 하이브 박태희, 그러니깐 왜 일간스포츠와 0000는 민희진 편을 드는 기사를 쓰느냐고 갑질 (하이브 홍보 관계자들은 가처분신청 결론을 앞두고 언론에 이성적인 일반여론은 자신들을 지지하고, 이성적보다는 감성적 어필에 움직이는 팬여론이 아직 민희진 쪽에 있다고 이야기하곤 한다.) 9. 루이비통 엠버서더 문제 (하이브의 브랜드시너지사업팀에서 어도어와 루이비통 양측에 서로 다른 거짓말로 계약을 체결, 판결문에 명시) 10. 하이브, 민희진에게 음반밀어내기(초동부풀리기) 권유 (판결문에 전혀 근거가 없다고 단정하기 어려운 점 명시) 11. 타그룹과의 유사성 문제 (가처분 인용당시 판결문에 명시) 12. 하이브의 뉴진스 차별대우 (판결문에 명시) 13. 하이브 셰어드서비스 문제 (중학교7학년 신상공개 승인 됐지만 하이브 법무팀 관계자 퇴사했다는 이유로 소식없음, 빅히트, 플래디스 다음으로 매출이 큰 어도어, 수수료 많이냄) 14. 박지원 : 도쿄돔 끝나면 뉴진스에게 긴 휴가를 줄 계획이다. 그레미상 받은 프로듀서를 섭외하는데 1년 반 정도 걸리는데 최대한 빨리 붙이려고 한다. 15. 버블검 표절 시비 (하이브 내부에서 어도어 조리돌림, 이후 샤카탁측에서 언급없음) 16. 연습생 영상 유출 (하이브에서 기자분들과 언론사 데스크에 업무상 취득한 정보 혹은 취득할 수 있는 범위를 넘은 정보를 직접 보여주며 언론플레이를 하려 했다는 제보) 17. 방시혁 과즙세연과 베버리힐스에서 발견 (과연 순수한 관계일까? 빅히트때 회계업무 봐주던 외부 사람한테 방시혁 썰을 들었는데..더보기) 18. Ditto MV 감독에 대한 갑질 및 협박 (일요일 밤 전화걸어 월요일 오전까지 뉴진스 관련 영상 안 내리면 위약금 2배, 내용증명 보내겠다) 그밖에 정리하기 귀찮아서 두서없이 사견과 함께 대충 씁니다 민희진, 2024년 3월 부터 하이브에 내부고발(유사성 항의, 음반밀어내기) 4월 22일 하이브, 어도어 감사 실시, 4월 23일 여론전 시작, 4월 25일 하이브, 결정적 물증 확보. 사우디국부, 싱가폴투자청, 네이버, 두나무, 타 팬덤 이용해 민희진 함께 공격하기 위한 시도

[@applepieholic]

이거 고정갑시다

[@renecci]

정리의 신이시네요. 👍👍👍

[@calliopef392]

Has this been presented in court?

[@justmdzn23]

Thats what im thinking. the girls did nothing wrong at all. dont blame them pls.. they got nothing to do with this. it's... the company's problem, thats all!! whatever will happen, we'll keep an eye on this

[@AzertQsdf-j8c]

이게 팩트죠! 완벽한 정리 감사합니다 혹시 이글 복사해서 다른 댓글에 노출 시켜도 될까요?

[@dikuba.k.aliciaashley6002]

I don't mean to defend anyone but looking at this from an umbiased look, HYBE is messed up. But for real tge reason NJ net pick every single incident happening at HYBE is because when they started HYBE gave them everything and focused on them but now HYBE isn't focusing on them anymore since from the beginning they've been against HYBE and always refused HYBE's arrangements. But the manager also telling his team to ignore them is rude and bad but legit I kind of see the staffs ignoring them from now on though. And what the new CEO says about not being able to do anything without evidence is true, firstly they rejected the CEO so telling the CEO this incident and asking for it to be resolved like talking directly to the CEO, instead of going through the hierarchy and also that after rejecting her and requesting for her to be replaced, the new CEO will feel disrespected and feel like you're clowning her and also she can't go about warning or punishing the other staffs without evidence or do we think they should hold a press conference to denounce the staff.

[@dolbuk1]

Translation error at Hani word. Not, He told me to ignore him, But, He told them(his members) to ignore Hani.

[@masqueradeee]

F that's brutal imagine working in such environment it'd be better to just leave

[@buzzaldrin2556]

@@masqueradeeeNo , they all want you to shut up and leave. Newjeans are fighting back now!!!!

[@Jmnmedic]

I give them credit for voicing their opinion. But as a company there is no way Hybe can do what they request. First mistake is that both new jeans and MHJ forgot they don’t own Adore. MHJ was an employee. I am sorry girls but you don’t get to demand who the CEO is. MHJ over stepped and Hybe no longer trust her. No one in their right mind would keep someone who tried to stab you in the back. They are making unrealistic demands. They should demand that MHJ be given full creative control of new jeans. That is something they may win. But telling Hybe to reinstate MHJ as CEO will never happen. .

[@Yourmother69-uuuu]

So you are basically telling that they should keep quiet and take in all the mistreatments?

[@viparmyblink9559]

​@@Yourmother69-uuuu like NJ being hybe artist is a delicate position right now First their parents spoke out and now NJ We know that MHJ was better for NJ but she tried to speak out including all other artists so it's kind of wrong cuz it gives negative impacts on that groups and respective companies So for this negativity hybe just asked her to stepped down from CEO he could've just kicked her out but he didn't I am not saying who is right or wrong but NJ should understand where to speak and what to speak at this position Now let's see what happens next I just hope it's not fifty fifty case again cuz I love NJ

[@hahahehe8915]

@@Yourmother69-uuuuthat’s not what they said. They just pointed out the fact New Jeans members don’t control what happens in the company so they can’t demand MHJ be reinstated as the CEO. In the end, they’re just employees at HYBE. They’re not likely at all to get what they want. HYBE isn’t likely to bend to their requests especially after MHJ tried to take ADORE. On a business level they’d be stupid to take her back. But nonetheless they definitely need to talk with the girls and make sure that there’s something they can do in the moment to make sure they at the very least feel safe.

[@noneofyourbusiness-tw7dp]

@@Yourmother69-uuuu being ignored is mistreatment? what was the new CEO supposed to do? Go and ask them to acknowledge her? if someone is being petty enough to ignore someone, then be mature and distance yourself from that, not cry and whine about it. That girl is not a middle schooler yet she acts like one.

[@Yourmother69-uuuu]

@@noneofyourbusiness-tw7dp not just ignored but they said the company even deleted the content newjeans made for their fans and they didn't even know why

[@luvnini2612]

It was very bold of them to do this, very proud of the girls

[@eclairs0909]

A lot of this just sounds like children whining because everything isn’t sunshine and rainbows anymore. They clearly don’t understand how business works. please don't make them delusional. I request/beg you to not make them do such stupid things. I like their music very much but after this they are over. please I really beg you not to say such things and give them a false sense of support.

[@teizereriko]

This is the same as what they did to G-FRIEND just to debut another group.. Lets not forget this timeline according to SinB on that video where they got interviewed 1. HYBE made Source Music as a subsidiary for a promise to treat G-Friend well 2. They didnt know theyre disbanding until the news broke out 3. The time they got disbanded, weeks later, three went as Viviz and some goes solo. 4. They got interviewed on different publication and they only said one thing about HYBE "THEY JUST WANNA MAKE MUSIC BUT HYBE KEEPS DESTROYING THEM" Conclusion : HYBE was just really on the mood to destroy groups they promise to build (on both subsidiaries and main) for the sake of Publicity and when the stunt went wrong, they will start making the artist on their control to comebacks and make them overwork on a weeks of promotion just to keep the people busy and forget about the mess they made. #protectartistfromHYBE

[@Lainelainehere]

HYBE is the one being unprofessional since the very beginning

[@eltafadhityasramadhan1398]

Netizen : "artist need to be speak up more about their feeling and what they want" *NewJeans do the exactly what they want to express* Also Netizen : "😡😡😡"

[@funwithpowerpoint7580]

bruh cuz it's manipulated'

[@idlegamea-ji6md]

@@funwithpowerpoint7580 You are not them.

[@eltafadhityasramadhan1398]

@jniiib if you seen in x, there is a lot of people blaming newjeans and said that these poor girls are attention seekeer, most of them is army and fearnot who keep defending their fav agency 🥲

[@RazgrizDavion81]

@jniiib exactly, this is common sense, for the NJ girls be doing this they either soo clueless or being manipulated into one.

[@SC-dj1sn]

@@RazgrizDavion81 Instead they are brave and you are a bully

[@jessie-ambre7730]

I think that you guys don’t get it.. in this industry nobody can speak out ! This act can lead to their disbandment.. this is literally crazy..

[@antonettemartinez6034]

They're trying to make a change to Kpop industry. It's crazy and they are brave.

[@jessie-ambre7730]

@@antonettemartinez6034 yes they are brave but this is not the best solution for their group and especially their career !!!!! This industry isn’t a playground.. I mean if you wanna stay in it there are some things Thant you can’t do !

[@vincelz14]

so are we normalizing tolerating not doing something about injustice?

[@igagyatt]

​@@jessie-ambre7730 Girl for them, who have been training since 2020/2021 to debut as idols, get to the point that they had to open up a live to expose a huge label for their distreatment shows how rough they have been going through the girls just had enough of it.

[@jessie-ambre7730]

@@vincelz14 ofc not but sometimes you have to make sacrifices

[@BPNJ45]

Instagram comments: they are playing victim cards KZbin comments : they are brave

[@racheltruong371]

So accurate

[@thatoneperson731]

they are the victims

[@BPNJ45]

@@thatoneperson731 Instagram comment are too toxic

[@eclairs0909]

A lot of this just sounds like children whining because everything isn’t sunshine and rainbows anymore. They clearly don’t understand how business works. please don't make them delusional. I request/beg you to not make them do such stupid things. I like their music very much but after this they are over. please I really beg you not to say such things and give them a false sense of support. This is grooming 101.

[@Meowlouder-g8n]

That’s because they are bots 🤖

[@vampr3751]

im sad that they are mistreated but happy that these younger idols are not afraid to speak up against these rotten companies. i hope what newjeans does makes other idols feel more comfortable doing the same ❤

[@r-foose]

this is incredibly brave. change better happen

[@aerineu]

Yeah, changes like their disbandment

[@Shin_yuki_]

Brave yes but stupid. Their career is over.

[@tomieeeeeee]

Those who are not on newjeans side are the reason why rich and evil people keeps on getting more powerful, richer and more evil. I expect they are kids who doesn't know about real world.

[@김지현-e1g3j]

​@@tomieeeeeee.....but now what will happen to them

[@Janeoftea]

the only change that could happen is k-pop agencies will add such an "penalty to any activity that could harms the agency" in the contract before debuting idols.

[@myheartbeatskkj2361]

I wouldn't be surprised if Hybe null and void contract with NJ. How many artists out here who didn't have issues with their record labels? Megan Thee Stallion, JayZ, Drake, Eminem to name a few who started their own record labels because they wanted their own way/direction or had issues with the record labels. If NJ can do it, why not do it? But if they can't, is demanding Hybe the right way to do it? IMO, I don't think so. I believe their demands will just fall on deaf ears and have greater consequences.

[@jessie-ambre7730]

In my opinion the only possible solution is that mhj creates her own label and manage NJ thanks to it

[@charleschchu]

​@@jessie-ambre7730 I have a theory all this is for that to happen

[@miminguyen3106]

I agree however they are very profitable group and hybe won’t let them out of their contracts without a big 💰💰💰. I don’t think mhj or nj have the funds to get out of their contracts. Artist contracts are basically slave contracts. It’s sad!

[@titanimarklee]

Are you dumb? Contracts puts responsibility on both parties to deliver on their terms. If HYBE is not delivering on theirs through what is now Ador, the artists have every right to complain. They can leave, but why? They contributed to the growth of Ador-majorly. But you l want them to just leave? Y’all always on the side of corporate bullies, that’s a shame. Brainwashed. Tsk tsk.

[@tuesdayjanae3676]

@@jessie-ambre7730I want that too but it’s not that easy because of contracts and the fact that hybe “owns” the name NewJeans. They have to change the group name idk 🤷🏾‍♀️ and everything else that they’re contracts say.

[@Michaela-v5i]

So proud of newjeans for speaking up, Stay strong girls! We'll always be here to support yall😢❤❤

[@lynneloud8565]

💔💔

[@imabratlol7967]

Can you guys just d word with newjeans it's literally harming other groups. Their live timing was very calculative after the illit cb announcement, lsfm vmas performance and BTS greatest popstar announcement. The desperation and jealousy of those girls are showing

[@entertainmentplaza5927]

They are deceived into thinking they have the power to demand anything especially restoring mhj. This makes me believe that these girls and their parents are under a spell set by mhj and her shaman because I don't think any parent in their right mind will support someone who insulted, their children the degree mhj did. She doesn't even acknowledge their talents and she's now using them as pawns I pity them and the parents who support them.

[@MehuAbigaelleCoralie]

As a MY and a BLINK i'll Always protect you NJ. I feel so sad for them but i'm also afraid for their future career Good Luck Newjeans ❤

[@Jyot.23]

Do you realised we stan the same groups and literally most hated girlgroups too😭

[@Tradie_2.2]

Same

[@jijialove]

so brave, and im proud.

[@CarlyMarsh-g9f]

Wow… Minji is so well spoken. So proud of them for speaking up

[@voltz8945]

Power move from new jeans to do this. These girls are strong and I know they have what it takes to go through this hurdle.

[@animegirl0001]

I understand their concern. This is a first time anything like this has happened. But them bashing HYBE and glorifying mhj is a little weird. I get it, she's made the group. Worked on them. Made them great so they're grateful. Yes, I get that. HYBE is wrong in whatever they're doing. Yes. But so is mhj. I appreciate the girls for standi up for themselves. That's very brave. But them portraying mhj as an angel is where I draw the line.

[@_lovingenhypen]

i'm so proud of newjeans for not staying silent like a lot of idols do when conflict occurs i hope hybe stops treating these sweet girls like crap.

[@deanmarkie6282]

This takes guts. Feeling so much love for you. Stay strong.

[@pulwilwi]

Let us give courage

[@Engeneforever-l7k]

Thank you for not hiding it and having courage to stand up and actually announce this! HYBE YOU BETTER TREAT THEM NICELY OTHERWISE US FANS WONT BE HAPPY! NEWJEANS DONT BE BLUE 🩵🩵🩵🩵🩵 Be safe NewJeans ❤ Take care ❤

[@MrGadiriz]

The main issue is MHJ. She’s just an employee of HYBE! How can she expect Adore to operate without HYBE's involvement when HYBE is the company that built and supports Adore? MHJ was under investigation, yet she held a press conference and tried to go against HYBE! How can HYBE remain silent when someone like MHJ is acting out of line and holding a press conference, even mentioning other idols in HYBE by name? Yet, she gets upset when other agencies interfere with NewJeans members. HYBE demoted MHJ, and then she told the media that the situation was making the members sad and that they even messaged her to comfort her. How manipulative is that? Using NewJeans to get attention from the public. Now it’s NewJeans’ turn to speak up. WOW! It’s all very similar. I feel sorry for these young girls; they’re still too young and are acting out of loyalty and love for their CEO. They don’t understand how the real business world works-there are costs, agreements, contracts, and penalties for those who break them. Acting as if they don’t want to be controlled and want to run things on their own? Then start your own company. It’s only been two weeks since MHJ was no longer the CEO, and they’re already resisting this much? Even threatening HYBE the company where they carry out all their activities, which made them who they are? That’s just crazy. Whether an employee or an artist, everyone is an employee. Yes, sometimes companies make wrong decisions, but to rebel like this is extremely bold. Who in the world bites the hand that feeds them? What’s more brutal is that their point seems to be solely to reinstate MHJ as CEO. Isn’t that strange? This isn’t the first time they’ve mentioned this; even at award ceremonies, they emphasized their love for their CEO. Isn’t that weird? MHJ must be behind this, manipulating these young girls' sincerity. MHJ is the one responsible! How dare she use these young girls to the point where they speak out like this. Shouldn’t she be the one calming them down?

[@savage_corn]

People are saying they are brave but this is not good for them.

[@milliemagicwonder]

true, I dont understand, many ppl seem to not get how big businesses and korean music industry work

[@savage_corn]

@@milliemagicwonder so true and you can't clap from one hand.it's both MHJ and hybe 50-50 fault.

[@Musicgeek97]

Exactly this wasn't brave, this was plain stupidity. They should have stayed out of the legal war between hybe and mhj. Both sides are not that great but they are employed by hybe. Speaking against them won't do them any good. By actively supporting mhj who has brought massive hate trains to other hybe groups they are only isolating themselves from other hybe groups and staff. I won't be surprised if hybe sends them on a long hiatus I mean who wants to deal with this mess.

[@Musicgeek97]

@@joelee3716 even if they are happy with mhj as fans how can anyone want them to be emotionally manipulated and groomed by her. The best thing for nj is to cut ties with both hybe and mhj, but they will probably go with mhj. I don't know if they are ignorant to what mhj has done or if they simply don't care . Either way it's disheartening.

[@Musicgeek97]

@@joelee3716 my mother is not a criminal and doesn't have legal cases against her. Even if I love my mother if she was legally in the wrong I wouldn't support her. I'm not saying they should hate her but this level of support for her is weird. Either you can't recognise right from wrong or you just don't care as a human being that what she's doing is wrong(which makes nj selfish) either way it's not looking good. In one case they are immature and doesn't have the sense to recognise what's actually going on and in the other case they only care about themselves.

[@colin2926]

New Jeans were nominated for a VMA award. It will be interesting to see how they do without a big company like Hybe backing them.

[@benhillario3828]

this brave little girls just stand up for their rights to be protected, they feel safe with the former CEO because she will FIGHT for them. i still can't believe they insult hani like that, the sweetest amongst the sweetest. if twice, red velvet, blackpink seeing this live, we all know they will sided with newjeans because this kind public statement has never happened before in k-pop and no other groups as brave as this young girls who's stand up against the giant like HYBE with their little note on the desk risking their future to make this statement

[@HibiscusJelly]

Honestly I don’t expect any idols to support them. This industry is way too conformist and the show off about being boss bitches is only limited to the lyrics written by someone else. It would be a pleasant surprise if they support these girls though.

[@Su.Wiss_810op]

I have a hope that there are idols who will support them​@@HibiscusJelly

[@chuforeichi]

No way. Even Blackpink was dungeoned for a year. You don't hear them publicly complaining.

[@SCRROP]

​@@chuforeichi this isn't complaining this is them coming out about their mistreatment and how this situation has affected and how they truly feel about it

[@aerineu]

@@SCRROPsucks that they were groomed by minhee but 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@CRAZYBUNNYalice]

Some people dont juz understand.....They are saying "OMG HOW COULD NJ DO THIS VIDEO THEIR CAREER COULD BE OVER" whether they do this video or not HYBE is already planning to end their career like how just after new ceo came up in ADOR NJ's previous video production team was disband and all so it would be better if they stand for theirselves like this I M PROUD OF YOU NEW JEANS!!! BUNNIES FOREVER

[@ernestolin8804]

Your boss used to hold a press conference to humiliate other artists in the company, and now their manager just ignores you... Be thankful that people don't insult you directly

[@djunlee5588]

I'm sick of delusional hype stans.HYBE IS THE ONE THAT STARTS THIS CIRCUS AND JEOPARDIZE NEWJEANS AND MHJ.

[@Lainelainehere]

@@djunlee5588 I wonder how much money Hybe is paying to these delulus 🙄HYBE IS THE ONE WHO STARTED ALL THESE MESS

[@wooygif]

@@djunlee5588 min heejin is the one who dragged newjeans into a fight that they didn't belong in in the first place. stop being blind and accept the fact that both hybe AND min heejin are both horrible and in the wrong

[@miniha5541]

Always support NewJeans from America ❤❤❤❤❤

[@Shadows_fall]

Being under contract doing this was very brave and bold for NewJeans. Standing up for what they believe in takes courage. The date they gave for results really speaks volumes. I'm so proud of them and love them more as a fan could. NewJeans has helped me through some dark times with there later songs after debut. They deserve better as others do but this is about NewJeans. Whatever happens now is in the air. Again i am very proud of them not just a fan but as a human. Much respect to them. Sorry for my rant.

[@Grace-yq8ce]

People who say this is new fifty fifty This can’t be. Hybe illegally published their trainne videos doing heel choreo and also published their health documents without their consent. They purposely made bad reports about nwjns..if the company is not protecting the artists, nwjns has right to stand up.

[@FeelTehPOWA]

what baffles me it its not just the company not protecting them... its defaming them and hurting and neglecting on purpose WHILE at the same time claiming to be victims and them (nwjs and mhj) as the crazy unethical ones. Its sad af hybe worked hard against them...

[@heidhymarbangun2498]

As you grow older, you will come to realize that there is no one in this world that is irreplaceable. It is a shame that you do not believe in your God given talent and solely rely on this one person. Start believing in yourselves and stop relying and giving 100% credit to this one person for your hard work. In the real world, one can only succeed if you can adapt to change - for nothing is constant in this world.

[@pulwilwi]

It may seem like they are relying too much on Min Hee Jin. They are still young girls. As you said, they may need to learn how to adapt to change.

[@summer-plumeria]

The translation is difficult to understand. The grammar is wonky but I get it thanks

[@thisisntallowed9560]

We must support NewJeans. It's the only power we have. This act of courage must be rewarded

[@pulwilwi]

We don't know exactly what's going on, but their courage will change a lot of things.

[@M-hm7dy]

From the beginning, MHJ and NewJeans distanced themselves from other artists and staff at Hybe, and collaborating with Aespa to provoke others wasn’t the smartest move. Their fans’ behavior, including harassing other groups, has only worsened the situation, making it understandable why other groups are keeping their distance. This seems like part of MHJ’s plan to exit Hybe without facing any penalties. Her marketing team is working tirelessly to justify her actions, and it’s clear how manipulative MHJ is, using the members solely for her own benefit.

[@김지현-e1g3j]

Where did you find those words to yap bulls**t

[@M-hm7dy]

@@김지현-e1g3j I have been closely following MHJ’s case from the very beginning, reviewing all available articles and testimonies.

[@jiminsukuna]

​@@김지현-e1g3j lol you're probably not an army

[@djunlee5588]

Another delusional army get a life

[@agust-dbae6495]

​@@djunlee5588he/ she's not an ARMY for sure

[@pengbingyan5113]

Tbh I’m not a fan of NJ. But I’m really supporting them for this!!! They really deserve a lot better. No other idols would ever go against their company especially if the company is as powerful as hybe. I’m sure NJ is aware of the consequences and they had thought a lot about it too. People can think they’re ruining their careers. They’re not entirely wrong, but this will go down the history for sure. I’m hoping the best for them.

[@JanDigital-tx3vk]

Couldn't agree more.

[@ryujinilla5622]

Highly agree on this

[@ruchisingh1747]

OMG that's so unkorean thing to do . These girls are so brave and calculative and smart . I hope other fandoms can interfere and save and support this group .

[@MC-xt6xf]

Remember, there are two hot-blooded Australians involved!

[@Arkv-o1n]

Minheejin is not even right in the first place

[@softeuph3974]

Calculative to what? Getting disbanded? Getting manipulated by MHJ???

[@xxLilly05xx]

Ador is not a regular Kpop company. It's teeny tiny company and it doesn't run like the mega companies like the big 3. Min Heejin personally hand-picked each one of these girls and had personal relationships with them & friendships with them. She trained them herself. And allowed them to have artistic opinions in the work of their comebacks. They had creative freedoms and abilities to make decisions and voice their opinions on the concepts of their music. That is why their concept felt so fresh and innovative. It's because it felt like you were looking at life through the lens of these five teenage girls. All of that was reflected in their song lyrics, dances, fashion sense & their MVs. That is WHY we all loved NewJeans, there's something sincere and genuine about them. And all of that was possible because of Min Heejin. Now Hybe wants to overstep on their power and run these girls like a standard Kpop company. Where they just have to shut up and take whatever the company writes up for them. And it's extremely difficult for these girls to accep that because they're NOT used to being managed that way. Also, it takes away from what makes NewJeans special in the first place!!! That's why they're saying that they want Ador to be reinstated in the way that it was before

[@injeolmi2675]

that chairman bang has too much of ego problem he can’t stand a group which doesn’t thank him on award shows

[@yudhasetiawan1220]

​@@injeolmi2675 Since its debut, New Jeans has never thanked the label...they are naive kids, they think the entertainment industry is like a kindergarten that will always give them happiness whenever they think about it?

[@sidrabhai60]

Bruh, Mhj is not a sane person. The way you described mhj being so good to nwjns sounds like mhj is an angel and the only villian here is HYBE. HYBE did what needed to be done with mhj due to her own problems, there's no involvement of nwjns by hybe. Who did involved them in this mess was their own ceo mhj. If you support a problematic person, it will obv make you seem problematic too, simple. If they had simply highlighted their mistreatment at HYBE without asking for MHJ to return as CEO, the situation might not have taken such a negative turn as it is now.

[@danny8747]

yea and this ceo has is being sued for mulitple things some of them being covering up SA and workplace bullying be fr guys. she staged a coup against hybe. thats ILLEGAL and thats why she got sued 💀💀also why she cant be their ceo again

[@february8573]

SAME THOUGHTS.

[@welcometodoritos]

I'm just so worried for them. Hearing hanni's testimony just made me wonder how much the girls must have been suffering. I just hope everything come back to normal like they wish. As a bunnie, I'll be always supporting them. 뉴진스 멤버들 모두 화이팅하고요, 버니즈들은 항상 응원할 거라고 절대로 잊지 마세요~

[@taekooksugaminpakistan4411]

i'm afraid the girls were probably spoon fed wrong information and that's literally all they know. they don't read their own news and don't seek out their own information because there were glaring issues in what they say. "mhj produces our music" no she does not, mhj has never written a song in her life, let alone produced one. "we own the copyright to our mv" no you do not, the copyright owners is hybe and ador. "new ador did not listen to our demands" the demand in question is to bring mhj back as ceo, the person even the court said was trying to harm hybe. use common sense as to why that demand was not met, girls. "they spread bad news about us before our cb" no they spread articles about mhj, your old boss who is not a member of your group. she is just a random lady. "a manager told someone to ignore us and new management told us there is no proof and its too late so we think they won't protect us" as opposed to mhj? what will mhj do? go on a press conference to air out the manager and the group? is that what they want? also someone not saying hi is again the base of their mistreatment. "creative management worked together perfectly and fine the old way" no it did not, as what the dolphin guy showed, he was given flimsy okays verbally but never in contract form. mhj herself said she was not good at business and just wanted to do the art part. "now we are not allowed to not work with our director" no. he literally said in his statement thathe refuses to work with new ador again and then he burned that bridge on his own because new ador told him to take down a mv that did not agree with an advertiser. "we found out that mhj had been removed through media" and isn't that mhj's fault too? because she had been notified of the meeting days prior and she approved the meeting. she could have called them right after it happened but she didn't. which is hard to believe after they said mhj called them in the middle of the night to cry about all of this when it first started. did she lose their number suddenly? "i hope you will stop harassing ceo min" they do not know the prime reason she is being removed, she was trying to directly harm hybe. any company, not just hybe, any company would remove someone who is trying to harm the company. "we just wanted to make music, what did we do wrong?" once again, they think mhj being taken out is an attack to them, that it's hybe wanting to punish the girls. they did not fire mhj to make them sad, they fired her because she was caught trying to steal from ador and meeting with investors. like they still don't know the prime reason why it started and it was mhj. no one is on their side. their parents, mhj, the old ador staff, their fans, all of them failed those girls and its so unnerving to watch it unfold

[@Akanksha_Pisal]

@@taekooksugaminpakistan4411 exactly I don't understand how people in the comments still want mhj to work with nj. Like, NO . That lady has manipulated the girls wayy too much. It's not like mhj is fired she's still working with them. But the fact they're asking to bring her back to the previous position is concerning and that too within a timeline??? And what are they gonna do if the timeline isn't met??

[@NewjeansCupcake]

she literally produced all songs on V's layover album go check the credits at the end of his MV's

[@Meowlouder-g8n]

뉴진스 비하인드 안 보냐 민희진이 모든걸 하나하나 다 디렉팅했는데? 뉴진스에 관심도 없는 니가 뭘 알아

[@Meowlouder-g8n]

@@Akanksha_Pisal뉴진스보다 너가 더 내부 사정 잘알면 너가 어도어 취직하면 될 듯! 👍👍

[@lingth]

The fact they criticize the new CEO, I feel they will be in trouble.. I doubt ADOR will disband and terminate their contracts as doing so will actually set them free. It is more likely they will be held in place with their contracts but not given a comeback. The prev comeback is with the former CEO. I suspect ADOR is probably preparing a new girl group to debut ...one that is not under CEO Min..And if it's true then all resources will be channeled to the new girl group instead of NJ.

[@Gabriella-iq5he]

It’s crazy cuz NewJeans doesn’t even realize that the person who did this to them is literally the person they love and admire, MHJ. Like yes, Hybe should’ve treated them better but it’s concerning that they don’t give a single ounce of blame to her.

[@wxyzai]

ikr what did they expect after all… as well as they ignored their new CEO too when they called MHJ their only CEO on stage :)) nj seem to be truly blind. I don’t even feel sorry for them anymore. it makes me mad how silly & brainwashed these girls are.

[@wxyzai]

ikr what did they expect after all… as well as they ignored their new CEO too when they called MHJ their only CEO on stage :)) nj seem to be truly blind. I don’t even feel sorry for them anymore. it makes me mad how silly & brainwashed these girls are.

[@Yanny999]

LOL u think they are dumb? MHJ controversy is filled with lies and misinformation and propaganda. Ofc there is truth to numerous matters about her, but HYBE is definitely to blame for a lot more than MHJ when it comes to Newjeans and they in a more technical sense are correct in the sense that credit should be given to her for NJ success

[@jiminsukuna]

​@@Yanny999 that doesn't change the fact that without hybe new jeans will be nothing and without BTS hybe is nothing too Since their mommy leaked their personal information and brought terrible hatred to BTS and other groups. It is impossible for her to come back, and yet They ignored all their ceo's actions and selfishly wanted to get her back to her high position with honor and respect? Lol in their dreams after this stupid act of theirs they will most likely rot in the Hybe basement until their contract with Hybe ends.

[@Yanny999]

@@jiminsukuna LOL with BTS I agree, but Nejeans??! You’ve got to be kidding me 🤣 Hybe can easily afford to lose newjeans and will not experience the same loss as they would with bts, don’t be ridiculous

[@yudhasetiawan1220]

There will be 2 possibilities that will be experienced by new jeans. 1: they will be fined by contract, 2: they will be kept by hybe until their contract expires

[@milliemagicwonder]

number 2, more specifically, until hybe has completely exploited them

[@carlandreibalanquit2040]

if they really decided to do this on their own why wait for someone before they start?why keep looking behind the camera if you really speak with your mind on your own?seems like someone's teaching theam what to say.poor girls.Don't bite the hands that feeds you.

[@Akanksha_Pisal]

Okay so from what I've read in the comments it says they were waiting for more people to join the live. But yeah I mean they keep looking behind the camera I thought I was the only one who noticed that / thought it's weird. Also mhj is still the part of the company it's not that they've fired her she still works with them. This video could've been just about the mistreatment they get ... But they talked about how great mhj is and how they want her back as their ceo 🥲 I think that's not good to say.

[@jourdynsmith1606]

they said they had their directors help to set it up.

[@audreyibojos632]

I look up to New Jeans so much especially for bravely speaking up. Im sure they are not the first one to experience such maltreatment from the entertainment industry they belong to. I hope they inspire more and more talent to do the same and fight for their rights so that depression and scuicide cases get alleviated in their country. WE STAND WITH NJ until the end of time❤

[@mlungan7717]

@@audreyibojos632 speaking up stupidly defending someone who ia cunning liar & a cheater is nothing to be proud of! Its theirs & their parents greed leading them to this!! No sorry! If hybe is that bad, BTS & other groups wouldnt have lasted this long! Think about it!!!

[@kaiuno7727]

It was so disappointing that even their own parents allowed them to do this. We want to protect you girls, we really do. But let us not forget that HYBE owns 80% of ADOR. They only want HER out, and she drags lots of group names on this issue. I was rooting for another comeback since the company has plans for you but now this... don't know anymore

[@hahahehe8915]

?? You’re mad they spoke out??? They’re scared. They want help. They literally expressed the fact they don’t feel safe in their current work environment and feel like no one will protect them. MHJ inflicted this pain on them indirectly but in the end if they only feel safe with her they shouldn’t have to suffer in silence. I mean they’re obviously desperate. They wouldn’t have gone live if they weren’t. They know their time as NewJeans may be coming to an end. They’ve got nothing to lose at this point..

[@Zainabhussainii]

Wtf??? You want ppl to tolerate mistreatment! They chose themselves and their dignity over anything, and im so proud of them for doing that, they even paved the way for other idols to speak out

[@mossball07]

It's not disappointing, they're voicing their concerns in a state where they truly believe there is no leadership to help or care for them. Just because they think MHJ is correct doesn't mean we give up supporting the girls, they're naive and are missing out tons of information regarding who has done what, you realize that right?

[@Sme-q6s]

There is a a thin line between bravery and stupidity . They ended their careers for minheejin, as if she is their mom. And mind u all min heejin was only fired from the ceo position, but she could still be the creative head and be with girls , protect them and participate in their music, nut she chose her pride and left the girls hanging. Now they are fighting with everything they have to bring her back! This is actually a dumb move it is definitely gonna cost them their careers and they know it, it even shows on their faces. This is what happens when you put kids in charge. Its actually sad to see then do this to themselves for someone like min heejin who left them behind. And about the mistreatment what is the guarantee everything is gonna stopbwhen superwomen min heejin comes back to protect them, mistreatment is sometimes many idols have gone through they just become strong and carry on for the love of their fans. But unfortunately njs are also like min heejin and chose their pride over career , each other and their fans

[@gwen_guinevere]

aint reading allat yap WE STAND WITH NEWJEANS ❤️✨

[@Sme-q6s]

@@gwen_guinevere I am not an illit Stan and I love new jeans as much as u do. I just don't support them ruining what they built for that minheejin who doesn't gaf

[@onlydbrasko]

"Ended their career" is not that easy for a successful artist in the age of social media. The girls' stream has put the spotlight on Hybe and every negative move Hybe makes of NJ they're the ones who look bad. It's a brilliant move for the girls to gain their protection as collateral damage.

[@seemats3493]

​@@onlydbraskotheir new comeback already flopped. They are out of top 30 kpop brand reputation ranking which released every month. Their new song didn't debut in hot 100 also. We have seen how many grp which were in peak of success lost their popularity by small incidents. The life is not same everyday. Anything can happen in this world.

[@onlydbrasko]

@@seemats3493 using brand reputation invalidates your so called opinion. The world knows what they're capable with a good production team.

[@danakimberlygalang6436]

So what they want is to bring back Min Hee Jin in Hybe who (1) publicly shamed hybe and hybe groups in numerous press conferences and (2) dismissed because of covered up sexual harrassment cases. Plus they are being "mistreated" WHILE staying at the 16th floor (this is higher than bighit), living in their penthouse apartment building, and can freely do a live youtube video against their company. Sounds entitled to me yet people are applauding them?

[@Roselinevv__2]

Correct

[@Gveze]

true

[@jiminsukuna]

Finally someone with common sense cuz all these blindfolded supporting without knowing or understanding a thing

[@Roselinevv__2]

@@jiminsukuna cause they just want to make it like only hybe is wrong and then eventually they want to point out other artists of hybe

[@agust-dbae6495]

True

[@MiMi-ui2yg]

this is so sad that MHJ is using these poor girls to deliver her messages... the way they're talking is exactly how she talks and it's so obvious the girls are being forced to say what's being said to them from the hidden earbuds and they're reading a script from the tablets... wish hybe and MHJ would leave these poor girls alone! resolve your toxic adult conflict on your own and protect the girls!

[@gowrisankarimr4284]

I won't blame the manager if his group was Illit.Their Ex- CEO called them copy of Newjeans and Newjeans supported that person after that. I hope someone in Hybe helps these girls,get them in therapy and do the right thing. I hope Newjeans apologizes to Illit and start over anywhere they want.

[@Sarah-tc9yz]

Same MHJ is doing wrong and hybe is being childish Hybe is ruining all their talent. I Hope that all artist under hybe will get therapy

[@Bloom_Jiya]

Finally someone with actual brains in the comment section. The gaslighting by mhj has affected fans too. Even I thought I was insane for thinking exactly like this 😭

[@suhe6]

법원에서 판사가 뉴진스는 차별대우를 받았고, 아일릿에 대한 표절 제기 또한 정당한 사유라고 인정했다. 차별대우와 표절을 당하며 향후 뉴진스에 심각한 피해를 초래할 수 있는 사안을 대표인 민희진이 가만히있었다면 그것이야 말로 계약위반이자 해임사유가 됐다. 결국 법원은 민희진이 해임될 이유가 없다고 판결내렸지만 하이브는 법원 판결까지 무시하며 해임시켰다. 이에 대해 법적 전문가는 향후 민희진이 소송을 하게 된다면 법의 결정까지 무시한 회사가 질 확률이 매우 높다고 말한다. 니가 하이브가 법원 판사도 치료해야한다고 생각하는게 아니길빈다.

[@bbwalk100]

​@suhe6 Your comment is not true.

[@wavefromearth]

I'm supporting Newjeans at all costs, I think kpopers are so hypocritical because these girls are talking about the mistreatment, the fact that HYBE is no longer caring about them, how they are so vulnerable and have no way out ETC., but people are just caring about how they supported MHJ,MHJ and HYBE are manipulating newjeans as if they were just cheap entertainment or some kind of disposable garbage,MHJ is a bad person but you can have sure that she were the only one that really cared about Newjeans and that protect them,i honestly understand.

[@itsgivingcher]

yeah.. this comment should be pinned. i hate when ppl keep bringing nwjns for defending mhj and ignore all the mistreatments that hybe did to them

[@aerineu]

@@itsgivingcherminheejin spoke sht about them r u stable??

[@aerineu]

they drove themselves into a deep pit because of this, minheejin ruined them

[@Warisha224]

@@aerineuthey stood up for themselves, are you blaming them for doing what they should? Are you blaming them for standing up for themselves? Have you lost your moral compass or what? You would rather support a company instead of the Arists who protested…Disgusting rat

[@ros3s_4u]

@@aerineuExactly. Would somebody who supposedly cared for you call you a b*tch behind your back. HYBE nor MHJ are innocent.

[@pratikpalchowdhury2454]

Honestly both MHJ and Hybe are bad. Two things can be bad at once and these girls don't seem to realize that. MHJ sold their personal info, singlehandedly created a hate train towards BTS and Gfriend and lesserafim, accused Hybe of culty rituals AND has those weird pictures of REAL little girls in her studio. She very much deserved to be fired. And NJs have been supporting her ever since this thing started so it's very natural for that manager to tell their group to ignore Hanni because she is essentially supporting someone who is selling their company out. NJs aren't full on kids, Minji and Hanni are both 20 so they have to know what's wrong and what's right atleast a little bit. They aren't fully at fault though because MHJ probably groomed them before their debut and hence this huge amount of trust in her but it's very stupid to go against a MNC like this. This is career suicide.

[@tranlenamphuong6192]

She didn't say that tho? It's HYBE doing media play

[@glennbarrow8325]

i noticed that most of their bashers are bts fans

[@johnhlee6846]

Hybe has been spreading lies against Min via it's massive KZbin and social media propaganda machines and their news media connections without any proof. Most turned out to be lies. But I-netz fell for them as usual. But the lies can't last long.

[@pratikpalchowdhury2454]

@@glennbarrow8325 i ain't even a bts fan anymore, and even if i was my point would still stand

[@vanesalusaria7860]

@@glennbarrow8325facts are facts regardless of who says it

[@cryovernanami]

i can't describe how much i'm proud of those girls !!

[@Izzy_Gtz]

I feel for you girls, and I applaud you for speaking out, you're very brave. It should be a symbiotic collaboration among company, staff and artist and not just companies using you as disposable material. You are the only voice to speak for yourselves, stay together stay strong. FIGHTING!!! 👏💪

[@미-m6x]

so proud of you guys! talented brave girls 💖

[@euzinaningombam576]

So proud of my girls ❤

[@lynneloud8565]

💔

[@Starfruit074]

They are fighting to have their own autonomy as not only artists but as humans. I do not care if they disband. I will support them in their future endeavors no matter what!

[@Yuuuk_1]

They are so strong and brave, I love them so much, I really hope they aren't going through such a hard time :( ❤

[@BigDaddyMacc]

Im happy they speaking out! MHJ NJ BUNNIES FIGHTING!

[@sasha6367]

The problem is MHJ who in the end made newjeans felt left on, everyone in HYBE distanced themselves from MHJ (of course NJ) because she is indeed problematic

[@정성문-j8p]

한심한 일이고 이렇게 어린 뉴진스가 말을 할수 있다는것은 총체적인 사람이 무엇을 어떻게 컨트롤 하는지 삼척 동자도 잘알것이다 그저 돈과 명에를 쟁취하기 위해서 한심한 잣대를 보여주고 있는 그누군가는 각성해야 할것이다 모든 틀에 비추어 나의것을 만들기 위한 술수는 이제 멈춰야 될것이다 사람이 배부르면 그것을 망각한다 왜냐면 더먹기 위해 갖은 술수를 부리는데 희사하는 봉사의 정신이 없는 하이브의 경영진은 각성을 해야 정신을 차릴까! 배고프고 모자랐던때를 잊고서 배부른 돼지가 되여가니 한심하기 그지없다 초심를 잃어버린 지금의 자태는 만인이 다알고 있으니 뉴진스를 괴롭히는 행동은 이제그만 그들에게 꿈과 희망과 바램을 주기바란다 무엇이 오른지를 모르면 그것은 빈깡통의 머리가 아닐수 없다

[@Mayy_N4ki]

This is brave of them to talk about this I hope the company and people listen !

[@uarim-13]

Ok I'm not a fan of new jeans nor I hate them and I really do appreciate their talent. It so brave of them to come live to speak up their own rights but I don't think they are seeing the reality of the situation. MHJ committed wrongs and now she is being punished for those wrongs. I think MHJ manipulated them cause they should also think about other groups that were insulted by MHJ and how can they never think MHJ was also wrong. As an artist adaptability is important they should atleast give a try to adapt. They shouldn't have request to bring back MHJ .

[@Lachocholatte23]

There's no way there's no one behind them, I think they're still innocent and don't have the courage to do this. Isn't it a bit strange for them to appear like this? Someone told them to do it

[@HINOK8]

Indeed 💯

[@strwbkook]

they might've just came live on their own without anyone's permission or order

[@okakaaa96]

Ain't no way their parents are not involved and their parents are also with mhj so.

[@Jyot.23]

Y'all act like these girls are toddlers . And it ain't very Hard to believe that they are more courageous than other kpop artist who even hide/ apologise for pity things as relationship/smoking and all

[@kate-hx5he]

If they are not happy with Hybe, pay the penalties and leave the company.

[@voltz8945]

it ain't that easy is it? all their brands are owned by Hybe. They'll have to change their group to something new and everything else

[@onzeenf]

🤮

[@yanjungrass715]

@@voltz8945then why the drama for a woman who put them in this situation and also called them lazy etc

[@hibitsu2436]

Exactly

[@jiminsukuna]

​@@voltz8945 then what did they expect lol😂? They've shouldn't threat their boss And they should've known that hybe is the head not their mommy

[@oownooy_24]

No cause their courage is insane for this. Huge kudos to them ❤

[@MotionFlix101]

This situation puts them in a very difficult situation unfortunately!😢 Music industry is one of the most corrupted and toughest job to be part of and its so sad they had to face such unfair treatment

[@Phrolova_23]

Kpop stans always want idols to speak up yet when Newjeans did it, they are ungrateful and entitled?? Wtf is wrong with those people???

[@ViewportPlaythrough]

yah, i dont get it.. when they see other groups getting mistreated they cry for that group to get treated correctly, but when they finally see a group getting treated fairly they say that that group is being groomed/brainwashed.. like what??? then they say members should be grateful. but grateful to whom are they really saying? should they be thankful to hybe who just tossed them money at the start then treated them like trash, or to mhj who built newjeans with the members right from the start? cause as far as i can see, the members are being very very very grateful to the group of people who has taken care of them, which is mhj and the og newjeans core team. hybe did gave them the initial funding, true. but thats all there is to it. most of the investments and income that newjeans got is because of the members' hard work and mhj + newjeans core team's hardwork. so thank hybe for the initial money, but be loyal to mhj and the og newjeans core team

[@lilabouabbache5241]

Yesss !!! It’s true !! Bravo aux New Jeans 🎉 cette industrie musicale va changer pour le meilleur ! Parler c’est important, et tellement courageux.

[@mpc5584]

wrong timing and circumstance.

[@Christiephua52]

NJ do not have good professional adults to counsel and guide them for overcoming such times of changes. OR they are too brainwashed to closed blocked their mind and paths for Only MHJ as their boss. The more NJ girls trying to fight their Contracted Employer for MHJ, the more mature and intelligent people will not trusts MHJ and will not dare recontract the girls as a group under MHJ moving forward . Such issues are scars and can resurface wherever they go with MHJ lead. It will be a Sad future for them that they are being hopeful in wrong unethical person.😢

[@Snowgulp]

Bruh yall love riding hybe so much it’s crazy

[@djunlee5588]

Brainwashing theory doesn't work honey get better one

[@Lainelainehere]

How much is Hybe paying you? You think HYBE is being professional from the start? Honestly, even though both MHJ and HYBE are bad in certain ways, the girls felt much more security when MHJ was with them. And YOU deululu HYBE fans are villainizing MHJ too much while being blind to HYBE's wrongdoings. And remember, HYBE STARTED ALL THESE MESS FIRST! GET THAT RIGHT!

[@suryaabraham-nn1sr]

Sok tau loe, nyet...

[@sz4368]

The New Jeans は境界線のジレンマに直面しており、停滞するグループになる可能性があります。この困難を乗り越えるために、ネチズンの皆さんが声を上げてサポートしてくれることを願っています。 これは全世界が注目する声です...しかも彼らはまだ16歳です…😢😢😢

[@richardduong2129]

Stand up for your’s rights; I’m so proud of them😊.

[@Dai1lest]

I definitely did not expect them to just pull a live stream like this on a new account. This is how backed in a corner they must have felt as a group and always trying to smile through it, but something broke and here we are... Look I don't mind all this, in fact I love it because they are standing up for themselves and mistreatment and showing everyone just how insane this business is, my only gripe and has always stuck around is just how much MHJs influence on them seems to be, I get it she was there from the start and all of it, but still just doesn't sit right with me personally. I hope for their happiness and them getting back to just making music and seeing them smile and not try to hide behind it because of issues that they should have never been in but unfortunately are.

[@syzygyyyy]

Sadly, NJ has become collateral damage between MHJ's battle with Hybe. It wasn't their fault, it was MHJ who got greedy and practically bit the hand that fed them. I wish they could have distanced themselves from MHJ and taken themselves out of the equation, trusting that their talent and skills could take them much further than MHJ did. Sure, she "made" them, but without Hybe's capital, they wouldn't have this as "easy." I admire their courage, but being loyal to someone who's done the shadiest things to get ahead, will not bode well for their careers. I wish them all the best and I hope they learn a lot from this experience. What a way to grow up and hopefully, mature.

[@charliebitybytes]

Hybe controls the media in south Korea and turned her into a witch. Now you're talking out of your ass sucking up to a multi billion dollar company that has all the resources to ruin anyone they please.

[@liyar1880]

we are forever with you new jeans! Fighting my girls🥺 you are my favourite💞💞

[@cannyruka]

WE MONSTIEZ STAND WITH NEWJEANS ❤

[@bangtan_enha_bonekdo]

The girls may not be comfortable with the new CEO or want their CEO back cause of their good bond with her, understandable. However whatever she did was wrong and cannot be forgiven. Their CEO was wrong but they should not be the one receiving this cold shoulder by others.

[@Yellowaluvu]

they're changing the Kpop industry