Macbeth | Act4 Scene 1 | Line by Line Analysis | Nibblepop

[@shilpakumari4027]

Mam u really deserve praise to be so vivid with ur explanation ...i do watch all ur videos and admire the way u speak which is quite lucid

[@goldenticketcomics3038]

My favorite video of yours, so far! Thank you so much!!!

[@crazyfacts24857]

Well one thing I don't understand since we know that before Lenox and other nobleman talked how they don't trust Macbeth and said they're not in his side Then why Lennox informed Macbeth about macduff's plan That he fled to England to prepare an attack against Macbeth In some way Lennox pushed Macbeth to kill macduff's family by making him angry and more frustrated with macduff So I think why did he do so, when he was not even in Macbeth's side

[@NibblePop]

In Shakespeare, minor characters often show inconsistency. I guess he focused less on these characterizations at times. Good observation though.

[@kushalagarwal7033]

Wow , just wow superb explanation!.

[@suvendumaity9830]

Satti mam professor hisebe apnakai manay...satti mam hat's off ,teaching quality is beyond praise and knowledge is also too too good 👍

[@NibblePop]

I am just doing what I can. Really grateful that I can serve the students because that gives me a real purpose for life

[@DaniaHussain-x1q]

Thanks mam...u made me understand each and every line.. Which hides deep meaning😊

[@oliviadey1849]

Wonderfully explained ma'am. Also I couldn't help but notice that Macbeth said something about one of Banquo's descendants being the ruler of more than one country. Does this mean that Shakespeare wanted to please James I his patron and thus incorporated this little detail because we know James I ruled both Scotland and England, also the fact that he wrote Banquo's character as the noblest because he claimed him to be the king's ancestor?

[@NibblePop]

Absolutely yes. I have mentioned that in one of the videos too if I remember.

[@oliviadey1849]

@@NibblePop okay ma'am thank you. I think I might have missed it 😅my bad

[@nupurbarnwal6438]

I had a confusion... why is Macbeth more restless in killing Macduff and his family when the real fear for him is the crown which is predicted to be taken by Banquo's descendants?

[@gitanjali5775]

Yes he is also threatened by banquo and his descendants as it continues to haunt him between the gap of his own downfall and the whole play Here he feels zero security because he has reached to a point where a Hindi reference (muhavra aage kua piche khai) So he plans to murder em

[@souravpal4974]

wonderful explanation

[@adrijabanerjee4618]

Ma'am what do those apparitions represent? Will you please discuss their significance?

[@NibblePop]

Macbeth's inner fear and in a way fate

[@adrijabanerjee4618]

​@@NibblePop thank you, ma'am.

[@AVRABHATTACHARJYA-xn2kq]

Are the apparitions real or hallucinations like that of dagger and Banquo's ghost?

[@rekhasharma6038]

thank u mam 🙏

[@gitanjali5775]

Hello ma'am Pls guide us what projections of insights to takeaway from macbeth act four scene one

[@PrinceMishra-hw7ud]

Mam i have doubt 25:40 . Why does lennox gave information about Macduff that he fled to England. Its mean that Lennox in previous scene act 3 scene 6 , getting information about Macduff so that he could informed to Macbeth. My question is that Lennox is spy of macbeth??

[@NibblePop]

@@PrinceMishra-hw7ud it is very obvious. Spying was part of Macbeth's plan all along

[@PrinceMishra-hw7ud]

@@NibblePop Thank you mam and wishing you Happy Teacher`s Day😇🥳

[@remyat4456]

Class is beyond words.👌👌👌👌👌👌after completing Macbeth can you do School for scandal?

[@NibblePop]

Will try. Thanks for the suggestion.

[@subirbiswas3613]

Westbengal state university Te Mam 1st and 2nd semister kon Month aa hoi. Aktu bolben. Please 🙏 replay me.

[@NibblePop]

Usually 1st sem is around end of dec to middle of jan and second sem is around May/june. But in pandemic there is no fixed schedule. Depends on circumstances.

[@mahboobali4110]

Mam you said that you will talk that these appartions àre relatble to macbeth thiñkiñg but didnot tell àt last

[@NibblePop]

Macbeth was already suspicious about Macduff. So the apparition was just an external projection of his inner fear. He felt that Dunsinane castle was safe but he feared retribution of nature.

[@smitarahaman8430]

Mam,my result of 1st semester has been published.According to SGPA, my grade is 7.30 I can't understand what will be the accurate percentage. That's why i can't certainly say is the result good or bad or medium ! Can you help me ?

[@NibblePop]

which university? it should be 65.5%

[@smitarahaman8430]

@@NibblePop KU

[@NibblePop]

@@smitarahaman8430 you seem to have a pretty good result. But that again depends on batch result.

[@smitarahaman8430]

@@NibblePop Obviously mam, but I would like to say that I had written self made notes mostly. I don't have any regret for that. I think I don't need to look at those points who had utilized the opportunity of online exam. Mam, please don't misjudge me by my apparently seemed harsh words as I don't have any intention of showing off, I am just stating the truth at all.

[@NibblePop]

@@smitarahaman8430 One thing I have realized over time Smita. Exam marks does not matter so much. What matters at the end is your grasp of subject and ORIGINALITY. And I have seen that you have amazing analytical skill. You will achieve a lot in life if you be yourself. But I am also happy that you have scored well.

[@biprasarkar6757]

Madam whatever the witches predicts , it proves to be true . from this point of view , it seems that everything has been predetermined . but since it's a renaissance play it shouldn't be . so madam i am confused about it that while narrating the significance of the predictions of witches , what shall be the essence of my answer ? ( I can understand madam that it's Macbeth 's own free will to listen the witches but I am confused due to the accomplishment of their(witches) prediction )

[@NibblePop]

The play is not about how the predictions come true, it is about how Macbeth gets himself involved in the fulfilment of the prophecy. Even within the predeterministic frame, there is the question of man's free will to be an active executioner of this predetermined action.

[@biprasarkar6757]

@@NibblePop thanks madam . I have got it madam . It's like Oedipus Rex . where the fulfilment of oracle isn't important but how Oedipus finds out the mystery of his parentage and faces his downfall , that's important . thanks madam.

[@jyotisingh-bv2qm]

Mam i have a doubt - the witches prophecised that banqua will be the father of kings but in the end of the play we see that malcolm becomes the king then how the prophecy will be true

[@NibblePop]

But they did not say that Banquo's son will be king of Scotland😀

[@jyotisingh-bv2qm]

@@NibblePop yes mam thanku very much 🙏🙏🙏🙏 for clearing my doubt

[@areebakhan12879]

😊