Macbeth | Act3 Scene 1 | Line by Line Analysis | Nibblepop

[@anushkadutta8204]

2:27 starts here

[@kabir6335]

Its really interesting too see that... Macbeth says that Banquo will go to heaven which also implies of him saying indirectly that "I will kill the Noble to Rule this hell" and that he is going to hell forsure... ( ofc not realising it) Lesson: Our limbic thoughts may sometimes make us create unfortunate situations for ourselves, that maybe completely opposite of what we want. (here) Macbeth wants Power and wealth in his posterity i.e. he is wanting to create a heaven for his prodigy... But ends up doing something completely opposite of that.

[@dikshitakumari6499]

I really like your teaching style

[@shriyasrivastava6443]

This is really helpful 😊 I really appreciate this 😊👍 explanation is fabulous 👍. Thank you ❤️

[@syedarshedmoosvi6898]

Thanks for the lecture

[@sandhyak4252]

Really helpful.. Thank you Maam🙏🙏

[@GodOp-hf4cp]

Thanks alot ma'am....pls keep helping us this way ❤

[@winnerkullu3673]

Mam please make next video on Act3 scene2, I am eagerly waiting for your next lecture.

[@ErenYeager-ig5oc]

Best explanation ever heard in youtube

[@abhishekgupta7769]

Madam, do macbeth wanted his own sons to be the king or he wanted to kill fleance becoz he feared him and wanted to remain as king?

[@smitarahaman8430]

Yes mam, this is my query too....

[@najimuddinislam9]

Macbeth had no sons, children in fact.

[@ridikaamantithi1841]

Macbeth didn’t have any sons...or children

[@sohiniroy435]

Amazing explanation ❤

[@sandhyatiwary3249]

Mam, What is the changes seen in the relationship of Macbeth and lady Macbeth from Act 2 to Act 3

[@arpitapal1436]

Thank you so much 🙏

[@smitarahaman8430]

Mam, in 28:32, we can see on the screen that Macbeth is now so determined that he does not need any witches or lady M. Will we consider Lady M. as a witch for her evil thoughts because we see her name in very next to the witches ?

[@NibblePop]

Have the witches suffered like her? If not then perhaps she is not comparable to the witches.

[@smitarahaman8430]

@@NibblePop Not clear mam. Will you please explain it again ?

[@NibblePop]

@@smitarahaman8430 the witches were evil because it excited them to cause mayhem. Lady Macbeth was not evil for the sake of it but for her husband. It was ambition and not love for crime that made her do what she did. So no, she was not the fourth witch. Then she would not have turned mad at the end. You will get my point after you finish watching the video on the sleepwalking scene. I have specifically talked about fourth witch question there.

[@smitarahaman8430]

@@NibblePop Ok mam.

[@elichakma3126]

Just leaving a thought:--As Macbeth believed in the prophecy of three witches then how come he thought killing banquo will prevent fulfilling the prophecy that was made for him(Bnqo). It's kinda stupid of him that prophecy could work only on him but not the others .

[@NibblePop]

Stupid indeed, and that is exactly what he realises at the end

[@elichakma3126]

@@NibblePop thank you ma'am 😊❤️

[@sabahat_5575]

thanks for lecture

[@techiamazon]

maam raat ko padh raha tha introduction dara diya🥲

[@NibblePop]

😈

[@HansaShekhawat2211]

Thanks mam...😊😊😊

[@shaheengulzar4316]

Ma'am plz can you describe " MACBETH AS A TRAGIC HERO"...... plzzzzzz ma'am plzzzzz🙏🙏🙏

[@suzumehiye]

Thank you mam

[@smitarahaman8430]

Mam we see the prophecies on Macbeth to be fulfilled perfectly...but at the end of the play we will see Malcolm to be the king of Scotland, prophecies about Banquo along with his son would remain unfulfilled. Has Shakespeare put the referance of the prophecy about Banquo in this play to give his play a proper, complete form of tragedy ? As the witches would not prophesies Banquo's son would be the next king after him, Macbeth would not think of doing another crime, his downfall would not be completed. Right ??

[@NibblePop]

Did the witches specify that Banquo's son will be king of Scotland? Nopes. Macbeth assumed so and brought about his downfall

[@smitarahaman8430]

@@NibblePop Isn't it ? So what the witches prophesied about Banquo ? Is not that not he but his successor would be the next king after Macbeth ? That is why the witches stated equivocally "Lesser than Macbeth but greater Not so happy but much happier."

[@smitarahaman8430]

Isn't it mam ???

[@NibblePop]

@@smitarahaman8430 nopes. They said Banquo will be father to a line of kings. Nothing mentioned about succeeding Macbeth or being king of Scotland

[@smitarahaman8430]

@@NibblePop okay, yet had the prophecies about Banquo that he will be the father to a line of kings been fulfilled at last ?

[@suzumehiye]

Madam . What reason does Macbeth give to the murderer to kill banquo

[@NibblePop]

He aays that Banquo had cheated the man out of his property and hence he should take revenge

[@anishasultana2698]

Ma'am, is there any mention of Macbeth's son in Hollinshed's Chronicles? Did he has any son or not? bcoz in Shakespeare's "Macbeth", there is no mention about that..

[@trishaghosh2817]

Ma'am the scene is really very difficult but over all I understand it,in this scene we see the other side of Macbeth's character, for that I'm confused about the character

[@NibblePop]

Shakespeare's central characters are never one-dimensional. They have multiple shades which make them realistic and human. Macbeth also shows multiple shades. His conflict is basically the conflict of these shades. He had felt guilt, killing Duncan, because of his inherent goodness. But, over time, that voice of conscience will be getting more feeble and he will choose evil path over good.

[@trishaghosh2817]

@@NibblePop Thank you Ma'am I understand this properly

[@suzumehiye]

Madam please solve this question

[@snehamallick8787]

Mam pls can u give question answer.. Mam it will be really helpful for my board xm

[@shehzadibano1549]

Macbeth ne new palace kyun banaya tha

[@NibblePop]

Macbeth lived in his own palace in the beginning. After he became king he changed his residence

[@sanjhi1362]

Mam english me toh phle se hi likha hua h..hindi me smjhao na..plss🙏🙏

[@NibblePop]

I think students of English Hons should develop some skills of understanding simple English. I am not just reading it dear, I am explaining it. Trust me, the more you listen to English lectures the more you will develop. Kabhi toh aap bhi padaogey, hain na beta? ❣️

[@omkesharwani9834]

ma'am aap pan masala khate ho naaa jhoot mat bolnaa......😒😒😒😒

[@NibblePop]

😀😀😀 masala nahi but paan kabhi kabhi

[@omkesharwani9834]

@@NibblePop bolo zuba kesari ma'am🌝🌝🌝🌝

[@RubelRubelReang]

Can't understand your explanation 💆‍♂️💆‍♂️💆‍♂️💆‍♂️

[@IshanJha-dt6vi]

Your standard Is still not up to the mark buddy