Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds ft. Kylie Minogue - Where The Wild Roses Grow (Official HD Video)

[@Nickbeck97]

“And I kissed her goodbye, said all beauty must die”. So beautiful, disturbing and emotional line. Nick Cave have to be the greatest lyricist of the past 30 years.

[@TrickOrRetreat]

Death chant indeed

[@nadiaaurelia8518]

Indeed

[@lisamcdonald1014]

I cried so hard at “All beauty, must die”

[@marksmith8556]

Morrissey, mark E smith, Alex turner all streets ahead of him. But he's still sensational

[@Mozarts-Sister]

*Jeffrey Lee Piece* was better imo, & a great inspiration for Cave - & gave him the idea for a murder ballad LP!

[@DenMore1]

Kylie singing with him. That was a shock. The lyrics, also a shock. The song, a masterpiece

[@claudiaschaper8452]

I absolutely agree with you ❤😢

[@tapoi07]

Heard this today for the first time in years and it’s a still a beautiful song in 2024. The melody is to die for.

[@vintentgreene6959]

Me too❤

[@baueringa8648]

szinte érzem azt a büdös rohadt sásos víz szagát....

[@Octaoliva]

Correct, great song

[@MrSardoc1]

Hah "to die for". Sometimes the puns just write themselves.

[@АнастасияДенисова-л7н]

​@@vintentgreene69591

[@8ACCraftworks]

I love the juxtaposition of the last verse "On the third he took me to the river/On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow." Shows how much she trusted him and what he had planned to do all along.

[@PneumaNoose]

100%! The more i actually read the lyrics, the more i discover

[@Mathemusician3141]

Yes, I love the distinction between the third day and the last day. Every time I listen to the song it is one of the things that sticks out to me most.

[@carstenewest8617]

I like that in all verses Nick is singing the first part .. but in the last one Kylie begins, because after the murder she could not have sung it after Nick

[@8ACCraftworks]

@@carstenewest8617 I hadn't twigged that!

[@angiewolflove4040]

She's like Ophelia. This song is hauntingly beautiful. The visuals are amazing.

[@sicklillette]

Agreed

[@БейкаКосая]

Я теперь думаю, что Офелия не сама утопилась...

[@valchehov9703]

@@БейкаКосая аналогично, коллега. что еще переосмыслим?

[@necieau2700]

No wonder people romanticism serial killers. This was fucking beautiful and I wish nothing like this would ever happen again

[@ironheadfm]

A painting of Ophelia actually inspired Nick Cave to write this song.

[@sofydebehault4345]

So many years since I heard this song and I still listen to it enraptured very often. So terrible and tragic and still poetic, perfectly balanced and haunting. One of the masterpieces that will never grow old.

[@Ozzy977]

Same for me

[@pialinden9368]

One of the Best ever written and composed songs on this earth. When I feel happy,sad, anything ,I listen to it.❤Pia,Finland

[@miloseviczarko45]

The album was even caled Murder Ballads. Coincidence?

[@Robin_Hood054]

*This* *is* *not* *song* *.....* *This* *is* *timeless* *masterpiece*

[@xx..tiasan]

For sure, like many songs of the Greatest Nick!!!

[@BobAt101]

Yes, i do not understand why Nick is not a billionaire, his music is excellent and not run of the mill.

[@hansbittink434]

Prachtnummer!

[@TomTom-lj7px]

oh yesssssssssssssss !! love and free hugs from france

[@barbarabarbara1527]

Great author, great voices, many people doesn't know this perfect song...

[@robertschumann9059]

I´m a man of 52 years and havent heard this song for 20 years now. Tears ar running through my face...

[@florincristea8607]

I cry easily too listening this music....

[@ОксанаОксана-ю5л8п]

Мне 49,та же история...

[@Ireland831]

One of the most intense musical performances I have ever bear witness to. Bravo Nick....

[@kristinedurant3249]

Pour moi cette chanson rend hommage aux victimes tuées par amour .cm quoi les sentiments peuvent tuer combien de femmes par ans ????

[@IceBreakBottle]

Nick Cave is just absolutely brilliant. One of the best story tellers of our time

[@jayne.7752]

This song is a true masterpiece. There is nothing that could be changed to make it better. Kylie is supporting Nick's singing while never showing off, or trying to take lead, which shows her true skills as a singer. Nick manages to sing amazingly throughout the whole song. Their voices fit together perfectly. The lyrics and the video are together truely more than either alone. True art that ascends music.

[@kmacgregor6361]

I like the cover by Kamelot.

[@SAseeker101]

Kate Bush was better. P.J.Harvey would have also been better.

[@greymann]

Get a grip on reality.

[@hendokhech1461]

​@@kmacgregor63613и тми м. От тъъ4р😢4ч?

[@hendokhech1461]

​@@SAseeker101ղզֆ եդ ❤սցզզսղ❤ կկ

[@joycecrider1942]

Dramatic, like a Shakespearean tragedy. Emotional, beautiful

[@VerbruggenSouthwood]

Hello Joyce how are you doing

[@EnCo-pg1ko]

Great duet. Historical piece of art. Kylie, she is the inspiration 🎉

[@ларисачубова]

Как же я люблю этот клип эту мелодию этих исполнителей

[@Дюша-з9ш]

Открой свою голубизну🤣

[@СветаИсина]

Солидарна 👍👍👍👏👏🥰💞

[@UrgenG]

Как же долго я искал это, не знал название, помнил только клип, спасибо нейро сетям, и этому челу, что выложил эту песню🙏

[@slavapavlov1958]

Лучшая американская двадцатка из начала девяностых.​@@UrgenG

[@AGMundy]

This along with Confide in Me , are for me, Kylie Minogue's finest songs. Enchanting and disturbing.

[@tkps]

I find those 2 songs show us the quality of her voice which a lot of her popier ones don't manage as well. She's not the best singer in the world but she does have talent. Her sister Dani actually has the better voice.

[@elizanne6660]

@@tkps I agree about the quality of her voice with those songs, yes.

[@juvialockser7390]

I also loved Chocolate, to display her voice talent, very sensual song.

[@Stevenwmcanulty]

​@@tkps"actually".. that's utter crap. Kylie is WAY better vocally.

[@misstara11]

Agree

[@hik-tb2ho]

Kylie's beauty won't die because it's imprinted on this masterpiece. It is engraved in music, lyrics, and images.

[@miloseviczarko45]

Even in her 50s, she is still the one.

[@ray.shoesmith]

Danni was hotter tbh

[@maureenwagg5305]

Mezmerizing. Beautiful, haunting and scary all at once. Nick Cave lyrics blow everyone out of the water. He's on the Leonard Cohen level.

[@rebeccawinter472]

Yeah, I was getting Leonard Cohen vibes throughout this song.

[@timotarttanen8841]

Nick Cave is one of the best song writers of our time so poetic its great to see two Aussie artists in collaboration so such a great tune.

[@4andronicus]

Such a horrific, tragic scenario woven into an incredibly beautiful song. It makes me think of all the women who lost their lives to disturbed individuals throughout history.

[@Imitation0]

Always makes me think of the Dahlia murder. In the song she doesn't get why they call her the rose as if she has no name and that's basically what the media did in that case.

[@littlemissscare-all5320]

+Imitation0 yesss i also thought it was about The Black Dahlia, and that "they" were the media who called her so

[@Hunterspuddy]

i just think theyre trumps wives

[@BOSIE321]

If it's any consolation, Nick plays the character of a sweet and innocent boy called Henry Lee who gets stabbed and thrown down a well by a scorned woman in the song of the same name :p

[@etisunshine1058]

I feel the story is about a woman who was so sad that she wanted him to take her pain away.... for me this is the Most Beautiful love story

[@GaGaWorkshop]

2024. It’s still one of my all time favorites!

[@МаксимОзирный-ь9ж]

С детства мурашки по спине от этой песни! Лучшая лирическая баллада 90х,...на мой взгляд.

[@drugtaken]

Максим Озирный это песня про убийство

[@АннаПресноваВладимировна]

А кто перевод знает? Обожаю эту песню!

[@elishaeva]

@@АннаПресноваВладимировна гугл

[@radioteplo]

@@АннаПресноваВладимировна В озере плыла мертвая принцесса. Она была молода и красива. Тут откуда не возьмись поя вился Ник Кейв и ухватил бабу за сиську. Принцесса ожила и поцеловала своего спасителя....

[@СильвияБокаччо]

"Она была слишком красива и я ее убил".Жуткое содержание,но какая музыка!И как спето!

[@ashwilliams4095]

Who is listening to this magical song in 2020 ?

[@alinstaicu8780]

Here i am!Greetings from Romania!

[@josephyn89]

Me! I want to sing it with my bf, who's a huge Nick Cave fan.

[@ashwilliams4095]

@@josephyn89 Will you be his Elisa Day?

[@dinhetacane1666]

Me.Bosnia.

[@Dead-st7ry]

Give it a fucking rest

[@jamiesmyth5965]

The lines “they call me the wild rose. But my name was Elisa Day” just makes me think all of those victims who became nothing but a name in the media that people would recognize only because of their horrific murders. The one that comes to mind immediately is the Black Dahlia. Another flower name. A woman who was the victim of a horrendous crime and is now only known through that dehumanizing title

[@heerollie7797]

This is exactly the most creepy part of it. Very well explained, thanks

[@Sea_witch_]

Perfectly said.

[@maggiekermott-santos7788]

Her name was Elizabeth Short. She was given the moniker “Black Dahlia” to sell newspapers. Honestly, she was exploited even in death. Sadly, “If it bleeds, it leads.”

[@thomassutherland2647]

Elizabeth Short was The Black Dahlia. Sad. Three main suspects, still seems a mystery. Hopefully one day it, is solved. As for Jack the Ripper, some believe it is an American that was kicked out of medical school. His habits included collecting parts for study. He worked as a "Quacksolver" - the medical term Quack Doctor or simply Quack comes from it. He travelled to France, and was in England during the time of the killings. They stopped the week He had left England, never to be seen again.

[@becky231]

This is so true!! Nice observation

[@grumpysorc3744]

The whole album is a masterpiece.

[@oz_jones]

It is.

[@ricardini9560]

I agree!

[@Jedisau]

I listened to it everyday when I was young and still love it

[@anp5331]

Верх музыкальной гармонии музыки и режиссуры, при минимуме спецэффектов, стиль, выдержанность, красота ❤️....

[@wondakling3482]

I can't believe I'm discovering Nick Cave being 19 years old. What I was losing! A dark dark work of art. Brilliant!

[@deabajo]

Still time to catch up :)

[@acz3705]

I cant believe I'm discovering Nick Cave now when I feel sad. His songs comforts me especailly into my arms

[@pihda77]

lol i discovered him in my late 20s u are just on time

[@maryjanevasconcellos9013]

He's brilliant ❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@PhantomFilmAustralia]

_Mercy Seat_ is one of the best songs ever written.

[@_rainman_3542]

отличный дуэт, исполнение на высшем уровне аж до мурашек))

[@ВсеЛенная-ф1ы]

Перевод печальный

[@initializing_delete149]

chicka pow wiki wow russia time

[@ГогаБырышкаков]

Компот 😛🍌 большой

[@오렌지-t2g]

Наверняка, многие помнят клип с Ником Кейвом и Кайли Миноуг на песню Where the Wild Roses Grow (Там, где дикие розы растут)., но мало, кто знает, что в песне отражена настоящая, жуткая легенда. ЭЛИЗА ДЭЙ Жила когда-то молодая женщина по имени Элиза Дэй, чья красота была схожа с красотой диких, кроваво-красных роз, которые росли неподалёку у реки. Однажды в её городе появился молодой человек и сразу же влюбился в Элизу. У них было три свидания. В первый день он пришёл к ней домой. Во второй день он принёс ей одну красную розу и попросил встретиться с ним в том месте, где растут дикие розы. На третий день они пошли к реке, где молодой человек убил её. В руке он спрятал камень, и когда она повернулась к нему спиной, молодой человек прошептал: “Красота должна умереть!” и ударил её по голове. Она умерла на месте. Он вложил ей в рот розу и опустил её тело в реку, наблюдая, как оно погружается в хрустальную воду. Её тело так и не нашли. Прошло много лет, и люди забыли имя девушки, и стали называть её Дикой Розой. Некоторые люди утверждают, что видели ее призрак, который бродит по берегу реки. Голова призрака испачкана в крови, а в руке девушка держит розу.

[@СветаИсина-р5п]

​@@오렌지-t2g😢😢😮❤❤❤❤Спасибо за перевод .УДАЧИ ВАМ 🎉🎉🎉

[@sam-sebe-gitarist]

Шедевр на все времена!!!

[@monikajasinska9086]

I used to hear this song sometimes when I was a little girl, I had no idea that it was a murder song, because English is not my native language and didn't know the translation. However, I always had chills whenever I heard it. I'm almost 20 now, but the feeling I used to have still remains with me. Amazing song with disturbing lyrics - always gives me chills.

[@alinonea6973]

?????

[@candlegender7950]

Same here

[@ariellalima7229]

From an album titled "Murder Ballads". It's the theme for all songs.

[@alexanderzhdan389]

Русская сразу видно. Мышление...

[@monikajasinska9086]

@@alexanderzhdan389 я русская? нет ;)

[@melindamarley3889]

“The death of a beautiful woman is, unquestionably, the most poetical topic in the world." -Edgar Allan Poe

[@johan.ohgren]

Must suck to be a beautiful woman..

[@thetideishighandsoami3928]

Johan Öhgren well...I wouldn’t know

[@raunorepomies8621]

Not true, love is. Edgar was probably tripping at the time.

[@GeeVoo]

i like this quote

[@iammrbadguy9706]

Edgar Allan Poe.That´s a name I haven´t heard in a while.

[@s.mathersrichard3719]

Pure poetry - beautiful, disturbing, and tragic. One of the best music I've ever heard. Sweet and gloomy

[@fionajolly5801]

This is horror disguised as beauty. A very dangerous thing. This song displays it so well

[@hennesdahmerized7351]

Beast

[@ДмитрийСоловьев-д2з]

Обожаю Ника. Вдвоем с Кайли они великолепны!!!

[@Лето-к9р]

Согласна!❤❤❤

[@Moshingmary-fd9xw]

2024 anyone? Love this song ❤

[@jen_shen1087]

Always here❤

[@cristinapiera9822]

Yo la escucho

[@cristinapiera9822]

❤

[@klausg.355]

Me ... love this song. 😎

[@manuelahrasky8472]

November 27, 2024. 🩷

[@adriangrigorescu4108]

I know this song since I was a little kid and I had only the TV with MTV and even though at that time I didn't knew English I felt the sadness of this song and now, after all those years I searched and found the meaning of this song. It's a great thing to discover and rediscover a song after years and years. If you feel the same as me I hope you will have a great life ahead!

[@kingjohnbullseye]

ce zici Adriane?

[@adriangrigorescu4108]

@@kingjohnbullseye da un translate :))

[@ChiefWindyCheeks]

The most romantic non-love song ever made

[@Myrslokstok]

It is a lovesong in my book, it isn't about a murder it is only a methaphorik if it make you feel better about the song. Actually I find the message very important in our time.

[@letsrock12345]

​@Myrslokstok i personally feel it is a murder ballad. And its message isn't really metaphorical. Its on the album titled "murder ballads" And it seems to draw a slight inspiration from the black dahlia murder.

[@Myrslokstok]

@@letsrock12345 It is the murdering of his old idolising of women, its is about a man looking beyoond womens cheep trixs and his own uncontroled lust fot physical beuty in a woman. Selfpleacing etc Alizaday is "As light as the day". It is nomoore done in isolation, darkness and fantasy. There are different kind of death, and for the self to evolve some parts of a man have to consiusly be murdured! The rose 🌹 symbolizes the union (true) of the female (flower) and masculin (torns).

[@Myrslokstok]

@@letsrock12345 I think the title "murder ballads" are methaphorical, on a superficial level its about murders ofcourse, but these wordly things has no deeper meaning. The song is moore a kind of metha level lovesong. Its about a deeper dive into ones selfconsiusness. The girls name is something like Alizaday, wich stands for "as light as the day" to bring to your consius. She is this kind of entety that lives for free in your consius, and he becomes selfaware about his shadow self and worshiping of a iconic objectifying view on woman wish trapps him. Hard to explain this when I don't speak English that well! The wild rose 🌹 stands for the unification of yin and yang forces or (intercorse), the flower part is the female (vag*a) but also beuty part, the stem with its torn (stiff erection fallos) and maskulin part in this story!

[@letsrock12345]

@Myrslokstok well, while i personally feel it is about murder. I love your deeper view of it all and the way you find symbolism in it. That is why art is amazing. Because we can all find different messages within. Thank you for sharing your views of the song. I like it!

[@rondid]

Ok, if it wasn't for Nick Cave, I probably never heard of this song but I must admit Kylie Minogue did an absolute great job on this

[@frozennubblets9005]

Best song she’s done ……

[@Lucian1692]

@@frozennubblets9005 I think "Confide in Me" might disagree.

[@Ludvigvanamadeus]

@dani cali she didn't actually get murdered during the making of this video, she's still alive and well. #themoreyouknow

[@JadelovesMCR]

Best murder song ever.

[@klausnewman8125]

+Jade Marques I love Alvares de Azevedo too!

[@JadelovesMCR]

Oh, but he's such a genius, isn't he? He was emo before it was cool XD haha :)) A Night in the Tavern is one of my favorite books!

[@worldofgnr]

Oh System of mine, tell me when will i die.

[@erdincefe1]

Charakter song.

[@stenofontanari7772]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rXPIlHmbgt-UhqM

[@ИванИванов-щ9и3ы]

Кайли прекрасная, красивейшая женщина с отличным вокалом.

[@saamohod]

Тощая дюже.

[@andjelavlaovic9641]

I love their voices so much. Just the two totally different types and ,, colours '' of voices. Nick's is so so so deep. Like he is confessing to us what he did to the most beautifull woman he ever saw. Just like a dark movie narrator. And Kylie's is like a gost's echo, because she portrayed a victim. And it's beautifull how they dressed up in white, showing that white color symbolises youth and innocence because he didn't want to see her beauty grow old, and dissappear.

[@konstantinospapacharalampo1350]

...the perfect moment of simultaneous brightness and darkness

[@МаринаКудрявцева-у5и]

какой ответ. великолепно

[@nikita70]

Konstantinos Papacharalampos ...the very thin edge where the best art is raising. But also another one version of the tale about Red Hood Girl with a fatal hispanic-like inevitable disaster instead of happy ending.

[@markwilken2492]

“And I leant down and planted a rose ‘tween her teeth...” ... the man is a poetic genius, but Christ he’s dark...

[@welshpaul9932]

The first time I heard this song I expected him to say “And I leant down and planted a rock 'tween her eyes", because it rhymes. I still can't stop singing it 25 years later.

[@koribanks3641]

@@welshpaul9932 Right... 🤣🤣

[@7h698]

@dani cali why is he scary? Sorry don't know him well

[@Trialia]

And since for some reason I can't edit to add this: Not that I'd want to spend time with Nick himself, because we have way too little in common as people. We'd just end up constantly fighting.

[@kasperchristensen8416]

I always thought he said “And I leant down and planted a rose ‘tween her _tears_ [in her eyes] ...”

[@MsHEADbanging]

5 years ago: My mom showed me this. Best pre-first date warning. EDIT (2022): Yeah 4 years into therapy and mom traumatised me enough with her fear mongering that I don't have any kind of healthy relationship with men nor do I date. So.... stop praising her

[@pesonen205]

You must listen Your heart,no matter else,Your happiness is in Your heart,

[@seelenwinter6662]

in my heart is only blood... where can i find there that damn happiness...???

[@divinefallfromgrace]

MsHEADbanging Just avoid all short-haired men and you'll be doing alright.

[@pesonen205]

There is no matter,what ever hair You have,the Love is important,You understand that.t.hannu

[@ascadorcern6106]

it is ;)

[@Paplikola]

Прекрасная песня. Изумительное исполнение, превосходная музыка

[@jeannettegajst9415]

Une chanson qui ne vieillira jamais. Belle interprétation par 2 grands artistes

[@ew6371]

Always gives me shivers, even after so many years, the sign of a great song ❤

[@jayteedeene5981]

Kylie really looks beautiful in this video.

[@marcosgomes7681]

Yes😅

[@leopoldstotch3524]

Is there one she doesn’t!

[@theaffablefool9452]

Some songs are masterpieces and this is one of those songs. Absolutely breathtaking.

[@geroffmilan3328]

The collabs on this album were simply fantastic. This one, and Henry Lee with PJ Harvey, both have an amazing juxtaposition of very different singing styles. And those two songs are a good contrast, with the murderer being male in this one, whereas it's the woman in Henry Lee. Awesome imagery conjured up in each one. Nick is a legend, deservedly working with other legends (be they The Bad Seeds, Kylie, PJ, or the all-star cast on Death Is Not The End)

[@kateyounger4995]

lyrics: They call me 'The Wild Rose' But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me it, I do not know For my name was Elisa Day From the first day I saw her, I knew she was the one She stared in my eyes and smiled For her lips were the color of the roses That grew down the river, all bloody and wild When he knocked on my door and entered the room My trembling subsided in his sure embrace He would be my first man and with a careful hand He wiped at the tears that ran down my face They call me 'The Wild Rose' But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me that, I do not know For my name was Elisa Day On the second day, I brought her a flower She was more beautiful than any woman I've seen I said, "Do you know where the wild roses grow So sweet and scarlet and free?" On the second day, he came with a single red rose He said, "Give me your loss and your sorrow" I nodded my head, as I lay on the bed "If I show you the roses, will you follow?" They call me 'The Wild Rose' But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me that, I do not know For my name was Elisa Day On the third day, he took me to the river He showed me the roses and we kissed And the last thing I heard was a muttered word As he knelt above me with a rock in his fist On the last day, I took her where the wild roses grow She lay on the bank, the wind light as a thief And I kissed her goodbye, said, "All beauty must die" And I lent down and planted a rose between her teeth They call me 'The Wild Rose' But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me it, I do not know For my name was Elisa Day My name was Elisa Day For my name was Elisa Day

[@nebo274]

You who post lyrics in comments are the real MVP.

[@moy-gospodin]

Отличный перевод

[@violamerjo8800]

Is this song about necrophilia ?

[@vladimirsaakyan509]

Thanks!

[@arthurlampion]

thanks

[@eusouaquelaxD]

2024 anyone? I woke up today with this masterpiece in my head 🩶

[@PeterGatho]

Yup same.to me

[@dmitryderek4096]

Here😅

[@eusouaquelaxD]

@@dmitryderek4096 🥹🥹🥹 now its in my head again today, thank uuuu

[@noname8104]

me, 8 feb. 2024 😂❤

[@eusouaquelaxD]

@@noname8104 good taste 🥹✌️

[@ЕвгенийЛевтеев-с4ц]

Под эту песню я танцевала с тем,кого любила...первый раз на первой встрече, несколько раз позже,когда жили вместе,танцевали и последний... мы знали,что завтра каждый пойдет своей дорогой,и наш дом,который провожал нас,горько плакал под эту песню...

[@SandyLaLane]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jKWYi4KJqrmCiw for you, my cover ❤

[@АлександрСедов-в8к]

Расскажи, как тебе целку срывали. Будь откровенной до конца

[@АнатолийПлюснин-ж8к]

Красивый клип, шикарная песня

[@РинаСкарамуш]

It's funny, the way some songs by groups like Rammstein may sound as if they're going to kill somebody and when you read and translate the lyrics it turns out that the song is about love and peace etc., while a song with a nice soothing melody like this one is about a murderous maniac, no matter how romantic all this stuff about wild roses may seem.

[@Gusttafa]

thats art

[@Castvr]

Рина Скарамуш I love that. the fact that you can assume something just by how it sounds, but then it turns out to be so different.

[@analazovic441]

baneoftheoblivion yes me too

[@jackragnarok8141]

ameroffsky I read somewhere that Cave had a crush on her and wanted to kill her in a song.

[@postmortemritual]

ameroffsky the vid was inspired in the paint "Ophelia" by John Everett Millais.

[@ksenijavukelic6527]

Davno nisam čula ovu pjesmu a znam da kada se je puštala da sam je obožavala bez obzira na mračnu atmosferu.

[@juvialockser7390]

I first saw this clip and the song when I was 16y old, now, 25y later at 41 it still gives me shivers, and I shared it with my 13y son. Beautiful song and atmosphere, although it's a murder...

[@aleksmoris885]

Эту песню я видел мельком по телику.. сейчас слушаю в цифре на Ямаха .это шедевр..Волшебно ! Каждый инструмент звучит волшебно..!

[@thomasraahauge5231]

The most haunting love story I ever came across . . . Haunting, disturbing, heartbreaking - and beautiful beyond words.

[@reanimr4500]

Сегодня ехала в аэропорт, услышала по радио трек и буквально зависла. И,несмотря на то, что клип видела лет 20 назад-прокрутила в голове почти полностью. Специально в аэропорту вышла в сеть и снова посмотрела. Что сказать-гениальная Музыка и гениальный клип. Можно смотреть и вглядываться в детали, слушать и слышать неуслышанные нюансы. А ведь подзабыла про неё. Клип-в любимые и слушать и смотреть!

[@saamohod]

All beauty must die.

[@user-buser1970]

@@saamohod только во Ника Кейва уже нет, а Кайли поёт!

[@olga17018]

​@@user-buser1970 что значит нет?) есть и выступления, и треки

[@user-buser1970]

@@olga17018 долгих лет ему! А я где-то давно ещё прочитал, что он умер... Ну, сейчас мало кому можно верить...

[@СветаИсина-р5п]

​@@user-buser1970Как жаль 😢😢❤❤ даже не знала ,поди молодой был ???

[@Pushinka1805]

Убийственно-романтично❤😢

[@cristinicolae2124]

❤

[@shmasmrmaad]

учитывая, что песня иллюстрирует полинезийский ритуал подготовки девушки к съедению людоедами, всё верно! только тут не показали, что ей предварительно ломают кости и рёбра, чтобы она не могла пошевелиться и сбежать, а то видос популярность бы не набрал среди обывателей. ну и в конце Ник сжалился над зрителями и не показал, зачем он принёс булыжник. ваш уютный воображаемый мирок - совсем не то, чем кажется.

[@Pushinka1805]

@@shmasmrmaad много букв))

[@lifeislife5230]

Вы не правы, это про маньяком, убийц которые убивают женщин, молодых девушек. Одна из версий что у девушек обычно в голове и что у маньяков когда они из заманивают к себе. Я читала книгу, “Serial Killers”, не по своей воле а во время учебы, брала психологию. Узнала столько всего и каждый раз когда читала, думала как всё-таки повезло что не наткнулась на такого. Плакала когда читала, хотела бросить но дочитала все таки.

[@lifeislife5230]

Уважаемая Pushinka1805 я отвечала не вам а shmasmrmaad.

[@vadym.hryhorjev]

можливо я вже писав це раніше, але: дякую за те, що я можу це слухати

[@КАПИТАНСМОЛЛЕТТ-ф8я]

В этом клипе и песне встретились два гения на тот момент.Итог.Фантастическая гармония.Химия потрясающая.После увиденного говорят-такое бывает один раз в жизни.

[@borabora5351]

Conan Varvar согласен, чудесный дуэт.

[@КАПИТАНСМОЛЛЕТТ-ф8я]

SULMEDIRA WORLD За двадцать лет после их дуэта ничего подобного никто не сделал. Мне так кажется.

[@Запиздюна]

Ник Кейв: «Я по-настоящему увлекся Кайли после выхода ее клипа „Better The Devil You Know“, и я помню, как, глядя на то, как она поет, я думал: „Черт, лучше бы она пела что-нибудь грустное и медленное“. …Шесть или семь лет у меня вызревала мечта написать песню для Кайли. На протяжении этих лет я написал много песен, но ни одна из них не подходила, на мой взгляд, Кайли. И вот, когда мы задумали этот проект, я наконец решил, что лучшего, чем сейчас, момента для Кайли не может представиться. Тогда я сел и написал „Where The Wild Roses Grow“. Я думал о ней пока писал песню, и в тот момент мне даже не было важно, согласится ли она спеть эту композицию или нет. Потом я послал ей пленку. На следующий день она позвонила мне и сказала, что находит эту песню просто замечательной. Я всегда думал, что напишу для Кайли какую-нибудь протяжную, медленную песню, и поэтому, когда мы начали записывать с ней „Where The Wild Roses Grow“, я подумал, что это очень опасная песня для нее. Когда менеджер Кайли услышал демоверсию песни, он сказал, что это безумие. Но Кайли сказала мне „да“. Кайли на самом деле многим рисковала, взявшись исполнять эту песню, но в итоге все получилось просто замечательно». Автор: Сергей Курий Источник: shkolazhizni.ru/culture/articles/48965/

[@kolibry7777]

Хмм. Мне первое на ум пришло, что наконец басы настроил и мужской голос не звучит "толерантно". Так жену в отпуск, басуху в лапы.

[@amadzu3]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6vQfnVumbmqfdU Эта вещь тоже достойная

[@TheLovelyCreature]

I remember seeing this music video when it first came out, I must have been around 10 or 11. I was sitting on the floor in our living room, eyes glued to the TV screen. I was amazed. I had never seen any thing quite like it... That incredible beauty and eeriness of the video stayed with me for years. It wasn't until later, as a teen, I started listening to Cave, and realizing that I'd always had a thing for the macabre.

[@tgktgkify]

I worked on this video - I did the online edit (back in the 1990s). It was probably the most beautifully-shot thing I've ever worked on.

[@vincebevis2277]

and religious.

[@Veritanky]

mate thats amazing

[@kalirose9251]

ME TOO! I REMEMBERED THIS JUST 5 MINUTES AGO AND SEARCHED FOR IT. I HAD A HAZY MEMORY OF WATCHING THIS AS A KID TOO, AND IT NEVER LEFT ME

[@nikita70]

TheLovelyCreature The same here. I think I could easily relate with the way you feel. Remember how I fell in love (well, 'got infatuated' fits better I guess) first time ever. I was like 13 or so and 'he' was my classmate. Needless to say it was one of those numerous, early, unrequited platonic 'loves'. I remember me having concocted a long, mawkish poem, inspired/influenced by the story of Ophelia or so, as I believe, in that I identified myself with a virgin girl that commited suicide throwing herself to the river after being brutally raped and 'corrupted' by her prospective lover (must be I desperately wanted someone to 'treat' me like this, but good, these times, lol). Well, childish enough yet I think I have been 'infected'/'afflicted' with this 'macabre thing' since forever as you reported to be. The exaltation and morbidity is kinda intricincly, inevitable part of my imagination I just can't escape. I used to literally hate and avoid tales with happy endings, relished exalted (to the extent of being mawkish and kitschy) stories involving suicide and/or bloody murders, and still hang on this nasty vice to 'torment' my characters/protagonists as I'm writting tales and, of course, while letting my imagination running wild and fantasing. My heroes needs to be 'aesthetical flawless'(not to confuse with aethical) and suffer a whole lot (definitely way way more than an average hunan being is able to make through/endure) before I let them die finally. Oddly enough, now the 'cyrcle' seems to be about to get completed... I was turning 40 and and 'met'/'discovered' Nick Cave whos work seems to embody all my cheap thrills and obsessions perfectly. Plus, I ran across this song that I do really regret not to know as I've been through all this 'early love episodes' and wonder how it's possible it left unrevealed/undisclosed for so long to me or rather how I was able to omitt it... Slap the palm, all you romantics that are not afraid to cross boundaries and move one step further than average Valentines, so said...

[@zanzibar6698]

This song should be made into a feature length film.

[@levanabrzeni]

I believe, Zhang Yimou's ''House of flying daggers'' was inspired by this great song. If not, than I tie them together. I love both of these works of art

[@voloshanca]

Gulliermo del Toro should be its director!! I still remember the genius work of make up artists in his "Devil's boneback" and "Crimson peak"! Really creepy but fascinating-looking ghosts of Santi and Tom from Crimson Peak, the blood from their wounds floating in the air.... The same make-up artists should do Elisa Day's ghost, same atmosphere, died hit by a blunt object on the skull as well, would fit perfectly.

[@photogeen]

definitely, but instead the white rose, should be called black dahlia instead

[@CarlosMota]

This is one of the best duet songs. Kylie's sweet voice and Nick's rough voice work very well in this beautiful song. I've already seen a concert by Nick in Portugal, but I'd like to see both of them singing this song live. I remember hearing the song the moment it came out and it's been 28 years. It was only a few years ago that I learned that the song's lyrics tell a crime story. The music video is masterful and seems influenced by John Everett Millais' painting Ophelia (1852).

[@ricardini9560]

O nome do album é "murder ballads" Todas as músicas são divinais! ❤

[@elenaphilipona5134]

This a maniac's song, absolutely! He finished her life so easely, even if he would be her "first man" (but it didn't happen)… Brrrrr… Nick Cave has not only sang the song perfectly, but also played the role above all the praises! Bravissimo! The beauty of this song transcends music, it is a poetic beauty framed in a horror tale, we will never have more songs of this type, today the authors and performers are judged and punished for the literal interpretation of their works, as a society we have lost all poetic sensitivity.

[@Ayeshteni]

You are aware this is based on a true story?

[@ramonastapic9681]

2024 anyone?

[@MarcoDoring-nh6bi]

❤

[@МаринаВласова-ъ5н]

I enjoyed his life performance yesterday. Impressive!

[@yagmursimdi9103]

❤

[@Fatty-qh5jx]

No 😂

[@juliadantsin4]

2025 in 2 months

[@tommye75]

This one has been aging like a fine wine

[@philippb7028]

Or like a great Speyside Single Malt. It just ages great!

[@DorotaGabal]

Unlike Eliza Day

[@zaednovideo]

Or like a dead human in a swamp

[@boilerhousegarage]

As in, it turns to vinegar?

[@blackrose_cba]

More and More through the years🖤🌹

[@christinedowie2859]

Such a sad story and tragic end to the life of the prettiest girl in Ireland at the time. So 😊beautifully retold by the talented wonderful gorgeous Nick Cave and Kylie Minogue.

[@polinapetrova4000]

Is this a real story? I know tne song since it came out, but never had paid attention to the lyrics (I am Bulgarian, so English is not my first language). Few months ago I read an article about it on a website named Webcafe and it made me listen to it again. I was like: OMG, that is so creepy! But the article said, that this is just a legend, created to teach the young girls to not trust a strange men. So which is the truth?

[@sudeepdas443]

The music is so soothing. The lyrics are so poetic but the meaning is so dark and sorrowful. This music video is a true example that many a times the beautiful things are not filled with happiness.

[@MTBStoriesWithTheFishtail]

We were so blessed in the 90s. The wealth of music was staggering. My son keeps telling me he was born in the wrong decade...I think he might be right. Came here to watch Henry Lee after seeing PJ Harvery live at The Roundhouse last week. Love both that and Where the Wild Roses Grow.

[@OnThe100]

Сколько медляков на школьных дискотеках было станцовано под это романтическую песню. Ну не знаем мы английский настолько хорошо!

[@elenaphilipona5134]

Романтическую песню? Учите английский и другие языки! Эта песня - песня маньяка, который даже не имел с девушкой тесной связи, он просто её убил камнем на берегу реки, оправдывая тем, что "all beauty must die"/ любая красота должна умереть!😬😱

[@OnThe100]

​@@elenaphilipona5134 это и имел ввиду

[@suboforever]

А "Джинни" Фалько, ахаха!

[@suboforever]

@@elenaphilipona5134 Может, всё же лучше нормальные песни слушать на родном языке?

[@elenaphilipona5134]

@@suboforever И нормальные песни слушаю на родном языке, и другие тоже... В общем, слушаю и понимаю на английском, немецком, французском, итальянском и испанском языках. 🤣 А Вас-то каким ветром сюда занесло, на "ненормальный" клип? 🤗😉😁

[@caterinadivina5006]

This song has devastated my soul ♥️

[@katarzyna3500]

he has such a beautiful voice and the song has so much meaning truly WELL DONE

[@kalynlambert6889]

Haunting voices and lyrics. 🥀

[@mihalyvarga667]

Ha jól tudom: Nick és Kylie osztálytársak voltak ..... Nick plátói szerelmet érzett Kylie iránt, és ezt a csodálatosan szép dalt írta ennek a szerelemnek az emlékére ...

[@noname-dp1nx]

It's so southern gothic. The music, the visuals, the lyrics

[@nonononononon71]

Why the hell don't we have songs like this anymore?!

[@paganknight72]

not in the mainstream media for sure but dig into neofolk bands here and you might find songs of similar beauty ,depth and filled with emotions !

[@smartalek180]

8 yrs on, a few suggestions for yr consideration; I hope @ lst one of them will do it for u? (Apologies if any r tracks u know already; most r very well-known in their own right) Chris Isaak: Black Flowers Kongos: Come With Me Now Leonard Cohen: You Want it Darker Soho Dolls: Bang Bang Bang Tom Waits: Hold On Tom Waits: Jockey Full o Bourbon Townes van Zandt: Waiting Around to Die (tho I'm partial to the cover by The Be Good Tanyas) Hozier: Angel of Small Death & the Codeine Scene Franz Ferdinand: 40' Squirrel Nut Zippers: Blue Angel

[@rockwrecked]

Yes we do, we have...RAP!

[@melvert33]

If someone keeps calling you the Wild Rose but your name is Eliza Day it's definitely time to extract yourself from that situation.

[@vikingjohn9813]

@Swilly Billy weighed down with rocks on the river bed lol

[@awesomebonnie1014]

@@vikingjohn9813 💀

[@kasperchristensen8416]

melvert33: Hahahaha! What a wonderful humor you got, buddy! 😂

[@voloshanca]

Guess it's kinda hard when you're a ghost and tied to the place of your death, and living people can't even hear you speaking....

[@natachaveronesi2103]

🤣

[@nanetteroeland7847]

Ever since The Birthday Party, I knew this man has it. He is a master of words whose skill reflects all that is haunting, primal and beautiful. It is great to see how new generations have discovered You. Love You Nick, always have, always will❤

[@Teeko2003]

I am planning to play this song at my funeral. Just for the craic. But unfortunately won't see the mourners faces. Love this.

[@cl4wnie]

2021 anyone?~

[@seeyousoonsailormoon]

Me!!!

[@firstsheshinschannel8106]

+

[@aniaibartek100]

Polska

[@badbabvy]

Meeee.

[@SD_RAMOS]

Me!

[@PeterCTheRock]

this song is magic..just pure magic!

[@Tuur_TL]

Peter C you said it

[@Seraliskas]

В детстве обожала эту песню...голоса, клип. Завораживает...

[@Robmarbz]

Great great song and, Kylie is like an angel. She's so beautiful.

[@Dermacrosis]

Funnily enough her fans dropped her when she entered her "indie" phase which includes this song. Irony being she topped the indie charts as PWL was classed as an indie record company.

[@Trialia]

@@Dermacrosis Not all her fans. I've never been enough into her stuff to go to a gig, too expensive, but I have always enjoyed it, and this in no way put me off. Though to be fair, I *was* only nine when this came out.

[@Dermacrosis]

@@Trialia I didn't say all, though I should have been more specific in my wording so that is my fault. However all her "fans" that I knew personally dropped her when she went into her indie phase.

[@LunarEleven]

@@Dermacrosis it's understandable honestly. Most fans will do that when an artist changes genre. They liked a certain kind of music. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I personally grew up with The Loco-motion and then loved everything she released in her later come-back but this collab with Nick Cave?! To me it was next level for her. So I can't relate to fans who dropped her but I can still understand, honestly it sucks for them to not be able to appreciate an artist's growth. I respect her for doing what she wanted because she surely knew it was not gonna be where the money was. Sorry that was a rant, I probably just feel elite for appreciating Kylie in all her incarnations but I actually just grew up with more diverse music than most people so it's more luck.

[@LunarEleven]

@@Dermacrosis also I'll just add that my experience was the same, I remember showing this to people I knew liked her, thinking they were going to be mind blown but they were like, "uh... creepy." 😐

[@__VR__8]

What a haunting and beautiful masterpiece

[@pesonen205]

In this world,there is nothing,just nothing ,as beautiful as a Woman :)

[@paulcaine2603]

Art try's, but ultimately fails.

[@Zokambaa]

Man... Nick Cave sure has a talent for making beautiful but such dark themed songs.. very haunting

[@gemolibre]

Strange and magnificent song.

[@guranboroda]

+Philip HENRY Странная и завораживающая. Мне нравится.

[@TravlosTheManichean]

+guranboroda Наистина е много странна.

[@halinad6686]

Ja jestem!

[@pavelm625]

the text is crazy and at the same time incredibly poetic ... a luxurious thing

[@kellyryan0909]

What’s so poetic about a psycho murderous fruit loop?

[@lizgorrie2204]

2022 just randomly came into my head to play it. Beautiful duet! Who would have thought of these two doing a duet? Bizzare like the.song but it i love it and the video. Great song!

[@HEZ63]

Nick Cave's masterpiece for me. (Apart from "Tupelo") Even more, after having read "And the Ass saw the Angel". This is the song to the book!

[@martynguest2892]

This has to be one of the best songs ever. They both have amazing voices.

[@Jaymes400]

well, It's definitely one of the best songs about a man bludgeoning a woman to death with a rock LOL, it is an absolute classic though!. it's a masterclass in creative songwriting.

[@boogieelaine]

Hauntingly beautiful

[@Екатерина-ы3и2ч]

Эмоции переполняют! Очень круто!!!

[@ditason]

have tried finding this music video for years after singing it on singstar when i was a child. what a beautiful song, and not to mention the music video!! wow.

[@58m48]

They call me The Wild Rose But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me it I do not know For my name was Elisa Day From the first day I saw her I knew she was the one She stared in my eyes and smiled For her lips were the colour of the roses That grew down the river, all bloody and wild When he knocked on my door and entered the room My trembling subsided in his sure embrace He would be my first man, and with a careful hand He wiped at the tears that ran down my face They call me The Wild Rose But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me that I do not know For my name was Elisa Day On the second day I brought her a flower She was more beautiful than any woman I'd seen I said, "Do you know where the wild roses grow So sweet and scarlet and free?" On the second day he came with a single red rose He said "Will you give me your loss and your sorrow" I nodded my head, as I lay on the bed "If I show you the roses, will you follow?" They call me The Wild Rose But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me that I do not know For my name was Elisa Day On the third day he took me to the river He showed me the roses and we kissed And the last thing I heard was a muttered word As he knelt above me with a rock in his fist On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow And she lay on the bank, the wind light as a thief And I kissed her goodbye, said, "All beauty must die" And I lent down and planted a rose 'tween her teeth They call me The Wild Rose But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me that I do not know For my name was Elisa Day My name was Elisa Day For my name was Elisa Day

[@daz12345daz]

It's genius the way that she sings about it being "the third day" and he sings about it being "the last day".

[@robbiepeterh]

Kind of terrifying too...

[@leiwolf27]

It’s seems she is still waiting for him

[@Orlando-Corea]

Poetry

[@Umetnik]

Indeed, this is a masterpiece part. It is also worth nothing that the duo sings: "man, woman, man woman, woman, man". Emphesasing he had the last word when the story will end, while she just sings in hope, he sings in certainty of the end.

[@_VR_8]

indeed

[@bugina4640]

Nadčasová a nádherná píseň, která nikdy neomrzí a super spojení dvou odlišných a krásných lidí.

[@ssidach]

Two incredible and enigmatic voices, creating such an amazing murder ballad!❤❤❤ “As I kissed her goodbye, I said, “All beauty must die””… Every single time I hear this, my brain plays “I must love what I destroy, and destroy the thing I love” in the background… Yes, from the “Moon Over Bourbon Street”, by Sting. Different pieces of amazing music, conveying the same message...

[@НатальяРихтер-ч3ш]

Не знала что женская партия в этом бомбическом клипе Кайли Миноуг , дуэт просто космос мурашки по коже....