Skater XL vs Session | Direct Comparison

[@SkatingOnTheRocks]

The sound during the manual phase, Session emits the sound of the wheels hitting each crack of the sidewalk but SkaterXL doesn't. I've been skateboarding for 20+ years and that sound is staple of the skateboarding community. Just hearing that sound makes me look around for skaters, just like smelling weed in the air makes you turn your head.

[@hipettyhop]

I thought the exact same mate. No 'clack clack clack' noise is a deal breaker for me haha

[@Gekke_Gerrit94]

Hell ye

[@christopherson93]

overall, minus the clacking of the wheels hitting the cracks, SkaterXL has a more satisfying sound to me atleast.

[@killmozzyvfx7516]

SkaterXL does this every crack sound, just the ground he picked exactly doesn’t have it which is shitty, but there is other types of tile that make the sound perfectly, just as your looking for homie

[@hipettyhop]

@@killmozzyvfx7516 Thanks for the info man. As if I won't buy both anyway haha Still, it's good to know :)

[@felisasininus1784]

lol Those two characters' faces look horrifying in their own different ways.

[@mattgrimes6218]

yeah hahaha

[@vattss1668]

Both games are really sick, I hope to see them evolve over time and become something really great, we need more Skating games

[@Lmaoeatrr]

Honestly, if Session finds a way to emulate the physics of Skater XL, Session blows away the competition.

[@vattss1668]

@@Lmaoeatrr I hear you there brother, if they can really master the physics and controls, it could be one of if not the ultimate skate game

[@Korrigantrublion]

Christopher Menendez I agree, Session has more potential in my opinion. But right now, SXL is better overall

[@Stickybobby]

Your just desperate for any new skating game lol. We need a good sequel to Skate 3

Wtf opinions on this are all over the place. People either really hate it or really love it. I think I gotta grab it because my curiosity is killing me.

[@lucky_sevans3527]

I'll take better skate spots with poor grass textures.

[@RipnDip561]

Agreed.

[@rjj4736]

Skater XL has better spots for people with a minimal relationship to real skateboarding. Session is better for real skaters imo. Having skated some of the spots in both games before, session did it better.

[@Geri5100]

@@rjj4736 I'm worried about Session though. I mean financially. If you're a game dev it's not neccessarily a good idea to target a group of people that would rather spend their free time skating. Only time will tell though.

[@maggiolins]

@@rjj4736 yes. I don't understand how people say that skater xl is realistic ??? Session is still full of bug but the base is very good.

[@berealbud2963]

@@maggiolins skated for 7 yrs.. Played both. Skater xl is the closest I've felt to being on a skateboard since I skated...easily

[@popeaici]

Remember , Skater XL was made by a team of 7 peoples.

[@Dman130]

Session was made by 2 dudes they just expanded their team.

[@rocco2389]

@@Dman130 so therefore it was made by a whole team

[@Dman130]

Rocco is still a small group, smaller than easy day.

[@rocco2389]

Doulton M still I would rather a game with bad grass textures that actually feels fun to play 🤣

[@Dman130]

Rocco lol that’s your comeback, this is about how create-ure studios has less people working on their game. Not saying skaterxl is bad. To me session is more challenging thats what I like (more realistic)

[@Darklord6664]

Woody: "Quick everybody hide! Andy's Coming!" The toys: 1:59

[@Zeeshanbeats]

Lol

[@jayrukks8039]

🤣

[@ihaveanopinion1557]

Underrated, lol.

[@mrcraggle]

The Session dev team have recently said that they’re going to be redoing the physics system in the game so development of other systems won’t continue until that’s completed.

[@maximilianschaffler9981]

Its not good to see a game dev studio rework the fundamental part of the game so late in development, i find that a bit worying

[@ScarlxtPink]

@@maximilianschaffler9981 It's still in highly early access, so I'm not sure what you mean.

[@rosvokomppania]

@j mula I like session controls much more. I used to skate quite a bit and they just make more sense

[@jiggaman727]

Maximilian Schäffler session is in pre alpha so if you think thats late in development then ion know what to tell you

[@Pnk117]

@@maximilianschaffler9981 not smart

[@moffitdetrapp4878]

Both games would improve if they added animations for the character when he bails or slams. Kinda sucks how the game characters don't try to catch themselves when they fall or jump out of sketchy tricks rather than just lose all control of their nervous system and fall like a rag doll. I still enjoy both games though, at least I can kinda skate when the weather sucks!

[@migueeeelet]

Yeah I noticed that too. If at least you could do like in Skate 3 and control the ragdoll...

[@swaggypea3866]

Yeah all of these bmx and skating games have rag doll physics, but it would be awesome to see some realistic nails.

[@TrevWard-G]

Remember tho, session hasnt released their game yet like skater xl has and its already better. But lets all be honest were all waiting for skate 4

[@Hayden11335]

Session is most definitely not better then skater xl lmaoo the animations look terrible lol

[@CrispyCross-]

session > skaterXL

[@TrevWard-G]

@@javidelvalmusic its been a year now. I realize skater xl is better now. Plz next time reply within a year

[@TrevWard-G]

@@javidelvalmusic also im still waiting for skate 4 a year later

[@landonellis7479]

😂😂😂 still waiting here too

[@markbradley5355]

Maybe I missed it but, seems you didn’t touch on how amazing the editing feature is on skater xl.

[@killmozzyvfx7516]

FACTS!!!

[@omgvague]

Session has live map editing, not sure if Skater XL does. Skater XL has quite a few mods that enhance its gameplay, not sure if Session does.

[@dhaloh]

@@omgvague Session is just worse than SkaterXL all-togheter atm. SkaterXL has more mods

[@dhaloh]

@King Dingaling But Session is still worse lol

[@WorldWidePatriots]

What editing feature? I'm on console and Skater XL is basically half a game. Hardly any content.

[@rustysussen5225]

Me personally, I think session and skater xl should collaborate on a fusion title. Skater xl being ahead in release and session being ahead in visual modeling. I've also been waiting on a full on map creation option for awhile.

[@TheSunIsMyDestroyer]

And if they added multiplayer to that, that game could probably destroy Skate 4.

[@DarkBrotherhoodMurderer]

This takes me back to the EA skate demo that was available in August of 2007 before the retail version was released. I just remember being fucking speechless at how realistic it was. The physics in the game engine was just unparalleled coming from a THPS game. I see this video now and it’s disappointing to see that, even 13 years later, skateboarding games have made barely an improvement over the original game that revolutionized the genre over a decade ago. With that being said, knowing the ambiguous and free form nature of real life skateboarding, I could understand that creating a game like this is a colossal undertaking and undoubtedly a programming nightmare, so kudos to the developers for making any headway they possibly can. I guess it’s a testament to the original Skate, that game really was way ahead of its time.

[@snailcage]

XL is a vast improvement from Skate. The fact that Skate & Session use animations for their tricks put XL in a completely different league. Games vs Simulator.

[@maximebourgault2057]

These games are a huge upgrade from skate. Weirdly, the game looks very bad when you watch gameplay but once you play it you understand the hype surrounding the release. If you skate in real life these games feel amazing

[@xzaveonalvarez237]

You also have to take into account that Skater XL was made with a team of 7. So it's super impressive that they're even able to pull this off

[@ruok-l5t]

Snail Cage XL still use keyframe animations for its tricks. The only difference is that it has complex physics applied to them so you can sort of control the weight. Without animations it’d be just like a ragdoll board

[@snailcage]

Ruok It basically is a rag doll board. They just scripted rules that prevent it from getting too far away from the character. They have a video on their channel about how they did the motion capture and how they did it. But it isn’t animations in a sense where they motion capture someone doing a kick flip and process it in Blender or something like that and then have it coded where that animation plays while the board is flipping 360 degrees. They motion captured hundreds of kickflips, cut each one into a thousand pieces, and scripted it to where the way that you do the trick determines how those pieces of the kickflip are combined, while the board spins freely underneath you. Other games literally just have the character play a pre-made animation while the board flips the same way it always does.

[@antoine257]

Session definitely lacks impression of speed, pop and especially impact on landing...the character skates like a 60 year old grandpa

[@PumpkinSmasher85]

The person doing this review hasn't realised you can push faster by tapping A or X in Session, then went on to complain that it's too slow. As for the impact of landing, are you kidding me? In skater xl you can literally land from any height no problem. Session is far more realistic in that aspect and even has a feature you can enable that requires an input when landing from height to avoid bailing.

[@yoscopezz359]

session isnt even a fully developed game..its still a beta

[@MiniPunxx]

YoScopeZz pre-alpha man. No even beta yet.

[@TyrellW]

@@yoscopezz359 yeah neither is Skater XL but it didn't stop the devs from scamming you

[@lucarobinson701]

And the animations are really stiff and don’t look realistic at all

[@FocusFilmsCo]

Session is still in very early development. It looks like they are focusing a lot on details but I'm so stoked to see what they come up with. (This is coming from someone who has 100hrs on Skater XL and 50 on Session)

[@lilplum37]

but session is also LONGER in development. SKATER XL came outta nowhere. I know there was a mobilegame called "skater" but they came with 1 video and released it

[@marvinmartir]

LIL PLUM it didn’t come out of nowhere lol

[@Cashcrop91]

No session is not in early development, it just looks like it because they've made little progress over the last 5 years lol

[@lobbetobb3387]

Theyre working with unreal engine, ofc its gonna be longer. SkaterXL didnt come out of no where, its a mobile game port. Literaly just reworked with some new models. Thats why it feels so floaty and arcady. Which is fine its good to have two different games.

[@Yell.LV.]

@@Cashcrop91 Because Session devs aren't rushing it, not like Skater Xl devs that release an incomplete game on console.

[@wotntarnation3012]

So basically: Session looks better. Skater X has better animations, controls, maps, and general gameplay.

[@iSeeEZEkill]

@@alexandrep4913 session has canned animations.

[@markbradley5355]

Skater XL uses physics to make the board flip, whereas session uses actual animations. This is the reason the movements on session look more “ robotic “

[@SkatingOnTheRocks]

Damn, I have SkaterXL and they officially released 1.0 over all consoles, and I have to say, I was pretty underwhelmed. I love the mechanics, but there is still tons of bugs fixed and overlooked features that are totally needed. Thinking that Session might have been better.

[@stevebonamara4174]

@@SkatingOnTheRocks this is just 1.0....... still TONs of updates to come

[@SkittleDick]

@chris ortiz yeah w mods its a lot better

[@CrazyShaolinWarrior]

I feel like you left out a lot of details. For example how you can style your tricks in skater xl which is HUGE

[@migueeeelet]

Style them? Explain, please!

[@CrazyShaolinWarrior]

@@migueeeelet everytime you do the same trick in skater xl, it's gonna look different. You can catch a kickflip with your front foot, back foot, both foot, tweak it to the left, flip it slow or fast etc etc. Theres no canned animation for tricks

[@migueeeelet]

@@CrazyShaolinWarrior Wow that's actually impressive!

[@stitched_]

@@CrazyShaolinWarrior it's the same in session as long as you set your gameplay settings that way. Session's gameplay is far more in depth, realistic, and customizable. Skater XL literally became too easy and boring after just a week of playing

[@tremolony4924]

jacob danowitz Its boring on console but on PC with mods its way better than session...

[@randomguyonyoutube591]

They should've add NPC like skate 3. It feels empty in my opinion.

[@luiscarvalho7899]

Their target audience are skaters and simmers. What they care about is how good the simulation and controls feels. Everything else makes no difference, specially with mod support.

[@stevebonamara4174]

skate 3 had a huge dev team, these games only have less then 20 people working on them

[@zonkbronk5260]

eh npcs wouldnt do anything for me

[@randomguyonyoutube591]

No worries my guys it's just my opinion and by the looks of it the game is fun, cool skate physics

[@GrizzlyThatHawk]

the newest modded map for Session called "Peitruss" has NPCs. It's amazing

[@IgorTavern]

Both skaters looks like Dead by Daylight survivors, haha. Thanks for the video!

[@jayrukks8039]

😂😂

[@bergerman487]

Comparison from my point of view: Session: 1) Still in Early Access 2) Few glitches 3) You hit a curb, you'll fly 10 meters away 4) Customization just ok unless you have a mod 5) Gameplay is much harder than Skater XL but 6) Flip tricks more cleaner than Skater XL 7) Does have late Flips 8) Unreal Engine Skater XL: 1) Full released 2) More bigger map 3) This game community is awesome 4) Mods 5) Customization is really good 6) Gameplay more friendlier but 7) Full released but still few glitches 8) Flip tricks still sloppy 9) No late flips yet

[@Wookeenook]

Session does have late flips

[@bergerman487]

@@Wookeenook Yes i know, sry i'm not being too specific

[@SourceOfShorts123]

yessir

[@aaronb543]

2 things to note, session has been in development for longer than SkaterXL. And a lot of the reason Session looks better is due to a lot of purchased asset packed.

[@CamBonerJoner]

I personally think skater XL’s flip tricks are very impressive coz the board flips with physics so every one is different

[@riiyaFGC]

I've played both a bunch, but enjoyed Session a lot more in the end. I feel like Skater XL is a good game if you want to have this "realistic" kind of approach, but would still like to quickly feel like an amazing skater - supported in the game by the ridiculous amount of handholding for doing/landing tricks, including basic things such as jump height etc.; and Sessions is the better choice if you don't need things to be as flashy, but would like to have the skating experience (minus breaking your bones irl), getting to land cool (but considerably less flashy) tricks after putting some effort into learning how they work. Skater XL might be more "intuitive" in the end, but I feel like the complexity Sessions brings is in the game for a good reason, since the control scheme links a lot more to what you'd do when skating (with the thumb sticks linked to your respective feet) - but I can see someone go for either game depending on what they're looking for.

[@lobbetobb3387]

Yeah i agree, session for me too. Just because of the creative freedom you have. Also the historical challanges are great!

[@dhaloh]

I feel the exact opposite. I found SkaterXL to be more realistic because of how you can tweak your tricks. You can do them slow, quick, catch with front foot or back foot.. do a shifty if you want. Do an ollie where you actually jump up yourself so you just hippie ollie. There's way more control given in SkaterXL and it's still complex. Like doing a varial flip shifty can be super hard especially once you've done tre flips, which reminds me of how it is IRL.

[@fknsticky]

@@dhaloh you can do all this in sessions too

[@theactualbobross5556]

Skater xl just has new bearings and really waxed grinds

[@dranradan5076]

Just imagine Skater XL’s gameplay with Session’s content and creative control in one game. That would be perffff

[@dranradan5076]

Matt G “Session XL” lol or “Skate Session”

[@haterfanroo9]

I prefer session over xl controls and feel

[@dranradan5076]

Alex I love session as well, I just feel like it’s a little bit robotic or stiff, especially on the grinds. Haven’t played in a while but I think creature said something about updating its gameplay and I do sure hope it comes soon

[@haterfanroo9]

@@dranradan5076 I get it and get your point on mixing them. However I prefer the inmersive experience of moving the caracter rather than a landmark, manual catch, the size of the assets is more realistic, and foot work seems more real. I own both and would put XL grinds, maps and replay editor into session. Regarding stiffness and horror faces they are both the worst, cripie xd.

[@dranradan5076]

Alex totally true. Tbh I want both games to succeed over money grubbing EA 😂

[@L2DG]

EA watching this while doing a birdman handrub followed by major note taking

[@WorldWidePatriots]

Merchant handrub* 👃

[@InnuendoXP]

worth mentioning - the board dismount & sprint mechanic allows you to get a running start to a line too.

[@salmone5939]

Actually i really enjoy session's world design, it feels more authentic when you live in a little city with no skateparks or skate spots, where you have to create your own spots and even a little curb can be something fun to skate on

[@TheOrangeSunsetGaming]

So far I enjoy Skater XL's animations, map layout, and the flip tricks (even though the gravity is fucked), while on Session I do enjoy the way it looks and the sound design. After my experience in skating I would say as far as everything goes Session is a little more realistic, but Skater XL is just as fun. I don't think I could fully pick between the two.

[@NoahSties]

Skater xl is a lot more fun in my opinion, the overall UI, colors, and feel is a lot more polished and session feels a bit dull.

[@Lmaoeatrr]

It’s naturally easier, that’s why you enjoy it more. The fact that riding fakie or switch in Session is as difficult as riding switch in person (without practice). Session is more realistic. Even though the physics are different between games.

[@yourmother9747]

Christopher Menendez realistic doesn’t translate to “fun” buddy

[@TheRyanAkers]

@@Lmaoeatrr regardless of how floaty SXL can be, its definitely more realistic and much more satisfying imo

[@CommonSenseless1993]

I kinda feel bad for Session. They have been in early access for so long and now Skater XL comes along and will most likely take whatever market share they initially had.

[@Avratin]

Yeah, it's a shame, but SkaterXL just has better bones. The controls make more sense and are better.

[@warpig2786]

I don´t, I just feel like Skater XL is so rushed where as Session hasn´t shown all it has offer yet, I would take the Session simulator simly because it seems to go deeper in those fine details that this gentleman just pointed out.

[@dbspaceoditty]

@@warpig2786 i feel so many of the people who favor XL are not experienced skaters. i love how buggy session is, because nothing like hitting an edge in a grind. it happens. to every skateboarder to ever try to grind. oh, you thought that 5-0 was great, nope, you hit an edge. or didnt balance right ,and you eat shit. having to control the front foot to ollie only makes sense. and session is WAY more rewarding when you finish a trick. the more i play XL the more i realize how bad it is. also, watching footage of people do some legit THPS stuff in XL already just like they did with the skate games. oh, you wanna 360 nose blunt to 360 hard flip manual too tripple kick flip blunt slide down a rail to a manual to you know. endlessly combo. without mods i feel Session is way better. but people dont realize session has mods too. even i havent done modded session yet.

[@1venusflytrap]

@@dbspaceoditty u can have ur opinion, but honestly i 100% prefer xl. session just feels... off. idk maybe its just me

[@tylershank1870]

MattEye that’s usually what happens when an indie developer takes on a huge challenge of creating a game from scratch. Another developer sees the weaknesses in their game and tweaks them and release a better product. Take BMX streets and BMX the game for example.

[@tajforney7085]

it would be cool if they made one game together putting together the strong suits from each game.

[@alembic1105]

Can I just say that this channel is criminally underrated.

[@Leigh_Bailey]

For anyone on the fence about buying Skater XL on consoles, I'd really suggest holding off for now. It's incredibly buggy with some frame rate issues and a surprisingly small amount of content. You really have to make your own fun for now, but at £35 and with a lot of core features missing I'd say it's not easy to do. Also for anyone who cares, it also has a trophy that is seemingly impossible asking you to skate over 40,000 kilometres. I bought it because I love the skating genre and I want to support small studios. But unless there is a roadmap of extra content coming for free down the road I find it hard not to feel a little ripped off right now.

[@spicynips8466]

40,000 KM??????????????

[@treyhayes101]

Going off my skate 3 stats I think it could easily be done 😂

[@Leigh_Bailey]

@@treyhayes101 there was a lot more to do in Skate 3 though :p

[@rosvokomppania]

I have played GT sport 196 hours and have 30k km how the hell you suppose to skate 40k

[@JSRMedia]

2:15 Nobody was looking at the arms.

[@laubowiebass]

I didn’t know about Session. And with Tony Hawk about to come out, what a good year for skating fans ! Is this coming to PS4 too?

[@fboypasunbandit499]

Skater xl is available on ps4 and Xbox

[@s.h.1114]

@@fboypasunbandit499 and pc

[@emmanuelugalde475]

SVN she said session not skater xl

[@chasejackson63]

easy day studios said they are focusing on the physics aspect until they get that where they like it before focusing on the textures and graphics

[@dickmccarthy9496]

And that's how they should do it imho. Master one thing before going to another. They are literally sitting on a gold mine right now.

[@Mrgtaman533]

This was an amazing comparison video please do another soon or in the future when both games get updated further. A couple major things you forgot to mention that you could've mentioned: The Switch Stance How each trick looks Bails Skybox Trick Complexity P.S. I am more of a fan of Session even after Skater XL's full launch, I am still hopeful for both games in the future. Session feels more like skateboarding to me as I do skateboard in real life and have for the last 16 years.

[@lilplum37]

in Skater XL you normally turn with the triggers too.

[@flimsy364]

It’s down to preference I like to turn with the triggers

[@Nitroh-]

skater xl better animations the way the character flows, it just looks like jump cuts half the time in session with no real smooth transition between character movement and trick movement. Also session looks better because your comparing unreal engine 4 to unity, there can be some great looking graphics come out of untiy but its no way up to par with unreal

[@maximilianschaffler9981]

No the graphics are worse because the game is getting a release on consoles including Switch, look at Escape from Tarkov, in my opinion it looks better than any Unreal game (because of the smooth look of unreal) if you search for Escape from Tarkov be sure to watch a video from the devs (battlestate) because you can set your own color grading and sharpness (a lot of people use this to get a better vision at the enemy, thats why im saying)

[@screwball992]

@@maximilianschaffler9981 We are comparing these two games, which both are on consoles, so I dont see the point you are trying to make? Sessions clearly looks better graphicly. Skater xl looks better in some animations. Both need work but even though I like skater xl better I just don't see it being graphicly better than sessions ever, and I'm okay with that. Always been gameplay over graphics, even though I ditched consoles and moved to pc to be a graphics whore.

[@blzy2305]

Unity can achive the same level of graphics than unreal.

[@screwball992]

@@blzy2305 I get that, and as much as I love the game I just dont think skater xl is going to achieve that.

[@Nitroh-]

@@blzy2305 that depends on what textures they use

[@spadedonemcdysentery2493]

Yo, what are the odds you revisit this video in September when Session hits 1.0 and full release?

[@AuSTyN10R]

You can go a lot faster in session if tap “push” fast

[@robyroby3665]

the sound when you grind in skater xl is soooo satisfying idk whyy

[@troyleehittinswitches]

Skater xl sounds are pulled straight from the app that they failed to update

[@MaynardOwns]

I feel like session if you can get really good with extreme real settings like board catching and manual spin and scoop speed inputs is gonna be so rewarding to get good at.

[@itsjaieverett8005]

lets gooooo ive been waiting for this for a while! cheers nick

[@sdawg4166]

Skater xl forever man. The fact that every trick looks different because it’s physics based is everything. And if you can mod it, it’s the best skateboarding simulator ever hands down. I’m not bashing session though, because everyone has their own opinion

[@hughjass7246]

Session also seems really choppy and stiffly animated too. Like don’t get me wrong I might end up buying it anyway, but Skater XL just seems more smooth.

[@1venusflytrap]

exactly my point. once the stats menu is in the base game, we will have a clear winner in my opinion

[@samsavage712]

@@1venusflytrap That's what i'm saying, most peoples complaints are that it's too floaty. They need to add stats menu to console as well if they can.

[@JReaLBiz86]

Session looks and sounds better, SXL plays better. Session's animations look stiff, SXL's animations are fluid. Session has an object dropper, SXL has the clearly better replay editor. They both need more customization options (including a way for players to import textures for custom clothes and boards), they both need to clean up their transition physics and add a way to "pump" to pick up speed. I like Skater XL better because it's more intuitive, It has the better replay editor for making film clips, and the board physics feel nice. In all honesty, if Session's controls were a *little* less complex, and it had better controls in the replay editor, I would make the switch, because being able to control the time of day and drop in objects is essential for better skate films.

[@mikiestew2you]

You can pump in skater xl

[@lookforthegood1]

Also mods if you're on pc that you can do all of that on skatexl

[@uhhcolton7232]

Push the sticks in opposition directions to pump in sxl

[@INADRM]

Skater XL audio sounds weird. i really like how Session sounds when running over bricks.

[@nate_lublin]

In order to push quickly in session you have to spam a or x. You can actually push faster in session.

[@Jamesvidds]

Nate Lublin you can just hold a or x

[@nate_lublin]

Sexy Skaters you can but you go a lot slower if you do

[@Jawnietheboy]

Us skaters don’t really care about the details. As long as you can catch tricks whenever you want or bone them we’re good

[@johnmorrison5502]

This is the correct answer

[@HanisGamingofficial]

Your videos are always fun to watch. I, literally, managed to know most of the games from your channel and you never disappointed me. Thnx

[@HanisGamingofficial]

@Josh derp Everyone has his own taste in games.

[@justfodo3299]

I would like to see this direct comparison nowadays please :DD Great job

[@wretchedslippage3255]

"some great looking arms and hands". SOLD! Im fucking sold. Im buying it.

[@wretchedslippage3255]

Basically if we could get everything about Session but with XLs controls it would be the perfect skate game.

[@ExStepsister]

Idk man, I really like having to catch your flip tricks and brace when you're doing high drops. I wish skater XL had a hard mode, but maybe I'm just a masochist.

[@sentelnbalivebolton7399]

Sessions sound more authentic but XL look badass its the lighting for the most part

[@Th3g4merb0y]

You commented “first” so nothing you say matters

[@suttichatnilkuha7637]

First

[@logan4x6]

Second

[@shane4429]

Ow

[@fullsendcamosesh4782]

When session drops the finished edit you’ll see a giant difference skater xl might be similar to madden avatars

[@ea-sk8er_775]

The issue with session is that it doesn't use physics, it tries to emulate physics but it's all animations based. Skater XL is not animations based it's physics based just like the skate games. So while session might look prettier the whole point is gameplay and session really lacks. Say what you want about realism but a game has to be fun first, and skater XL achieves that while still being very realistic. I don't see session ever having better gameplay because of their animation lock on type system. It's just not really fun. I bought session and had a horrible time, I skate in real life, am a master at gaming owning over 400 and grew up with Tony hawk and skate and man session just leaves too much to be desired. With skater XL I was doing awesome lines in no time, the modding support is so much superior and the community keeps making amazing maps, what more is there to say. Physics based skateboarding games win every time.

[@chases.536]

I bought both on the same day back in March. In week I had 30 hours on XL and barely over an hour on session..

[@tremolony4924]

u can keep hoping and wishing that session will look better in the future... by the time skate 4 comes out session will be forgotten...SXL on the other hand need to hurry up & implement mods and community maps for console... they should even make DawgvinciXXL / babbo / sound mod standard inbuilt features of the game...

[@Jer9-Carver]

Nice comparison, though considering you had issues with speed with the ramps is likely due you didn't seem to know that pushing in Session had a gta mechanic. Where if you rapidly tap the push button you get up to a faster maximum speed. It will help you getting air time a lot better. Also I feel the object dropper should have been mentioned during the map comparison part since it allows you to place down new ramps/rails and other objects to turn locations into good skate spots. Hell, you can even reach higher locations with it if you stack them up like a staircase, haha. Can't wait to see your 1.0 Session vs SkaterXL vid in the future though. Your comparisons are awesome!

[@majiidsalim1703]

What if the creators of session and skater xl went together to make the ultimate skate game. What a dream

[@ca_ja25]

Fax, the graphics and skate board customization of Session, with the smoothness of Skater XL

[@Zunigafeid]

Nick I love your videos I find myself sometimes just listening in the background because I find them so relaxing lol

[@hipsterdoofus1332]

I recently bought skater XL on PS4 and although it’s far from great it’s pretty good to stick on Spotify and just skate around grinding rails n stuff

[@bjornzek]

session literally sounds like you’re constantly skating on sand or gravel or something

[@pearbuns101]

It literally sounds like the ground he was skating on in the clip. The skating sounds in session are way better than xl except for the grinding

[@Dman130]

That sounds realistic

[@DLoading1477]

U dont skate its almost perfect how session sounds

[@eatconcrete6443]

That’s how it sounds on the east coast

[@bjornzek]

Doulton M it sounds realistic if you have really shitty wheels on a really cracked and rough road, that’s just my opinion

[@maad1670]

Great video, but I just wanna say you should've mentioned the realistic-leaning EA's Skate more instead of the arcadey THPS, because Session and XL are more akin to EA's, making it more fitting to be compared to.

[@joejoe2658]

excellent topic and video. as a life long skater, XL has been amazing over the last 18 months (and it's coming to switch, at 60fps apparently). XL is like learning a string puppet. i'm not so keen on session...

[@Drummaniac17]

I'm also a skater but I personally prefer Session over SkaterXL (both are fantastic imo), but I'm curious what about Session are you not so keen on? For me, Session's controls are slightly more true to life which is why I prefer Session.

[@FALLENSK8ER1995]

Drummaniac17 also for me with session doing grinds and all that feels more akin to Tony Hawk, since you actually have to do the motion with the stick in order to even get into the grind, whereas in skater xl you just land on the rail like ea skate

[@Wurldly]

After 20 hours of game time on SXL, I love being able to control all my tricks and transitions with only the analogs. It’s rather intuitive. -edit- SXL with mods is a superior game.

[@TheSamuelCish]

I tried out Session just now (Aug. 1, 2022) and it doesn't seem to be in much different of a state than shown in this video. Just letting anyone know who happens to read this and is curious as to the state of that game.

[@creativeyoutubename664]

Both games are insanely fun! Sessions for hardcore rewarding gameplay and Skater XL for a more arcade feel that never gets old!

[@koston777]

I want skater XL playability with Session's detailed graphics. Lets call it Skater Session

[@MrRobertGillan]

Session XL

[@HrsnOnYoutube]

Session is awesome and I have high hopes for it but it is a bit more clunky whereas Skater XL feels very smooth

[@NoahSties]

Skater xl is a lot more fun to just pick up and play at this point, I agree

[@HrsnOnYoutube]

@W J It's true, Session is in a worse state at the moment, mechanics and animations are smoother/better in SkaterXL

[@TheRyanAkers]

@W J Yeah, it's not about difficulties. It's about the FEEL of the game. Session is super clunky and strange feeling. SXL is super smooth and fluid. Very pretty animations.

[@marshalonegaming]

I like more Session tbh, for me its somehow more realistic and it feels harder to play do tricks etc... skaterXL feels like arcade

[@harlem710]

Session 100% .... the core is there & the mods make up the rest in its current state. its also getting a huge physics overhaul shortly.

[@FinnSwede906]

Was getting pretty burned out on Skater XL on my PS4 and realized last time my kids were over I was having more fun playing Skate 3 on their Series S so I was delighted this morning to see Session deluxe edition for half off on the PS4, it's downloading rn can't wait to try it out.

[@jachymdolezal5103]

you forgot to mention many detailed control features in skater xl. For example, you can make the tricks look more real. You can do manual and wiggle with the character with the other joystick. Furthermore, you can do one trick 10 and it is always a bit different, so you can add your style to the game. I play both games, but I prefer skater xl because it gives you more freedom.

[@mikepandel1646]

Skater XL has been my go to, I like the feel of it. I'm excited for some bigger maps over time. Only thing I really don't like about the game is when you fall you can't just get back up and start skating. It sends you back to the spawn point.

[@dibudabug8099]

session marker? duh

[@mrmcgiggles]

I feel like this video fails to actually explain the intention of both these video games. Context is huge. They're both designed to be "simulations" to some degree and fill a void that Skate 3 left, so you choosing to feature clips of how Sessions and SkaterXL both do a poor job of handling your 720 hardflip off a building is missing the point by a longshot. It looks like you spent about 5 hours with each game and didn't really spend, what I feel to be, an ample amount of time connecting anything the games do or do not do in relation to how skateboarding is realistically accomplished-- or what skating actually looks like. If you actually watch someone who has spent a lot of time learning the nuances of the game, you'll find both look incredibly realistic and accomplish what the developers set out to accomplish with skateboarding "sim". Additionally, I don't think any of your graphics comparisons or criticisms (except for character models, they're inexcusable garbage across both games) come from a place of game design or the titles play-ability but instead come from a surface level objective criticism. For example, pointing out that Session's shadows are darker and therefor better.... but not touching on the fact that visibility in the game suffers from this decision incredibly while maybe SkaterXL's lack of dynamic shadows is actually a deliberate choice so you can see where you are going. Like, not every game needs to look as good as Ghosts of Tsushima, some decisions are made in the graphical department so the games can get more frames per second and that maps can be larger with nearly every object having dynamic collision... which is the core feature of a skateboarding sim and why very few skateboarding games actually look good. And lastly, you didn't even mention SkaterXL's community. The modding community makes SkaterXL 90% better then what it is off the shelf and was a huge factor in why I stuck with that game versus Session.

[@Worry888]

yep this guy really doesnt get it

[@maximilianschaffler9981]

Yea i feel like the graphics are worse so that they can release this game on Switch and other Consoles, i mean for me at least this is Huge! Such a good game on the go, with some Community maps build in (I find it very cool of the devs that they include Community maps on their 1.0release, it shows how they think about the future of the game)!

[@Chocoburger]

I know these games are made on tiny budgets by a small indie team, and hopefully they can improve their games where it counts. One thing I didn't see you mention was how in Skater XL you spin in the air super fast, like in a THPS game. That comes across as out of place for a simulation game to me. Thanks for making this video, if for no other reason than to reinforce the reasons why I love the THPS series so much. Pure fun, no bullshit.

[@zonkbronk5260]

the in-game clip making on skaterxl is next level and on session it's just not the most intuitive unfortunately

[@brodienevens6557]

I mean session has its right to. Its completely still in development. Xl is a full release.

[@zonkbronk5260]

@@brodienevens6557 very true, im excited to see what's gonna happen with session!

[@borf1042]

@@brodienevens6557 its kinda a full release they added it to consoles early so they get to experience the new updates like pc did

[@brodienevens6557]

@@borf1042 it says directly on the thumbnail in the library pre release. Aswell when you open the game the first screen is a huge statement stating its pre release. XL is sold on a hardcopy.

[@nowhere1734]

@@brodienevens6557 wait xl is full release?? for the price yikes

[@Dalton_Boardman2000]

Both avatars each look like different types of serial killers.

[@Whybot182]

I have both, I have been playing Skater XL a lot more lately, the controls are just fantastic, then I went back to Session & I was like 🤮🤮

[@Whybot182]

@Drew Biggah Gonna be honest, Skate doesn't take much skill, neither does Session if you know Skateboarding, it's the same controls as Skater XL, it's just really sluggish right now

[@Kornholic]

@Drew Biggah Skater XL might feel more "casual" to you because the controls are actually intuitive and smooth unlike Session's controls, which are very sluggish, clunky and not fun to play.

[@dhaloh]

@Drew Biggah Session's controls are absolutely disgusting when it comes to being satisfying and smooth. They feel clunky.

[@z0mbiezak]

I never really noticed it, but Skater XL grind sound is nearly identically to the older THPS games. Personally, I was a fan of Session more than Skater XL mostly because it allowed me to mimic the Skate button mapping with the Legacy option. But, Skater XL feels a lot more polished to me at this point. I can at least do smith grinds in Skater XL. One thing I'd like to see added to Skater XL is a "bonk" type feature. They have the various powerslide methods, but if I could flick both sticks up or down after doing an ollie, this "bonk" feature would make things look a lot smoother than a perfectly timed "nose manual".

[@HumptyDumpty88]

I was literally looking at these two games this morning debating about which one to buy. Good video, thanks.

[@boyifyoudonttt]

skater XL all day trust

[@gordo4300]

if you can get skater XL for like $30 then go for it. it’s much more polished than session atm but really not worth the $40 they’re asking imo. might be when/if they add more features like multiplayer.

[@Diamond_2403]

@@gordo4300 Nah it'll be worth the $40 dollars when they add more maps.

[@paullucci]

Like you said, they both need tons of work. I've played a lot of SkaterXL, and I have really grown to enjoy its controls, even over Skate, but I need more challenges, objectives, etc. I can't imagine any casual player getting into either game for very long.

[@GabrielLima-ig1hx]

Steering in sessions look like the character just pooped itself , its ugly af

[@DustinNuttall]

Session looks and plays better and you can customize your camera view and controls.

[@Laoskennet]

Session has better sound but skater xl is more fun. I have stayed up all night playing skater xl cuz i just moved out

[@bighungry98]

Session: Looks better Skater XL: Plays better Winner: Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1 + 2

[@shockhs7371]

one problem that I saw in both games is when you finish the tutorial and later you don't have any objetive to do.

[@jarnold1789]

Personally that's what I like about Session. Feels real. You just explore and progress

[@Glizzy93]

That’s how it’s supposed to be, it’s a simulator, both games are meant to just be skating, not some random story.

[@jarnold1789]

@@Glizzy93 Yeah its way better without that kind of fluff. I put 24 hours of playtime into this game faster than anything else I've picked up in a long time. 30 hours in and it just gets better as you go, just like real life

[@benjaminschultz6501]

This truly helped cement my decision between the two games. Thank you so much for this direct comparison!

[@Freaky_Z1mos]

Session looks like skate 3 bit better graphics but still awful. Skater XL looks amazing!!

[@ntsakomathebula4840]

Session needs to update gameplay. Make it more fluid and faster. I think Session has the fortune off learning from Skater xl's mistakes and their own

[@Tombraithwaite1998]

Well now we can finally answer this debate, session or skater XL? Final answer: Tony hawk pro skater 1+2 remastered.

[@crillz9660]

i have tony hawk and skater xl, if you want the nostalgia, then get tony hawk. but if you like the game to be more realistic and challenging, then skater xl is actually pretty good, especially if you play on pc so you have access to the mods

[@G0ingN0where]

I’m so happy to see a realistic skateboarding simulator released on console. I dreamed of skate 4 for years, but this will do nicely!

[@joejoe2658]

@Bruh Moment skate is left in the dust by XL, u know that right?

[@fuadrahman2783]

Joe Joe you can’t compare skate 3... 10 years ago to skater xl. I’m sure a billion dollar company will create a better skate game modern day. Skate 4 will be far better. And everyone shut the fuck up about loot boxes. Ea literally can’t do that in skate 4. If there’s a board you need to pay for, DONT fucking buy it. The game will be great, Mark my words. Come back to this in the next 2 years

[@luiscarvalho7899]

As someone who owns both games: SXL shines at the grinds, they really, really, REALLY nailed it, but the game is kinda unbearable without physics mods. Every trick is too floaty, ollies are ridiculously buffed to the point you feel like you're playing a THPS game. Session is all about the simulation, sure, it's janky and stiff as hell and grinds sucks ass, but as a "straight out of the box" product it's feels more complete (even if it's still in early access) and it's way more challenging to learn and get good. It already comes with several control options that in SXL you'd have to download mods to have it. My verdict is: SkaterXL is the better option BUT ONLY with tons of mods so you don't lose interest after 20hrs or so. If you don't like going through all the hassle of installing mods to have a real challenging skate simulation experience, go with Session. That's just my honest opinion, based on someone who skates IRL and prefers simulation over arcadey gameplay.

[@1venusflytrap]

i agree but once stat menu is in the base game (which is coming) itll be muchhhhh better. youll be able to change it to be as realistic as u want :)

[@luiscarvalho7899]

@@1venusflytrap oh so good to know this! thank you!

[@slappy1312]

tsuki you mean sxl will get a stat menu without mods? if so thats dope

[@stutterdelldawkins2.068]

Ive actually been waiting for someone to make one of these

[@walzyswag]

session looks so stiff lmao

[@grusome3141]

Right!! Iv always thought that, to me it looks like the skater sits still an the world moves under it lol

[@PumpkinSmasher85]

I've always thought skater xl looks too loose and wobbly. Have been playing it a lot recently though while I wait for session updates, definitely needs a lot more work.

[@Kornholic]

It plays stiff, too. Skater XL is the superior game.

[@adlermatson]

sessions pushing animation is so bad 🤢

[@milhouse777]

It is

[@chadwohlgemuth849]

What are you even talking about with the ollie from session. the view is behind where he is rollling and you press down with the right and up with the left joystick. Where is the 90 degrees the controls are rotated at?

[@pw8416]

Skater XL is hands down better for skateboarding. Session just seems over the top and looks unrealistic with tricks tbh. Skater XL just flows better tbh and I feel like they focused way to much on the look instead of feel in Session.

[@pw8416]

chris ortiz I get what your saying but session looks so awkward. Dude goes like 4mph and barely ollies. Dude looks stiff. I’m just not into it. Obviously skater xl didn’t have as much graphical work but to me it just feels a lot smoother of an experience than session.

[@pw8416]

chris ortiz skater xl has a low Ollie for a reason. You don’t have to do the ridiculous ollie

[@inercy738]

Bullshit

[@isaackle]

Let’s be real though; Who cares about textures, lighting and character models in a skate sim? We want proper physics and good feeling tricks. That’s it. We want Rails, ledges, ramps and flat ground working how they should. That’s it

[@kimgonzalez1591]

I never noticed how bad the animations and game play was on sessions compared to XL

[@TrevWard-G]

Honestly session looks and feels better, the sounds are more realistic, like the grinding, its not so smooth like skater xl puts it out to be, grinding in real life is like gridy and sounds just like that. One thing i do wish is multiplayer and open world for both games.

[@henkaan7741]

I still think skater xl looks better graphically for some reason

[@1venusflytrap]

same. i think its the animations

[@rilili]

just want to say that even with the floaty gravity in skater xl, if you become fluent enough with the controls it can look just as realistic if not more realistic than session.

[@user-os5sd7sz4v]

But sometimes is not good. For example if you wanna do a cab tail slide on a small hand rail u have to hold both triggers to spin fast, but by doing that you make a super high Ollie, so if you wanna grind a rail like that you have to Ollie way before the obstacle. There should be a button that would allow to rotate fast like when u hold the triggers. Also they could apply some damage to the board as you are using it.

[@LanceHarbor_]

Pablo holding both triggers does absolutely nothing. They cancel each other out

[@user-os5sd7sz4v]

@@LanceHarbor_ on skater xl it does, it allows you to spin faster