Nier 2010 vs Nier Replicant | Graphics Comparison | Final Version

[@angelodewitt6336]

Yoko Taro without money vs. Yoko Taro with CASH

[@walidos195]

+ 10 years

[@milk-el8vq]

@@walidos195 budget still has something to do with it tho

[@walidos195]

@@milk-el8vq yes of corse , budget, techno, time, and they didn't change the whole game, they changed the graphics aspect and some game options

[@danielwieczorek1186]

replicant looks amazing but graphics wise it doesnt look that good

[@royolaniye6643]

@@danielwieczorek1186 ARTSTYLE it's not aiming for Realism

[@zoruasnivy]

The fact that the original still holds up speaks volumes about the smart decisions they made about the art style.

[@zjuraeventide8949]

It could have been so much worse, given that most games back then would have this muddy look to them.

[@thegatorhator6822]

In some ways it kind of looks better. Character models had more personality to them in the old style. They're more generic anime style now.

[@critical-thinker666]

it holds up... to 15 years old graphics XD

[@maytizevb]

@@thegatorhator6822 this is the bait

[@michaelmonstar4276]

I wouldn't say that this "holds up". - The thing is, though, that low resolutions, blurriness, aliasing and other issues just ruin a lot. - If the same game was run at a higher resolution, textures wouldn't have been compromised as much, anti-aliasing was used, and performance enhanced, it would just make the game as it is look so much better without really changing it. - So it MIGHT hold up, but not in this form, in my opinion. - Same goes for a lot of that generation, especially on PlayStation 3. - Games that were supposed to look beautiful, like 'Heavenly Sword' and 'Dante's Inferno', or 'inFAMOUS' and 'Red Dead Redemption', just suffered because of the PS3's stupid architecture. - I wish these and others would just get a remaster, at least.

[@ninjaydes]

Biggest difference: the down arrows don't poke as aggressively.

[@janterri3539]

Lol true

[@jamfilledjars]

I’m glad I wasn’t the only one to notice that precise thing the most out of everything else.

[@jaehaalexander1172]

This video is literally "How the game looked when I first played it vs how it felt" like dang dude the quality is amazing

[@ZonnexNecton]

When folks wondered why Skyword Sword HD for the Switch does not justify the huge price, show them this. I love Zelda, but I feel Skyword Sword HD needs a bit more than just an upscale and Switch control adaption.

[@WednesdayMan]

Skyward Sword HD is just going to be hybrid emulation (Part emulated, part running on real hardware) like Super Mario Galaxy was. there's no way they'd be able to get it improved like they did here, where they actually HDified everything to the point that it NEARLY qualifies as a remake. considering the price of Super Mario 3d All stars, Skyward Sword HD should be $20

[@t_tmad5293]

@@WednesdayMan Even if it's just a “texture upscaled” version, a modder managed to do a better job than Nintendo. He made a mod for Wii's version in which he re-creates the textures in 4k resolution and very high quality.

[@ShadowLucario64]

@@t_tmad5293 have you seen those u real engine ocarina of time remakes by modders they look beautiful nintendo don't care about make their game super pretty as long as it's fun

[@brotbrotsen1100]

Is the world in replicant slightly bigger in scale or does it just look like that?

[@gran761]

@@WednesdayMan it wont nearly qualify as a remake because they didn't build the game from the ground up.. Because they still use tHe same engine graphics nier replican remaster it feels like a ps3 game..

[@RasoKye]

1:07 night and day difference. Holy shit.

[@cesarborrego6542]

Explicaciones para los que se preguntan porque cambió el personaje: El juego original nier replicant que dónde sale el niño es la versión japonesa El otro es Nier a secas o también conocido como nier gestalt fue la versión que sacaron para el mercado fuera de Japón tuvo una cuántos cambios pero el que se nota a primera vista fue el personaje ésto fue para que fuera más aceptado en el mercado fuera de Japón

[@srflipx]

Y que dabes

[@FrancoRojas-95]

aaah, gracias por la aclaración por el dialogo del libro supuse que era el mismo pj pero igual me era confuso.

[@Taro_SMT]

El Gestalt (Nier adulto) tmb salió en Japón, la diferencia es la consola (Replicant=PS3, Gestalt=Xbo360). Fuera de Japón solo se vendió el Gestalt y lo llamaron NieR a secas.

[@cesarborrego6542]

@JGerardo cambia la historia ya que en la versión adulta es el papá y el jóven es hermano de entonces cambia un poco las historia y la relación entre los personajes

[@rc_ancap]

@JGerardo los cambios son mínimos y únicamente en algunos diálogos para adaptarlo al contexto.

[@bellinbluee]

This is one of those times where I'm astounded because all this time playing the 2010 version felt like playing the 2021 version until the graphics were compared side-by-side. Like with Wind Waker and Wind Waker HD

[@Airik1111bibles]

Yeah our brains fill in the holes.. That's how it was back in the day , games made your imagination work more. ...I still like the older atmosphere in many remakes that usually is lost. Like Deus Ex , that one lost its golden hue effect which really hurt the feel of the game imho. This game does look really nice BUT it did lose a bit of that other worldly look.

[@OwenWalker]

Nier (Father) has such a goofy run animation in the OG...

[@mybestfriendisaduck7992]

Yeah😂😂

[@fabiobalassia]

That's the dad shuffle™

[@Raquya]

The amount of watermelons I left out to die and dry still haunts me. Edit: Holy shit the graphical upgrades are insane,.

[@gtafan110010]

The lower resolution and bloom of the original gives the image almost a waterpaint kind of feel at times. I think 2:31 is a good example. It looks nice sometimes. Heck, it sometimes looks like a precursor to Breath of the Wild, although that's coincidence of course.

[@codshin]

I thought the exact same thing. This and the different lighting and (sometimes excessive) bloom result in somehow "warmer" sometimes even mediteranian looking scenes. Nier Replicant now looks sharper, but also colder and even more desolate. ^_^!

[@theKRAMNELLAo7o7]

1:28 was the standout for me

[@imo098765]

@@theKRAMNELLAo7o7 for me the snow looks better in Replicant it feels colder and harsher which fits an empty snow filled city. but then the reverse for 2:32 that looks vivid and bright to a more dull area

[@theKRAMNELLAo7o7]

@@imo098765 Oh yeah--don't get me wrong--the new one is better. I was just pointing out where I had noticed the painterly look, which still looks nice in it's own way.

[@infinimension5015]

i actually kind of preferred the way the interior of the library looked in og nier

[@RainingFlow19]

I do love the skybox of original nier. Quite contrast to the field.

[@redhawkneofeatherman261]

The difference is amazing. I'm glad both versions exist, because they're both good in their own way

[@kevinvu5432]

The original Nier Gestalt was OK at best. It's definitely has not aged well. You must have a thing for barebones RPGs.

[@bigblujay9729]

@@kevinvu5432 The original aged very well actually. You must have bad taste if you think it's barebones.

[@kevinvu5432]

@bigblujay9729 I remember how much of a slog it was playing the original. Weapons didn't feel that great and everything was muted and desolate. Dark Souls offered me more variety.

[@bigblujay9729]

@@kevinvu5432 Neir and Dark Soul has nothing in common.

[@sausage5488]

The improvement is huge, thank god for this remaster existence.

[@yherok]

Remake

[@sausage5488]

@@yherok it's new coat of paint, some improvements and additions therefore it's a remaster

[@sausage5488]

@Face ME it's just really really good remaster lol

[@FarikoWishless]

@@sausage5488 The lines are blurred for what’s a remaster and remake these days. This is a graphic upgrade like a remaster but change gameplay and combat like a remake would. FF7 and RE2-3 Remakes were more drastic upgrades this ones blurring that line because the foundation while janky was still fairly modern. The others were PS1 games.

[@FarikoWishless]

@@sausage5488 Not to mention Spyro and Crash Bandicoot keeping the gameplay but being night and day visually with some QoL changes yet those are called remakes. A remake is building something from the ground up in its real definition. So if this didn’t use the old games engine and assets it is a remake.

[@skyriotAndKadeGaming]

This remaster is sort of reminding me of Xenoblade DE in a good way, I'm glad that remasters now aren't shit as they used to be. Its getting to the point where they all look like proper remakes now which is what I always believed remasters should really push for. Its also a reason why I'm disappointed in the Zelda Skyward Sword HD remaster because the difference just feels really subpar compared to these

[@betofrederick1769]

Difference between remaster and remake, nier sits somewhere in between.

[@JohnSmith-uu5ov]

This is probably only a handful of times when they made a decent remaster, they kept true to the original.

[@mateoreyes6921]

Yeah This game, the one from the first Resident Evil in Gamecube and Yakuza Kiwami In me opinión the Best remasters

[@eking-knox5632]

​@@mateoreyes6921 The ones you mention aren't remasters, they are remakes.

[@arekusuripa]

@@eking-knox5632 actually, Resident Evil HD Remaster is remastered Gamecube version.

[@eking-knox5632]

@@arekusuripa He's talking about the 2002 remake, he's not referring to the 2015 remaster

[@arekusuripa]

@@eking-knox5632 you're sure? His one from the first RE HD in Gamecube sounded more like he mean actual remaster of remake.

[@darkdaimon9386]

What a hell of a game. The one in 2010 was huge and the one now is so lovely. I really love this license. Story, gameplay, music, graphic style all is really beautiful 🥰🥰

[@Kumire_921]

OG Nier was so good that it felt like playing the 2021 version back in 2010, i never realized the difference until now.

[@Nantorei1]

Es simplemente bellísimo lo que hicieron con esta nueva versión que no se limita solo a las gráficas me hubiera gustado ver una comparación directa incluyendo ataques con la versión original de Replicant en lugar de versión Gestalt o tal vez las 3 versiones juntas

[@acedcx6705]

pero por que cambiaron el aspecto de nier , si estaba bien ya que al ser viejo se le veia con mas sentimiento y pena en el juego

[@orellanazurie2comer]

@@acedcx6705 dos razones una tiene que ver con drakengard y la otra te lo explica reincarnetion , en resumen lo hicieron para que fuera mas concisa la historia sabes que está saga es muy confusa cuando cronología se refiere .

[@pedrodiaz3653]

@@acedcx6705 porque el chaval es el original de la versión japonesa (se que llego cinco meses tarde)

[@La-hora-del-terror]

@@pedrodiaz3653 exactamente, el padre solo fue porque Square America, dijo que el juego si lo vendian con el niño no se iba a vender y le impusieron a Yoko Taro hacerlo en adulto. Dijo que no porque ya tenian mucho trabajo echo con el Nier hermano y alego que cambiarlo en ese momento haria que el juego tardase mas debido al bajon de moral que iba a suponer empezar casi desde 0. Asi que sacaron Replicant solo para la PS3 exclusivo en Japón y el Gestalt para 360 en Japón en el que llevas al padre, luego sacaron el juego con el nombre de NieR (a secas) para PS3 y 360 fuera de Japón y era la version Gestalt para las 2 consolas. Por cierto, parece que solo Alemania, Renio Unido y USA querian al Nier padre, los franceses querian al Nier hermano y parece ser que muchos franceses importaron el Replicant desde Japón. No he jugado al Gestalt asi que no se como sera el padre pero lo que he jugado del Replicant 1.2 (que ha sido la ruta A entera) prefiero al Nier hermano.

[@Catboost]

4:47 No water ripples from the player character, no waves lapping at the shoreline, water looks worse in general, no shadows cast by the buildings, no rolling mist/fog effect.

[@Zephyr-lp2mi]

In terms of water effects old>new but thats all that I can agree on here

[@Catboost]

@@Zephyr-lp2mi most of these are just kinda. Objective observations.

[@Zephyr-lp2mi]

@@Catboost ik but most of these observations are abit exaggerated, this game doesnt seem to be the same case as dark souls remastered which literally just turned up the brightness of the game which just made the textures look even more aged, what ive seen from gameplay is a pretty good improvement from the 2010 version, its not a next gen build but it looks faar better than what we had

[@TheHammerGuy94]

The one thing they left in the original that they can remove in 1.224 The loading screens when switching areas... Most of the world of automata can load pretty easily going between locations. Could’ve made quests grinding faster

[@TheKewlPerson]

It's crazy how much of an improvement there is between only one console generation

[@MrDarkSephirot]

Two consoles generations (PS3 vs Xbox Series X)

[@mouadelmoujaddidi6580]

@@MrDarkSephirot - The game didn't release on next-gen, it's backward compatibility

[@MrDarkSephirot]

@@mouadelmoujaddidi6580 Oh I see, my bad. It is one generation indeed, there's not even an enhanced version for Pro/One X

[@littlegloom]

@@MrDarkSephirot Yeah I don't get why that's the case. Automata had an enhanced version :|

[@eternalinnocent9506]

@@MrDarkSephirot it is enhanced for the series x since it has the super fast loading, and the resolution is Def a bit better

[@Camdavis11]

The water is a downgrade for me. But this remaster is pretty interesting! It brings a new feel to Nier and to me actually stands apart from the original, I think its worth owning both.

[@assistantmagus5213]

Shame seafront wasn't included, that was one of the more noticeable ones for me, the new one feels like it has a lot more vibrant detail in the buildings and feels more like people live happy lives there, similar to how they improved the village

[@Ni4JeR]

Oh man, I'd wish I could play this game right now, I loved Automata and I never played the first one, but I don't have much time and money :(

[@aquamanxz2]

Get a job and make time. So long as you are alive there is time. But kidding aside. I feel you, man. Games are expensive and there are so many responsibilities as an adult.

[@pixytorres7117]

@@aquamanxz2 "Get a job" You realize there people who can't work because they're underaged? Not everyone lives in capitalist America that can work at 16.

[@VctrWsntHr]

@@pixytorres7117 he was joking dude

[@aquamanxz2]

@@pixytorres7117 I was kidding. Didn't you read the "kidding aside" part?

[@pixytorres7117]

@@aquamanxz2 No I didn't

[@JosanguzYT]

Se ve increíble y han retocado hasta la banda sonora y el combate, una maravilla

[@santiagoezquerrocordon1470]

Cuando en tu video decias que habían mejorado mucho los gráficos no me imaginaba que tanto. Pensaba que aumento de resolución y poco más.

[@finalfantasymax7]

in the remake, the shadowlord still has gestalt running animation,

[@EvanIsGolden]

I noticed that a while back.

[@flashentretenided3816]

NIER 2010 parece como si estuvieras dentro un sueño , algo borroso , lugares que recuerdas de manera sencilla sin muchos detalles. Y Replicant parece que despertaste de ese sueño y todo se nota con mucha más claridad.

[@IamFatcat.]

Se debe a los filtros nebulosos y marrones muy comunes en la epoca de la septima generación. Eran usados para que pudieran llegar a los 720p sin que las consolas explotaran.

[@flashentretenided3816]

@@IamFatcat. que buen dato amigo muchas gracias aprendí algo nuevo sobre los videojuegos.

[@Fran_622]

Uff, qué regulero se veía el Nier de 2010, incluso para su época xD. El Nier Replicant le da un lavado de cara muy bueno, en algunos apartados hasta parece un remake.

[@saannntii__]

Es un remake

[@joeld5338]

@@saannntii__ es una mezcla entre remake y remaster como el remaster de xenoblade

[@NDSiXL]

If any of the nier music was playing for this video than that'll be even a better video

[@melxb]

they really cleaned it up, that's how u do a remaster if u aren't going to do a full remake 👌

[@rubenjorge13]

It's a remake

[@melxb]

@@rubenjorge13 it's remastered still same assets under most everything, a remake to me is closer to a reimagining, almost ground up work, like shadow of colossus, demon soul's, ratchet and clank etc this is more like mass effect, u touch up some textures, maybe some terrible models, but it's all still there really, but definitely better than some remasters that just up the res and fps and call it a day

[@JackFrost-1856]

bruh wut? This is a night and day difference compared to Mass Effect, which is a remaster. This is a remake, there's entirely different assets on everything. Pretty sure it's confirmed to be using the NieR Automata engine as well.

[@melxb]

@@JackFrost-1856 no it's not really, every game website and channel including the devs themselves even called it a remaster

[@melxb]

@@JackFrost-1856 also idk if automata was made on the same engine and vice versa but they did say they wanted to tweak some of the combat to feel a bit more in line with automata and sure u may feel it's touched up more than mass effect but it still is a remaster...even if u take it to add better things it's something a remaster can do too

[@ganon01ryanoutsen92]

Wow that was 11 years but changes a lot. Just like BotW

[@otter1268]

I gotta be honest, though the visual of the 2021 version is an upgrade on every level, the higher light contrast and yellowish color tone of the original gave it a more atmospheric feel compared to the neutral gray tone of the new version imo

[@ryanontheradio4258]

The warmer colors and deeper blues of the water feel so much nicer in the original. The newer one feels a bit washed out in comparison. Much finer graphics however. Neither are bad, like others say. They both have their individual charms.

[@Chris-td2os]

Es una obra bellisima este juegazo y ahora se ve mas hermoso que nunca ,ojala pongan la skin de Papa Nier

[@Nantorei1]

@Mauro Martinez trajeron al elenco original de voces en inglés no dudo que puedan traer también a quien hacía la versión del padre

[@lexmanoctun3266]

Pues en los avatares de regalo viene el del padre, no me sorprendería si luego sale como skin

[@enmgame8056]

A mí me atrae más que sea el padre y no el hermano la verdad me parece un vínculo más original o más interesante

[@armandocarrion479]

Hubiese sido bueno que nos den un modo dcon el papa nier al termianr el juego, habria sido lo mejor, pero bueno

[@jordiguerrero9633]

@@enmgame8056 pues precisamente papá nier fue creado para personas como tú. Al final SE tenía razón y la figura paterna atrae más de este lado del mundo

[@SHINONIKAGE1080]

Tengo ambas versiones de ps3 y siempre me pareció que Nier Replicant tenía una ligera mejora gráfica o tal vez una paleta de colores era más brillante, no me extraña que luzca tan bien el remaster. Me da mucha ilusión jugarlo al fin en español😎

[@johnnyk3917]

This game does justice to the concept of making a game look how it felt when you first played it

[@bosnianlain]

i hate this statement people make, you can still enjoy old games on modern times, consumerism has destroyed your sense of opinion

[@GRAHFXENO]

I love both NieR 2010 and NieR Replicant 2021 and I've platinum'd both games, BUT I think I like the PS3 version more because the horrible graphics were actually kinda charming in a bizarre way. It's hard to explain, but I just find the humble, simplicity of the original's graphics/gameplay worked with this production. It's almost like a cheesy b-movie where the charm is lost with higher production value. The dated graphics (even at the time it was released) of 2010 NieR fit better, in my opinion. It reminds me of Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon on N64, a game with relatively bad graphics which ultimately adds to the overall charm and gives it an earnest look. Anyone else feel this way, or am I just crazy? Either way, I like both versions overall

[@xxBXTxx]

I know what you mean 👍

[@juststainsz]

man for the time nier looked sick! never played it back in the day but playing through replicant now is amazing. hope they do a next gen upgrade sometime down the road for series x and ps5 just to make it that much more, even tho the graphics already look dope i would just like more settings like turning off motion blur and shite

[@MikaelaCaliber]

The original game is so nostalgic... I miss that game.

[@ShiningLight]

I'm one of the few that liked the brother char more than the father.

[@MarcBR1]

Yep! Father >>>>>>>>>>> brother

[@ShiningLight]

@@MarcBR1 for me is the opposite :) I guess to each their own.

[@bosnianlain]

funny how the old one, in open areas, looks way bigger because of the blurring and low resolution, while the remake keeps everything clean, kinda breaks the illusion that you are in a big space and everything looks very close.

[@revalution1965]

How does the original still hold up THAT WELL

[@robertfarquhar2780]

I imagine it's the depth of field, bloom and brighter colors is what makes the old version hold up so well.

[@Needformadness2]

It doesn't

[@Meracog]

I'd say it holds up but not well.

[@revalution1965]

@@Needformadness2 for a lower budget game in 2010 I’d say it holds up as well as red dead 1 or bioshock 2 just look at the daughter/sisters room if you told me that was from the remaster I would believe it but it’s mostly because of the grayer tone and how smooth everything is

[@Needformadness2]

@@revalution1965 idk, i can still easily tell the 2 games apart

[@tHeWasTeDYouTh]

great video. you have amazing videos and I am happy more people are watching then but not only that big game websites have links to your videos

[@darkanimne]

2010 character looks like more mature and badass. I think 🤔

[@panadolf2691]

2010 character models look even more natural and life, and 2010 Kaine is pretty and 2021 Kaine is ugly.

[@oux3456]

The first release had two versions , Gestalt (father) (xbox360japan- xbox360andps3worldwide) and Replicant (Brother) (ps3 japan only) they only remade Replicant (worldwide)

[@Z7SMAD]

@@panadolf2691 are you serious??? Kanie in old version looking fucking ugly

[@littlegloom]

It's because it's not the same character

[@fes8807]

@@panadolf2691 2010 Kaine looks like an egg

[@Lintahlo]

I like the original colour palette more. And playing as the dad character instead is my preference too.

[@P.au.lo--Cesar]

I love this song. Beautiful...

[@visualnovels]

It's too sad

[@granthamlin8126]

@@visualnovels Fits the game then.

[@Mark-nh7zg]

I like the warmer tone of the original.

[@ALBERTOGG.]

Para ser de 2010 se mira increible ahora mas :0

[@diegoval7240]

Uncharted 2 el 2009 se veía 10 veces mejor

[@josecarlostorres7374]

@@diegoval7240 Juegos muuuy distintos

[@ALBERTOGG.]

@@josecarlostorres7374 si es como comparar gta v con halo o god of war

[@LeoMisterio2001]

@@ALBERTOGG. Parece que lo hacen para molestar.

[@CharLiiDewnlead]

@@diegoval7240 uncharted 2 tiene escenarios mas reducidos

[@yoshisuarez]

Sinceramente se nota que le han puesto cariño 10/10

[@Dodalalal91]

This is what remaster should look like Nintendo Pokemon.

[@alanvasquez6923]

It seems to only be a gamefreak issue since the xenoblade remaster was pretty good

[@elkmeatenjoyer3409]

This is a remake dude.

[@josephine.1226]

There is absolutely nothing wrong with 2010 version. I love whole franchise, btw.

[@anceru5801]

the remake needs that green tint

[@xix967_5]

2010 was still in the era where games wanted a dirtier look I think. For example SR2 and GTA 4, it does make me enjoy it differently, crazy how graphics and soundtracks have that much influence. However, they still could not have pulled off 2020 graphics if they tried to in 2010. While the environment looks way better in replicant, i prefer the faces of characters in the original. Just like the roughness maybe.

[@hareendrangangadharan6974]

the word I suggesting is; old games looks raw more than just dirtier

[@JAZ8470]

This remake is no JOKE!

[@SALTYTOAD000]

It is

[@jeanfrancozaratemarcial7916]

@@SALTYTOAD000 With the new ending?? Yeah you´re tripping

[@RPGNoZero]

This feels like Shadow of the Colossus comparison. While the remake looks more polished and detailed, there's just something about the outlandish, fairy tale-like atmosphere from original artstyle that was kinda lost.

[@leovanilla6833]

Yeah I agree. The murky atmosphere seems missing. Same thing with Demon's Souls and that remake. While the new graphical improvements are obviously nice, they evoke different emotions than their predecessors. I think if remakes in the future somehow kept the old feelings while upping frame rates/textures I think it'd be great. But they do feel like 2 different games. The left actually feels like a distant past whereas the right looks like a sequel that is simply revisiting the old areas.

[@CatPawns]

@@leovanilla6833 the color grading on the remaster is blueish, when the original had warm colors. the remaster tries to look as automata.

[@joseazofeifa4878]

Porque el protagonista del 2010 se ve más mayor que él de 2021? O son personas diferentes?

[@DiverGM]

El NieR del 2010 tuvo dos versiones, una para Japón (NieR Replicant) y otra para occidente (NieR a secas, o a veces llamado NieR Gestalt), la japonesa es la que tiene al Nier (hermano, el joven) como protagonista, la occidental lo cambiaron por Nier (padre, el viejo), pero en esencia son el mismo personaje con el 99% los mismos dialogos, el remaster lo hicieron a base de la versión japonesa, por eso tenemos al Nier joven

[@kratosnico2306]

@@DiverGM Buena info que crack, me estaba preguntando lo mismo.

[@nonhmusic4570]

While the remake is still colorful, the original seems much more vibrant, green and light blue things are much more striking, while the remake blends them a bit more, and also the lighting is weaker in some areas, some look better some could use more light, anyway looks nice though

[@Jeremy-uz6ve]

2010 brings a more God Eater Vibe

[@S_A_M_6251]

Did the MC go from Part 1 to Part 5 of Jojo or is it an other character.

[@DeskoDev]

Replicant Nier is Yonah's brother, Gestalt Nier (the only one we got) is Yonah's father.

[@juansnowgaming]

¿Sería posible hacer un video comparando autómatas con el replicante 1.22? Me encantaría ver las diferencias en texturas y animaciones.

[@hanchiman]

Strange that back in 2010, I thought the graphic in Nier was amazing and as realistic as game technology could, but now looking back to the comparisons you can see the difference with PS5

[@jonathanfabian]

That never happens, Nier looks like a PS2 game.

[@CharriiiLandak]

@@jonathanfabian Wii games to be exact

[@squidgybuffalo]

In some small occasions the original looks a lot sharper and more shiny!

[@danielcastrillon7643]

Me alegra tener está oportunidad de jugarlo con gráficos mejorados. Siendo franco la versión que llegó de PS3 a occidente no lo jugué porque no me llamaba mucho la atención el protagonista. Por lo visto soy de los que hubiera preferido el protagonista de la versión japonesa, así que me llega perfecto este remaster.

[@lafleur9277]

Pienso igual. Me atrae muchísimo más la versión del hermano, así que jugar este remaster/remake será mejor opción.

[@Demetrix982]

Lo había visto en imágenes y otros gameplays y no notaba tantísimo cambio... Pero el juego se ve increíblemente mejor, casi al nivel de un remake

[@Nothingelsematters.]

De verdad que sí, las comparativas no hacían justicia, se nota una generación de diferencia casi, de PS3 a ps4

[@Demetrix982]

@@Nothingelsematters. Sí, había visto videos donde decían que los mayores cambios eran los modelados de personaje y combate, pero los escenarios y fondos tuvieron un lavado de cara muy bueno!

[@furbi963]

Es un Remake 🐵

[@Demetrix982]

@@furbi963 Mmm nop, realmente no es un remake, es un remaster muy bien hecho + contenido adicional descartado en el juego original

[@charlieotoole5343]

I’m completely ignorant about Nier lore, why is the main character so different from the original? Any particular reason?

[@BunnyBoiler72]

The game was originally meant to be about a teenage boy caring for his sister. But Square Enix felt that westerners wouldn't like the brother/sister dynamic and had it changed to father/daughter for the western release. So the old footage shows the father character, and the remake is using the original brother character.

[@aceyaeger9041]

OG NieR looks flat compared to the new remastered version. Pretty much everything is much better. Full voice acting, much better graphics, all character models were redone, music was re-recorded, new story scenarios were implemented, the battle system was completely overhauled. I remember not being able to dodge while being in an attack animation in the OG NieR.

[@panadolf2691]

2010 NieR wins. It had better character models.

[@KaiSoDaM]

if a hobo is a better model... ok

[@mybestfriendisaduck7992]

Ok

[@carloscelano4617]

I platinumed in 2010 not because of the graphics, but of the music and story.

[@deusvlad2.083]

I'm surprised that they still can't swim in replicant, like it would of been awesome to have an underwater area swimming and fighting in the ocean and rivers would of added so much more depth

[@TheHipisterDeer]

They completely changed his original design he went from looking like a Chad man to basically a teen boy I'm not really a fan of that... Graphically thought the environments look fantastic in this remaster.

[@oux3456]

The original design is the brother. Back in 2010 were made 2 versions: Brother and Father, broher being the original ans a japan exclusive and Father was made for appealing the west

[@excitedmilk6046]

Based on the person above me, it seems that this is a remake of the Japanese version of the game. Or something. It's a regional difference

[@Floodsye]

So...I'm unfamiliar with this game, probably will buy it and play it since I loved Automata, but what happened to the main character in the remake? Is it a totally different character or did he just stop going to the gym for 10 years? I know the original release was weird with a totally different, alternate universe version in Japan/the rest of the world type thing.

[@hashtagtylerh]

Japan OG: MC is a brother to the sick girl (called Replicant) Western OG: MC is a father to the sick girl (called Gestalt) Brother MC has never had a Western release until now with Replicant Version 1.22... Edit: Adding info., the stories of both version are the same there's just slightly different dialogue and relationship vibes due to the different MC ages

[@joshpobje6938]

the thinner protagonist was from the original (and canon) Japanese release, while the buff protagonist was a reskin and rewrite for western audiences.

[@josedejesuslopezrubio4929]

Es la música del juego?

[@mmm.3839]

Can you check out the new FPS boost games that Microsoft added

[@fettibomba4504]

?

[@NieR_Gestalt]

I actually happen to own the North American copy of NIER and a copy of NieR Gestalt from Japan on Xbox 360 in my collection

[@Shiraimai]

as do i and am proud

[@ismaelaquino5849]

Que recuerdos con el Nier del 2010, vaya juegazo

[@wiffleboroughspaticus4390]

What's with remakes and remasters getting rid of fog?? It may help hide lower graphics rate, but it also adds a feel to visuals that is quite pleasing

[@fidelfuentes966]

ojalá un dlc con papá nier

[@realxemary1785]

Te puedo decir que si sale sera una skin de papa nier para ponerselo de seguro.una historia de el lo dudo.

[@r.daneel.90]

Yosuke Saito, productor de los juegos de Yoko Taro, dijo que si vendia la mitad que Automata podrian incluirlo. Osea, 2.5 millones ventas (aunque seguro lo harian por bastante menos).

[@deadmeme4276]

El productor dijo que si vendia 2.5 millones lo haria

[@RockLeeBl]

Está incluido en el juego ya, podéis verlo en el tráiler del contenido extra.

[@StrangyENPP]

@@RockLeeBl, queremos los que jugamos ver los argumentos del padre. No basta con tener las 15 batallas.

[@accipiter4349]

I think they could have added some more details to make the place look less empty. The area between villages has so many space yet there's only a few animals and shades. Even the village is too spacious it's empty.

[@alexandregiaccheri]

I'm 99% that's intentional

[@MariusMerchiers]

Nier 2010 really looked good for it's time. Very clean or is it running on emulator?

[@bryansvoboda5970]

In the first few seconds he states that the Nier 2010 footage was recorded on a european ps3

[@0-Seya-0]

Did they completely change the main character? Never played the games but i liked the old battered character on the left.

[@slashinghades7347]

It's the opposite actually. Young Nier was changed to a dad in the original western release.

[@predrtor4fun910]

lol the old man from 2010 must use some dragonballs or got reincarnated into the future with Young Body xD

[@jandavidsernaesquerra3443]

Hey serious question Are autómata and replicant the same Game being replicant an upgraded version, or are they, two chapeters of the same story. I mean, I'm confused, I don't know which one to Buy. New player here trying to play the Game for the first time. Please help me understand. Thanks

[@NhiroDarko]

Autómata is the sequel to replicant. Nier gestalt and Nier replicant are the same game

[@lpedrog3029]

Uma pena não vir com legendas em pt BR

[@martinsamanosoriano6118]

Esta comparativa solo me hace ver que estamos viejos 😞

[@RagnarokMic]

Prefer father Nier to brother Nier, but I guess I'll take it.

[@FALLEN9336]

Even though brother Nier is the actual original

[@haihuynh8772]

@@FALLEN9336 I mean father Nier’s design looks rugged. He looks more like a plausible part of the world, whereas brother Nier’s design feels a little too pristine.

[@FALLEN9336]

@@haihuynh8772 honestly, for brother Nier, they should have kept his older appearance through the whole game

[@burrosh5552]

Fun fact: Replicant(brother nier) was a japan ps3 exclusive while Gestalt(father nier) was xbox 360 exclusive. Gestalt was the only one to be ported to the west only under the title Nier

[@NerdInked]

The only reason father Nier existed was to appeal to the west.

[@karielmuller9101]

vas a hacer una comparativa, con las demás versiones del juego? (xbox one, ps4, ps5, etc)

[@EmaDarko]

por que quitaron al hombre?

[@VillRezint]

Porque el hombre es el protagonista de otra versión de Nier llamada Nier Gestlat, que fue la que llegó a Occidente, pero este nuevo Nier Replicant se está basando en el Nier Replicant original japonés que era el que tenía al joven como protagonista originalmente.

[@alvarobaltazar831]

@@VillRezint al joven o al flaco desnutrido ajjaa

[@kevinabanto]

Porque no es canon para el mundo nde nier

[@libezwolf9652]

@@kevinabanto si es canon pero de otra linea del multiverso, según yoko taro el creador, el hombre y el niño existen en el mismo mundo pero en diferentes universos

[@oux3456]

@@libezwolf9652 y en tiempos distintos

[@nickst2797]

Noob question. Has the main character changed? I thought the new game was a remake of the old one.

[@BunnyBoiler72]

The OG Nier was about a boy taking care of his younger sister. But they made a different version of the game, where it was changed to father/daughter. Both versions were released in Japan - Nier Replicant on PS3 with the teenaged brother, and Nier Gestalt on Xbox360 with the father. However, only Gestalt was released in the west. This remaster is the first time many of us get to play the game as it was originally intended, with brother Nier as the protag. So I'm guessing the creator doesn't have a copy of the original Japanese version and has to use the Gestalt version with Papa Nier for comparison. Hope that clears things up for you!

[@nickst2797]

@@BunnyBoiler72 Thank you! So the original concept is the brother/daughter. The one we get in the remake. This clarified things.

[@Dr.Halayqeh]

why the that strong looking man 😂 became that much cute😂

[@ztoogemcducc6360]

There are two versions of the Nier game. Nier Replicant and Nier Gestalt. In Nier Replicant you are a boy saving your sister. In Gestalt you are a father saving your daughter. Replicant was japan exclusive until now.

[@hartboxer1422]

@@ztoogemcducc6360 is the Father also in the game?

[@ztoogemcducc6360]

@@hartboxer1422 after you beat the game you can read Nier's Mother's diary and when you do you get to play some arena fighter levels as father nier. But other than that no. In the Gestalt DLC for the original Gestalt game you got to read your wife's diary and then you would play brother Nier.

[@Dr.Halayqeh]

@@ztoogemcducc6360 thanks for clarification

[@IrvingSegovia]

Ufff ya tengo ganas de comprármelo, lo más seguro para julio :’)

[@reefermon7048]

Such a huge fan of the original I still think I like it more than this version .

[@greenstuff9361]

I don’t have replicant, but is it possible to play the older looking protagonist? This dude actually looks like he can fight

[@Speedy-nq9ro]

Nope unless you buy the original Nier

[@Ozzianman]

Nah. The original releases of NieR had a japanese exclusive version named Replicant, while the western version was named Gestalt. They believed at the time that the main character being a father instead would appeal more to western audiences.

[@LIONREV7]

you can play with him in a bonus level, and they promised that if the game sells at least 2 million units they would add the dad as DLC for the main campaign

[@shim2822]

Also, before: Huge muscular character After: 9S replica

[@Zephyr_Weiss]

Can you make a cutscenes comparison video? With English?

[@angelyorha4611]

So excited to play it on xsx!

[@flufflenuggit6499]

It is time!

[@cyrlangaming]

Big Brother to Child Labor

[@SlightlyEMPowner]

Crazy how much 10 years can change video games

[@ALBERTOGG.]

4:26 no se alli nomas me gusta un poco mas el agua en el antiguo

[@alexreyez8011]

9:28 seguro?

[@ALBERTOGG.]

@@alexreyez8011 la segunda parese aguas negras XD

[@Eli-yq6ho]

el color se ve más natural que en la versión del 2010

[@hurtadodaniel7]

Hola,se tiene idea de a qué resolución está corriendo en series x y a cuentos FPS,se ve increíble

[@CrCc__]

No tengo ni idea de la resolución, pero el juego va a 60 fps

[@marcons7452]

60 fps seguro, se nota en la fluidez del juego