Can it Carry Astronauts ? Is ISRO Reusable Launch Vehicle better than SPACEX & NASA vehicles?

Recently ISRO successfully completed Landing EXperiment (LEX) for Reusable Launch Vehicle ( TSTO -Two Stage to Orbit) Segment for commercial market.
How does is compete with SPACEX Falcon?
Twitter
/ purohitmanish
Instagram
/ purohitishere
/ educationnimbus
Telegram
t.me/nimbuseducation
#jee #nasa #isro #intership #physics #jeemains #neet #manishpurohit #nimbuseducation #bhavyabapna #space #solarsystem #sun #planet #moon #isro #viral #youtube #youtubevideo #trending
#iitjee #neetug #cosmos #universe

[@sourabhsoni2930]

Lots of love to ISRO and Nimbus ❤

[@alamk1956]

An wasteful organisation; money could be better spent for buildings toilets for open pooping millions.

[@ramanathanviswanathan5640]

I fully appreciate viewing concepts and details of LEX and its future. Positive steps attaches us all to the gretaness of India

[@NimbusEducation]

❤️

[@chetanpadia4421]

Great work by ISRO really proud of my country and my country scientists. Keep it up boys'❤

[@ronnie2510]

Defeat Spacex is a big word. ISRO was never in competition to defeat anyone. Its focus has been to develop technologies independently to help the nation progress.

[@rohitsawant4452]

We have to defeat them

[@desistang8794]

I think SpaceX has already proven that traditional rockets with boosters and payloads are the safest and cheapest way to get mass into orbit, as long as reusability is addressed, which they have mostly done. This is why they are upgrading their Falcon to Starships to further increase reusability, despite the success of the Falcon and Falcon Heavy models. LEX, demonstrated by ISRO, is great for military reconnaissance missions, which is currently being done by the US with their version. However, ISRO still has a long way to go in reaching this machine to orbit and successfully re-entering Earth's atmosphere, as these are the most difficult challenges. The reason for SpaceX not using airplane-like landing like the LEX is to eliminate runway-like landing that requires its own infrastructure and space. In theory, the Starship model can land on any flat area on celestial objects that support physical entry with slight modifications. We should embrace this innovation and build on top of this idea

[@JamesBarker-yo2df]

so what about the 2nd stage? should we not reuse that as well? is Space X reusing the 2nd stage as well?

[@desistang8794]

@@JamesBarker-yo2df that's the starship project. Both booster and starship is reusable once the project is completed and successful. Falcons Second stage is not reusable.

[@saraths7147]

@@desistang8794isro now on the south poles side of the moon even nasa can’t able to get there ….

[@knowledge-21234]

​@@desistang8794but isro cant afford dozen of failed landing attemot likebstarship have they have billions over billions of free nasa funding

[@desistang8794]

@@knowledge-21234 Isro proved it can build things way cheaper than West, either way, NASA cant afford to fail also, it did take a genius and crazy entrepreneur to almost went bankrupt multiple times to get it right, now that its a proven tech, India could do what it doesn't best, make the same thing even cheaper.

[@snapshuttre]

fully cryogenic and reusable 1st stage is needed(it can be from the admire project). after that just make it way way way bigger and you got a competitor to starship.

[@PrasadIndi]

Amazing. Looks innovative. Especially the oxidiser gathering part. Only problem is our bureaucracy. It takes 20 years what Spacex does in 5 years

[@chilarai1]

A great achievement so far. The focus on commercial competitiveness is laudable as that is the future. Manned space efforts can also benefit from this once it is proven.

[@NimbusEducation]

It definitely will

[@harduttbhardwaj3072]

Sir, very glad to see someone helping us so passionately. I would gladly want a video about which is better iit or iist for students who would want to work at isro (considering all aspects ranging from campus, extracurricular activities, study, future opportunities, food with respect to North Indians, etc.) Please sir make a video for this Thank You

[@naturalworld4628]

Super.Hope India will be successful in astronomy and space technology.

[@vishal.yadav760]

Sir ji sachchi me aapne bahut jyada badiya tarah se yah topic clear kar diya.mujhe 4 mahine baad tak bhi yaani abhi tak bhi thoda confusion tha ki Apne Isro ne ye kiya kya hai.reusuable hai yah to pata tha.lekin kuch jyada nahin.aur na hi kisi aur channel waalo ne itna badiya se alag alag testing level ko bhi nahin samjhaya tha.par aapne apne ish video me sab kuch clear kar diya.aap sach me ek genuine knowledge de rahe hai ham sab ko. To sir jo aapne last stage wala reusable rocket dikhaya hai ushne Isro ish rocket ko upar space me bhejne ke liye booster ka use thodi karega. Ya yah total ek rocket ka solution hoga.seeda yahi upar jakar fir neeche aayega. Meri to yahi kaamna hai ki yah kaam ISRO jald se jald kar le. Bina booster ke direct yahi jayega aur bapas aa jayega.kitna jyada achcha lagega dekhne me.

[@edisonone]

The landing gears on it is so twig-like that the gears of a Cessna, of a Beechcraft, of a hobbyist play thing from the farming community of the Midwest is more rugged so tell us about break through it’s going to make for humanity in deep space!!!

[@snapshuttre]

there is another space plane at the end of it's development phase. it's sierra space's dreamchaser.(cargo and crew varient)

[@hardeepsaini3351]

Fantastic graphics and easy to understand explanations. Thank you.

[@dineshsivasankaran6157]

India could see the drawbacks of US and Russian space mission and deviate to the next more reliable technology. ISRO development for RLV is really amazing and at very low cost effective plan. Thanking the channels for the details ✅👍

[@amarjeetpanesar4220]

Why we perusing Shuttle type space vehicle, both earlier programs for NASA and Roscosmos were deemed expensive and abandoned including Russian Buran / Energia and Russian realized it’s expensive with one flight itself and focused back on rockets. I have my doubts on this approach if we can compete with SpaceX.

[@siddhus5012]

Quality content for space enthusiast... Very nice explanation sir👍

[@bullappa]

Beautifully explained by Mr.Purohit. thanks for making it so much comprehensible to the common man on the street. 🙏🙏🙏

[@utkarshmangal6559]

Sir you are doing great service by improving the rocket science knowledge of common people.

[@amandeepsharma4033]

Main sach me sabko yah batatana chahta hu ki sab log apana time barbaad karte h faltu knowledge leke KZbin se jo ki apne kaam nhi aane wala life me...balki aana chaiye....woh knowledge gain karo.....#nimbus me full support karta hu aap ka knowledge next lev. India me bohot Kam log h Jo acha Gyan dete h aap mere Aaj se favourite sincetest h😅 love u brother ❤ese hi knowledge bhadate raho Humara 😘✅🤗

[@musicalLad]

This video was very informative sir. I have been reading every ISRO update since the past 2 years and still some amazing things were introduced here. Can you give some more details about the ORV test? Maybe make a small video on that please. Also please make a video on gaganyaan. Thanks and all the best for the future :)

[@MuruganM-bd2ve]

Congratulations ISRO team

[@arkifoks253]

Lots of love n respect to you dear.... excellent presentation

[@snapshuttre]

the problem with space shuttle and buran was they both sit at the side of the boosters which is always very risky (check the challenger and coloumbia disaster). but interms of space planes on the market, they always sit on top of the booster and that is much safer than the previous way. great to see isro doing this also.

[@totoitekelcha7628]

Challenger and colombia disaster has nothing to do with the shuttle sitting at the side of a booster.

[@snapshuttre]

@@totoitekelcha7628 condensed ice fall from h2 tank cracked a part of coloumbia wing. That's why it was a bad idea to place the shuttle on the side of the fuel tank or boosters

[@snapshuttre]

@@totoitekelcha7628 what I have said that placing a spaceplane on top of an lv is a good idea. And placing it on the side is a bad idea.

[@totoitekelcha7628]

@@snapshuttre There is no good or bad in placing shuttle on top and side of a booster. It is purely your speculative. Do you think your payload will ne fine if the booster explode even if you put on top of it? If the booster exploded there is no good or bad it is a disaster for both the payload and the booster.

[@totoitekelcha7628]

@@snapshuttre No, Columbia disaster is very complex not only those things. Heat shield tiles are also fallen off.

[@rushilshah8717]

Sir please reply very important. Thus a colorblind (Red-green) not even accepted as coder for isro . Is there any possibility to be scientist with colorblindness

[@rajandnidhi]

Sir good information and your explanation is so good that common man can understand ,thank u sir

[@thebeuatyofnature.arvind]

Great info.sir 🎉❤❤

[@abhinow64]

Congratulations to ISRO and all space agencies for being useful for the country. I was wondering if our fighter jets like Tejus can be adapted to do this and more

[@whatthedeuce]

Sir oxidizer compression stage mein sare atmospheric gasses ko compress karega ya sirf oxygen ko separate karke compress karega?

[@tks5210]

ans is long way to go , see the size of the starship , to catch up to space - isro can’t with there approach of snail phase of progress

[@anupamyadav8282]

Thank you so much sir ❤️

[@ranviryadav2528]

Excellent vdo

[@Thanos.of.Titan.]

Thanks a lot from Japan🇯🇵

[@narendarreddysurakanti8309]

Best wishes to Isro...🙏🙏

[@satishchoudhary9822]

Love you sir aap log ho Desh ki saan ❤️❤️

[@harshitanand2333]

Why not we use same thing as space shuttles for astronauts as well as satellite launch it can be used for both purpose

[@niravmehta3103]

Great content video nicely explained thanks for the video

[@NimbusEducation]

❤️🙏

[@Thanos.of.Titan.]

ありがとうございます

[@muigoku2018]

Sir please make a video on time and theoretical physicist career plz sir 😊

[@beinghuman5285]

Best wishes to ISRO

[@amanlohiya2975_]

Sir please please reply Sir if someone is getting Aerospace Branch in IIT/NIT can he give ICRB and can he do the internship at ISRO (as u discussed in last video) And is there any specific branch to do btech to give ICRB ya koi bhi branch chalegi?,

[@SUCCESSHACK932]

In iit no ,direct job after interview to isro but for nit no big no

[@aadityachourasia2124]

I hope they have something like starship in mind considering full and rapid reusability

[@Vance_Williams]

You could never compete with Starship kids 😂 When you will send lander on mars, we would have already sent humans to mars When you'll copy starship and make your own, we would have been in Interstellar way... 😂

[@philipmelanchthon2440]

How can you compare Govt. Backing organisation va individual persons chievements???

[@subhashlata4184]

Thanks a lot Manish ji for explaining briefly 🙏 Please can you post a video on NASA’s Moon Mission in 1969 which technology and scientific theory they use that time to send Neil Armstrong, landed on moon then vehicle took off from moon and landed back to earth. Were the aware of highly charged proton’s plates in space? Please explain 🙏

[@smileplease3204]

Sir, Namaskar, very valuable.

[@arpitaghosh6808]

i want to know how to reach isro and what are the ways???? which stream will help us the most and all detail...please sir make a video on that please...

[@pkb1930]

Isro recruits through following ways: 1.icrb fir mechanical, electronics, computer science. 2. IIST B. tech placement. 3. M. Tech few vacancies based on specific discipline. 4. Placement in some good iits, nits and few other reputed college. But very rare in these.

[@tananatung1]

Nice one

[@rahulshahare5]

m following space projects from the last 4 to 5 years, yeah specially spaceX. SpaceX actually wants someone to use their current tech as they made it open-source but they need more ships to go beyond very fast. I want #ISRO to use spaceX tech and update it as per our specialized expertise

[@raghu_rsb]

ISRO is a highly efficient and well-managed organization with current allocated budget for the fiscal year 2023-24 of ₹12,544 crore (US$1.6 billion) which is 8% less than last years budget I whish they manage with all their projects with this budget especially launch vehicles which I'm eager to watch further the falcon kind. They are doing the best they could with such small budget where the next least budget of other space agencies being 6.4 billion.

[@ddlearning9456]

Thanks isro and nimbus

[@jayjoseph3104]

ABSOLUTELY YES 👍

[@srishdevtiwari3460]

Gajab sir

[@uvg319]

Go ISRO!! 😊

[@boys300jj]

Isro will never defeat spacex they are in god mode.

[@arpitaghosh6808]

sir please make a video on how to become an isro scientist.....please sir

[@ajayprakashpandey5335]

It took 7 years from HEX to LEX 😅. Also it is a glide based RLV so its commercial potential is doubtful.

[@AbhishekKumar-xd1up]

Covid impacted it.

[@1236612]

Whether, or not, this space vehicle is successful, I do respect the Indians for trying.

[@AhsanAli-dl5if]

Love from kargil ladakh

[@bamaaan]

Step by step. Manned missions cannot be hurried. Also need more than 10X to 50X investment when compared to current budgets

[@vishalbansal4502]

Sir please answer kardo sir please Sir mai class 10 me aya Sir apki video dekhne me toh achhi lagti hai lekin iss level par abhi samjh nahi atti and Sir I want to isro physicst sceintist Sir please advice sir agge kaise proceed karu sir please😢

[@dipakborade1026]

ISRO don't need to defeat anyone just fulfill India's need

[@toufikkhan1215]

Thank you sir ❤

[@rishabharyan-tf7rx]

Sir how can a doctor involve in space mission. Plzz tell us .

[@dhanamjayas]

Nambinarayan's sister Elangamani is my mother in law. She has stolen my mother's gold from my locker. Everytime I am complaining to police, Nambinarayan used to scuttle police investigation.

[@saraths7147]

Who are you 😂😂😂😂

[@dhanamjayas]

@@saraths7147 Nambinarayan's Jailer! You check ✔️ his right palm, there is a sign that he will die in judicial custody or in simple language jail.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. If you want to give company to Nambu, sent me your postal address!😂😂😂💩

[@Amanda-fv2te]

Sir, Bahut achha samjhaya aapne

[@rajratanmeshram8231]

Sir I am JEE 2023 (dropper) Student.. IISF (Indian International Science Festivals) 2024 Program me, Droppers and Under Graduate BTech ke student eligible hai kya ...Ya sirf 12th class tak hi student eligible hai IISF 2024 program me ......Please Reply😥???

[@mahanpathak24]

SpaceX Starship is the same. Isn't it? But with a payload capacity of 100 metric tons. Both stages are reusable. it will become one SpaceX vehicle for everything. Very successful Falcon 9 and even Falcon heavy will be retired. Does this mean that ISRO intends to capture the market for smaller payload launches that Startship might not like to carry?

[@quantumphilosopher1729]

Sir isme rotating detonation engine kyu nahi lag sakta

[@KrishnParth712]

Hello sir I am Parth and recently I have given JEE 2nd attempt. I want to become an ISRO SCIENTIST but I won't be able to clear jee advanced in 1st attempt. My basic aim is to become a scientist so so sir should I take a drop or should I become scientist in any other field. If I should choose 2nd option so what iare the competitive exams and college I should join. I won't be handle this pressure I think if any other choice would be there then I will not take if not then surely will take a drop. HARE Krishna ❤️

[@pkb1930]

Isro recruits through following ways: 1.icrb fir mechanical, electronics, computer science- this is open competitive exam. 2. IIST B. tech placement. 3. M. Tech few vacancies based on specific discipline. 4. Placement in some good iits, nits and few other reputed college. But very rare in these.

[@SaiKiran-ok9cq]

Bro Icrb exam would be there for getting into isro Mechanical, electronics engineers would be recruited as scientists in isro from this exam Do research about this exam and you will get to know about it

[@krishnananal8106]

Please stop this nonsense of comparing ISRO with SpaceX. We are still in the process of establishing ourselves with very meager funds. We may have many ups and downs in our journey to reach the top. Still that time, let us keep quiet and work hard. We will get our time to blow our trumpets. Please be patient.

[@vkrsoft]

When would ISRO have its own Space Station like ISS or Tiangong?

[@surilmehta2215]

Hail ISRO

[@dimitrz2000]

People need to understand that ISRO is not in competition with NASA or SpaceX . Objectives and mission goal of all these agencies are different.

[@ravishankar-rv1yh]

MADE IN BARATHA JAY SCIENTIST FOR INDIANS SUCCESSFUL ISRO JAY HIND JAY HIND JAY HIND JAY HIND JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY

[@AloneMusk211]

This spacecraft is so crazy😁

[@sundararamans654]

Let us pray the God that every future projects of ISRO will be successful.

[@ajjutube6320]

bina engine or propulsion ke relanding kaise kar raha hai

[@madankuma9953]

❤❤❤🎉🎉

[@starman9000]

Why the question of defeat!! We would like to try our ability, not to defeat anyone!!

[@deveshanand7534]

well the simple answer is no, first of all you are using the wrong question........

[@a.s.h.I.s.h.2.1.6]

👍👍👍👍👏👏👏

[@quantumphilosopher1729]

Sir rlv ki details kaha se padh sakta hu

[@sumantmaurya369]

Sir IIT Madras bs electronics pe ek video bana dijiye plz

[@vinod_kumar_28]

Difficult but not Impossible! 🇮🇳

[@user-zy3hb1cu1k]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@lokesh303101]

Mounted on GSLV MK-III.

[@thePerseption]

sir make a video on gaganyaan

[@MathsRevolution369]

❤️❤️❤️

[@graineryoftruth7183]

❤

[@cseonlineclassesmalayalam]

Instead of competing ISRO and Tesla, working together is the best option. Very valuable and informative video.🔥👍 Thank you

[@sahilsandhu1969]

I wish DRDO was working with this dedication. We wouldn't be in situation where we spend countless money on defense imports and still have shortage of defense equipments

[@manumudgal4988]

The problem is not weather ISRO can do it or not, the question is that weather funding of ISRo will increase or not.

[@chiranjiv1361]

is booster recovered?? That is very costly

[@Meska604]

Love you sir

[@Denzonggaming]

Will iISRO able to defeat SPACEX ? where is answer

[@prasanthpr274]

No way. Until and unless active private sector participation is promoted.

[@DD-kr8dm]

Thank you Sir. You have done a great job for the enthusiastic common people. Hope you will do such tries in future too. Better to do little more home work to avoid jumbing from one point to another and again to the previous. More over you did not explain how it is beneficial than Spacex. Bura nehi manleejiye.

[@NimbusEducation]

The video mentions clearly that cost per launch will be the biggest factor. In the commercial market that only will matter. Anyways thanks for appreciation, surely I will keep doing the videos. Jai Hind 🙏❤️

[@TheINDIAN]

This is taking the Russian Buran Shuttle concept and make it far more simple by removing the engine completely and using the shuttle as a pure cargo vessel . And placing the shuttle on top of the rocket. If the main rockets can have the space x reuse capability then ISRO will be way more profitable.and more bigger projects can be undertaken. We should make space x and nasa join us .

[@narayananunnikakkat4819]

Yes

[@ravishankar-rv1yh]

MADE IN BARATHA JAY ISRO WORLD NUMBER ONE SPACE STATION WORLD NUMBER ONE INDIANS SCIENTIST JAY HIND JAY HIND JAY HIND JAY HIND JAY HIND JAY HIND BHARAT JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY BARATH JAY