Nine Inch Nails - Broken (first time EP reaction)

[@kirawasareactor]

come tell me to react to downward spiral - patreon.com/kirawasareactor

[@ionsbrewable]

just do it! only joy will you find :)

[@rodger1nin]

yes.. I do believe so.

[@bryanjacobsen5005]

Do it! Plus, The Fragile, which is in itself a masterpiece.

[@johnmaynarich6943]

Downward Spiral is peak NIN. You've built your way to it properly. Fun fact: the peak never ended.

[@AlldayAudio]

i dont know if we are prepared for how much you'll enjoy TDS and then the Fragile.

[@ingoschmitt7972]

now you are ready for "the downward spiral "

[@mattvsmetaverse]

More like, "now you are ready to not be ready for The Downward Spiral." 😆

[@sandyyorke413]

The padawan is ready for her first test.

[@j_clarkson]

Nobody is ever truly ready for The Downward Spiral.

[@superunknown2812]

Fixed.

[@batman66ism]

She has to listen to the continued Fixed cd first. Such a mind blower. But so is the spiral as well. If she loves outros she'll love this one.

[@dfbovey]

This is when Trent really started to find himself and create what would become his signature sound. Perfected on the next two albums. Downward Spiral is a top 10 album of all time for me, and The Fragile is also amazing.

[@TheAsphyx666]

"Fragile" is an absolute masterpiece. Listening to it in one go is mindblowing.

[@dfbovey]

@@TheAsphyx666 Agree. Downward Spiral is more my vibe, but I love The Fragile as well.

[@SamFerguson]

I think the story is mostly apocryphal, but back in the day the story on the Internet regarding "Wish" and the Grammy award was that Trent said he wanted his headstone to read "Said 'fist-f**k', won a Grammy" XD

[@Scottie_McNaughty]

You're slightly off. He was trying to break his record deal with Broken, because the label wanted NIN to go in a U2 direction. So he recorded Broken in secret, then brought it to the label, who reluctantly released it. When he got a Grammy he was shocked, because he was trying to go as hard against the mainstream as possible, which is when he joked, "my headstone will read, 'Trent Reznor said "fist fuck" won a Grammy & died." I remember this as it was happening, reading magazine articles in 1992, before the modern Internet, which started in 1995... In 92 there wasn't such a thing as websites. Just chat rooms where computer geeks would type. Practically nobody was online (I was one of the geeks, so I remember that too)

[@SamFerguson]

Well, I'm just happy that my recollection of 30-year-old chat rumors was at least marginally correct 😆

[@07BSPtC]

@@Scottie_McNaughtyyes chat rooms, groups, and irc was about it.

[@voidwraithprime8521]

Most reactors start with The Downward Spiral and don't really "get it.". I feel it important to have the foundational albums under your belt to fully appreciate where Trent goes with the next few albums, so kudos to you. You didn't right, Kira.

[@kirawasareactor]

i always try with the important bands! except with opeth... i did them out of order WHOOPS hahhaa

[@Houldey]

with opeth imo it's just a case of better late than never, just get your foot in the door - wherever it is :P

[@voidwraithprime8521]

You're going to love the next few NIN albums

[@Purge00]

Waiting for it to blow your ears off.... 2:52 AND THERE IT IS LOL. Perfect

[@tomgrant29]

My cheeks are hurting from smiling lol, your reaction is basically the same as mine when I first heard this a long time ago :)

[@joshuamiller8259]

You have to watch the videos for this ep. It adds a whole new dynamic

[@sarccastro7879]

Also, a band that just came out last year feels like it's right in this pocket. Their self-titled EP "PUREST FORM" is spectacular and their follow-up single "Burn" is wonderful, too. Do check 'em out, they're my favorite new band.

[@thedanitone]

I’ll have to check them out! Thanks for sharing

[@sumonjamal1653]

Trent Reznor was heavily influenced by Ministry on 'Pretty hate machine'... NIN's debut album. On the 'Broken' EP, his musical vision became more original and NIN truly became a revolutionary musical project that would eventually bring the creation of their 1994 masterpiece album 'The Downward Spiral'... Ministry is also a great band to check out... albums like 'The mind is a terrible thing to taste'... 'Psalm 69' ... 'Houses of the mole' ... 'Dark side of the spoon'... etc.

[@chrisbergsten1429]

Yeah, if Kira digs the heavy guitar parts on Broken, she should definitely hear Ministry's The Mind Is A Terrible Thing To Taste or Psalm 69, if only to hear the influence on NIN and industrial metal, but I think she might be into it.

[@sandyyorke413]

I though the his first LP was pop Skinny Puppy, and Broken, Ministry. TDS is a God damned masterpiece.

[@samhainkid]

@@sandyyorke413 agreed

[@dinocam08]

He joined him on stage at least once - no higher praise IMO.

[@CitizenScorn]

Everyone else has said it, but imma say it again... I CAN'T WAIT FOR 'THE DOWNWARD SPIRAL' REACTION!!! 😂 Love the channel, keep up the great work.

[@atrus3823]

After close to 30 years as a NIN fan (at one time a die hard), I actually think this is their best album. It is just the most intense and visceral.

[@TheAsphyx666]

I feel like the industrial/electronic fans perked up their ears when "Pretty Hate Machine" came out. "Broken" was when the metal crowd got it as well. You will love "The Downward Spiral" and "Fragile" as well. I love watching your reactions. You display such a positivity, open-mindedness and genuine enthusiasm for music. I have a feeling that if I ever actually met you, you'd instantly become one of my favourite people ever. 😁

[@DrTim0thyLeary]

Yes! Love this EP. Before you go in to the Downward Spiral, it's good to know that it's a concept album that tells a complete story from the first song to the last. Keep that in mind when you listen and it'll make a lot more sense.

[@kirawasareactor]

ohhh that is good to know thank you!!

[@NBizn]

@@kirawasareactorYou also need to know that The Fragile (double album, with Left and Right sides) is superior to Downward Spiral in every way…but Downward Spiral is a great album.

[@xtldc]

@@NBiznAgreed. I consider the Downward Spiral as a top-tier album that still holds up 30 years later, but The Fragile is superior. I’d even venture to say that if the Fragile was released just as Disc 1, it would still be the better album.

[@DrTim0thyLeary]

@NBizn Interesting take, because the fragile is the album that made me lose interest in the band. But I guess we like what we like.

[@j_clarkson]

I think The Downward spiral is a more focused, concentrated album than The Fragile which can feel a little bit too much to digest in one sitting at times.

[@NoBrakes23]

The Adam Ant cover was a hidden track on this EP back when such things were kinda rare. I believe that Adam Ant had high praise for the cover.

[@billrobertjoe]

hidden tracks are rare nowadays, the 90s was the era of every other fucking album having hidden tracks

[@alejandromolina2435]

amazing cover!

[@Scottie_McNaughty]

Mine didn't have hidden tracks, I got one of the more rare mini discs with Suck & Physical... Skipped school to get it on release day

[@nathanpapp432]

​@@billrobertjoe You can hide tracks on a CD by just not letting anybody know they are there. Its kinda hard to do that with digital media, lol.

[@whitelikejesus]

Happiness In Slavery is my favorite song of all time so thank you for the validation. :)

[@kirawasareactor]

U have great taste !!!

[@Gizank]

The Fixed EP of remixes for this is also excellent. It features some excellent producers, and is the first (and maybe only) time I heard what sounds like a CD being skipped forward as a musical device.

[@brendanlong8872]

I would love for someone to listen to fixed. I love it, but its such and out there EP, I'm not sure how most people would accept it lol.

[@OneHipNinja]

I think fixed might be something to come back to after a few more releases because it's, well... challenging.

[@superunknown2812]

Fixed is a great ep probably one of there best of remixes for sure

[@dinocam08]

Personally, never really liked fixed - though at the time I was much more broken - might revisit now from a better place.

[@_portis]

NIN was ahead of his time for sure. Especially when it came to the Downward Spiral release. Groundbreaking. Pretty Hate was one of the first 3 cd's i ever bough in '89. I liked electronic sounds back in the day, and heavy stuff too, so NIN hit both of those with Broken & Downward Spiral. Cheers!

[@DanMilliganMusic]

Your energy is so contagious.

[@johnmaynarich6943]

wore this cassette out in my walkman in high school. love that you are enjoying it so much.

[@TrentonHawk]

I'm stoked you choose to react to the entire Broken EP. It's a masterpiece IMO. Trent Reznor is my favorite artist period. NIN helped me get through life this far. Gave Up is my favorite all-time song because of the lyric, "after everything I've done, I hate myself for what I've become". Really enjoyed your reaction to this album. The Downward Spiral will be a journey.

[@EzraStrayer]

Downward spiral is a lifestyle. That album changed my life. Broken is so underrated but its back to front bangers and almost long enough to be an LP for real.

[@voidwraithprime8521]

There's an amazing live-ish performance video of "Gave Up" you can watch on KZbin, recorded in the house where the Manson/Tate murders took place. It's...amazing...and really made me love that song. Check it out sometime.

[@heffatheanimal2200]

And also featuring Marilyn Manson on guitar and backing vocals

[@voidwraithprime8521]

@@heffatheanimal2200 and Richard Patrick (Filter) on the other guitar and backing vocals. Just a great moment in music history!

[@lsu1992]

My first college apartment in 1992... THIS was the soundtrack.

[@red-stapler574]

In the original CD, Physical and Suck were on a separate mini CD instead of track 98 and 99 on new CDs.

[@ublej]

I still have the original CD w/ mini-disk. The problem was that people would open the package in the store and steal the mini-disk. That's why they changed the format. As others mentioned, Physical is an Adam Ant cover, and the original version of Suck (still w/ Trent singing) was on the first Pigface album ('Gub').

[@jambulance]

I still need to find a copy of that, I have all the other albums, but I did pick up a copy of the Remastered Broken on Vinyl with the 7” with the extra tracks.

[@scarce911]

The jump scare on wish got SO many of my friends...i had a ultra loud stereo system in my car and i used it properly

[@kirawasareactor]

this EP is sooo loud in parts damn

[@scarce911]

​@@kirawasareactorindeed! I was quite obsessed when these albums came out, and still occasionally break them out to breathe LOUDLY ..after seeing the reaction I plan a listening party for myself soon! ❤

[@mindful2864]

Broken is a very good EP from Nine Inch Nails. You’ll love the dark masterpiece that is the Downward Spiral as well as the more upbeat double album the Fragile.

[@jyjjy7]

lol, calling The Fragile upbeat, that's a first possibly, though yeah there are fews things that aren't more upbeat than The Downward Spiral

[@Chumblefunk]

@@jyjjy7 Using the word upbeat to describe the album with "Pilgrimage" is hilarious.

[@zenoslime]

@@jyjjy7 tho to be fair tds has a few real fuckin jams on it

[@jambulance]

The Fragile is finally getting some love in the reactor space, Fern Stone and Smags recently did videos on them and it’s such a joy to see people just have their mind blown by Just Like You Imagined, I got Smags’ patreon just to watch the entire 2.5hr video.

[@mindful2864]

@Chumblefunk There are a few dark and depressing songs like Pilgrimage, but the overall vibe of the album is more futuristic and upbeat, at least in comparison to the Downward Spiral.

[@marcusedwards8283]

I'm a big NIN fan, and this EP is my favorite. Plenty of other great stuff to check out as well, but this is my personal favorite.

[@chinard]

So, fun fact about the last song "Suck" It was a hidden song on the CD, you had to go all the way to track 99 to find it

[@antitypical1807]

Physical was track 98

[@chinard]

@@antitypical1807 sounds right, its been a while :p

[@red-stapler574]

On the first release, it was on a separate mini CD.

[@jeremiahdunn6546]

It's also an original pig pigface song

[@deathsalad2235]

Also, the original version of "Suck" is on the Pigface album Gub. kzbin.info/www/bejne/lajZfaqnYsR6ra8 Edit: Still sung and written by Trent.

[@IfYouSeekCaveman]

The Downward Spiral and The Fragile are peak

[@jyjjy7]

The Downward Spiral and The Fragile are undeniably masterpieces but Broken has always been my favorite since the day it came out. It's beautifully vicious, kicks out all your teeth then heals your wounds and sets you free, like Jesus Christ on ecstasy 🙏

[@mrmassacre3366]

Every album has its own different feel. There definitely is a nin signature sound that follows throughout, but each album is unique and different. I personally ADORE Pretty Hate Machine, but I also really LOVE synths. The downward spiral is a perfect album in it's story telling. It's a concept album and will absolutely have peaks and valleys.

[@bigguy1164]

I'm very glad to see that the 90s output has so far impressed you. The Downward Spiral required Pretty Hate Machine to establish its electronic-ness, while Broken embraced the use of live instruments in the studio TDS fuses them both. Broken was recorded in secret on Reznor's dime. TvT record wanted Reznor to make another Pretty Hate Machine, but he was not interested in that. It resulted in a massive war between record companies. Reznor spent all his money keeping his band afloat until finally Iovine showed up at his doorstep with a record company. According to Iovine, Reznor gave his demands of complete creative freedom which Iovine agreed. Then Reznor. "Oh, here's by the way. Take this. It's called Broken." and handed him the finished EP. I know you'll enjoy everything up to The Fragile, but I hope you'll keep a mind open for older, sober Nine Inch Nails. Reznor isn't a fan of repeating the past. The music gets very different. youu start to really see Reznor's future scoring career come to life and the most recent releases: The EP trilogy return to the 1990s.

[@benmason9755]

The later stuff (especially since Atticus Ross became a full-time partner in the studio) is really great too, and some of that output genuinely is AS GOOD as what we got on these earlier releases. The track Less Than is, in my opinion, one of the best singgular songs that Trent's EVER recorded.

[@maskedman1337]

"Broken" and "Fixed" are my favorites from NIN.

[@robcoz98]

Two things in regards to Physical, the roaring sound in the background comes from Trent's dog Maisie who was a puppy at the time who bit sound engineer Sean Beavan to which is you speed up the roaring before that final chorus you can hear Sean shout "Ow fucker!" Another one is right at the start you can hear Trent whisper "Eat your heart out, Steve" which is a direct reference to Steve Gotleib, who was head of TVT

[@sandyyorke413]

Long time NIN fan. No one expressed GenX rage like Trent. Won a Grammy for saying "Fist F*ck", and now does good soundtracks for Disney.

[@tommj4365]

His soundtracks are really great. Starting with Quake which is just a banger of an ambient album, he and Atticus Ross know how to immerse you in a film, yet still put out signature memorable sonic moments. I prefer it all over NIN Ghosts albums

[@tutucatoronja]

No doubt you're gonna love The Fragile :)

[@markdavy3020]

The song Physical(you`re so) is actually a cover of an old Adam and the Ants song.

[@CaseyB]

I still remember having to hit the skip track button 90-something times to get to the hidden tracks 😆

[@MetFreak42]

I was one of the lucky ones, was able to get one of the original CD realese copies at release with the hidden mini CD in the package that had the 2 bonus tracks on it, rather than later releases included as tracks 98 and 99.

[@gddsisekejd]

​@@MetFreak42my dad had one of those but he lost the mini cd while moving 😢 (my mom also has one with the 90 extra tracks so I can still listen to the extra tracks)

[@tommj4365]

I'm glad you didn't skip this one, and man you make me smile so much, keep being you

[@Phyrrax]

Happiness in Slavery is kind of like a proto Downward Spiral song, I feel like you will looove that album.

[@surrealchemist]

I used to listen to this all the time when I was a kid, and now getting into music production in recent years I can hear all the layers and complex arrangements that had went into it that makes me appreciate it even more. There are some stems to one of the albums out there online, you can hear all the elements, its interesting.

[@GoreAndPeace]

This is my favorite material from NIN. If you have the stomach for it, Trent had some “secret” videos made for the EP, and the one for “Gave Up” is straight up a fake snuff film. Trent definitely distilled his angst on this release, and it rules.

[@heffatheanimal2200]

Nah, that music vid is for Happiness In Slavery. Was banned for years

[@j_clarkson]

God, I'd completely forgotten about the Broken movie. Gonna have to dig out a bittorrent client later and track it down again I think.

[@maskmedusa]

This was the SO revolutionary, and really the origin of his genius as a songwriter/composer. You have no choice but to listen to “The Downward Spiral”, and “Fragile”. Then your life will be complete.

[@fearlessvinyl]

i just knew you would lose your mind for this album. outstanding reaction!!

[@Metrikon9000]

I honestly can't wait for you to react to both The Downward Spiral and The Fragile (Left and Right). Those albums are two of the most impactful works of pure art in my entire life. Also, after listening to The Downward Spiral, I would highly recommend watching NIN's Woodstock 94 concert footage, or at the very least, their performance of Happiness in Slavery. It's absolutely monstrous- aggressive, dirty, and visceral. One of the most iconic performances of any metal or industrial band ever, hands down.

[@josephboulet4477]

If you like NIN, I highly recommend going through the whole discography in chronological order. I was first introduced with the album With Teeth so I give much praise to that one. Also really liked the ep Add Violence.

[@SPVFilmsLtd]

24:01 - Compositionally, Trent Reznor always writes his songs as long build-ups with the full realization of the song in the outro. That explains why you like them so much - going forward, especially in THE DOWNWARD SPIRAL and THE FRAGILE, you'll come across dozens and dozens of tracks that build up towards a huge climax and outro. Nine Inch Nails doesn't usually blow their load on the chorus very often, they're much more rare songs compositionally.

[@claymccoy]

30 years later, Trent Reznor wins multiple Oscars for composing music in films.

[@AaronBish]

Suck is a song he did with Pigface. I think there was a fight with the record label about his involvement on the track, which is why it was originally a hidden track on this EP. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nIamZH-CbdqIfLM

[@deathsalad2235]

Gub is an amazing album.

[@marcocostacalatayud4175]

You should watch their live show at Woodstock 94….BEYOND EPIC!!!

[@sarccastro7879]

It was so wonderful watching you fall in love with this in real-time

[@Gr13fM4ch1n3]

So excited for this NIN journey.

[@MikeSlansky]

This brings me so much joy, thank you

[@roneon4]

I love the fact the Broken was produce in secret and with a lot of anger against TVT Records(owner) during that time. Also the freaking Gave Up video in a way gives a look at their studio during that time and the infamous "Tate house" which Trent was the final resident.

[@cjonesufc]

I bought this on cassette when it came out. The whole beginning of side 2 was blank until the end when Physical fades in. It’s actually an Adam Ant cover and I saw NIN in Worcester, MA (US) play this the only time Adam Ant joined them on stage to perform it. Also, when the song comes in you can gear Trent whisper “Eat your heart out, Steve” which was directed towards Steve Gottlieb of TVT Records who wouldn’t let him out of a bad contract. This EP was recorded in secret and dropped after he was free from his obligations. So glad you liked the album. It was absolutely breathtaking when it dropped. Also, if you ever get a chance to see NIN live DO NOT MISS IT. Out of hundreds of shows I’ve been to they put on the best shows every time. By far. Closest thing to a religious experience I’ve ever had.

[@AnotherFacelessDigitalNoOne]

True fan 💙

[@AdamHodges-o6x]

I love hearing you sing along!!!😊😊😊

[@aliased2098]

Now you have to listen to Fixed, the remixes from Broken. Coincidentally, the best one is the remix of Happiness in Slavery.

[@Mobiggs_]

This and Nirvana "Nevermind" were the first 2 albums I ever owned. Still holds up. :)

[@Jefwth1F]

You're gonna have to dive into the live performances too. Especially Woodstock 94.

[@RunawayOcelot]

The Downward Spiral and The Fragile are peak NIN. Can't wait!!

[@cap873]

Reznor's first album was under the TVT records label. The label didn't want him to "evolve" his sound and wouldn't let him out of his contract. Fortunately, Jimmy Lovine from Interscope saw his genius and essentially bought out TVT. Interscope also gave him his own label, Nothing Records. Then the genius of Trent Reznor was truly unleashed on the world! Notable: Reznor signed Marilyn Manson to Nothing Records.

[@troytalbot5746]

Broken was an EP Trent wrote out of frustrations with his label, TVT, which had him touring non-stop. Interscope eventually got TVT to sign over NIN and allowed Trent his own autonomy on their label. Trent already had Broken written and recorded and launched it with interscope right away, the lyrics reflecting the intense frustrations with TVT. Trent also set aside a rule that Broken was going to be more guitar based. He has different instrument/arrangement focuses for each album/EP. (The Slip is supposed to sound like it was produced in a garage with little budget.)

[@alejandromolina2435]

Gave up is amazing! cant stop losing my mind to that song haha

[@antonbelyaev8295]

You're gonna love Downward Spiral

[@sk8erburd]

This started the career of Richard Patrick from filter. He played guitar in nine inch nails, and marilyn manson did cove vocals in this album. Trent went on to produce marilyn mansons album the antichrist superstar.

[@dhf030475]

Check out their performance at the ‘94 Woodstock. Happiness in Slavery is one of the highlights

[@swimdog]

Cant wait for you to get to The Fragile, easily their best album (and one of the best ever...)

[@Sir_Robocop_jr]

“Hes good at song writing” that is an understatement of massive proportions lol. Just look at all the movie and video game scores hes done on top of his music for nine inch nails.

[@CraigSkinflute69]

You 10000% gotta do the remix album “fixed” some of the greatest production evee

[@ionsbrewable]

Yes. :)))))

[@Metallniete]

Wow, I've got to admit that I never listened to NIN, but I very much enjoy these electronics. They're about as good as in Kraftwerk, but just a whole different genre. So much more metal, and really well done!

[@ogey_elise]

"Happiness In Slavery" goes unbelievably hard.

[@stopbunsen]

Gave up is my favourite. It's even better live

[@Theinfamouskira]

AWESOME! This is so cool, more NIN please! The best is yet to come, I promise

[@exploringwithasmr]

Perfect EP

[@richardloganpowelliii4850]

The heavier sound heard here is a great result of how the PHM songs were played on tour. The band made them heavier and meaner. According to lore, a major force was guitarist Richard Patrick, co-founder of Filter.

[@oppaipoison2074]

the fragile is nins best work to me!! and it was released on my birthday hehe (21 sep 1999) but im 2001 lol

[@Playongo]

I was 15 years old when this came out. Blew my mind.

[@jareds.e.8504]

Nine Inch Nails just announced today that because some dates of their upcoming world tour have leaked, a tour is confirmed. I think you owe it to yourself to see them live if dates are announced near you. Honestly, some of the best live experiences I've ever had were Nine Inch Nails concerts. The production matches the music's energy. You will not be disappointed.

[@marksmith2402]

Loved your reaction. when you finish your NIN journey, you should check out some of the earlier industrial acts - Ministry, Skinny Puppy, and KMFDM, and see how that evolved to NIN.

[@macgyverman1234]

Gonna sit back and have popcorn ready for your reaction to The Downward Spiral. I don’t think it’s possible to listen to that album and not be permanently changed by it.

[@jamesmcdonald2680]

1/3 of all cars in the high school parking lot had a NIN sticker on the rear glass in 1997.

[@chrisbarber1046]

When i saw your reaction to 'PHM', couldnt wait for you to hear BROKEN. =Awesome reaction!!🙌❤ -That was my first reaction to it also!lol Love that EP, still to this day!!! As a metalhead, dont think he ever topped this. I really like DownwardSpiral & Fragile, but not in the same way as Broken.

[@JadedHunter]

The first nin album I bought was "fixed". I only bought it coz there was a song called fist fuck. That set me on a path to downward spiral

[@iandawson6461]

Just know that this is probably the heaviest NIN project. The Downward Spiral is an entirely different beast. Heavy in it's on ways, and one of my all time favorite albums.

[@lewiswhitling1351]

just discovered your channel - huge NIN fan so looking forward to your future reactions to it, but most looking forward to Ghost Reveries!

[@KennethGong-s2t]

True story, when I was an intern at Wax Trax records the founders of the label Jim Nash and Danny Fletcher told me how they had misplaced the demo Trent sent to them. Imagine the world if they had signed NIN instead of TVT, but then maybe without the pure hatred Trent had for Steve Gotlieb, the band might not have reached the heights they did. Jim and Danny were such characters, rest in power!

[@jebraymer]

Physical is actually an Adam Ant song, but your point of Trent being a great songwriter still stands.

[@zenoslime]

now you're gonna have to do what i did after hearing nin and listen to skinny puppy, ministry, coil and other amazing '80s and early '90s bands in the industrial genre

[@zenoslime]

also uh btw i say that but like... explore nin and think about nin! we had all of the '90s to love and understand trent then, and the guy scores so many movies we see now. it's wild.

[@HamsterCaster]

Physical is an Adam and the Ants cover and Suck is a Pigface cover. On the CD they are tracks 98 and 99.

[@jameswarner5809]

I think you're going to like The Downward Spiral when you get round to it. Plus the stand-alone track Perfect Drug, not so much for the guitar, but because it's a rollercoaster ride.

[@nothinghaloart]

M.manson is on backing vocals and guitar on last 👌

[@MetFreak42]

A YT uploader called "Landon Ashbrooke" has the Videos tape uploaded, labeled as Closure DVD 2. From what I see so far, it looks to be intact, unedited or blurred.

[@efroster123]

Please react to ALL of their EPs and studio albums. Including their Quake soundtrack.

[@thedanitone]

Blessings to the person who requested the Broken EP! It was my first NIN purchase, The Downward Spiral was out at the time but I didn’t have enough money to buy it. If I remember correctly Broken was on sale so I took a chance on it, and oh boy! To say it rocked my world is putting it lightly. I believe a lot of NIN fans view the Broken EP more like a full length album. I know that I do. The crazy thing is, my favorite album from NIN is The Fragile. That album is very different from Broken. Like, really different. I won’t say anything more about it. No spoilers from me 🤫

[@-Heavy-]

Now you are on the right way!Time to spiral down now and getting 'Fragile'!

[@EarfWormzGaming]

Wasn't planning to listen to this tonight, but ill take it!

[@deadso]

FWY: Pretty much all of these songs have a music video, the VHS Closure contains them all, Trent released a fee to download DVD version of it a LOOOOONG while back though.