Nirmala Sitharaman's GST Hike On Used Cars Sale Stirs Debate? FM's Move To Hurt Middle Class| Watch

[@shenkipz3662]

Worst FM of India since it’s independence .

[@visusamy3749]

how many FM you considered for this conclusion ? 🤣GST is put on the basis of all state finanace ministers acceptance she cant implement anything on her wish

[@Deekshith-bs4ql]

Used Car Selling has no Tax if Individual sels it...only for comertial selling like a company, Bussiness used cars only need to pay tax

[@chandrandec31]

​​@@Deekshith-bs4qlthat too when the car company adds value and sells it for higher price, one has to pay the tax for the additional amount.

[@moviesee7465]

She will delete BJP from India like indira deleted Pakistan from Bangladesh aka East Pakistan. Never to be able to stand again.

[@Zackmeranaamhai]

As if she is solely making decisions going against the whole cabinet

[@amitjena1556]

Even Godi anchor didn’t like it 😂😂😂

[@RKV8527]

Her husband, about her, is 100 RIGHT. Tax terrorism only on middle class, pensioners and senior citizens. Nirmala Sitaraman earns several pensions, each MP, MLA term earns a separate pension packet, but she is against pensioners. It's an old strategy to constitute committees, if one is convinced of the merits, but does not want to give approval. GST on insurance has gone to the committee. She appointed Attorney General against the Bank pensioners in the Supreme Court in a case that pensioners won in several high courts and she refused to obey the court order and pending in SC. She had extracted a public apology from a Coimbatore Businessman, a humble, respected BJP supporter who canvassed for ANNA Malai elections. His crime was that he requested a uniform tax on bakery items. He had said that on one dining table for a family that takes lunch, the GST rate is different for each item. She will bring down the Indian economy, BJP supporters are scared away, especially middle-class pensioners and senior citizens. Corporates pay 25% tax Middle class pays 30%. and add GST, road tax, land tax, petrol tax, building tax, and professional tax, total tax is 60%. Look at the amount written off in banks. Corporates securing written-off, 25% tax, do not make private investments They clap and praise Modiji. NH toll is huge Middle class pays 60% tax and pay NH Toll as well.

[@ganeshkarra180]

Senior citizens pay more tax than regular earners as - tax on life time savings, with no life / medical security 😢

[@Deekshith-bs4ql]

Used Car Selling has no Tax if Individual sels it...only for comertial selling like a company, Bussiness used cars only need to pay tax

[@Rohityadav-nv4do]

@@Deekshith-bs4qlare bhai agr tum true value me jaoge to aapko tax dena dega individual person to person nhi dena

[@humbleindian6303]

yeh tax sirf company gadi pe hai, sarkar har transaction pe tax le sakti hai, 2nd hand gadi me bhi tax hota hai, jo gadi kharidega woh tax dega, agar aap gadi me modifications karke aap higher value me bechoge to tax to dena hi padega, bas isme maintenance aur modifications ke tax credit milna chahiye

[@kenibose2008]

She is the Pappu of BJP.. she alone is enough to bring BJP down..

[@abdulfarhan3810]

U literally seems naive🤣without the confirmation from PM, FM never implements such taxes🤣.

[@jacksparrow308]

Worst FM in Indian History

[@Joe-d8g]

Best FM ever , this only effects used car dealers,

[@aashutoshpatle2374]

Tere pass car hai. ?​@@Joe-d8g

[@amanrajpoot.ar04]

but i think the economists, bureaucrats who are suggesting these new laws to the FM are also equally responsible. Obviously, FM will not make these laws on her own, she will simply approve/reject, what her team is suggesting to her.

[@abdulhannanmohammad378]

This is not done by Finance minister . This done by super vikas prush modi ji government and governance.

[@mannkibaa.t]

​@@Joe-d8ghaha gazab bhakti h re tera

[@arunkumarm18]

Make Door tax 🚪 also if anyone wants to come inside or get outside home, Everyone should Pay Tax. 😅

[@Mr.LeonW.BlackQuadraRX1YAGRHTA]

We are already paying tax on it as well

[@asimmomin6479]

Ye sahi tha

[@EugenioDcosta]

I love the FM she is going to put the final nail in bjps coffin

[@b.e.ramachandragupta1720]

GST not the decision of the FM alone.

[@dropadifoundation4364]

But alone centre can reject these proposal but it didn't. That means govt want it

[@southlive4991]

If she is not going to replace definitely government is going to replace 😮

[@ajaypr68]

जनता कंगाल , और सरकार मालामाल।😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Savitribai-yf3mg]

We were hardcore supporter of BJP supporters but policies of Government imposing heavy taxes n making our life difficult.. Really unhappy with Modi's Tax Trap..

[@Finding_self]

Car purchase 12 Lakh Car sell 9 Lakh (-3 Lakh) Margin me ghata.. No GST 9 Lakh ka car salary person (individual) ne liya.. No GST 9 Lakh ka car resell company ne liya.. marmmat kiya.. 10 Lakh me becha.. 10-9= 1Lakh (positive margin) pe GST dena hai Pahale 12% dete the ab 18% dena hai..

[@TrueForr]

"This video misses important points, making it incomplete. The tax is only applicable to EV resale when it's a corporate transaction, not for individual buyers or sellers. Plus, it doesn't apply to petrol or diesel vehicles.

[@shindeamol25]

The only correct comment I am finding on this topic

[@Terahydron]

Company jo 12 ka 18 karegi uska kharcha customer pe nahi unload karegi?

[@dreppat]

Kya mst baat boli bhai , ultimately customer hi tang hota hai. , hotel gst ya aur sab humi se wasoola jata hai@@Terahydron

[@madhuskm]

The condition of middle class was much better during UPA, in terms of personal savings among other things. Unelected people like Hon’ble FM won’t understand people’s pain. If she did, she would’ve reduced personal income tax and GST rates. We are a services-led economy and service tax is at 18%. Modiji’s name and BJP’S image are being pulled down by such people.

[@xmd2007]

The real culprit is Modi. She is just a sycophant and scapegoat

[@gurmeet-cad]

Wrong calculation.

[@Amarnath-hc9ub]

Everybody knows the huge GST collected , from middle class and poor people.Opposition parties may win future elections based on this single issue .

[@ChandraSekhar-zy8hi]

This woman is alone sufficient to topple bjp. Worst than bureaucrat. Very much determined to get bad name for Modini

[@dilipsharma3878]

Only item government is unable to tax is air.

[@rohankumarpanigrahi7475]

Air purifier is 18 percent GST

[@ramakrishnaprabhumakam1113]

What about medical oxygen?

[@Learn_with_Ari]

Don't utter that word "sir" bro.. else, she might hear/see that and tax that as well... 😂😂😂

[@cosmicheathen1955]

That's why it's toxic

[@revmure452]

Example wrong - it is on the difference amount of Selling and buying, if a dealer purchase second hand car for 1L and sell for 2L then 18% apply on 2L-1L =1L i.e 18000.

[@KhanSalman-s4h]

Abhi bhi dalali kroge ya ankhe khulegi ab

[@Trishajain009]

Finance minister ❎ Tax minister✅

[@7u7uy7uu7]

😂😂😂😂👏👏👏👏👏👏 GALAT DIKHA RAHA HAI WO!!!!! 👉👉 PEHLE RULES PADO, SIRF MEDIA PE BHAROSA MAT KARO👈👈, gst MARGIN pe lagaya hua hai - depression value pe nahi aur margin sirf salesman ya business walon ka hota hai, general public ka nahi, isliye public ko iss rule se kuch lena dena hi nahi hai, DIKHAYA HUA EXAMPLE GALAT HAI !!!!!!!!!

[@visusamy3749]

as per news GST for used EV not for liquid fuel cars .also not for indivuduls selling or buying

[@RohitSingh-lr7fn]

I am a Bjp support but hate to say that Bjp is not going to come next time. They are looting us.

[@ArjunKumar-wr4sf]

SHE SAID FIRST UNDERSTAND THE DECISION THEN PROPAGATE. NO GST FOR PERSONAL SALE. IT IS ONLY FOR AUTHORISED RESELLER LIKE SPINNY

[@gulboyrathesungod]

I don't think this is a fair assessment, for following reasons: 1. This tax is only applicable for EV used car resale. Not appplicable for petrol or diesel vehicles. 2. Tax is only applicable when a corporate buyer sells or buys it. It is not applicable for individuals buying or selling the car. So, effectively it is only for corporates. Not mentioning these critical points, make the whole video biased. My opinion.

[@TrueForr]

Thank you, bro, you gave the correct information. This video only has half the information.

[@azmathmoosa4324]

who trusts MSM these days? they are only good for HvM debates nothing else. circus clowns.

[@himanshu4uk]

Bhai tension naa log agle saal Tak petrol car par bhi ho jayegaa

[@KG-lq7iq]

How can this media be regarded as the fourth pillar of Indian democracy? 🤦

[@navin344]

High tax has killed consumerism

[@onepieceanime3114]

People saying it's for dealers but dealers will sell for more and at end middle class pays more for used cars and no penny from pockets of dealers goes to fm nirmala Sitharaman

[@swapnilchouhan4602]

Bruh ye tax pehle se tha clarification diya h bas 18% starting se lagta tha

[@AllInOne-vl2ed]

​@@swapnilchouhan4602wow .. kuch b

[@cooldjk]

She's the only anti BJP in the govt...same side goals are her speciality

[@SaifisamSaifi]

जनता की किडनी निकाल कर बेच दो

[@rajanikantmaurya8046]

Give the right information to The public

[@Kkthinks001]

We should protest against this government we don’t want this type of FM plzz remove otherwise its last time bjp govt in India

[@love-oh8co]

Government of India ko stock market pe list karvao it will be most valuable company in the world😂😂😂

[@subratadey8381]

This is a great example of how this government is making all of us to suffer

[@manishkumar-pc9gy]

I urge govt of India to sanction the slavery amount as soon as possible,sir plz have some patience it will be sanctioned 😂

[@devadasanmungath8373]

Its time Modi got rid of Sitharaman & brought in Piyush Goyal as FM. The government gives aid to neighbouring countries who have become hostile from common Indian tax payers money but when it comes to increasing minimum pension of private employees in EPS the government says it cannot allocate funds. The minimum pension of EPS is Rs 1000 since 2014. 75% of 70 lakh pensioners get pension between 1000 & 1500. 20% get between 1500 & 2000. Only 5% get above 2000 !

[@Ruth_yukth]

This lady has lost her mind.i think we've to pay tax for speaking,sleeping and seeing also.

[@Indian67]

Dharam ke naam vote karo 😅😅😅

[@INDIAN3817]

Worst FM ..have some shame dont take anything for granted... whoever has taken the mass for granted has regretted...

[@vrgreddyvundela423]

FM and PM says parliament, no tax is upto 7 lacs , with action FM says in parliament not a single rupee to be paid. The reality in my wife case , for 5 lacs income income tax department assessed Rs.17500/-, the reason is capital gains are not exempted, so you pay. This is reality, with GOs, implementation. What to say, even FM and PM have taken for a ride by IT department. What, penalties and punishment should be given to all those. May be vote. Again the same flock with new attires, will act on the screen. Let the God, give some common sense, simple arithmetic to all those intellectuals, so let people live with peace. One recent live example, Actions of HYDRA at Hyderabad . Who should be punishable, ???

[@asfanasfan7787]

Bring back Congress again.. atleast inflation was low , rate was very low under Congress

[@maipakmeitei7570]

Tax... But no one rise against goi so what benefit? Wake up people

[@asfanasfan7787]

Don't blame fm, blame modi government.

[@viking5457]

This will effect only middle class people, she will not touch rich people

[@BabuTechie2025]

Rich people will pay.😅

[@YoursMohankumar]

We use Bullockcart for travelling jai gau matha jai shree ram...kattar Hindhu

[@AllInOne-vl2ed]

​@@YoursMohankumarkattar asshole

[@sdatta123]

Car is considered super super Luxury product in India. Only bicycle is best from Indians.

[@sanjayngg]

Go and this old car to our finance minister

[@smitamakked58]

सुब्रमण्यम स्वामी को लाओ

[@nidheeshtr1982]

This is ramarajyam. To live in this country every citizen should be prepared to pay higher taxes

[@Majith-pv3xq]

இவர்களை எல்லாம் நிதி அமைச்சராக நம் நாட்டுக்கு எவ்வளவு துர்பாக்கியம் . இவர்கள் உண்மையில் பொருளாதார படிப்பு படித்தவர்கள் ?........ என்று சந்தேகமாக உள்ளது .

[@drpkc007]

Worst ARROGANT FM of India

[@Bibek.Pradhan]

Calculation in this video is wrong as Gst calculated only incase of positive margin

[@Deekshith-bs4ql]

Used Car Selling has no Tax if Individual sels it...only for comertial selling like a company, Bussiness used cars only need to pay tax

[@deepakbhardwaj3040]

Bandhu agar tum daily pathsala mei ase hi kam karte to ajj ye din nahi dekhne padte 😂😂

[@ashokathuluri4396]

So people will stop buying old cars and they will buy car and it will boost new car sales. It's all psychology game.

[@mdasifsadique4675]

How could you complaint about taxes bro..!! You should understand that excavation process requires huge money

[@love-oh8co]

Where are they using this money

[@BharatIndoria]

BJP is paving its way out.

[@walkingwithshoaib3487]

Very good chushant 😂😂😂

[@kenibose2008]

Shameless lady..as she is just a rubber stamp of BJP

[@somankallada]

she must go out from government

[@review7779]

Tax tax tax....leaving india is much better option

[@surajkarale1042]

This calculation is incorrect, no tax on C2C ,C2B transaction, also tax to be paid if selling price exceed depreciated value in book, only on positive margin for B2B,B2C transactions Do basic information collection before presenting to a mass audience, this shows how irresponsible the media is.

[@techera1047]

Its not nirmala its the IAS officers who give suggestions on tax and all and have zero knowldege about our country Koi bhi place dekh lo north side me kitne electricty lines underground huay hain? Vacume cleaning trucks kitne hain jo roads clean kre and dust particles kam kre See the condition of rivers direct discharge ho rae No clean air water jo basic requirement hai We need britishers immediately to solve these things

[@ytthings2359]

I am pro bjp but but paying too much taxes. If such things will continue then due to just tax burden BJP will loose people support. Bcoz in return we are getting not benifit

[@anshukumarchoudharyanshuku3015]

Sad .....U hv not understood it .....U r misinformed.....plz remove the video......Direct and Indirect taxes issue is still debatable...however the clip is largely falsified info

[@KiranRoy-h5l]

Just like the tax.. ridiculous news.. please get taxation knowledge cleared. Don't show calculations based on memes :p

[@DevLife_in]

Wrong Information! On google it is different only business persons will pay that right?

[@Ytfamilyclips]

Good days coming bro or karo bjp bjp 😅

[@abdul.kareem525]

MIDDLE CLASS WALOON NE HI TO KAHA THAA KE NOON ROTI KHAYENGE MODI KO JITAYENGE AB KHAOO NOON ROTI

[@sreejikm]

Rajyasabha mp doesnt have to face peoples concerns and voices

[@ashthoush]

Indian media is all time low...this guy is an idiot... Margin is Selling price of the second hand car minus the deprecated value of the car value.... please don't create confusing... Your confidence and knowledge in economics is mind boggling 🤦

[@kumarsarvesh303]

Ulti ganga???? Main to soch raha tha ki aaj Sushant babu is naye tax ke faayde samjhayenge? ?

[@Syedvlove]

Take complete earnings will start begging

[@johneleazer9735]

Why is the term called 'tax on the middle class',? Does it mean GST tax and tax in general are exempted for Netha class and rich n tycoon class?

[@sn9426]

A fact check is needed, go read GST rules properly.

[@ags3785]

What fun to levy tax on depreciation amount, how highly educated FM India has

[@shivashakthienterprise7189]

BJP WILL LOOSE THE Ground.HORRIBLE.

[@aarushsingh9300]

Requesting Khan sir to make a video on the topic of tax influence in indian middle class people 🙏🏻

[@sushantsingh1229]

Ameero ka Robin hood Jo gareebo se leta jarur hai par ameero ko deta bhi hai😅

[@AYUSHSINGH-qc4qe]

Worst finance minister indipendent india

[@bornonfour4044]

Adani collection s😢😢

[@Xyz1998-si7mu]

Worst fm

[@Harsh-bv8vf]

LTCG tax and GST on depreciation assets like car and flat

[@awesome5566]

India is doomed.......end of great indian growth story

[@BrijeshSingh-tz1sx]

Sushant sir Why are you spread wrong news .You not understand old car gst

[@mohitchoprraa1687]

Dekho bhai humare pm koi is bat se anjane to nhi????sab unki dekh rekh me sab ho rha. Bht badi glti kri modi ji ko vote krke

[@megh07na]

Still vote For BIP ..

[@AmitShyamsukha-n2n]

What a Joke 🎉 of india 🎉 🎈🎂 luthra hai public ka.....she is not worth for Indian economy please 🙏 change fiance minister 😭

[@SudarsanaReddy-1224]

Less tax to corporate would increase employment? Individual tax increase shows growth in employment? Second hand car sales, applicable for business used, but not for individual. Business cars are already tax benefited. Hence they are charged more

[@ajukarthikeyan3796]

Next time my vote only for Nota .. Better.. These politicians are living freebies life they not no the values of poor peoples life.If developed countries people pay 40 +percentage to government because they have gud facilities like road infrastructure, gud public toilets, not polluted air , Here in India Roads are cow dung and dogs .. worse of worse .. Stop cows on public Roads

[@Jagatrakhshkan350]

Tge entire GST council to be dismissed and a new one formed

[@kuljeetsingh6005]

Yeh journalist bhi palat gya kya?

[@bhushan1854]

Modiji Ki Sarkar Me sab acha hua hey , bas Tax ka gadbad hey, is vajse shayad agli bar modiji ko dikat aah sakti hey

[@416890259x]

I've stopped paying tax all together

[@mohankumarchhetri]

Remove this NS as FM, reason for BJP fall

[@TheTraderrRaoSahab]

Dekho Sarkar ka pta nhi but iss desh me ganwaron ki kami nhi h .....sab ulta sidha samjh rhe ....so as per govt rules m smjhata hu saara Govt ne kahah ki second hand car sale karoge to margin pe tax dena hoga 18% ke hisaab se isko m example ke sath smjhata hu Maan lo maine gaadi kharidi 6,00,000 ki jaisa bayah or depreciation Iga ke maan lo business ki book me uss gaadi ki value 50000 h or humne wo 1 lakh me bech di To margin pe 18% gst Igega yaani sale price - book value 1,00,000-50,000 =50,000 ye margin h or ispe 18% gst ke hisaab se gst hua 9000 yaani 1,00,000 ki gaadi bechi to 9000 ka gst diya na 90000 Thank u

[@Prashant-s9h]

Middle class tax de nhi rha. Unse chinna ja rha

[@yjagannath]

FM lost mind, they shd think solution to increase the number of tax payer.

[@DiwakarKumar-fh4tc]

1:00 wrong information by this guy , don't get influenced but still buz guys impacts by this tax rule

[@perumalkaveti9399]

OTT SOCHHH SAMMAKKARRR DHALOOO JI MODI GREAT NIRMALA STHARAMAN GREAT 🙏🙏🙏