[NoNo's Reaction] Professional vocal teacher's comments on Singer 2024 Episode 8! Ep1

Watch the eighth episode of Singer 2024 with Teacher NoNo! See how the singers perform in this episode!
If you are interested in consulting about vocalization courses! You can add Teacher NoNo (Vancouver) WeChat: dengnono
1:00 Tan Weiwei
5:47 Faouzia
12:33 Huang Xuan
23:16 Wang Sulong

[@janetchung3377]

老師好敢講大實話，我欣賞你👍

[@a590116]

黃宣部份講解的好深入❤

[@ingridlai2732]

專業人士都懂

[@SoundMindVocal]

谢谢你一起喜欢他

[@Chemse_bouayss]

I'm sorry to say that, but even you if you tried to sing in Arabic which is the original language of faouzia, you gonna find difficulties as Fouzia find it in Chinese, and if you have ten vowels, in Arabic we have letters that Chinese don't have and it's so difficult to pronounce it . To sum up every language have its own difficulties, and Faouzia tried her best signing one of the hardest languages in the world ❤

[@vvv07010429]

分析真的很透徹，真的要音樂水平高的人才會發現他的作品真的獨一無二，特有想法

[@lukaliou4897]

老師評黃宣的真的評的很好，我也是一次一次聽越聽越能感受黃宣要傳達的歌曲意境❤

[@SoundMindVocal]

其实很多人说他这个歌不适合比赛，我并不这么认为。

[@davidhsieh1991]

@@SoundMindVocal 我覺得說不適合比賽主要還是因為是由觀眾來投票，而當下只聽了一次其實是很難細細品味黃宣每次表演歌曲裡面那滿滿的細節，就如同老師說的要聽四五次分開來專注在不同的細節才能明白這樣的表演他細膩之處

[@JOVKiss]

黃宣的歌是有敘述的感覺，每次都在講故事，總能自然的呈現故事畫面。

[@SoundMindVocal]

给你点赞。

[@Mettmettmettmett]

黄宣是透过这节目来玩音乐的，希望他开心的多玩到节目尾声。

[@hiqueenalin]

謝謝老師的點評，不像一些影片評論看到名次就跟著見風轉舵...不論是音樂底蘊，還是曲風嘗試，黃宣都是最棒的！

[@user-le7ej1dd1c]

老師說的好詳細，吸收了，很感謝～黃宣的歌真的愈聽愈好聽，音樂和人聲都很療癒，短時間要編曲的如此完整，加上動人的表達,真得太佩服了！

[@yawenchang2138]

可以發現黃宣在歌手的表演與，專業的音樂人的評價一般偏高。您是用您的專業素養來評論。但是節目是現場觀眾跟線上觀眾評的（大多都是非音樂人），因此他挑的小眾的音樂類型（歌雖然是耳熟能詳的歌）很難取悅大眾。這讓期待他有好排名的人，每週都提心吊膽😅。我想我應該調整心態，期待每期都能有不一樣類型的表演可能更好🎉。

[@sjc6984]

他不被淘汰就OK了

[@SoundMindVocal]

我已经调整到只要能留下，总能看一期好歌。

[@lairanky5760]

大家應該平常心，來看待黃宣的排名，學當初鄧紫棋參加這節目的本意，就是展示自已想表達的，將自己的音樂理念與大家分享，拿了個冠軍也沒啥用，讓觀眾認識你才是最重要

[@user-jv2mm6oi4i]

不管歌大眾還是小眾 有一點老師還真講對 9位歌手 只有黃宣是用歌聲帶著樂隊走 其他8位歌手都是被樂隊帶著唱 簡單說 只有黃宣是樂隊配合他唱 其他人都是配合樂隊唱 而且人聲先出 樂隊再出 需要的是絕對音感 太高級了

[@SoundMindVocal]

对，其实只要和乐队合作过就知道，人声要带乐队才能创造一个一个意境。。不然就会觉得一直被音乐压着，无法突破。

[@leeyvonne993]

精闢分析

[@elsahuang0305]

聽了老師解說, 我試了一下, 錯拍唱, 真的好難, 連那種氣音唱歌都好難! 看黃宣唱的輕鬆, 結果真是不容易吔~ 大家也自己試試看😀

[@user-mz2sd9uj8n]

因為歌手這個節目讓我了解到內地普遍的音樂素養原來還停留在二三十年前。

[@janewu4985]

這個節目的商業考量大於藝術的價值…所以音樂素養很難進步😢

[@lotuswoo]

講黃講到後來自己都為他哭了

[@SoundMindVocal]

就还好没有淘汰，不然真是直接放弃看这个节目了。

[@user-fp9mw4sn6x]

專業的老師👍

[@user-wx4is4zx2q]

其實除了Yellow 的獨上C樓之外.....每一場的比賽歌曲，我最愛他這一次的編排創作！他的藝術魂勾起了....我們更愛~❤😊

[@Nooneelse7766]

我覺得黃宣第一句 超性感的～～

[@SoundMindVocal]

哈哈。。。

[@theepic-raxteh1657]

支持老师勇敢的客观点评而不是一味盲目“造神”和“神化”一些overrated的表演 我看了老师的评论区其实80％都不太健康 没啥特别有营养的客观留言 希望你别被影响，继续保持自己的独立思考 加油💪

[@SoundMindVocal]

谢谢。

[@crystalw1966]

特别喜欢老师的点评，非常细致。❤❤❤

[@yihsiangtseng7105]

只要黃宣不離開就好，名次不強求

[@smpy888]

老師解說的好仔細，大愛黃宣❤

[@chutihunterfeng8682]

完全同意黃宣不應該排到第八

[@chi-yuancheng541]

專業！黃宣最少前二！ 因為音樂性及創造性及旋律都是一時上品！

[@lwilliam4990]

前二就夸张了，前四可以。FZ和谭毫无疑问前二。那英这一期哪怕只是吃老本也足够优秀

[@SoundMindVocal]

就是。

[@alexchu9523]

老師評的好專業！感覺節目是故意拿黃宣製造爭議話題，就像上周那英最後一名一樣

[@SoundMindVocal]

对，我也会忍不住这么想。

[@elenaroxana4202]

I think each artist has something that make them different, I am fan of Faouzia.... I am still very proud of her performance on chinese song Devil From Heaven . From my point of view she chose not modify to much in that song that need to be sang in a language that she doesn't have professional knowledge, choosing stability ,a powerful voice and focusing on the emotions. Still very proud of her ,and I been proud of every foreigners singers in a Tv show that try to sing a song in my language because of difficulty of the language itself.

[@GenieJ88]

Exactly this! Agree.

[@SoundMindVocal]

I believe there has been a lot of misunderstanding. I have always recognized the difficulty of singing Chinese songs and her work is very good. What I regret is that I wish to see her art works with her own style.

[@elenaroxana4202]

@@SoundMindVocal I agreed, as a fan I would enjoy more her style😍 but then if you don't have enough knowledge of the song , new language and you don't have enough time ,how can you master it and make it your own . As long as we give Faouzia time I believe she can master everything😊. Probably the same for the other singers ☺,everything is a new experience for them,give them time and we will see more what they improved or need improvement. Still I wish them all the best and I believe they will give the best performance they can , even if I am a bit biased .😊 Faouzia fan.

[@TheSifolle]

​@@SoundMindVocal look i'm really confused here i don't know if you're talking about her way of singing this chinese song or you're talking about her music in general. and that makes me wonder if you really know the artist you criticinzing here. do you know any of her songs or did watch any of her covers. because your opinion is the weirdest things i've heard about faouzia.

[@yanglee4921]

老師您的講解真的很棒

[@gowhy852]

老師 就把這個節目當作綜藝看看吧😂

[@SoundMindVocal]

哎。。看来还是要看心态。

[@brandonchangus8520]

大家都心知肚明。如果黄宣被淘汰，没人会去看歌手这种烂节目。

[@user-qk7tm1nk5p]

實話總是刺耳

[@Amy-pq6uy]

聽了不少評論 忍不住要說 雖喜惡自由 惟曾刻苦學習過的人 方懂得用聲之優劣 極度贊賞老師的專業實誠❤

[@SoundMindVocal]

而且我也认为，有思想的人才能用声音来传递。。。很厉害的。。哎。。。

[@user-ed2dd6qf7y]

這次最大的爭議就是黃宣 連微博的耳帝都發長篇為黃宣抱不平 我個人認為上次是那英倒數。這次是黃宣倒數。 無論你認不認同排名 這個排名都成功炒熱話題😂 只能說芒果台很懂的博收視率🤭🤭

[@SoundMindVocal]

我就是觉得这个排名够奇怪的，其实就算他的歌小众，其实这首colse to you还是耳熟能详的。

[@Nauma3]

No offense, but your criticism of Faouzia's lack of creativity does not make sense. If you think it's normal to sing in a completely different language and culture, try singing an Arabic song live and modify it in a way that will please and definitely not offend the arab audience. Faouzia was actually respectful to the culture and audience by not modifying or changing anything in the song. I mean, listen to the original versions of the songs she's covered so far in the competition and tell me again that she's a copier!

[@kentchang6030]

老師說的太好了，就藝術性質而言，黃宣實在很難得。

[@hibaom4106]

Let's see if some of the Chinese singers can sing in Arabic with very good pronunciation miss gurlllll

[@user-sh3yt7eb2n]

黃宣像馬丁叔叔一樣回火星去了，以後少了許多樂趣😂

[@menghungtsai5343]

把唱一首歌，變成一個作品，差很多

[@VIP-ow3ck]

You're talking nonsense, the fact that she's singing in a diffrent difficult language is creative in itself. I challenge you to sing one verse from an arabic song and let's see how well you can do that and how creative you can be......Faouzia is an amazing artist she writes and produces her own music and is well known for her creativity, she has multiple covers and she has made them her own so for you to say that she just imitates songs is mind-blowing cause it's THE Faouzia we're speaking about here, the artist of artists, just be appreciative, she worked so hard on this song as a thank you to the Chinese audience that in return has be so kind to her.

[@SoundMindVocal]

I totally agree with you, and I believe that it isn't easy to sing another language. I emphasize that her focus on learning Chinese songs does not reflect the artistry of her solo work this time.

[@user-sh3yt7eb2n]

聽Moore唱the best,聽到You're simply the best Better than all the rest的贊美之辭，原以為是歌頌愛情贊美女友好棒棒天下無雙之類的，後來去看了原唱的m.v,才發覺弄了個大烏龍，原來居然是贊頌賽馬，描寫人與賽馬之間的深厚感情的。😂原唱m.v的確拍得精彩無與倫比，尤其人模仿賽馬的步伐舞動，再到臨尾來段像梁羽生筆下白發摩女的哥哥白發摩男在燈光照射光下如喝醉酒般左搖右擺吹色士風，最後來個仰天長嘯，簡直是神來之筆，太帥了😂尤其配上Tina英姿颯爽騎馬的鏡頭,搖滾風味十足的配樂和Tina磁性的唱腔，如同處身策馬飛馳的狀態，一聽就忍不住搖頭晃腦，的確動感十足，經典之作。改編後，配上古箏的淡雅，moore唱起來情深款款，感覺從原唱策馬飛奔的動態一下子唰的一聲瞬間切換到了寂寞林中與馬兒雙雙林中散步，深情告白的靜態，對比反差挺強烈的，挺有意思的。

[@SoundMindVocal]

哇塞，你可是用心之人啊。

[@tina1063]

這老師真專業

[@user-qk7tm1nk5p]

很喜歡老師的講評，也很喜歡你的聲音

[@SoundMindVocal]

谢谢

[@Rosannasfriend]

This is where we get into an issue of translation because the word “parody“ isn’t not really a compliment in this context at all.

[@Rosannasfriend]

I’m not saying you were trying to complementing her there, but it’s more ridiculous than I think you meant to be of Faouzia.

[@ravindratamang1535]

​@@Rosannasfriend You tell that woman!!! I really don't like her overanalysis of every damn thing.

[@ravindratamang1535]

Also i love that i find you in every faouzia related video, keep supporting our girl❤

[@SoundMindVocal]

I have always appreciated her skill and singing ability. I think her fans are not ordinary people, at least expect her to produce personal works, promote her creativity. In fact, the last song, I think she changed her mind very much. Although the ranking is not good, I think she made her work. Sometimes fans' preferences directly affect artists' creativity.

[@agnes-7541]

別糾結名次，出場費 不會少給。雖然每個歌手價碼會不同。

[@amyso6396]

Faouzia 的歌聲的响亮度寬濶度和歌唱技巧嘟在鄧紫棋之上，她唱她的歌唯一難度是語言，而連這也沒難到她，她就是勁!我心中冠軍!

[@SoundMindVocal]

对于她的技巧和歌唱能力我一直表示非常认可的。我想喜欢她的粉丝也不是泛泛之辈，至少期待她能出个人的作品，推动她的创造力。其实上一首歌曲，我就认为她改变的很有想法。虽然排名一般，但是我就认为她制作了她的作品。有时候粉丝的喜好会直接影响艺人的创作力。

[@anh2947]

Fao có thể hát mạnh hơn Gem, nh rập khuoin y như bản gốc, rất ít sáng tạo cá nhân. Hãy nhìn Hoàng Xuân hát tiếng Anh

[@oldgong]

亞洲人習慣大歌，抒情歌，悲傷歌，就是欣賞不了黃宣的爵士樂。

[@sylvialiang167]

呃～應該是華人這樣吧，其他亞洲國家表示不想被拖下水🤣🤣🤣。

[@user-ss4qy8hd3h]

不會！我小時候就聽很多種音樂（我特別喜歡爵士、藍調、鄉村）

[@lisayist]

爵士在哪国都是小众。

[@user-qk7tm1nk5p]

我喜歡的是黃宣的表演

[@sarakhabar6549]

Let's see if some of the Chinese singers can sing in Arabic with very good pronunciation, stop your critical in 7 weeks she dares to sing Chinese songs like that

[@SoundMindVocal]

Of course, completing such a high level in a week is not an ordinary ability, so I will go one step further and ask if I can push her to become a stronger singer-songwriter. Only a unique creation can become a long-term shining star.

[@nanyanguo1]

yes hope to see chinese singers try arabic but lst get an arab country to hold an equivalent show like The singer n invite chinese singers such as Zhou shen and Tan Wei Wei , Zhou Shen can sing in multiple languages incl russian , korean , japanese , indian like the natives of these languages. Tan Weiwei is also versatile singer . Wont be surprise they can learn to sing arabic songs if they participate in arab singing show Some singers just have the talent in learning n singing other languages. It is another gifted talent that they have besides their singing talent.

[@chou5209]

close to you 是木匠兄妹的世界名曲，大家不識貨，看來黃宣要適應觀眾要把水準放低一點

[@user-jy3um3ye8z]

黃宣選了方大同跟陶喆的歌，都被節目組否決，他才選這首的....

[@xunanhou4171]

黄宣的音乐是面向极小众的品味，我身边有人能接受或喜欢。但这种改动的雷区在于，熟悉原曲的人会不太舒服，carpenter超脱轻松的意境变成了瘾君子苦情歌😂

[@vilisawonder]

同意，對我來説那意境不是我喜歡的😂

[@xunanhou4171]

@@vilisawonder 没飙高音的现场也不讨喜 哈哈

[@user-ro3vg2iv1n]

Faouzia❤

[@user-vm8gh5en1n]

老師解說的超好滴

[@drakxy1796]

Oh,,why u comment a foreigner sing local song PARODI,, than what do u think a foreigner feel when listening mandarin song,,

[@SoundMindVocal]

Hey, there I don't think I meant to say parody there, It is the auto-translation. I think the more accurate word would be mimic.

[@1988kennyrogers]

我覺得很特別的是最後，他最後一句唱完，旋律剛好接回原曲的經典旋律，而且是非常低調的，輕輕的原曲旋律，也就是他手最後在搖的地方，聽了好幾次才發覺，除了編曲製作很棒，感覺最後他還向原曲致敬

[@SoundMindVocal]

谢谢你的提醒，我同意。

[@life_is_a_lie01]

真的有認真在聽細節嗎？如果真要拿兩人來比較，英文那兩句也是Faouzia靠後一點，加上她音色本來就比較dark比較沉；「你就是傳說來自天堂的魔鬼」這句明明放的地方也不一樣，更靠後了一點，不然為什麼Faouzia可以保持厚度輕鬆唱上去？看了好幾個現場，GEM唱到這句都是偏弱的

[@anh2947]

Gem hát nhỏ câu đó thể hiện sự yếu đuối, bất lực của lí trí đối với con tim

[@lanyuan-jing9301]

沒有黃宣每週的精彩，我想我也不會再追歌手了🤣🤣

[@SoundMindVocal]

哈哈。没有黄宣我就指望香阿姨了。

[@borislai9146]

其實他就不是來比賽的啊～

[@kwoo24]

简单来说，汪苏泷就是编曲大于歌唱能力。

[@SoundMindVocal]

对。但是我听汪讲话，我觉得以他讲话的口音，唱歌不应该这样。

[@Sally89-13]

汪就是錄音室歌手，錄音可以唱的不錯，以唱功而言完全不適合競技節目😅

[@GaLi_09.07]

看黃宣這場表演就好像看懸疑片 要聽好幾遍ＸＤ

[@SoundMindVocal]

对啊，你看他这首歌，结束部分多少完美。。。

[@LiLi-ij5uk]

不用对排名这么在意。都是电视台安排。好声音也是一样。中国特色。

[@mennahesham35]

Actually all chinse people said that faouzia's pronunciation was so accurate and good even singers, too so i found it strange that u didn't like it and u only heard 1 verse of the song so how could someone judge based on this!!! Faouzia is such a greaaat singer nooo one like her and i trust her singing abilities and i know how far she could goes by her beautiful style and her unique voice.

[@maxsingularity8151]

Faouzia可沒有模仿 裡面有很多細節都不一樣 「蘋果」那裡也有自己的改編 還有一個地方鄧紫棋的轉音她也沒有用 是用自己的處理方式 而且她的聲音更加沒有斷層（原唱也很好 兩個版本各有千秋 以上為觀點 並不是從比較方面來講）

[@user-sh3yt7eb2n]

也算是很有技巧和針對性啦，黃宣和譚都是以改編聞名的，你方唱罷我登場，技巧性替補同類型選手讓大家有點新鮮感也說得過去。 譚充其量也只是霎眼娇，也就初現驚艷那麼一下，時間久了聽多了就覺得煩，什麼音樂接手都手痕忍不住中西合併亂改一通，像那首周華健的刀劍如夢就改得亂七八糟，慘不忍睹。一點美感都沒有。

[@jerrykung6294]

❤😂🎉

[@fiduork5104]

Bullshit, I challenge you to learn just one phrase in Arabic and pronounce it correctly in 7 weeks to see if you can.

[@SoundMindVocal]

Of course, completing such a high level in a week is not an ordinary ability, so I will go one step further and ask if I can push her to become a stronger singer-songwriter. Only a unique creation can become a long-term shining star.

[@jdu2584]

Faouzia的重音在第一音节’Faouzia而不是在第二音节Faou’zia😅

[@Wang_HaHa]

老师好喜欢你的视频和风格轻松自在分享的感觉，不是在说教。你多喝些水吧，嘴唇很干擦点唇膏，好几次想跟你说了，希望你别介意嘿嘿嘿

[@SoundMindVocal]

哈哈，我是着急。我这拍摄的照相机必须在38分钟之内完成，不然就会过热关机。。我的妈呀，，我不自觉地增加语速，有以后也是郁闷，其实还有好多细节想讲，但是剪辑花太多时间。。。

[@user-pp7vd5fl9z]

黃宣加上陶喆的沙灘

[@SoundMindVocal]

我就想，22如果是黄唱应该了不起。

[@bossmeng5360]

黄宣淘汰了好可惜😢一直都很期待能听到他唱coldplay的《Yellow》

[@user-em9ob2it8y]

黃宣還沒淘汰啊😂

[@bossmeng5360]

@@user-em9ob2it8y 哦！那真是太好了！第八名也不淘汰吗

[@elsahuang0305]

@@bossmeng5360 這次是補位, 不淘汰, 但排名會影响下次淘汰賽!

[@elsahuang0305]

@@bossmeng5360 突然想起有一個沖榜沒成功, 所以這期沒人淘汰

[@drakxy1796]

Yess,, that's how great Yaya is,,vocaly and artistry only Yellow can match her,,TWW performance still bellow Yellow,,, it's pure the band performance that make her 1'st place,,

[@wueric5304]

抱歉~實在只對黃宣有興趣😁

[@SoundMindVocal]

闹。。。。。。

[@user-vd4jl9xx7y]

这节目一开始调性那么高，打着现场live真实的名义，后来又出现各种修音、还有我认为是肉眼可见的投票不真实…反正这个投票我不信，逐渐失望

[@lidali6770]

汪苏泷唱的更贴近人心，有情感，如果按您说的那样唱，听机器就可以了😅

[@2000711]

你聽不得別人說汪苏泷

[@user-el8fs3mf1e]

專業

[@motivationstudy6947]

I am sorry but you are talking non sense faouzia deserve to be the first 🥇

[@allenyu4893]

只能說大陸的聽眾水準都很淺才有如此離譜的排名

[@Gooodyoutuber]

模仿秀到这个程度，也是尽显个人功力

[@SoundMindVocal]

其实我是佩服她的，我第一次听的时候我都吓了一跳。而且一气呵成，非常惊艳。听完之后就会为她可惜，她绝对有能力可以创作。

[@oldgong]

黃宣的歌適合大會表演，小型演唱會，根本不適合比賽。

[@amyso6396]

也適合一班玩音樂的人一起Jam歌，他骨子裹是充滿音樂细胞，在節奏和律動都掌控自如，他演繹出歌的每i節情緒，但個人總覺欠完整性!

[@user-lg3jf6mx7v]

100分？真敢说

[@Amy-pq6uy]

競技場上既狠又準 所以100分.. 喜好不論 這首歌的綜合表現是無懈可擊.

[@user-lg3jf6mx7v]

@@Amy-pq6uy100分？那如果接下来有更专业的表现，那岂不是200分？？？

[@Amy-pq6uy]

@@user-lg3jf6mx7v 原來您更寬容 我只能給105分

[@SoundMindVocal]

哈哈。。。。。我说1000分也没用啊。。。

[@user-bw5om8gl3o]

汪唱功唱商其實很一般，這首尤其明顯。副歌真是災難，主歌又沒敘事，，糟透了！

[@LionsFit]

I agree with u Faouzia didn't make this Chinese song hers. Did u consider the fact she only had One week to prepare for it? she also had a tour one day, where she didn't practice. learning the pronunciation should be first on list so Chinese people can understand it? You are Vocal Teacher, which u teach how to sing, correct? yes. so teach yourself how to sing an Arabic song by Next week. So Next Saturday post an Arabic song where it was sung Live in front of some Arabic-Chinese people. and yes, Do Not make it your won, just copy what the singer is saying. Prove us all Wrong please. you'll choke. there are arabic letters and words that most chinese cannot pronounce. if we don't see an Arabic song then your analysis of Faouzia is fake and prejudice.

[@vilisawonder]

I think she might not be wrong or fake in her opinions, but she just ignores the fact that the challenge of this song is learning a new language with good delivery of the song, more than the reinterpretation of the song. While she requires F to be in the next level, it might not be justified for F considering this is a totally new language for her, which learning it simply takes away most of her attention this week…

[@SoundMindVocal]

I have always appreciated her skill and singing ability. I think her fans are not ordinary people, at least expect her to produce personal works, promote her creativity. In fact, the last song, I think she changed her mind very much. Although the ranking is not good, I think she made her work. Sometimes fans' preferences directly affect 。Of course, completing such a high level in a week is not an ordinary ability, so I will go one step further and ask if I can push her to become a stronger singer-songwriter. Only a unique creation can become a long-term shining star.

[@LionsFit]

@@SoundMindVocal what you are describing applies to the fluency of an artist's languages. an artist can't be creative in constrained time; one week to prepare for the song not possible. for example, the Best singer, Dimash, sang a Chinese song in TheSinger2017, however, Chinese people couldn't understand him, but they knew he only had one week to prepare. They loved him for his outstanding vocals and deliver that melt the heart of a listener. Even Dimash said, my goal is for Chinese people to understand what I'm singing. he also said, it's very hard to sing in Chinese. Faouzia is fluent in English, French, and Arabic, she in these 3 languages and made the songs her own. so far Faouzia sang all in English and little bit of Arabic in Desert Rose, and made it her own in all of them. she has many songs in French that she made her own

[@LionsFit]

@@vilisawonder Here's one of French song that Faouzia covered and made it her own. Many French artists sang this song, including Celine Dion, but Faouzia's rendition and interpretation to the song is heart melting. please find the lyrics in Mandarin, it's beautifully written. it's about how much her lover means to her and what would happens if he leaves. I hope she sings it during this competition. take a listen. but first here's Celine Dion (Diva) rendition (it's a cover not her song) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqnNqGiLqbSHsJo Faouzia Link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eYPVhZWipZ52mc0

[@ammimhamedamina4982]

👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎🤔🤔🤔

[@MchdYsf]

nonsense

[@jiaweiliu762]

先把Faouzia名字念对吧 吹毛求疵的👎 你唱歌感觉才像是一直模仿柯以敏 油腻腻的

[@Amy-pq6uy]

唱過歌嗎？ 會唱歌嗎？？ 完善歌唱之路皆有過一定程度上的模仿.. 就這話罷了 您至於嗎？！

[@abcdef2957]

不要乱乱说

[@SawLakyaw]

怪不得你只是音乐老师，

[@applelee-mw9sc]

怪不得你只是酸民🤣

[@Amy-pq6uy]

學以致用有啥問題嗎？

[@SoundMindVocal]

其实我想做厨师的，下次分享我烧的东西。。。

[@photosalice2689]

沒用！譚維維唱的這首歌本身太差，不好聽就是不好聽唱得再好也是難聽

[@Nevermin665]

看你好像是塔綠班的告訴你個資訊，維維老公是台灣人。她跟很多台灣藝人都是好朋友也常來台灣，你又攻擊錯目標了。

[@magic32v7182]

我反共反民進黨！ 但我也覺得譚選的歌曲很難聽！

[@lwilliam4990]

好不好听是你的耳朵习惯问题！你们从小被情情爱爱的歌曲磨惯了耳朵，听这种歌自然是“不好听”，因为你听不出这首歌背后的西北文化和黄土一样的力量

[@rickyhuang0205]

谭维维难听至极！全程高能噪音！

[@deter3]

黄宣过度在演唱上雕琢，晦涩感严重。 这两个才是改编的上乘之作，流畅，创新，格调高。 kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y16xi6WEibWXr7s ， kzbin.info/www/bejne/ap7YlXeqZ9tnZ8U ，kzbin.info/www/bejne/gnTZnHukqL-pZrc 。

[@MsBuyFashionTalk]

3個演唱影片 我都看過了 我不瞭解的是只有Jacob Collier的算改編，其他一個是幾乎是原版照唱 和 一位改編了曲風但聲音主線只是原版加快，不喜歡黃宣就不喜歡，我尊重你的耳朵，但拿一些不三不四的翻唱來比較，我會覺得你毫無聽音樂的本能。

[@deter3]

@@MsBuyFashionTalk 不三不四的翻唱， wow，wow，好佩服你“聽音樂的本能“ 。

[@MsBuyFashionTalk]

@@deter3 翻唱跟改編是兩馬子事，你搞清楚再回話，不懂就好好學。

[@deter3]

@@MsBuyFashionTalk wow, 好佩服你的素养. 赞赞赞！

[@MsBuyFashionTalk]

@@deter3 與其浪費時間佩服我 不如省下時間去多聽聽音樂 珍惜能翻牆的時間 多聽點好音樂

[@sunminghao]

😂因為中國音樂圈土氣啊😅😅😅😅

[@Simon-ts6mr]

黄宣的风格不适合比赛而已，并不是不够好。

[@MsBuyFashionTalk]

那我可以說你的風格不適合留言，並不是不夠水準。