"NOT CUTE: PART 1 - Elephants and the pianist Paul Barton replies to Iris Koch

Video reply to answer FAQ relating to blog post "NOT CUTE: Elephants and the pianist Paul Barton" by Iris Koch, posted to "Future for Elephants" website, March/June 2020.
"NOT CUTE: PART 2 - Elephants and the pianist Paul Barton replies to Iris Koch Part 2:
• NOT CUTE: PART 2 - Ele...
Links to reports/posts referenced in this video:
Iris Koch blog post: "NOT CUTE: Elephants and the pianist Paul Barton"
www.futurefore...
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
REUTERS "Pianist plays for rescued elephants in Thailand"
www.reuters.co...
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Germany ARD "Das Erste" Weltspiegel Entdeckt - Thailand: Klavier für Elefanten (German language)
www.daserste.d...
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Deutsche Welle or DW is a German public state-owned international broadcaster. "Beethoven's 'Pastoral': Artists revisit a symbol of climate protection"n (English language)
www.dw.com/en/...
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
To see "Piano for Elephants" clips in full featured in this video:
My "Piano for Elephants" KZbin playlist:
• Piano for Elephants
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Facebook: / paulbartonpiano
KZbin: / paulbartonpiano
Art website: www.paulbartona...
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Tripadvisor:
Elephantsworld: www.tripadviso...
Elephantstay: www.tripadviso...
Elephant Nature Park: www.tripadviso...
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Amanda Feldon documentary "Music for Elephants"
www.imdb.com/t...
www.amazon.com...
www.musicforele...
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Richard Lair
Extinctions : How to protect elephants in Asia, by Richard Lair
• Extinctions : How to p...
Extinctions : Richard Lair tells us about Thai elephants
• Extinctions : Richard ...
Extinctions : What future for Thai elephants? by Richard Lair
• Extinctions : What fut...
Extinctions : The mahouts by Richard Lair
• Extinctions : The maho...
Extinctions : Laotian elephants by Richard Lair
• Extinctions : Laotian ...
Extinctions : Elephants and Tourism, by Richard Lair
• Extinctions : Elephant...

[@marnanel]

I admire how polite and respectful you can be with someone who is so rude to you.

[@rheajohson4420]

No gentle act of kindness goes unpunished . I must have been a large land or sea mammal at one time too. Beethoven forever. Have you ever thought about leaving a huge drum and sticks out and see what happens? Love what you do. Play on... First one comes, spreads the word and they all show up. How can anyone argue with that?

[@lazyartist7682]

If the elephants feel abused or hurt by the piano playing, then they would run away from you, not towards you. I’ve watched several of your videos and clearly the elephants walk closer to you when you play. Some even feel curious enough to touch the piano and play a few keys themselves. This clearly suggests that the animals are enjoying the encounter. Please keep the wonderful work you’re doing.

[@bmoy2812]

The elephants are enjoying and singing along with Paula's piano playing. Lovely

[@karenunwin824]

Knowing we live in a world where a kind man is playing piano to elephants has lifted my spirits, especially this last year, and I know I'm not alone. This is a wonderful answer to a misguided attack

[@patrickhaegeman6610]

Who’s Iris Koch ? ... Don’t even wanna know it ... keep on playing for those lovely smart giants !

[@imissnickplur4964]

every. single. time. JRS always at play. their group believes that all other groups only do charity work or good deeds for self-aggrandizement.

[@joopdaloop5840]

board member of elephants nature park

[@PaulBartonPiano]

​@@imissnickplur4964 yes.

[@05bastille]

@@joannemercader7139 So is the piano player, so what was your point there?

[@Mike-ox8sq]

@@PaulBartonPiano Sawa dee kap. May I ask? Have you received an apology and have Iris K. withdrawn her crazy accusations/downright slander? On a lighter note...Here are some special music (and footage/editing) for human beings, I think you will enjoy. Maybe show this to the mahouts one day? Humans seem to enjoy this. It makes them happy and joyful and many express deep awe. I am grateful that you and the people around you make the efforts you do. I have travelled the world and have been to Thailand many times but have now limited myself from flying so much to limited my impact on climate change, so it will probably take years before I come back to Thailand, if ever. Should I come back I will try to come by and say hi and make a personal donation. Until then, I hope this can bring you and those you might show it to, 6 minutes of Quality time. With admiration and appreciation for what you all do. Mikael. kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5_YgHSoesukfdE

[@darkhafgor]

We have your back Paul, always remember that

[@urzathehappy72]

And most importantly, so do the elephants

[@PaulBartonPiano]

Thank you, my friend.

[@KYoung-nj8ri]

Now THIS is how you handle criticism, well done. Keep doing what you do ♡

[@cathyvogel7939]

How sad are you Ms Koch

[@carolinegray7510]

Criticism has its place. Dealt with in all humility it is constructive. Ms. Koch obviously has had many experiences that showed her the extent of human cruelty. She looks for the smallest hints, the better to stop such things. Such dedication has, perhaps, altered her POV to the degree that it's all she sees. I encourage her to take in as many eye witness experiences as possible...to see for herself that ALL humans are not so wicked. Some love unselfishly and dedicate their lives to giving. Paul's response to Ms.Koch was very kind. My hope is that she will be relieved to find loving care givers do exist. Everywhere. In all facets of life.

[@AdrianR2]

@@marypoppins2232 you can use your judgement to tell the difference between a person making unsubstantiated allegations, and this large volume of evidence from video and from many witnesses. Of course philosophically one can never be absolutely sure about anything, but in practice one can assign overwhelming probability that he is telling the truth, and she is plain wrong.

[@reenatpinchas2680]

I’m sorry you even had to make this video. Nevertheless, you addressed her abhorrent claims with class and honesty. Thank you for all you do for elephants, the people of Thailand, and making the world a better more loving and caring place.

[@andi2234]

Well said Reenat!

[@astutebellas3325]

Every time I watch you play for the elephants, Paul, my heart opens wide and tears come to my eyes because of the joy you bring to these once abused elephants. Thank you, Paul, for giving these incredible elephants so much joy, so much love, and so much kindness. Thank you, Paul.

[@Job220701]

I have lost my husband and the loneliness is unbearable. One night, I touched the YOU TUBE button and found you.. My nights are now filled with the strangest and rare ability to picture myself in the midst of you and the elephants. Perhaps, being a musician myself Has enabled me to enjoy your friendship from every angle. All I know is, I am healing. You and the elephants are like no other remedy I have found to sooth my empty heart. Thank you so much, Jim’s widow.

[@rheajohson4420]

Humans should declare a truce on elephants whales etc the larger mammals and smaller ones too live in families live their parents and children. Respect their dead. All that stuff that humans do. Don't kill them !!! We are not that needy.

[@ecoquilting7077]

Mr. Barton, it pains me that you and your fellow carers have been maligned like this, and I very much support this long and heartfelt pushback. You have given so much while expecting so little in return, and when you've expressed the honor and pleasure of caring and playing for them, and sitting or walking with them, I've been so touched by your patience and kindness. You have a beautiful little human family, and I wish you all the very best!

[@louverousse9023]

Sir, I went to read the article and was profoundly saddened by what this woman has wrote . Only a human with a tortured soul could put such terrible accusations on the fabulous work you have done with these amazing animals . Thank you for giving time, efforts and love to the pachyderms.

[@TheOriginalNiceGuy]

She’s a product of the SJW eco alphabet mafia metoo feminism etc. They need to manufacture fake comfortable villains in order to keep their fake self righteous power grab party going. Evil.

[@chuckberry36]

The first time I saw an old elephant gently absorbing your music, ears moving to it, body close to the piano, was a great moment of relief and joy for me. I thought: at last, somebody who knows what to do with life. God bless you for what you do for these superb animals, and for life. Anyone and anything else is just wrong.

[@Otm_Shank]

I can't believe somebody would write something so asinine. Your videos are beautiful and inspiring. I have been enjoying them for years.

[@judil3294]

True. Amazes me how many people want to pull down others without knowing a thing. It only reveals how ugly they are inside.

[@karietruelove4621]

This piece makes me very emotional...beautiful!

[@barbrarussell4568]

Absolutely 💯

[@WadmanP]

I can certainly believe that someone would think and write those asinine comments; We currently live in a climate of hyper activism where certain people feel its their mission to be offended by anything and then attack it.

[@DjMicr0dot]

@@WadmanP were just not out of the dumb ages yet

[@mariarohmer2374]

We support you and elephants, Paul.💪‍🏽‍🐘🐘🐘

[@FcBow]

You are an amazing person, Paul. It takes a huge heart to reach out with so much love to a person who has wronged you.

[@arupsan]

Dr Paul you are an gem asset of this world.. don't even answer those people...

[@Frei_Raum]

I'm glad he did. I guess it was in the name of thruth. And I think, this is always a good reason. So, I'm glad he did answer Iris. Maybe she could learn something from it.

[@andi2234]

@@Frei_Raum I don't think she is interested in learning my friend or she would have taken time to investigate her erroneous and harmful accusations that have zero foundation. I too am glad he answered. Too many people believe what they read without looking into painful and horrific claims against a person or people. Shame on you Iris.

[@Frei_Raum]

@@andi2234 Ja, I think you are sadly right. If she would have been really interested in what's going on with Paul playing the piano for the elephants she would have researched better.

[@andi2234]

@@Frei_Raum Paul is genuinely humble, so rare these days. He responds very respectfully. I am inwardly embarrassed at what I know my own response would have been because his response is so perfectly correct and effectively potent.

[@Frei_Raum]

@@andi2234 And that's why I'm glad he did response. A good example to learn from - for me, too ;-)

[@aerocam2]

Paul, Unfortunately, the world will never run out of people like Iris. They spend a lifetime trying to project their own unhappiness in anyone who they secretly perceive as more successful, giving, caring, etc., etc. You will never please those people because they are insistent that you will never measure up to their proclaimed level. Ignore them and give them no more of your time. What you are doing is a beautiful thing and people like Iris should rightfully be ignored and recognized for what they truly are. Carry on mate!

[@marilievanderwalt]

I have been singing in choirs for the past 45 years and cannot imagine my life without it. I can personally attest to the healing power of music. Mr Barton, please continue to improve the quality of these elephants' lives. For many of us, watching your videos has been a light in a very dark world over the past year. Thank you so much!

[@Dave5843-d9m]

The film of Paul's night time rendition of Moonlight Sonata to Mongkol, the rescued 61 years old logging elephant, is absolutely stunning.

[@mudkip_btw]

I've enjoyed free videos and music from you for over 6 years. I cant imagine how anyone would think you're doing this to make money. Don't stop following your passion, Paul. Best wishes from NL

[@andi2234]

I honestly dont see a problem with making money from KZbin, almost everyone on KZbin wants to and many do make money from their own channel. Its his channel and his time and effort and that of his family. I am very sorry he doesn't make money. He should be. What he does with his money is none anyone's freaking business but his wife. Who does ANYONE think they are to make an effort to slander an innocent person with this hate speech? He so completely blew her claims out of the water and I believe he could sue this woman for her contentious lies. But Paul won't. He's more forgiving than most of mankind and certainly people like Iris.

[@AmnerisMonster]

First of all, I LOVE the work that you're doing. Second of all, I admire the kindness and grace you've exhibited while explaining why what they said was wrong.

[@digitalproductions4758]

It's so strange, you'd think this kinda post would come from the typical journalist whose job is to simply be as sensational as possible with articles to get clicks and such. But from someone who also cares for these majestic creatures and wants for them to have a healthy and happy future...? Paul and the team's extraordinary treatment, enrichment of the elephants and ability to educate all of us through this medium are unquestionably obvious throughout this entire journey over the years.

[@sallyshipwreck4315]

I suspect she is a lot like Newkirk of PETA, and had her own agenda. If you read the About Us - The Team section of her website she says this: "We have experience in designing successful political campaigns." No mention of who the team is, only that they have 20,000 likes on Facebook. I'm not impressed.

[@Catglittercrafts]

@@sallyshipwreck4315 exactly. She’s a professional outrage grifter. Getting people upset over things they don’t understand so she can take their money while promising to “bring awareness”

[@jzk3919]

No-Not a journalist. That is a corrupt but legitimate profession. Libeler and joykiller is NOT (yet).

[@Dave5843-d9m]

There are very few real journalists today. Most of them operate to a hard socialist agenda. Iris seems to be one of the worst exponents of this now distorted "profession".

[@quicklykay]

@@sallyshipwreck4315 A fine post. “We have experience in designing successful political campaigns.” So she designs political hit pieces, much like what she attempted here. 🤨

[@cretax]

One can argue against therapeutic effect of the music on these majestic creatures, I could understand that. But it is obvious in your videos that the habitat they live is so peaceful and this and the mere fact that they are not restrained in any form are enough to make her claims void. Best wishes

[@rockybernard2997]

iris's writing exposes more about Iris than it does about Paul Barton and his musical elephants

[@Smith-Orange]

This video is most likely the only reason anyone would have heard of Iris. It is very good to see the History, and background, of your time with the Elephants. Thank you for your videos, And thaank you for your time, as well as the time of the others there, who are caring for the Elephants

[@jogriffiths4797]

I wish there was a stronger response I could make than simply a thumbs up. How awful that a deceitful blog post can have such repercussions and cause such distress to so many people. Your integrity and love for the animals and people around you is plainly obvious, and I applaud your thorough and complete response to this blogger.

[@galen61]

Paul, you are the living embodiment of graciousness. Indeed, you live so that when ill is spoken of you, no one believes it.

[@andi2234]

Well said galeb61!

[@janniebee9501]

Earis has no friends. Imagine having such a reduced understanding of the world that music is abusive. Don't give silly people a greater voice. No one would even have to try to make any sense of her nonsense if you didn't mention it.

[@what-I-enjoy-doing]

How can she say all that without evidence, this is a very delicate issue to accuse people like that. I love your work your paintings, your music and the way you and your daughter interact . Keep your good work, many blessings.

[@urzathehappy72]

Yes; i mean if were just making things up now someone could easily write a whole article about how Iris enslaves monkeys to write her horrific articles. What nonsense. She should delete that horrific libel.

[@andi2234]

@@urzathehappy72 i doubt she will on her own but I truly hope she is shamed into doing just that. Maybe it should stay public to show what a fool she is?

[@AemiliaJacobus]

There is plenty of evidence that elephants are being mistreated at the places Paul volunteered at. You absolutely should not ride on an elephant's back because their spines are not developed to carry heavy loads.

[@what-I-enjoy-doing]

@@AemiliaJacobus well you should show the evidence then.

[@GuyG.KTalesOfAnimals]

some people try to do their best at doing good but don't have the skills to do the gather their information and than word it right, fact check it correctly, they have a need to advocate something that they feel deeply about, but they're not doing it well. some people also likes pointing frauds out at any chance they have, even if they're not having the full picture, if the person really thinks they're right, they will call a fraud. advocating right and wrong is not simply easy, and lots of information doesn't make it easier.

[@myracahill7409]

I love how much you love what you share with the elephants. I hope you continue to touch their souls and add beauty to their lives, as you do to your fans.

[@ggwoman]

Poor, poor Iris Koch. Imagine living in the self contrived darkness of her soul?

[@pianoish]

There are so many people who have it so good in this world that they are desperately looking for something to be mad about.

[@f-Lm5MbLM4_8]

Looks like one of those impulsive immature people who always want to “fight evil” so that they can feel better about themselves.

[@greymouser8659]

@@f-Lm5MbLM4_8 aka Personality Disorders. The 21st Centuries media growth industry....sadly

[@ruthrogers808]

A person that chooses butter not better is the real sad part of a person/s that does not exist happy therefore finds it difficult to share joy😌🙂😳🐘😊🎹🎤🎻🌼🕊

[@lifeofwonderment]

I know you are doing this as a rebuttal, but I am finding it a fascinating behind the scenes look at what you do. Thank you for sharing!

[@julianmachin3051]

The elephants seem to have decided this argument; often in ways that bring one to tears; so beautiful their appreciation of this music can be - thank u.

[@NateGerardRealEstateTeam]

I agree, this piece was frequently very moving.

[@DiyEcoProjects]

Dear Paul ~ sorry youve got the brunt of some twats out there. Dont give them the time of day. What you and elephant world do is wonderful and beyond reproach. Intellegent creatures apprecaite music because it tingles the senses and they are emotional. My you be surrounded with love and blessings, all the best kieron

[@suziemelton8491]

It was an honor to meet you at Elephants world. The music you give to the elephants and the world is a gift to all. Keep doing what you love. I feel sorry for those who are so negative...

[@sallyshipwreck4315]

Thank you Paul and your family for your work and your graciousness in this weird, strange and sometimes cruel world. Don't stop. Condolences for your losses of both 2 and 4 footers.

[@theresatyler4043]

Why would someone belittle, dehumanize your efforts to share love and kindness with these intelligent, sensitive, majestic Mammals..? 🐘🙏💖🐘

[@andrewdavidson8854]

You, Sir, are a saint and you are doing God’s work. Please keep it up!

[@randomgrinn]

I just wish God was doing God's work...I would think he could get rid of all the evil around here if he bothered to lift a finger. Screw free will, people who do evil don't deserve any free will.

[@polishscores]

I came across this article the other day, and I'm extremely glad you set the facts straight in the way that you did.

[@caseym8385]

Dang, I did not expect to cry this much in a video about music and elephants. The tribute to your friend around 40:00 and her outlook on life was really inspiring. Thanks for sharing this Paul.

[@StarCrusher.]

Some people are just so negative, sad, hurt and thus cynical that, when someone does something genuinely kind they can't help but make up a cruel story in their head of how things "really" happened.

[@theresatyler4043]

they got to be loaded on something in their head. HOW DARE THEY...Iris who the fluk ever.

[@calliecanrinus8318]

Your kindness to Iris is Undeserved on her part but it's evident you love the elephants. I loved watching this. Elephants dance to your music it seems! Thank you for fulfilling your calling from God. It's beautiful.

[@mendyboio3917]

Paul you are obviously a loving soul. Please keep up what you are doing, with the elephants. May you have a long, healthy and joyful life.

[@jgalaxygal]

Iris, trying to snuff out the light and goodness of others does not make yours shine brighter. You have just cancelled yourself. Envy is not a virtue.

[@nancyfarris6006]

WELL SAID!

[@judyfowler2023]

There's always a sour apple in every bunch, she the one! He tries to bring beauty into poor animals life and she finds that bad. Poor woman, I pity her

[@SuseV8]

Excellent painting Paul ~ shining a LIGHT on the darkness. Thank you for loving elephants , animals, people like you do ~ Many Blessings ~ Suse & Crew Vancouver Island BC CANADA ~*~

[@arletquintero2738]

Mr. Paul, really is Extraordinary when you are playing the Classical Music to the elephants!!! Exactly, Music is "The Universal Language". I see to the elephants when they're listening the music and they're relaxing. This is Amazing!!!

[@joyliu9527]

This is true courage, an honest and peaceful voice

[@jmjanacek4335]

Paul thank you for this gift to the whole world! You truly are a treasure!

[@lynnrussell1630]

Not only do they listen but they feel vibration through their feet. This is calming, stimulating and enriching for the elephants.

[@An0niem4]

I love how the first thing you play for an elephant is literally the Elephant from the Carnaval des Animaux 😄

[@judycook4314]

I love the squeaks and trumpets! Happy elephants not being forced to do anything or mistreated in any way!!!

[@PaulaSand]

Don’t worry to answer Paul! You are doing a blessed work! She doesn’t know what she is saying!

[@vitaredit6781]

Paul, please be sure that all of us as Animals lovers from all over the World, are all convinced of your wonderful work, commitment, great love for elephants and strong support for Elephant world and their Mahouts ! What you are doing with your Family is priceless! Thank you so much to deliver your music to them and to us altogether, for your dedicated time to take care of the elephants and understand their reaction. Thank you for your pedagogy to really understand the behavior of each one of your great friends gentle giants, and for explaining their past, their suffering and then, you adapt your approach according to their own story. And thank you to contribute to bring them joy and pleasure in their lives. What you demonstrate through this beautiful musical approach is, that our friends are really developed in their minds and so far, humans have hugely underestimated their intelligence, their sensibility ! You also play for Macaques and this is also incredible. I am sure that Natsuo and the other friend you lost, would agree with me. Best wishes from France

[@15minutestoread97]

There's only one reason I can think of her writing this article. Attention. She got it, troll of the day. Let's move on now. :)

[@stjust17320]

One of very few great people in this world today..bless you Paul thanks so much for your example of humanity and selflessness

[@JoshuaC923]

You know you are doing something right when people hate you, great response Paul! Keep up the great work!

[@JoshuaC923]

Those baby elephants, they are too adorable!

[@joec4251]

We have always enjoyed your video's of playing to the elephant's Paul...we can see how you touch their hearts, and move them to a calm content mood....it touches our hearts, and keeps our faces wet in happiness...we think the world of you, and all the others there caring for the elephants...you inspire us, and we are so grateful that there are such kind people in the world to care for these beautiful creatures...Thank you for your kindness, love and mercy...please keep it up, and don't change...we love you all just the way you are, you are angels to the elephants, and wonderful beyond words...God Bless

[@SnarkNSass]

I can't stop my tears. Your videos are a blessing for us all. How anyone could watch and have a negative thought is beyond me. I share your videos with friends and we all feel the joy. It was nice to hear more background info of the elephants and your story. ❤💜💙💚💚💛💖

[@Juraberg]

Paul, my sincere congratulations for your precious work with the elephants and for this great video 👍🏼.

[@ashleyrenegade]

It’s probably the best response to someone who just throws uneducated spiteful accusations. Some folks have a hard time believing there are decent humans out there who share their talents and give to those in need selflessly.. and without expecting anything in return. The gift of music is one of the best gifts of all, and should be shared with humans and animals alike. If her agenda is to self soothe by sabotaging others, her problem runs deep within herself. Thank you for opening up and showing transparency. “As an antidote to battle unkindness we were given kindness.” Marcus Aurelius

[@TheOriginalNiceGuy]

She’s a product of the SJW eco alphabet mafia metoo feminism etc. They need to manufacture fake comfortable villains in order to keep their fake self righteous power grab party going.

[@ecoquilting7077]

I think I'll take the word of the experienced rescued elephant caretakers, who saw the elephants respond to the music, over that of Iris! Also I will trust my own eyes ears and heart which all responded when I began to see Paul's videos. After the lives of pain and loneliness that the elephants have suffered through, to see them respond by relaxing, or trumpeting, or squeaking, laying down in the river, or like Peter the elephant, playing the blues, it is a beautiful thing that Paul's done,

[@eMrSKgold]

You do wonderful healing music to the elephants and us! Thank You and warm Alohas!

[@emilyscloset2648]

This is a beautiful piece. I thank you for all your work that you do. No one can doubt your devotion and love of these amazing creatures

[@jessicarasmussen3466]

I just discovered you this morning. What an inspiration!! I applaud you for taking this route in educating your “attacker”. I hope Iris has changed her outlook on you and all of the selfless work you do for these beautiful animals! I hope everyone remembers not to believe everything you see and read online without educating yourself first!

[@videosfromelsewhere926]

Paul your performances are excellent and your affection for animals is remarkable and sincere. Don't let the critics dissuade you or discourage you, they are seeking their own selfish gain and are jealous of you. Keep on sir!

[@comevincent]

Thank you for everything you do Paul, I wish you and your family the best !

[@SuzetteGrist]

May I return as a Thai elephant under Paul's care.😊

[@debrafshoemaker7071]

Thank you, Paul. Blessings and peace to you and your precious family. Keep up the amazing and beautiful work. God has truly gifted you in so many ways. 🐘 ❤️

[@Sunshine-hv1eu]

In a way, I’m glad that Iris Koch wrote that erroneous blog…because now we get to see in-depth, your beautiful work with these magnificent elephants. They are truly soulful and sentient beings. I’m very glad you responded to her misguided and misleading accusations with this beautiful video. I was also deeply moved by Natsuyo Jaeko - hearing her speak and watching her kindness was a stark contrast to the vile accusations made by Iris. Rest in peace Natsuyo-I wish I had the opportunity to know you. Lately, in a world populated by extremists and hostile, misguided people like Iris Koch, I’m reminded of this… “Beware that, when fighting monsters, you yourself do not become a monster... for when you gaze long into the abyss, the abyss gazes also into you.”-Friedrich Nietzsche. Many “activists” who once had good intentions, have become the monsters. Thank you Mr. Barton, and for your lovely wife and daughter, for all that you do! ❤

[@reyag7206]

I cannot believe somebody would be this salty over something and someone so wholesome

[@2Happee]

Thank you so much for your compassion, love and care for these precious creations of our God. I'm a huge fan of 🐘 🐘 🐘 🐘 🐘 🐘🐘. May God bless and keep you well in all you do.

[@cutiesusieq7413]

Beautiful artist and concert pianist and so caring for the elephant s! Amazing man!

[@janelahmeyer2014]

Chin up, Paul, since I found your site my life is as uplifted as the elephants’ who are so lucky to be part of your love and beautiful music. You’re a lifesaving helper.

[@DeniseRispoli]

Paul, thank you so much for what you do! The face and demeanor of these elephants is so obviously so very positive! I play the piano myself and wish I had ONE person who provided me such undivided attention when I play! You are so fortunate and blessed and you have my total moral support! Thanks again!

[@galepatrick1702]

I hope Iris Koch has the grace to make an apology - she may have done more damage than good for the elephants

[@ernstraedecker6174]

She will not.

[@birgitfreyler6076]

I find your response to her , more than amazing. You have my greatest respect. Keep up your great work and spirit!

[@katesterner]

Thank you, Paul, for putting so much effort into extending compassionate grace to a person who clearly suffers from great bitterness. Whatever the cause of her own poisonous animosity, you have taken the time to show her, and the world, the truth. You have repaid injury with kindness. Thank you for leading by example. Perhaps she will change. Perhaps she will not. Bitter people will always be with us. But at least you know you have not succumbed to the same hurtful and acidic behavior. You have stood up for the truth without hurting anyone in return. Bless you, Paul.

[@andi2234]

Well said. "You shall know the Truth and the Truth will set you free" __Jesus Christ

[@amj.composer]

I'd rather trust someone whom I've been watching for years and followed the tutorials of and really helped my growth as a pianist than some no name on the internet begging to be noticed.

[@christopherjamesmarinopian8523]

(Keep playing for these lovely smart giants. I love it that you fight back with kindness. I strongly believe that kindness is a lot more stronger than negative people because kindness is everything and kindness makes you want to be more successful in life but the only thing more powerful than kindness is music.)

[@sheraaa9169]

Beautifully and classy response to a clearly bitter woman thank you for all that you do for these beautiful animals xx

[@barb6379]

I'm sorry Iris has offended you. I have been watching you for some time now and I thoroughly enjoy it. I have a love of elephants, but I've never had the pleasure to meet one. You bring the experience through your videos and I appreciate it greatly. I'm sad of the darker stories of what has and still happens to them, experiencing harsh cruelty, but I love all the people who show and have compassion for them. Thank you for doing what you do. I'd like to think I'm right there with you. I cry and feel your pain when you lost the young elephant you have become close to. God Bless you.

[@TheMusicalKnokcers]

I think he was more hurt than offended as one would be, what do you think ?

[@rlunger1]

Paul, I watched this whole video. It says so much! Thank you for everything you do to help elephants and their care-givers. Ross

[@schwobi123]

.....amazing answer to a thoughtless post as well as topmost Buddhist lecture I´ve received so far! Thank you Paul

[@IlGattonero13]

What a pity that you were compelled to take precious time to assemble evidence against Koch's groundless and slanderous charges. This video is as reasoned, measured, and gracious a refutation as I have ever seen. Your intentions are clear, your hard work and generosity have been offered unconditionally, and the elephants' spontaneous and positive response speaks for itself. I am deeply moved by how the music cheers, engages, and calms these magnificent animals -- and by the astonishing effects of music on many species. My life would be empty without music. Thank you for enriching the lives of these elephants and for demonstrating to the world the potential of music and the spirit of appreciation in nonhuman creatures. Sending my best wishes.

[@andi2234]

Well articulated.

[@TheOriginalNiceGuy]

She’s a product of the SJW eco alphabet mafia metoo feminism etc. They need to manufacture fake comfortable villains in order to keep their fake self righteous power grab party going.

[@Ajdizzle4rizzle]

I wish I could like this more times because it is kind and beautiful.

[@craigkeller]

Music is the universal language of the heart. It is unfortunate some people don’t speak it. Or hear it.

[@dimensionalfuse1810]

Paul- you are MY HERO! Kind, gentle souls can be deeply wounded by malevolent, taker-type people. I have not read comments from this video yet but I’ll bet you have 99% opinions much like mine. The fact that sad, angry, upset people want to pull you down a ring or two is the small minority. And as much as I like the wonderful things you share on KZbin - I will ALWAYS prefer hearing sweet Emilie sing or play over even your well trained classical fibers and ear. You two are quite the team.

[@critterfriendly9055]

Excellent response Paul. Lovely music and wonderful passion you have for the magnificent creatures.

[@dafffyduckx494]

Paul, thank you for everything that you do! ♡

[@emilyadams6194]

This is an incredible video--again so sensitive and so well done and informative about the emotional nature of elephants. I am 80 years old and think of nothing more delightful than hearing your music. Fortunately, I can just turn on your videos. Love your choices of music. I believe you and your wife have been an important part of understanding these lovely animals.

[@mariageorgakopoulou1236]

Mr Barton you are an exceptional soul. Thank you so much! Keep up your excellent work ❤️❤️❤️

[@coolbpf66]

Your wife's sculptures are simply astounding!

[@TermiteUSA]

Paul, what you do and the music you bring them, you also bring to us. I love your detailed presentations and the titles and history of classical pieces. The actions of that woman are disgusting, arrogant and hateful. Some miserable people can't stand that others can improve their own lives and that of others. Be strong and stay safe. You have real substantial talent and class. Thank you again.

[@jc9552]

Paul, don't let it get to you. Everybody knows you love music as much as animals. You are a kind and gentle soul and bring joy with your music to people throughout the world as much as to animals. Ignore her and keep doing what you are doing. You are much loved and respected for it.

[@galepatrick1702]

I've loved watching your videos - to see these wonderful elephants being able to enjoy the medium of classical music in the wild and in their own unique ways has been a gift - thank you Paul and thanks to all who make it possible-

[@clementblisskrypt464]

This video has sliced me up and helped me focus on what I always wanted to do for a living as a kid. Never bury your vision of what the world should be. We have to work for wildlife and sharing our emotions with it. We're born on the same ground, and if we feel like we're the top of the ''chain'' we must use our position to save and live with animals, it's our duty. Protect and carry them. Paul Barton, i wish you the best and hope i'll be part of it someday for the rest of my life.

[@christaporche]

Paul, thank you for seizing the opportunity Iris offered you to teach us more about elephants with their capacity to enjoy music. And to offer people around the world to expand their compassion toward these beautiful animals. I hope Iris was able to open up her heart and understand the amazing way you open yours to everything that you do. Thank you.

[@JFrameMan]

I've been following since before you showed yourself playing to elephants, and I knew it was a fake accusation from the start. I'm glad to see you taking it positively and I hope it didn't bother you too much. Most people have to deal with the misfortune of slander as they rise to fame, and some people won't leave others alone, so this is a solid response to end it.

[@carolynnunes3922]

This is far worse than slander. Slander is somebody SPEAKING lies about you. This is LIBEL! Libel is when someone says lies about you in WRITING! It does far deeper and longer lasting hurt and damage to a person whose reputation has been lied about! I think that people libel others out of hatred and malice! It is evil! Unfortunately, we are living in an age of those deceiving and being deceived, and propaganda is rampant. Even the fact checkers aren’t really fact checkers at all! And unfortunately, even if she repented of her actions and printed a retraction, people won’t remember that. They will remember the lies that she told initially. All journalists learn this. They feel free to lie to get sensational headlines, because they know that this what people remember, not the correction or retraction days later! I pray that everybody will rise up and defend Paul, and I hope that she will receive an avalanche of “shame on you!” Responses! Oh dear! I really hate editing my comments, I like leaving them as they stand, but I neglected to say how much I love Paul and wife and their daughter Emile, and watching him play for the elephants and creating paintings, and he inches daughter reading stories and creating stories and it’s just so uplifting to watch. To think that anybody would attack Paul and family is insane!

[@dianechicarelli8605]

@@carolynnunes3922 Far from correcting her defamatory lies, Iris' response was to double down on the misinformation she is attempting to spread. Instead of admitting she was wrong when she claimed these videos were made to make money somehow, she linked to videos of animals being abused - not by Paul or anyone at Elephants World. I get it. The more outrage she can work up in her readers, the more likely they will be to donate to her organization. Very sad.

[@francesbruno8445]

Anyone who has seriously worked with and observed animals, know that music does "Soothe the savage beast". Music is played in stables, milk parlours, etc. We left a radio on for our German Shepherd in our commercial greenhouse. Today, we can settle our Gordon setter's nightly rip, by playing a Leonard Cohen CD, which puts her immediately to sleep. There are new communication networks opening as brain damaged people can communicate with both parties singing, where talking part of the brain no longer processes. The Canadian pianist, Glen Gould used to sing to the Elephants at the Toronto zoo. Last question... Why do animals sing, whistle , howl, tweet together in constant melodies?

[@karenramnath9993]

Love this documentary type video; I learned so much! Your painting came out beautiful. It’s sad that some people can’t stand to see others make beauty in the world. God put a gift in your fingers, so you could help make the world beautiful.

[@patrickcahill7998]

Wonderful stuff Paul. You’re a credit to humanity. Much love to you and yours ❤️

[@Betterworld47]

We can clearly see that the elephants’ reaction to the music is pure enjoyment. If we appreciate music why wouldn’t they? I have most respect for their efforts to prepare all the food for these beautiful giants and play music for them. Congratulations to Mr Barton’s dedication.