The Israel Lobby Is Real. This Is How It Works | Aaron Bastani meets Ilan Pappé

[@bloodmuffin123]

AIPAC NEEDS TO BE LISTED AS A FOREIGN AGENT.

[@JerrySeriatos]

Tribal agent

[@ManlioMocchi]

AIPAC is n. 1 Terrorist organization in the US

[@adeptpeasant6161]

I'm not sure if it qualifies when the USA and the UK are defacto parents to Israel as Israel can't stand on its own two feet without the sweat and deaths of their nations

[@stevensica5918]

Subversive enemy group is more to the point.

[@NotEvenDeathCanSaveU]

More like listed as terrorist group

[@Gee-xb7rt]

Why call it a lobby? It's a racketeering mafia ring.. .

[@realolivertwisted]

🎯

[@QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

Yes, I have long called it a political mafia. Some Italians have the criminal mafia, and some Jews have these lobbies which make the Italian mafia look like angels because they haven't massacted 10s of thousands of people.

[@stasiandme]

They are selling everything, even your birth certificate is for sell.

[@jackklugman107]

Yup like the ADL is an extortion racket that works with intelligence agencies.. like the mob

[@AlluminaOnyxia]

It's too often the same thing.

[@huqmafizul]

Before the 7th of October attacks on Israel, my knowledge on Israel was very vague and I'd support Israel, but Prof Pappe's lectures in different platforms opened my eyes. I kept studying and learned the truth. I'm grateful to Prof Pappe for telling us the true story.

[@fuckbankers]

Thank you.

[@theresabarzee1463]

Me too! Huge beautiful bodies of work w/so many real scholars of conscience coming to teach us thru love! Welcome!

[@khaderlander2429]

Well it goes to show education in the modern setting is not doing it's job of real education which used to mean to lead out what is within, like socrates said long ago learning is a process of recollection, to bring forth the genuine genius within. Modern educational environment is more like indoctrination to make one a cog in the western machinery of corrupt capitalism. Slavery never truly disappeared in it's totality, what takes it's place is the modern wage slave culture and modern education inculcate that status, everyone is assigned their place in the pyramid.

[@fabiobrondi8199]

I'm sorry, but what Israel was doing before before Oct 7th was very obvious. They have been dehumanizing, dispossessing and violating Palestinian human rights for 70+ years. What more evidence or information did you need?

[@silwiagrabo2319]

Thank you for beeing open minded and awaken

[@marketads1]

I live in the US. I made friends with a Palestinian while working at Xerox and saw the deep emotion in his eyes when he said, very simply, “I have no country.” He had no billionaires to stand up for him.

[@TJMotionPictures]

💔

[@lightbody232]

this is very sad 😔

[@KJ-yises]

He is American.

[@tawfikabbas5888]

@@KJ-yises no, we're not. our culture is already being erased enough already

[@6060juggler]

Their country is Jordan as that was part of the mandate called Palestine. Too bad his leaders could care less about their people

[@NurulHuda-xj8ob]

Thank God for Novara media sticking up for Palestinian kids when no one else did. Please keep donating and supporting them

[@Globaldave1970]

Ever death caused by Hamas.

[@number1neek]

Hell yeah! I love being a supporter and watching them grow and improve. They're always punching above their weight and bring on top quality guests. We must help them keep growing, they are the future of journalism ✊

[@serpentines6356]

​@@number1neek Do you support Israels right to exist in peace?

[@number1neek]

@@serpentines6356 of course! But not at the expense of another people or nation. An occupied people have a duty to resist their occupier. The occupier does not have a right to self defence on occupied territory. Plain and simple

[@theviewfromnowhere2747]

@@number1neekan occupier does not have the right to occupy so how could Israel ever exist in peace ?

[@benwalid6702]

Free USA from AIPAC

[@mercomania]

And the UK from our version of AIPAC which hides behind several names.

[@benwalid6702]

@@mercomania yeah... That is true

[@tuckerbugeater]

Free us from the Holy Roman Empire free us from the Pope free us from the British free us from America

[@offmyface1]

So they are not a small group of highly organised intelligent people running the world by holding it ransom?

[@jackklugman107]

Bribery and blackmail like the ADL extortion racket

[@FuadMohamed-k7o]

Imagine what Israel did to the Palestinians when we couldn't see their crimes on our phones.

[@realolivertwisted]

💯

[@jolima]

Yeah, or what the Americans did, or the Chinese, or the Sudanese, or the Iranians, or the Ruandies, or the Serbs, or the Russians, or… It’s all pretty horrible

[@norbertgeorge]

We don't need to imagine, we can all look it up: 1937: Haifa massacre 1937: Jerusalem massacre 1938: Haifa massacre 1939: Balad Al Sheikh massacre 1939: Haifa massacre 1947: Haifa massacre 1947: Abassiya massacre 1947: Al-Khisas massacre 1947: Bab Al-Amud massacre 1947: Jerusalem massacre 1947: Sheikh Bureik massacre 1948: Tantura massacre 1948: Jaffa massacre 1948: Deir Yassin massacre 1956: Khan Yunis massacre 1967: Jerusalem massacre 1982: Sabra al-Shatila massacre 1990: Al Aqsa massacre 1994: Ibrahim mosque massacre 2002: Jenin refugee camp massacre 2008: Gaza massacre 2012: Gaza massacre 2014: Gaza massacre 2018: Gaza massacre 2021: Gaza massacre 2023 - ongoing: Gaza genocide

[@BeccaBow010]

I honestly can't even begin think about this. The fact that so many still proudly display that flag on their profiles 😫🤯🤯

[@marcsmith-mt9vz]

and what we wouldn't have seen if it wasn't for the bodycams on the 7th

[@manuelpousa6533]

Thanks, mr. Pappé. We need you more than ever. Spain stands with Palestine

[@mariadoloresgonzalezalvare2694]

Ni siquiera apoya a las personas ,Hipócritas 😎

[@Haka61276]

Ilan Pappe Sir, high respect for your unbiased investigative history. Your work will go deep down into future studies of how to make this world a better place. Thank you, Sir.

[@leaalia2394]

THIS man is one of the REAL chosen ones ✊️✊️✊️

[@carlretter4263]

We are living in a time were truth requires courage. Thanks for having both

[@TheHonestSpeaker]

Age of deception brother

[@Ln-cq8zu]

The truth always requires courage. 😊

[@Ln-cq8zu]

​@@TheHonestSpeaker Lies are the modus operandi of the so called leaders! 😮

[@irwan3064]

_All my opinion comments in You Tube were taken down with a warning and eventually suspended for 24 hrs._

[@DonnyKanone]

​@@Ln-cq8zuNot at all. Truth requires courage when it comes with consequences for the teller.

[@HijabigirlBydesign]

I condemn the terrorist acts and war crimes of Israel. I support the creation of a free and independent Palestinian state. This will end all the violence. As civil society, we need to accept that Israel is the occupying force and we need to do the right thing and give Palestinians their own independent state free from Israeli interferences. CRITCIZING ISRAEL ISN'T ANTISEMITISM!!! JUDAISM HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH ZIONISM !!!!

[@71suns]

Thank you for speaking the truth.

[@annychest718]

Is it not a bit late for peace now after more than 500,000 deaths..untold injurers attacks on Yemen Lebanon Iran and Syria not to mention the 'Wrest's' coalition in the fabricated wars against Afghanistan and Iraq following the 9/11 false flag.. things have changed You are coining a phase.. but what is A/S❓ Moreover what is Judaism❓

[@samcinematics]

❤️ I echo this!

[@mschickie007]

100%

[@greggsenne1268]

How does a Palestinian state come about? By whose authority? The UN? Israel ignores the UN as it wishes. As long as Israel opposes a Palestinian state, the US will not force the issue.

[@gerhard7323]

“The greatest evils in the world will not be carried out by men with guns, but by men in suits sitting behind desks.” C S Lewis.

[@irwan3064]

_That's what happening to the US administration inside out_

[@annalisa14]

@@irwan3064. And has been for decades

[@youkouncoun6533]

Brillant Statement!

[@madelinecoren483]

Yes, the 1%.

[@Dada-s5d]

Ali nije li ispod časti slušati naređenja ljudi u odijelima ako nas nagovaraju na zlocin Užas šta ljudi rade za novac a svi idemo tvorcu sami sa našim djelima

[@mseesea]

Keep AIPAC out of American politics! Long live Thomas Massey!

[@angiek1827]

And Bernie Sanders

[@IanuaDiaboli]

So many pearls dropped in this interview. I am so grateful I could live in the same lifetime as masterminds like Prof. Pappé.

[@1972543]

This man ..prof pappe ,prof Norman Finkelstein,prof naom Chomsky and media journalist like Chris hedger and max Blementhal are beacons of moral justice and integrity with intellectualism.there efforts will be be remembered and taught in history classes .we ,the moral concious people of the world are profusely grateful and inspired by them .🙏🙏🎉🎉

[@greghdn]

Check out for Miko Peled too.

[@janetwalk4996]

Yes these 5 people have restored some clarity and humanity in this chaotic period of barbarism.

[@Saxtrup]

To call Blumenthal a beacon of moral justice is to completely overlook the vile propaganda, that he did in favor of the fascistic dictator Bashar Al-Assad. The Palestinian cause is not fought by denying the atrocities committed by Israels enemies. You are welcome to research Mr Blumenthal's work on Syria yourself

[@greghdn]

I would add Miko Peled to the list as well.

[@1972543]

@@greghdn oh yes ..I forgot miko peled ..He too is a great i con

[@cacevedo07]

Thanks for interviewing, Prof. Pappe. This channel deserves millions of followers

[@jazmin1932]

Ilan Pappe ! An honorable human, historian, and the kind of Israeli the world needs

[@Astra-k5d]

What the World needs its to put a stop to the Jews going on about "anti-semitism".

[@stevensica5918]

More Ilans, fewer Bibis!

[@JesseReza-g4l]

a true Human Being.

[@H.A.S-s4i]

Full respect for Professor Ilan Pappe.

[@alyoung7529]

WOW!!! What an interview. This scholar has filled in spaces and blanks in my understanding of the machinations of the Israel-Palestine picture. It also led to more light on the power that Israel holds and how they attained it. I could not square the idea of Israel and how they seem to maintain the unconditional support they have always had. I now have a better understanding of the Israeli influence and how it came to be. INSIDIOUS!!! Thank you Ilan Pappe and also Aaron Bastani.

[@mohamedsalem6014]

Hail the new media! Getting out of traditional media channels is like atonement

[@tuckerbugeater]

Hail Caesar!

[@Lynnthomason45]

I have not watched network tv news in 2 1/2 years. I’m free of all the lies. It’s more peaceful here online. 😎

[@GiNyYu222]

and relief

[@adammckay2647]

Way to go...​@@Lynnthomason45

[@silvamnatsakanyan3774]

Today Armenia recognized Palestinian state 👍🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲I am very proud of my government

[@americanescu]

My hat off! Much respect!

[@GiNyYu222]

where? i didnt saw any official statement of Armenia gov

[@emmanuelobareki4655]

Delusion of grandeur

[@ahhdodbegyd]

love from iran to armanian brothers

[@persieprince9345]

Love and peace to the people of Armenia

[@jologo18]

Fascinating! Prof. Pappe's "Ten Myths About Israel" and "The Biggest Prison on Earth: A History of the Occupied Territories" have transformed my understanding of the Israel-Palestine conflict. I will add his new book to my reading list. Thank you both for an informative and insightful conversation!

[@morninboy]

Read Norman Finkelstein's Gaza as well.

[@bleep957]

Really , try looking at Gaza and PLO history of terrorism, maybe you'll understand why theres big walls round Gaza .

[@qadriyyahshabazz4369]

@@jologo18 I WHOLEHEARTEDLY AGREE

[@touloulou54]

​@@morninboy👍🏼 Shlomo Sand is brilliant too

[@mischevious]

John Meirsheimer’s The Lobby!

[@viracocha4261]

Love Ilan Pappe! He's the genuine article.

[@SirAmicVarze]

Great conversation. The part about how the lobby now heavily relies on threats these days because the moral argument is no longer possible to make is spot on.

[@SA-km3oh]

Massive Respect to Pr. Ilan Pappé 🙏 Thank you Novara Media for this interesting and insightful exchange 🙏

[@imjamesiam]

Israel is such a waste of my taxes. They should stand alone.

[@rehan2118]

Nobody wants to have anything to do with Israel but they keep shoving themselves to the world

[@victormeidan1062]

What taxes ? What are you talking about ?

[@rehan2118]

@@victormeidan1062 all the tax payers money goes to Israehell

[@dondomingo6578]

Hear hear

[@rehan2118]

@@dondomingo6578 Israelhell is a waste of breath

[@stellamillburn6145]

Ilan Pappe is a giant among men, such a heart and such a mind, an amazing human being

[@jackklugman107]

He is what Israel could’ve been

[@LC2025-e8n]

​@@jackklugman107You understand this topic well, excellent work!🖖🏻

[@LuzEmiliaSanchez-cz5si]

This video is very important so that people understand what this dangerous lobby means for the peace and economy of the world.

[@harouttorossian275]

UNBELIEVABLE, the TRUTHFULNESS!!!!!!!

[@TheFaro2011]

I met him in 2009, I wasn't as well acquainted with his work as I am now. What an honest man, can't believe he's Israeli!😅

[@QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

I heard of him back in 1998 or so and met Finkelstein then. Both influenced my thinking.

[@MaryLou5239]

Mine too

[@lidiyasimatovic1118]

Every nation has good and bad people. Israel to have a lot of good people.

[@laurastuart3814]

Gilad Atzmon is also very interesting.

[@bleep957]

Wow , really hilarious. Try living under Hamas 😂😂😂

[@joegunner1702]

This is by far the most comprehensive bit of education you'll ever hear on the palestine issue. Finally someone has given Ilan the time to speak and none of this 30 seconds nonsense you get on social media these days. You cant stop listening to Ilan.

[@MaryLou5239]

Agree

[@Ln-cq8zu]

And since the advent of podcasts, it now quite obvious why MSM didn't want long style conversations! 😢

[@djpaulcfunkeddub3951]

Actually Palestinians is the most comprehensive educational perspective, but this helps

[@susieharmon2229]

Yes, I agree. Prof. Pappe has many really good and crucial interviews but this one somehow covers so much ground.

[@dLehman]

Thank you for bringing on Ilan Pappe. He’s a legend.

[@cynthiamadrid1430]

❤ ILAN , found him so teresting and honest after the Oct. 7 attack. The history he shares is valuable for understanding the conflict in Gaza, now Lebanon.

[@poerava]

This was a seriously amazing interview Thank you

[@syy9429]

Ilan Pappe. A fighter for humanity. Thank you sir for your voice.

[@thecheshirecat999]

Ilan Pappe is such an important figure in Palestinian liberation, he will be rememberednand read for generations to come. Thabk you!!!❤❤❤

[@mattlech8641]

Good to see the professor looking so well

[@irwan3064]

Cheers Professor,my ovation

[@789loveislam]

Thank you for standing with the oppressed people of palestine.

[@JesseReza-g4l]

and informing us with humane facts.

[@paulinemilwood333]

“We cannot win the moral argument” … an insightful Israeli acknowledgement here. Thank you, Prof. Pappe.

[@Maryanne-j2e]

Mr. pappe, a man of Honor and fairness. God bless you and Free Palestine

[@vidaller79]

Everyone should listen to this!! Thank you Prof Pappe ✌🏽❤️

[@JesseReza-g4l]

listening. so what now?

[@omiid8393]

Mr. Bastani, thanks fir your courage. Respect from Axis of resistance in I.R.Iran 🇮🇷❤️🇮🇶❤️🇵🇸❤️🇾🇪❤️🇱🇧❤️🇦🇫❤️🇸🇾

[@Bosniandandelion]

This is such cool way to show what is happening in Palestine. I would like to buy those books

[@chrisso1029]

I did not have the time or energy to watch a +1hr discussion right now and yet here I am at the end utterly blown away by how much was covered and at Ilan’s exhaustive knowledge. I’ve been thoroughly impressed by his older books and I’ve just downloaded this current one after listening to this. Also the interviewer is obviously well read enough to provide relevant points and informed discussion. Great stuff.

[@Kinbstdds]

Ilan Pappe is one of humanity’s treasures.

[@irwan3064]

Professor,take good care of your health ...

[@DiamondBodyHealing]

Love hearing this guest speak - he's sober, humble, kind, warm and thorough with no egoic baggage even though he's been through a lot. Method and a thorough meticulous approach will always trump hyersteria in the end. Stay courageous.

[@theresabarzee1463]

This man's smile as he teaches us, is priceless. To be valued as our guide, moral compass & heart intact! Brave, dedicated, brilliant life-energies in service to our humanity. Thank you both!

[@sae7050]

It’s the most insightful interview I’ve seen in a long time. Now I understand why western politics are supporting Israel unconditionally. Such lobbies should be illegal.

[@PrettyGoodLookin]

Palestine needs more people to help them !

[@tollfree650]

So go and help !

[@ahoyforsenchou7288]

@@tollfree650 I think Israel should help them. Open borders for Israel!

[@tollfree650]

@@ahoyforsenchou7288 as long as Israeli's are going to have Islamic militants around their country, their borders will remain secure at the highest level , especially after 07 October . Israel is not only one country in the world , that has such secured borders !

[@emmanuelochieke1645]

You are in luck; that is exactly your job.

[@Witcher58]

​@@tollfree650When you're only able to claim your right to exist by cowardly murdering the innocent, you've already lost all rights to exist.

[@Ahreman_egy]

Thanks Novara media

[@sevilkurdoglu3944]

Honest, intelligent and courageous man. Wish we had more of them.

[@bustersverden4689]

Extraordinary interview!

[@ignatiusmachadoroystonsavi6390]

Thanks to professor Ilan it takes courage for him to stand up for his beliefs.

[@sjbesq1]

Thank you for doing the quality, conscientious work justice requires.

[@Yogafran]

We are very fortunate to have Ilan Pappe living here in Exeter in the UK. We must do all we can to share his impressive work. Aaron asked some really good questions and it was clear how much Prof. Pappe enjoyed Aaron's deep-dive thoughtful approach.

[@MaryLou5239]

Agree 💯

[@megthornton1371]

Isnt he Aarons father​@MaryLou5239

[@shandovarda5609]

Thank you for this talk Aaron and big thanks to Ilan Pape for sharing his wonderful historical clarity and insights with us all. Much appreciated! Yaay for independent media !!!

[@paulojorgesantos2344]

Great interview. Congratulations!

[@arlettedevaud2872]

Ilan Pappé you are a very clever man. Thank you so much

[@LaLasta]

Ilan Pappe is a magnificent man 🙌🏽❤

[@Laight4work]

absolutely phenomenal interview. Professor Papoe is a treasure for a world seeking truth and justice. Well done.

[@diggerman00007]

BDS...LONG LIVE PALESTINE

[@ghulamustafabozdar3636]

Ilan Pappe is the free person of the world. Great salute to him for his courage and commitment to remain a free person of the world.

[@vaheavetian]

Brave man. Thank you Mr. Pappe!

[@syedalimujtabahaidertirmiz7441]

Great man Ilan pappe they arrested him in the airport because he speaks the truth

[@QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

They questioned him. He was not arrested. He shouldn't have been bothered, though.

[@irwan3064]

MOSSAD was behind it

[@mischevious]

⁠@@QUINTUSMAXIMUSThey detained him for hours, demanded he unlock and turn over his phone so it could be checked for Ham.. connections. Not because he was suspected of violating any law or having Ham.. connections, just because he speaks critically of the belligerent state. That’s just a bit beyond questioning, more in the realm of fascist fear tactics to scare him into silence.

[@doaamath1738]

Prof. Illan Pappe is a great hero. Thank you so much for giving us a chance to listen to him. ‏‪

[@MarionThi]

Ich bin froh, dass es Menschen gibt, die sich in der Öffentlichkeit für Gerechtigkeit ⚖️ einsetzen und die Wahrheit sagen ‼️Dankeschön für diesen Beitrag 🕊

[@MaryLou5239]

Es wäre toll so jemanden im deutschsprachigen Raum zu haben

[@_Safee]

​@@MaryLou5239acTVism

[@hanssilberschmidt6351]

Danke!

[@mary-kittybonkers2374]

Thank you, Ilan and Aaron for a thoughtful, insightful and illuminating interview.

[@alokmukherjee8160]

Thank you, Ilan Pappe, for the work you do to educate us and fight for change. I salute you.

[@yahyadeeb5840]

Great interview, we need more of that . Thank you from a Palestinian

[@yzfr1q2w]

we need less of u. Thank you from the world.

[@kellyedey8573]

Palestine?.

[@cosmic7748]

Will definitely buy that book!

[@binniparis8024]

Thank you for your integrity and courage sir. Now the world sees how correct you are. Xx

[@artoaco]

Thank you for an interesting discussion about the roots of zionism and Israel. Light destroys the darkness. Truth will win. We know it. Thank you all truthseekers.🌼🌺🌸

[@juliewake4585]

Brilliant Novara. Keep at it. (I know you will!)

[@jfahmy1]

I hope Professor Pappe sees these messages. Sir, you are a model of courage and moral integrity and an oasis of knowledge in a sea of propaganda. Thank you for all your efforts I’m a long time admirer. Free Palestine.

[@mohammedfouad148]

Great Respect to Pr. Ilan Pappé 💚💚 Thank you Novara Media for this interesting and insightful exchange 👍👍

[@StateOfPurgatory]

People in the world admire your courage and not giving up on your Nobel philosophy

[@aca2883]

You are one of a kind intellectual Mr. Pappé ❤🎉

[@craftspaces4475]

ILan Pappé is a blessing for the Palestinian cause. He has been doing so much to inform people and make them aware of reality on the ground.

[@naqirizvi110]

What a brilliant interview! Learned so much from these brilliant men

[@stephen_pfrimmer]

Thank you Ilan Pappe. Thank you Aaron Bastani. In future, could we explore the history of nation?

[@matta7215]

One of the best and most accurate podcasts on this issue.

[@hugobnyc]

Simply Amazing interview Thank You for having Professor Ilan Pappe’on your podcast

[@AbuSous2000PR]

جبل ...يحاور اخيه الجبل.. اتحفتونا بهذا الحوار الشيق... كل الحب والاحترام من فلسطين ❤

[@ducadukeoflondontown9473]

Superb interview of an extremely intelligent, articulate & knowledgeable guest... wow!! Thanks Ilan & thanks Aaron!

[@NV_Out-of-Place]

Thanks NM for this great interview....

[@maryblake3866]

Thanks for this interview,,the whole hour and a half was fascinating, more from this professor please.

[@rehammaklad6033]

You have covers so much needed ground. Everyone needs access to such conversations, revealing so much about the historical back ground and how Zionism and antisemitism are two sides of the same coin.

[@ouagadougou4672]

What a brilliant conversation! Thank you both for sharing it with us! My big dream is to sit around a nice table full of delicious food in deep conversation with people like you. This interview made me feel almost there.

[@theresabarzee1463]

Hear, hear!

[@AilinAlias]

So insightful. A great interview. Thank you.

[@PeppermintPatties]

Thank you, Novara.👍 Ilan Pappé, more than anyone else, has totally changed my understanding of Isr*"l, and how it's the top of the iceberg for all justice and even climate issues everywhere. His academia has been utterly galvanising for me, and give me so much hope. 🙏🇵🇸❤️

[@ashokddani]

Thanks!

[@tirdadhakhamanesh5396]

Salute to great historian of our time Professor Illan Pappe 🌹🍀🌹

[@brina6680]

Love Ilan pappè. He is just a well of knowledge. I learn more and more every time I listen to him. Great interview!

[@474fsde]

I really love Ilan!! He is amazing!

[@MargaretDeakin-d6m]

Aaron Thank you for being a truth teller.

[@janetbeale4648]

Brilliant interview with Ilan Pappe ❤

[@janedasilva7792]

Phenomenal interview!!!!!!

[@DaraghORourke]

A pleasure to hear Ilan Pappe speak