Former Boyband Member Reacts to BTS - Make It Right

[@sariel8406]

JK was harmonising with Suga. During a live studio performance, they used a backing track for JK's part. But Suga was not happy and asked for a second retake of the song and asked JK sing his harmonising live. This story was shared by a studio audience who was there during the recording.

[@goldafreires678]

Please watch them sing live at The Stephen Colbert show.

[@emilyl1094]

Yes, he'll be able to see who was singing which verses and their harmonization.

[@mistym1752]

Yes! Way better.

[@alinda412]

Yess please🎉

[@loa_2314]

You got the same idea as me. I just did the same comment.

[@betulhasten4566]

Yesss!!

[@KMHSeattle]

V can sing really high too, his range is amazing! 💞💜💞

[@sinevins]

Yeah if I am correct, V has the widest range

[@KajjaFeeluv-g4e]

Baby I know - Jimin that was so good

[@sewingBay1255]

Hobi is underrated for his singing ability. He has a lovely tone.

[@morganmariex]

Yesss. My favorite part is when Jungkook harmonizes with Yoongi's rap!

[@JackInTheBox0294]

My fav too😊

[@ronnilabonde5818]

Jimin always caught my attention the way he sings “baby I”

[@КираМихалева-с4р]

yeeees

[@jm95mj58]

13:20 yah jimin angel voice

[@jiix7076]

Jimin voice 🦋🦋

[@Nikki1249g]

You really need to watch this live. The colbert show version is my favorite. The way they harmonize live is unreal. Especially the rap parts.

[@rina00Z]

Love this song, You don't realize how high V can sing or range! Only because within BTS they usually only utilize his lower tone in most songs, but not all. Rarely does he show off his higher register. V has a crazy beautiful vocal range. You wouldn't think he can hit those crazy high ranges, but he can, and I wish or took more opportunities to do so. Thanks for the reaction.

[@JackInTheBox0294]

And he cant relize that also JK can sing high and low

[@BaibyDoll]

​@@JackInTheBox0294 The guy is an idiot. Everything is Jimin even when he can clearly see that it's Jungkook singing, he prefers to give that credit to Jimin. Jimin stans are always on his channel so he likes pandering to them. Jungkook harmonizes 95℅ of BTS songs, 3℅ is Jimin, 1℅ is Jin and the remaining 1℅ is V but trust them to claim every high pitch is Jimin as if Jk doesn't do high pitched or high notes.

[@addison5938]

V has quite a range. He often sings high parts or high harmonies in their songs and his own solo work as well.

[@sanaz1171]

This song is army's comfort zone

[@YuhiJu]

The "alright" parts and tone you thought was Jimin was him haha

[@BaibyDoll]

Jungkook also sang it so it wasn't only Jimin. Y'all need to stop with the unnecessary lies and misinformation just to hype your bias. It's so distasteful.

[@panggilsajamawar-zi8vd]

​@@BaibyDollhe mean his tone

[@BaibyDoll]

​@@panggilsajamawar-zi8vd it can't be his tone alone when Jungkook is also backing him up. So stfu!

[@panggilsajamawar-zi8vd]

@@BaibyDoll Jungkook use so much airy voice when doing background singing, and who notice that? Nobody knows at all, Because the tone doesn't really stand out

[@kenzadouaa1413]

The one that was harmonising with suga is jungkook 💜

[@JackInTheBox0294]

Yes

[@CelestialBaecon1997]

Ed sheeran produced it and RM,Suga and Jhope wrote the lyrics.

[@eskimopieo0]

The only part Ed requested they leave as is was the lines "I can make it better, I can hold you tighter"

[@loa_2314]

6:19 they always wear their concert merch dresses during the encore part of the concert.

[@HailToTheMeep]

They sound good on the lower range. As a new fan I always wonder why Big Hit has been a little obsessed with high processing and high range vocals when many sounds great low. What I noticed is that higher voices often sound younger. I don’t know. But as a massive fan of Jimin’s amazing vocal texture I have been wishing that he might explore his lower range more one day.

[@hakantas2630]

My bias is also jimin but this much of jimin bias is incredible 😂😂😂

[@rjs722]

Yes that was our V. He has the widest vocal range of the guys and he went up an octave after Dynamite. He tends to sing baritone for his solo work since when he sings with the rest of the vocal line he sings at a higher range. In the early songs, they did not know how to maximize his voice, so he had less lines and he growled a lot. LOL Until Layover, I believe his vocals were underrated.

[@brayonne1755]

Stigma live! RIP me lol 💜

[@panggilsajamawar-zi8vd]

Jimin's voice is just very sexxy when he does low notes, a voice that is so seductive

[@virginia_the_elder]

Your cover of Fake Love was jaw dropping. Bravo!

[@parafighterwifeTK]

Tae has an amazing vocal range, check out the live version of Stigma, he hits a high note beautifully

[@anjdracul6562]

JIMIN JIMIN JIMIN JIMIN JIMIN 👑❤️‍🔥🧿✨🐾🐥🫰🏻💕🤩🥰😍😇 #JIMIN

[@loa_2314]

You can watch their live performance that they did in the late show with Stephen Colbert . They sound so beautiful there. You can also react to the one feat. lauv. And that one has a different MV too.

[@petragrevstad2714]

V has the widest vocal range in BTS 😊. Amazing low tones, beautiful falsetto.

[@patriciaselestra-sankey3606]

It didn’t show Jin started singing @ 4:32 after V. Their vocals are superb as always.

[@sandraheasman7908]

V has a good high voice especially on his solo song Stigma hear it live you just HAVnt heard many songs with his high voice!

[@LaynieFingers]

V's versatility is unreal. To be able to transform between high and breathy to high and intense to low and sultry to that growl.... insane!

[@dinahmahlman-hl1ie]

Yes, to this. Stigma showcases V's insane range!

[@nikkio197]

Love how you pick up on how much they put into the production. Watching their live performances they do those harmonies you talk about and it’s so cool to see who does what in person. You pick it up so much more seeing who does what bit and how they back each other up & add support with all the harmonies and adlibs 💜

[@mstreet6671]

I know you like Jimin - he came out with a new song, Smeraldo Garden Marching Band…would be curious to see what you think of it!

[@janiemclemore4756]

I feel like they made those production choices because they wanted the song to feel like a letter being read to Army. Meaningful and subtle

[@cindybee9270]

One of my all-time favorite BTS songs. Watching this makes me miss them as a group.

[@aseelismail6135]

You should watch their live performances as they take you to another world and you will love them more because they showcase their voices live

[@ShelKim1991]

I like the performance of Make It Right they did on Stephen Colbert's talk show. 💜

[@JackInTheBox0294]

+++

[@adelaciobanas7479]

" Permission to dance " - BTS , " YES OR NO " - JK ( GOLDEN album ) are also written by ED SHEERAN

[@Happydaysxox]

You need to watch a live video to see who’s singing which part as they aren’t always focused on who’s singing in that moment

[@LalaH-23]

I think it is fun watching you get so excited about BTS songs.

[@TaylorCanada8]

Jungkook is amazing at harmonizing and ad-libbing behind the rappers. My favourite example of this is the live version of Outro Wings.....it's fantastic.

[@anildafreitas2930]

Hey! Thank you for reacting to BTS, 🎶 Make It Rigth, it's one of the group's songs that I love and the one who harmonizes with Suga is Jungkook. The version you are reacting to is the same as in the shows.💜

[@bellahsagas]

He really love Jimin.... I don't know how many times he said his name until the end hahaha..

[@alinegreen7266]

I absolutly LOOOOVE Make it right, no matter the version or remix! I am sure you`ll LOVE Butterfly🥰 Its so cool hearing you explain the music production side in all your reactions, its so nice to get to know the technical side of producing a song. As a layperson, I get the singing part and song writing one, but miss so much production wise, so thank you so much for pausing a lot and explaining, its very appreciated❣

[@RachelLily69]

You’d be surprised what they can do with their voice. They’re extremely talented. Since the beginning they work so hard trying to improve on pretty much everything it’s insane. I’ve only been an army since 2019 but I’ve watched videos on what these men have been through and it only makes me love and respect them more.

[@mariannevaughan980]

Thank you SO, So, MUCH for your reaction to this song! It has been one of my go-to songs for years from BTS when I'm stressed, and I didn't even know why! I learned so much from you today! I didn't even know it was written by Ed Sheeran!

[@arshdeepkaur7784]

V has the widest vocal range, he can go both highest and the lowest💜😎

[@catarinapaula9458]

I learn so much with you, and I see me putting that knolege to work when a listen to music... Thank you.. 💜

[@elizabethluzon1351]

Jk is the one who do the harmonizing in most of bts songs... Fyi😉

[@JackInTheBox0294]

Right

[@Yas15247]

Jimin wouaaaa❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@arcy4100]

Great vid! You should react to "Crystal Snow" and "Your eyes tell", more specifically their live performances, it's no dance and all singing and just vocal fests of high notes and unique melodies, it's crazy

[@paolarojas2981]

Thanks Nathan!!! 💜💜💜💜💜🇨🇱🇨🇱🇨🇱🇨🇱

[@Starringminie]

Hey Nathan, Jimin just released a new song called smeraldo garden marching band. Please react to it.

[@Moonshinestheway]

Yes its so good

[@itzelvazquez9430]

And it's live

[@dorisarmy]

Thank you, Nathan for your detailed reaction!!!I love ,how you excited you can be over the instrumentals and over the top the harmonazing vocals with the rap part!!! You're a true musician💜 Please don't loose your passion💜You make my day better💜

[@donitapolk9413]

Wow, I really should listen to music with both earbuds in ... I didn't hear half of those high harmonies until I put both ears in. 😂😂😂 I mean some songs I just have to wear them; Lie, Butterfly, Louder than Bombs being the first ones that come to mind, but thanks Nathan - I'll do it more often!

[@ronnilabonde5818]

Yes it’s Jimin

[@agibsoro1313]

Yeah Lauv! I’m such a huge fan of him too. He and BTS did a song called Who together (although it’s just JK and Jimin). It’s so good.

[@monqui10]

If you come across this, please send your prayers and positive energy. I’ve been battling health issues for years.

[@adenirantitilope8601]

If you believe in God, May God grant you sound health and heal every part of your body that is sick. I wish you quick recovery so we can go watch bts comeback in 2025

[@asmaahmed6028]

may u be healed soon inshallah 💗

[@yvettemacleanofori8480]

I pray for excellent health for you

[@sarafinaspeaks2232]

Sending love and healing energy to you.

[@1986almira]

My little baby boy and I always turn the volume up with this on and sing our hearts out ❤

[@roseyll5083]

This is one of my favorites …. Please don’t stop a lot 😆

[@shelbya-o]

You responding to the sound "Oh that's pretty" Me saying oh yes that IS PRETTY they're gorgeous! Thanks for the video. Miss them.

[@et1373]

Listening with you is really cool!! You point out so many details that I would never realize are there. It makes the music all the more interesting :)

[@mahakamran8244]

watch their live performancess

[@noorfathimasj]

This song is so good 💜🥹❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@cherylloper7320]

Snuck another one in Nate! Yay!!! Love it.. in those stacked vocals, if you were to slow it down a bit you can hear all 4 of the vocal lime starting with Jin, Jimin, JK & Tae. And yes V can hit those high notes!!!! And I'll never stop loving Hobis unique singing voice, it is beautiful!!! When's your next cover? You had us guessing, we guessed, now it's time to deliver!!!💗💗💗💗

[@lilac_k7995]

Jungkook also did so many harmonization with members, adlibs and back chorus in this song. Jungkook always has been doing so many layered vocals under Rap lines and also other vocals. He's been doing guide of their songs ( He also did some other members' solo songs guide ) Producers and members always uses Jungkook's voice to connect their unique colorful voices beautifully as one smooth flow, I guess you've already known about it though.

[@Kett6363]

With your guidance, I learn more about the songs I love. Thank you for sharing your knowledge.

[@sandys1890]

The video tells BTS and ARMY story … the girl represents ARMY💜

[@andriaciel5468]

Really, really good reaction. I so appreciate the education.

[@wmproduction9472]

v sings low, but that doesn't mean he can't sing high. Verses are written by the members so they produce the vocal arrangement hook is written by Ed Sheeran to answer your vocal stacking question

[@lenamoukata6459]

Very beautiful song 💜 thanks

[@anne_on_youtube]

Watch live versions of their songs. Then you can see and hear who does which part 💜

[@hortbeck]

V = Stigma for high voice

[@LaynieFingers]

OMG yes! Utterly sublime!

[@heesuh9505]

And with Japanese song like Your Eyes Tell, you can hear V's high tone.

[@Nishiki27]

I'd say about half of the stacked vocals you're hearing on this song are actually the vocal line harmonising with each other. In live performance, there's usually two of them singing the pre-chorus and chorus; even if there's an obvious lead vocal track the other singer is still there in the mix adding depth.

[@erivera9313]

You need to watch them perform this live on the The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. It’s an amazing version and it sounds phenomenal!

[@annaperou5157]

I love this song!!!! ❤❤

[@alicevz3211]

V singing so well beautiful voice ❤

[@JulianaMota-bi1xx]

My favorite song in life 🥹🥹🥹 thank you for reacting to it 🙏🏻 aaah and I love your presentation on the channel, I always say it together with you 😂😂😂 hugs from Brazil 🫂💜🇧🇷

[@tanyaseeley9867]

I've heard this song a million times and you point out things I've never noticed! Your reactions make me love their music even more! Thank you!!

[@nellysnoakes5278]

I feel like I could tell it was Ed Sheeran straight away. I googled it as soon as I heard it as it reminded me of Eds track Beautiful People. Would love you to listen to that track and see if you can hear it too. Also, most of the harmonies and adlibs that you love so many are actually the incredible Jeon Jungkook

[@Zae-N]

my dude, they SHOW you who is singing the main part or the main harmony basically for the whole video besides the end - you can see them actually singing the song on the screen with their mics to their lips! 😂

[@MuddaFuffa]

Another great time learning from you! Thank you Nathan! 💜💜💜

[@Arenas_22]

I love this song ❤️‍🩹🥹

[@dyaneleblanc6447]

Jimins new song is out! Inspired by the album he purchased in ny. It’s a track video meaning he’s singing live. The album? The Beatles. Sgt peppers album jacket. It a great summer song and part of his new album muse. All about finding love and inspiration after the darkness of face. Hope you listen to it!

[@뽀삐언니]

러블리지민

[@kafams9320]

for bts , nothing impossible , always remember that ,😏😉☺️

[@VanefromUruguay]

😂 you're in your zone here ...🙌 I like the new color of your room 👍

[@tvdisney3]

I really enjoy your deep dives into the musicality and production of these tracks. Thank you for your insight. I love seeing how excited you get when you hear something fun or unique.

[@red_lady4842]

Listen to who are you , lau and BTS

[@rightvibe6132]

I really liked your breakdown of this song. You’re always so genuine and thorough with your content. It’s really enjoyable…and BTS makes it so easy to love, too! Thanks, Nathan!

[@sfesandra1406]

This was the 1st BTS song I ever heard on the radio (I know, old school) and I had to know more about them. It will always be one of my favorites!

[@euniceazarraga2406]

I always get excited watching your reactions. Props on focusing on the technicalities. Besides their amazing characters and visuals, we of course want to hear acknowledgements of how talented they are and how super genius they are in creating music. I’m sure not everyone appreciates it. But I’m here for all the dissections you share. It only goes to show how generous you are in sharing your knowledge about music production. 🎉💜👏🙌

[@DevianID]

Jimin just released a single for his upcoming album: Smeraldo Garden Marching Band. Thanks for a awesome review!

[@maryfebry2211]

Please react to the live concert performance of BTS

[@jenaguilar8613]

Try live performance!!! 😻😻😻😻😻😻

[@ACORN403]

I recommend you to watch MV videos/ lyric videos and after that watch their live performance. For you to see who's who is singing and differentiate the difference between live and studio recording. Thanks for the reaction though. I always look forward to your reactions. Keep them coming I love it.

[@TravisCarlson]

I am a little older than you. The way my daughter got me to explore Kpop was watching the most watched Kpop videos of all time. I found so many groups I had no idea existed BTS and EXO were some of them. June 2024 is our.

[@tedkim5771]

Love the song and your reactions

[@alinda412]

Why dont you watching this Live??? So you can know who is who on the lead, tho on the adlibs, right?? I bet 🥹

[@MsLyonesse]

those stackings are usually JK's voice. so amaziiing 🤌🏻 perfect match to be stacked with each members vocals

[@EyeHeartJimin]

This song is so pretty 😭 I would like to let you know Jimin just released a new track that’s part of his new album coming out next month. It’s called Smeraldo Garden Marching Band! The song was inspired by the Beatles’ sgt pepper’s lonely hearts club band album. It features a Korean rapper named Loco. It’s a live performance. Would love for you to react to it 💜💜

[@thvstan1]

V’s vocal range is so wide, he easily can do both💜 versatile king🙌

[@jesssote7029]

In this song all the four vocals sing the chorus 2gthr,n jk taking the low harmonizing dem here n Der.

[@JackInTheBox0294]

Yes