NYC First Timer MISTAKES To Avoid! Skip These Attractions?

[@HereBeBarr]

Smash the like button if you learned a lot from this video! 🛒 SHOP our NEW NYC Guides For Your Next Trip: www.thatch.co/@herebebarr

[@elainebarn]

Hi, enjoying the videos. Using them to prepare for our visit in April 2023. Do you have any advice on booking the ‘Friends experience’ the site has some less than flattering feedback. Thanks

[@LoriKasprzak-yk6nc]

We can see everything for free on KZbin -- up front, no crowds & no waiting.

[@brandonlabbe3577]

I know it's an editing style to start talking before the last sentence is finished, but it came across like you kept interrupting her. Seemed jarringly rude and took me way out of the video.

[@stepheneson4107]

If the majority of your viewers are tourists who are just in the city for a few days, you should add another consideration: the "opportunity cost" of seeing attractions. For example, the Statue of Liberty may be a great attraction, but with the lines through security, boarding the boat, sailing to the island, and then waiting in line to board the return trip back, visiting the Statue will eat up a lot of the day. Same with walking the Br. Bridge, same with touring the Met. You can see and do two or even three things for the time spent seeing these attractions. Similarly, Coney Island might be a lot of fun, but the subway ride from Manhattan is nearly an hour each way. Time considerations must be a part of the decision for tourists.

[@HereBeBarr]

Often overlooked, great point

[@shanekeenaNYC]

@@HereBeBarr Great inspo for a potential series of videos, John. Give us one of the biggest and best attractions in New York City for each video, in-depth to each experience.

[@adrianwebster6923]

The best way to do the Met is to only stay 2-3 hours. you cover enough and still have time for other nearby museums, central park strolls or hopping a bus/train to other neighborhoods.

[@ryanrodriguez4535]

@@adrianwebster6923 I personally do like 1-2 exhibits at the met to really get an in depth time. But I also like like 25 minutes from the met. So I have a different experience than tourists

[@andyl9920]

Agreed. Long lines and a lot of the attractions r so far apart. If a tourist is only there for 2-3 days. Its not enough time. Even with a City Pass, its still not enough time

[@SarahFunky]

It was so fun filming with you Jon!

[@HereBeBarr]

Thanks I enjoyed our debate over some of these. It was really good!

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

You guys are great keep up the good work.

[@saulgoodman1390]

I went to NYC recently for the first time and did the Brooklyn Bridge walk because it was one of the things you "have" to do but I was genuinely surprised how much I loved it. It's such a stunning bridge with amazing views of lower Manhattan. Even though it was cold and extremely windy (which probably worked to my advantage with smaller crowds) it ended up one of my favourite things in NYC. I don't agree that you can't see the Brooklyn Bridge on the bridge itself because you get great views of the beautiful towers and stand amongst the suspension wires, as a photographer, it's a dream!

[@jessedylan6162]

There are too many street vendors lining the bridge selling the same stuff that i thought it takes away some of the aesthetics of this beautiful bridge walk@Saul Goodman

[@jacobmassey3897]

It's on my bucket list because in the UK you don't get that kind of experience when crossing a suspension bridge. The walkways tend to be off to the side of the road so it dosent feel all that unique but actually walking above the traffic is the type of quirky, unique thing I really enjoy experiencing at least once.

[@amandalong220]

I agree! The view of the Brooklyn Bridge is BEST on the bridge itself, IMO. We stayed in FiDi and so it was an easy walk to do first thing in the morning. Beautiful morning light, no crowds, iconic views... one of the highlights for me :)

[@elreyofbrisbane]

I got to meet John Barr today in little Italy filming and he was an absolute gentleman!

[@angelhernandezrivera6195]

I LOVE when my two favorite NYC KZbinrs get together! Hi Sarah!

[@defining_moments]

I’ve only visited New York one time and I don’t feel New York will ever be overrated. New York is so beautiful and I’m glad they don’t have earthquakes like California

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

I never get sick of it man. It is one of the best places on Earth because you're never bored.

[@defining_moments]

@@ProjectGaiaTravel I agree with you 1000%

[@seanwagner6992]

I am a native Californian, born and raised in the Los Angeles area. And I have to agree with you. I was in the Navy. Out of boot camp they ask you were you'd like to be stationed. Being from California, I asked for the west coast. No one told me they usually give you the opposite of what you ask. So I got sent to the USS Aylwin stationed at the Brooklyn Naval Yards. And wow, it was one of the greatest things to ever happen to me. New York, New York. What a great place. Beautiful, full of life and always something to do. You can't get bored living in New York.

[@danloki78]

Yep u going to NY one time or first,course u wanna go up ESB.

[@mkhanman12345]

Thank you for enjoying

[@talalfarooq432]

For someone who first time visits US and NYC, nothing is overrated. Yes it could be a lot of hassle but for someone who's seen NYC only in movies, shows and yt videos and has developed a fascination with NYC, it's worth it!

[@TommyHasle]

I have been to NYC two times and I think the first time you’re there, see as much as possible, so you at least can say that you saw it, even the attractions that are overrated. But I am still regretting Madam tussauds museum. You live and you learn😊.

[@technojunkie123]

Love seeing my two favorite NYCtubers in one video

[@alexkaine4625]

I loved walking the Brooklyn Bridge.

[@JuanMartinez-xf3uz]

The immigration museum on Ellis Island was a jarring experience. Reading all the nativist rhetoric from 1930s America reminded me of 2016. Everyone should visit there.

[@A94-c5z]

The secret to skipping the super touristy part of central park is to enter it uptown instead of 59th st. One of the best parts of central park is The Ramble which you can best access through the 77th st entrance. I also recommend entering at 103rd st to explore Great Hill, The Loch, and The Ravine. Another thing I recommend is walking along the Jackie Kennedy Onassis Reservoir, which can be accessed east or west starting at I believe 86th st. Also completely agree with you on the Met. It is spectacular. I think MoMa is essential too.

[@shanekeenaNYC]

With you here John. The Manhattan bridge gives a better view down the East River, and the Williamsburg Bridge has explosive views of Midtown.

[@SilversKr]

Thanks!

[@juzoli]

FYI, observation decks with bars instead of glass are WAY better, if you want to take great photos.

[@McStrokeAvision]

Love NYC but not really for tourist trap type places. I love it because of the feel you get in the working class neighborhoods in the boroughs. Reminds me of Chicago. You can explore all day and find new stuff.

[@surfboard396]

Hey Jon. I’ve done them all being from Brooklyn. It’s really just opinion of overrated or not . If you enjoy one over the other you will go back. Great job buddy. Thanks

[@frednich9603]

I was screaming ELLIS ISLAND! thanks Sarah. Besides, the new Liberty museum is actually very interesting.

[@HereBeBarr]

😂😂

[@121476]

I've been to NYC many times. I agree with Sarah more. Sorry Barr! 😂

[@davidmosley2328]

I went to New York for the first time in June (2023) and I walked the Brooklyn Bridge, and it was so worth it. I LOVED IT!

[@irishgirl9514]

I'm travelling to NYC next year for the first time! Watching your video's are such a great help as i want to make sure i get the best experience and only do the best attractions!

[@wtfRyantater]

Statue of Liberty is NOT over rated. There's a great museum there also, and the view back towards the city is beautiful

[@amyt2400]

I’d add that if your family arrived to America through Ellis Island, it is not to be missed! It’s actually a great indoor activity if it’s raining. You can look up your relatives on kiosks, do an audio tour, grab a bite. Admission there includes admission to the Statue of Liberty - do the audio tour there as well- worth it. Both places offer a place to get a bite to eat.

[@anttiranki3690]

Honestly, take a transit ferry. We took one with my friends to Rockaway beach on our last day and it was absolutely awesome to see the financial district, UN building, gov's island etc. etc. from utterly different perspectives for a couple of bucks. The travel time was about an hour one way but so worth it. We hopped off at Rockaway, went to the beach for a walk and grabbed something to eat. then back on the next ferry

[@cobracommander4378]

I only comment when it's an awesome video! I love both of your honest opinions. It's not all about who is right, but getting different prospectives. P.S. I love when you bring Sarah on board

[@juliegreig2936]

My husband and I travelled from Scotland in February 2020 and we were lucky to get tickets for Statue of Liberty crown. It was good to say we had been but was a bit disappointing as you don’t really see much more than from the pedestal, although it was interesting to see how it was built from the inside. We brought our daughter in February 2022 when crown was closed but views are definitely good from the pedestal. Worth the money definitely 👍

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

The crown is a bit disappointing because you can't see that much agreed. Did you know you can just pass by the statue for free on the Staten Island Ferry and get excellent views of the harbor?

[@CityHaulN]

I have walked the bridge a few times and I think its worth it. When u really understand its not just the Bridge, its the people there that make NYC, so loving the whole vibe of the bridge walk

[@cehaem2]

Time Square - yes, absolutely. We just came back from NYC and spent there exaclty....10 minutes, probably even less and then two days ago crossed it without even stopping. You get there, take a look around, realise how tiny, noisy and crowded it is and then you move on. One of these places that you just go to to tick off on your list and that´s it. Brooklyn Bridge? It was certainly busy but not packed and neither we bumped into people or had to wait anywhere. So it depends on the time of the year. Statue of Liberty?`Since it´s en route to Ellis Island it´s quite cool. Plus, if you want to pick up a few small souvenirs from the NYC for cheap the gift shop is a good option since it´s owned by the gov. And by buying stuff there you actually support both maintenance and development of this place and not stuff money into the pockets of a private owner. And it offers the best views of Downtown Manhatten. The only snag is - it requires tons of time and during busz periods you might have to wait in line for an hour to get back on the boat to Manhattan....

[@walkietalkietraveller2932]

thanks, cehaem2. that was an interesting read :)

[@NaturalBohemia]

Went to NYC for the first time Dec 2021 and I loved it! I did the Brooklyn Bridge walk and it was an amazing experience. Times Square was nothing special (reminded me of Hollywood) I lasted only 20 minutes there. Central Park was one of the memorable places. Absolutely beautiful.

[@danwallach8826]

I love the Bethesda Fountain.

[@ExploringtheworldwithJennifer]

That’s cool Holmstead designed Central Park because he also designed my favorite park here in Rochester NY as well, Genesee Valley. Very cool.

[@susannedoe9320]

We skipped the Statue of Liberty the first time we visited but my little one just learned all about it in school so we are excited to show her on the visit.

[@ninjanik2095]

Saras face when you say Brooklyn Bridge is overrated is PRICELESS!

[@chrislopez816]

The one really cool thing about Time Square is the Midnight Moment. Just really cool at Midnight when a lot of the screens show art for just a few minutes.

[@maril1379]

Great video thumbs up. Native NYC here. TS is good to see once at night. Otherwise do not eat there very expensive. Take the SI ferry to see the Statur of Liberty. Go on the right side of the boat going over. Nice you have cohorts. Thumbs up Rockefeller tree go see it at 6am! or go after New Years it stays up for a few days. Yes the tree looks the same.

[@jamesbirtwistle6390]

As a Brit I did a 7 day solo trip to NY I agree that times square is over rated but if it's your first time then definitely go and grab the picture. I really liked the vanderbilt for the observation deck and the experience as a whole there was worth it and you get to see the most iconic views like empire state building. I enjoyed walking the brooklyn bridge but I did the walk early morning, it was a bit much in the afternoon though but great views and DUMBO was nice. I enjoyed the Highline and stopping off for tacos in Chelsea Market. I did enjoy a really touristy day where I did a long walk from the Financial District seeing g the statute of liberty and walked all the way up to Central Park in the summer heat to see all the big named buildings, Bull, ghost busters fire station, friends apartment, Washington Square Park etc I am glad I did the touristy day and got the pictures and the helicopter ride but if I came back I can happily skip that but I am happy I did it. Love your channel

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

There are many places that are hidden and that noone ever sees. Make sure you check out some of the cool neighborhoods in the outerboroughs next time you're here.

[@jamesbirtwistle6390]

@@ProjectGaiaTravel I would love to come back. If you have any recommendations that would be great. I'm hoping to visit with my son

[@jackiealbans72]

Coming to New York again very soon,absolutely loved it,top of the rock is fantastic :) love from the uk

[@thegeneral123]

I can confirm just how bad the crowds were at the Rockefeller tree on Christmas day. It massively tested my patience.

[@christinerocheleau7568]

I’m going to be in NYC next weekend and we’re doing both summit one and top of the rock.

[@colino72]

I just used the Brooklyn Bridge walk as a way of getting back to Manhattan in the evening after having some drinks in gay Brooklyn. It was great in the evening. Statue of Liberty - just a return trip on the Staten Island ferry. Was enough for me, but maybe I’ll do it later in the year when I am back for marathon. Can’t beat a run around Central Park. One of my favorite ever anywhere.

[@maticcro5992]

If you are going in December, make sure you go to Bryant Park, the vibe is so unique and people so friendly, ok the prices are overrated for almost anything, but cmon, its NYC man 😁 me and my brother we walked 10miles every day, and the only time we left Manhattan was to go see Brooklyn Nets play Celtics 😁Love this city, hope to one day return

[@jameshicks6435]

Visitors to Neew Yiork should go to Bryant Park any time of year. It's beautiful!

[@thecatholicmarine]

My wife and I are planning our first trip to New York City in September of this year. Your videos have helped so much! Keep up the great work!

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

Make sure you check out some of the outerborough attractions when you're here as well if time permits in your schedule.

[@thecatholicmarine]

@@ProjectGaiaTravel awesome thanks for the advice!

[@joboring8397]

3:04 Did she say that she never been to the crown? Then how can she say it is overrated??

[@jacksdjfam]

Totally agree with TOTR being the best. Amazing view of the empire state building and central park. As for times square, have to see but just once for about half and hour and then never again

[@TheFrogfather1]

I booked the crown for May two days ago - really looking forward to it. Also booked on one of Sarah's tours!

[@Danofstockport]

Could you PLEASE do a video on bars with good music to visit in NYC? Jazz bars, blues bars rock bars 🙂 We're visiting from the UK in May. Can't wait!!! Love your videos

[@avisitorhere]

Bonus: When you buy a ticket to the Met Museum, you get free same day admission to the Cloisters which is definitely not overrated and is a NYC gem overlooking Ft. Tyron Park and the Hudson River. Its also a pay what you wish site for NYS residents.

[@jessedylan6162]

My apartment window faces the Cloisters Museum. Yes it's a very nice place to visit in Ft Tryon Park overlooking the Hudson River@avisitorhere

[@jamesrawlins735]

I love the Cloisters - such an amazing medieval museum. It SOUNDS great in principal - getting free admission when you visit the Met - but if you have to take the subway it's a LONG trip so be prepared to spend a lot of time.

[@jessedylan6162]

@@jamesrawlins735 that long trip you refer to I take every day up and down on the A train. After 55 yrs of doing so, it gets a bit tiring, for sure.

[@gabrieladanesi7470]

I don´t know now but in 2019 the ticket was good for 3 days in a row.

[@avisitorhere]

@@gabrieladanesi7470 Yes, you are correct. Tickets are definitely worth it, 3 consecutive days, 2 great museums

[@coolpantsmcgee9103]

I’m in New York now and I watched all of your videos before I came. I’m here for 3 weeks, and I’m halfway through.

[@JustOnePageAway]

This was so good. Loved hearing the 2 perspectives 😅

[@christophermyers3758]

I finally made my first trip to NYC in August 2017. I went SOLO and had the best week of my life! I flew into JFK and hailed a cab into Manhattan. When the cab made the final approach to the entrance of the tunnel on the East River, it was overwhelming... the entire skyline from the financial district, One World Trade Center, the Empire State and Chrysler buildings, all the way up the East River! I remember telling the cab driver that it felt like Dorothy seeing OZ for the first time! I stayed at the Colonial House Inn in Chelsea (since closed and sold 😔), in a 4th floor room with a street view of the trees below and the historic church across. Was there for 6 nights. Managed to visit the ESB on 1st day, was so clear, could see over 50? miles. Went to the MOMA for a Frank Lloyd Wright retrospective exhibit ( the reason I went that August), the Guggengeim, the 9/11 Memorial Museum and the Occulous (where you were standing) The Met, and also saw Times Square, Rockefeller Center, Macy's Herald Square, the NY Public Library and Bryant Park (had lunch next to the Bocce ball area), the Diamond district, Radio City Music Hall, Chrysler Building, 432 Park, Grand Central Station!, sat through Sunday mass at St. Patrick's Cathedral, walked 5th Ave. a few times (once from The Met to The Plaza... 45 blocks along Central Park!), Billionaire's Row on 57th & CPS, and treated myself to a glass of wine at The Palm Court in The Plaza! The Palm Court was absolutely beautiful, as the original stained glass ceiling had been restored. A must-see! I informed my wine steward that it was my first trip to NYC, and was having an incredible visit... she left and returned with a small plate of macaroon cookies, and written in chocolate... "Welcome to The Plaza"! OMG... I remember telling her, now I know how Eloise felt (the painting was just outside in the hallway). Afterward, I rode the subway, back to Chelsea (with my weekly pass), and then hailed a cab for my last thing on my "to-do" list... drinks at The Stonewall Inn in Greenwich Village! After leaving the bar... one more thing... at almost 1:30 am, I stood under the street sign of Christopher & Gay Streets... that is my name, and yes, I'm gay. What a truly memorable moment... I cried a few minutes, then hailed another cab back to Chelsea. That Monday morning, a quick breakfast in the area, and a cab ride back to JFK, via a drive-through parts of Chinatown, and Soho, across the Manhattan Bridge, with a view of the Brooklyn Bridge! Unbelievable! I want to go back so bad, and stay another full week. I highly recommend others do the same! 🤗

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

Sounds like a good itinerary. Next time check out some of the attractions and neighborhoods in the outerboroughs. That's where the real heartbeat of New York lies.

[@schen5425]

Wow you accomplished a great deal while in my City 🤗 glad you had a great time!!!

[@scoutandscooter]

Top of the Rock is really the best. I watched 1 Vanderbilt go up when I sat in my office in the Chanin, but never went up. I guess I was trespassing the first time I went to the High Line because I don't think it was quite open yet. Granted, all the plantings were new and dormant, but I was the only one there. That was ~2008? Too crowded now.

[@cehaem2]

Top of the Rock really is a solid option. But it all boils down to your personal preferences. Each NYC observation platform has its pros and cons. We picked TotR as well and don´t regret it. It wasn´t crowded, the views were very nice. Ticket price? We paid more to get on the CN Tower in Toronto.

[@jameshaley7665]

So far I've only been to NYC once in my lifetime back in 2007. For all the attractions you've mentioned in this video, here's what I have to say about them (overrated or not): 1. Now I've already been to the Empire State Building during my first trip so there's no need for me to go there again. I believe the observation deck was worth checking out when I first went there. It was also the first time I got to be on the top of a skyscraper and observe the windy view. 2. I've been to Times Square briefly during my first trip, but that was to see a Lion King musical that my mother really loved. I personally would love to go to Times Square again so I could have more experience of the beautiful bright light signs that surrounds the entire area and also drink a coca cola while checking out the coca cola sign (sounds silly, but it's my vacation). 3. I've seen the Statue of Liberty during my first trip while riding on a taxi boat on the East River, but I've never been to the statue or the island it's located at. I don't know if I would go there since the statue has a bunch of spiral stairs you need to go up to in order to reach the statue's crown. Who knows, maybe I might go. 4. Now I live in the state of New York so the chances for me to see the Madame Tussaud's wax museum would be either in NYC or at the Louis Tussaud's Waxworks in Niagara Falls in Ontario. I would love to go to either of those two since they're the closet to where I'm from and because I would love to see amazing wax sculptures of current/former celebrities. 5. Not only have I seen the Brooklyn Bridge, but I've also been under it too during the ride on the Water Taxi (along with the Manhattan and Williamsburg bridge). Now I would definitely NOT walk on the Brooklyn Bridge, but I would bike ride on the bridge since not only it's less crowded, but also won't take too long to cross it. Also, if I ever get a chance to own a Go Pro and manage to find a bike trail with a good view of the city of Manhattan, then maybe I might record a video of the city as much as I could while riding across the bridge. Maybe I might do the same on the other bridges too, who knows. 6. I've never been to Central Park and I probably might not be able to see all of it due to how huge the park is. But I might see some things that the park has, as long as I don't get easily lost in there. 7. I've been to the Museum of Natural History, but I've never been to the MET Museum. I don't know if I would like to see this museum since the only artifact that interests me in this museum is the painting of Washington crossing the Delaware River. If there are any other paintings that might interest me, then maybe I might go to this museum. 8. I've never been to Rockefeller and I'm probably not thinking of going there during the holidays just to see the Christmas tree. But I would check out most of Rockefeller Center and also take a tour inside and go on top of the observation deck of 30 Rockefeller Plaza. 9. The High Line is new to me, but I might check it out since you can walk on an elevated pathway away from the busy streets. Along with that, I would also like to check out the Hudson Yards which is also new to me.

[@agnieszkazelaznicka6330]

I have just returned from NY and actually I visited the places I really wanted to see, experience NY. I did not go according to the MUST SEE-TICK OFF list. and yes some places in NY I felt were overrated, but that is a normal thing :) I really enjoyed the Ellis Island museum, and as I am Polish it was amazing to see a lot of Polish texts in the museum.

[@jessedylan6162]

I hope you got to visit the Greenpoint section of Brooklyn where there's a large Polish population, nice shops and bakeries plus the views over Transmitter Park@Agnieszka Zelaznicka

[@agnieszkazelaznicka6330]

@@jessedylan6162 actially not. I know most of these from home 😂 during my first visit to NY I focused on what I wanted to see and experience. Maybe next time.

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

NYC has so many great things to see. You said you're Polish- NYC's biggest polish neighborhood is Greenpoint Brooklyn. Check that out next time you're here.

[@jessedylan6162]

@@ProjectGaiaTravel Correct, i already advised her to visit there.

[@jimbo6059]

Yes you have Tokyo and also Piccadilly Circus in London as well.. Can't believe sarah thought the statue is overrated. I only went past it on the staten island ferry.. Very overrated madame tussauds in and country, including the original in London.

[@Helux1957]

Central Park was originally designed to obscure any views of buildings outside of it. So liking it for the buildings you can "see" around it, kinda misses the point.

[@effjoo]

born and raised in nyc and never walked the brooklyn bridge. I did walk the triboro, queensbridge and williamsburg bridges.

[@susannedoe9320]

I agree. I don’t want to go someplace that I can find in other cities

[@Dead2you]

i recently just biked over the Manhattan Bridge to go over to Washington Sq. Park from Park Slope, and then took the Brooklyn Bridge bike lane back. i gotta say, the Manhattan Bridge lane was a little nicer because it had actual spots to pull over if you get tired. i noticed some people parked int he middle of the lanes on the BK bridge.

[@lyncohn9505]

I can take or leave Times quare however my wife can sit for hours on the steps people watchng, suits me as i just nip down 47th to the Longacre Tavern !!

[@liviaperce6032]

thank you for the video. I have a question: if I book a Liberty statue tour one month earlier, can I change the day in case of bad weather?

[@rodneyboulton6410]

Agree 100% about madame tussauds. I only visited as it was on my attraction pass and I had a spare couple of hours, otherwise I wouldn't have bothered. Like you said you can visit them at other places. I wouldn't recommend.

[@Lyons_T-BAG]

Excellent video Jon great to see Sarah as well! Overrated or not if I was in NYC I'd have to go and see all those places 🤣.

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

They still are must sees nonetheless, however, next time you're in NYC consider checking out some of the attractions and neighborhoods in the outerboroughs.

[@YanaBana79]

Fun fact: I just tried to book the Statue of Liberty Crown for the end of April (2 months early), and it was booked solid. So maybe a mix between John and Sarah-book around 3 months in advance!

[@jasonbeech3049]

We walked from NYC to Brooklyn across the Manhatten bridge and then back to NYC across the Brooklyn Bridge 👌

[@daylightdaylight6612]

I was the first time in NY in November 1980, than you paid one fee for the entrance of the Statue of Liberty and you could also go to the crown wihout paying extra. Even there where no advanced reservations required at that time, now you must made an advanced reservation or otherwise you can not visit it.

[@kathleenmcadams7392]

THere are some things you just have to walk through - like Times Square. We spent about half an hour, got some great pics, saw some excellent break dancing then left. Dumbo was gorgeous and there was no one out on that blustery, rain-soaked day. Couldn't find Chelsea Flea but that was probably because of the rain. We decided to try the Met, but the line up was unbelievable - from the door down to the corner. Los Tacos No. 1 was worth the line up - no ticket, no tacos! A Broadway play via Broadway Roulette saved any discussion about what we went to see, and Guantamerra and Momofuku were awesome. But now I have Covid...blargh

[@scoutandscooter]

Most underrated (and often ignored) museum: The Museum of the City of New York.

[@jessedylan6162]

NY Historical Society Museum is also great@Scott Edson

[@scoutandscooter]

@@jessedylan6162 Agree!

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

That is one of my favorite museums in the city and not a lot of people know about it.

[@Neville60001]

Even better is the New York Transit Museum.

[@ttg_ndottootact]

The Bronx river park tower is a famous cool attraction

[@dragon1979x]

WOW! you guyz are my 2 favorite KZbinrs, I'll be there in 4 days and I'm really exited to try some of your recomendations., can't try them all I'll be only 4 days and one thing I want to avoid is been overwhelmed., I'm craving royal grill halal lol it looks delicious amd I'll be staying pretty close.

[@ausflygirl3430]

Loved this! The honesty, reviews and insights you can't get any where else. Thank you!

[@sophiaisabelle027]

Thanks for giving us a tour. May God bless you all the way.

[@richmackin]

My most interesting trip to Times Sq was several weeks into Covid-19 shutdown, where I drove around Times Sq and kept parking. Otherwise, it's mediocrely worth looking at when I walk by, since it's often on my walking route, except for the midnight minute, which is a cool thing I learned from some youtube creator you may know.

[@SamSitar]

once I got lost in NY Central Park. I had there fun anyway.

[@80skid83]

Yes very big in there and Google maps is a must if in there

[@LizaSixx]

Just come back from New York loved it, loved everything apart from Top of the Rock, it was so small & crowded inside & the buliding wasn't the best, it looked runned down.

[@Krillinish2]

Just booked a statue crown tour for July. Lots of open spots available between now and then.

[@AHVlogs16]

hey jon, I met you in Times Square with ActionKid 2 weeks ago, Loved the video, and a real shame they are tearing down the Nabisco factory this year on 208. Goodbye childhood cookie smell :(

[@HereBeBarr]

Nice meeting you!

[@arimermelstein9167]

I love prospect park more lol. And when you’re in prospect park you can go to the brooklyn botanical gardens, the central library of the brooklyn public library and the brooklyn museum which has beautiful art. And it’s all in one general area (if you like to walk).

[@hothotheat3000]

The Brooklyn Bridge walk is so annoying now with all the buskers and tourists blocking the way, so I agree that it’s overrated. Seeing Lady Liberty for the first time moved me to tears. It’s a powerful experience to see her in person, especially if you’re an immigrant. I’ll defend her all the way!!!!

[@danwallach8826]

The Promenade is way better.

[@joeyclemenza7339]

the breakdancers that stop the walk just so they can perform for their tiktok audiences and solicit tips... that's annoying.

[@MRP3261]

Jon and Sarah. Statue of Liberty Overrated. I saw Statue of Liberty from the Staten Island Ferry numerous times As well as fishing for Fluke on a Sheepshead Bay Boat. Madame Tussauds is just a waste. One and done. Central Park is beautiful. High line is great too. But both you forgot Brooklyn Bridge Park. It is underrated and just plain beautiful. Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree is so Overrated what got me aggravated is people stopping and using those pesky selfie sticks. I'd rather go to Dyker Heights instead. Had some awesome times there. Any way cool video.

[@jodiegale-thepsychosynthes1070]

Disagree about ESB- do that at night when crowds are lower and Top of the Rock in the morning - 2 great perspectives.

[@ejorbe]

Unfortunately, the Nabisco Factory in Fairlawn, NJ closed and the last time I drove by the Nabisco signs on top of the building were already taken down.

[@HereBeBarr]

booooo

[@inakristinapangan9705]

Hello. Can you give me tips / suggestions on how a couple traveling can have nice photos? Afraid to give my phone to strangers and ask them to take our photos. Private photographers might be an option but seem expensive.

[@adventureswithcarl123]

I honestly don't think times square is overrated because I like to watch the performers there throughout the day! Also the statue of liberty is definitely not overrated either because I dig seeing the view from the crown! Also I really enjoy the Empire state building observation deck ...would go there alot more if it wasn't so expensive! Madam tussands is also not overated because not all of all the madam tussands are the same which interests me

[@cehaem2]

The view from the Crown isn´t too different from what you see from even underneath the pedestal. You only do it for the experience of having been "inside" one of the most iconic structures on the globe.

[@80skid83]

I don't think it's overrated either, however it's much smaller than I thought it would be.

[@mrmartywaring]

I try to avoid Times Square unless I'm going to a show. Also, since I catch the Peter Pan bus every time I come to NY, I'm usually close to it when I'm coning or leaving.

[@HereBeBarr]

Good old port authority, don't get me started as someone that used to commute from the other side of the Hudson there.

[@williamllambelis3254]

Keep up the good work ! I have been watching your channel forever ! You should review some escape game rooms in NYC .

[@jurgenhadley]

Going for first NYC visit in July (I'm turning 40 this year and the only time I've ever been in NYC was a youth group visit where we ONLY went to Natural History Museum). My kids are pushing for a lot of the overrated places :-|. We're going to go ahead with doing Empire State Building, but I think we're going to do it at night since it's open until super late and it'd be really cool to see NYC lit up from up high.

[@ProjectGaiaTravel]

Hi Joe. I actually always recommend people go the the Empire State Building at night because its quieter with crowds. You can see all the lights of the city, and, you can hear the city so well at night.

[@andyl9920]

Statue of Liberty is great but their dumb TSA is more strict than the airport. Their signs clearly stated they do airport TSA check, but threw my travel size hairspray away! this could go past the airport but not at this location. Sfmh

[@danwallach8826]

Pete Hamill liked to say the best view in NYC was the Empire State Building because you could look at the Chrysler building.

[@kiesha86]

When i will visit NYC i will try to see and expierence as much as i can. Even the scammers in times square

[@halfthefiber]

Here are my takes, as a long-time resident: 1. ESB - overrated. I always compare the ESB with the Eiffel Tower. It's (the Eiffel Tower) not overrated when you're at the Tuileries Garden admiring the tower at ground level. But once you go up to the summit, it becomes overrated. 2. Times Square - not overrated. It's free (just don't get scammed and hustled by the touts) and the lights are really pretty. 3. Statue of Liberty - not overrated for the reasons you said above. It's $25 well spent. 4. Brooklyn Bridge - not overrated. Again, it's free and you can choose to not cross if there's a huge crowd. 5. Central Park - not overrated. There's enough sprawl for everyone and tourists. I love the views too. 6. Wax Museum - overrated. Why people want to pay for wax figures of celebrities confounds me. 7. The MET - not overrated. Along with the Louvre, one of the best museums I've been to. 8. Rockefeller - neutral. It's only worth visiting during the holidays when the Christmas tree is up anyway. Side note: Top of the Rock beats ESB as the observation deck to go to. (I haven't been to the One World observation deck so I can't comment on that.) 9. Highline - not overrated. The crowds are fairly manageable and there's enough opportunities to stop and take pictures or read posted materials.

[@cordeiro.justin]

Question for you do you think the ice cream museum in New York City is overrated I'm wondering price wise

[@jamesm.3967]

I live in the Midwest, where life is nice and easy, and when you go to New York, you underestimate the amount of effort and money that It takes just to move from point A to point B I would recommend clustering things in neighborhoods. What looks easy on a map is not once you get to New York.

[@oltlghfan2008]

A lot of these places you mentioned, I think, are places to visit once just to say you’ve been there….lmao!! I have been to all of those places (except the Met) several times. I always tell people if you want to see a Christmas tree without the crowds, go to Wall Street or South Street. Never any crowds there. I, recently, walked The High Bridge for the first time. You can get great views from there without the crowds from the Brooklyn Bridge. 😉

[@jcire4785]

Just leaving NY today, 6th July 2023, after spending 7 days here. I think the problem with most of the viewing decks is the time and herding around in lines leading up to actually arriving on the viewing decks. Some of them are over-priced for what they are actually offering, which, at its most basic, is a great vantage point from which to take good photos. The food is also vastly overpriced. The Summit: €10 + taxes for a packet of chips on a plate with a bit of dip. Is unashamed robbery plus the tip to the cashier just for taking your order and not actually waiting on your table

[@Hajduk-Kralj]

When i was in NYC the statue of liberty crown was closed? When did it open back up?

[@durgaprasadpaili]

Hey John, do we need to carry a booster seat for kids while riding a taxi or a uber in NY or NJ?

[@rfischer1984]

I just got back from NYC and the Rockefeller Christmas Tree was a huge let down. For one, it was so crowded you couldnt even enjoy it. It just looked like any Christmas tree. I got me a picture and left. The tourist made it miserable. We enjoyed Central park. Kids loved it.

[@si06civic86]

Jon. What the heck ! The Brooklyn bridge is amazing. Then head to time out bro for happy hour !

[@HereBeBarr]

I think my issue are the crowds, outside of that a fan.

[@Betoni]

Before even watching this, just take the staten island ferry, it goes past the statue of liberty, take ur pics from there. Thats how i did it on my manhattan visit.

[@Peppermint2384]

I did too. As part of the tour I booked.

[@thegloryhunter3118]

For First time New York tourists i am sure we will find everything not overrated ...

[@highlanderNC-mr8fe]

Times square is awesome