The Incredible Engineering of the Battleship Yamato

  Рет қаралды 1,508,599

Oceanliner Designs

Oceanliner Designs

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 2 900
@OceanlinerDesigns
@OceanlinerDesigns Ай бұрын
Hi friends! This video is the first in a proposed series where we look at the engineering of famous warships in depth. Which other ships would you like to see covered like this? This episode wouldn’t have been possible without the incredible work of Janusz Skulski and his book ‘The Battleship Yamato.’ These sources also proved invaluable and make for great further reading; warshipprojects.com/2018/04/24/the-yamato-class-genesis/ www.navweaps.com/Weapons/WNJAP_18-45_t94.php www.diepresse.com/4702366/die-selbstmordfahrt-des-letzten-super-schlachtschiffs www.dreadnoughtproject.org/tfs/index.php/Follow-the-Pointer www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1907/january/size-battleships-function-their-speed
@yogaflame30
@yogaflame30 Ай бұрын
Obviously,… The Bismarck :)
@F-Man
@F-Man Ай бұрын
Definitely the Iowas, Nelsons, and KGVs need to feature!
@amb9087
@amb9087 Ай бұрын
Iowa class
@Archer-e2t
@Archer-e2t Ай бұрын
"Big E" USS Enterprise Admiral Graf Spee and her sister ships Admiral Hipper Escort Carriers Ark Royal
@SetsunaF.Seiei00
@SetsunaF.Seiei00 Ай бұрын
Scharnhorst/geisenau
@MB-nn3jw
@MB-nn3jw Ай бұрын
That was probably the best description of the Yamato and her construction that I have myself encountered on YT. Other videos I have watched provided a general description and then went into great detail about her career and final battle. Yours was the opposite and helped fill many a gap in the questions about what made Yamato so impressive and imposing. Great video. Thanks from a fellow Aussie.
@daleslover2771
@daleslover2771 Ай бұрын
👍 👍 👍 incredible shake down.
@robertgittings8662
@robertgittings8662 Ай бұрын
​@@daleslover2771*the funniest thing is that the more advanced American/British radar during the wartime was actually invented by Japanese British person or a Japanese living British ... Had he stayed in Japan that will be having terrifying effect on the Allied forces*
@edensarnelli9373
@edensarnelli9373 26 күн бұрын
@@robertgittings8662The Japanese really did dominate when it came to technology huh? Not just in the world wars, but even today. Japan is arguably still the most technologically advanced country on Earth. And they still make it cheap, but high quality… Just imagine being cryogenically frozen in Japan since the Second World War and seeing what tech looks like today? That would be CRAZY
@worldwarIIstori
@worldwarIIstori 18 күн бұрын
Couldn’t agree more! This video goes above and beyond in explaining Yamato’s incredible construction and design. The focus on what made her so unique filled in so many gaps for me too. Thanks for such a well-researched and insightful look into this legendary battleship!
@daleslover2771
@daleslover2771 17 күн бұрын
@edensarnelli9373 Right before fire season, then after fire season. we start cutting wood to make it through the winter here in Southern Oregon.( 45) 16" to 18 " rounds equal a truck load when split. Approx 210 pieces of Doug Fir, 5 cords for my neighbor, who is 80 years old. 3 to 5 cords for myself, Every year, it's the same. Great photos of these laden down trucks, heading towards the sheds. 18 loads equal 4 cords, 3 loads of oak make it even 5 cords. 20 year old Toyo 8 ply tires, Inflated to 60 Psi It's a slow go on, old logging roads, chuck holes, warsh out creeks, 55 mph on the freeway, 4x4 flashers on. 20 + thumbs up, people going by 5 windows that are down Some guy or girl yelling out Do you want to sell it.? What the wood? No... the truck! Haaaaaaaaaa, Sure, $25,000 cash at the bank...( a piece.) (2) 1977 Toyota Hylux trucks 20 R sweet hearts. As the old saying, there are only 3 gureentee things in life. Taxes, Death, and Toyota trucks. 😂
@Plaprad
@Plaprad Ай бұрын
During the war, my Grandfather was on board the USS Alabama. One day he was telling me about the Battle of Samar and how he missed it because they were heading for the carriers up North. He mentioned at the time he was mad that he missed a chance to take out the Yamato and was salty for a couple years after. At the time, the Navy thought she was just a really big ship with 16" guns. He said after the war he learned she had 18.1" guns. Suddenly, realizing the Alabama was armored against 16" guns, he wasn't so salty about missing the battle anymore. Also, I like how the model used is early war on one half, and late war on the other.
@Wha2les
@Wha2les Ай бұрын
Those 18.1 behaved similarly to Iowa's super heavy shells in penetration though
@stanleyrogouski
@stanleyrogouski Ай бұрын
Alabama had radar and vastly superior fire control. Punching through Yamato's belt armor would have been tough but with the amount of fire Alabama could throw up she would turned Yamato into a flaming death trap by riddling her superstructure.
@xxnightdriverxx9576
@xxnightdriverxx9576 Ай бұрын
@@Wha2les at medium and close range, yes, but at long range (20+km) Yamatos shells had superior penetration. They also had a bursting charge that was almost twice as large (41 lbs/18.5kg vs 75lbs/35kg) so they would do more damage after a penetration. They also had more fuse delay, which means the shell takes more time to explode after impact, that can be good or bad depending on where you hit, your chances to penetrate deep into the gun turrets, magazines or machinery spaces and thus do more meaningful damage are increased, as are your chances of a sucessful underwater hit, but there is also a higher chance of your shell not doing any significant damage as it passes through very thin sections of the ship, like the bow or upper parts of the superstructure.
@Plaprad
@Plaprad Ай бұрын
@@Wha2les While true, I don't think that would be very comforting if they were falling around the ship you were currently on.
@Plaprad
@Plaprad Ай бұрын
@@stanleyrogouski True. But I think Drach was right with his opinion on the battle had it gone that way. Alabama and Washington would have gone after Nagato and the other smaller ships while the Iowas would have gone after Yamato. Would have been a hell of a fight.
@georgebenta3435
@georgebenta3435 Ай бұрын
This must be the most detailed and technical video of the Yamato I've seen. Unlike other documentaries that are made more for entertainment rather than the educational content. This video actually explains the details , unlike other videos where they just list the details and stats.
@solusanimefan
@solusanimefan Ай бұрын
Watch Drachinfel for great detailed documentaries particularly about navy ships from early history up to WWII. He does great detailed guides. Ocean liner Designs is also great obviously, and neat to see him going into military vessels.
@JackFlame-pl9xj
@JackFlame-pl9xj Ай бұрын
yes and they get informations wrong but atleast hir you see that he did reserch
@daszveroboy
@daszveroboy Ай бұрын
@@solusanimefan Drach is a bit too technical in most cases, viewers need a baseline knowledge to understand what he's explaining most of the times. I'd actually suggest Oceanliner, then Drach for individual ship. For naval battles BazBattles/ House of History before going to Drach or Montemayor. Epic History for the Napoleonic naval warfare, he's currently collaborating with Drach on Nelson's most famous battles: Cape St. Vincent, the Niles, Trafalgar. Edit: spelling
@NibsNiven
@NibsNiven Ай бұрын
Agree. Well said. Hats off to the researchers/writers.
@pedrofelipefreitas2666
@pedrofelipefreitas2666 Ай бұрын
Funny, I'm no engineer, but i never felt drach's videos were unnaccessible. He's pretty thorough when explaining things, and usually starts from the premise that the viewer is a layman. ​@@daszveroboy
@marklivingstone3710
@marklivingstone3710 Ай бұрын
I’ve watched a documentary on Yamato. She was built with the highest level of secrecy they could manage. A screen was erected around the ship yard so you couldn’t see it on the slipway. It was launched at night without fanfare or ceremony, all locals told to remain in their houses and all businesses closed for that night. Apparently, when the hull was launched it created a wave that swamped the town causing a lot of damage.
@cokiea57
@cokiea57 Ай бұрын
Dumbasses should have launched at low tide.
@davidlogansr8007
@davidlogansr8007 3 күн бұрын
I don’t remember where I heard about the flooding of the town post launch, but I heard about that too!
@ebw_servant_of_GOD
@ebw_servant_of_GOD Ай бұрын
Having served in the US Navy for 21 years and a student of history for over 55 years on one hand it is great to hear a cogent history and explanation on Yamato's construction. But as a sailor I always pray for the souls of her sailor... They served their ship and duty with honor. GOD BLESS their souls. EBW M.Ed. USN Ret
@politicsuncensored5617
@politicsuncensored5617 Ай бұрын
I'm 71 and I have built more than 450 warship models, including the Yamato. Most models were of the 1/700 scale because there are enough kits of all ships to create the fleets of WW2. About 15 years ago I began building large scale models & I chose the 1/200 scale Yamato as one. I chose this model because of how large the kit was "Almost 5 feet long", because of the incredible detailed parts about 2,000 and I was able to motorize the model. I did a lot of research of the Yamato before building the model. Sadly there are no video recordings and very few photos. I have enjoyed your channel now for a year or more and this is one of my favorite of your videos on ships. Thank you for uploading it. Shalom
@DigtialCr0w
@DigtialCr0w Ай бұрын
My respects
@memeofwheat
@memeofwheat Ай бұрын
Legend
@mazack00
@mazack00 Ай бұрын
The Japanese Navy along with a lot of the military high command burned most of their records. An insane amount of knowledge about this ship was lost.
@OneKauz
@OneKauz Ай бұрын
Nice 1/200 I built the 1/350 scale Yamato by Tamiya. It as well was motorized & I took it to a few lakes for fun. Of all the WW2 battleships my favorite was the Yamato followed closely by the Missouri, then the Bismark
@WillieWanker8135
@WillieWanker8135 Ай бұрын
I’m working on a 1/200 Bismarck, the plan is to to a 1/200 Yamato next and finally a 1/200 Iowa(probably New Jersey tho I have a plank of wood from her deck restoration project)
@goattactac8790
@goattactac8790 Ай бұрын
I am a Japanese and ex-car design engineer. so I am interested in engineering including ships. it is very well edited and visualized story of explaining Yamato. I am very impressed in deed. Thank you very much.
@robertthweatt1900
@robertthweatt1900 Ай бұрын
From our perspective, the decision to destroy so much of the record of her design and construction (why no mention of her sister, Musashi?) Is not only really unfortunate but hard to understand. I suppose it was too difficult for those responsible to imagine the post war perspective. But that perspective emerges remarkably quickly after wars, well within a generation, usually first among professional military officers, and historians, of course..
@Tlh09-k4v
@Tlh09-k4v Ай бұрын
how did you get started in that gig?
@marksummers463
@marksummers463 Ай бұрын
My wife is Japanese. Her grandfather was a bodyguard for Hiro Hito, her uncle was transferred to the Yamamoto after suvining two hip sinkings, and would have missed the war completely had he been born three months later. Her nephew is Moto Shibata, winner of several medals for extreme skate boarding in the X-Games,
@stevezelev7008
@stevezelev7008 Ай бұрын
GOAT, could you please give the proper pronunciation for the ship? Is it YAMA-toe or Ya-MATO. Thanks
@Echohawkdn
@Echohawkdn Ай бұрын
​@@stevezelev7008Neither? All syllables have the same stress.
@rossbabcock3790
@rossbabcock3790 Ай бұрын
When I was stationed in Japan, I took a trip to Kure City and went to the Yamato Museum. The model of the ship is unbelievable!
@sankyu3950
@sankyu3950 Ай бұрын
Lucky man, i too wanted to visit kure specifically for yamato but only had 3 days in tokyo but luckily managed to visit mikasa at yokosuka. Definitely a unique piece of museum ship to visit
@DiscothecaImperialis
@DiscothecaImperialis Ай бұрын
By the time you visit the museum. did Leiji Matsumoto exhibitions section being built there? still there or relocated elsewhere to different museum?
@ronwade6252
@ronwade6252 Ай бұрын
Brilliant.
@JK-dv3qe
@JK-dv3qe Ай бұрын
you are an ambassador of a country that nuked mostly civilian cities. twice. don't be mystified if the locals don't like you
@Lurking_Sturmtiger
@Lurking_Sturmtiger Ай бұрын
​@@JK-dv3qe The locals should think about what they did: the "ambassador" should be the one who dislikes them, certainly not the other way around.
@mewXD-mn6ec
@mewXD-mn6ec Ай бұрын
Having studied the Yamato , her design and much more I really appreciate how detailed and in depth of a documentary you have managed to produce whilst being unbiased in anyway or form. Most youtubers when talking about the Yamato love to compare her to other ships of the time and call her out for just being a cheapscape waste of resource but I’m glad this was not true for yours The Yamato is a very beautiful ship, and perhaps its reason for sinking so quickly or being flooded had to do with a fault line in her torpedo bulge the engineers found to have during one of her times in harbour. Japanese were unable to fix such a fault leading to such catastrophic flooding. Another interesting thing to note was Yamato Straddled light escort carriers at the battle off Samar, with her shell design damaging USS White plains at 17 miles via an underwater explosion. Whilst she may not use radar as part of her fire control, it must be noted radars were good at finding range quickly, however lacked the ability to give reliable headings to the target. So Radars were good, but not too good in WWII as if a cheat code to win any engagement.
@EllieMaes-Grandad
@EllieMaes-Grandad 18 күн бұрын
Odd then that Mike does not mention the fault line and attempts at rectification.
@ArtD_dry-engineer
@ArtD_dry-engineer Ай бұрын
I have viewed many videos of Yamato design, construction and sinking but this video is by far the most informative within a reasonable condensed format. Look forward to many more videos.
@WarhammerWings
@WarhammerWings Ай бұрын
Legitimately one of the most beautiful battleships built.
@steven4315
@steven4315 Ай бұрын
I would argue that the Italian Littorio class battleships were quite good looking.
@arnoldcobarrubias6593
@arnoldcobarrubias6593 Ай бұрын
​@@steven4315i would like to disagree and bring up the Scharnhorsts and Dunkerques
@steven4315
@steven4315 Ай бұрын
@@arnoldcobarrubias6593 Took another look at both classes respectfully disagree though the French ship is better looking than the German ship
@arnoldcobarrubias6593
@arnoldcobarrubias6593 Ай бұрын
@@steven4315 If you love Italian ships they also got the Conte di Cavour-class and Andrea Doria-class
@steven4315
@steven4315 Ай бұрын
@@arnoldcobarrubias6593 Don't really love Italian ships, the subject was looks. If I had to pick one battleship that I like as a warship, I think I would go with the USS Washington.
@briancross7835
@briancross7835 Ай бұрын
Mike Brady, my friend, your content just gets better & BETTER!!!
@apathist04
@apathist04 Ай бұрын
For real! It was great when the channel first came out, now the quality is just insane
@davidgentz1731
@davidgentz1731 Ай бұрын
Like I say oh it was a really bad to the bone but that didn't stop us we sunk it
@SC457A
@SC457A Ай бұрын
As a kid, the Yamato I first learned of, was from the TV show Star Blazers. Something about it, hooked me for life. I looked into it often, and loved learning about it.
@matthewnewport2024
@matthewnewport2024 Ай бұрын
I actually went to comments to see if anyone mentioned starblazer
@45bombom
@45bombom Ай бұрын
And it still has a powerful gun!!
@DiscothecaImperialis
@DiscothecaImperialis Ай бұрын
Basic story is written by the same person who wrote Galaxy Express 999.
@davidvanhorn3340
@davidvanhorn3340 Ай бұрын
At one time, the Yamato was a great battleship, it fought nobly, and to the end. While rust and decay have taken away her once sleek beauty, the legend remains bright. A legend of bravery, and sacrifice. Now, just as the ancient ship appears again, the legend will come alive again, a legend, and a ship, that will save Earth.
@ozwogman
@ozwogman Ай бұрын
We lost two coats of paint....
@CheapCheerful
@CheapCheerful Ай бұрын
Incredible video. Thank you my friend. The fact that the Japanese (mighty as they were) could be so defeated, yet post-war emerge even stronger and allied with the western world, and be respected by all for both their contributions to human engineering and culture is so good that I'm sure nobody would have believed it at the time of war. As an Australian, whose country was bombed and target for invasion by Japan (something only stopped by the lives of so many Australians in hellish conditions), yet these days we hold much respect and admiration for them. Let's hope one day all countries can come together as allies, stronger than ever, just like the Japanese, British, Americans, Germans, and Australians did post-World War II.
@gryfandjane
@gryfandjane Ай бұрын
Mike, this is excellent work. The depth of detail you present is fascinating, and is greatly appreciated.
@l77scmaro2
@l77scmaro2 Ай бұрын
As has been said, Yamato was like forging the most perfect sword in the age of rifles.
@mitchellhawkes22
@mitchellhawkes22 Ай бұрын
Another way of saying it: The Japanese were taking a most beautiful gun to a gun-fight, but the other side had a hundred guns -- and most of them were flying guns.
@l77scmaro2
@l77scmaro2 Ай бұрын
@@mitchellhawkes22 I think Occam's razor wins this one, esp given the context.
@smith7602
@smith7602 Ай бұрын
Naw i think it's more like designing a ship that adheres to your decisive battle doctrine so you design it to take on multiple ships but your opponent not only has those multiple ships but an incredible air arm that obsolete it anyway.
@Rex_Nichts
@Rex_Nichts Ай бұрын
Let's not try to one up the original comment, considering that every iteration after is a lot worse than the original.
@smith7602
@smith7602 Ай бұрын
@@Rex_Nichts Yeah, this comment section is like playing telephone with a Family Guy gag about a classic movie scene
@Evil.Totoro
@Evil.Totoro Ай бұрын
This is the best doc on the Yamato I have seen yet. The production value is top tier.
@K1ddkanuck
@K1ddkanuck Ай бұрын
I would love for the channel to do a video on the NYK Line, which was Japan's ocean liner and mail carrying line through the interwar years. Their ships set records for fastest Pacific crossings between Japan and California. Pretty cool stuff and right up Mr. Brady's alley.
@cbspock1701
@cbspock1701 Ай бұрын
“Searching for a distant star Heading off to Iscandar Leaving all we love behind Who knows what dangers we’ll find….” Oh wait that’s for part 2 Yamato’s space modifications ;) This was a very interesting video. This ship was a beast
@jimmyguy428
@jimmyguy428 Ай бұрын
@@cbspock1701 I loved that show.
@charleswidmore5458
@charleswidmore5458 Ай бұрын
I used to watch Star Blazers everyday after school. almost felt bad for deslock of gammalon when they got there
@Aikurisu
@Aikurisu Ай бұрын
The remake series is also incredible. Especially it's soundtrack. I forget how many times I've listened to Gamilas' national anthem alone. x_x
@senioravocado1864
@senioravocado1864 Ай бұрын
I wish Tom does a video of this soon lmao
@Peter22055
@Peter22055 Ай бұрын
I wouldnt mind episode about, THE Space Battleship Y a m a to
@mellissadalby1402
@mellissadalby1402 Ай бұрын
Hi my friend Mike Brady from Ocean Liner Designs, That was a really great episode, thanks for posting it.
@adrianc4323
@adrianc4323 Ай бұрын
What an incredible video. Thank you.
@ameisee4
@ameisee4 Ай бұрын
I'd love to see a video about stowaway passengers on oceanliners. Might make for an interesting video.
@35Cyt
@35Cyt Ай бұрын
I would absolutely love to see that!
@rumblepuss8848
@rumblepuss8848 Ай бұрын
When I first clicked on an OLD video, I wasn't sure how much content a channel could get out of this premise. A year later, I'll watch anything he puts out. Absolutely would love a stowaway video.
@Achilles22
@Achilles22 Ай бұрын
Especially on the Titanic!😢😢
@OvelNick
@OvelNick Ай бұрын
​@@rumblepuss8848and there's still topics you wouldn't even think you'd want to hear about in great detail.
@MiniMC546
@MiniMC546 Ай бұрын
Oh I'm pumped for a video like that. Surely there are hundreds of stowaways on every oceanliners in history.
@nkc-cam9897
@nkc-cam9897 Ай бұрын
Hey Mike, I’m Kiel from the Philippines. I am a big fan of your videos. Your videos have been a constant source of enjoyment, particularly during my late-night meals. They have become an essential part of my evening routine before I fall asleep.
@OceanlinerDesigns
@OceanlinerDesigns Ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and hi from Australia :)
@MaksimRamos
@MaksimRamos Ай бұрын
Hey, I'm from the Philippines too!
@nikolaikalashnikov4347
@nikolaikalashnikov4347 Ай бұрын
Hi from Germany. Fitting to the theme of the channel your name means "keel" in german and is also the name of a big city here in Germany, which is famous for their maritime history and its port.
@ricbarker4829
@ricbarker4829 Ай бұрын
"essential part of my evening routine before I fall asleep." Hmm, could have worded that a bit better Lol.
@timyo6288
@timyo6288 Ай бұрын
do you keep your pants on?
@GuentherVanRaven
@GuentherVanRaven Ай бұрын
Truly one of the ocean liners of all time.
@theheavytonk928
@theheavytonk928 Ай бұрын
One of the hotels of all time
@champagnegascogne9755
@champagnegascogne9755 Ай бұрын
Two* Hotel Yamato and Hotel Musashi
@kookie3834
@kookie3834 Ай бұрын
​@@champagnegascogne9755pretty sure just yamato because musachi took part in mutiple operations
@yeeters2347
@yeeters2347 Ай бұрын
@@GuentherVanRaven One of the coral reefs of all time
@beneddiected
@beneddiected Ай бұрын
There was a hotel here in Surabaya that was originally Hotel Oranje, then Hotel Yamato, when the Dutch and Japs colonialized us. But now it’s Hotel Majapahit, which was the name of what’s once the greatest kingdom in Indonesian history
@zhouenlai2569
@zhouenlai2569 Ай бұрын
Thank you for the beautiful video. Excellent, well presented information. May the souls of the men who died aboard the Yamato find their path to the Yasukuni shrine, and their sacrifice not be forgotten.
@worldwarIIstori
@worldwarIIstori 18 күн бұрын
Amazing video! The explanation of Yamato's engineering is detailed and captivating. You really brought the design and history of this legendary battleship to life. Great work!
@nah-xl6no
@nah-xl6no Ай бұрын
Did a double take when I saw which channel put this video out. Very excited to see you cover military ships
@saftevand
@saftevand Ай бұрын
Thanks for doing this, the production value is amazing and worthy of what Discovery Channel used to be before becoming reality-TV.
@SakuraRcJapaner
@SakuraRcJapaner Ай бұрын
Oh, as japanese this is the most exciting video from Oceanliner Design!🔥 Thank you so much! 8:16 You even drew in a Mitori Zu(見取り図)format, with your Katakana channel name! That is just so cool!!
@chamuuemura5314
@chamuuemura5314 Ай бұрын
The national anthem at the and was fitting and sad.
@Masted-dy7xl
@Masted-dy7xl Ай бұрын
Fun fact ,Yamatos triple 6” secondary armament located either side of the superstructure were removed and fitted from the Mogami class cruisers ,only to be replaced with multiple AA mountings by 1942.
@Vlad-1986
@Vlad-1986 Ай бұрын
Happy to watch this video: I always thought that the Yamato was sort of a stupid idea, and now I know they made it as good as possible with the tech at the time, actually quite amazed about how advances it was!
@General_Dane
@General_Dane Ай бұрын
I recently watched a video by Drayhnifiel where he said that by the Second London Naval Treaty, the US absolutely refused to go down in displacement limits in battleships as the British were proposing, because they wanted their battleships to be able to stand up against what they fought Japan was building (≈40-45 thousand ton battleships). They did not, in fact, expect a 70 thousand tons battleship with 46 centimeter cannons.
@muddyhotdog4103
@muddyhotdog4103 Ай бұрын
Well they were indeed correct for doing so, and even if they knew it would exist there was no reason to change the core bulk of your battleships for a chance engagement. It's only one ship (well 2 along it's sister Musashi) and was more a liability to the Japanese than anything, and only finally got used out of desperation. Tho the plan was quality over quantity, the class was more a sense of national pride in just keeping them in existence than any real strategic game changer in the long run. Tho a lot of that is in hindsight
@bkjeong4302
@bkjeong4302 Ай бұрын
@@muddyhotdog4103 A lot of myths there: - the Yamatos were NOT symbols of national pride due to all the secrecy surrounding them, and propaganda had absolutely nothing to do with their construction. That’s a postwar fabrication. - The idea Japan should have built more smaller battleships ignores that a) building ANY battleship was a bad idea at that point, and b) Japan didn’t have enough slipways to build that many battleships (or carriers) in the first place. The Yamatos were the RESULT, not the cause, of Japan being limited in how many capital ships they could build; they were effectively forced to go for quality because the infrastructure for quantity simply didn’t exist. - ALL battleships that were built around that time were strategic liabilities for their navies, because the issue was that aircraft carriers extended battle ranges to the point battleships were left unable to even fire a shot at the enemy, leaving them to serve as pointlessly gigantic destroyers (and thus a waste of resources). Other contemporary battleships from other nations (including the Allies) also failed to have much of an impact, if at all. The problem is that the Yamatos tend to get singled out for existing by various narratives that either pretend nobody else wasted money on battleships (when everyone did) or that other nations actually managed to use their new battleships effectively (which they couldn’t, and no, simply having a battleship burning fuel sailing around doesn’t count as effective usage when it’s not doing anything other ships can’t do better).
@puff7145
@puff7145 Ай бұрын
@@bkjeong4302 British battleships had a huge impact on the war, being a crucial part of destroying the German and Italian fleets, convoy escort, and other roles like shore bombardment. The resources could probably have seen better use on a force centered around carriers from the start, but naval aircraft were nowhere near as capable as they would be by the end of the war.
@bkjeong4302
@bkjeong4302 Ай бұрын
@@puff7145 First of all a lot of what British battleships ended up doing in WWII was with older vessels that weren’t immediately obsolete upon launch, and as you said the resources used on the KGVs and Vanguard could have been better used on more carriers. As it was, land-based airpower played a much bigger role in suppressing German and Italian heavy units.
@scottcunningham4525
@scottcunningham4525 Ай бұрын
Well put sir.​@@bkjeong4302
@oldtimegames96
@oldtimegames96 Ай бұрын
It's our friend Mike Brady from Oceanliner Design
@stoned9874
@stoned9874 Ай бұрын
You forgot the S
@uurkisme
@uurkisme Ай бұрын
He's the best
@basfinnis
@basfinnis Ай бұрын
Better than Drachenfel who just reminds me of a bloke down the pub droning on 😮
@lukum55
@lukum55 Ай бұрын
​@@basfinnisBecause thats exactly what he is and thats the way I like it.
@Vaginaninja
@Vaginaninja Ай бұрын
No. He's MY friend and I will not share
@AQWorldsRay
@AQWorldsRay Ай бұрын
I just wanna say, I've been with your channel since the early days, for years I enjoyed every video you dropped, but always craved one thing in the back of my mind... "I wish my friend Mike Brady would cover the IJN Yamato". I can't believe it, but the day has arrived, and I'm THRILLED!
@OceanlinerDesigns
@OceanlinerDesigns Ай бұрын
Made this one just for you :)
@Votrae
@Votrae Ай бұрын
What an outstanding presentation Mike. This was a real treat, I always knew about it, but now I can appreciate it. May its like never be needed again 🇺🇲 🤝🇯🇵
@randallreed9048
@randallreed9048 Ай бұрын
Your unbroken record of excellence continues unabated! This focus on design and engineering, as opposed to operational record, is a good one. Somewhat unique I think. Go for it! When the video discussed upgraded systems as the war progressed, I remember seeing a stunning overhead view of the Yamato's anti-aircraft protection over the years, with a series of diagrams showing the increased numbers of 25mm AA guns added as the war progressed. The increases in that weapon was stunning. With elevated superstructure space filled up, the IJN was forced to locate the 25mm AA guns fore and aft on the main deck where ever space could be found. (The irony, of course, was that by 1944, the range of the 25mm AA gun was totally inadequate since US aircraft would have already released their bomb and torpedo ordnance before the aircraft was within effective range of the 25mm AA systems.)
@PeteOtton
@PeteOtton Ай бұрын
The USN was having some of the same problem with their 20 mm Oerlikons. One of the ironies is that Yamato may have done as much damage to her own AA gun crews with the blasts of her 18 in guns firing AA shells. The blast waves killed and knocked out the light and medium AA guns and gun crews with out actually doing anything to the incoming aircraft.
@TiborJakkel
@TiborJakkel 21 күн бұрын
@@PeteOttonBismarck and Yamato
@eriktrainzfan9429
@eriktrainzfan9429 Ай бұрын
The Yamato is my most favorite battleship, and this has to be not one of but the best videos I’ve ever seen that covers her history and design. Great job!
@Peter22055
@Peter22055 Ай бұрын
Yamato is not only a great Battleship, but also the best Space Battleship
@yeenmachine206
@yeenmachine206 Ай бұрын
​@@Peter22055 she is my favorite scifi spaceship as well
@mbryson2899
@mbryson2899 Ай бұрын
I have watched and read far more than two dozen accounts af the _Yamato's_ construction and demise. Yours, Mr. Brady, is top tier!
@markbelsom3174
@markbelsom3174 Ай бұрын
My friends late father who was in the Royal Navy, wrote a letter to the designer of Yamato, he actually got a reply. My friend still has the latter. I believe his father was a Naval designer of some sorts, not sure exactly.
@theshapeexists
@theshapeexists Ай бұрын
Super cool. Curious what the letters said.
@NayTableIguess
@NayTableIguess Ай бұрын
What does it say I’m so curious?
@markbelsom3174
@markbelsom3174 Ай бұрын
@@theshapeexists not sure,friend never told me.
@cliffordthies6715
@cliffordthies6715 Ай бұрын
My goodness, oceanlinerdesigns, what a satisfying and respectful story.
@Kuristina_M
@Kuristina_M Ай бұрын
I never knew that Yamato's funnel was armoured. That is new information for me
@trailrunnah8886
@trailrunnah8886 6 күн бұрын
The Battleship New Jersey KZbin channel has a great video about the armored funnels of the Iowa class battleships, the video is actually shot inside of one.
@edjopago1
@edjopago1 Ай бұрын
Mike, this was an exceptional video. Thank you for all the time and effort you put into the research, finding the archival photos and the commentary.
@FreedomIII
@FreedomIII Ай бұрын
Thank you for being respectful to the ship and her crew ❤
@charleshaacker9568
@charleshaacker9568 Ай бұрын
And for playing Kimigayo. Those 3000 were mostly kids doing the bidding of their government.
@philoshaughnessy906
@philoshaughnessy906 Ай бұрын
This was a fantastic presentation, as good as anything you might see on the History Channel. Well done, Sir.
@JoshuaC923
@JoshuaC923 Ай бұрын
Holy moly Mike! This video is saved for a later date when i have more time to sit down and watch properly
@mimigamerz
@mimigamerz Ай бұрын
The production quality's been getting better every video! The editing, animation, music and sound design is really incredible🤩🤩🤩
@alexandercurtis4427
@alexandercurtis4427 Ай бұрын
Mike will never run out of awesome ship content, love this channel
@8ballmashups293
@8ballmashups293 Ай бұрын
I have been WAITING for a video about the Yamato thank you
@nonna_sof5889
@nonna_sof5889 Ай бұрын
Incidentally the fact Yamato was hit only on one side was an intentional tactic to make her capsize.
@glenchapman3899
@glenchapman3899 Ай бұрын
Yes they figured that out after the sinking of the Musashi.
@stuartmcpherson1921
@stuartmcpherson1921 Ай бұрын
After dropping bombs the aircraft straffed the AA guns which took out many gun crews.
@aldrinmilespartosa1578
@aldrinmilespartosa1578 Ай бұрын
Yeah. Its much harder for damage crontrol to counter flood if only one side have been damaged.
@FerroEquus-262
@FerroEquus-262 Ай бұрын
Commander Joseph F. Enright used the same tactic when USS Archerfish sank IJN Shinano the previous November.
@ThatZenoGuy
@ThatZenoGuy Ай бұрын
@@FerroEquus-262 Not really? It's a submarine, you only get one chance to torpedo, so they usually hit the same side.
@Sheetal-i1s
@Sheetal-i1s Ай бұрын
I saw over 7 videos on Yamato, and this is the only video that describes every details in depth ❤❤❤. You just got yourself a new subscriber
@Royaleoake
@Royaleoake Ай бұрын
As soon as I saw this one I had to see it. It’s one of my favorite ships of all time.
@chheinrich8486
@chheinrich8486 Ай бұрын
And then 250 years later, it got a second lease on life, IN SPACE, uchuu senkan YAMATO😊
@mikebrase5161
@mikebrase5161 Ай бұрын
LoL, Im 50 and I just got a buddy to watch Starblazers for the first time.
@davidvavra9113
@davidvavra9113 Ай бұрын
Betcherass
@ijnfleetadmiral
@ijnfleetadmiral Ай бұрын
And in another AU, life as a shipgirl that dislikes being called a hotel. 😆
@mikethompson2650
@mikethompson2650 Ай бұрын
@@mikebrase5161 Which one, the on from 1979 or the newer anime version call Starblazers 2199?
@mikebrase5161
@mikebrase5161 Ай бұрын
@@mikethompson2650 the old school one. He is into Anime and I'm not. I told him the only one I liked was from when I was a kid. Turns out all 70 something episodes are on KZbin.
@benmccrobie9272
@benmccrobie9272 Ай бұрын
That intro was the best you've ever done on this channel. Actual chills.
@loneranger515
@loneranger515 Ай бұрын
Fantastic video! Excellent description of her unique engineering and the music choices were spot on. Well done!
@furn2313
@furn2313 29 күн бұрын
This is some of the best work you’ve ever produced 🙌would love to see more of this format
@LukeTalbot
@LukeTalbot Ай бұрын
What an amazing and respectful video. I could write a whole paragraph but can see that others have done so already. The final thoughts at the end of the video were almost poetic.
@lloydknighten5071
@lloydknighten5071 Ай бұрын
Mike, my grandfather, G/M 2nd Class Will Colbert was serving aboard the U.S.S. ESSEX (CV-9) when her planes attacked the I.J.N. YAMATO.
@darbyohara
@darbyohara Ай бұрын
This is the most well done expose on the Yamato I’ve seen. The visuals and comparisons are very helpful on understanding the engineering marvel
@priatalat
@priatalat Ай бұрын
0:49 Don’t listen to anyone saying you’re pronouncing the name wrong. In English it becomes Yama-to but in Japanese it’s pronounced Ya-ma-to. So you said it correctly.
@bazonics
@bazonics Ай бұрын
@@Ivellios23 Are you mentally ill?
@priatalat
@priatalat Ай бұрын
@@Ivellios23 Are you okay? Read what I wrote again. Also fyi I grew up in Japan and my name was Ta-ra-toh kun.
@priatalat
@priatalat Ай бұрын
@@Ivellios23 Dude 🤦🏽‍♀️ Read my original comment again, slowly this time. You’re literally agreeing with me.
@Placeholderdo3
@Placeholderdo3 Ай бұрын
You hurt your toe?
@andrewf9677
@andrewf9677 Ай бұрын
Genius, he calls it *Yeah-ma-to* for the first 10min. Factually incorrect pronunciation
@Erokk1988
@Erokk1988 22 күн бұрын
This is a top tier documentary. Wonderful content!
@StaK_1980
@StaK_1980 Ай бұрын
OG Documentary levels of a KZbin video! Well done and informative! I think this video did the ship, all her designers, engineers, builders and soldiers, justice.
@fnggaming89
@fnggaming89 Ай бұрын
Yamamoto was a crazy feat of a ship the fact that those guns were still firing while tipping over is a testament to that build quality as well as the crew even tho they were enemies,you gotta respect that
@baronvandragon2427
@baronvandragon2427 Ай бұрын
I would argue that IJN Yamato wasn't obsolete the moment she hit the water. Until the advent of aircraft mounted radar to help with attacking at night. The aircraft carrier couldn't really handle a nighttime operation. Whereas a battleship with night optics, good training, and, for bonus points, radar assisted gun fire control. A battleship can and will destroy targets. Admiral Lee in Guadalcanal and Admiral Cunningham off Cape Matapan both demonstrate this.
@ComeAndTakeIt9235
@ComeAndTakeIt9235 Ай бұрын
I don’t think that Yamato was good but by no means obsolete the ijn just didn’t have good tactics
@nmccw3245
@nmccw3245 Ай бұрын
Lee was an Olympic class marksman despite terrible vision. When he aimed a gun of any size, he didn’t miss. Fitting that the penultimate battleship vs battleship fight in history was his to win.
@paulpotter1041
@paulpotter1041 Ай бұрын
So HMS Illustrious night attack on the Italian fleet a Taranto does not count.
@baronvandragon2427
@baronvandragon2427 Ай бұрын
@paulpotter1041 The Battle of Taranto is a vast difference to encountering a fleet underway in the dead of night. The harbor had been a target of interest since the Italian invasion of Abyssinia in 1935. Years of planning plus the fact harbors and ships at anchor don't move the best. Contrast this with the Battle of Cape Matapan, which did have HMS Formidable. Once the sun went down, no more aircraft were used in attacking the Italians. There are even reports that HMS Formidable cleared her deck guns for use in the battle line with the battleships when a radar contact was spotted.
@thundercactus
@thundercactus Ай бұрын
Agreed but sort of on technicality. While Japan was pursuing two doctrines; conventional warships, and advancing carrier warfare, aircraft weren't seen as the fundamental future of naval combat even when Yamato was undergoing sea trials. The battle of Taranto proved that a carrier was an invaluable asset to a surface fleet, and that torpedo bombers could cripple battleships that were in port. The sinking of Bismarck once again proved that a carrier was an invaluable asset to a surface fleet, but all the aircraft managed to do was disable the rudder. Pearl Harbour was the very first time that a predominantly carrier based fleet engaged in a major battle, and while it was wildly successful, most of its targets were in port. However, this becomes the turning point of where the US starts to focus more on carriers. *IJN Yamato would be commissioned only 9 days later* -worth nothing that the Val dive bombers and A6M Zero that made Pearl Harbour and IJN naval aviation so successful were only entering service right as the Yamato began its sea trials. So the moment Yamato hit the water, carrier superiority was still a very uncertain ideology. Pearl harbour wasn't the global turning point of battleships being obsolete. Iowa classes were still being laid down, the Montana class wasn't cancelled until 1943, HMS Vanguard was 2 months into construction and was completed in 1946, the Lion class of the late 1930's was delayed but still underwent redesign in 1942 and 1944. While the Japanese would scrap the A-150 battleship project in favour of more carriers and cruisers in 1941, signalling that they understood that carriers were the way to go, Shinano didn't start conversion to an aircraft carrier until after the disastrous battle of Midway in 1942. I would argue that the moment Yamato was *commissioned* (moments after Pearl Harbour) the IJN at least understood that naval aviation was the future of naval warfare, but they weren't ready to give up battleships just yet. But from the western perspective, they were still building battleships to sail alongside fleet carriers. Because aircraft can sink ships in port just fine, but what happens when a battleship is at sea with an escort? You're gonna need a battleship to sink a battleship at sea. It wasn't until late 1944 and mid 1945 that the superiority of aircraft was REALLY cemented after Musashi and Yamato were sunk exclusively by aircraft. Late war advances in engines, aerodynamics, and torpedoes only made this even more obvious as the path forward.
@randa200771
@randa200771 Ай бұрын
Amazing story brilliantly narrated
@myke49
@myke49 Ай бұрын
This is one of the best pieces of work that I have seen on KZbin. Thorough, detailed and just plain wonderful. Thanks mate. Mike in Oz
@yweleung
@yweleung Ай бұрын
Thank you Mike for another wonderful video. I love the graphics and animations, those are really helpful in understanding the various design aspects of the ship. Keep up the great work.
@kokunoskos6836
@kokunoskos6836 Ай бұрын
Its in fact quite an irony that meanwhile Japanese hugely invested in building the biggest battleships in the world. It was also Japanese who (just a few months after puting Yamato in service) actually in Pearl Harbor and mainly by sinking of British Force Z (Repulse and PoW) were first to prove battleships vulnerable to air attacks and in fact obsolete.
@davidhugheszerobubblemodel1865
@davidhugheszerobubblemodel1865 Ай бұрын
Actually it was the British fleet attack on the Italian fleet at Taranto in 1940, that proved air power could take out a fleet.
@kokunoskos6836
@kokunoskos6836 Ай бұрын
​@@davidhugheszerobubblemodel1865 But that was still stationed fleet at anchor in harbor (same as US fleet at PH). But force Z (Repulse and PoW) were destroyed by planes at open sea... which is fairly different situation- giving ships far more chances, but those battleships were still easily massacred with minimal loss of attacking airplanes.
@fryertuck6496
@fryertuck6496 Ай бұрын
​@@kokunoskos6836Those ships had minimal anti aircraft guns and were sitting ducks. Anti aircraft guns on RN ships were increased dramatically after that incident.
@cluster4583
@cluster4583 Ай бұрын
Yeah but tbf, they also built many aircrafts carriers and before the US had the most, largest, most remarkable and most experienced carriers with the most skilled pilot at hand. Not to mention how impressive the shokaku class aircraft carriers were that achieved victory whenever they fought the yorktown class aircraft carriers for example battle of Santa Cruz, and both shokaku and zuikaku while damaged survived both coral Sea and Santa Cruz while sinking one of the enemy carrier in both battles.
@The_Smith
@The_Smith Ай бұрын
Well done Mike, well done.
@williamcarter1993
@williamcarter1993 Ай бұрын
our friend Mike Brady from Ocealiner Designs keeps making fantastic videos
@oqf17pdr
@oqf17pdr Ай бұрын
I always been in awe of Japanese designs since I discovered them when I was middle school. Their planes and their ships are the best engineering in the world at the time. I consider them as art pieces.
@ashhawk2346
@ashhawk2346 Ай бұрын
In a parallel universe, she's preserved as a museum for all to admire.. Great video, a thought provoking educational piece. Thanks.
@Wuzzup129
@Wuzzup129 Ай бұрын
Imagine shooting Honda Civics at an enemy battleship. That's the Yamato, baby.
@RossoVerdeNero
@RossoVerdeNero Ай бұрын
Honda Civics are not generally filled with high explosives...
@namewithheld8115
@namewithheld8115 Ай бұрын
@@RossoVerdeNero People must treat their Civics differently where you live. Most people I know keep their Civic as full as explosive as possible, just in case they are needed.
@eustache_dauger
@eustache_dauger Ай бұрын
​@@namewithheld8115do they hold more explosives than Corollas though?
@Science_Fiction13
@Science_Fiction13 Ай бұрын
Then in 2199, she was brought back into service to save Earth
@shakybill3
@shakybill3 Ай бұрын
What is this a reference to?
@bitharne
@bitharne Ай бұрын
@@shakybill3Space battleship Yamato. A very revered Anime; comes up immediately when trying to google it.
@hazenoki628
@hazenoki628 Ай бұрын
@@shakybill3 宇宙戦艦ヤマト(uchuu senkan yamato or Space Battleship Yamato), a popular 70s anime where they turn the raised battleship into a spaceship and fight aliens.
@universalflamethrower6342
@universalflamethrower6342 Ай бұрын
I actually clicked on the video expecting an anime nerd telling me about how Battleship Yamato was designed to autistic levels of detail
@michaelminervini1908
@michaelminervini1908 Ай бұрын
@@shakybill3 Starblazers, animated show from the 80's.
@lukum55
@lukum55 Ай бұрын
Ah yes, our friend Mike Brady from Battleship Designs.
@Balrog-tf3bg
@Balrog-tf3bg Ай бұрын
Well look at that, it’s my good friend Mike Brady from Oceanliner designs with another I’m sure to he fantastic video
@cdplus2339
@cdplus2339 Ай бұрын
A consistent quality that is nearly unparalleled. Fantastic as always
@Latinkon
@Latinkon Ай бұрын
Trivia: Before directing _Godzilla Minus One_ Takashi Yamazaki made two films featuring the Yamato. The first being the live action adaptation of _Space Battleship Yamato._ The second film is a fictionalized account of the construction of the Yamato - _The Great War of Archimedes._
@daffaaoki174
@daffaaoki174 Ай бұрын
HOLY SHIT hol up now that you said it im starting to see similarities between live action space yamato and minus one namely the love drama of the main protagonist.
@imperial_crest6809
@imperial_crest6809 Ай бұрын
The director really did well on the vfx on the two movies before Minus One.
@bsa45acp
@bsa45acp Ай бұрын
Many years ago I had the great fortune to listen to a lecture by Ted Crosby who flew the aircraft from which all the sinking of the Yamato photographs were taken. Most of the developed negatives were stolen for souvenirs so that is why only a few photos remain. The 25mm antiaircraft guns on the Yamato were based on an earlier French design and they could not be depressed low enough to defend against very low flying aircraft and the rate of fire was slowed down if elevated vertically. Thus attacking torpedo aircraft and low flying fighters strafed these guns and their crew first. The torpedo attacks concentrated on just one side of the Yamato to induce a list rather than have her settle evenly. He said to me that he knew we were certain to win the war when they got the updated Hellcat fighters. He was also royally pissed off that he got assigned to take pictures rather than attack the Yamato. She was a beautifully designed ship for a bygone era that was never used to her full potential... fortunately for us. Excellent video which concentrates on the nuances of naval architecture rather than just history.
@loganhuffgarden9705
@loganhuffgarden9705 Ай бұрын
Another outstanding video Mike!👍
@hugonubario
@hugonubario Ай бұрын
I really love your story telling either a liner or a battleship it's always a joy to watch your videos
@firstnamelastname6216
@firstnamelastname6216 Ай бұрын
Mike Brady, you mos def knocked it out of the park on this one!!! A+ !!!
@nigellawson8610
@nigellawson8610 Ай бұрын
Yamato was a beautiful-looking ship.
@glenchapman3899
@glenchapman3899 Ай бұрын
I am not a big fan of her overall look. However there is photo taken from the bow look back along the main deck, and the graceful curve that deck has rates as one of the most beautiful images I have seen on any ship ever.
@augustosolari7721
@augustosolari7721 Ай бұрын
​@@glenchapman3899I wouldnt describe it así beautiful, but as menacing AND totally badass. If Darth Vader had to choose a terrestrial ship to direct operations from, it would be Yamato.
@Nyx_2142
@Nyx_2142 Ай бұрын
Even prettier after her magazine detonation.
@themoonhurtsdaddy
@themoonhurtsdaddy Ай бұрын
​@@Nyx_2142just like uss arizona 😂
@pissiole5654
@pissiole5654 Ай бұрын
​@@themoonhurtsdaddy at least Arizona got a museum built to honour her in the end though, to allow future generations to admire her prettiness and act as a symbol of prestige after the us were done thoroughly spanking the japs for sinking her
@John_Doe657
@John_Doe657 Ай бұрын
Emagine if one of those beasts survived and became a museum ship. What a sightseeing it would have been.
@lexloose2112
@lexloose2112 Ай бұрын
Ive just had a stroke and watching your well researched videos kerps me sane, something worth watching. Thank you
@micahfoley9572
@micahfoley9572 Ай бұрын
hope you're doing alright, homie
@molivroman9806
@molivroman9806 Ай бұрын
This was massively interesting to me and I am sure countless others! Thank you for this wonderful history lesson on a work of art.
@Local-Of-The-Mitten-State
@Local-Of-The-Mitten-State Ай бұрын
OMG, Mike dropping a video on the Yamato was a big surprise, ngl.
@ericpiatt2436
@ericpiatt2436 Ай бұрын
More battleships please 😊😊
@AnimarchyHistory
@AnimarchyHistory Ай бұрын
Well now Mike, here is a video worth watching.
@jameswade4097
@jameswade4097 Ай бұрын
Brilliant. I would like to see HMS Rodney the ship that "mostly" sank Bismarck
@Nice_Things
@Nice_Things Ай бұрын
Would be keen to hear you talk about the Iowa class next potentially. for my opinion some of the most beautiful looking battleships of all time.
@RG-Models86
@RG-Models86 Ай бұрын
Deadly and beautiful in equal measure. That's the way I would describe the Yamato.
@BHuang92
@BHuang92 Ай бұрын
It was a finely crafted sword brought into battle where everyone has guns
@jeffslote9671
@jeffslote9671 Ай бұрын
She was out of date before she first left port. A waste of resources. An utter failure
@kulot-ki1tu
@kulot-ki1tu Ай бұрын
@@jeffslote9671 this is spoken with severe hindsight and hubris from a modern perspective yamato by launch, and by 1945, was the most advanced and well designed battleship afloat there was only a handful of issues in regards to her rivetted armor design since her armor was THAT thick it couldnt be welded with technology at the time, people who claim yamato was old technology are mostly apathetic US navy fanboys who keep flaunting the mk 38 fire control was a magic aimbot which could simply annihilate yamato at long range in any surface fleet engagement, yamato wouldve utterly annhilated an opponent ship so long as she wasnt severely outnumbered, but as japan gives up on kantai kessen by 1942-1943, there wasnt much operations that would justify the investment of fuel and resources in moving the ship seriously, the amount of people talking with hindsight on "OH THEY SHOULDVE BUILT MORE SHOKAKU CLASS CARRIERS!!!!!!!!!!!" or "OH YAMATO WAS BIG AND OLD TECH!!!!!!!!!!!!" is astounding considering yamato had one of the best gunnery records in her brief engagement with surface ships off samar using the type 98 shagekiban fire control computer, which was a manual process involving 7 people. the guns had significantly lower dispersion than an iowa class as well which is the main point of reference that people use as a counter example to yamato www.fischer-tropsch.org/primary_documents/gvt_reports/USNAVY/USNTMJ%20Reports/USNTMJ-200F-0023-0085%20Report%20O-31.pdf the issues with yamato didnt lay with design, it was something out of the control of the imperial japanese navy general staff, how is anyone supposed to predict and justify that aircraft technology wouldve advanced at a pace unrivalled in the history of the second world war, the few glimpses we had were radical flyboys in the US during the interwar period demonstrating the effectiveness of carrier combat, but that was against a slow / stationary ship with no anti aircraft return fire and no supporting fleet to aid in its defense yamato is just used as a pedestal to represent the obsolecence of battleships from people with huge hubris and hindsight, which is unfair for such an engineering marvel
@yeeters2347
@yeeters2347 Ай бұрын
No, not really. Slow to maneuver, expensive, a money pit, relatively underpowered guns for their size, only comparable to, if not weaker than the U.S 16-50, a much slower muzzle velocity. Nearly a generation behind technologically despite being relatively new, and used antiquated Optical Aiming, as Japan had no access to Radar at the time, making the ship relatively inaccurate, and nearly impossible to accurately use at night. All Yamato was ever good at was harassing smaller ships, that had no chance of killing it, if it had ever come face to face with a proper American Battleship, she would have been killed a lot sooner, and far more violently.
@MarcusRhodes-q2s
@MarcusRhodes-q2s Ай бұрын
@@kulot-ki1tu THANK YOU! The number of times I get IOWA fans spouting out arrogant statements about US navel superiority based only on "we still have battleships what happened to yours?" argument. The Iowa's simply can't compare to the Yamato in any meaningful measure. Faster yes but what's the point of sacrificing armour over the ability to run towards your death faster. Iowa's had a similar armour scheme and layout to that of the KGV class who were treaty battleships and therefore built with cheap in mind. Yamato is just on a whole new level of warship. AND just so GORGEOUS. I mean the Japanese can make good warships but at the same time they look like a piece of art. This gorgeous warship is no exception. Compare it to the Iowa and it wins hands down just by appearance alone. Yamato has curved shapes, angles and odd shapes all over the place and non standard features most other battleships don't have. Compared to the flat, square and regular shape of the Iowa that looks like it was designed by a 4 year old with no creative style whatsoever. Iowas are only around because they were introduced too late in the war to do anything meaningful and with the USA having profited from the war unlike most of Europe they had the funds to keep their warships around after the war where as everyone else was flat broke and had to scrap their warships even those with exceptional records that no Iowa could achieve. SEE HMS WARSPITE FOR DETAILS. Iowa's are only mistakenly seen as the best battleships because there is nothing to compare them against.
@drecksaukerl
@drecksaukerl Ай бұрын
Easily the best Yamato video yet. Mike, you've outdone yourself. That said, it's sobering to think what would have happened had the Japanese taken the resources that went into building Yamato and Musashi and built 3 or 4 Shokaku class carriers instead. They probably would have won Coral Sea and taken Midway. They then could have based subs at Midway and harassed shipping between the US west coast and Hawaii. They could have taken the Solomons without interference and isolated Australia. The allies would have been on the defensive for a long time.
@dicksanders8206
@dicksanders8206 Ай бұрын
Glad that didn't happen.
@PeteOtton
@PeteOtton Ай бұрын
They would have had to relax their standards for pilot training (brutal is an understatement.) At most it would have delayed the end of the war another year, two tops. The US had the Essex and Independence swarm coming in mid to late 43, along with pilots to crew the planes needed to fill their hangers. And the Fletcher and Cruiser swarms, along with fleet submarines and working torpedoes, and CVE's to help with shore bombardment with the battleships, cruisers, and destroyers and to hunt any subs lurking near beach heads. Taking the Solomons would have added 2-4 weeks transit time to Australia.
@drecksaukerl
@drecksaukerl Ай бұрын
@@PeteOtton Point taken. Still, it can't be denied that the Pacific war would've been a lot longer and bloodier had the Japanese built carriers instead of the Yamatos. So you could plausibly argue that the Japanese actually helped the allied cause by building them, as they contributed very little to the Japanese war effort.
@Calilasseia
@Calilasseia Ай бұрын
I remember Jeremy Clarkson describing this vessel as "hyperbolic". At nearly 73,000 tons displacement full load, that was a strikingly apposite choice of adjective. It's also notable (and *many* thanks to Mike Brady for providing the details) that the Japanese designers were meticulous and thorough when designing this colossus. Unfortunately, technology - particularly aircraft carrier and strike aircraft technology - overtook the Yamato. A supreme irony, given that the first attempt by the IJN at a "decisive strike" was a carrier assault itself. A Japanese film about the Yamato's last hours exists, and it's compelling, if at times gut wrenching, to watch. Those sailors may have been enemy combatants 80 years ago, but they were still human beings, and watching them die in that manner takes a strong stomach. The film also gives a good indication of how much bombing and torpedo strikes it took to sink her.
@kulot-ki1tu
@kulot-ki1tu Ай бұрын
otokotachi no yamato is a brilliant movie even though its centered around the crew the final battle scene is worth an entire military movies worth of engagement
@bkjeong4302
@bkjeong4302 Ай бұрын
Frankly Yamato gets singled out for being obsolete on launch when that’s a problem that applies to EVERY battleship built at that time, including a number of highly praised Allied designs like the Iowas (which ended up as gigantic, needlessly expensive destroyers without the depth charges in practice). The IJN was stupid for building Yamato, but everyone else was being equally stupid in that respect and building their own wasteful and pointless new battleships.
@SennaAugustus
@SennaAugustus Ай бұрын
@@bkjeong4302 Yes, most of them were not worth the money, and the only ones that got their money's worth were the ones in the 1910's and 1920's, although if the US were to fight mainly in the Atlantic instead of the Pacific, it would have been a whole different story, because carriers were unusable in the Atlantic if you did not have Swordfish.
@oxolotleman7226
@oxolotleman7226 Ай бұрын
​@bkjeong4302 it's also crazy the us kept the Iowas in service for half a decade. Curious as to the total amount spent to run them that long was as it has to be truly astronomical.
@bkjeong4302
@bkjeong4302 Ай бұрын
@@oxolotleman7226 To be fair, the Iowas spent the majority of that time in mothballs due to lack of actual value, but that in itself should tell you something (and even the smaller amount of time they were active for was arguably much too long, given that the Iowas were intended to chase down and intercept enemy capital ships, a role that became nonviable before they even hit water).
@MrTallpoppy58
@MrTallpoppy58 Ай бұрын
Great post !! Clear, concise and interesting for the entire 38 minutes.
@marcosflores5280
@marcosflores5280 Ай бұрын
This is one of the best videos about the Yamato I have ever seen. Great job! Even the pronunciation of the name "Yamato" is done right!
@FreyFox87
@FreyFox87 Ай бұрын
One other thing I find amazing is that they actually built TWO of these amazing monster ships, the other one being Musashi, which was also lost during an earlier stage of the war.
@slavicboi8068
@slavicboi8068 Ай бұрын
Technical 3 if u count shinano although she wasn't finished as a battleship
@CruiseShips-he8vq
@CruiseShips-he8vq Ай бұрын
There was a 4th that did not get past early construction, some of its armor was used on the light carrier Shinyo.......... not to be confused with the 3rd hull finished as the super-carrier Shinano.
@m2fw815
@m2fw815 Ай бұрын
Now you need to do one on Space Battleship Yamato...
@CountBasie56
@CountBasie56 Ай бұрын
The Yamato has to be the most beautiful warship I have ever seen. Many thanks Mike for uploading this. Much respect from Western Australia
@AlexJohns-kw2um
@AlexJohns-kw2um Ай бұрын
Yeah it's a very beautiful submarine
@stevenkarnisky411
@stevenkarnisky411 Ай бұрын
New information that I have not seen elsewhere. Good job, Mike Brady.
@markcraig4341
@markcraig4341 Ай бұрын
Very well done and presented video, Your hard work and dedication are greatly appreciated, Look forward to seeing more of your work, Cheers 🎉
How This Battleship Changed History | The Design of HMS Dreadnought
24:08
Oceanliner Designs
Рет қаралды 502 М.
Sudden Destruction: Why Did HMS Hood Explode?
30:36
Oceanliner Designs
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН
The IMPOSSIBLE Puzzle..
00:55
Stokes Twins
Рет қаралды 114 МЛН
Titanic in 2007? How it Almost Happened Again
32:20
Oceanliner Designs
Рет қаралды 400 М.
How Scharnhorst was Sunk: Battle of the North Cape 1943
1:17:48
Oceanliner Designs
Рет қаралды 2,3 МЛН
How the Lockheed SR-71 Blackbird Works
55:30
Animagraffs
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
How a Nighthawk Was Shot Down
12:06
Yarnhub
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
How They Salvaged Pearl Harbor: The 'Zombie Battleship' (2/4)
30:38
Oceanliner Designs
Рет қаралды 1,4 МЛН
Naval Engineering - What happens when a shell hits a battleship?
30:26
How an 18th Century Sailing Warship Works (HMS Victory)
25:27
Animagraffs
Рет қаралды 11 МЛН
M10 GMC , the Best Stop-Gap | Forged for Battle
23:07
ConeOfArc
Рет қаралды 52 М.
Niall Ferguson Stuns World Leaders at ARC Australia - "Are We The Soviets Now?"
19:44
Alliance for Responsible Citizenship
Рет қаралды 402 М.