Once Upon a December: which skirt works better?

Would it have been easier to literally take the entire costume off and then put it all back on???? yes, yes it would have been so much easier if I done that. Is that what I did??? no no it’s not what I did. so here’s part two of the once upon a dream Anastasia dress in which I try to make the entire Internet happy by doing the skirt both ways, so let me know what you like. Are we going with sparkles over or sparkles under?

[@katybradley5143]

As a historical inspired gown, sheer on top. As a cosplay of the animation, sparkles on top. But really, you can’t lose either way because the sheer on top adds a richness to the skirt that blends so well with the bodice, and the sparkles on top adds magic and movement. Enjoy the dress! It looks amazing!

[@simplystreeptacular]

This. This is the answer.

[@MissingRaptor]

​@@simplystreeptacular Agreed 👍

[@beatalewandowski6968]

That is the best answer! ❤

[@cucamongaphilips]

You said what I was thinking so much more eloquently than I would have. Thank-you.

[@katybradley5143]

Thanks y’all! I don’t comment often, but when the words hit to explain why it was hard to “choose,” I decided to share and glad it was helpful!

[@laural4431]

I really thought i was wanna prefer the sparkles on top, but after seeing the second option, that’s my winner. Sparkles on the bottom for me😂

[@jahanshadi1934]

Same here !

[@cypriennezed5640]

Agreed, flows better with the bodice, to my surprise

[@madelinecoats1017]

Same here because it does look like the cartoon.

[@Heart-wf8jd]

Same here 😂

[@AndromedaCripps]

SAMMMMEEE

[@nicholeritchey1383]

I was worried the sparkles wouldn't show under the sheer fabric and I'm glad that I was wrong! Sheer on top looks beautiful and looks perfect with the bodice.

[@E_FoxSnowspirit]

My thoughts exactly

[@disney_et_moi]

I like the sparkles under the yellow fabric.❤The yellow colour comes out much better whereas the sparkles on top of the yellow fabric steal a bit of the authenticity of Anastasija’s dress. I mean it is yellow afterall and not sparkly white. Thus I would suggest the sparkles to go under the yellow favric❤❤ Take care miss Asta Darling

[@Amy_Rice]

Oh my gosh! Sparkles on the BOTTOM FOR SURE!!! The sheer layer on top is SOOOOOOOOO PRETTY and feels waaaaaay more like the OG! BTW, I LOVE this costume! You did a great job!!!

[@E_FoxSnowspirit]

I agree!

[@_maxgray]

Sparkles under sheer looks more like her dress in the movie, so that's the winner for me!

[@Snow-Willow]

Definitely sparkles on the bottom. Especially when you're swooshing the dress around it lets it stay more yellow, instead of just the sparkle layer swishing.

[@julia.95]

option two is way more elegant, it looks like there's not too much sparkles - and then you move and they pop!

[@E_FoxSnowspirit]

^^^ Yep!

[@rebecca7766]

I think that sparkles on top matches better with the sleeves, but I like the look of the sparkles on bottom better when just looking at the skirt. Either way it’s very pretty!

[@daniellebenitez]

I thought I’d prefer sparkles on top, but seeing sparkles underneath looks so much more like the animated version to me!!! Sparkles on bottom for sure!!! ❤😊

[@emilysinkova7131]

😮The skirt GLOWS with an ethereal Anastasia beauty with the sparkles underneath. Other way is still pretty but it looks polished and coronation worthy with that glow from the sparkles underneath ✨

[@kaylaroo710]

I personally like the sheer on top and sparkles underneath. You still get that glittery glow without it being too much.

[@Lillybe]

I think sparkles on the bottom, it makes the yellow look a lot nicer colour. It also looks closer to the animated with the sheer over the top, so it is just a hint of sparkles without muting the yellow. Really pretty!

[@ameliaclarkson4195]

Sparkles underneath makes the other layer standout!

[@E_FoxSnowspirit]

I think so too!

[@AyyMayMay]

It's so hard to decide because it's gorgeous both ways. 😭 I can't help but think sparkles underneath looks more like flowy liquid like the animation which I've obsessed over since I was small. But the sparkles on top is so dazzling like it should be under stage lights or a dance floor. Maybe it could be a day to night transition without a real costume change!

[@zuzzura6455]

I'm going with the sparkles on the bottom team. The color and the contrast of sleeves are just beautiful.

[@kathleenburns7065]

Sparkles on the bottom for the win! It looks so much better and more like how I always imagined it to be from the film if it was done as a live action.

[@rahbeeuh]

Sparkles on the bottom! ✨

[@CherieJohnsonDearth]

They are both beautiful, but ... I like sheer on top better. The fabric seems to drape better on top than the sparkle fabric does. I'm not sure that I've commented before, but I'm always amazed and delighted by your designs and execution. Living vicariously through you. 🥰

[@laneyhesse8102]

Sparkles on bottom for me!

[@electriclllady]

Oh my gosh I love both!! I thought I would love the sparkes on top but actually I think in real life the sparkles beneath looks more like the animation ! GREAT IDEA that you did the layers separately so you can literally mix and match depending on your mood, thoughts, event style, etc! And also you can mix and match in different dresses because that is literally the perfect belle gold yellow skirt too ! ( is that the one that was on your belle dress? I fell in love with that skirt layer the second I saw it bc noone has been able to actually find the right yellow shade for her dress, they either go dull gold, green gold or neon or mustard yellow - none of which are close to the animation - but this delicate, light shiny silky fabric 100% is xxxx🎉 ❤💖💗💕😻😺💞

[@henr5189]

Sparkles underneath ❤❤❤

[@lis1734]

I love both so much! I think I prefer the sparkles underneath the sheer - it brings out the yellow a bit more. The yellow matches the bodice a bit more closely than when the sparkle layer is on top, which dampens the yellow a bit. But both are gorgeous - and you should choose the one you feel you would look the best in!

[@Ruknabal]

Sparkles on the bootom looks so much better ! It makes it feel like the animated dress, and more realistic as well.

[@elizabethfeuerbach5006]

I personally like the sparkle layer on the bottom of the sheer. It matches the bodice better than the other one, and it creates the magical effect without going overboard. But, that’s my opinion. Amazing work. ❤

[@AestheticCosplay]

I like the sparkles on the bottom just because they do make the skirt look lighter than the bodice. I loved the original dress too

[@llamasugar5478]

Sheer layer on top! It looks much more rich with the sparkle toned down a bit, but really both are lovely.

[@maxineAzea]

Very pretty dress!!!! Sparkle on the top vibes more with the animation feel so I think it looks a bit better for the look, but the sparkle under sheer is also very cute

[@dragonzrreal]

The sheer on top adds contrast to the sparkly sleeves. The fact that you can still see the sparkles under the sheer makes it perfect. ❤

[@isabellaereshki]

I like it a lot both ways, personally slightly prefer the sparkle layer under the sheer layer, but do whatever makes you happy not worry about what the internet says

[@E_FoxSnowspirit]

True- it really is her choice since she made it

[@abipoole2859]

Sparkles underneath, but they’re both gorgeous. I think the bodice and skirts seem to go together more with the sparkles underneath. You look gorgeous!

[@RebeccaTaylorTillery]

Sheer on top of sparklers, definitely 😊

[@lisa_wistfulone7957]

Make yourself happy!!!💫✨ I already personally preferred sparkles on the top, but seeing how radiant you are as you swish and swirl seals the deal!!💖✨

[@E_FoxSnowspirit]

I like this idea

[@rebekahrutledge1633]

I love the sparkles underneath!

[@stephanieclauser881]

Second. Definitely the yellow on top and sparkles underneath

[@vanessaknobel4937]

Sparkles underneath, I think. It brings out the sparkles in the blue fabric better that way, and is less overwhelming with sparkliness!

[@KyraHogue]

Sparkles UNDER the sheer. That was my thought at the beginning and confirmed by the video. Both look great, the later is prefered!

[@E_FoxSnowspirit]

Sparkles on top- Magical Sparkles on bottom- More consistent with the bodice

[@hitomi94009]

Sparkle on the bottom. You have the shine and shimmer of the sleeves going all the way down. It's better not to overdue the Sparkle power. Also, the second option it more accurate to the movie... in my opinion.

[@marissabulso6439]

Gosh, I love how the sparkles on top look when you’re spinning about, but I really do like how the sheer layer keeps the overall impression of the skirt as one unit. The sparkly fabric falls in folds in such a way that you can see it doesn’t blend with the sheer layer. And here I thought I was going to be team sparkles 😂 You really can’t go wrong, though, so if sparkles on top makes you happier, DO IT! I’d bet the majority of us are happiest when you are happy, so don’t worry about pleasing the whole internet. Though I do love and appreciate that you show us various options for your projects! I like feeling involved. 😁🥰

[@ralucadudescu]

Second is definitely better, goes well with the blue fabric.

[@sandraoskarsson]

Def. Sheer on top and sparkles underneath!

[@LittleFugueFlute]

I like the sheer on top because it makes the sparkle on the sleeves come out more!

[@samanthadean1083]

I’m going to say the sparkles underneath, it matches the bodice more and is more movie accurate to me!!!

[@Thebirthdaylibrarian]

I prefer the sparkles on top because it matches more with the sleeves but both are incredibly beautiful! Well done!

[@RosyOutlook17]

The sparkles underneath is the way to go! So pretty!

[@clairethompson5549]

I think I like the sparkles on top! It looks closer to the movie to me. Beautiful, beautiful work!!

[@AquaMoonMaiden]

Sparkles on the bottom for sure. I did notice the skirts catching on the bottom of the crinoline? Maybe a ruffle on the plain base layer might help fluff that out without adding too much bulk

[@KGlena-kx1df]

More outfits in general need to be pieces like this, normally I’m 1000% sparkle on top but with the spring around the corner yellow makes my heart happy 😂

[@Aries_Mom]

I like the sparkles on the bottom, but you have to pick the one that make you feel more beautiful❤️

[@Kathrynryn]

Sparkles on top for me. It goes so well with the sleeves and bow! But you really can't go wrong either way.

[@trishr2081]

Sparkles on top is just incredible! ❤

[@MS-tf8vh]

Sparkles underneath for sure

[@jaxolantern93]

sparkles beneath the sheer for me!

[@RedGarnettArt]

The first way, sparkle on top! Beautiful ❤

[@EarlGreyCrochet]

I prefer the sparkles under, but honestly, both options are incredible!

[@somi_bbg]

Sparkles on the bottom 100%!! The skirt looks amazing 🤩

[@codymadsen8710]

Definitely sparkles on top because then it matches the bodice more than the other way round😊😊😊. Love the work that was done❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@mnels5214]

Depends on how sparkly you feel that day. The sheer on top is really pretty and rich with more subtle sparkle, while the sparkle on top is really sparkly and would probably come alive at night in the lights.

[@Hannah_G]

Sparkles under for me personally

[@debbiebalnaves4842]

Sparkles on top gives it a shimmer when moving Sparkles under gives it more elegant looking I like both ways myself, option on how to wear is great You've got the chose of two ways 😊

[@SkippackCougar]

the flow is lovely in the sparkles under version version.

[@laniatienza7709]

Sparkles on top!! It matches her sleeves perfectly & balances it

[@lesakingsbury1612]

DEFINITELY 💯 LOVE 🥰 the sparklies on the top, it is just beautiful, 😍 perfect. You look beautiful as always ❤❤❤

[@kristicitak3932]

Love the sparkles on top!!!!

[@nikkie1843]

I love the sheer one top.

[@laniatienza7709]

You look so much more happier with the sparkles so I highly recommend the sparkles

[@AndromedaCripps]

I think actually sparkles beneath!! GORGEOUS dress btw, great job!!!!

[@MrsBrit1]

Sparkles on top, but also an extra petticoat to stop the hoop shining through the fabric!

[@pinkprincesswhee]

Sparkles underneath!!!!100%!! Its like ..SUBTLE GLITTERING~. The sparkles on top.........make it look... cheap in a way?? Like if i were to step closer......I'd be delighted by the 'under-shimmer' of your dress~

[@gothllama]

Sheer on top ✨️

[@jenfirelight]

I actually prefer the original skirt. That being said sparkles on the bottom. But hey with you having the layers the way you've got them you can do whatever you want depending on your mood.

[@kateworkman921]

Definitely sparkles on top. It goes so much better with the sleeves that way.

[@kloassie]

Honestly, I don't see _a lot_ of difference, but if I *had* to choose then I'd say option nr 2. But maybe the difference isn't very clear (to me at least) bc I/we see it on video instead if IRL? Anyways, both options look great and I trust your judgement (also *_because_* you're the only one who saw it IRL) so I'd say whatever you think looks best is the better option

[@michellegriggs]

I prefer the sparkles on top, but both ways work really well x

[@user-vd7tv6xg4k]

I Love the Sparkles over the solid skirt! ❤❤❤

[@underthebluesky92]

I like the sparkly over the yellow shear. It, the sparkly, mellows the yellow, but brings out the best of that yellow color.

[@Pineapple_Cheasecake]

Sparkles on the bottom

[@sthefanyfrare3241]

Yeah, I don't think anyone is going to come to a consensus any time soon 😂 But I prefer the sparkles on the bottom ✨️

[@heathermacmillan962]

Definitely sheer on top...you atill seem to get a bit of sparkle shining through 😁💙

[@justanotherreader]

Sparkles absolutely on top! The outfit is gorgeous!! You're never going to make everyone happy so do what you like best :)

[@KaijaMcClure]

I think I prefer the sparkle underneath.

[@jengl4401]

Sparkles under! When they are over they wash out the yellow and it is not as harmonious with the bodice. Also when you lift the skirt to twirl, sparkles on top looks a bit odd (unless the layers were sewn together, I suppose).

[@peggynewvine8138]

Sparkly on top, also I really love the new top

[@denisemanley5318]

It’s a beautiful dress either way. I liked both ways.

[@meridethhendry5733]

Who could choose? I love them both.

[@catherineleslie-faye4302]

Color wise sparkles under the sheer yellow. The original set with all that tlle hid the hoops in your hoop skirt... the less floofy skirts show the hoops for all to see.

[@maytiessen8045]

Sparkles on the bottom, the dress looks better ❤

[@lynneelizabeth]

Commenting to tell the algorithm that this dress is rad and amazing and we want it on our feeds!!!

[@ladylibertywdc8324]

Sparkly on top!🎉

[@emmastraub6842]

So cool 💛

[@blondieg95]

You are living my dream come true and sparkles on top all the way

[@jessicafang3273]

Sheer on top for sure!!!

[@WaterNai]

If you keep the layers separate, you can go with how you feel that day, and you also have a sparkly layer to wear with another outfit.

[@allisonsanders]

You look so beauty the dress is cute. The last part look much better than the first.

[@sharonyost3807]

Sparkles under looks like her dress in movie but both are beautiful!

[@Justanobody875]

I vote for sparkles underneath.

[@Trufriend61]

Definitely the sparkly layer on top!! ~Chris

[@dreyamudgett1927]

Sparkles on top hold more true to Don Bluth Animation. The entire reason I LOVE Don Bluth's animation is because of the use of sparkles!!! The sparkle over sheer really gives that ethereal vibe Don Bluth animation is known for.

[@asiam8087]

Sparkles on the bottom. On top is for me too much. But, you know what they say... There's never too much glitter 😅 so, probably, we'll never decide