One Game Per Shelf Collection Challenge | Board Games & Brew

[@MrJossVideos]

Jeff won by 7 picks. After the Tapestry, Scythe, Baseball Highlights trifecta, it was over. Fun video!

[@preymantisss]

Team Jeff. Not only do his tastes align with mine more but his collection just talks to me more.

[@Truebluedrew330]

Jeff… I gotchu, I’ll give your collection the nod! Fun video guys!!!

[@jacquelineadcock3507]

Jamie definitely gets my vote, lots of my favourites in her selection!

[@MarinaS341]

Gotta go with Jamie! She has more of my favourites

[@ChristinaHeber-f6b]

I'd love to see this again in your new studio space and with all your current games!

[@FostertheMeeple]

We will see what we can do!

[@ChristinaHeber-f6b]

Awesome! Haha sorry if you see a bunch of comments on old videos.. I’m rewatching!

[@Thebrad11984]

This was fun. The faces you guys were making for so many of these choices both when you knew you were stealing or holding your breath as the other picked. I honestly can’t decide who picked better. So many games I enjoy between y’all and so many I haven’t played

[@thadthomas3105]

I usually align with Jamie’s taste in games a little more, but Jeff’s picks are my favorite in this one. Fun video!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Ya love to see it!

[@Neon_Gorilla]

Keep up the great work. I love you channel so much. In fact you have inspired me to step out on a limb and start my own channel. Look forward to seeing you channel continue to grow!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Thanks so much for the kind words!!

[@myronmychal7806]

This one comes down to Cuba Libre trumping all. Team Jeff for the win.

[@Opelikacrush]

Fun video! Vote has to go to Jamie!

[@guitarguy1357]

Anyone that picks Scythe and Return to Dark Tower has a banger of a collection. Well done, Jeff, I award you with my vote.

[@FostertheMeeple]

I accept it gladly

[@seanb5007]

Sorry Jeff, you had some of my favorites in there, but I have to go with Jamie's collection. Great video! And thanks for all the hard work you both put into your videos!!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Thanks so much for watching!

[@asyahussain7560]

These are my favorite kinds of videos of yours! I feel like i'm chilling there with you guys, it's so fun and cozy!

[@FostertheMeeple]

We really appreciate that feedback!

[@laurieharris2591]

Jamie for the win with Obsession, Wingspan, Cascadia, Arnak, Red Cathedral, Isle of Cats and Cobble & Fog. Jeff’s picks of Isle of Skye (game that hooked me into the hobby), Under Falling Skies and Ark Nova (+more) were awesome but not quite enough! Love your chatty kitty!

[@FostertheMeeple]

She’s definitely chatty!

[@alisonwentland3765]

This was such a fun video! I have so many of these games because I saw them on your channel. Jamie, I have Hooky! I am on team Jamie for the games that are more fun.

[@FostertheMeeple]

Hooky is such a brain burner

[@GenXMoose]

Jeff for sure. When you do these type videos, you should have one "break the rules" in addition to a veto. It'd be a fun bit of chaos.

[@FostertheMeeple]

Good idea!

[@GabeInTheTube]

What a fun video ! New to the hobby and your channel is my favourite (Go 🇨🇦 Go!). Got Silver Bullet and love it.

[@FostertheMeeple]

Welcome to the hobby!!!

[@doumace2158]

Jeff clearly wins with Wonderland's War and Ark Nova!!!!

[@Schaeff72]

Jamie in a close one! Great video, thanks for sharing!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Thanks for watching!

[@Azaria7026]

Jamie’s!!! I was hoping you’d do the shelves in that cool glass cupboard!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Ohhh we should have!

[@timborocksloud]

First of all, it was really great getting to say hi and chat with you guys for a few min at Gen Con. Hope you got home with no misadventures. This was tough, Jeff had some good games, but Jamie had a few more that hit home for me. Heat, Obsession, The Godfather maybe in my top 5 of all time, and My Father's Work was one I really want to play and just missed my suitcase cut at Gen Con. Also, Agricola looks almost as exciting as watching paint dry :). Looking forward to seeing you at the next con, and maybe being able to throw down a game or two together.

[@FostertheMeeple]

Nice finally meeting you!!

[@jkledis]

When you first started picking I was all in tune with Jeff and then towards the middle Jamie made a quick comeback - but the Jeff choices at the end pulled it out for the win!!!!

[@FostertheMeeple]

MY MAN JIM

[@MrJmarzetti]

Great challenge, too hard to choose with great games in both collections.🤓

[@jjtheBaldBoardGamer]

Jamie by a count of 17 to 11 in my opinion. This is based on my current collection, favorites, and games I REALLY want to try. But both were great. This was fun!

[@MarshaKay605]

Jamie! This one was a tough call for me. Through out the video I thought I was going to pick Jeff. He picked some games I really love but in the end seeing all the games on the screen at once I had to pick Jamie! Fun video 😊

[@FostertheMeeple]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@debbieholecek3293]

Jamie!! Although Jeff nearly had me with fort and boop😊

[@MarkusKraus]

Jamie for sure. Though, I think I would have picked Bunny Kingdom over Flamme Rouge since the collection already had Heat? Maybe I'm biased, but I don't think I'd ever play Flamme Rouge instead of Heat if I want to race. Wroom wroom!

[@ncreson]

Tough choice. Pretty close, but I have to give it to Jamie for having Cascadia, Wingspan, Isle of Cats, and others. Had Jeff not vetoed Azul, it wouldn't have been close.

[@robrattley3902]

Jamie's selection is probably my comfortable place but I'm going to team Jeff for this one.

[@FostertheMeeple]

You chose wisely

[@SonofSol1]

If i could pick one collection to add to my shelf it would be Jeffs

[@sacheen1712]

Team Jeff….for his shirt❤

[@FostertheMeeple]

Best team!

[@terradudley1240]

Both are great collections... really really great. Gotta go with Jamie though (just got Red Cathedral and its quickly becoming an easy fav) and Obsession is probs my number 1 game...

[@TheCardboardWarlord]

Is there no rhyme or reason to your collection organization? I lump mine by designer (if I have 1 cube or more worth) or primary mechanism (coop, dice, polyomino, dexterity, deduction, etc.)

[@FostertheMeeple]

“If it fits it sits”

[@TheCardboardWarlord]

@@FostertheMeeple Preposterous!

[@darbyl3872]

Jeff's collection is 50% better than Jamie's. You can't argue with numbers.

[@FostertheMeeple]

Math is important

[@jimsherrill]

Jeff's Ark Nova and Space Base gives him the edge. Disappointed nobody took Gaia Project! :(

[@FostertheMeeple]

I do love Gaia!

[@MikeAlger1964]

Tough choice. Both sets of games look amazing. Heat: Pedal to the Metal give Jamie a slight edge though. Sorry, Jeff. If you had vetoed Heat: Pedal to the Metal you would have won.

[@joannahiles6227]

Team Jamie this time but Jeff has picked some great games too

[@FostertheMeeple]

I may disagree but I respect your choice

[@gottimighty]

I hope My Father's Work is a hit for you guys. I was so excited for thus game and although it's a nice game, it just didn't excite me as much as I'd hoped.

[@FostertheMeeple]

We hope so too!!

[@Argentos-Shadow]

Sorry Jamie, but I would have to go with Jeff's collection 🙂

[@natalierind17]

Veto Azul but then neither choose Azul mini 🤔….Jeff actually had some “cute” game in his! 🙌….but Jamie still wins here….

[@niland1848]

Team Jamie!!!

[@jeffbrantz6620]

Will you PLEASE play Wacky Racers on the channel? I know you were planning a racing day, but this game is my childhood!!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Hhaha we will try!! More likely would be on twitch though.

[@ChrisCuly]

Jeff, 💯

[@LLee-jx9og]

Team Jamie!

[@hschwarz75]

Jeff!

[@boardtoplay]

Ahhh so hard to choose, I think I have to go Jeff😅

[@FostertheMeeple]

You chose correctly

[@kevinsmith9899]

Jamie gets my vote for picking both Horrified and Oracle of Delphi.

[@Paul-hm8dd]

Oof, I'm usually on team Jamie with these challenges, but Jeff wins, hands down... the tipping point for me was Meadow.

[@FostertheMeeple]

You love to see it

[@fanniszathmary2266]

Jamie won for me just for Mansions of Madness :D

[@ivokostelecky]

Team Jeff

[@iceofswords]

I wish you had listed the games on the shelf before you made your picks, it was hard to see the contenders!

[@stevewithington1787]

Team Jeff.

[@OrangeCrushD84]

Jaw Drop, Root not number 1?! I'm saying Jeff on this one ya butts. Someone needs figure a way to do the full on collections from all you stars(Murphs,Themers,Garden,BeforeyouPlay,Tim,etc), and then do a tournament of letting us vote on collections until there is only ONE.

[@rplmb2]

I know Jeff loves Star Wars Villainous, have you guys been able to play the new expansion yet?

[@FostertheMeeple]

We haven’t! Hopefully soon

[@bryanscollick8305]

This is a tough decision. Jeff’s tastes in games is very close to mine (space, campaign, crawlers) but Jamie got some of my favorites (Sleeping Gods, Arnak, Familiar Tales). I am going with (it’s like asking who is my favorite child! ) I will go with Jamie by a score of 50.1% to Jeff’s 49.9%.

[@FostertheMeeple]

This is the wrong choice Bryan

[@bryanscollick8305]

@@FostertheMeeple It was so close. Don’t make us do that again! Actually, I just saw the Brothers Murph do their scavenger hunt! It was a really fun concept!

[@martinthibault148]

You should try LongShot: the dice game. It’s a roll and Wright racing/ betting game. Way better than Camel Up. BTW #TeamJamie

[@FostertheMeeple]

We have played it a few times!! Still like camel up better :)

[@chocklad9]

Jamie!

[@malvinafis6907]

Jamie wins by Picking my 2nd favourite Game of all time: Paint the Roses. Since None of you picked my favourite I think (Terraforming Mars)

[@FostertheMeeple]

yaaay!

[@clairemack2750]

I think I might ACTUALLY be #teamjeff this time.... Jamie likes horror too much, but Jeff has a lot of my more whimsically puzzly games in his.

[@FostertheMeeple]

LETS GOOOOO

[@bigfro77]

Team Jeff here!!

[@spielmill1755]

We have to ask, how are your games organized? We had a whole conversation about this both during this video and the one where you shared your collection lol.

[@spielmill1755]

also, now that we've finished the video, Jamie wins in a close one!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Our organization methodology: “if it fits, it sits”

[@spielmill1755]

@@FostertheMeeple hahaha That works. and you always seem to know exactly where everything is which is all that matters. We may have organized our books according to the dewey decimal system so we may be too invested in organizational systems lol.

[@pro5002]

What's the deal with marvel Dagger??? 😮

[@FostertheMeeple]

Hasn’t had a great reception!

[@annam.6494]

I’m team obsession as well!

[@annam.6494]

Also team Jamie. Sorry Jeff 😢

[@FostertheMeeple]

Wooooo (from Jamie haha)

[@ceazyondabeat4672]

teamjeff

[@ajcrosby87]

This is a tough one, but I'd have to go with Jamie's collection. Sorry Jeff!

[@FostertheMeeple]

Apology not accepted! ;)

[@hollydenman2929]

Keep the microphone! Perfect sound

[@TheCardboardWarlord]

Jamie crushed it for me. Jeff picked 5 games I'd save from a fire and Jamie saved at least 10, including one Feld. I can't believe there werent more Felds in this video! Do you not own The Castles of Burgundy, Amerigo, Bonfire, Bora Bora, or Marrakesh??

[@FostertheMeeple]

We do not own them! Well, we now own the new CoB

[@TheCardboardWarlord]

@FostertheMeeple My wife and I just cracked our new CoB copy yesterday! I highly recommend Amerigo. It has a very satisfying cube tower, action selection system.

[@niteshmg]

Jamie had a better collection 😊

[@camelxhol551]

I thought this was you guys splitting games for a divorce.

[@FostertheMeeple]

Nope!

[@phillipheaton9832]

I really would have liked for written lists for each one of your picks, it would be much easier to compare them.

[@FostertheMeeple]

You can write them down and compare!

[@davetomasheski9509]

Team Jeff