Opera Singer Reacts: DUST || Punishing: Gray Raven (OST)

[@MarcoMeatball]

Last Resort is Next

[@raveelemental4928]

LET'S F*CKIN GOOOOO

[@Blackcatxd053]

LET'S GOOOOOO I can only say... wait for the drop!

[@thatnohrianscum6475]

LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@GlobalGlorypgr]

After last resort , you should react to revelation from vanguard sounds studio ( Punishing Gray Raven) and under dimensions that recently come out 👍👍👍. My bad before under dimensions u can react to shattered doll and exorcism

[@DisappointedAether]

Nice! I thought Last Resort would be the last

[@Vanguard-Sound]

knock knock 😉

[@Yotsuki10400]

GOAT

[@thatnohrianscum6475]

EYYYY 💓💓💓

[@MarcoMeatball]

Hiiiii

[@flapflapflapflap]

So, when's Keiki's Comona version 2 or Overburning dropping, buddy?

[@harya7517]

Why are you everywhere?

[@Daark_Karma]

"Oh I play music" "Oh cool! what instrument do you play?" "Train"

[@MarcoMeatball]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@totsukabladez369]

Wait, Kaarma!? I never expected to see you on Marco’s channel!

[@hito-sama]

You freak, i got caught off guard 😂... I can't not laughing

[@araguardian6954]

Context/ spoilers: this song takes place on what’s called the Eternal Engine, a city train that hosts an advanced city of traders who negotiate with our characters on The selling of a beast that is currently eating their train! And as we hear this song you fight a gluttonous mechanical beast while traveling through an endless desert.

[@VsectPT]

In addition, it's nicknamed the 'Eternal Engine' because the filters that filter out the Punishing Virus from the atmosphere in the train are dependent on the train's engine, so the train must never stop otherwise the filters stop working and everyone inside gets exposed to the virus. Even maintenance and repairs have to be done while the train is running.

[@liandoaethend2403]

Other name for the beast "Cancer Ball"

[@forlogic53]

You also have to explain who theyre selling the beast to. On one hand, they have Babylonia and in exchange for selling the beast to them, they want to be able to live in Babylonia (basically a massive space station) so that they can be safe from the virus. Babylonia wants the beast for research purposes and to prevent the Ascendants faction from getting their hands on it. On the other hand is the Ascendants faction, basically their goal is to spread the virus and take down Babylonia. By giving the beast to them, the Ascendants offer to let the inhabitants of the train into the Ascendant Network, basically turning them into Ascendants. As an Ascendant, they would have control on the virus, which also "saves" them from it.

[@daysand123]

I'm still in a dream train eater.

[@Zliarx]

so basically meatball

[@ssadalas]

"all you have to do is chase the damn train" - Bianca probably.

[@flapflapflapflap]

"All we had to do was to follow the damn train, Lucia!" -Bianca upon walking away casually from the motorcycle

[@soldier1stclass987]

Big Bianca to Carl Lucia

[@sheizanskyline]

"This is like Ace Combat to me" You're in for a surprise. Punishing Gray Raven haven't released this officially from their channel on global but... they have a collaboration with Keiki Kobayashi, Ace Combat's composer. The song's called Overburning.

[@MarcoMeatball]

😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😌😫😫😫

[@flapflapflapflap]

What's next, Ghost Final or Haloweek making osts for Ace Combat?

[@donnycorn3086]

​​@@flapflapflapflapcame from the future here, your buddy Pixy from Ace Combat Zero returns in a J15.

[@flapflapflapflap]

@@donnycorn3086 eh? Wdym?

[@donnycorn3086]

@@flapflapflapflap Corrupted Battlefront in the latest patch. The landing fighter jet has a single red wing.

[@sandermarkunzo4538]

It slapped to my ears when I heard the middle east music and dubstep combine perfectly.

[@crispy_querem]

PGR Music [X] NARWHAL [X] Hikari [X] Sie Liebten sich Beide [X] Huaxu (華墟) [X] Exorcism [X] Dust [ ] Last Resort [ ] C.O.R.E. [ ] Kowloon Night Ship (九龍夜船) [ ] Industrial Strike [ ] Puppet (傀儡 曲) [ ] Grand Blue Battle BGM [ ] Reverse [ ] Two Flowers (二輪の花) [ ] Holy Moonlight [ ] Moon (月) [ ] Memory Rescue [ ] Structures [ ] Initialize [ ] Echo Aria BGM [ ] Wraith [ ] Total Domination [ ] Exorcise [ ] Lamia [ ] Edenis [ ] Circling (盘旋) [ ] Wind's Sight (风的视线) [ ] Echoing [ ] NANAMI IKIMASU [ ] Revelation [ ] Surviving Glimmer BGM [ ] Firefly Ballad (萤灯谣) [ ] Voyage Among the Remains PV [ ] Left Unsaid PV [ ] Shattered Doll [ ] Spiral of Chronos PV [ ] Under Dimension [ ] Dim Light [ ] Overburning [ ] Renaissant Le Fantasque BGM

[@gastar8057]

Edenis is sorely missing from this list.

[@leav4360]

Exorcism is checked, he heard it on halloween's stream

[@crispy_querem]

@@gastar8057 ah right I forgot about thia

[@DisappointedAether]

Add Lost Control and Brand New to the list. The Holy Trinity of Sadge along with Hikari Part II

[@lovelution_]

don't forget Holy Moonlight, tho its kinda short and repetitive in a way

[@atrocious7766]

The Eternal Engine was my favorite set piece in the game. There's nothing like fighting a massive creature on a high speed train through the desert while resisting the urge to get up and start dancing.

[@utkarshsh]

5:24 Macro is like, wtf this wasn't in the script, how does vgs keep delivering such unpredictable banger drops and beats

[@MarcoMeatball]

I was expecting it but was still like whaaaaaat

[@spindakins]

Something I want to mention is how genius the use of drums and bass is, because it perfectly immitates the sound of the train we hear in the beginning, just faster. The bassline is very much the monotone, repetitive tone you hear when sitting in a train, whereas the drums immitate the rattling of the track segments. I just think that's super cool!

[@NothingXemnas]

The repertitive drum and bass is a massive hallmark in psytrance music. Perhaps GhostFinal (the composer) decided that genre's hypnotizing yet monotone rhythm would fit well in the unrelenting speed and momentum of a train.

[@1ch1r1n]

Marco: "Alright, this is the last PGR track I can cover, I've done them all and there aren't any new tracks out yet." PGR Fans: "... Can you do them again?"

[@Valysion]

More like "are you sure?"

[@Terribly_Grimm]

Every chapter in PGR feels so different visually and musically, the game really is a great art piece, the writing keeps getting better as well

[@jo3y960]

ARABIAN NIGHTS BABY. WE GOING BACK TO ASLAAM. If there's one thing to take from vanguard is that they use environment in the tracks that they belong to. Snow in Narwhal. Train in Dust. Asian flutes in the Kowloong stuff. Muffled tracks when going underwater. AND IT JUST WORKS SO WELL

[@CelticBotansDigitalArt]

I'm SO OBSESSED about tracks like these in the P:GR soundtrack, I love the mix of "traditional" elements like the sitar and the vocalizing, with the eletronic atmosphere - the fact that these songs are SO reminiscent of early 2000s trance music makes it even better because I love trance ahhhh

[@phanquan9470]

Agreed lamia and revelation when 😭

[@WCX]

I can not stop listening to this song. It’s such a fascinating mishmash of musical styles; synthesizers alongside Indian sitar, though the melody seems to zig-zag between traditional Indian and Arabic styles. And the sick beat that drops when the Bulgarian folk singing comes in is just *chef kiss*.

[@juanpejk]

the train at the star also cougt my atention at first, is amazing when song use the natural sound of an object alien to music (like a typewriter). Creativity knows no boundries

[@Armageddon5]

Btw vanguard sound released a new pgr music called under dimension based on the recent pgr chapter! I hope you take a listen and give us your thoughts!

[@noobselfish1536]

This is what they called "the vanguard studio rabbit hole", the more you listen to them, the more you become addicted to their musics Also you should also check gfl major event ending themes and wuthering waves ost, they are so hecc good

[@DisappointedAether]

You might also get into their game and the genre Fr i play PGR and got into trance thanks to Narwhal lol

[@noobselfish1536]

@@DisappointedAether played pgr since first day in global, but google account got deleted for unknown reasons so bruh

[@cryzieee]

@@noobselfish1536 bro you should ask support about this issue. Many players had problems with their accounts and pgr's support gladly helped them

[@AriaBelmonde]

Love Dust, the main beat/rhythm reminds me of riding an actual train when it goes over the small gaps of the connecting parts and it makes a bump sound kinda like the tune of the song Not sure if I explained that in an understandable way, but I’d just like to say it gives me a more thorough authentic train-feel

[@Kaiscoolness]

So happy to see you finally reacting to this theme! Have to say, it’s definitely one of my personal favorites from PGR. If you’re willing to look into it, hearing your reaction to some of the music from Pokémon would be awesome. In particular, Giratina’s theme from Diamond, Pearl and Platinum would be awesome Edit: also, if you’re looking for more PGR themes, Lamia might be worth a listen, and Edenis would also be really cool to see. -Exorcism is also relevant right now because it’s associated with the current event, and it’s just a cool theme in general- scratch that, you apparently listened to it already haha

[@royjonzejr]

He did listen to Exorcism during the Halloween stream but didn't do an extensive analysis

[@Kaiscoolness]

@@royjonzejr ahh okay, haven’t gotten around to watching that one, thanks!

[@halleyk7Art]

@@royjonzejr Do you have the link to that? I can’t seem to find it.

[@royjonzejr]

@@halleyk7Art It's the October 14, 2022 video titled, "SpOooOoOky Video Game Music Listening Stream" and then it's at 41:50

[@halleyk7Art]

@@royjonzejr Thank you for the title! I immediately went and watched it. :)

[@ambrielsglobalrange2226]

Having an EDM party at Sahara desert be like :

[@vergilsparda4295]

When I played the Eternal Engine chapter,I ascended when I heard this ost

[@DisappointedAether]

Best music to catch the damn train

[@Yilue]

I have no idea what that game is like but this banging tune I can imagine your beating the crap out of tones of enemies with some badass weapon and some headphones 😎

[@whatamess8894]

It's actually a bow, but it's one of the best bow user moveset in mobile game. when you click on a skill pattern you activate sniper mode, and she unleashes some electrically charged shots

[@tsahhv7199]

@@whatamess8894 I can already hear bianca snapping her fingers before entering sniper mode 😌

[@Smittywerbenya]

I don't have to imagine. That's what I already do in this game :D

[@cryzieee]

@@whatamess8894 not only among mobile games, other hack and slash PC/Console games don't have nearly unlimited locking distance!

[@ShadowSausage]

There is track also from PGR,【GhostFinal】Structures Its released with PGR and Nier: Automata collaboration, awesome OST

[@lunaazur7676]

I've been listening to it and the only reason I think it's not as famous as Narwhal is because maybe it doesn't last very long

[@atrocious7766]

It's way too short. I like it, but it also feels a bit unsatisfying.

[@flapflapflapflap]

Might as well check Weight of The World

[@ShadowSausage]

@@flapflapflapflap Already have kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3Kpq3eEorWlY8k&ab_channel=MarcoMeatball

[@xedala1940]

I know you would like this, I think the drum and the effects sounds like thunder/electric given that the character is a lightning element. Ty for reacting😉

[@Yuyuu97]

Loved that moment when marco forgot to give comments and just go crazy with the song

[@imjustczarina]

YYYYEEESSSS I joined the game during this event! And Eternal Engine Patch is what sold me to continue playing PGR. Up until now I'm simping for its gameplay and characters!

[@knightofwisdom8851]

*FOLLOW THE TRAIN LUCIA*

[@vampyerion6804]

Dust is an awesome one for sure! I remember booting the game up when the second ever event on global rolled around and this theme started up. Super cool! I know you’re covering Last Resort next, but I still can’t help but recommend Lamia and/or Exorcism. Love your videos dude!

[@GamingZeroTV]

Its so nice to hear, that Punishing: Gray Raven catched your attention so nicely and hope the rest will suit you as well as the last once. Btw the new ost "Under Dimensions" which got released 2 Days ago, is a Banger as well. Stay tuned Marco.

[@aaron_guzman]

Thank you for reacting to Dust. This BGM is 🔥but there's a whole playlist in front of you. Hope you may like it all. If you ever play PGR in/out stream or if you already played Eternal Engine chapter, I hope you had enjoy Bianca's gameplay (my best DPS construct so far).

[@elly9513]

Love how he never paused from drop to end.

[@danielvutran]

that''s how u know it's gud

[@Blackcatxd053]

rave song is best song! PGR has banger after banger, all gives this energy of power (and under dimension, "The merciful one" boss theme gives this image of POWER from the beyond, like a higher being). they never miss! also the OST of login screen of Wuthering waves (Another game of kuro the creators of PGR) called "Flow" is a banger too!

[@raihanhabibie8219]

3:58 Egypt Style, nice to heard it

[@Multimanplayer]

He did it!!! Marco always true to his word let's go haha

[@sandermarkunzo4538]

5:23 DROP THE BEAT!!!!!

[@TheTraconia]

I wouldn't mind hearing Code Vein music reactions :3 And all of the reactions you've done are great, keep at it :)

[@jpgarcia7892]

Better late than never, tuning in! Finally, Marco is now breaking down the theme of Eternal Engine and my queen, the ever straightforward sniper, Bianca Veritas!

[@utkarshsh]

My waifu Bianca's release ost Always will have a special place in my heart

[@renzokuken8445]

Something very grounded, very rooted" Eternal train: ummm

[@zukafu__462]

The creativity of Vanguard Sound will never run out as long as PGR lives🔥🔥🔥

[@АнатолийКнязьков-р6я]

Thank you for covering this song! More PGR reviews pls)

[@henrychan4870]

Hope you see your LAMIA review as well, that is gorgeous！

[@kowalski2385]

Marco, if you loved this, you'd LOVE Infected Mushroom's music. This is pretty much Psytrance. A SUPER COOL GENERE.

[@TheOnlyRinzy]

This is easily my favorite song of all of P:GR. It's so cool to hear your thoughts on it, thank you ^^

[@sadchildepicture7670]

Dust is such a banger for me! Im glad Marco like it.

[@vinatron3125]

Vanguard sounds just dropped their new OST for the new PGR event too, so it'll be nice to hear that eventually covered too!! It's called Under Dimension.

[@DatBisa]

God, PGR hits so hard and I love seeing you pop off at its OST, but you just HAVE to take a look at Vanguard's other works as well. Their work on Sunborn/MICA Team games (Girls' Frontline and Bakery Girl franchises) is pretty much the foundation of the company (and the entire leg of the industry), everything they've done since 2016 is an undeniable banger, and even their formative works from 2008 to 2014 have some real gems hidden in there.

[@yt_thesinner]

Wow! This style is pure Goa style music... i like so much =) 6.45am in spain and i am here listen it hehe

[@chente511]

so happy to see you continuing to listen and enjoying the music of PGR

[@angel__king]

Im recommending it again since you probably get a lot of requests but you should listen to “serpent swallowing the horizon” it’s the final boss theme of bravely default and you can either listen to the in game version or the actual concert version and both of them are great

[@danuuu2293]

this song reminds me to the music from Perfect Dark, old times... btw always great análisis from the OST...

[@RinTheSpaceDragon]

My god this goes hard 😮 I wanna play these games ;-; wish there was a PC version. Judging by Wuthering Heights, the lore seems really interesting. I like the middle eastern dubstep/electronica in this one. and THE VOCALSSSSSS OMG 😭😭😭 I love vocal chants in songs. Really hope Star Rail or ZZZ will have music like this. I kinda doubt Genshin will, unless there’s another continent/world more advanced than Teyvat after we complete the main story.

[@Blackcatxd053]

then you will be happy for 2 things, first it seem PGR will have a PC port, hope it will be good, and the other one is that it will release another game called "wuthering waves", they already released a video fighting against two bosses, if you are interested watch it, and the music will obviously be by Vanguard Sound! "Flow" is the login music and is BOP for a login screen :D

[@RinTheSpaceDragon]

@@Blackcatxd053 I’ve heard of Wuthering Waves and saw the videos~ that’s why I said the lord seemed interesting C: thank you for the info on the PC port! I hope it comes to Steam. Would be great on Steam Deck.

[@hachikuji_mayoi]

pgr works well on an emulator imo.

[@atrocious7766]

I play PGR on the LDPlayer emulator and it runs smooth as butter. I'd recommend using a controller and adjusting the buttons to your personal preferences though.

[@freykiva3887]

Regarding the PC version, it's coming soon, have fun!

[@viviangansey]

My favourite song from PGR so far!

[@Chihuahua-meow]

PGR music that sounds good are Revelation, last resort, Dust, final spark, Hikari, narwhal, left Unsaid and voyage Among Remains PV themes

[@royjonzejr]

6:33 reminds me of the end part of that old song "Crimson and Clover" by Tommy James & the Shondells

[@KofeiroRuim]

A fresh reaction is so good. Lamia next please!

[@teddy_scott36]

This song sounds like if Cyberpunk took place in the Middle East

[@LaplaceBacklogs]

Yes! More PGR content! I recommend listening to “Revelation” and “The Last Spark” as well.

[@genjixi7589]

PGR ost doesn't disappoint almost all their tracks leave me with good impression

[@zulfikaragustian9249]

With PGR, Imagine this: Snowpiercer, but through the desert wastelands. To put it simple, and in the words of Big Smoke from GTA: San Andreas : "All you had to do was follow the damn train, CJ!"

[@ZetaZeds]

Mommy's theme song😍😍😍

[@creamcrimson695]

I used to didn't understand why people LOVE Dust SO MUCH, but now after listening to your explanation about the music, I might understand it a little bit. I don't hate it, it just... not my cup of tea I guess. Now Lamia and Revelation on the other hand, those two are my cup of tea.

[@agraya7972]

Follow the Train CJ

[@bloodknight3907]

I highly recommend you check out the other ones like:C.O.R.E,Imprisoned sight and inscription of labyrinth from the same group.‌they are incredible pieces.

[@govetastream9003]

Dust is my most Favorite of them all ^^

[@najiv8797]

Good shit! 👍🏻

[@laurentina8056]

OMG you actually did it , I suggest try listening to LAMIA next 👍🏻

[@MarcoMeatball]

Last resort is next!

[@laurentina8056]

Can’t wait 🙌🏻

[@Valysion]

I know you already aknowledged it but i'm just gonna remind you about Chesed battle theme from library of ruina because it is a delightful piece of art.

[@lelouchlamperouge3077]

2:40 Ooopppppssss !!! 😆

[@hexfizgamingch]

There's still ton of VGS x PGR music you need to hear ... Down the rabithole we go ...

[@ShikikanAventa]

I wish you could react to Girls' Frontline songs too as they are also composed by Vanguard Sound !

[@hago66]

Mmmm that drop hits the spot. dun dun dun dun

[@GhostFinal]

😆😆😆😆😆

[@MarcoMeatball]

Oh hi! 😅😂🤣😂😅😂

[@GhostFinal]

@@MarcoMeatball Thanks for your reaction!

[@justinjamin]

lmao, @ 3:25 I just kept hearing Darude - Sandstorm.

[@khairiizwan3919]

you need to hear [Last resort] from pgr ost

[@dedcet634]

the music is too lit for story that has only train and crab boss

[@amirsalehabadi7243]

Marco you absolutely must hear the latest song "Under dimensions" by CoyDe from vanguard It is absolutely insane

[@Shinransa]

That tracks sound for me like something out of both Nier and The Martix for some reason.

[@halleyk7Art]

That’s such a good mix to describe a part of PGR. Kuro Game loves Nier and it inspired them while PGR is set in the future of a post-apocalyptic world with robots fighting a virus war. The time-stop dodge is actually called entering Matrix in the game!

[@Demondayo]

I'll be waiting for the day he react to "Left Unsaid"

[@ArataItsuka91]

Im sure Marco will be "Left Unsaid" after hearing that track 👀😏

[@albroiser]

I play the game moving like Marco in this video, that's an average PGR player skill btw. 🕺🏾💃🏾

[@renkyuji6167]

Ahh yesss DUST

[@xtcaudio]

Wonderful

[@CaosBolt]

imagine him hearing Left Unsaid or Last Resort

[@madaggar9765]

Interesting to hear progressive trance.

[@kaz-tl2st]

This song is soo goood bianca best waifu

[@LunaSawako]

Still waiting for Lamia and Revelation. And now Under Dimension too! (the new soundtrack)

[@sidestream7876]

Yes the song plays on the arabian snow piercer.

[@danielvutran]

5:24

[@darkrayan]

PGR is rly BIG game when you think about it music wise. You should hear more Arknights too tho, reminding bout Radiant and here is 1 more for later [Arknights] Stultifera Navis BGM - The Golden Age Will Return Again

[@savagelove1939]

If you can you can listen to PGR's Exorcism

[@summerfox6132]

im waiting for Exorcism so much!

[@persephone3472]

Its hereeee

[@flapflapflapflap]

You know, since you mentioned that this is like Ace Combat music now i cant unsee that one F-16 pilot dodging against Iraqi missiles during the Iraq-Iran war

[@nexovec]

That was calling for a harder drop imo but that's subjective. This is very unique. It's like darude sandstorm turned indian cyberpunk.

[@depresespres4214]

There’s a remix of narwhal made for the game by a different producer at Vanguard you should look at

[@advisorv]

One of my favorite tracks ever. Also when you spoke about a heist... why don't you go listen to some Payday 2 soundtrack, something like Razormind by Simon Viklund ? I think the similarities are interesting...

[@liandoaethend2403]

Ah yes the place where we fought cancer ball