Opera Singer Reacts to Shoshana Bean | She Used to be Mine | Waitress | Performance Analysis

[@MisterHurtEnglish1]

Be careful...she's addictive. I am a 50 year old black man who has no experience with Broadway and this lady had me listening to this song on replay for months. Just Awesome!

[@10GolDenHeaRts]

You’re not alone ! She got us both !

[@1Ma9iN8tive]

@@10GolDenHeaRts - Me three ha ha ha ha

[@amberharrison8017]

Add me to the addicted list…

[@CruellaJunella]

Girl me too! 50, black, addicted to her voice! When I heard her sing this song, I hit replay over and over and over and... 😉

[@valeriecherish449]

I can't stop listening to it, I have a problem.

[@1dancersmom]

Shoshanna Bean’s Make it Rain Live at the Theater at the Ace Hotel is one of the best performances I’ve ever watched. You will not be disappointed!

[@stewiegriffin993]

YES!

[@dylanhafner7608]

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

[@corvus1374]

Shoshana's singing with Cynthia Erivo is an event. The two together are magic.

[@jgalvan96]

OMG YES PLEASE IT IS THE BEST VOCAL PERFORMANCE I HAVE EVER EXPERIENCED

[@yushaa]

YESSS

[@chaos862]

Shoshana is the perfect example of knowing your voice, knowing the character, and LIVING in that moment. Cynthia Erivo, Lara Fabian, and Yebba are the same way. All embody the song. From before the first note is sung, until well after the last.

[@crhu319]

It's also what Barbara Streisand is known for. Many including Lara looked up to her and to Jacques Brel.

[@kelvinalexander4353]

You are the 1st reactor to notice (mention) the subtleties of just what she did in this song. Thank you! I am moved every time I see this performance. I hands down think this is the best rendition of all the covers because of her delivery. If you are so inclined...you should check out her version of Make It Rain Live. In a word...transcendent. Great reaction!!👍🏾

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Thank you! And I will add that song to my list ☺️

[@natashatrad]

I love how you notice the littlest details that very few people pay attention to. Definitely subscribed to you. I think you would find Lara Fabian- je suis malade with translations to be absolutely stunning. She is the epitome of feeling rhe words and conveying so many emotions while singing

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Thank you and I've never heard of her. I will write her down :)

[@joel2421]

Any Lara Fabian song would be great, but that one in particular would be awesome.

[@joel2421]

@@jessicasopranonotes You’ve never heard of Lara Fabian? You’re in for a real treat.

[@cjdonald1983]

You will love Lara Fabian if you appreciate emotion during singing! She is THE MASTER!!!!!!!!!!

[@stryker9745]

omg yes this performance is INCREDIBLE

[@carr0760]

I'm a musical theatre teacher, but was classically trained. I always teach my students about recitative vs aria, because no...there isn't really a term for this in the theatre world. We mostly describe it as "speak singing." Even in older "legit" musical theatre, a lot of songs have a "recit" section, but as far as I know, there isn't a name for it in English/modern terms. Modern theatre doesn't typically structure songs that way, but as you pointed out, the speech-like approach is used within the song. With my students, I obviously teach proper technique, but we prioritise acting through song. Vocal perfection can, and should, be sacrificed for the character and storytelling. I remind them to act, and it brings them back to speaking. Shoshana Bean is a masterclass in storytelling. Every single time. She also happens to be one of the best voices in the business...a rare combination.

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Thank you for the clarification! I've never had a musical theater voice teacher or pop teacher so I'm clueless on the terminology used between the genres. I absolutely love that you put acting at the forefront. It's incredible how much improvement can happen when we're not so focused on technique but just delivering a message. Very nice to meet you, and thank you for stopping by!

[@carr0760]

@@jessicasopranonotes Absolutely. You have to let the story lead you. Take Bernadette Peters for example...is she the best singer? No. But she is an absolute master in acting through song. There's a reason she was Sondheim's muse for years. I'd take her over a perfect singer who can't tell a story any day of the week. Technique absolutely matters, but the different between good and great is how much of yourself you are willing to put into a song. Honestly, it's the reason I made the switch from classical/opera to theatre. I just can't connect in the same way when I'm singing opera...I have to focus far too much on the technique. This was my first time watching you, and I was pleasantly surprised! I appreciate the level of detail you picked up. You clearly know your stuff. I'll be back!

[@toleaves7893]

I feel like her performance here is filled with “flaws” and “imperfections” from a vocal technique perspective, but it’s flawless in terms of conveying emotions and the meaning of the lyrics.

[@emelianemone777]

it truly is masterclass theatrical singing, that's for sure. ♥️

[@ssabell31]

Shosh really is one of the most vocally talented female singers out there, today. She has worked very hard and knows exactly how to use her voice.

[@bluckyslotscardo4005]

Omg this performance was amazing, im glad i was not the only one crying. AMAZING!

[@jessicasopranonotes]

It's SO good!! I can't get enough

[@gregstorkwilson2745]

This is indeed a master class in acting a song. Ive been watching it since it dropped, and I return to it a couple of times a month. Everything you pointed out is spot on, and I really appreciate your attention to detail. The skill, technique, and emotion that Sho puts into this performance is demonstrated by the fact that you, as a professional singer, were so touched by it that you stopped analyzing and evaluating and were actually moved to tears should be proof enough to anybody how great Shoshanas performance is. She has been singing professionally a very long time, and has a few albums and lots of credits to her name. If you want to hear more of her I cant recommend her take on "Let it Rain" enough. It is COMPLETELY different than this, but is also one of the greatest vocal performances Ive ever seen. Its one of my favorite things to watch is people who don't know Shoshana react to her. All I can think is "Just wait it gets even better" kzbin.info/www/bejne/l5C8hIxpn8h1q9E

[@jessicasopranonotes]

So well put! I couldn't agree more when you said her performance is like a masterclass. I have gotten many many requests to react to that specific performance and have written it down. Thank you for the link!

[@iago07]

4:29 that breath on the beat MY GAWD 🤯

[@L0C0vision]

I rewatch this a ridiculous number of times. Your insights and appreciation for this performance brings me back again and again.

[@nofuture2890]

The cracks in her voice and the growls she made 😩😍 i love your videos btw ! It’s great to finally find a passionate vocalist and teacher on KZbin

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Yes, I love the cracks and rasp in her voice! And thank you so much ☺️

[@nofuture2890]

@@jessicasopranonotes exactly! And you re welcome 🙏🏽 pls keep at it ! ❤️

[@jayjayhibbs]

Hey I have come across a few of your reactions now because I have been watching reactions to her and avery Wilson cuz I can’t get enough of them and ur so good love ur videos and how u explain everything it’s really interested and helpful. Ur so clever ❤

[@trentt5310]

She makes me cry too! Thanks for the beautiful reaction to a beautiful song!

[@jessicasopranonotes]

You're so welcome 🤗

[@kevinkimbrough8010]

I must agree with the gentleman. I am a 62yr old black man, also with no Broadway experience. I listened to Shoshana Bean and many of the other singers reaction to She Used to be Mine. I was drawn back to Ms Bean....mesmerized by her voice and performance. Each day for a week, I have replayed her singing over and over again. When she belts "scared of the life that's inside her....to fight just a little ", I raised off the stool for her. Absolutely stunning. Power house performance. "Make it Rain"....she did it again

[@jesusmariacatalanventura8174]

This one is, without a doubt, the best version ever of this song. I've seen many people singing perfectly technically speaking, but empty of emotion. This song needs raw emotions.

[@KyBeautyChannel]

The way you Articulate not only the voice and technique, but the picture the performer is setting up for the audience through their movements is very detailed and truly refreshing! Subscribed!

[@mattiep81]

I've watched MANY different vocal coaches/performers react/critique this performance and I must say that yours was the most in-depth and cohesive one I've seen. I agree with your assessment about her going into her chest voice in the one section but I have another theory as well. When taking the entire context of the song into consideration, I feel as though she's using her lighter, breathier tones when she's talking about her current situation because it feels like it's something she can't do anything about. When she reminisces about how her life used to be and everything she used to be/used to have, her chest voice comes out because it's what she longs for again.

[@dancerguy07]

She is the greatest actress while singing it’s INCREDIBLE! I’ve watched this more times than i can count ❤

[@lutoph]

To date my favorite interpretation I’ve seen recorded. She wasn’t just signing she was living that song and you FEEL it.

[@jnewmark41]

She is soooo underrated...

[@dollyknockers]

This performance moves me to tears every single time I hear it.

[@MitochondrialSteve]

The minute you cried, I hit the subscribe button because in that instant I KNEW you were from the same tribe as me! The sublimeis you picked up on the eyes, the head movements, sign of someone who is truly in touch with the arts and their emotions! Beautiful analysis of a beautiful performance!

[@wolffbites]

flawless and brilliant. the lyrics the music the performance the critique. big thanks

[@crhu319]

I think that sincere dramatic presence combined with the expressive voice is why there are such dedicated fans of David Draiman, Floor Jansen, Gordon Lightfoot, Alanis Morrisette, Jinjer, and pretty much all the Postmodern Jukebox singers. Style of song and the specific emotions are less important than contrasts & sincerity.

[@maxm.grinnell139]

I feel like musical theatre performers often forget that the art form evolved from operatic techniques. These subtleties are vital in storytelling and I applaud Shoshana for understanding that and showing it here. Thank you for calling it out.

[@romulosucre2382]

I met her a few days ago and she is amazing artist and amazing human being

[@cevaldesp]

I’m in love with the way you talk about music, and the heart you pour in every one of your videos

[@billizetti]

You won’t even believe it when you hear her sing Make It Rain! 🌹

[@arnoldramos7693]

My favorite version of all time. She is an absolute beast

[@greene.apples]

this song always makes me tear up based on lyrics alone, but this performance had tears rollinggg down my face the first time I watched it. The shifts in her voice she uses to create that "crying" sound near the end just tug on the heart strings, it's not over exaggerated and it really feels like its coming from a place of deep, long-held, emotion

[@EV4RY]

Brings me to tears after 30+ times, great reaction really enjoyed it.

[@pauljames84]

Agree with everything you say. She creates art and takes you into her world straight away!

[@Dani-rz8dj]

Your reaction was me the whole time. Every little thing she does I feel in my bones. Just crying the entire time. Subbed♥️ I’d love if you did more reactions that have emotional weight to them. The most powerful kind

[@ricmotta2495]

A master storyteller with control, range and power so very underestimated by the general public.

[@gilbertrobinson7944]

You should check out her version of Make it Rain live at the Ace Hotel. You will be floored.

[@chalacor32]

I love the big note she belts, but the part that absolutely guts me is when she follows it with “she is lonely most of the time” at 11:44. Great reaction.

[@yushaa]

Hands down my favourite Shoshana reaction video! ❤️❤️❤️

[@ivanroman8970]

I feel you and I'm feeling her performance too. I really appreciate how you are analyzing and breaking down for us the acting and body language that goes so well with her vocal dynamics to truly communicate the emotion and the message of the song. Singers that connect to and are able to transmit the emotion -- how a song is supposed to make us feel -- are the ones who truly stand out. That to me is equally or even more important than having a seemingly perfect vocal technique. Just discovered you and will now have to look up more of your reactions. Thanks.

[@iago07]

4:19-4:24 is probably the best series of notes when it comes to emotion and the smallness with big pay off… CHILLZ!

[@ericweir3966]

I adore ShoBean! Ive watched this video about 5 million times and it impacts me more every time!

[@kinzojusti1352]

Honestly saw this video 4 years back as a singer myself with classical training it is so in the details, when I hear this song, loved the song from its writer and the musical, literally fell on to this, during that year, broadway week…ma’am…Mrs. Bean, Annotated, period, just blown away! She’s amazing! You’re amazing for bringing this to us, showing us your skills! Liking and following!!! ❤🎉❤ can’t wait to see more!!!

[@hmariet1999]

This song is amazing when anyone performs it but Shoshana's is defintely one of the best. You should react to Lucie Jones' version as well, it's breathtaking.

[@lynette599]

Wow...I was SO impressed by your analysis of this performance...I live in South Africa where we do not have access to great performances like these...your emotional commentary really brought this performance to life for me and gave me a much better understanding of what there is to appreciate and admire in Shoshana's singing.

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Oh wow! I'm so glad you came across my video! She's brilliant at what she does and I get emotional every time I listen to this.

[@Hey_Jamie]

My god even coming with the video links in descriptions.... you are truly one of the more respectful reaction channels I’ve seen!

[@crhu319]

I'm going to watch all of Shoshana now. And you. Thanks.

[@yushaa]

YAY MORE SHOSHANA BEAN REACTIONS PLEASE! ❤️❤️❤️

[@WreckOfLamb]

Sho Bean owns this Sara Barielles song. Marvelous!

[@nicholasgiaquinto3278]

I am just seeing this for the first time and I am beside myself what an engaging revealing performance and you as you always do break it down in such a beautiful thoughtful way.

[@addiegrace3508]

If you haven't heard Jeremy Jordan's version of this please go watch like right now...my favorite version. He is brilliant!!

[@1Ma9iN8tive]

I love Shoshana Bean I loved that you choose to give her love by privileging her with your critical appreciation. All the loves.

[@jaimemacintyre8545]

You managed to put into words everything I saw but didn't know how to explain, which is something I've not seen yet from the many reacters I follow. I'm happy to sub forever for just that, but you also manage to react and explain without removing yourself from the performance, and allowing yourself to visibly feel every syllable. It's an instant connection and I often found myself reacting the same way (without any idea why), which is another thing I've never experienced with any other pros who react. I find a lot of pros tend to disconnect from the source after hearing so many renditions. The only way I can explain it is that you sing from the heart, but you also listen from the heart.

[@jnewmark41]

Shoshana's "details" are amazing to see in concert. She is always SO CONNECTED. Her voice is a national treasure....

[@Bleuxman]

You’re one of the best out there. Loved your breakdown. My favorite was the growl. The minute heard it it I felt it. So good.

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Thank you! And the growl was so satisfying

[@SAYoung15]

Thank you for making this video. You put words that I was not able to articulate behind why I love this performance so much

[@lilliantaylor-whitfield1952]

I so enjoyed watching your reaction. It was so beautiful and pure. Please react to Shoshana’s “Make it Rain”. I think you will love it.

[@kevinmcbeuks]

I LOVE YOUR REACTION!!! 😍😍😍 This has been the ABSOLUTE VERY BEST! reaction to Shoshana’s cover of this song!!! You are so amazing. Thank you for amazing reaction! 👏🏻

[@magnoliaskogen]

I discovered your channel tonight and have been watching many of your videos. The depth, detail, and nuance of your reactions are the best that I have seen on KZbin and I have watched many, many reactions from many creators. Thank you for your channel and for sharing your knowledge and wisdom with us.

[@annclancy1394]

I have listen to her sing this so many times I can’t count. Your reaction and discussion gave me so much more to think about and appreciate

[@thisguyny8379]

If you haven't, you should check out Jeremy Jordan's performance of this song. Totally different and equally thrilling. And for the record, Shoshana should change her last name to Beast. She's brilliant.

[@johnokamoto6762]

my favorite version of this song ever and you are spot on with the way she grabs you from the very start and emotionally invested!

[@robertgould8099]

Thank you for your analysis. I felt every subtle emotion as Shoshanna's story telling told what any woman should feel when this story is told - and any man should want to hold her to make it all better. I cried with her (and you).

[@crhu319]

I agree with you it's a magnificent head performance. Every emotion conveyed by the voice, gesture and eyes together.

[@m.a.2658]

I love your reactions. Hearing your intelligence and perceptiveness on display is wonderful and you are really beautiful.

[@markspencer8449]

Oh wow, I totally agree with every one of your comments. I’m watching this in the carpark of the supermarket with tears pouring down my face. A master class in performing with truth. The authenticity makes it flawless. Love your commentary btw- smart and knowledgeable x

[@fayapo]

You are teaching more than music in this video, thank you so much Jess, you're my favorite KZbinr now

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Awww thank you 🥺🥺

[@dp8169]

You take a beautiful performance and bring so much life into it with your knowledge and passion. Your tears made me what to wrap you in a warm embrace.

[@L0C0vision]

Oh my!!! I love that you love her and can so accurately describe what she is doing that pulls me into her song and mostly her performance. She sang "Stars and the Moon" for a Playbill video. Just sitting on a chair with only a piano, she takes me on a journey on a way that other actresses with an orchestra, set and costume sometimes cannot. Even if you don't make it a reaction, I hope you treat yourself to her Playbill performance of "Stars and the Moon." This channel is outstanding!!!

[@like-rq9wk]

Love From South Africa I am Not a Technical Musical Person But This Woman Tells This story Like No Other Not Even The Original Singer Sarah Yes This is a Real Song im hoping you listen to the song uninterrupted

[@arnoldramos7693]

This is my favorite version, she is jaw dropping great

[@frasergavin9100]

Beautiful song beautiful singer beautiful reaction , you've done it again Jess WOW.

[@user-gr2vc2kv8r]

Please react to her singing Make it Rain at the Ace Hotel. It’s insane, in the best way possible.

[@shigemorif1066]

This is an amazing performance and this review/analysis is also amazing. So detailed and informative.

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Thank you, David!

[@richardk8821]

Thank you for the analysis. Your sensitivity and awareness as an exceptional musician yourself is apparent and appreciated. Here, SB combines exquisite musical theatre singing and acting with storytelling to pique interest, lure us in, keep us involved, make us care, and, finally, break our hearts. In the final analysis, using music and lyrics and acting all together in the service of storytelling is what we singers-classical, musical theatre, or otherwise-should be doing as best we can. Never underestimate the smallest nuance of a note, time signature, single word, phrase, or physical gesture.

[@melissacoviello2886]

I am so sad that I haven’t known of her until just recently. She is breathtaking in what she can make you feel.

[@popcultrejnkie]

What I love most about this performance is that even though she’s not performing as Jenna, she’s still acting out all these emotions. It feels like you could put her in a costume and slot this performance into the show. I’m definitely with another commenter about her Make It Rain live performance, I heard that and I was a fan forever. I hope you’ll consider reacting to that one too.

[@tlneader]

I could not get through the entire song without sobbing . The performance is insane.

[@felicitymoore7340]

This brought me to tears, it's my life....................

[@johndiaz6431]

This video is better than any award anyone could possibly receive (for me, anyways). “Oh, you have 24 Tony’s, cool. Has anyone ever documented their love for your work with such enthusiasm, clarity, intelligence, and genuine LOVE??? Well, you’ll get there someday.”

[@diannaw3034]

I did not know this artist or this track!!! I had just watched your amazing Justin Bieber - Lonely SNL reaction.. so this came up next. Sooooo happy I got a chance to hear it.. and your reaction to it! Magic!!! I soooo appreciate your emotional reactions.. and technical breakdowns.... they are so fulfilling! I feel so entertained.. yet I learn a few things at the same time!! You are doing such a phenomenal job! Solid content!!! Keep up the great job!

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Omg I'm so glad I introduced you to this performance! And thank you for the many compliments, it really makes my day to hear how entertaining my videos are. So nice to meet you ☺️☺️

[@Lego51]

I love Sara Bareilles and her version of this was my everything .The first time I saw Shoshanna sing this I was like, Sara who? Shoshanna is amazingly talented. Her chanel has an amazing array of her music. Im 52 and 5 of her songs have been in my top 30 of all time for the last 5 years. This by far tho is my favorite performance. Thanks for reacting to this. It made me love it even more. 🥰 Peace and love!

[@alessandrogandolfo]

Thank you for the analisis! You explained details that I didn’t notice.

[@jessicasopranonotes]

You're welcome Alessandro ☺️

[@Orholam5]

You should watch Jeremy Jordan do this! Masterclass in contemporary musical theatre delivery.

[@heartw.2222]

Loving your analysis vids of Shoshana and Cynthia Erivo... so have just subscribed to you. Thank you, I'm a soprano a capella singer and am enjoying hearing your tips. Thx

[@madeleinebelle2105]

this is the only version that affected me emotionally...she took me immediately to me...thank you...it moved you too!

[@Skybolt211]

What a beautiful reaction... love your breakdowns and I've subscribed. Very much looking forward to watching many more of your videos!

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Thank you Jon!

[@dwight9012]

The first few times I watched Shoshana sing this song I cried too. She’s 🔥

[@kodeispresser5307]

I love this. Please do more musical theater reactions.

[@giorgiagorski]

OMG you're gonna looove Je Suis Malade and Adagio by Lara Fabian. The interpretation is amazing as well!

[@angiebby1122]

I've seen your videos....and this reaction video is the best, my favorite. Perfection! So moved! ❤❤❤❤

[@bradders1st]

This is such a quality analysis and reaction please I beg you do more mt

[@justine11012]

i really like your analysis. here, take my like!

[@susanbenes4094]

I always cry at this performance.

[@pgismo1012]

This is like the 4th or 5th time I've seen this video. I love watching your reaction/analysis to this performance - it is simply amazing and dead on. I love Shoshana - whatever she sings, she puts her all in it and brings out all the feels! You should check her video of "Make It Rain".

[@mshalo1822]

What an amazing reaction to an amazing performance. Just subscribed.

[@johnokamoto6762]

I cry every time I watch this

[@asherpaolo4773]

Loved her reaction videos. Gotta subscribed to her channel immediately! 😍

[@jessicasopranonotes]

Ahhh, thank you! 😊

[@elizabeth5985]

I cried with you, yes I did. I've watched it several times, and I was crying AGAIN. She does it as good as anybody, including the original Jenna in the role (who is no slouch!) Flawless is right. Thank you for appreciating it and allowing yourself to be moved by it. That's what art does. It moves us.

[@Griff.photography]

I’ve never been into Broadway or anything I know nothing about it but this cover of hers I’ve listened to thousands of times