Oppenheimer quoted the Bhagwad Gita. So what?

Support this channel by becoming a member / @vimoh
Or make a one-time donation by clicking the Super Thanks button under this video!
I am Vimoh, an Indian atheist and my videos have to do with religion, atheism, Indian culture, and sometimes contemporary political happenings.
Below are some videos from this channel that every Indian atheist must watch.
✔️ Videos for the Indian atheist - • Delving Deeper
✔️ How I became an atheist - • My journey between rel...
✔️ Why I am not a "Hindu atheist" - • Why I am not a Hindu A...
✔️ Why I am not a "Hindu atheist" (part 2) - • Belief in karma = beli...
✔️ The Indian atheist problem - • The Indian atheist pro...
✔️ Why atheism is important - • You can't fight irrati...

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

Chaddi 1 - Dude, did you heard what Oppenharman said when the atom bomb exploded? Chaddi 2- Yes I know what he Sayed. But told it to me again no, please Chaddi 1- I am become like death... Chaddi 1 and 2 both together (sporting tiny erections from the excitement)- The destroyer of the world's. I know it man. Orpanharman such a great scientist, and he followed the Geeta, and here is our youth, talking about Jugal Nawab Harihar, and his book Saapent. (The misspellings and grammatical errors are intentional, and are a true reflection of how most chaddis speak)

[@akshat_2100]

"Jugal Nawab Harihar" lol this one is lit🔥🔥 🤣🤣

[@divyanshmishra9706]

@@akshat_2100 i didn't understand. Who's jugal nawab?

[@akshat_2100]

@@divyanshmishra9706 He is trying to mimic the WhatsApp graduates by writing the author's name wrong. The real name is 'Yuval Noah Harari' who wrote 'Homo Sapiens'. book.

[@helloguys7041]

@@akshat_2100 😂

[@Ex-M_Musicophile]

Okay then what...😅 Criticising a organisation which has nothing to do with this matter that itself shows your hatrate towards sanatan😂 don't call yourself libral.. you are certified Librandu 😅

[@AnonymousAlien2099]

When a Gora quotes our scripture, we reach climax and when the same goras constructively criticize our country or culture, we lose our shit. Hypocrisy in a nutshell.

[@sahilrajput1297]

You r mentioning 2 different things. Scriptures are different.

[@jitukumar-wx3hc]

We mention NASA to support our arguments rather than ISRO.

[@y.muralikrishna4733]

when did he even use the word nasa or isro in this video?

[@alpeshmittal3779]

NASA is confirming birthdate of Ram and Krishna to find out validity of sanatan dharma!!!😂 as if they don't have anything more useful to do!

[@matrixsmarther2325]

Don't you know NASA has a secret room filled with Vedas, that every new recruit has to study and master ?!!! 😂

[@YourParas]

@@alpeshmittal3779 what happened when shree ram's kundli was put into nasa's planterium software?

[@whykoks]

​@@YourParas you tell what exactly happened. I'm seriously curious to know. And please don't tell me to google it.

[@sunnychiwande]

They cite quotes of white men and they also say that we don't want a validation for our beliefs.

[@alpeshmittal3779]

That's actually shield they use so that we can't show them examples from more liberal western societies.

[@skeptic2561]

Ya ,just recently richard dawkins tweeted something against hinduism and the present state of governance in India and many of this kattar sanatanis came across saying the same

[@dead34311]

it is not a validation, it is an acknowledgement that what a reader of bhagwad gita (here oppenheimer) felt on seeing a power beyond imagination, a power beyond scale of human capabilities, a power able to destroy millions in seconds, gave him similar feelings to what the description of lord krishna is written in bhagwad gita, just that, nothing more, and you may say why i do not give such acknowledgement, because my low brain powered boy i had never a pleasure to see a nuclear bomb in person.

[@warrior_of_liberation]

I read someone saying "Oppenheimer accepted Sanatan Dharma". Reading that, some of my brain cells died right then and there.

[@reshavgovindam1280]

sanatan dharma,you know aajkal yeh word sunke bada ajeeb lagta hai,yaar hinduism use karo na,kya faraak hai🙂🙃

[@ShieldYoung]

​@@reshavgovindam1280ha yar sanatan sun ke jis tarah se use kiya gya hai bahut radical feel hota hai jabki Hinduism relatively peaceful

[@reshavgovindam1280]

@@ShieldYoung wohi toh yeh baat word ki nahi hai but maine jaha jaaha dekha hai woh itna agressive lagta hai ki woh maar he dega dusre community ko,mai iss point pe pahuch chuka jaha pe agar koi sanatan word use karta hai,mai samaj jaata hu yeh kaisa aadmi aur abhi tak lagbhag sab waise he log nikle,unke personality itna obvious ho jaata hai yeh word use karne ke baat..mai aajkal aise logo se baat karna avoid karta hu ki kyuki mera dimaag kharab ho jaata hai aur kya pata haath uth jaye,so better hai nikal jau waha se🙂🙂

[@ShieldYoung]

@@reshavgovindam1280 haha nhi par Maine bahut logo ko dekha hai jo sanatani bolte hai khudko par real life me bahut nice hai mostly kuch log hi baki logo me jahar ghol rhe hai (politicians aur media both traditional and social)

[@reshavgovindam1280]

@@ShieldYoung i wish mai tere position pe hota ,mereko bhi hate nahi karna kisiko yaar

[@Armada762]

J Robert Oppenheimer was an admirer of the bhagavad-gita since he studied Sanskrit in the 1920s and fell in love with the text it does not mean that he's an authority on or anything like but what he saw in front of him reminded him of the imagery that came to mind when he read the he didn't say one religion was right or anything like he was just using a metaphor to describe how he felt

[@pauldirc..]

Yes sir i am tired of these claim , people are busy in proving all modern science in vedas and these things are fueled by some statements of schrodinger, hisenberg, i request you to gove me some gppd argument against it debunking claim that schrodinger, hisenberg, Oppenheimer developed / stole principal of quantum dynamics from our vedas I know it true that schrodinger used to admire vedanta philosophy but it not possible he derived eqn from those scripture Whenever i tried to argue any friend against anything written in vedas, he contradicts me by giving authority of these scientists Even one of my friend doing BSC in physics trying to find grand unified theory of quantum gravity in vedas

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

@@mr.gamerkabir8142 Forget about science understanding consciousness mentioned in the Veda’s, science has not yet understood how cow urine can help cure diseases as mentioned in Ayurveda, which is part of the Veda’s. We can’t see consciousness, but cow urine exists, and even cow urine is beyond science. Scambhooooooo.

[@adityabhattacharyya8727]

@@pauldirc.. But while fighting superstition are you sure you are not becoming blind yourself. Most scientific concepts stems from Philosophy and metaphysics. Example: The concept of computer programming comes from 'Logic' in philosophy(Also studied in Mathematics). The concept of Law comes from 'Ethics' in philosophy - and there are countless other examples. And Bhagwat Geeta and Vedanta are subjects which have indeed evolved for thousands of year(at least more than 2000 years). So it is quite natural that many of the scientific concepts will have their roots in it. Of course there can be parallel studied which may have come up with similar concepts. And Of course Quantum Physics does have extremely similar concepts to Vedanta. I mean by no means we should think ourselves superior to others because of our heritage but at the same time lets not be blind ourselves,

[@pauldirc..]

@@adityabhattacharyya8727 i am trying to read schrodinger book what's life , there is chapter of vedantic vision in that book which talk about vedas and eastern philosophy, what i understand they were finding some interpretation of quantum mechanics or how to reliase reality through it , but i am not fully convinced by them Here is the passage from his book - "Suppose you are sitting on a bench beside a path in high mountain country. There are grassy slopes all around, with rocks thrusting through them; on the opposite slope of the valley there is a stretch of scree with a low growth of alder bushes. Woods climb steeply on both sides of the valley, up to the line of treeless pasture; facing you, soaring up from the depths of the valley, is the mighty, glacier-tipped peak, its smooth snowfields and hard-edged rock faces touched at this moment with soft rose colour by the last rays of the departing sun, all marvellously sharp against the clear, pale, transparent blue of the sky. "According to our usual way of looking at it, everything that you are seeing has, apart from small changes, been there for thousands of years before you. After a while -- not long -- you will no longer exist, and the woods and rocks and sky will continue, unchanged, for thousands of years after you. "What is it that has called you so suddenly out of nothingness to enjoy for a brief while a spectacle which remains quite indifferent to you? The conditions for your existence are almost as old as the rocks. For thousands of years men have striven and suffered and begotten and women have brought forth in pain. A hundred years ago, perhaps, another man sat on this spot; like you, he gazed with awe and yearning in his heart at the dying light on the glaciers. Like you, he was begotten of man and born of woman. He felt pain and brief joy as you do. Was he someone else? Was it not you yourself? What is this Self of yours? What was the necessary condition for making the thing conceived this time into you, just you, and not someone else? What clearly intelligible scientific meaning can this 'someone else' really have? If she who is now your mother had cohabited with someone else and had a son by him, and your father had done likewise, would you have come to be? Or were you living in them, and in your father's father, thousands of years ago? And even if this is so, why are you not your brother, why is your brother not you, why are you not one of your distant cousins? What justifies you in obstinately discovering this difference -- the difference between you and someone else -- when objectively what is there is the same? "Looking and thinking in that matter you may suddenly come to see, in a flash, the profound rightness of the basic conviction in Vedanta: it is not possible that this unity of knowledge, feeling, and choice which you call your own should have sprung into being from nothingness at a given moment not so long ago; rather this knowledge, feeling, and choice are essentially eternal and unchangeable and numerically one in all men, nay in all sensitive beings." -- Erwin Schrödingerwhat life

[@ksrishankhchakra1528]

@@adityabhattacharyya8727 🤣😂😂😂😂 bruh? what? quantum physics and that too relationship with VEDANTA? what sloka? gimme some reference? dude, stop glorifying your past religious texts with science. okay>

[@divyanshmishra9706]

An Appeal to authority has become so mainstream and pushed like propaganda. Another popular example of this kind is the Natraj placed in CERN being associated to how cosmic dance of destruction has some scientific end and "hey, if an institution like CERN has a figure of a hindu deity, in a scientific institution, they must think it's greatly scientific or lends some inspiration to it. At this point if you start pointing out the number of absurdities in a single such argument, it increasingly becomes redundant.

[@pauldirc..]

Yes sir i am tired of these claim , people are busy in proving all modern science in vedas and these things are fueled by some statements of schrodinger, hisenberg, i request you to gove me some gppd argument against it debunking claim that schrodinger, hisenberg, Oppenheimer developed / stole principal of quantum dynamics from our vedas I know it true that schrodinger used to admire vedanta philosophy but it not possible he derived eqn from those scripture Whenever i tried to argue any friend against anything written in vedas, he contradicts me by giving authority of these scientists Even one of my friend doing BSC in physics trying to find grand unified theory of quantum gravity in vedas

[@spuriusscapula4829]

​@@pauldirc.. It's possible that some scientist got some random idea from an idea mentioned in a story book, which leads to a great discovery/invention. Does that make the story book "real" or "scientific"?

[@NeKo19113]

Most i heard in news was that india itself gifted this statue to CERN as a gift as india became it's member? 😐 Am i wrong?

[@PscycologyFactss]

If I am a scientist and I read books from different cultures, It doesn't mean my work is inspired by them. Reciting a line just means the way we feel in certain situations. One day I quoted Batman but that doesn't mean that it has to do something with my professional work😅😅😅

[@vimoh]

Ok Mister Wayne

[@spoonman5051]

You didn't do your push ups today, Mr. Wayne. Alfred asked me to find you.

[@SrMway]

Ok now no need to start crying, which you probably will do if you watch what Carl Sagan said about Hinduism.

[@spoonman5051]

@@SrMway Doesn't mean he's a hindu, lol

[@SrMway]

@@spoonman5051 Who said he is! OP said Him quoting Batman doesn't mean Batman has something to do with professional work but he did quote Batman not Tommy Wiseau in the Room. That means Batman is a much higher standard of art compared to The Room. Which means it appeals to an educated mind, and that does mean something!

[@time43200]

This quote should be popularized more and more because it can save us from WW3 but it doesn't mean to say that it should be taken as validity for the religion.

[@TheAlmost89]

its what many believers still do when they have to justify their idea of god. they start misquoting einstien and make it seem like one of the greatest ever scientific minds also believed in the existence of god

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

Ram Setu was built by the Vanara Sena - Einstein

[@spuriusscapula4829]

@@whimsicalvagabond6906 Also Einstein - "Jai Hanuman Gyan Gun Sagar"

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

@@spuriusscapula4829 - What do you mean?

[@y.muralikrishna4733]

its sad that these so called India's smartest podcasts don't acknowledge how much philosophy and philosophical things Bhagvat Geeta contains but instead they claim it sCiEnTiC

[@alpeshmittal3779]

Can you please give examples about philosophy contained in Gita?

[@swagatochatterjee7104]

At least spell correctly lol. 😂😂😂

[@blahblahanything]

@@swagatochatterjee7104 the last one word scientific was a sarcasm bro😂

[@blahblahanything]

@@alpeshmittal3779 well bhagvat geeta is one of the core book of vedanta philosophy

[@alpeshmittal3779]

​@@blahblahanything and what does it say?

[@SqrtNegativOne]

Oppenheimer actually was a devout reader of the Gita; they say that he found physics to be very clear cut and precise so the religious nystique appealed to him. However, that still doesn't prove anything. Conservative Christians in America also use examples of famous Christian scientists like Newton, Mendel, Pascal etc.

[@pauldirc..]

Yes sir i am tired of these claim , people are busy in proving all modern science in vedas and these things are fueled by some statements of schrodinger, hisenberg, i request you to gove me some gppd argument against it debunking claim that schrodinger, hisenberg, Oppenheimer developed / stole principal of quantum dynamics from our vedas I know it true that schrodinger used to admire vedanta philosophy but it not possible he derived eqn from those scripture Whenever i tried to argue any friend against anything written in vedas, he contradicts me by giving authority of these scientists Even one of my friend doing BSC in physics trying to find grand unified theory of quantum gravity in vedas

[@RR_theproahole]

Don't forget to include that he read the Gita through the lens of a westerner. There are many things in the Bhagwat Gita which are of no problem for someone who's reading it outside the influence of Indian society, like its ardent support to the Varna system and how it is divinely created (The whole concept of Karma Yoga is based on Karmavibhaga which is divinely done based on one's Guna which is the basis of one's Varna and Guna comes from birth so ultimately Varna comes from birth), a westerner can easily ignore it as narrow thinking of people of old times because he doesn't believe it's said by God, but it becomes very important when you see it in the context of Indian society and you read it as an Indian.

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

@@pauldirc.. - Don’t worry, he will grow out his hair, grow a beard, wear ochre/saffron robes and become a yogi, and give motivational talks about how the vedas can help his audience achieve success everywhere.

[@pauldirc..]

@@whimsicalvagabond6906 i think yku are roasting some KZbinr but whom ?

[@challenger539]

Vimoh, I understand we have a habit of exaggeration but for that reason if u provide Strawman Fallacy that's no acceptable. If u get butt-hurt by anything with Indic civilisation then what's the difference between self-proclaimed nationalists and self-proclaimed liberals? It's true he was nowhere close to conversion or neither were his scientific works influenced by scriptures but it is well-recorded how deep profound effect in his personality was left by the indic school of thoughts. It was so much that he started learning the pure sanskrit language itself at Berkeley in 1933 by Aurthur W. Ryder, an indologist. Not only Bhagavad Gita but also he studied other works of literature such as "Meghaduta". He later cited the Gita as one of the books that most shaped his philosophy of life.He wrote to his brother that the Gita was "very easy and quite marvelous", and called it "the most beautiful philosophical song existing in any known tongue." He later gave copies of it as presents to his friends and kept a personal, worn-out copy on the bookshelf by his desk. He even nicknamed his car Garuda,(Vahana of Vishnu). In a conversation with Science philosopher David Hawkins he concluded the hindus were far more deeper than the greeks. His interest crossed all limits that his colleague Isidor Rabi remarked that his interest over sanskrit literature also harms his attention in science. Clear texts with primary citations are available on wikipedia. So, yeah these are important . Not for pride, but the deep profound effect of one of the most important personalities of the last century as part of the study of him(hope the film portrays it well). But what we got to do? Well, of early western scientists can cause a scientific revolution with pov of reviving ancient greek scientific inquiry, why can't we do with ours? The hindus are falling since the last millennia and a half...but they have immense contributions in the past. Those could be inspiration for modern achievements.

[@TurdBoi-tf5lf]

I ain't reading allat 💀

[@waltershumer4211]

I trust The Vedas, because I imagine if I were popped into the world not knowing who I was or where I was going or what this place was. I wouldn't ask the youngest person in the room but instead the oldest. And that would be the Vedas

[@castario_]

VEDAS HAVE FLAWS...

[@rohankohli07]

i guess you never felt inspired in your life

[@vimoh]

Sure I have.

[@NextToNone1]

4:22 openhiemer was not indian or hindi speaking he suffered from mental illness he went through vast sets of book but he admire gita

[@jacobmanoharan5532]

Ur logic is not convincing bro... Scientifically this is not the only instance... Again, u couldn't say, why Robert Oppenheimer only used Verses of Bhagwat Gita and not of quran n Bible.. While during 50's Bhagwat Gita was nowhere to be found around the world and only few among westerners were knowing about Gita. Plz dont cheat ur subscribers bro...

[@vimoh]

His uttering from Gita is still not proof of anything. My point remains.

[@anamelessmonster]

He just qouted the dialouge what's so special in it? I don't understand? 😂

[@roopendrasingh1487]

​@@vimohcertainly, Oppenheimer isn't becomes authority to validate the importance of bhagavat gita. However, someone like Oppenheimer being born far away from India or hindu background atleast found something amazing and thought provoking in Gita, many Indians, they never bother to read what Gita has to offer. So its highlighting that Oppenheimer quoting Gita is not for raising the importance of Gita but to tell that someone is taking inspiration being not born in India, atleast you should give Gita some importance and then put forward your arguments for or against it. Don't be lazy to just keeping your ass on chair and shouting for evidence, do some hard work become a seeker, read Gita and bhagavat and upanishads. As far as Sanatan dharma is concerned, no person invented it, it has always been there, yes from eternity. Don't cheat yourself and others. If you really think you have rational mind, please consider presenting the fallacies of sanatan dharma quoting from scriptures and not what any common random hindu is saying about it.

[@hungrylearner9110]

People who try to get validation from religion are accepted that they don't have any power in there own and not accomplished any things which one can really count on, sadly most Indians (including me) are like that only

[@childhoodindoctrination9661]

Brilliant work 🔥

[@dead34311]

wow really ,, so amaze af

[@kuldipchaku9885]

Dear sir . Bhagat Geeta and Upanishads dont need anybody's validation.

[@TurdBoi-tf5lf]

Sure pal

[@castario_]

Just like Qur'an and Bible... Sadly

[@alpeshmittal3779]

Hello everyone, What is the good counter to the argument that bohr,tesla, schrodinger were fan of upanishads and advait Vedanta Philosophy specifically and found it compatible with quantum theory.

[@vimoh]

Compatible how? Given that people even today don't know how quantum mechanics works, how could they find it compatible with Vedanta?

[@alpeshmittal3779]

Thank you for your reply Vimoh. I have many links which claims this but I can't post here as my comment will get deleted. But few things: bohr said I go into upanishads to ask questions. 2. Schrodinger said "the team spirit and continuity of vedanta are meditated within side the team spirit and continuity of wave mechanics ". Seems like bohr, schrodinger, tesla were very impressed by vedanta philosophy. Also there is a thing that swami vivekanand inspired tesla about energy and mass interchangeability before Einstein came up with special theory of relativity. It looks like would require more than argument from authority kind refute.

[@vimoh]

@@alpeshmittal3779 Unless you can provide something more than their personal opinion, I'm afraid it's still just regular old argument from authority.

[@alpeshmittal3779]

​@Vimoh there is a site with articles: scienceandnonduality which has more detailed description of the argument in question.

[@vimoh]

@@alpeshmittal3779 Feel free to come on the live stream and present those arguments.

[@ramaraksha01]

It was a great moment - a life changing moment and in that moment he quotes the Gita Do you realize how in a great stressful moment if you think of something, it is something that you spent time on, read, understood, dwelt on? He didn't just quote something at random - he quoted from a book that he had read deeply . One of the disappointing thing about Atheists is that they fail to realize how different Hinduism is from other religions I always say if the Buddha had been born in Christian or Muslim lands, he would have gone the same way as Giordano Bruno or the Mayans - tortured and killed! His books burnt, his followers killed! There would be no Buddhism today! If the Mayans had invented Yoga instead of us Hindus, that would be lost to us because the Christian conquerors burnt ALL their books & forced Christianity on them Even today, here in the US, there are many Christians who refuse Yoga because it is Hindu! So many small religions have been crushed this way - as they say dead men tell no tales & we know nothing about these lost Buddhas! But that did not happen in Hindu India Other religions and people are not hated, not even Atheists Atheists live in fear in several countries - namely Islamic countries Jews face attacks all over the world but a Christian and Muslim media covers it up!

[@Roonlovesfish3874]

Very well put. Off-topic, can you please do a regular series of book reviews? Maybe even start a Vimoh book club.

[@thepurplebox380]

The guy thought something sounded cool, and people got so excited 🤣

[@merimarzi-yh2or]

Your pajeet can't help go belive in flying monkey

[@pauldirc..]

Yes sir i am tired of these claim , people are busy in proving all modern science in vedas and these things are fueled by some statements of schrodinger, hisenberg, i request you to gove me some gppd argument against it debunking claim that schrodinger, hisenberg, Oppenheimer developed / stole principal of quantum dynamics from our vedas I know it true that schrodinger used to admire vedanta philosophy but it not possible he derived eqn from those scripture Whenever i tried to argue any friend against anything written in vedas, he contradicts me by giving authority of these scientists Even one of my friend doing BSC in physics trying to find grand unified theory of quantum gravity in vedas

[@whykoks]

Excellent 👏👏👏

[@Skrullx273]

Idk why theists seek validation from us atheists so much especially Hindus.

[@vamshikrishna8694]

Who has asked your validation btw???

[@thesecret6019]

Nobody is seeking validation from you. So don't mislead yourself into some sort of delusion. And the reason why religious people are here is not to seek validation but to debate with this atheist who has a social platform to present it to masses

[@AntonioMiller-kw6sx]

He mentioned something which belongs to Indian culture so it's matter.

[@goddalehundibharathraj4374]

So bhagvad gita was used to normalise murders in 2 wars now!

[@ayushkatarpawar6429]

finally,someone said it. thank you for the video😅

[@vishwas.setlur]

Interesting that this is the second/third time, I am observing my comments getting deleted on your videos. Not sure if YT is messing up something or the creator thinks it's inappropriate due to any reason and deleting them.

[@namank93]

The funniest thing is when many hindus claim that nuclear bombs were already there at the time of Ramayan in the form of bows and arrows. 😅 Now I am not a nuclear physicist or know much about how such weapons work but don't we need machineries, industries and entire group of scientists in order to devise such serious technolgies? It is a serious delusional among many hindus. And your argument and the rebuttal of this logical fallacy is quite good. You can always take some example from a well known scientists who has invented some technology or transformed the world, and has quoted some text from holy books around the world. I mean Albert Einstein was much greater than Oppenheimer when it comes to scientific achievement and he also mentioned that all the organised religions are pretty stupid. He was a penthiest as I am aware of. Also if Oppenheimer was such an ardent follower or admirer of Geeta then how come he didn't practice the religion and the teachings it prescribed for all? I cannot find much evidence for the same. It is just another desperate attempt by many theists to further their religious claims

[@AI_Speaks77]

@@mr.gamerkabir8142 Bhagwat Purana=> "Krishna has stolen the Gopis' clothing while they were bathing and is shown sitting in a kadamba tree teasing the naked cowherdesses shivering in the cold water." You can look by yourself. Krishna wants gopi to be nude but saved draupadi from getting naked. Womanizer Krishna is really great example for us 😣

[@AI_Speaks77]

@@mr.gamerkabir8142 nope I have read Bhagwat Purana and you didn't. That's why you don't know when krishna made gopis nude in public place, they didn't desire him as husband. They were shivering, and plead to get their clothes back. Read 📚 it. Just for a sec, even if they desired him as husband, is it fine to make your wife nude publicaly? Do you also make your wife and moms nude in public by getting inspired by womanizer Krishna huh?

[@spuriusscapula4829]

@@mr.gamerkabir8142 Ask the average temple-going Hindu about "Advaita Vedanta".

[@dutchphysicist]

I am a white man, brought up in Christianity, lost my way, and trying to find my way back. My quest has nothing to do with Hinduism, or Islam, or Christianity. I just feel like we all are looking for the exact same thing - What are we here for, what are we supposed to do (as opposite to the question "what is the meaning of it all"?) My current take on this, is that we are supposed to better ourselves by providing help to others. In the end... are we not all the same person?

[@Playerone1287]

Lol your English indicates that you're an Indian 😂

[@saikishanjena9778]

There is no need for religion to be a good or better person. If you really want to be a good person without religion then humanist philosophy is the best thing ever. These religions and blind followers only need validation for their religion by hook or crook . But they don't know that science and religion are two different things. Me as an atheist living my every moment without religion no need to believe in anything, no hope for miracles, not a deluded person only living the life with my best. Sadness and happiness is the part of life these will come and go and will teach us lessons of life and make us better humans to approach our next day in another way.

[@InsertYTHandleHere]

​@@saikishanjena9778 look, there is nothing outside of religion. What you believe is a religion too. Religion basically can be described as a set of beliefs. An individual cannot exist without beliefs. And your beliefs shape your actions. It is impossible that you don't believe in anything and just because you spawned outta nowhere.

[@saikishanjena9778]

@@InsertYTHandleHere there is a difference between following and believing you fool. Blind beliefs can make you so extreme that you will be proud of doing anything unethical which is absolutely trash for this modern society. Humanist Philosophy and ethics are observations of reality which can shape us to be a good human. If I can't come anywhere then god also can't come from anywhere conscious species always comes from anywhere if this is then we can also say this for the universe also come from nowhere if God can come from nowhere. If we don't find some answers then people make a tag that it is done by god but when we find that answer then people go to some other things to claim their beliefs. it is natural for a human to ask questions every thing if he doesn't get answers then people will tell him that there is god so obviously he will believe that.

[@saikishanjena9778]

@@InsertYTHandleHere and yes atheism is not a religion it is denying the higher power which has no evidence

[@Neeraj-cu8bo]

Finally someone said it. Thank you Vimoh.

[@pauldirc..]

Sir you are doing amazing work I request you to make video on debunking claim that schrodinger, hisenberg, Oppenheimer developed / stole principal of quantum dynamics from our vedas I know it true that schrodinger used to admire vedanta philosophy but it not possible he derived eqn from those scripture

[@kalyanimookherji8834]

Love it how you untangle the knots and actually identify the kinds of logical fallacies operating.

[@rach101]

Please make a video on Bageshwar Dham. I get so angry seeing that crook all the time and their idiot devotees.

[@prajwalavhad7059]

Sir literally predicted the future 😅

[@adidevchafle]

when people uses science to validate religion/god they are confirming that religion is inferior to science 🙄

[@Zeal_Zone_Era]

All about mindset, I see exactly oppositely.. Those who were born in christain Or in any other religion following family, they took time to read our sacred book and admires the holiness.. That means the book is helpful to the whole world.. See in this way, I guess you will get lighten up!

[@sayanchakraborty1]

I think openheimer’s quote is looked at by people validating in encient scriptures philosophical value exists, hinduism has no battle with atheism in my opinion and there is no reason for atheists to feel standing on the wrong side when hindus try to validate the theology. They do it because it surprises them how foreigners in west ( including me) continues to be fascinated by the knowledge of encient hindu texts. It amazes the mankind repeatedly. Yet it is very little studied because it is not a mandate.

[@Vor567tez]

What is he validating? That Lord Krishna agree with mass murdering over ego and superiority complex?

[@sunilsurginath]

@@Vor567tez no that mass murdering his cousins , uncles and other family members would lead to the establishment of peace and prosperity for the lakhs of innocent in his kingdom , and if you had read the text and some thinking power maybe you would have understood

[@Vor567tez]

@@sunilsurginath And why did he asked to kill them? To colonisation the whole planet?

[@AI_Speaks77]

@@sunilsurginath Bhagwat Purana=> "Krishna has stolen the Gopis' clothing while they were bathing and is shown sitting in a kadamba tree teasing the naked cowherdesses shivering in the cold water." You can look by yourself. Krishna wants gopi to be nude but saved draupadi from getting naked. Womanizer Krishna is really great example for us 😣.

[@spuriusscapula4829]

@@AI_Speaks77 In the end it's just a fictional character. End of.

[@sumanchatterjee2480]

Exactly a one point in this video stands in which context he was saying it he feared the monster he created and the quote came into his mind which he obviously read it doesn't validate anything or decrease the importance of anything the thing is I have conversations with scientists researchers and one thing is common between them that they all love reading the books taking the knowledge it's just there behaviour for knowing the unknown some of them probably are reading modern day writings and quote ' I am batman ' while planting another corona virus attack it doesn't mean he believed in batman it was the guy reading batman and the line caught his attention

[@bhupatvarma9592]

All are regions but Hinduism only dharma dont compare dharma and religions

[@nortanleisure1399]

This guy speaks as though he was a friend of Oppenheimer 🤣🤣! Whatever might be the argument Mr Ghulam, Oppenheimer quoted that, which potentially means he could have read the book by his choice & intrest ! I know u will not accept this argument, because ur mind is indoctrinated by Ghulami mindset !

[@vimoh]

Not saying he didn't read it. Saying it doesn't matter that he read it. It only matters to those who are insecure about their culture and need validation from a Westerner. That's all.

[@Sam-1972]

Vimoh, I agree with you that we shouldn't care about validation from the west. But unfortunately we are so colonial in our minds, that we still need that validation. In the 80s and 90s and till the early 2000s yoga was not an accepted thing in main stream. You would be belittled if you said you had a yoga class in the morning. But only when the west accepted it then it really flew in India. Prince Charles needed to come and endorse the Mumbai dabballawalas ... and now the dabbawallas are giving lectures on six sigma processes. All said and done the white man made hindus ashamed, self loathing and deracinated from their culture. I think they did an fabulous job!! This continues to be the trend ... it makes us feel progressive. But that's the privilege a hindu enjoys I guess. The west has defined what is Morden and civilized. Eating with hands might not be considered civilized for example. The words - morden and civilised have a colonial and western connotation. The west has set the standards for us and it is unfortunately embedded in us. Yes, we do still need that validation unless we feel decent amount of pride in our own culture and heritage. If the Whiteman starts appreciating Sanskrit, so will we ... because we are all lord Macaulay products ... I wish we could get rid of this need for validation like you are saying, but chief it's going to take a few generations. You as an individual might not need it but others might feel the need. Whiteman can only bring back our sense of pride in us and make us realize what we have ... in my humble opinion.

[@spuriusscapula4829]

You are the Ghulam ironically. Yourselves seek western validation and call rationalists "ghulams".

[@pranayghosh4413]

There's a difference between between acknowledgement and validation 😭 And why are you generalizing?

[@kuldipchaku9885]

I request u to first learn Sanskrit,then read the Upnishad before commenting.

[@vimoh]

Have you read the Upanishads in Sanskrit?

[@iamdead8781]

@@vimoh but he isn't giving gyaan about it does he?

[@vimoh]

Then how does he know I need to read it?

[@alpeshmittal3779]

Read history of Anglo Hindu law and Anglo Islamic laws. British consulted Hindu pundits and Muslim clerics to make laws according to their religious beliefs since 1772. Max muller hired hindu pundits for translation work. He was himself interested in upanishads. Even swami vivekanand praised max muller as expert in upanishads and praised his work. This lost in translation fallacy does stand chance.

[@AI_Speaks77]

@@alpeshmittal3779 Bhagwat Purana=> "Krishna has stolen the Gopis' clothing while they were bathing and is shown sitting in a kadamba tree teasing the naked cowherdesses shivering in the cold water." You can look by yourself. Krishna wants gopi to be nude but saved draupadi from getting naked. Womanizer Krishna is really great example for us 😣

[@koushikghosh2615]

Hello Mr. Vimoh, your explanations are very good and factual. Also I have seen that you talk about hustle culture and motivational propaganda spread by new age gurus. Here one thing I have observed that Indian parents don't question the education system and don't question the government also because there is 2 fundamental reason: religion and hustle culture. Why am I talking about education system because Indian parents have a mindset that if anyone do just hard work they can be successful and when they see that some people are becoming successful from very poor background(people or any student who claims that he comes from a poor background and some of them don't have a proper house to live)then why not others can be successful just by hustling?

[@koushikghosh2615]

Even when people see that anyone who comes from very poor background has cracked any competitive exam their hustle culture mindset get charged up and they don't necessarily ask any question to the system. Somehow I have seen that hustle culture also charge up the religious, non questioning mindset.

[@nerf2752]

Who asked ?

[@TurdBoi-tf5lf]

I did

[@rohittekchandani5720]

Definitely not you! I don't even think that you contain that level of intellect to even ask for such things.

[@Lilith_2002]

It is normal to relate many things mentioned in old books and scriptures but that doesn't become the truth.

[@moongrass217]

He actually did not say that. He said like thousand suns........

[@SOV4-xy1zl]

Deep down i knew it but wasn't sure.

[@akankshasolanki5308]

I agree with vimoh's so what. What if Seth Andrews make videos or publish something on agreeing some ideas of vimoh, so then will vimoh say "so what " and don't give s* about seth or vimoh will make another video or publish something to thanks seth.

[@fleshpuppet2679]

A controlled derange man who is a physicist, the Japanese paid a price for being cruel to their fellow mankind.

[@vimoh]

Please don't justify use of nuclear weapons against humans.

[@sahasrakiran]

Its either you didn't understand properly why a great scientist like him quoted Gita or you are just a jealous Atheist 😂

[@vimoh]

You either didn't understand the video or you are just a moron religionist. 🤣

[@cosmicwarriorx1]

Nuclear Peace ✌️🕊️ 💥

[@MrX-il2jt]

You have no stance , the video don't make sense

[@ronydsouza7596]

how did you do the subs??

[@vimoh]

Descript.

[@abhinaviconic2555]

Hit the nail on head, dude I hope every one who claims oppenheimmer's words listened and watched your video.

[@blackbuddhaa]

Oppenhimers 2nd fav book is Gita. He took moral lessons from the Gita and it also helped him with his depression and morality. Please read the book American Prometheus. Also he was not white but Jew. You should study more before making videos like this and assuming if he was a 'admirer'. He even named his car Garuda. No Hindu claims he is Hindu.

[@vimoh]

My question remains - so what?

[@blackbuddhaa]

@@vimoh so what? Oppenhimer was a brilliant scientist who did change the course of history, he wasn't just some random 'white guy'. The bombs did bring world peace in someway. He was at the forefront of the greatest war in human history and the Gita did help him to draw moral values and he did see him as Arjuna in the battle. Obviously his views shouldn't be used to validate a religion I agree to that but I think in oppenhimers case as a Hindu he inspires me to study gita and find what made him read it and admire it. I know so many (most) Hindus have not even read Gita and Gita is not some magical book, its a very practical book about duty that anyone should read. I also acknowledge that admiring your own religion without studying it and understanding and not criticizing it is peak ignorance and reason for violence we see in todays world.

[@vimoh]

Whole lot of assumptions there little boy. No evidence to say he worked on thr bomb BECAUSE of the Gita. Or to say he drew moral values from it. Or to say he saw himself as Arjuna. I fet the need to find validation for your native culture from White saviours but this is just desperate. Grow up.

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

@@blackbuddhaa - So he saw himself as Arjuna, and made a bomb to kill the Japanese? But Arjuna killed his cousins. Which Gita did he read?

[@blackbuddhaa]

@@whimsicalvagabond6906 what??????? He was building the bomb to fight Nazis. He could related to Arjunas story because of the moral dilemma Arjuna faces, weather to fight or not and same does Oppenheimer. I don't think you have any understanding of Gita or Oppenheimer so please educated yourself before commenting.

[@abhijeetbhagat100]

You should have more subs

[@mukeshrawat1040]

Sorry brother but i am not agree with you because some time you have to become a devil to kill devil .

[@vimoh]

And then who kills you by becoming a devil? And who kills them? How does it end?

[@mukeshrawat1040]

@@vimoh because you do not want see other side of reality . If hydrogen bomb ware not invented than world war 2 wouldn't be stopped

[@AI_Speaks77]

Bhagwat Purana=> "Krishna has stolen the Gopis' clothing while they were bathing and is shown sitting in a kadamba tree teasing the naked cowherdesses shivering in the cold water." You can look by yourself. Krishna wants gopi to be nude but saved draupadi from getting naked. Womanizer Krishna is really great example for us 😣

[@JSR1551]

Tu indian hai kya wo bata nahi thi uske liye bhi counter answer dega

[@vedicarya7]

We know that , so?

[@vimoh]

so has been answered in the video

[@vedicarya7]

@@vimoh answer my other comment essay writer kg guy

[@vimoh]

Feel free to come on my live stream tonight at 8 pm and ask face to face on screen. Channel link of Vimoh Live on main page of this channel. See you then.

[@AI_Speaks77]

@@vedicarya7 Bhagwat Purana=> "Krishna has stolen the Gopis' clothing while they were bathing and is shown sitting in a kadamba tree teasing the naked cowherdesses shivering in the cold water." You can look by yourself. Krishna wants gopi to be nude but saved draupadi from getting naked. Womanizer Krishna is really great example for us 😣

[@3C273]

Just a jealous Christian

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

Christian? I am disappointed in you my man. You seem to be a newly minted chaddi. The right term for Christian is Rice Bag. Repeat after me, slowly, R I C E B A G. Your chaddi friends will be proud of the progress you have made. Learning new words. Run along to the Ayurveda shop and sell some bottled bovine micturate by claiming it will cure cancer. And don’t forget the coronil pills.

[@AI_Speaks77]

Bhagwat Purana=> "Krishna has stolen the Gopis' clothing while they were bathing and is shown sitting in a kadamba tree teasing the naked cowherdesses shivering in the cold water." You can look by yourself. Krishna wants gopi to be nude but saved draupadi from getting naked. Womanizer Krishna is really great example for us 😣

[@3C273]

@@AI_Speaks77 nope, Jesus rightfully crucified by the Romans for pimping his wife and mom by the same name is the ideal

[@thephilosophicalnerd]

0:48 Shouldn't this outrage Hindus? Oppenheimer literally claimed to be Krishna when he supposedly said that "I have become death"... which is what Krishna said.... he is essentially equating himself with God 😅😂