Origins Of "Palestine"

[@mikehilkins1847]

Its about time someone has balls to say the truth

[@terrybaker8156]

It’s about time someone told the truth and said that I want his balls in my mouth

[@agentlibra5703]

@@1moneyking lol.

[@BoottheHost]

It may be true but I and 15 million others identify as palestinian because we lived in the land for centuries (in a region called palestine). So what should we identify as then?

[@GideonDavis]

Suhayb Yousef Arabs

[@BoottheHost]

@@GideonDavis half of us are probably not even arab (genetically) and other half hasnt seen mecca in 1000 years (figuratively speaking). No where else is our home, period

[@max11well001]

I’m nether Jewish nor Arab but this is still interesting.

[@Crackz0r94]

i wish more people had a brain and the will to explore the truth and whats actually happening here and in the past. if you would ask the typical brainwashed person who hates israel or defends terrorism or thinks the arabs are the victims what is palestine he'd prob be like "uhh it was a palestinian state that was stolen by the jews 70 years ago" omegalul

[@miriinedj264]

@@Crackz0r94 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@stover14]

This is nonsense, this man claimed that Palestine is a hebrew word hahahaha what an idiot.

[@GoogooX]

@@stover14 You can check the origin of this name and validate what he says

[@stover14]

@@GoogooX okay, I just did verify it ( I didn't really need to as I don't get my history from KZbin videos I actually read) The term "Palestine" first appeared in the 5th century BC when the ancient Greek historian Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" between Phoenicia and Egypt in The Histories. How are you even disputing this? It's hilarious to me when people correct someone when they're wrong themselves haha stop watching Jooish propoganda

[@Mr9mann]

Kinda funny Palestinians insist to be "natives" to the land yet unironically identify themselves with a term that literally means "invaders". And that word is actually Hebrew too *smh*

[@dtownblastinsalvi62]

The same with Native Americans and Latinos they take the name of the invaders because they were forced to. Making fun of a people for using a name that they were forced to is pretty dumb. Jews are native there but they left because they had to and the Palestinians took the name because they had to are you dumb it’s minorities just fighting minorities because the enemy has made them fight for years it’s sad honestly who gives a fuck about the name just embrace their own brothers their own blood. I’m Latino Native American my people get killed every year but we don’t even have a country of our own but yet here are some idiots killing their own over a name self extermination at its finest.

[@Mr9mann]

No one forced them to use the Palestinian moniker, moreover they denounced it at first. They only embraced it as a political tool since the land was called Palestine in the times the Jews were forced out of the land and they use it as means of propaganda for those who don't know history... which is clearly the majority of people. I don't know the history of all NA tribes so I won't pretend to know to how your identity was formed. But there isn't some monolith called minorities, it's a lie created by people that seek power through this consolidation. Do you really think Muslims and LGBT people share the expirience? And just because Muslims are minorities in the West doesn't change the fact they are majority in ME. And let me tell you a secret, the way they treat minorities in there makes the West look like paradise.

[@michaellamont2605]

And the kings were??? And the currency was?? I love pointing out the holes in פלשתים

[@deficrypto1234]

What people identify themselves doesn't change the fact of whether they are indigenous. Nigeria's flag, country and area was named by the British. It doesn't change the fact that their was an indigenous population that was colonised.

[@Mr9mann]

@@deficrypto1234 how can Arabs be indigenous to the land still associated with Jewish titles like Someria and Judea aka West Bank or Jerusalem, yet another Hebrew word, when Arabs come from Arabia and only got to this land through Caliphate which is Muslim crusade aka Imperialism. They are as native to the land as white or black Americans are to America ...

[@raseel7364]

hey, thank you for this, I'm an arab and I've always known the truth.

[@عمرالمختار-ث2م]

Same here

[@eternalhistory4706]

@@عمرالمختار-ث2م Then you're both educated Arabs

[@AhmadAltibi]

So tell me please your truth?? I am a Palestinian and I would like to know about my history??

[@عمرالمختار-ث2م]

@@AhmadAltibi You are absolutely a living person that has every right to live and you have every right to call yourself a Palestinian. If you want history of the word Palestine and of the arabic use of this word, it's in the video.

[@LeagueofLore-z3w]

@@عمرالمختار-ث2م The term "Palestine" first appeared in the 5th century BC when the ancient Greek historian Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" between Phoenicia and Egypt in The Histories en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_name_%22Palestine%22#:~:text=The%20term%20%22Palestine%22%20first%20appeared,and%20Egypt%20in%20The%20Histories. dosnt change the fact that we where the original owners of these lands my friend and i can assure you these lands where owned by my grandfathers not some jew i even know there names israel was created by great Britain they where given the choice to choose either palestine or argentina and one more place i dont remember even the torah is rewritten today ,go and read the pentateuch(real books) which are the first 5 hebrew books of moses (jerusalem was never mentioned in them) todays torah is rewritten based on specific individual intrests you can argue about that but in the end u cant argue about taking someones house or land because before 2000 years ago a jew lived in it

[@tofujelly]

The Truth Never Changes.

[@ourstrugglemadeusstronger7403]

E Pearson yes yes the history of the Jews has soon because Zionist killers of the children just like pharaoh did with the Jews so yes history has changed!

[@tofujelly]

@@ourstrugglemadeusstronger7403 that's why Palestinian population has increased exponentially in the past 50 yrs. Keep drinking the kool aid

[@pazhadad9658]

@@1moneyking come on , stop be dum ass bitch , stop fake the history , fucking liar , just Watch the video and shut up.

[@pazhadad9658]

@@tofujelly They are afraid of the truth, love you girl ❤️🇮🇱

[@pazhadad9658]

@@ourstrugglemadeusstronger7403 stop lie bitch

[@BrianGreco]

I came here expecting to not like your channel. You’re one of the more well spoken and educated young people I’ve seen in a while. So I’m listening and at least learning your side.

[@Rockandrollgeerage]

He is the best at explaining the facts without emotion. Unfortunately the far left university types like to change history

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@natanbirnbaum2576]

How about you go mind your own business, there is no side for you to chose. Go drink a vegan gluten-free latte and watch some Marvel movies.

[@i_hate_this_world]

Do be aware that what he is saying is bigoted and hateful. He is saying things confidently and calmly, but the words themselves (eg. saying that the word Palestine was given by Jews and was just an insult) feeds an ugly sense of entitlement in anyone with supremacist beliefs. He is portraying his theories as fact when they are very far from them. There are actually facts from well-regarded publications and people that disprove his versions which makes me more inclined to think that this isn't just a misguided take on information, but a deliberately hateful speech.

[@Rockandrollgeerage]

@@i_hate_this_world he speaks the truth!!!!!!

[@elessar2777]

A shame there isn't an hebrew version of this video. I wanna show it to my classmates

[@abdelhakwinston6200]

well it's too bad ur freinds a bunch of uneducated dumb fucks

[@BrunoSantos-gi1sr]

@@abdelhakwinston6200 Well that's kind of degenerate for you to say.

[@emiliogereros7112]

@@abdelhakwinston6200 bet you have some friends like that buddy

[@svsv123]

A shame thay you are so lazy to translate into Hebrew for your classmates

[@fredsavage7380]

@@abdelhakwinston6200 pray for Ysrael🇮🇱

[@daleiverson6822]

Hi Rudy, yesterday without seeing this after watching one of your other videos, I looked for something concerning the origins of the Palestinians. It's refreshing to hear a channel that defends the truth about Israel rather than blaming it for everything that's wrong in the Middle East. I grew up in Christian churches, and I never went along with the anti-Israel bandwagon and I like to speak for the truth/factual accounts and moral values, so I'm interested in knowing where I can learn about the history and your preferred news and opinion sources concerning Israel and its struggles with other countries. Thank you for this channel.

[@i_hate_this_world]

What Christian churches went along with any anti-israel bandwagon? The comments in this video are truly bizarre

[@daleiverson6822]

@@i_hate_this_world I definitely didn't mean to suggest that the Christian churches I grew up in were anti-Israel.

[@northwind8821]

Rudy is a liar. Most of what he said was lies and not even real history.

[@kidspecial1764]

About time someone makes an informative video about this

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@axela4606]

Informative? The man fails to even mention 1200 years of Palestinian history including The seljuiks, ottomans, rashuidins and more

[@kidspecial1764]

@@axela4606 go and have a cry you wombat

[@Hail_Sagan]

This is the best explanation regarding the origin of the word "Palestine" that I've ever heard.

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@i_hate_this_world]

It's also not true. I can't understand why people are thinking that because this man talks with confidence and calm that he is trustworthy, when the words that come out are so obviously bigoted and from a place of disdain.

[@Hail_Sagan]

@@i_hate_this_world If you claim his explanation is not true, then explain why. Otherwise your claim is pointless.

[@sitiyati6515]

@@Hail_Sagan @אטילה ורס sorry for interrupt.The word philistine (plistim in Hebrew) had mentioned more than 30 times in Old Testament of Bible. If believe all of u know bible write in Hebrew. Then the philistine ancient found actually are Canaanite. The canaanite that being match DNA by archeologist at West Jordan, Beirut and North Israel is same in bronze and iron age. This is reported by National Geography research. Not by religion book claim. So its prove that canaanite that mentioned in bible its true. On 2019 national geographic report that canaanite DNA found in Jews and palestinian that call arab by your people. On the same research they found more than 50% palestinian decent is no from arab but from Lavant, syria, egypt and Jordan. They found palestinian had match DNA with canaanite research by American University Beirut. But suprissing most Jewis DNA match to Canaanite nit Jews. Probably inter-marriage. The most amazing is Jews and palestinian only had around 70% match. More 90% match to Canaanite is Lebanese and lavant. This research and proven DNA reported in National Geography and registered Journal. So i think with ur ideology mean Lebanese and Lavant can come back in future claim their land too there. So learn to share my lovely Israel people. I was still under my research and collecting as much research reference by truly source. I believe Palestinian had truly right on that land.

[@wngdhssr]

@@i_hate_this_world I don't just trust someone if they're calm, someone could be shouting aggressively but if what their saying is based in fact (I do my own research to fact-check) then I have no problem with it. This dude is one of the very few people getting it right, y'all being played by bigots of the the past. Many different groups of people have hated jews for one reason or another.

[@gumarogram8559]

You’re amazing!! Thank you!! Please write a book!! No one has been able to expose history like this!!

[@hagitaleinikov8643]

Great idea! 🙂 he should write a book

[@phillipstraghalis]

Dear cousin. It goes even further than that goes back to Abraham. Everybody in the world is occupied Palestine and the Palestinians since then we are both from the same father Abraham. So we are actually Canaanites. That’s the irony of this whole thing is to very similar people fighting against each other. It has gone on for too long.

[@dannybrown5889]

Israel by Noa Tishby

[@skontheroad]

​@@dannybrown5889 Noa Tishby is a HUGE anti-semite! Be honest--she is Ant -Israel! And she would even say so herself

[@m.barsan7875]

The Koran in 5:20-21 says that Allah gave the Holy Land (Israel) to the Jews. How is it that Muslims don't know this?

[@btbingo]

They know but its inconvenient to admit.

[@btbingo]

@@bamssudardjo2572 when you read something whose meaning escapes you then you are spouting drivel and tripe. Of course this is ubiquitous in religion.

[@btbingo]

@@bamssudardjo2572 strangely enough when Christians translate the phrase into Hebrew it is rendered as God is Big.

[@Saimashafaque]

Jews were chosen people. Still they did crucify prophets and started taking ribah . Yet it belongs to Israelites but it is not exclusively for them. They belongs to Holi land with given conditions. If you don’t follow the conditions you won’t get ever. Please let me know if you want to know the conditions

[@btbingo]

@@Saimashafaque wrong. The Romans crucified him assuming he even existed. Who lied to you? Did you waste time reading the Koran?

[@Unknown-ow1ts]

My history teacher always tell us that if we want to learn *true* history we should learn it from neutral person

[@mahawk12]

For real

[@simko8665]

Which means a blind and deaf person.

[@user-ys8vi9ek9y]

Not really. Well maybe just not in this case. A forgiener can't describe thousands upon thousands of rockets that are fired in Israel and what is going on in Israel right know

[@franciscofalabella4644]

Neutral? The guy is a Zionist jew lmao

[@emanuelyasheav1040]

Or create a time machine and go back in time The problem with neutral person is not having any idea what happened because that is doesn't related to them Example: would you teach about China-Japan history if you know that? How would both nations feel when someone who wasn't born in their culture will represent their history not 100% accurately?

[@deanbianchi9236]

may we all live and smoke weed together in peace, LOVE IS THE ANSWER! 🇮🇱❤🇵🇸

[@asalamabyebye]

Sudani flag homie

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@MrHRanjha]

@@yansideabacoa6257 dope comment but I think you pressed the wrong button while commenting. This has come up as a reply to a comment about israelis and Palestinians smoking weed together haha You should post this again so it hopefully gets likes and seen by more!

[@nobody8204]

😂

[@motina10]

One correction here, the Philistine did survive David as a group around the Pentapolis. The displacement of the Philistines didn't occur till the Assyrians, who would do the same to the Israelites/Samaritans and vassalize Judea. Excluding the early Arab invaders, by the time of the Crusades the land was not known as Palestine. It was known as Syrian, just like under the Ottomans. While there were many attempts of create smaller kingdoms within the Ottoman Levant, outside of Syria, the only identifiable group trying to gain an identity during this time were the Maronite Christians where the modern state of Lebanon is from, although the French made it larger, causing a much smaller Maronite population. There was no Palestine, there was no Jordan. There was a Kindgom of Jerusalem. The land of Palestine is is name kept alive by Christians and the west. They called the land Palestine during the crusades, not the Arabs. This is why you have people in the west refer to Judea at the time of Jesus as Palestine at the time of Jesus. They associate a name to the land that was not called that until a 100 years after the death of Jesus. And while the Hebrew definition of Palestine/Philistine is different, but it looks like the Latin Palestine is related to the Greek word pelasgian, so not only was it an insult to Jews, it was a greco-roman claim to the land. They knew the Philistines were ancient Greeks.

[@manawa-2872]

I hope INDONESIANS can learn from this video. So many hypocrites in my country. I hope their eyes will open and understand that ISRAEL is real. Love you Israel from Indonesian Jew.

[@Hchris101]

Indonesia 🇮🇩 tasty food

[@waheedtahan2428]

Rudy love your videos and the work that you do. Keep up the good work.

[@yenerbayar]

The Ottomans did not use the word "Palestine" it is a British invention. In the Ottoman administrative system, those places were called the Saida Eyalet. Quds, Syria, Lebanon were also used as official province names but the Ottomans have never used the word Palestine to name any place on the earth.

[@yenerbayar]

@@user-pi4su6je8p The Ottoman did not use the word for centuries, other than history books there was no Palestine at all.

[@yenerbayar]

@@user-pi4su6je8p The Ottomans did not use the word for centuries, other than history books there was no Palestine at all. We have many petitions in the Ottoman archives that were written by western visitors and travellers who ask permission; even in these petitions in French Italian German or English the petitioners or their ambassadors mention the word Palestine but while translating them into Turkish the Ottomans replace the word with Saida, Quds etc. This shows how they were decided to not use the word Palestine. Probably it was sounding Jewish to their ears. I don't know the exact reason why they avoided this word but obviously, they avoided it.

[@yenerbayar]

@@user-pi4su6je8p Dear HF, I just corrected the video I have no hidden agenda. Thank you. The number of Jews was not high because the Ottomans did not give residence permits to them. Otherwise, there were always many Jews who are very willing to migrate to Jerusalem, but the government did not let them do. Nowadays the Turkish government is proud of this policy.

[@yenerbayar]

@@user-pi4su6je8p Dear HF why do attack me insistently in such an aggressive manner with a fake user name? Now you did accept that the Ottomans did not allow the Jews to migrate to Israel. But you continue to accuse me of unnecessary things. My comment was that the Ottomans did not use the word Palestine, and it seems that you had already known this fact but you pretended that you don't know it only to attack me. Why can't you just accept the truth? This is your problem, not mine. I don't want to think that you assume that before 1882, it was free to settle in any city of the Ottoman Empire (let alone Jerusalem). So I guess you can't be that ignorant, again, you're after another fraud. However, keeping my wishful thinking still, I want you to know that this is never the case. Ottoman settlement policy did not allow the Jewish population to increase in any city (an exception can be the ones in Greece). And you can be absolutely sure that the Jewish population did not increase in and around Jerusalem only as a result of the Ottoman government's policy. It was a deliberate limitation. This was even true for the Christians. So please stop abusing my time and good intention.

[@yenerbayar]

@@user-pi4su6je8p because you did not watch the video. I just corrected a mistake there but you cannot understand it. There is no place name "Palestine" in the Ottoman Empire but in the video, they argue that the Ottomans used it, that is all. Why do you react so aggressively? It is extremely important to know this fact to understand how the British introduced this country name after the first world war. The Arabs were not sovereign before the great war. Besides, if they were sovereign, they would not have given this name to their country.

[@ezrapirk9173]

Rudy I watched many of your Videos. You are doing such great job. I am really glad there are people Like you out there sharing the Knowlede and being active and bringing change. and I am so tired of all that hate and craziness people project on each other its exhausting. I wish you all the best and lets hope the World will calm down again and people will Make a Step towards each other more again.

[@yakigesher-zion7289]

1:59 you ignored the fact that the word Palestine is also mentioned in many Classical Greek sources

[@RudyRochman]

Yea from the Philistines, not Arabs that now call themselves Palestinian.

[@yakigesher-zion7289]

Rudy Rochman yes, but even so, it gives in opportunity for people to try to discredit by saying that the Greeks mentioned the philistines. Writers such as Herodotus

[@RudyRochman]

@@yakigesher-zion7289 Yes the Philistines, which are also mentioned many times in historical scriptures by the Jews. This population has nothing to do with the Arabs of today that identify as "Palestinian".

[@yakigesher-zion7289]

Rudy Rochman even then one should still acknowledge that it was mentioned. There are actually a lot of interesting theories of the origin of the name “Palestine” one being that it is the Greek translation of “Israel” as “Palaistis” means “wrestler” as Israel means “wrestled with god”. The Greeks also used the word Palestine to refer to a larger area of Eretz Yisrael

[@LC-gt3ku]

@@yakigesher-zion7289 Israel means here dwells god

[@laughingmyhijaboff]

Your argument is such a far reach. You keep saying it was called mandate of.. region of.. area of... then say Palestine and just because the word COUNTRY was not used "according to you" does not mean it doesnt exist. You can't justify the creation of Israel with trying to restore an injustice that happened THOUSANDS of years ago. That is way far back, without mentioning all the empire takeovers that happened after that and that included other areas around Palestine such as Lebanon, Syria Iraq, etc... Would you then argue that these countries don't exist because they weren't one society speaking one language?? And what about BEFORE Judea? Before the founding of Judaism? No one lived there? That video as a whole was a ridiculous to justify the legitimacy of Israel who today is an ethostate that treats its non-jew citizens as second class citizens and is willing to give full citizenship to people from anywhere in the world if they have converted to Judaism.

[@ffff-ll5is]

You forgot to mention that there are Arb Israelis that they are the citizens of Israel, with Israeli IDs.

[@hatasakuta8012]

@@ffff-ll5is so?

[@happydillpickle]

They would complain equally if there was no such thing as a convert: let's just be realistic about that...

[@carnivorewitch]

Why can’t you people just get it in your head that the Jews came back to decolonize their own ancestral lands? The Arabs even fought them for it and LOST that’s how the game is played.

[@AntonAdelson]

Spread the truth! Truth shall set us free!

[@ourstrugglemadeusstronger7403]

Anton Adelson the truth you don’t even be told the truth as kids like Santa Claus is coming down the chimney on 24th December. The land belongs to the holy peaceful people not Zionist!!!

[@joane.k3567]

Set you free from what huh. You're not trapped in your country and watching people getting killed every day are you?

[@ourstrugglemadeusstronger7403]

Joane. K my people are getting killed every day by Zionist you don’t even spare the young children so yes you are the new pharaoh. Do you think there won’t be another Moses that will rise again and free my people from your high walls and water cuts guns and nuks yes there’s one he is coming soon He will stand against your false messiah the anti christ!!!

[@joane.k3567]

@@ourstrugglemadeusstronger7403 if you're talking about palistine then everything you said is true if you weren't then everything you said was false

[@ourstrugglemadeusstronger7403]

I’m talking about the Zionist Jews even though they are not real Jews have you ever read the Old Testament and tried seeking the truth??

[@nicolasfeduccia9573]

That was so good, Rudy. You would make an amazing statesman. It’s Shabbot where I am in a few hours so you’re probably in it right now but want to wish you a belated Shabbat Shalom.

[@etamlak8199]

Shabbat not shabbot...

[@nicolasfeduccia9573]

@@etamlak8199 My apologies. Ethnically Jewish and am learning now. My parents tried but didn’t listen I get Shabbos Shalom and Shabbat Shalom confused Again, my apologies and thanks for pointing it out to me or I won’t learn. Peace

[@etamlak8199]

@@nicolasfeduccia9573 You most likeky confused it with Shabbes, the yiddish word for it, used by some haredi communities cause they believe they should not speak hebrew outside of prayers... Another rabbit hole... Anyway.

[@gabrielnunez7371]

The fact that you said that Palestine had no national identity prior back when the Ottomans controlled it is so wrong. Mufti Khayr al-Din al-Ramli literally wrote in legal documents back in 1670 saying "our country of Filastin". Palestine was not its own country but an Ottoman military district.

[@Doxansq]

yes and if you say that then you have Israel as well and Judea in the same region

[@sitiyati6515]

Doesn't Israel in Filastin?

[@josiestephens1671]

One of the best and most informative videos I've seen on this topic. Thank you for this.

[@HankD13]

I have been alive long enough to remember (yep, I'm old) when the problem was Arab vs Israeli. Palestinians (people who lived in the area of Palestine, Arabs, Jews, Christians, whoever) came into the fore in the 60's with the failure of Arab armies to defeat Israel. That struck me then as probably a much more successful tactic. In 1977 a PLO spokesman said it publicly - The Palestinian "people" do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means of continuing the struggle against Israel and our Arab unity. I have always wondered why the incredibly wealthy Gulf states or Saudis do not solve the Palestinian problem. They could build them cities in the desert and make them bloom. Makes me think they prefer them being where they are. Only a thought.

[@rosana9577]

"The palestinian problem". That is disgusting. You want to displace people, Just like the romans did to jews. It is amazing how history repeats itself, now with a different people.

[@Khaled91]

Palestine as an "Arab" or "Muslim" entity in our hearts and minds is a relatively new concept...Nowhere in the Quran or the authentic Hadith does it mention Palestine or the Arabic word "فلسطين". There is mention of the Levant/Sham region...There is mention of the people of the Levant...There is mention of Al-Quds/Jerusalem and the blessings of the city and the land around Al-Quds. There is mention of the blessings of praying in Al-Quds... But there is no mention of the fake "Palestine". The Romans named it Palestine! Then when the Romans converted to Christianity, it ended up being a western Christian name for the Holy land. When the Muslims ruled it that name was never used! Then when the British controlled it once the Ottoman Empire collapsed they brought that name back. When the Muslims ruled it they didn't call it "Palestine". If you look at old Ottoman Turk maps of the region, there is no mention of "Palestine"... It's a lie! Palestine as an Arab entity grew during World Wars 1&2 along with the growth of the Pan-Arabism ideology...Pan-Arabism was the tree and Palestine was just a small branch... The tree fell and Pan-Arabism died. Yet people are still holding on to that small branch when there are far important matters at hand.

[@doronfurman1216]

كل الاحترام. لا يمكنك وضعه بشكل أفضل.

[@thedropoutfarmer3128]

You know nothing. Before Moses left egypt the region where Jerusalem located qas called Canaan. When Israelites recieve mandate from their God it was called promise land for them by God. After 40 years they have rich Canaan and make war with the canaanites. They conquer the north and south of the region. The southern is where the 2 tribes of israel positioned. It's called Judah. And the philistines or Palestinian are settlers where gaza strip now they called sea peoples they are non canaanites who live in the coastal area of canaan. They're not natives to that area. Jewish is the true owner of that land because God commanded them to conquer the canaanites and it is for them israelites not the muslim or any other groups. Understand?

[@asmahermasa8288]

It is the land of Canaan and those who first inhabited it were Canaanites, and my ancestors are Palestinians. The land was never for the children of Israel. They were guests in it. And the earth is inherited by righteous people

[@דניאל-ר4פ]

haha😂 the Israelities are cnaanaites the Palestinenians are Arabs stop trying to twist the facts​@@asmahermasa8288

[@דניאל-ר4פ]

​@@thedropoutfarmer3128Israelities was simply cnaanaites the Palestinenians today are Arabs from different Arab and Muslim countries

[@HappyKiller5000y]

אחי אני התחלתי לצפות בערוץ שלך וזה נורא כיף לדעת שמישהו באמת יודע את המאחורי הקלעים של כל החרא שמתלך אצלהם שהם בעצמם לא יודעים

[@charlespalmer5014]

You're not going back far enough in history. This story began thousands of years ago. First off Palestinians are not Arabian, genetically Palestinians and Jews are related to each other through the Canaanites. It is like a giant family feud. The sad part is since the beginning of time all the wars that mankind have fought makes me picture mankind as a bunch of fleas fighting over the dog they live on.

[@blueninja5069]

Hi Rudy, can we get the resources where you got all the information from? Thanksss

[@fresiamaldonado3609]

Yeah, good question. It is like just repetition from different" sources " can be from reliable historical facts or created.. perhaps anyone can read and memorize a book and make it their narrative, but it does not necessarily represent their identity.

[@mattheahanse57]

What an amazing video!

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@hanselbers6987]

Rudy the OFFICIAL propagandamachine of israhell. Don't be fooled by his calm appearance. He is an actor.

[@daniellecoh]

@@yansideabacoa6257 you do not understand the languages used here. p-l-s means invader (migrants forcefully arriving uninvited like the Sea Peoples)in Hebrew and related Semitic languages. Falasha is used to describe Ethiopians Immigrants and falash mura. Modern local Arabs say Balestina because they have no 'F'. Hebrew has both p and f.

[@Fit_Art1993_Zev]

thank you rudy, im a jew from dagestan in russia, i actually did not know this, and im learning much from your videos about jewish peoples history! thank you !

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@i_hate_this_world]

Do look at many sources and try to make up your own mind. This video has some questionable theories portrayed as facts. Some of what is said is actually contradictory to some well-establish facts. There are a few comments already here with the information. Knowledge is important. And a critical mind is essential to gain knowledge.

[@joshr1205]

Rudy, since you appear to be so knowledgeable of the region and truly wants to seek ways of making peace between both the Jews and the Palestinian people of Israel (which I find most refreshing) realizing the corruption of their current leaders , would you be willing to write an Op Ed piece in the NY Times stating your views that will hopefully help combat some of the anti-Israel bias that currently exists both within the NY Times and in all the Ultra left progressive movements today. I believe it is truly heroic what you are trying to accomplish and wish you much hatzlacha and success

[@lebronjames5577]

he is a great explainer, he should post articles and debvunk palestinian lies

[@yaacovk]

the anti Israeli articles in the NYT is due to the reason of the new antisemitism and it doesn't help for any explanation

[@RedCloudBeechWaveAhh]

Hi Josh, Can you tell me some things that are there in the coverage of the Times which show an anti-Israel bias? Please enlighten me if you have a few moments, because til now I haven't seen it in the current coverage. Thanks.

[@L98fiero]

It's true that there is corruption on _both_ sides of the conflict between the Israelis and Palestinians but the problem isn't with the ultra-left progressive movement, it's with the ultra right fascist apartheid policies of the State of Israel. I agree that Rudy seems more knowledgeable than most but then much of that is due to explicit suppression of the truth and efforts to rewrite history by the Israeli government. There really can't be any peace until Israel accepts what they did to the original inhabitants of the area.

[@ahyaok100]

@@L98fiero "What they did to the original inhabitants." If you look at the facts, you'll see that much of that is propaganda too.

[@greenearth9945]

And by the way Im not of the opinion that Jews should be kicked out of the area but Im against settlers from Europe and United States entering the land. Those immigrants shouldnt be allowed because 2.000 years ago they might have had a jewish (ethnic) grandmother from the area. I think the solution is a common state which respect both peoples and with full equality and opputunity for all. Like Belgium were you have two different ethnic groups in the same country well functioning together. Not a jewish state, not an arab state but a common state. But to be honest I dont think its gonna happen as long as the israeli government have all those religious extremists far right people who only want a jewish state and allows aliyah only for jews and not palestinians because it would cause a "demographic threat"

[@rebilium4195]

Is there any historical material of those stories? Would love to read more about this subject. Also That would strongly prove the point.

[@monke6010]

I mean, if most of the jews would trace back their family trees then they would end up in judea

[@ronnylarock13]

Yes., Its called historybooks.

[@rebilium4195]

@@ronnylarock13 which books ? If you don’t have a good argument, mind as well just stay silent, eventually silence is gold.

[@ronnylarock13]

@@rebilium4195 "Silence is gold" ... Worth thinking about when you ask "is there any historical material of those stories"... Are you admitting you dont know the name of any historybooks or encyclopedias? I.e Britannica?

[@Parlefalk]

@@ronnylarock13 This is a textbook example of how to NOT communicate in a positive and productive manner. The exact opposite of what Rudy is doing. Be more like him, don't be like that. It's counter productive.

[@wildflower3723]

Thank you for your thoughtful words and the honest presentation without being confrontational. Those of us that know the truth appreciate it!

[@ajvlogs5626]

Fight for your existence brother ....wishesfrom indian hindu ..... i can also understand your pain ...we faced these from 1000 years

[@homershimshon4172]

In my Semetic language of Assyrian Neo Aramaic, peleshet (invader) sounds a lot like our word palasha means fighter or fight. I wonder if it's a cognate.

[@yuccalyptus]

Interesting. I think they could be.

[@nadaawassa4902]

why is no one asks if the palestinians are the same people that lived long time ago on this land but converted to other religions and the jew people that came from europe also converted to judaism

[@C.I366]

Palaistis is Greek indeed and it means "wrestler". You are mixed genes. Religiously too, you are cousins, from Abraham

[@asm255]

from my opinion the only way to move forward is by having a federal government controlling both states, no borders, no discrimination just one country with two or three states with a whole new name and a new flag.

[@RaphaelKaufmann]

In my opinion, the only way forward is to have the Jews exert sovereignty in their land and the other groups accept it or leave. That will bring both peace and justice ✌️⚖️🙏

[@RaphaelKaufmann]

@normalcy kid If you consider "dumbass" a respectful and accepting way of addressing someone, I then respectfully invite you to fuck yourself. Best regards.

[@oneDAYoneDEED]

It's funny that this is even something that Rudy would address when the history of Jews is arguably just as convoluted as the Palestinian history is being painted in this video - and Rudy eludes to this notion in the video without really providing a balanced summation. Also, modern Isreal didn't exist before 1949, and Jews come from several tribes and many have a significant European heritage. So what is the point of this video?

[@ani2756]

Jews always had a connection to the Israeli land in their prayers and cultural rituals. It’s our promised land no matter if our enemies want to take it away from us we’ll always return as god promised to our ancient fathers. We’re welcoming the Palestinians to live with us in peace but they want to take away our entire country and we’ll fight till death before we’ll let it happen. Stop fighting the jewish people and god will bless the entire world. Peace for the Middle East inshalla

[@elizabethspring2208]

Could you tell me when Palestine was born, and when Judea was born? I’ll wait.

[@credibility63]

@@elizabethspring2208 Judea existed over three and a half thousand years ago. This is where the children of Israel (descendants of Jacob) settled after leaving Egypt and took their name, Jews from the land. Palastine as a region, it was never considered a country was named by the Romans two thousand years ago. This was like America losing to Japan in World War 2 and being renamed Hitler land as an insult to be endured every day.

[@carnivorewitch]

Show me “Palestinian” artifacts, I’ll wait. 😂

[@shawoomco]

The name "Palestine" was appropriated by the British mandate in 1917, following WWI. But prior to that, during the nearly 400 years of the Ottoman rule, the land was part of "El-Sham", the southern part of Syria province. in the 400 years under the Seljuks who preceded the Ottomans, there was also no mention of "Palestine", in much the same way as there wasn't any mention of "Palestine" under the Crusader kingdom or the Abbasid/Fatimid early muslim empires.

[@suleyman8696]

It’s Syrian then 😉

[@majidabdullah5562]

@Suleyman 🇸🇾 yes the whole region, Syria, Palestine/Israel, Jordan and Lebanon are countries in modern day Bilad asSham/Levant

[@omarzoghayyer5405]

Bibles from the 1700 have maps with the name Palestine on it.

[@ritasalemme4708]

My family left Italy from Palestinian as Orthodox Jews 500 years ago and married other Sephardic Jews. Oh, my heart loves Israel.. we eventually became Catholic. But I converted back to Judaism.

[@justchilling704]

What made you reject Yeshua? I get leaving Roman Catholicism btw.

[@ritasalemme4708]

@@justchilling704 about 2 years after I converted, I picked up a bug from the hospital unit I was working on ( I’m an RN).. I went into septic shock and now I’m a below the knee and left toes amputee. In the depths of my heart I don’t feel I left Yeshusa, but a Constantinople view of him. I now have returned. I’ve not uncoverted, why? Because, Judaism is truth just lacking Yeshusa Messiah. When he returns and establishes his kingdom..Torah will be taught in truth and the world will heal. Amen let’s pray for that day. Like me I’m a whole person, but lack a part. I’m in pain.. the world is in pain, I’m waiting for my Yeshusa.

[@musicpersonale1231]

Shalom from Kosovo, this guys so young and knowledgeable , should go in more debates in other channels .

[@chris123sim]

YOU ARE DOING A HOLLY WORK, THANK YOU. כל הכבוד לך על ההסבר המפורט והמדוייק הזה, העולם צריך לדעת את הדברים שבתקשורת מנסים להסתיר.

[@mujemoabraham6522]

chris sim Palestinians are the descendants of Canaanites and Arabs so they are indigenous and native of the Holy Land. The real Arabs and Bnei Yesrael carry the Haplogroup J1 The majority of Arab tribes ( Qahtani and Adnani ) from Yemen, Saudi Arabia, the Gulf region , Levantine, Iraq, Egypt and North Africa carry the Haplogroup J1 About 45% of Cohanim Jews ( descendants of Aharon ) carry the Haplogroup J1 Famous Jewish families ( Ashkenazim and Mizrahim ) carry the Haplogroup J1 Arab Christians in Levantine carry the Haplogroup J1 Majority of Yemenite Jews carry the Haplogroup J1 ( majority of the Yemenite Jews are Arabs from Kholan and Hemyar tribes ) A new study of ancient Canaanites DNA reveals that " Saudi Arabians,Bedouins and Iranian Jews had the highest percentage of ancestry matching that of the Canaanites, followed by Palestinians, Jordanians and Syrians." Majority of them carry the Haplogroup J1 , read the study as follow : www.nationalgeographic.com/history/2020/05/dna-from-biblical-canaanites-lives-modern-arabs-jews/ twitter.com/haaretzcom/status/1266237684101476355

[@barackobama546]

@@mujemoabraham6522 Canaanites were from Africa, btw. They came and settled on the land from there, so this argument isn't logical.

[@joshua8774]

Barack Obama Canaanites were not “black” lol. The term Canaanites refers to different groups of people living in the region of Canaan. Israelites (Jews) were Canaanites, as well as Phoenicians (Lebanese people), and a few others.

[@nizarshawwa3704]

@@joshua8774 so basically the land is rightfully everyone's by ancestral birthright. And what Israel is doing is wrong and illegal because it's choosing 1 group of people among many to be the rightful owners of that land.

[@ofeknahon7579]

@@nizarshawwa3704 actually the Israelites are the only surviving group. the rest of the group went extinct or merge with other groups. The modern Palestinian are actually descended from the area of Saudi Arabia.

[@kellikocha7733]

Now I know why Palestine and Philistine sound similar.

[@Longordon1]

@Channel that is true bro

[@ratsbelongnowhere2548]

It’s also called “falestine””فلسطين"in Arabic almost the same pronunciation as philistine

[@Longordon1]

@@ratsbelongnowhere2548 that come from Rome Empire to insult Israel, in the end falestine is false name

[@ratsbelongnowhere2548]

Longordon1 yes I know I’m just saying it’s pronounced in hebrew just like in Arabic as philistine and not like how Palestine is pronounced

[@Longordon1]

@@ratsbelongnowhere2548 ok bro, thanks for that information

[@danitadmor]

Hi Rudy, this is a nice video portraying a lot of hope for a better and peaceful future :-) That said, I must add an important comment regarding your saying on 5.40min "the United Nations decided to split up the land into 2". Well, the United Nations cannot decide such things Rudy. Both the United Nations General Assembly and - in most cases - the International Court of Justice have advisory powers only. This is very fundamental. Many people think that the UN is some kind of a powerful world government but that is not true at all. It is mainly an administrative organization. You mentioned the year 1948. I assume you meant the UN Palestine partition plan of 1947. Many people tend to think that UN resolutions and plans are binding. This is usually not the case. This also includes the 1947 UN Palestine Partition Plan (resolution 181). It could have been legally binding however the Arabs rejected it. What IS legally binding are international agreements such as, in this case, the Mandate for Palestine (1922) which was signed by all members of the League of Nations including former occupier Turkey and which was later also accepted by the UN.

[@ansamgroshong]

(I know your comment is from 2 years ago, but hoping you notice this:) Could you please explain a little more? I've been trying to learn about the conflict, but I still have a lot of questions. if the UN couldn't decide on the land, then who gets to decide the borders? and what happens if there are no international agreements? since the borders changed a few times in history (with Egypt and Jordan) then what are the parts that are considered occupied now, and how are those determined?

[@danitadmor]

@@ansamgroshong Hi Ansam, the UN (usually) does not get to decide about land(s) and borders. I wrote usually because they did come out with a partition plan for Palestine in 1947 (resolution 181). Although a plan by itself is judicially non binding in terms of international law, however, if that plan was accepted and signed by both Jews and Arabs then (and only then) it would have become legal under international law and so its borders too. But since the Arabs rejected it then that plan became meaningless. What many people call 'the borders of 1948' were actually not recognized borders rather armistice lines (cease fire lines). After the peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan in the 70s and 90s they became recognized borders. Therefore the (internationally recognized) borders with Egypt and Jordan did not "change a few times in history" as your words suggested. Many countries around the world did not even go through any 'judicial process' and indeed no international agreements! That was not the case with the Palestine region, the Levant (and including today's Iraq). The reason that this region did go through a judicial process lays at the defeat of the Ottoman Empire in the end of WW1 (they ruled that whole region). At that point the League of Nations (the organization that preceded the UN) appointed the winning powers, Great Britain and France, to establish mandates in that region. The mandates that were established were the Mandate for Greater Syria (which then included Lebanon), the Mandate for Mesopotamia (Iraq) and the Mandate for Palestine. And the goal was that France and GB would assist the local populations towards establishing their independence asap. The mandates were legally binding under international law, signed by all members of the League of Nations including the defeated country Turkey. I hope this clarifies things a bit?

[@ansamgroshong]

@@danitadmor thank you. I appreciate your taking the time to explain and write all this. I did have another question. but i just need a day or two to write again (takes me some effort to write - medical problems).

[@ansamgroshong]

@@danitadmor Hello yes I understand the clarification you made about the UN Re what I wrote, yes I guess I wasn’t accurate. I only meant the control over the land changed, but I didn’t know what changes were considered agreed on borders and which weren’t. I went over your reply more than once and I think you answered everything. (You really explain well. Thank you). I’m from Iraq (though now I live in the US) so I know about the ottomans but I didn’t know the details you wrote. It wasn’t only till some years go when I started to think how we always thought of the western countries as the occupiers and colonizers, but nobody talks about the ottomans. As re Israel- Palestine conflict, I don’t know if you’re aware we have a very very different story on the other side. Earlier this year I came across some videos by an Israeli person (a tour guide) on youtube, and I was surprised how all he said was different from what I had known (or thought had known). I’ve learned more since then, esp after Oct 7. My view has changed completely. I meant to ask about the settlements, but I think maybe I better wait and find some videos. I don't want to make it too much for you. Maybe one question: (if ok): a few have mentioned the Jordan (or Transjordan) too was part of the mandate of Palestine, and say therefore the arabs already had a bigger part. But not all Israeli supporters mention this. Is it a debated issue? Thank you again.

[@danitadmor]

@@ansamgroshong You're welcome Ansam, and no problem for asking the questions! (that's what we're for, not? ;-) Indeed many people have many stories to tell about the Israel-Palestine conflict but what I wrote earlier wasn't a story rather international law: the Mandate for Palestine. You can read the contents of the mandate on the site of the UN (I think I cannot send links here..?) As I mentioned earlier, with the fall of the Ottoman Empire, the winning forces of Great Britain and France got control over the remaining areas of the Middle East that used to belong to the Ottomans. That was Iraq, Greater Syria and Palestine. Political rights under the mandates of Iraq and Greater Syria were given to the Arab populations in those areas whereas in Palestine (which at first Transjordan was indeed included in) were given to the Jews. But 2 years later Great Britain decided to separate Transjordan (which amounts for 74% of Palestine) from 'western Palestine' and give that area to the Hashemites. Jews were no longer allowed to settle in that area. So when the actual Mandate for Palestine was signed in 1922-1923, Transjordan was excluded from it. But, according to the mandate, Jews were (and, as long as no new international agreements are signed/finalized also - are) allowed to settle in all of the remining areas of Palestine west from the Jordan river (and they are even encouraged to do so according to the international community!) - this is all to be found in the mandate. The mandate, except for the fact that the British have returned it back then to the UN and as long as no new international agreements have been signed/finalized, is valid up to this day.

[@90sHouseBoy]

Scotland also kept the romans away. They were that terrified of us Celts that they built a wall to protect themselves from us Celts from attacking them. So Scotland wasn’t conquered by Rome. Alba gu bràth 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@YamnayaSintash]

You where colonised by the English though lol. Just kidding

[@90sHouseBoy]

@@YamnayaSintashtell that to Edward II of England and the Battle of Bannockburn lol 😂

[@md.kafiluddin7708]

May Allah bless you, Rudy!

[@yogev3953]

Bruh I see here people that say it's a lie. I'm shocked that in this age, 2021, people turn their back to facts and history. This are facts I learned that in school last year

[@ТаняСонина-р8л]

This is most likely written by provocateurs and bots. Or just very uneducated people.

[@달-d7f]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@admin-ts8uv]

Very interesting!! Makes so much sense.

[@bobbybrown851]

Can you give the link to the conference where it is said that they chose the word "Palestine" for this reason?

[@DonaldKEOGH]

In biblical times the greek speaking Philistines settled in Canaan but had largely assimilated or had vanished by the time the Babylonians arrived. Not sure what the connection to modern day Palestine is but surely it's up to the Palestinians to identify themselves as they see fit without reference to Jewish identify or biblical connection to the land. Similar countries like Ireland and Cyprus , with post colonial pasts abd divided societies have had to struggle with land and identity which is only ever achieved when some measure of justice and fairness is applied.

[@avraham2158]

יפה מאוד! ממש מוכשר צריך עוד אנשים כמוך

[@MaziBiafra]

I want to learn to speak Hebrew I love the language

[@Mo-np1me]

I like how you mentioned terrorism from the PLO, But no Israeli killed Palestinian ?

[@talerez83]

Always from self defense

[@talerez83]

@Marshall Teach how about learning a subject before you say something

[@nocapwithcaps3625]

@@talerez83 it's never self defense, they bomb gaza on a daily, killing Arab Jews, Muslims and Christians in the west bank

[@yurichtube1162]

@@nocapwithcaps3625 you are crazy

[@nocapwithcaps3625]

@@yurichtube1162 I am speaking facts, look at eye.on.palestine and Jewish voice for peace on instagram. The truth is there

[@kingicicle]

Very informative and factual video!

[@jesussaves1875]

Israel was under Roman rule until the Ottomans took over (Pompey subjugated Israel at least 100 years before the temple was destroyed)... then the British came and kicked the ottomans out (the ottoman empire dissolved) Britain retained control for approx. 30 years under a mandate from the League of Nations. It was Churchill that split palestine (white paper of 1922) The palestinians were never an independent or separate nation, they merely occupied the ottoman empire territories (a "province" called palestine)

[@luigianchondo7241]

Any Muslims and Arabs are going nuts and crazy over this video, this man as a narrator is an Arab himself. (I’m assuming that he is a Muslim).

[@levizioni]

He's a jew

[@amirjan4722]

@@levizioni a zionist

[@amirjan4722]

@@levizioni illuminati puppet

[@bilalbataineh8367]

I will try to summarise the mistakes in this video briefly . 1) 00:50 about the origin of word Philistine as PEOPLE: The first records of the Philistines are inscriptions and reliefs in the mortuary temple of Ramses III at Madinat Habu, where they appear under the name " prst ", as one of the Sea Peoples>>>>so Hebrew has nothing to do with this word as far as I know from unbiased sources. you can find in Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_name_%22Palestine%22 2) 02:40 the name of Palsestine as a COUNTRY : here he said that this country was called Palestine by Romans to humiliate Jewish people. In fact, the whole region was called " Palestine" by Greek historians long time before Romans came. from Wikipedia "The term "Palestine" first appeared in the 5th century BC when the ancient Greek historian Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" between Phoenicia and Egypt in The Histories.[6] Herodotus applied the term to both the coastal and the inland regions such as the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley.[7][8][9][10] Later Greek writers such as Aristotle, Polemon and Pausanias also used the word, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.[11] The word is not found on any Hellenistic coin or inscription and is first known in official use in the early second century AD.[12] It has been contended that in the first century authors still associated the term with the southern coastal region.[13][14]" >>>>>so the Romans came and just used the name " Palestine formally which was used traditionally before them the link en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_name_%22Palestine%22 3) Now, we have the word "Philistines" or pelesht : which refers to sea people, or Israeli enemies which seems to be from Egyptian origin as a word ..and the word Palestine which had referred by greeks to the whole country even before Romans came, HOW had this happened ???? - There is a strong hypothesis that says that the ancient word Palestine has nothing to do with the word Philistine. According to the hypothesis, the word " Palestine " is the literal translation of the word Israel. note that "Isra" in Hebrew means "wrestler" or "fighter" in the greek language. wrestler in greek means "palaistís" (you can translate yourself in google translate)..... ..so the confusion came from the fact that the words " philistine" and "Palestine" look similar, but seems they have different origins. to read more about this interesting hypothesis check this link cojs.org/when_palestine_meant_israel-_david_jacobson-_bar_27-03-_may-jun_2001/ 4)So we have two regions, a smaller one called "Philistine" and the larger one is " Palestine" which is the whole land. let's talk about ancient Philistine! it was an area had contained the five cities (the Pentapolis) of the Philistine confederacy (Gaza, Ashkelon [Ascalon], Ashdod, Gath, and Ekron) and was known as Philistia, or the Land of the Philistines. the popular opinion says that people who lived in ancient "Philistine " were European people or sea people..... but is this TRUE ????? well , ARCHEOLOGY and GENETICS have disapproved this opinion clearly. A- GENETICS : genetic studies in Ashkelon(Philistinean city) found that ancient people of Philistine were Canaanites NOT Europeans !!!!! however, the same studies showed that those Canaanites had SLIGHTLY more European genes than other Canaanites and for a SHORT time !!! short time means that Europeans genes had disappeared shortly ..to read more about this study check this link : advances.sciencemag.org/content/5/7/eaax0061 B- ARCHEOLOGY : archeological findings in Ekron (another Philistinean city) shows that ancient people of Philistine also used Canaanites language which was used in the other surrounding regions!!!! you may read more in this link en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ekron_Royal_Dedicatory_Inscription?fbclid=IwAR3rj0THTmPiityQb4n0zqpXxtI00rV11a8v-nY7O3ljVUBZfCK7NCSvtMY# to sum, from points A + B we can say that ancient people of Philistine were Canaanite on both cultural and the genetic levels , not European!!! However, it seems like for some time they were occasionally affected by Europeans .but absolutely NOT as the popular opinion goes that philistine consisted of European invaders exclusively bla bla bla . its just like some Europeans moved to this land and diluted between locals, exactly like adding 1 gram of sugar to 1 liter of water. 5) What about the CURRENT Palestinians ??!! in 05:05 he said that as a part of " colonial migration" Palestinians came to this land means that they are not aboriginal , but is this true ???? again , genetics clearly answer this question that CURRENT PALESTINIANS are ANCESTORS of ancient CANAANITES !! -here are some useful links about this topic : www.nationalgeographic.com/history/2020/05/dna-from-biblical-canaanites-lives-modern-arabs-jews/ www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/07/ancient-dna-reveals-fate-mysterious-canaanites www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2000/05/000509003653.htm 6) in 08:20 , he is trying to deny the Palestinians identity, while we all know that Palestinians have their own specific culture including food, clothes, dance, dialect, which makes the ethnicity, with some natural differences here and there like any other region/country on the world. for example, in England, you may find different English dialects, but they still called English people. On the other hand, Israeli people have NO there own culture as much as Palestinians have, they took the culture from the countries from where they come or from the locals !! 7) in 06:58 he claims that term " Palestine was dead and cameback only in 1964 , which is absolutely NOT true !! this can be simply proved by reading this article which says that this land have been named " Palestine" almost continuously since 500 B.C.E . read " Timeline of the name "Palestine"" en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_name_%22Palestine%22 Now some Additional Points !!!1 8) they're trying to convince us that on this land were living jews in a great kingdom called Israel, Judea or Samaria whatever (which is still not proved archaeologically by the way) . even their holiest place "the western wall" was built by ARABIAN king " Herod the Great" , moreover, when they dug under this wall they found a roman theatre. generally, seems like Jewish people just lived here side by side with other groups of Canaanite people. 9) They are trying to convince us that Arabs came from Arabia only after Islam, while the fact is that Arabs used to live out of Arabia BEFORE Islam , you can read about Nabateans, Hatra (northern Iraq) , Lakhmids, Gassanids, and Edomites(partially in current Palestine). even some of those Arabs gave hand to the newcomer arab-muslims from Arabia against the Roman empire. even, surprisingly, genetic studies shows that Arabs originated from what's currently Jordan and partially Palestine (around Petra ), they just migrated to arabia and after Islam they came back to the Levant .anyway, this is relatively another topic. but here is a quotation " Arabic speakers recolonized the Arabian peninsula in the Bronze Age from the north-west of the peninsula, close to present-day Jordan. The rise of Islam in the 7th century CE played a major part in the re-expansion of J1 from Arabia throughout the Middle East, as well as to North Africa, and to a lower extent to Sicily, Spain and Portugal." and the link if interested in this topic : www.eupedia.com/europe/Haplogroup_J1_Y-DNA.shtml **** Finally, I want to say that history is not that piece of cake or some fairy tale that we can tell to kids easily before going to bed, also we can't use the Bible, Torah, or any other religious book as scientific evidence (no offense). we have to search and dig into history deeply to understand what's going on scientifically. this guys kind of is showing us sympathy, but at the same time, he denys the history, identity, existence of other group people, or he just really doesn't know the facts!

[@agentlibra5703]

I will save my self time and not going to read any of this because it's Wikipedia on one of that most stupid and biased conflicts in history so yeah, Wikipedia isn't a Good source chief

[@beigechrysalis9497]

UPP

[@bilalbataineh8367]

@@agentlibra5703 only 3 points out of 9 were from Wikipedia. Even those from Wikipedia are based on other resources linked in the article. it's your problem to be too lazy to read!

[@boiboi3403]

אין לך מושג עד כמה אני מעריך אותך ואת כל מה שאתה עושה. גיליתי את הערוץ שלך היום ואני לא מספיק לראות סרטונים. תמשיך ככה! תודה רבה. סוף סוף יש לנו מישהו עם קול שלא מפחד להגיד את האמת

[@masterbrawler6061]

רק היום?! טוב אני מבין שחיפשת משהו בנושא בגלל כל המצב אבל יאללה לך תראה עוד סרטונים שלו!

[@boiboi3403]

@@masterbrawler6061 כע...זה צץ לי ביוטיוב הקטע עם הנאצי שהוא דיבר איתו והתעניינתי והתחלתי לראות עוד דברים שלו ואני מכור אליו עכשיו הוא מדהים.

[@Electricc__]

@@boiboi3403 huh

[@simonklein9844]

What about the cananites . They lived there before the Israelites

[@a.a.6789]

Fam you're so gross to lie like that, there's bloody documentation of Armenians in Palestine identifying strictly as Palestinian, all what you said is lies, scholars have identified as strictly Palestinian since the 14th century at least, absolutely disgusting to try to sound non-racist/revisionist. And enough with the Jordan argument, it didn't exist and was known as the empty quarter, most of them, Christian and Muslim, were unsettled Bedouins a few generations ago, and it's a non-argument anyway, like Christopher Hitchens said, if an Americans from a state was exiled from his own he will no back down without a fight despite having 49 other states to go to, they all still have their own identity. Absolutely infuriating video.

[@lalremsanga4089]

It was Roman emperor Hadrian who renamed Israel into Palestine after crushing a great Jewish revolt. The present Arab(so called Palestinian) had nothing to do with Palestine. Emperor Hadrian renamed it to crush the spirit of the Jews, thousands of them were deported from Judea. The Philistine were also called "Sea people", they invaded middle east in the late bronze age, they also invaded Egypt during the reign of Ramses III. Philistine were extinct race of people now

[@tbishop4961]

Blessed are the peacemakers ✌

[@ritasalemme4708]

Rudy how do I support you! You’re awesome.

[@ritasalemme4708]

I’m so sorry some my heritage is Italian, but I’m Sephardic also. You are so right.

[@Alexander1005]

“Palestine” could just be a Greek way of saying “Israel” (both words come from “wrestle” respectively.)

[@MrHRanjha]

It seems you think the issue is more to do with who came to the land first and should be there. When speaking to Palestinians they're argument isn't that Jewish History didn't exist but that the Palestinians have their own history too. But you speak of them as if they don't have a 2000 year history. I think the main issue is that Zionist want Israel to be a 'Jewish State' but that's not possible with a community of a few million Arabs. If israel were to drop the 'Jewish State' idea and allow full rights to all people, especially voting, then maybe we'll start moving in a good direction. Majority Jewish Israel = Killing and displacing the Palestinian Arabs. That's not okay.

[@SebaX92]

Rudy is one of those who respects Palestinians and their own heritage. In the end of the vid he said there’s no future with no Palestinians and no future without Israelis in this land. So no, he is not one of those extreme Jews that want to kick out people. He is a good guy, I met him in person. I’m half Polish half Arab Palestinian born in Israel.

[@SebaX92]

Democratic Jewish country doesn’t contradict the fact that Arabs can and will live there freely. The issue is that many of them want Sharia law and other stuff. Which is... passé. I lived there and it’s really ok. Much better than life in Jordan or Egypt, not only from economic perspective but organization and caring about infrastructure, technology, job opportunities, freedom of speech, healthcare, education. I just want from Israelis to recognize the fact that Palestinians are a nation with its own flag, anthem and Arabic language. We can make as a federation like Russia did with Chechnya. They had over 10 years of bloodshed, Grozny was a ruin. And now? It’s very prosperous. Same thing can be with Palestine if we agree to a federation. So Israel will be called the Federation of Israel, being a democratic Jewish State. And I put Democratic before Jewish cause I want Israel to be a secular place that respects all of its citizens.

[@MrHRanjha]

@@SebaX92 This is very beautiful. Thank you for sharing and educating me more on the topic. I have a personal issue where I dearly wish to visit Jerusalem and the holy land but the Israelis will stop me at all costs from doing this. Hopefully one day we can see that land in peace with love and respect for all.

[@SebaX92]

@@MrHRanjha I also hope for that. I live today in Poland. There's a nation inside Poland called Kashubians, they are having they're own language, flag and anthem, living in north west Poland. They're respected and part of the whole country. I do wish same thing can be with the Palestinians, to be respected citizens with all rights and acknowledgement. My family is still in Israel. The issue today is Iran that wants to make chaos - in the middle East as a whole. They're doing it with Turkey btw. Syria and Lebanon are a good example, Iraq is now for Iran just like Belarus to Russia - a puppet state. I'm not hating Iranians but many elderly people are saying that there's a prophecy saying that a mighty army will come from the east to destroy Israel and it'll be in judgement day "Yaum Al Kiyama" . And in that day the sun will rise from the west. In that term we can understand that it's in Saudi Arabia and Jordan perspective - so means that a nuclear blast will be in Israel and will be bright like the sun rise. Which will begin a nuclear war and the end of humanity. The judgment day 😞

[@MrHRanjha]

@@SebaX92 What you've told me of the Kashubians is very interesting. I wonder if there is any videos about them on KZbin... It reminds me of a similar case where I come from, Pakistan. Our western most regions in the mountains has groups of people who are their own ethnicity (they look like europeans as they descend from alexanders people), speak their own language and some even have their own religions and cultures. These people have lived remotely in the mountain for thousands of years. The thing is, us Pakistanis don't consider them as Pakistani (they request this). They have a stronger link with the Afghans and would actually like to be part of Afghanistan. But due to the insane political climate in Afghanistan for so long it's been difficult for Pakistan to officially gift the land to the Afgans. So for the moment, that land is considered part of Pakistan as it falls under Pakistani border however they are free to govern themselves as they wish. Pakistan simply gifts them with security and protection. Nothing else. The worst part of it all is that they actually have strong links to the Taliban and are the reason th Western media are able to say Pakistan has terrorist camps. When you look at a map with no knowledge of the land and people then yes Pakistan does. But when you know about the Afghans living independently in the mountains you come to realise all of these camps are in their territory. Territory Pakistan has zero control over. In regards to your theory about Iran and Turkey, I have heard this before. And iv also heard the opposite from the other side. As a Muslim that is not from that region I am able to look at this from an informed outside perspective. It seems there is a bigger problem here from which all of these smaller problems are coming from. There are over 50 Muslim majority countries in the world. The Muslim population is not only huge but extremely strong which is why there have been so many Muslim empires that have ruled big parts of the world. It has been a long time now since a Muslim empire ever existed. The West (Brit, Europe, America etc) split the muslims apart and have not only done a great job of it but are currently maintaning it very well too. If the muslims were to get back together and become one empire with one empire that would be the end of the Unitied Nations, the end of Nato, the end of Russia. The muslims will very quickly take over the world! What I believe is going on here is simply politics. The current rulers of the world are making sure the muslims fight each other so they can't join forces and take over. - What this means is, everybody is bad. All of the bad people have been put in power in order to make sure the muslims keep fighting each other. Turkey, Iran, UAE, Saudi, every single one of the leaders are just as evil as each other behind closed doors. If they werent evil, they simply wouldnt be in power.

[@terrybaker8156]

He’s gorgeous

[@terrybaker8156]

el desconocido I’m really in love

[@terrybaker8156]

Wolf Puppy y

[@dreznik]

brilliant, especially for your age. Keep up le bon travail

[@almansoori7875]

Ruby can you do an ethnicity genetical test as a new video I’m waiting for it

[@ALBHAISIMOHAMMED]

:)) why?

[@RaphaelKaufmann]

Your stupid question with all its bigotry and racist outlook is all too common. Do you think the Jewish people is defined by genetics? Do you think there is any genetic difference between Arabs from Egypt, Israel, Jordan, etc? None. The Jewish people has a much higher holier definition of society and peoplehood. Anyone willing to become a Jew can adhere to its constitutional values. So there is no reason in theory for genetical consistency. The reason why Jews are nevertheless genetically strongly related across countries is because few people have the courage to become Jewish. Only the bravest among the nations do.

[@almansoori7875]

Raphael Kaufmann I am wondering what triggered you in my comment 😂😂 I think that there is a difference as jews that are all originated from “Judaea” isn’t it? So what’s wrong about tracking the DNA origins and see the evidence of Judea there. Accusing me of being racist for this question is equivalent to calling population geneticist, DNA companies, other people that are interested in this field racist !!! And on the other hand you replied me with a comment that is different than the KZbinr opinion that states as the following :”Judaism is a race and A Jew can be an atheist but still a Jew” so you all have different theories and opinions and others have the right to know the truth, right Mr. scientist that only asks smart questions?😭😂 see there is no difference between religions and etc in this modern world and your ignorant comment is making a specific religion more superior. Make some research about Jordanian (the Levantine overall) and Egyptian history because I spotted some terrible mistakes, and check the KZbinr video before attacking me and I suggest you to make a genetic test too to see your holiest result. Be brave

[@RaphaelKaufmann]

@@almansoori7875 Why don't you take a test yourself? Not genetics, IQ.

[@almansoori7875]

Raphael Kaufmann oh sorry, not gonna share my result with you racist Mr. Scientist to not let you feel sorry about your self, you are already frustrated (stupidness has no cure and racist people have the least IQ) 😎

[@pureevil4674]

1:40 you claim that the original philistines that originally lived in the area just disappered after the land was conquered by the jews but how can you know that for sure, how can u deny some peoples claims who say their origins are from the philistines just like you claim to be from the original jews from one of the tribes? Especially if they can go back many generations?

[@hatasakuta8012]

Philistines were defeated but not disappeared They still exist until Nebuchadnezzar (whatever his name) conquered Philistia and The Philistines were forced to assimilated so the term of Philistines as "ethnic groups" were just gone. It was just the term of ethnic group, not the existent of people.

[@geegeeh.6118]

You forgot the Kingdom of the Nabaeteen which is current day Jordan and it’s borders spread to the Mideterinean. Your history is missing lots of facts Rudy. Jews lived in two Kingdoms, the Kingdom of Himyar in South Arabia, and the Kingdom of Khazaria somewhere near the Russian Empire. The ones in Judea at the times of the Romans were a tiny tribe whom of which converted forcibly to Christianity, just like their brethrens in Himyar. So Philistines or not, it does not give Jews, converts from all around the world, to claim it as their ancestral land.

[@ShelloSongz]

This is sooooo interesting. Bless you for your content.

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@hanselbers6987]

Rudy the OFFICIAL propagandamachine of israhell. Don't be fooled by his calm appearance. He is an actor.

[@varunsingh2592]

i am happy the way you are proving that real talks among people can impact relation better

[@timramm1]

Spot On

[@jamilabidrabbu1198]

What is ? This is all none sense . The problem was never jews against palestinians cuz there are jewish palestinains now a days who r 100 percent against the so called Israeli state.

[@tFighterPilot]

@@jamilabidrabbu1198 Who are these "Jewish Palestinians" you speak of?

[@agentlibra5703]

@@jamilabidrabbu1198 they are not Jewish Palestinians, we call them extreme left jews who are against zionism and themselves in favor of the Palestinians

[@agentlibra5703]

@@jamilabidrabbu1198 there are Palestinians who believe what ruby says

[@Argos2335]

Culprit: HADRIAN call the diabolic by name HADRIAN

[@huthayfaainqawi4348]

I can search where the name America came from and prove every American is a descendant of immigrant parents who were not born in America, but no one has the right to come hundreds of years later, reclaim the land and displace Americans. We all came from nowhere and placed on earth and no one has the right displace you or stop you from living where you want, but thats not the case in the land you call Judeah. In Palestine, people are constantly being displaced from their houses in Hebron, Jerusalem and many other cities. Construction in area C in west bank which constitute most of west bank land is prohibited for Palestinians. Just few days ago, IDF demolished few houses in my village in Ramallah for the reason of illegal construction in area C.

[@marl3y890]

Name America came from Amerigo Vespucci

[@simko8665]

@@1moneyking No. 3 - the Hamas terrorists and the former ones.

[@simko8665]

@@1moneyking yep.

[@simko8665]

@@1moneyking Israel has no intention to conquer not Gaza and not the West Bank. 1. Israel ruled Gaza till 15 years ago and went out of it. Israel does not need the 2 Million of the Arabs from Gaza. 2. Gaza was a test case to see what will happen if Israel will withdraw from the all the West Bank. Now Israel knows exactly how it going to be and in some time she will annex it to Israel giving the citizens there an opportunity for a self autonomy. 3. Why are you suddenly agree two states solution? You were offered it 72 years ago and you rejected it. Why do you agree to it now? Ha, because you were sure then that you are going defeat Israel. It didn't happen, on the contrary, Israel took over your most area and you were left with much less then what was offered to you. B.Z.W. What borders will you accept? 1917, 1947, 1948, 1967, 2005? Isn't it ridiculousness? In 29.11.1947 the Arabs rejected the U.N. decision to divide this area in two just as you want now. In 1967 the Arabs were offered back all what had been taken away by Israel but in the Khartoum comity the Arabs decided the three famous no's, turning down that offer. Why are you in a hurry to accept it now?

[@simko8665]

@@1moneyking Is that all? I can understand your frustration but you have to get used the fact that Israel is here and will be here for ever. As for the the BALESTINIANS, they start to wake up and see how their brothers are leaving them one after the other and at the end they will be on their own because their brothers are getting tired of them. The young generation is also tired of the old leadership and they start to leave to other countries for a better future. Time is playing in favor of Israel. Now you can eat your hat.

[@harsha9128]

So many Jews converted to Christianity and eventually to Islam. So the people there now who are levantine arabs were natives who 1400 years ago were jews/Christians. After the Islamic conquest, Jews and Christians converted to Islam. That still makes them native and not outsiders!

[@mce3210]

The only answer is for all Jews to return back to hashem,he is waiting for us to talk to him we don’t even want to spend one hour a day alone talking to him,he’s crying for us to be close to him.... that’s our ONLY ANSWER.....please return back to hashem let’s keep the Torah let’s talk to our father at least an hour a day...... it’s about time... ❤️

[@ragingblazer2941]

Mc E Yes!!!

[@subchan6595]

@BVEmasTRUTH I never knew the victims of "apartheid" could have representitives in parliament, have full citizen rights and even be soldiers of this so called apartheid state. You are confused.

[@cholponkudus8719]

Rudi, can you do your DNA ethnicity, look like you have bit of South Asian blood

[@Benadav7]

He is israeli of morrocan and polish heritage

[@kingofrexdale8598]

@@Benadav7 Agreed....not to nit-picky though , But “herritage “ would be the wrong word. Heritage implies that his families roots are morocco/ polish. His family roots, where they are descended from as all Jews were, was from Israel. Whilst during their explosion they may have picked up some aspects of for, culture language and some blood from polish and Moroccan miscegenation respectively, that’s not where is herritage is , rather their “experience “.

[@Benadav7]

@@kingofrexdale8598 actually i think the right word would be descent. He is jewish-israeli of moroccan and polish descent.

[@Benadav7]

@@kingofrexdale8598 his family roots are from those countries, but if you go much further back, than originally he's a descendant of the israellites, yes

[@Benadav7]

Just as I am jewish-israeli, but my grand parents from one side were born in poland and moldova, and the other side were born in israel. So part of my family lived in europe for many years

[@jada1015]

Thank you for your context! I wish this was taught in American schools. The American educational system is very anti-semite.

[@devrimsarigul8387]

A Palestinian is a person living in the region falsely called Palestine. Therefore, the Jews living there are also Palestinians. Before the establishment of Israel Jews were called Palestinian Jews and Arabs were called Palestinian Arabs. There was never a Palestinian nation and still isn’t, that’s why the museum for Palestinian history is empty.

[@diamondluck3851]

Your videos need more viewers.

[@N.a.syed.]

Hey Rudi, good video. Can you please link me to the historical references?

[@nathanhanon6214]

yohanon.blogspot.com/2014/11/palestine-1939-tell-me-again-whose.html

[@majidabdullah5562]

This^^^

[@DaN-ze8gv]

It is written in the Torah that Adam blesses the Jews God bless him תודה חבר

[@christopherrodriguez2870]

Adam never blessed jews

[@tanikhan1821]

He doesn't bless zionists

[@roeypolin5174]

@@tanikhan1821 he blessed me personly

[@sarah-beruriahbooi9529]

😂🤣😂

[@emiliogereros7112]

@@tanikhan1821 Zionist means being one who supports a state for Jews to call home and feel safe. So to be against it is to be against the Jewish identity

[@Legitdupe]

Great video!

[@ostrados]

*Reposting my comment that Rudy deleted:* I have one question for you: If the Israelites lived in Palestine *3000* years ago and stayed for 100 years or so (Based on *Biblical stories* no science), and *Jerusalem* is actually *7000* years old and *Canaanites-Arabs* lived there *6000 BCE* for *4 millenniums* or so (Based on *science and archeological* evidence), then how come you claim the land while obviously you *were not the first neither the longest nor the latest inhabitants* ??! In what logic you claim the land as yours!!? *Also, Assuming you are somehow from the same lineage of 2000 years ago, with absolutely no outside conversion to Judaism or intermarriage with other culture.. Somehow!! (I am gonna delete my brain here for a minute for argument sake!)*

[@ostrados]

@R S So, as you said israel is an illegal occupation (conquer = Colonization = occupation), therefore it is not whatsoever natives to the land or legitimatr. Based on that the Palestinian cause is only just and their resistance is legitimate and its a duty of free people in the world to stand in solidarity with the Palestinian people liberation struggle of their lands in all forms. This what justice and human morals demands. Naive minds don't legitimize a 72 years colonization that committed ethnic cleansing and genocide and expulsion of the Palestinians. Redefine your position

[@ostrados]

@R S in case you dont know Palestinians are in Palestine for more than 2000 years, and israel is the creation of british colonialism that happened in 1948. Illegal and inhumane by definition, That's why the majority support Palestine.

[@albanianbear8578]

@@ostrados *Let’s start with ethnic cleansing myth. The crux of the complaint is that after Israel declared its independence in 1948 it went to work expelling its Arabs residents in order to create an exclusively Jewish state. In the process, 700,000 Arabs were forced from their homes. The truth is the exact opposite. In 1947, the United Nations voted to partition the land into two states, one Jewish and one Arab. This Jewish state was to have a sizeable Arab minority. British Mandate of Palestine’s Jews enthusiastically accepted this compromise. They actually danced in the streets to celebrate. The Arabs had a different reaction. The leaders of Palestine’s Arabs and the surrounding Arab states all rejected the partition of Palestine into two states. Instead, they vowed to destroy the Jewish state. The day after the UN vote, Palestinian Arabs launched a sustained series of guerilla attacks against their Jewish neighbors. And when the British officially departed the land in May of 1948, five neighboring Arab states invaded Israel. Before the Arabs launched this war to destroy Israel, there were no Palestinian refugees - not one. The Palestinian refugee crisis was the direct result of this Arab aggression. Wars are terrifying, and the large majority of Palestinian refugees simply fled the fighting as it approached their villages. In the limited cases where Israel expelled Arabs, it did so because of a clear military necessity created by this war. Having to flee one’s home is a terrible tragedy. No one should deny the human suffering experienced by these hundreds of thousands of Palestinian refugees. But recognizing their suffering does not require us to blindly blame Israel for it. The ultimate responsibility for the Palestinian refugee crisis rests with those Arab leaders who rejected Israel’s creation and launched a war to destroy it. *In regards to the stupid "genocide" myth...The maths could not be clearer. Genocide = the intentional mass murder of certain groups of people - shrink the population of the targeted group. The Nazi Holocaust, for example, reduced Europe’s Jewish population from 9.5 million in 1933 to 3.5 million in 1948 (Pew Research Centre). How much has the Palestinian population shrunk as the result of Israeli policies? It hasn’t shrunk at all! Quite to the contrary, since the birth of Israel there has been a sustained Palestinian population boom. In 1947, there were approximately 1.2 million Arabs living in the BRITISH MANDATE of Palestine. Today - despite the fact that many hundreds of thousands have left this territory - that original number has grown to approximately 6 million (4.4 million Palestinians in Judea & Samaria (West Bank) and in Gaza, plus 1.9 million Arab citizens of the Israel). There are actually more Arabs living in Israel today than were living in all of "Palestine" when the state of Israel was created! Even in the IDF code of ethics (which you definitely haven’t read) they are taught how to SAVE a life and protect others BEFORE they learn how to shoot. Simply put, if Israel is trying to commit genocide against the Palestinians, they’re doing a terrible job of it 😂😂😂 Israel has never had a policy of intentionally harming Arab civilians. Quite to the contrary, even during wartime Israel goes to extraordinary measures to protect Arab civilians. These efforts to safeguard Arab lives - efforts that expose Israeli soldiers to far greater risk - are the exact opposite of genocide. These are the policies of a government that values all human life. Oh and Jews are culturally indigenous to Israel. Always have been, always will be.

[@albanianbear8578]

@@ostrados Also the majority does NOT support Palestine

[@sitorp116]

Canaanites are from Africa. Canaan who is the son of Ham is from Africa. Therefore Arabians and Canaanites are NOT the same people. Stop lying to yourself. In what is called Israel today was the land of Judea held by the 12 tribes of Judah. Islam was created 1500 years after Christianity. Judaism is older than Islam and Christianity.

[@Karen-dk1ec]

Th Roman general replaced the Kingdom of Judea with Palestina-Syria, over time it was Palestine. The Ottoman Empire gave a completely different name. The British Mandate used the term Palestine as a territory not a sovereign state. Jews and Arabs living there were referred to Palestinians. It was Arafat in 1965 that developed the terms, Palestine and Palestinian as an identity.

[@irihodgson804]

Genesis 32:28 - KJV “And he said, Thy name shall be called no more Jacob, but Israel: for as a prince hast thou power with God and with men, and hast prevailed.”

[@yansideabacoa6257]

“Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece, Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη) in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea. Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.” This is the actual history. “Pelesheth” does NOT mean invaders. It comes from the Hebrew root word “palash” [פָלַשׁ] which means “act of mourning” or “to roll in”, and has been transliterated as roll and wallow, and there’s speculation it was applied in migratory terms. Additionally, modern palestinians are not exclusively descended from Philistines, but also Canaanites and Jews themselves.

[@youronlyboyyasser5095]

@@yansideabacoa6257 thank you for the detail, learning more from you

[@claudioborton4394]

Ce que tu dis là je ne cesse de le répéter partout. Souvent dans des pays arabes où je voyage beaucoup. Je m’identifie totalement à ta démarche.

[@globist9527]

Moi aussi

[@orit1551]

יישר כוח! אני ישראלית שגרה בחו"ל ואני מופתעת לטובה על האנגלית הרהוטה שלך ...כול הכבוד הארת את עיני

[@rockysandman5489]

נדמה שהוא ישראלי שגר בארה"ב, הרי יש לו סרטונים אחרים בערוץ בהם הוא משוחח עם אנשים ברחוב לגבי נושאים בקשר ליהודים, פלסטינים, וישראל. עושה עבודת קודש בלייצג אותנו.

[@emanuelyasheav1040]

השאלה אם שמעתם אותו מדבר בעברית...

[@orelbandela9352]

@@emanuelyasheav1040 כן הוא מדבר עברית, ושירת בצהל

[@eden5260]

עברית במבטא אמריקאי.

[@Azraenore]

What languace is this? :0

[@bebopkirby]

One thing for sure, whatever wonderful future Rudy sees for the Palestinians is not going to be viewed as such by the Palestinians.

[@Malodaiofficial]

Never change Israeli jews are outsider, if I called Palestinian are included Muslim jew and Christians of native region of Palestine.

[@asalamabyebye]

My grandparents were kicked out of their homes in Palestine in 1948 and I cannot agree more with the last statement you made. 10:03

[@sitiyati6515]

Im from Malaysia we will always support u

[@asalamabyebye]

Erik Rabe Røstad I think you should elaborate on this.

[@sitiyati6515]

@@asalamabyebye i believe philistine had related to palestinian. I need true fact source to prove the relative it. So lets world know philistine is there same time with Judah.

[@sitiyati6515]

sorry for interrupt.The word philistine (plistim in Hebrew) had mentioned more than 30 times in Old Testament of Bible. If believe all of u know bible write in Hebrew. Then the philistine ancient found actually are Canaanite. The canaanite that being match DNA by archeologist at West Jordan, Beirut and North Israel is same in bronze and iron age. This is reported by National Geography research. Not by religion book claim. So its prove that canaanite that mentioned in bible its true. On 2019 national geographic report that canaanite DNA found in Jews and palestinian that call arab by your people. On the same research they found more than 50% palestinian decent is no from arab but from Lavant, syria, egypt and Jordan. They found palestinian had match DNA with canaanite research by American University Beirut. But suprissing most Jewis DNA match to Canaanite nit Jews. Probably inter-marriage. The most amazing is Jews and palestinian only had around 70% match. More 90% match to Canaanite is Lebanese and lavant. This research and proven DNA reported in National Geography and registered Journal. So i think with ur ideology mean Lebanese and Lavant can come back in future claim their land too there. So learn to share my lovely Israel people. I was still under my research and collecting as much research reference by truly source.

[@Simpleworkathome]

@@asalamabyebye were they literally kicked out?

[@christoabbe]

We need to give the land to the stone age ppl who lived there first around 150,000 years ago. It's their land

[@TorahEternity]

Who are they? They have no mark on that land. Where ever you dig in Israel you find Jewish history

[@michelbitt1]

A small correction at the time of the ottoman empire the region that included Lebanon Syria and Israel was called Arabic: ٱلشَّام‎, Ash-Shām;or grater Syria In the later ages of the Ottoman times, it was divided into wilayahs or sub-provinces the borders of which and the choice of cities as seats of government within them varied over time. The vilayets or sub-provinces of Aleppo, Damascus, and Beirut, in addition to the two special districts of Mount Lebanon and Jerusalem Jerusalem consisted of the land south of the Galilee and west of the Jordan River and the Wadi Arabah. THERE WAS NEVER A STATE CALLED PALESTINE. NO CAPITAL NO FLAG !!!!

[@Klopp2543]

Flags,states and nationhood is less than 200yrs old? Did you know that? No flag,state does not mean no people?

[@radiozelaza]

Do you have any information about the number of Muslim Bosniaks and Albanians resettled by Ottomans into the lands of the later British Mandate, who eventually became "Palestinians"?

[@ayjayeh]

can you give the source for this? (put the references).

[@fresiamaldonado3609]

Extremely important .thanks

[@modestpublican1617]

Palestine was never mentioned in the Quran. But Israel and the Jewish people were mentioned numerous amount of times. The state of Israel belongs to the the Jewish people

[@truearyan1217]

ShinigamiUzi how so?

[@roshanigladson9331]

@ShinigamiUzi how so?

[@subchan6595]

Jerusalem is mentioned 700 times in the Jewish Torah. I think that says it ALL. Pallywood is biggest modern day LIE.