Origins of the Muslim Brotherhood

[@CaspianReport]

Special thanks to NordVPN for making this report possible! ✔ GET NORDVPN ► nordvpn.com/caspianreport ✔ USE COUPON CODE ► caspianreport ✔ USE THE CODE SO YOU CAN GET 70% off 3-year plan + 4 months free

[@youtubeunofficial6323]

Long live Muslim Brotherhood Long live Ottoman ( 🇹🇷 Turkey) And Persian (🇮🇷 Iran)

[@youtubeunofficial6323]

But we create our own version of world orders . Iran is the best example of making a New anti satanic world since 1979 . After 100 year Turkey is restoring it self as a major global power .

[@youtubeunofficial6323]

Our existence means the existence of 🇮🇷islamic republic of Iran 🇮🇷 , 🇹🇷powerful indipendent Turkey 🇹🇷 and 🏳️islamic Emirates of Afghanistan🏳️ is your failure... A failure. to the lsrâel made and lead New World Order which is followed by innocent or (brainless 0r puppet government of ) Christian and liberal Muslim counties

[@drunkensailor3736]

@CaspainReport When can we expect you tp talk about the ongoing SEPARATIST crisis in Yemen? Is the country doomed to be divided? I think so at least based on this analysis of the Yemen separatist crisis, Civil War and US involvement in it: kzbin.info/www/bejne/paLTeYlprad2eKc Your thoughts?

[@sijut1515]

can u make a video of muslim nationalism

[@kenansaaloukeh2165]

Would love an episode on the Assad family and pre-Assad Syria.

[@morisco56]

@Prolific Vision 2020 also yom kippur, lebanon and their own civil war

[@ZioStalin]

@@morisco56 This is Lebanon's civil war kzbin.info/www/bejne/jpiXi2Sfnt5qibM

[@rawanissa5306]

No!

[@eget4144]

This video would be exciting

[@tabletodestroyer8174]

@X Salz yes right.

[@laithalabri8456]

Hey Shirvan, thank you for another enlightening video. A small suggestion for future videos: It can often be somewhat difficult to keep up with foreign names (individuals, groups, or places), so I think it would help immensely if names appeared on screen when subjects are introduced. I know when captions are ready for the video that this is no longer a problem, but I think it would just be very helpful to see the words on the screen, for ease of further research and memory retention. Keep up the phenomenal work!

[@ebusanta001]

keep upvoting this comment, people!

Yes, I absolutely agree with this. I do not take pride in not understanding the Arab world and its culture, but such details would definitely help us all to pay attention and understand everything that's being said in the video.

[@peternagy6067]

It would be very helpful

[@actionman4520]

@ Odakle si Proka?Dalmatinac sigurno hehe

[@MrVenc-ef8fm]

Maybe even if the names were colored by different colours. That would make the names more striking to the eye and easy to remember if they were brought back later on the video.

[@GeoPerspective]

Caspian Report videos need to be watched with a pen and notepad at hand!

[@drunkensailor3736]

Truly a learning moment. I'd love to see him talk about the situation with Separatists in Yemen? There’s a great video analysing the Yemen secession crisis as well as a background explainer of Yemen's Civil War and US involvement in it: kzbin.info/www/bejne/paLTeYlprad2eKc

[@yousuck785why]

CR is a great youtuber

[@DuLzzPKC]

@@drunkensailor3736 yeah the situation in Yemen is distressing and no one is mentioning it. idiots saudi government. if u want to fight the houthis why not invade with ground troops but the idiots blockaded Yemen and airstriking there.

[@ivanfreely6366]

@@DuLzzPKC The Saudis aren't known for their fighting ability. Thus, they hire UK/US mercenaries.

[@lyrieladuial4901]

That nasser guy has some nice performance on television, playing his oponents with wit and a sympathetic smile.

[@dodovomitory3496]

he's a n word

[@fadhlanarmon3670]

@@dodovomitory3496 why even say this?

[@hendrikdependrik1891]

He had so much charisma the people blocked him from resignation after being extremely humiliated by Israel.

[@kingi97]

@HendrikdePendrik That was actually staged. Like many other fake events he purputrated: Virgin Mary appearence, assasination attempt, indigenous egyptian supersonic fighter and so fort. Classic machiavelian ruling style.

[@youssefhany546]

@@kingi97 No it was not staged.I know various Old people who were Imprisoned by him and sing his praises Until this day.

[@prashanthb6521]

Beautiful story telling by CaspianReport !

[@ungrateful-66]

He does have a nice voice, doesn’t he? It surely does help!

[@abdo5615]

Hello, Shirvan! Greetings from the heart of the Delta in Egypt! I think this was a great and unbiased video that explained the situation really well. Thank you for making these videos and enlightening both us and the West about our current situation here in the Arab world. Please keep on going

[@darkmatter4132]

@Δημήτρης Ντάβος I don't think Egypt will be involved directly in the war between haftar and the GNA

[@abdo5615]

@Δημήτρης Ντάβος worry not. The chances of Egypt directly intervening in Libya are very slim. The economy cannot afford a war and the army certainly learned it's lesson from intervening in Yemen decades back under Nasser. The massing of forces on the border and the military exercises are only a show of force. The losses from intervening would be many times greater than the benefits. Plus, the armed forces have much greater threats to deal with, such as the Ethiopian dam or the insurgency in Sinai that's been going on for years.

[@arminius6506]

How's things going bw Sisi and Akhwaan??? 🤔

[@arminius6506]

@@abdo5615 You need no worry about finance, UAE would take care of finance and Russians would supply the equipments (BTW Turks have turned the tide)

[@masimooddo6011]

@Zahin Shahazad sisi is puppet so what about ur god erdoggan

[@nourmatroud73]

Dear Shirvan, your content is awesome - always a level and broad perspective ❤️🇪🇬 love from Egypt

[@githinjikaranja]

Thank you for your informative piece of work. I'm watching from Nairobi, Kenya.

[@panzerofthelake506]

If you know a Nigerian prince that lives in Kenya tell him I am waiting for my money.

[@mbathroom1]

@@panzerofthelake506 lol

[@ally_crawford]

Agreed. Scotland here. A firm believer that the world will be a better place the more we understand of each others identity. Videos like this help!

[@githinjikaranja]

@@panzerofthelake506 haha I sure will

[@edgelord8337]

The most scariest thing In any historical time is a people United by one flag and a common goal. Once you have that you are unstoppable.

[@martinp3166]

Ideas are powerful

[@GrandmasterFerg]

Until you're not.

[@dunloplego]

You haven’t explained why that is scary.

[@COLDoCLINCHER37]

@@dunloplego just look at hitler.

[@martinp3166]

@@dunloplego It can be scary or awe inspiring, depending from what point of view you have in the given context. The core concept here is, that when a mass group of people unite and mobilize in order to fulfill a goal by overwhelming force. Think of the Crusaders, the Mongols under Genghis Khan, the Arab conquests under Mohammed, the French revolution, the Napoleonic Wars, the Russian revolutions, the Fascists movements of the 20th century etc. These movements, as examples, each had drastic effects upon the the environments they acted out their ambitions in the name of a unifying goal/idea.

[@abhishekparmar6702]

Oh that Nasser's speech ! Ive seen it before and I was so impressed

[@itzikashemtov6045]

I will never understand how you can admire a man that got humiliated by you're enemy (Israel) so hard after the Six Day war.

[@ahmedhusain8911]

@@itzikashemtov6045 I think the parent comment is Indian, so i wouldnt assume Israel is his enemy.

[@BruceWayne-qe7bs]

@@itzikashemtov6045 Many nations have lost wars. But it's about how they come back.

[@Ashish-yq2lt]

I just found this channel. I like your videos because you explain things slowly and calmly rather than speeding things up like many other KZbinrs related to history and geopolitics. All the best for your channel and you have a new subscriber

[@DrMohGomaa]

As an Egyptian, I salute you for your in depth and largely accurate way in explaining modern Egyptian history. However, you mentioned around 14:24 that the Muslim Brotherhood was responsible for assassinating Sadat, which is not true. Sadat was assassinated by another militant islamist organization that has no relationship with the Muslim Brotherhood. Also, you mentioned that the Mubarak regime used them as a tool to assassinate people which is also inaccurate.

[@_robustus_]

I’m so early there’s no one here to fight with.

[@fightttttt]

hate it when that happens

[@zaidshah4535]

Hahaha

[@Sh-hj8zk]

I’m here now go on say something, let’s begin

[@ItsukiandYN]

Muslims are too talkative

[@ItsukiandYN]

Is this curse of 'allah'?

[@hughwalters5701]

You’re the best geopolitical commentator on this platform. Now that I say it, you’re one of the best on any platform. Bought a hoodie to support you and I look forward to your future content.

[@Solbm27]

Love the content and love the work you guys do on researching and putting together these extremely informative videos. Kudos. Perhaps you may want to consider posting some bibliographical sources and citations to each of these? it would make for an even more evidence-based work. But, thanks a mil for making it available!

[@مرحبابك-ض1ن]

An offshoot assassinated Sadat for recognizing Israel, which had already caused Egypt to be expelled from the Arab League. Omitting this context is unforgivable.

[@lawbringer9857]

مرحبا بك Chill dude it's not that serious. Egypt has too many of its own problems to be worrying about Isreal

[@مرحبابك-ض1ن]

@@lawbringer9857 Ah, he was assassinated why in your opinion?

[@lawbringer9857]

He was assassinated for not supporting a terrorist organisation. Egypt needs to be careful before they become the next Libya .

[@MS-qd1jj]

@@lawbringer9857 libya was purely US jealousy and imperialism.

[@darkmatter4132]

@@lawbringer9857 😂😂😂😂😂😂 please don't push Egyptians what to do and what not to do stay busy with your business and your country before you become the next Libya

[@glenn2537]

Do one on the politics of the Nile River, a present conflict between Egypt and Ethiopia.

[@drunkensailor3736]

He already did. Search his channel

[@naumankhan8975]

there is a video about Nile

[@bakr6405]

He covered them in two videos before.

[@inferno0020]

Yes. Shivan has done it already.

[@burnttoast546]

You should watch the Renaissance Dam video

[@Brett.Crealy-kh1sk]

Very educational! Thank You! I hear the title Muslim Brotherhood often & felt it was time to learn about them. I appreciate this video! 👍

[@sharadchandakacherla8268]

The photos/artwork were so good. Great going shirvan. Btw you are Azeri, is that a common name there?

[@Ragd0ll1337]

I know it's the name of a city there... thanks to EU4

[@spoctone]

@@Ragd0ll1337 +1

[@Amitdas-gk2it]

And you are indian is that a common name there 😂

[@313asm]

It sounds like 'Shravan'. So, Azerbaijan must be a part of ancient Bharat. Right?

[@pranit960]

@@313asm if possible watch videos about indo European language origins

[@ahmadbabkier8581]

Fun fact : Naser himself was once member of the Muslim Brotherhood, and had trained the members of the group on guns

[@o7016-c7i]

Your " Fact " needs a fact check, nasser since the beginning was a secularist and issued a secular constitution in 1953,before the confrontation with the muslim brother,this is just a lie made up by muslim brother hood members and reactionaries that hate Nasser.

[@Omer1996E.C]

@@o7016-c7i no, hes right and this fact is very known

[@hasanal-mashhadani8112]

@@o7016-c7i Nasser was indeed a member of the Muslim Brotherhood even though he was a secularist. He did in fact take the oath involving the Quran and the Pistol, which at that time was the way they took in new members. It wasn't just some rumors to spark some skepticism regarding him sticking to his principles, because these facts were mentioned in Hassan Al-Banna's autobiography. And he died 4 years before the July 23rd coup, so Nasser was just a Lieutenant with no significance at that time.

[@parthasarathyvenkatadri]

Behind every military organization there was once an intellectual organization ... 🤣

[@Argentvs]

Rich intelectuals with an easy life, bored and angry at their parents is what have made most revolutions and caused the death of most people in the world. Such as communist guerrillas that took power. Rich kids should always be sent to public schools and made to live working paying their own shit without a cent from their parents to learn the real life and stop their idealism BS.

[@parthasarathyvenkatadri]

@@Argentvs But idealism is the right way ... the problem is with the ideals ...

[@dennyderawan986]

Argentvs literally you just gave ideas which makes you an idealist yourself Lol.

[@rahul__sharma__]

Very true

[@ordinaryman2299]

this channel has to be one of the best channels for modern history going, it is well researched and will inform any one who is a novice to the the well versed one various topics, well done !!!

[@zaneaulner4333]

First from Homeland,good job brother.🇦🇿❤️

[@azamkhan1526]

as salamu alaikum akhi

[@appleslover]

Aleyküm selam

[@nenenindonu]

Is the guy of this channel azerbaijani ?

[@ToastieBRRRN]

@@nenenindonu yeah

[@zaneaulner4333]

@@nenenindonu yes,he is from Azerbaijan.

[@goldenlight2577]

I was privileged to follow your channel after Dr. Aref Hijawi praised you He reminded you of good manners and strong description and praised your intelligence He said that you - think and learn and teach- I was excited to attend what Dr. Aref attended and thank to allah i could see your thoughts From Algeria - Shaima💙

[@sporegnosis]

A monumental video, with details that *I* didn't even know, given that my family were europeans in alexandria in the 60's. I applaud you sir!!

[@MrRambldor]

Sizdə sağ olun Şirvan bəy...belə mövzularla maraqlanan hər kəsə məsləhət görürük kanalınızı...tezliklə milyon izləyiciyə çatmaq ümidi ilə hələlik)))

[@ramsaravana]

Thanks Shirvan! The passion for religious & cultural revivalism and their factions using arms to prove their interests, has very similar lines of evolution in almost all religions in Indian subcontinent & south east asian countries too who have been drastically influenced by colonialism. Their interests to capture power is also so in line with muslim brotherhood explained in this video. Really opened my view on the similarity in patterns of both cultural and religious revivalism prevailing at present globally.

[@gaurav2412]

Now same brotherhood is entering india to make it unstable

[@Mahmoud-ko9eb]

This is probably the best short summary of the Muslim Brotherhood on KZbin.

[@sepep6288]

The Muslim Brotherhood didn't assassinate Sadat. Actually they were his political ally.

[@kingi97]

@Omar Maaitah: General President Nasser killed Sayid Qutb. Read some history.

[@Goodguy507]

@@kingi97 You're actually right I got them confused, my mistake

[@darkmatter4132]

@@kingi97 nasser who executed sayid qotb not sadat

[@darkmatter4132]

and yes sadat was the one and only political ally to most of the Islamic movements

[@sepep6288]

@@darkmatter4132 king Fuad, King Faruk and Hosni Mubarak had good relationship with the brotherhood too.

[@JanASS1991]

Amazing how geopolitical project (Sues canal) completly changed social dynamic in Egypt. As always- good job!

[@comb528491]

I was under the impression that EIJ killed Anwar Sadat, and they were independent from Muslim Brotherhood, and more of an Offshoot of Jamat At-Takfir Wal-Hijra? Like, they were unrelated to Muslim Brotherhood, right?

[@amrmohamed1387]

Yeah, this wasn't accurate.

[@adelannapolis4709]

u r right

[@o7016-c7i]

the muslim brotherhood has a history with attempted murder of Egyptian presidents,they tried it once with Nasser but they failed.but sadat was their buddy and used them to crush the progressive secular culture of the egyptians at the time so i find it weird that they would kill him.

[@emmanueljuma5420]

@@Cjephunneh that doesn't makes sense man because Sadat was in good relationship with the west and state of Israel he even signed a peace deal with Israel why would they assassinate him

[@Kenbow183]

@@Cjephunneh I guess I can see a possibility, especially seeing Hosni Mubarak pushing Egypt into the US sphere of influence somewhat. I just find it odd that why would Reagan allow the CIA to do it since his focus was more in Afghanistan, Central Africa, and elsewhere against the USSR.

[@fernandobeauregard7093]

Shukr'an for this beautiful video from Mis'r

[@avantelvsitania3359]

Great report, as usual! Just a little correction - at 10:53, the image on the left is not of King Farouk, but of his father, King Fuad I.

[@JabbarTV1]

good job spotting this

[@ytrew9717]

As a french, I feel shame belonging to a savage nation that oppresses the Egyptians (among others), supports torture and dictatorship, which sell weapons simply for... money. Even the nazi pursue less primitive goals when they did oppress and torture. I'm an atheist, I don't really like religion, but I believe we (westerners) should not have overthrown the Muslim brotherhood. Westerners are mostly too egocentric and selfish to be able to see themselves as the bad guy, but they will be remembered as such in history. I believe the next generation of french (or the one after) will ask forgiveness for what we are currently doing in the middle east as we hypocritically do for the barbaric action of our grandparents (war, colonization, oppression..), even if we aren't much less savage than them. Egyptians, I'm so sorry for what we are doing.

[@googleminus1442]

Lol this idiot does not know others will do the same to him if given the choice. The repression and religious persecution the muslim brotherhood enables is deplorable. Nobody is a "bad guy" for opposing and overthrowing the muslim brotherhood is not. Look before colonization how the middle east/north African region has treated Europe. They conquered and colonized all the way to the french border. Do you not know about al andalus? Did you not know they once occupied Carcassonne? Narbonne? Raided and enslaved people of southern France? When did they apologize for that? You are weak, naive, and stupid.

[@RamHadji]

First from Uganda 🇺🇬 good job Shivan

[@appleslover]

*Why are you gae?* Am sorry I had to do it

[@invertidols1307]

Can you show me da wae?

[@william97able2]

Wart ahh yu duwing? Uganda be kidding me....

[@TheNorthHawk]

Christ, these replies. This is your brain on memes, kids. Not even once.

[@chriskapou3519]

@@invertidols1307 why are yu ge ?

[@AbdulrahmanMuhammed]

As an Egyptian, I have to thank you on this video. I've seen and read so many reports on MB but never seen one that takes up this point of view.

[@Klassischergeist]

Thank you for this good video summarizing many aspects of the history of the MB and in line with the quality content you always offer us. I have following remarks on the content that I share below: 1. I think that the influence of Jamal Din Al Afghani on the early development of the MB has been overpresented. It is true that he contributed to the rise of Pan-Islamism (also due to his origin and the fact that he was mostly active in far-away Egypt but still his work was resonating with the people), but he is still ideologically quite different (more liberal) from the MB who received ideological influence also from Rashid Rida and also far influence from the Wahhabist movement of the 18th century (and this movement was not a reaction to European expansion in the region). 2. There should have been more emphasis on the effect of the abolition of the Caliphate by Atatürk in 1924 on the founding of the MB. That was the last drop that filled the cup and made Al-Banna and his sympathizers feel an urgent need to step in and make an attempt for a Islamic-inspired leadership to fill the void created by the lack of a Caliphate (and the failed attempt by Sharif Hussein to claim the title for himself due to the humiliation he suffered after the betrayal of the British + his military defeat against the Saudis that prompted the loss of Hejaz including the Holy Cities and all his argument for becoming a Caliph). 3. A key moment of the MB-Nasser conflict was the arrest and execution in 1965 of the highly-influencial philosopher and political theorist Sayyid Qutub whose books are still quoted today by different reactionary forces today. This contributed to the aura of the MB and different Islamist organizations that have no trouble to cast themselves as living martyrs among a considerable part of the people. This execution should have been included in that video. 4. The socio-economic conditions of Egyptians and the quasi-monopoly of the economy by the European elite were a factor in the rise of the MB but neither the only nor the main one (other factors are mentioned above) as those conditions were most important for the secular nationalists (like Mustafa Kamil, Saad Zaghloul and the nationalist branch of the Wafd Party) who used it to trigger insurrections like in 1906 after the Denshwai Affair or in the 1919 Revolt that paved the way for the abolition of the 1914 protectorate (effective starting 1922).

[@elizaher6110]

One of your best videos yet, well done, Shirvan!

[@TantiFighter]

The last time I was this early the middle east was still polytheist.

[@tikal5897]

Last time I was this early India was still a part of Africa.

[@kuwait__]

Tikal 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@mobashshirkareem976]

@@tikal5897 last time I was this early, there was only 1 continent...

[@dylanh04]

Last time I was this early, the British hadn't yet consolidated myriad Vedic traditions into "Hinduism"

[@sumlatinkid]

@@dylanh04 wait can you elaborate on this point please? are you saying that Hinduism was a British "invention" which is based on the real and authentic Vedas? i dont know much about eastern religion and i would like to know more. the only problem i have is WHAT AUTHOR TO TRUST. because i read MEIN KAMPF (original interpretation from congress itself in the 1920's to understand the "mind" of hitler" so there was no hidden agenda) and it is different that ALL the other interpretation that buy off a book store or online like amazon for example.

[@mohameda3550]

A job well done!!!!!! Informative and unbiased short documentary video. You accurately summarized the true history of the unfairly portrayed group in the Arab world. Greetings to you from USA

[@RisingStarOfKorea]

Clicking only 3 minutes after posting , I am surely the first viewer from Hungary

[@deleteduser8949]

Urban

[@thorr18BEM]

Hungary is in Korea?

[@sumlatinkid]

@@thorr18BEM no, its in africa. dummy.

[@barrybrevik9178]

There is no honor in being the first to post.

[@jonaramire]

Wow

[@sidschukowv6677]

One can't discuss the Muslim Brotherhood without discussing Sayed Qutb'

[@dmarbleton4387]

Qutb joined the organization more than 20 years after its founding whereas this video is titled; "Origins of the Muslim Brotherhood." That's probably why it doesn't mention him.

[@samuelj8592]

The British took Suez off the French towards the end of the 19 century, how did that affect the Muslim Brotherhood, what were the machinations with the British then? what about after the end of WW1? seems to skip to the 1930's very quickly then 1948 then 1952. I didn't learn anything about the Muslim Brotherhood from this video, except that they used violence only for self defense! I am not too sure about that. Mentioned Hamas in passing, did not mention where did they get their support from. or how they were able to thrive? great graphics, and a nice angle, but still left with so many questions. Frustrating considering it's a 17 min video.

[@drunkensailor3736]

The British have had their hand in alot of Middle Eastern affairs. Same applies to Yemen which was split in two by Brits and Turks. Now englulfed in civil war with Southerners wanting independence. There’s a great video analysing the Yemen separatist crisis as well as a background explainer of Yemen's Civil War and US involvement in it: kzbin.info/www/bejne/paLTeYlprad2eKc

[@werewolfhunter2011]

@@drunkensailor3736 The reason why there was a south and north yemen was because there was a socialist movement in yemen that ORIGINATED in the south, they planned to take the entirety of yemen but because the more north you go, the more difficult it is to fight in the mountains, so the south socialist yemen just decided to not bother and make claim to the land they have and leave the rest to the republic of yemen, which was dubbed the north. Now, the north was still somewhat "backwards" and very tribal and highly conservative religiously, as opposed to the very secular and open and "progressive" south, thanks to the british occupation and socialist government. Alcohol was sold openly and there was a brewery in Aden producing local alcohol that matched the standard of american or european ones, it was the only brewery in the arabian peninsula. people went to work or school mixed with males and females, females very rarely wore the hijab let alone the full abaya, it was even totally ok to wear skirts and wear bikinis on the beach. People could produce music or shows/movies or radio shows as they please and talk about whatever they wanted. Even ghat/gat, the plant drug thats plagueing yemen right now, was VERY limited, you were only allowed to chew it on non-work days, which was thursday and friday. It was basically like any other "normal" country. But after the unification, immense pressure from its northern neighbor to change their southern ways became too much, and the north being allied with the wahhabist saudi's made the south so wary. that were was even an open revolt that happened after the unification but was crushed. Genders were segregated, drinking, selling, producing alcohol was illegal, every female is pressured to wear the full abaya, residental buildings and any other buildings were neglected but in every street mosques were built even tho the country had no money and the houses/buildings were getting worse and worse. Even afterwards, multiple huge protests happened in the south but nothing came of it. Then the arab spring happened, then the houthis came, yemen again fell into a civil war and the south movement gained some momentum that there might be a chance for it to rise again and claim independence just like before.

[@drunkensailor3736]

@@werewolfhunter2011 Yeah most of those historical events i saw covered in the video but i didnt know so much about the social side. Honestly sad and another example of a relatively progressive Muslim country ruined by Conservative strains of Islam

[@ochaarul786]

@@werewolfhunter2011 and Now southern yemen change side, allied with Saudis. Is it right? How can Socialist/progressif movement allied with Islamist in the name of fighting iranian houthies. Isn't that weird?

[@Robespierre-lI]

​@@werewolfhunter2011you omitted the underlying geographic divide between Sunni and Shia sects in Yemen. A good way to misunderstand the middle east is by paying more attention to ideology than sectarian identity.

[@farazkhan7035]

Very good journalism. Keep up the good work. Love from Islamabad Pakistan.

[@omrimoshe3993]

I am a simple men, i see a CaspianReport Video and i like.

[@nicogray7352]

One of your best videos to date. Very well explained. Please make a video about the Hazimi movement next or something along those lines.

[@ashrafmarwan6906]

The statement that the Muslim brotherhood were "collaborators" in the 1952 Coup/revolution is simply incorrect. The coup was started independently by the free officers movement. While there were some brotherhood sympathizers among them, most notably Mohamed Naguib, the actual brotherhood were not an integral part of the overthrow, just another organization who wanted to get rid of the current regime.

[@the_faris]

being an egyptian.. I really am amazed of how much info this video has about the MB, I wonder where did you get These informations from. Great work as always shirvan!

[@bobmills2371]

Watching from Scotland, really enjoy your videos. Can you do a video on why Arabs don’t help Palestine ? Egypt even blockades Gaza and I don’t understand it ?

[@mfetto]

oh boy ... answering this question would be so long and complected .. it's he tip of the middle east geopolitical drama .. and it's is connecting every thing .. the reason why Israel was established from the 1st place .. the colonial heritage, the religion wars .. communism .. capitalism .. trade routes .. petrol .. just name it .. and it will have something to do with this question

[@stafer3]

You had it mentioned in the video that one part of Muslim brotherhood that wanted to continue violent fight and overthrow government went its own way and crated Hamas. And seeing how Hamas currently rules Gaza it’s pretty understandable why would Egypt cooperated rather with Israel with whom they signed peace treaty, under which Israel returned Sinai peninsula to Egypt, and which grants both Israel and Egypt yearly aid money from US to buy military equipment which had sweeten the deal, rather than with Hamas that would rather overthrow them. . In case of Jordan, Palestinians tried to overthrow government there, so once again, that government will rather cooperate with Israel than with them. . In terms of Lebanon. Palestinians tried to overthrow government there and to this point Hezbollah rules over half of country, so it’s not like they are seen in good light there either. And to be honest there are dozen other groups that hate each other regardless of this, so they will rather go to civil war than to go fight somewhere outside for Palestinian cause. . Syria is last the last on Israel enemy train. And they are in civil war. . And then there is underlying cold war between Saudi Arabia and Iran. And since Iran funds all militias that go against Saudi interest, and Saudis fund militias that go against Iran’s interest, and Israel is currently in conflict with Iran too. It’s seems like pretty straight forward enemy of my enemy and all that jazz.

[@mattpotter8725]

@@stafer3 Good summary, it's seems, and is very complicated and I think Egypt just doesn't want to get involved and introduce even more instability into the region. Also the last time all the Arab countries combined to try to go against Israel it didn't end up too well for them. If the border was opened to the Gaza Strip and weapons were found to be smuggled in it would provide Israel a reason for retaliation and so Egypt is happy to leave the border closed. It would be nice the think that eventually there could be a Palestinian state with open borders to surrounding countries, but that isn't ever going to happen whilst Hamas are in charge, and I don't see that changing anytime soon.

[@dancyprus6863]

Superb content as always, thank you.

[@MSA_madi]

ohhh this is unexpected. I thought you mean the general "Muslim Brotherhood".

[@TheTariqibnziyad]

Isn't egypte the birth place anyways ?

[@fefds1558]

what is the difference ?

[@degenerals6127]

fe fds Muslim brotherhood is an organization He thought chirivan is talking about the brother like bound between Muslims

[@EzekielDeLaCroix]

@@degenerals6127 Which one? Shia or Sunni?

[@MSA_madi]

​@@degenerals6127 yes. thank you for understanding. Ezekiel De La Croix, technically you shouldn't say which one...as I said generally.

[@brianjonker510]

I have watched many episodes from the Caspian report. The breadth of his topics is stunning and seems to come with a real understanding of the local issues

[@winstonbarquez9538]

Good report Shirvan, but you missed an important ideologue, Sayyid Qutb, who was imprisoned and executed by Nasser and who was an influence on Usama bin Laden.

[@mfetto]

Nasser was the only one who managed to deal with Muslim brotherhood the right way.. that's why during his time there was no terrorism . no sexual harassment.. and egypt was pretty modern

[@MySim14]

And Muhammad Qutb, his brother also, was a huge influence on the Muslim Brotherhood as well

[@winewomenwagesorg]

Sayyid Qutb writings are insightful. Athough I may not subscribe to them, however, within the framework of Islamic thought I understand why he wrote what he wrote.

[@moulayismail1546]

Man stop repeating the saudi propaganda.. Sayid qutb has nothing to do with Usama bin laden he was a WAHABI

[@altairauditore1398]

Every pan-Islamist was influenced by the writings of Sayyid Qutb, stop trying to make these stupid connections that we only hear on Saudi propaganda.

[@tommyjames9561]

As someone who is interested in geopolitics across the globe, but particularly in the ME, I have to say that this channel is incredibly overuseful and underrated. No biases, just background facts. Glad channels like this exist on youtube.

[@dudapvt]

i've been doing research on this for the past month!

[@bakr6405]

Although Shirvan covered alot, he failed to mention that it was Sadat that gave them political freedom to get rid of commies. Ironically they killed him. It was Sadat that revived islamism in the Egyptian society. This was his only failure. I also don't know if Mubarak really used them to make people disappear as Shirvan said in the video, but it is something I highly doubt. other than that the video could be used as a great source.

[@the_faris]

@@bakr6405 It completes what we already know about them, it just told us the hidden info

[@Yenlag]

@get there Like CCP?

[@altairauditore1398]

@@bakr6405 I dispute the Mubarak point also.

[@TonyAlmeida610]

Let me help you on this : modernity striked arabs (Napoleon invasion), some thought this is because they were too muslim (modernists), some thought because they weren't muslim enough. The Arab split into two forces then: the first wanting to change arabic culture to adapt to the west, the others wanting to return to the "core" of islam to resist to the west while making some adaptations. All arabic political parties can be understood through their position in this spectrum.

[@houssamassila6274]

Extremely well balanced report in an otherwised powder keg of a subject! well played Shirvan.

[@retf8977]

As an Egyptian that lived through the 2011 revolution and subsequent rule of morsi, I would prefer being ruled by the Muslim brotherhood than the current Military rule at any time. I am not an Islamist or a member of the Muslim brotherhood myself, but at least they are Democratic and want to remove the domination of the Western powers and the corrupt military from power. I hope all good occurs to Egypt, and that sadistic Dictator, Abdelfatah El Sisi, would be overthrown soon, or even dies.

[@adelannapolis4709]

+1

[@ImBananas4]

Watching this report it seems like they (muslim brotherhood) are more restrictive on what you can do. You would replace a military dictatorship with a relegious one much like Iran no?

[@ibnu9969]

@@ImBananas4 he said they are more democratic than current military gov. Whats your point?

[@CriftPro]

@@ibnu9969 MB against secularism which will probably turn Egypt into Iran.

[@mohammadnazieh6700]

@@ImBananas4 when the MB were in power they respected all other political parties, why are you suggesting that it will be a dictatorship? the two years in which the MB were in power are literally the only two years of democracy in the history of Egypt.

[@zhajjar4793]

Hopefully more channels will be as comprehensive as this channel is !

[@HikmaHistory]

The way the Muslim Brotherhood combined the religious and the social together was fascinating!

[@resistencialiberal9555]

Horrible.* they doomed egyot and help the middle east to be a sad place to be.

[@digdug1577]

Best geo political KZbin channel! . Your research and savvy video production make for a great watch. Do you have patrons? Love to support you. Thanks brother

[@ichheieferit]

Salafism/Wahabism was there long before the Europeans came.

[@mohammedalsuwailem9628]

Salafism is as old as medieval times, what you call whabism is an old concept called Islamic revival. Mohammed bin Abdualwahhab like many Muslim scholars in his times have intercepted that the Europeans might invade sooner or later and saw that the only way to prepare is to unite and reform society.

[@oghuzdynasty777]

@@mohammedalsuwailem9628 That's not true. Muhammad Bin Abdul Wahhab was against some form of sufi practices such as intercessions with the grave. He consider that shirk. Of course that's not new,. Also he wasn't aware thet European powers would come, although he dislikes the Ottoman power very much. I think the word salafism or wahhabism is stupid because those ideas existed long before.

[@fogshadow9112]

@@oghuzdynasty777 Abdual Wahab married within the Saudi family and together one being king of politics the other king of religion were used by the britsh to destory the Hashemite family ruling Hejaz. The cancer of Islamic world today is Salafi/wahabism. They are the reason why the world today view us as terrorists.

[@Contraband0o-w7x]

Fog Shadow do you really love committing shirk that much fear Allah leave ahlul bidah and return to the sunnah

[@kareemtheeb1478]

@@fogshadow9112 Muhammed bin abdulwahhab lived in the 18th ce. Ottomans ended in the 20th ce. Ikhwani😂😂.

[@Era_Of_Awakening]

well, not bad tbh however did you know that Abdul Nasir was actually a member of the brotherhood but when he gain power he betray them ?

[@Surrealistescape]

Im surprised theres no mention of the Brotherhoods alliance with Turkey and Qatar, who support them especially trying to establish themselves in Libya. Do you have more info about how they rallied these state actors to their cause?

[@shastealyomeal]

Perhaps

[@ashrafmarwan6906]

me too. But i guess this video was just focusing on their origins, not their current affairs

[@hendrikdependrik1891]

To make it more interesting, MB is also supported by George Soros.

[@sonofnike2800]

BCCI; Al Qaeda and British Intelligence. Global Islamoc Network. Check Phil Haney, an Obama Whistleblower; US and Europe are Inflitrated. Phil Haney is now Dead. He revealed how Obama Admin forced the elimination of Terrorist profiles from Department of Homeland Security.

[@AhmedMahmoud-tv9vw]

That's a rather late state of the brotherhood.

[@victornderu143]

Your grasp on history is on another level. Fantastic content.

[@rufuspanjaitan5759]

Great video! One more thing though: putting the symbol of MB in front of the swirling dervish doesn't seem fit. The dervishes are from sufi movement, not practiced by MB members.

[@the-quintessenz]

Just leaving a comment as hint for the algorithm that this must be quality content. I'm downloading it, so I haven't come further than "French expedition". But then again in contrast to French planning, Shervan's content tends to work its way into my brain and stay there in the section of "quality information".

[@dillon5906]

Always wondered about this topic. Thank you for the insightful video! -from USA

[@towhidrana7669]

Thanks for your video ❤

[@yardbird8135]

Useful video to outline the major features of the MB, albeit it's important to remember that the army officer who perpetrated the assassination of Anwar Sadat, Khalid al-Islambuli, didn't belong to the brotherhood. He was affiliated to the so-called "Egyptian Islamic Jihad" ("Tanzim al-Jihad") extremist group which wasn't part of the MB galaxy of affiliated groups. As disclosed by none other than the current leader of al-'Qaida, Ayman al-Zawahiri, (in the book of al-Zayat, Montasser, "The Road to al-Qaeda", 2002) " [the EIJ] is different from the Takfir wal Hijra group (the extremist offshoot of the MB, formally detached from the MB) as we do not consider people infidels because of their sins. And we are different from the Muslim Brotherhood because sometimes they do not oppose the government". It's important to get these facts straight as to not confound an already multi-layered and complex scenario. Thank you :)

[@MrAndyshanahan]

Dr. al-Zawahiri's arrest, torture and imprisonment as part of the plot to assassinate Sadat was what truly radicalized him. He went to Afghanistan after his release, where he met OBL. There's film of him addressing the court in English from the courtroom cage containing multiple defendants.

[@bramvanboom6322]

Interesting report Shirvan!

[@fightttttt]

Amazing insightful report as usual. I just wish it was longer and went into the Turkish AKP role in the brotherhood in the future.

[@essidmedamine8130]

AKP is not MB but something apart

[@fightttttt]

@@essidmedamine8130 "role in brotherhood" they partisipate in proping them up, find a english speaking friend you need to work on it :]

[@winewomenwagesorg]

Another solid and Informative video. Most Western scholars and writers do not venture this deep into the narrative you've offered. Again, well done!

[@yasarkhan672]

Shirvan !! I am your biggest fan from Pakistan.

[@heathenfire]

I am his biggest fan from india.

[@sarcastictaqvi12]

Even I'm his biggest fan from Pakistan

[@hugosetiawan8928]

The biggest failed state

[@sauskeuchiha6945]

I am pork fan

[@sarcastictaqvi12]

@@hugosetiawan8928 not the biggest failed state actually. There are more failed states

[@mohammedalshames7337]

Would be great to see a video about the complicated Civil War in Libya and the Turkish intervention there.

[@xberman]

This was a clear and informative video, congrats! It was a pleasure to watch. Please do a follow up with contemporary Muslim Brotherhood, Qaradawi and its offshoot in Gulf politics.

[@mfetto]

you've missed few important points.. where did Hassan Al Banna get funds to build schools ? he was a poor employee after all ? this point is very important because answering it will change the entire base of your theory 1- Britain funded the Muslim brotherhood .. in order to create Islamic movement.. to cancel and counter the existing national movement led by Al Wafd party ( Al Wafd was a national party wanted liberate Egypt from Britain ) 2- Muslim brotherhood had a very minor part in 1952 coup, Nasser was the leader of this coup, Nasser was young and he wanted a front for the movement , so he brought Nageeb and the Muslim brotherhood however .. Muslim brotherhood wanted to turn the country into the radical direction ( with support of the west .. to fight the soviet expansion ) Nasser didn't agree with them.. as he wanted Egypt free from both, imperialism and communism 3- Muslim brotherhood violence is not an exception .. read Sayd Kotb books.. it is the base of every radical group existing on earth right now the only difference between Muslim brotherhood and isis . it's about the "timming"of using violence while MB think they should rule first, then show their guns.. isis shows their guns first then rule - i do really like your videos, and enjoy the depth .. but in this video particularity you took the outside shell of the story and neglected the core .. which is the west role of creating radical organizations and dividing countries by religion Britain used religion in the Arabic peninsula during the grand Arab revolution 1917, used it again to create Saudi , used it to create Pakistan 1947 .. and Egypt was not an exception just their everyday divide and conquer

[@ahmetokay3264]

This exactly.

[@golagiswatchingyou2966]

You forgot one thing, the USA also funded and help the MB and many other islamic movements to help destabalize nations in the middle-east and elswhere for proxy conflicts, the UK right now is barely a power at all and has many pro islamic policies both within their own nation and outside of it, so while they did support the MB for a long time your current day enemy is the USA not the UK.

[@mfetto]

Golag Is watching you Yap..USA continued the British legacy I’m from Egypt.. during 60s we got Nasser who was a great president.. zero terrorism .. zero sexual harassment .. we stared to turn industrial and modem That upset lots of countries who wanted us poor and extreme.. USA is the main one of course They fought Nasser everywhere And made sure the next president is a puppet.. who unleashed the Muslim brotherhood on us And since then.. we are going down with terrorism .. USA loved the puppet president .. loved the Mujahedeen..

[@shabikhwanii212]

Yeah sure UK funded MB to fight them in the Canal region in 30s thats the most stupid info i heard so far 😂 it seems you love Nasser the founder of military dictatorship in Egypt one of most ruthless stupid ruler that govern Egypt in last century and enemy of MB so no wonder that your full of shit info are based on his propaganda

[@shabikhwanii212]

There’s tow pieces of info I would like to educate you more about first that Nasser himself joined MB and swear allegiance with his hand on Quraan and the gun in front of hassan al bana , second that so called Nasser’s Enemy (US) forced the enemies to withdraw from Egypt during the tripartite attack back in 56 😁

[@zupermx]

As always: awesome report Shirvan

[@zmustafa111]

I think these Islamist parties are by far the most formidable challenge for modernization in Muslim countries. Where ever the hold sway is just a wasteland. Sudan, Mauritania, Pakistan, Afghanistan etc. you name it.

[@mohamedsonofkemetegypt979]

True they are fighting us in sina and libya right now #egyption And they fight syria while rolling turkey right now

[@michaelruatfelaralte84]

You mean, its not that great??

[@quran1012]

Turkey, Malaysia?

[@quran1012]

Only only places where MB has been in power is Turkey and to a certain extent Malaysia and tunisia all other countries have had their own domestic groups not related to MB

[@apostolispouliakis7401]

I disagree it is not a challenge to modernization the desire to retain one's culture and tradition it is fundamentalism(in the form of violence) and foreign intervention that cause harm

[@hassanelsayed1774]

Really enjoy your episodes.

[@Maia_Cyclist]

During the first minutes my brain was expecting NOD brotherhood, joke's aside great video learn a lot, thanks

[@jakedee4117]

That's not a coincidence

[@MrkasperSOS1]

yes, they believe in Tiberium

[@randomka-52alligatorthatis34]

Kane Lives!

[@dansims1234]

Wow this is one of your best!

[@مرحبابك-ض1ن]

The officers did not turn against each other, Nasser just murdered everyone opposed to him so Egypt would not become a democracy. It remains under military rule today, only a brief intermission 2011-13.

[@redmo1494]

As an Egyptian I must say this is quite accurate. I know personally people in the Brotherhood and they have been discriminated against, including at work, and some even seek asylum in the chapter in Turkey.

[@sagardyenchilwar8762]

@bittercottoncandy Who???

[@moulayismail1546]

@bittercottoncandy Do you mean tariq ramadan?

[@abdullahbokov]

Assalamu alaikum!! Greetings from Chechnya and Ingushetia!!!

[@sintasirait835]

What's the story behind your user name tho? Lol

[@s.a5332]

Walaikum salaam wa rahmatu Allah wa barkatuhu

[@abdelrahmanfouad4164]

The thing is nasser was part of the muslim brotherhood and then played them and nagieb to grasp the power for himself along with his fellow officers

[@オッさんタイプXの日産に乗る]

Muslim Brotherhood soon they will return. insha allah with the almahdi..

[@ZAGAD-i2x]

No

[@farshads3367]

you have a strong monitoring people to immediately remove disliking comments! good for you!

[@expertcontributor8464]

I thought this was going to be about the Arab League from the thumbnail!

[@MPHJackson7]

Looking back I can see how it looks like it

[@yorkssery]

It's worthless league anyway

[@BoqPrecision]

The US compelled Arab governments to form the Arab League. It's useless.

[@danielalemu3029]

Arab league and Africa union are most useless organization. There is no one thing they have done without western countries approval.

[@abdelra7man87]

All Islamic based political in the region including Turkey and Iran are somehow offspring from the brotherhood in Egypt

[@marycavender7136]

Thankyou for making this simple to understand. I will compare what I've learned here and will crosstrain the info. 👌

[@Much_place8461]

Last time i was this early the middle east was still a colony..

[@abcd2222222222222]

No. They were riding camels

[@osamabinlackin1556]

@@abcd2222222222222 lmao we still ride camels

[@drunkensailor3736]

Last time I was this early Yemen was not in a chaotic civil war exacerbvated by Saudi Arabia...oh well. So apparently southern separatists have declared independence over there. There’s a great video analysing the Yemen separatist crisis as well as a background explainer of Yemen's Civil War and US involvement in it: kzbin.info/www/bejne/paLTeYlprad2eKc

[@ishandagar1]

Most of the middle eastern countries were “British Protectorates” not colonies.

[@toaster182]

@@ishandagar1 same shit

[@georgenafea7505]

Picture at 11:02 is for King Fuad who died in 1936, it was Farouk (his son) who ordered Banna to be executed

[@AhmedMahmoud-tv9vw]

The Muslim brotherhood formed during the British protectorate era, after the fall of the ottoman empire.

[@danapeck5382]

Thanks, appreciate the content, all the best

[@Hession0Drasha]

Any group or idealogy that forces the spread of a specific culture is bad, let people decide on their own and give them the opportunity to. That goes for western culture and the brotherhood.

[@moulayismail1546]

Can't you realize that you are forcing Liberalism by assuming that leting people decide on their own is the right thing to do?

[@moulayismail1546]

@@Cjephunneh Financing Hassan El banna to attack their interests in Egypt... That's pretty smart from them

[@Hession0Drasha]

@@moulayismail1546 not forcing, by definition. Giving it a space to exist as long as people think it's a good idea. It's not a secret that I think good ideas don't need to be spread by the sword, they spread on their own, on their own merit.

[@moulayismail1546]

@@Hession0Drasha You can't just give it a space without forcing liberal values... Everything you said is from a liberal background and the fact that you already assume that the freedom of choice is a basic thing. Some ideologies like islam are against "liberty" in fact islam literally means submission

[@moulayismail1546]

@@Hession0Drasha Im arguing the "let people decide on their own" part of your comment

[@kabdoun]

Im glad you have returned to the previous global map... it was so entrenched with your channel... keep up the good work

[@5aledSefarat]

How do you say such a thing as: They Killed Sadat so confidently without references?!

[@thorr18BEM]

If I recall, he publishes the reports with references included for Patreons.

[@ThreeBooleans]

Leaving a comment because I enjoyed the video

[@sjsudhdhhdhehdhdhshshs]

Reestablish the Caliphate

[@shihanafridhi9517]

Insha Allah! May Almighty Allah give victory to the Ikhwan Al-Muslimeen (Muslim Brotherhood) and the muj@hideen of G@z@, H@m@$. Ameen

[@lantinian]

Very educational as always. Thank you