Our Favorite Carisi Verdicts | Law & Order: SVU

[@blenderfox]

The "My office is satisfied", "Well, I'm not" scene is the one that sticks with me the most.

[@MMuraseofSandvich]

Badass judge right there. Judges often get a lot of discretionary power, and she used it in the best way possible.

[@RK-cj4oc]

@@MMuraseofSandvich Funny how you are whining in all other comment section about the judge using that " power" you described to let a innocent man go because a woman faked her ID and they threw a not deserved rape charge on him.

[@darkhorseash4337]

Yeah. ALL the guest actors in that one were brilliant. 10/10

[@moonqueen2k184]

​@@RK-cj4oc im sorry but hows that guy innocent??

[@RK-cj4oc]

@@moonqueen2k184 Because he did not know. To all his knowledge only people 18+ are allowed into the club. Thus anyone he picks up and has sex with in there has to be 18+. If she falsefies her ID and then has sex with someone while being underage that cannot be blamed on him.

[@bryanhernandez-kz5ky]

Always knew he was gonna be an ADA when he mentioned going to night school and had barba mentoring him along with stone

[@autwhite6797]

Well, he said as much, right?

[@carolbradley2639]

Any judge who says it's "Consensual sex when clearly it's not needs to be FIRED AND BARRED FROM EVER BEING A JUDGE.

[@voiceacticon667]

Legally yes but the girl lied about her age and knew exactly what she was doing. The guy didn’t know the age of of this lying girl. She would state yes or no weather she was of consenting age or not; on both counts that she lied about her age. Therefore, I blame the girl; I don’t care if she’s under consenting age.

[@JB-it5nw]

@@voiceacticon667 agreed. I feel like some girls that lie about their age should be put at blame too

[@MMuraseofSandvich]

@@voiceacticon667 It doesn't matter if she lied. Statutory rape is a "strict liability" crime, meaning ignorance is not an excuse. _I don’t care if she’s under consenting age._ The law does not care if you don't know what the law actually is, and attitudes like yours undermine efforts to address sex crimes against minors.

[@MMuraseofSandvich]

The judge was being blackmailed by the defendant for sex with a minor. He agreed to be wired up to finally bring him to justice.

[@RK-cj4oc]

@@MMuraseofSandvich Yeah no. Its simply a moronic law. The women having sex while knowing the is under 18 is at fault. Not the guy that sadly was lied to.

[@anotherdayanotherslayxx]

i love this man. he’s had the best character growth and peter plays him in a way nobody else can or ever could. if the writer ever do something to hurt him i will be suing.

[@j.bennette3390]

[@impracticalnuke]

Let me tell ya something. It's been 8 month since you've commented this, but I'll tread lightly in case you haven't watched the new series. But by the way things are going in it, I have the feeling something is about to happen to him because he has an almost clean record of not getting hurt mainly on screen.

[@anotherdayanotherslayxx]

@@impracticalnuke me too.. i’ve been watching and i feel like something with henry most likely

[@samueldixon8421]

8 months later I think the same thing. They nailed this casting. He’s made the show extend it’s prime. What a character.

[@dmf1301]

He was stabbed by that child psychopath who grew into an adult psychopath in season 22. He was fine, though.

[@cpmow831]

Carisi beautifully baited Marquivius into what he said. Barba did a great job. Reminds me of when Barba baited the dude into really strangling him with the belt.

[@dershaymcdonald5409]

Barba was INSANE but he did the hell out of his job 💀💀

[@ri3130]

which episode is that?

[@cpmow831]

@@ri3130 I don’t remember exactly

[@heatheraucoin5832]

@@dershaymcdonald5409 Episode 25 Acts (parody of 50 shades, I remember bc Anna Chlumsky was the r@p3 victim of story) After that I knew I liked Barba

[@dershaymcdonald5409]

@@heatheraucoin5832 is that the one he lets the rapist damn near kill him in court?

[@cnzhk5925]

My office is satisfied "Well I'm not. ....The long arm of the law can work both ways: " We need more judges like her in this world.👍👍

[@dershaymcdonald5409]

And the kicker carisi’s office was NOT satisfied they got what they wanted in the end fr. They had to say they were satisfied bc the judge wouldn’t admit to more but the fact the judge was like oh uh uh I LOVED this ending

[@redwood9992]

"the long arm of the law, can work both ways" the look on his face after she said that was priceless 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@trivonnereid769]

Him saying "nobody says no to marquis" sealed his own fate.

[@preciouswilliams22]

I must admit, Carisi used to annoy me when he FIRST joined SVU. However, in years since, Carisi has come into his own as a detective, & NOW as an ADA, he's matured, become more finessed, grown more empathetic, & become ALMOST as good as his mentor Barba... ALMOST😉 I enjoy Carisi😄

[@christopherzaki8052]

Boone’s better than Barba!

[@MeganAngel315]

I can’t stand Rollins she’s annoying as hell and didn’t really fully develop as a character

[@sam02025]

@@MeganAngel315 i love rollins

[@julnercelestin5843]

The last scene made me smile a little when that judge threw the book at him

[@tristyy404]

"If a 15 yr old has the constitutional right to an abortion without parental approval, how could she not also have the right to consensual sex." I would've lost my sh*t!

[@ThePokemonSoldier]

That judge, Ellery, let the guy go because the guy, Getz, had dirt on him. What dirt? Video of Ellery sleeping with a 17 year old. The judge himself had commit statutory rape. He later made a deal to expose Getz and get him and his accomplices imprisoned, and yet Ellery was still a judge, which Carisi did NOT like (and I agree, as the judge should have been disbarred and imprisoned).

[@khushiraizada262]

I don't know the full case I might be totally wrong but based on this clip, she lied about her age and gave consent to sex. In that case how is the guy at fault??

[@IllidariShizen]

@@khushiraizada262 I might not know how/why is it so but weirdly enough that IS what the law says he IS at fault. My best guess is to prevent 'ignorance' to become the same as the "self-defense' or 'mental-defect' shields many people try to hide behind.

[@rocknroll20024]

Same they would have too keep me back

[@pandora-224]

Right! like you are not a judge to discuss what should and should not be legal!

[@bellerain381]

Look at him! Our little baby detective all grown up!!! 🥺🥺🥺😭😭😭😭

[@angelaholmes8888]

I really love carisi as a prosecutor he's still trying to put the bad guys in jail and try to give the victims justice ⚖

[@BillyButcher90]

I look forward to when he becomes a judge.

[@wykeishacraft6820]

Carisi and Peter going to stand up for their cases. I love them both.

[@tragiclaila]

The last judge is an angel and a goddess 😍

[@robertc7232]

Excellent job by that judge in the last scene seeing to it that the corrupt rich judge got what he deserved.

[@mikebasil4832]

One of the best triumphs for the SVU team indeed.

[@debbiereilly900]

I have watched every episode since day one, never missed any my favorite drama. Thank you Law and Order SVU for 22 incredible years. ❤❤❤❤❤

[@mappingoutthesky]

When he threw up, I felt so bad for him! Poor baby

[@rosepuff321]

Always love some Carisi videos! Peter Scanavino is such a great actor and pretty handsome too!

[@terrywilliford2915]

Love the judge in season 22 episode 5. She needs to come back.

[@moonqueen2k184]

If that judge was in charge of the wheatly trial and not the judge who let a rapist walk free wheatly would've been found guilty

[@ohitsmaiii]

Only just finally binged svu and caught up until last season. Carisi is amazing as an ADA. I love that he's still full of heart and he's become more "mature" and confident. I will say I'm kinda disappointed with him not being as present in the series as he was when he was a cop. But I def enjoy him

[@jaylonwhite6217]

The way liv said “make it hurt” makes me want to run through a brick wall

[@cecillefutalan4143]

i've always loved Carisi from being a detective and ADA, i knew he wins those cases

[@myfriendcaffeine-tb2fn]

"Make it hurt." I love Benson! ❤❤❤

[@hollyroxy25]

He’s really the perfect man, he’s both macho & compassionate. If only they were all like him lol

[@crystalcoleman1985]

He isn’t bad to look at either!

[@sirkylanthered]

The judge in that second video was disgusting. That kind of circular logic only helps predators, and punishes victims

[@andrewevers2420]

That was one heck of an episode.

[@hannamouse1]

If I remember correctly, he was in the rapist's pocket.

[@ajvanmarle]

Not at all. the moment that girl provided a fake id the statutory rape case became ridiculous. You cannot expect people to do complete background checks on each other. Requiring that he checked her id is one thing. You cannot ask him to have the ability to spot a fake.

[@ClonetrooperCaptain]

While I agree that what he did was horrible, he is also not omnipotent. if she showed him a fake id then by all accounts he was not sleeping with a 15 year old as far as he knew.

[@dfmrcv862]

Yeah, but he's spot on with the logic. Circular or not. Add to it that she showed fake ID and accepted lavish gifts...

[@valor5080]

"Did you just throw up?" "No. . . . Yeah."

[@Animedingo]

I dont think that judge can make that call about age of consent. The whole point is that people under 18 are abusable and manipulatiple. Hell anyone under 21 is

[@voiceacticon667]

Legally yes but the girl lied about her age and knew exactly what she was doing. The guy didn’t know the age of of this lying girl. She would state yes or no weather she was of consenting age or not; on both counts that she lied about her age. Therefore, I blame the girl; I don’t care if she’s under consenting age.

[@RK-cj4oc]

She showed him a fake ID that showed she was a adult. She is the one that should be charged.

[@voiceacticon667]

@@RK-cj4oc thank you!

[@voiceacticon667]

So you think anyone who is 17 is easily manipulated and then in 1 hour comes their 18th birthday and POOF! All of a sudden they are no longer was at one easily manipulated? People can be manipulated just as easily if they were 18,19, or 20; they would still have a lot of growing up to do. Her being under consenting age means nothing!

[@Ashbrash1998]

​@voiceacticon667 That doesn't matter the law IS the law.

[@ceceelizabeth527]

I love a good Carisi moment!

[@bamilekewoman373]

I love Carisi's thick, shiny, amazing hair!

[@user-ve5ln5le9y]

IKR? His silver/salt and pepper waves are so gorgeous 😍 Reminds me of 1940s style ugh I wanna run my fingers through his hair ❤️

[@ELmayberry]

I pray it stays like that 🙏🏽

[@wykeishacraft6820]

I love watching Law&Order SVU episodes it is a great crime drama. Great Detectives that do put their life in danger to save and help others.

[@lynn8101]

I can't till this show comes back on this season I wish barba was on the show again

[@queenheart6167]

Yeah!

[@UltimaKeyMaster]

That last judge might be the one time where a GOOD guy goes "I am altering the deal. Pray I do not alter it any further."

[@subman23]

Man, I hope for that last one somebody thanked the judge

[@mattslater2001]

I liked that last judge. Justice Served.

[@bombombombobob2330]

That last part took a turn a BIG turn

[@hhh123837]

10:48 - Looks like Johney Sack went from mob boss to Judge in no time!! 😁😁😁😁

[@IraserH]

This man is painfully handsome

[@KingCon62]

The second one is absolutely crazy, a state judge has no legal right whatsoever to base his judgement on his own opinion of what act is constitutional. That is by no legal sense whatsoever, his decision to make. Absolutely outrageous

[@crazyaces2g]

The last one was my favourite

[@Mister008Gaming]

Same here. A lot of people get away with phony plea deals and it’s disgusting that prosecutors, attorneys, and judges are all okay with this. Brock Turner and Curt Johnson are prime examples of this.

[@BangsChansDimples]

He's all i got left now 🥺

[@nave712]

I was especially glad to see that Rory guy get what he deserves EDIT: Are we ever gonna see Sir Toby go to court

[@hhjm26]

I love Carisi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@mikebasil4832]

We will need brave judges like Annette Lewis more than ever now to make sure that real justice is always served.

[@marieblade0613]

Love the last judge, not today Satan! Lol

[@mason.11]

That clip wasn't from Turn Me On Take Me Private. It was from the subsequent episode The Long Arm of the Witness (S22:E6)

[@Hophbrinkle]

Some of the most recent SVUs have been hit or miss for me but one of my favorite recent moment was when that judge changed his cushy house arrest into actual prison time.

[@malloryweeks3306]

It seems that since Carisi became the ada he is going to have a stroke or heart attack.

[@London_J]

season 21 EP 11, that court scene is how a prosecutor does his duty, offering him the wire, then letting his hands burn on it.

[@violetchanel438]

She paints for vengeance was sooo good

[@inmyopinionnnn]

I miss him as a detective they should turn him back into one

[@eldridgedavis]

Agreed

[@alexandraanderson3988]

Mmmm hmm 😢😮

[@delmicortave]

The first 2 get away with everything hate that verdict, the last one is really good 👏. But I love sunny 😄

[@maddieharr7211]

the Judge in the 1st clip was Maria on Sesame Street

[@maggimaster]

Thanks now I feel old

[@MentalLiberation]

And both Luis and Gordon was on these shows, too. Go Sesame Street!

[@redmustangredmustang]

9:50. Johnny Sack did survive cancer. He became a judge.

[@podsmpsg1]

He's pretty good as ADA.

[@scribe712]

I stopped watching Law & Order: SVU decades ago. Looks like I need to stream the seasons I've missed over the years. At the very least the later ones.

[@Highspirekid13]

Johnny Sack flipped so hard he became a judge lmfao.

[@thomasharrington1477]

that second judge is not forklift certified. which means his actor did a perfect job with his role.

[@michaelreece2966]

I love Caruso’s passion.

[@mikegosnell2556]

7:08 Nice to see Janice recovered from her Epstein-Barr to become a judge.

[@rhx_ary]

??

[@erica70]

I KNEW it was her! My guess is someone figured out she wacked Aprille💁‍♀️

[@MrJacobrabbit]

Great show 👏 👍

[@jpsned]

3:26 That's Vincent Kartheiser playing the accused, looking just as slimy as he did when he played Pete Campbell on Mad Men.

[@ashleypoindexter6273]

And as when he played Connor on Angel

[@travisnewberry936]

I love that last judge.

[@kaferrat]

I like Carisi as ADA...but he spends way too much time in the squad room & at crime scenes. When did you ever see Barba, Stone, or Cabot do that? They visited the squad room occasionally...but it's almost like Carisi is still a detective as much as he hangs around.

[@JayBeeIRL]

I mean Barba was at the squad room quite often, but not until they "called" him. He definitely needs to dial it back.

[@shanaedidgood]

Casey Novak started her career in SVU at every crime scene then eventually she spent less time there. Jo Marlowe, though she was Stabler’s ex-partner, also spent time at crime scenes. Carisi isn’t the first is all I’m saying.

[@ELmayberry]

@@shanaedidgood that's true

[@LeoraSims]

Thank-you!

[@JeremyBearimy913]

Man, who knew so many of "our" favorite Carisi verdicts involved Carisi getting straight up Charlie Brown'd...

[@beebix247]

3:05 that judge would absolutely get disbarred for that decision

[@kamenriderblackman4426]

11:05 Why doesn't the judge just put out bench warrant for his arrest?

[@TheCoolProfessor]

Johnny Sack is alive and a judge?!! Wow!

[@fatty002001]

"My opinion of John Sacrimone as a man just plummeted!"

[@trivonnereid769]

Marquis sealed his own fate.

[@stickycherry96]

That’s my man 😍 he’s so gorgeous

[@AdmiralHalsey1944]

Apologies, but Judge Gallaghers episode is the 6th episode of season 22, and it's titled "The Long Arm of the Witness"

[@Hatsu-Momo]

Liv's reactions is me most of the time

[@GailB0707]

12:30 is my favourite

[@enchantedpropaganda]

Miss him as a detective

[@ryang54712]

Do this for all the adas of law and order. Not just carisi.

[@Atmo29]

Especially Barba

[@queenheart6167]

@@Atmo29 😍😍

[@ryang183]

Now do this for McCoy and I will be even happier

[@terrynasonisasupervillain9017]

Nice video

[@sheepdog8140]

Johnny Sack as a judge is pretty sweet.

[@milly7843]

Why is this a compilation of "favorite verdicts" when the majority are nothing but a bunch of frustrating ones? Like, I'm assuming that they continue to the actual verdict time, so why not show those clips instead?

[@ScarfaceGameReviews]

Johnny Sack and Janice Soprano are judges!? New York City never had the makings of a varsity athlete.

[@SomePerson_Online]

1:04 Oh Carisi, if only you were here roughly 9 seasons ago

[@aidenrawlins8709]

Yeah something about judges going rogue and making their own decision regardless of the situation really doesn't sit right with me

[@petershieldsofficial]

By dipping your wick?! 😅

[@otaviofrnazario]

2:07 Is that Brucie from The Longest Yard?

[@pachekko...ellobo3905]

Temporada21 episodio11 mencionar que este fue el primer juicio de carisi como ADA, y empezo con el pie derecho! Y esa mirada de olivia con carisi en el 6:37 celebrando la victoria, carisi diciendole si pude olivia, gracias por motivarme💪🏻(recordemos que se estaba decepcionando a medio juicio)

[@mckayleem3098]

PRO👏MO👏PRO👏MO👏PRO👏MO

[@sidneyatkins6678]

I can't wait for they bring back the episode where Henry Messner returns

[@Wickedreptiles]

Jonny sack moving up from mob boss to judge!

[@coolerjr]

As a third-generation immigrant I believe our border should be stronger. The number of criminals crossing the border into our country has drastically increased not all of them are people trying to seek asylum. Like the college student who was stuck by an illegal immigrant in murdered

[@killingerk]

the second judge made a good call

[@RafaelFabregas-c2o]

ADA Nicolas "Nick" Amaro Jr (Danny Pino) es uno de los mejores Abogados y Policías de SVU

[@grant8653]

A judge cannot just ignore the law because another law that has nothing to do with it is different then the actual law. They do not have that type of power.

[@Dysan72]

The last clip is from Season 22 Episode 6: The Long Arm of the Witness (not episode 5 as shown)

[@crystal7965]

no one gon talk abt hos they labeled "long arm of the witness" as "turn me on take me private"

[@tomwotton9]

Is that the end of Season 21 episode 9? only I didn’t realise this show did sad endings as well as happy ones.

[@jaredmcbrine4376]

Wait, nobody is noticing both Janice Soprano AND Johnny Sack are judges?!

[@stephh_m1694]

Isn’t that Elon musk ? 2:24 😂

[@nursekayc9255]

I couldn’t stand Hadid I felt like she was so corrupt she was the worst boss for Carisi