Our Most Controversial Opinions Yet (Agree To Disagree)

[@FreezerBurn]

Tommy walked so far forward for the pizza round that he became crew again.. oh wait

[@Flaxguren22]

im with tommy that pizza is overrated

[@SASORI55555]

Username checks out

[@Melkweg7]

what's the oh wait

[@piccoloatburgerking]

@@Melkweg7 Oh wait is that he's still technically part of the crew despite appearing on the main cast frequently.

[@AyushYadav-mr5jj]

@@piccoloatburgerking it's so sad that you had to explain the joke.

[@brisingrbrom9542]

You can see how much Ian held back on the astrology question to keep the peace lol

[@Lobossumi]

Yea, i would have went ballistic for that amount of bullshit they were trying to swindle.

[@zambonie50]

yeah I get that, don't really get why they included it. That convo can get super controversial, like saying "Christianity is over rated", so many people have such strong beliefs and putting someone in a situation where they have to explain why they disagree with others core beliefs is weird. Like I don't personally agree with astrology but I don't have a problem with others who do believe in it.

[@jmurphy0684]

Astrology at least feels less harmful to society as a whole than religion. But I also don’t agree with it.

[@VIRTUEL]

yea, it's fine, unless they try to justify bad behaviors/personality traits and or why they automatically dislike certain types of people with it. which is a little too frequent with those that are into astrology.

[@CEFG100]

I have had to bite my tongue on so much to keep the peace.

[@Hal_Law26]

Literally one of the things talked about in Psych 101 is things like personality tests, astrology, and the MBTI types, being intentionally vague so as to not exclude a majority of people. For the class I was in during my freshman year, we were given a list of the descriptions for the astrology signs and asked to pick which description went with which sign, not one person was able to guess them all correctly, and a vast majority got even less than half. Also, there is self-fulfilling prophecy, the more you believe it, the more you lean into those behaviors, which only reinforces your belief. Of course, sometimes some of that stuff will be right, a broken clock is right twice a day.

[@cass12234]

Kimmy and Shayne both have Bachelor's degrees in psychology

[@asrealkatsikaki6306]

MBTI is based on real psychology and it does work as a system to categorize people in (although it doesnt really do much for the scientific community admittedly) , theres also the cognitive function theory of mbti that is nicer to use, also the personality test as a concept is obviously a valid method researchers use, but yeah, those on the internet are definitely not scientifically validated i would also like to add that aside from the self fulfilling prophecy, theres also the barnum effect, and also the fact that all humans want to be both included in something and have a need to stand out, so astrology fills up those 2 needs perfectly, no wonder its so popular, it brings people together in a structured way

[@fingalh]

@@cass12234Shayne isnt in this episode and Kimmy agreed with the statement “Astrology is fake”

[@cass12234]

@@fingalh I'm just telling the person since that brought up their psych class that two members have degrees in psychology. Wasn't saying anything about the video 🤣

[@southgamer2154]

@@fingalhbonus, Shayne doesn’t believe in astrology either in the bumble dating app video he did with Courtney

[@bibarrel5111]

The look on Ian's face when Courtney started defending astrology was hilarious, he definitely held back there lmao. Kimmy is absolutely right about Astrology having such catch all descriptors for what are supposed to be specific traits for specific people. Our cognitive biases will lead us to believe whatever our horoscopes say as long as they generally apply to us, which all of them do, even Courtney acknowledges that it sometimes doesn't match certain people to a tee, but if so, what's the point of it then? And there is nothing to "study" about Astrology beyond it's historical context. It's not a science or any field of study for that matter.

[@bayunugroho9553]

Kimmy also has a degree in psychology, no wonder she didn't in believe astrology

[@jasontankable]

The doctor who delivers you has a greater gravitational pull on you than any of the other planets. Inverse square law.

[@thezx5795]

Courtney bringing up calenders was hilarious

[@leahstewart1002]

hi its a belief system for some people the same as many religions and its not meant to be a 100% science because many people believe its spiritually influenced. i think its offensive to even talk about in this context because they wouldn’t do it with any other belief system that hasnt been trivialized as a “female” hobby. i think it was nice everyone avoided directly dogging on it because its about belief and opinion, and its rude to say it has no foundation because it most certainly does.

[@VIRTUEL]

@@leahstewart1002 i think they meant scientific foundation. which is true. doesn't mean you can't have fun with it i guess, you do you

[@fernandoluzuriagaacosta5338]

I would have liked to hear Shayne and Damien's thoughts on the acting question. They have experience there.

[@notjustlaura6708]

I was thinking the exact same thing

[@thespankmyfrank]

So do some of the others. Olivia acts outside of Smosh and I think Keith does too.

[@Snowstorm...]

Thought the same thing. I've been playing that new Fire Emblem game where Damien voices the protagonist and I'm reminded of it every time I watch Smosh now

[@EPICpersonified]

@@thespankmyfrank Yeah glad Keith talked, but would've loved to hear Olivia and Kimmy since they've booked roles too

[@amyccc56]

shayne and damien talked about their acting experiences on one of the smoshcast episodes, and it was very interesting

[@slimcognito5221]

Ian is very self aware. I respect him a lot more after seeing this video.

[@justjoshing1771]

In what part was he self aware? Not saying you’re wrong, I agree actually so I’m just curious.

[@unlitrash]

@@justjoshing1771same here^^ im genuinely curious too what made them think this way

[@UncleCheeseBone09]

@@unlitrash probably the bit about acting and his privilages

[@rachelvining7321]

As someone that isn't conventionally pretty, pretty privilege is 100% real. I see it all the time. Nobody can deny it's a thing.

[@--Danni--]

At 18 I was 280lbs; I lost 120 over the course of 2 years and it was shocking to see peoples treatment of me change in front of my eyes. That turned me into a man eater real quick lemme tell ya 😂

[@zeekeno823]

it's also very real with money as well.

[@appledough3843]

@@--Danni-- You been throwing it back around town?

[@kenzienicole443]

no 100% im currently at my highest weight, and i wouldn’t say im the next super model of the century or anything remotely close. i personally don’t think im super ugly(i have those days) but when i see people who do fit the standard they tend to be treated better🤷🏻‍♀️

[@sebbychanforever]

Yeah, there’s lots of anecdotal examples of this, and I also learned in my psychology classes that it is a real evidenced bias

[@NejiijeN]

Kimmie is right about astrology. It’s like those Facebook quizzes that give you your personality. They’re all very general, and what you want to believe about yourself. “You’re very down to earth. People trust you, but you keep them at an arm’s distance. You’re usually very nice to people, but you have a dark side that others would be terrified to see”. Like great, just like everyone else

[@thespankmyfrank]

Yes, and also, even if there are pieces that don't apply, you just ignore those. Basically, you cherry pick, even if subconsciously, because you want to believe.

[@lemongrassass]

yeah but people who actually have a studied understanding of classical astrology they don’t believe in horoscopes that’s the problem people buy into capitalist marketing astrology and not from actual studying the classical literature on the material

[@NejiijeN]

@@lemongrassass but also like tommy pointed out, I think it’s a very first world idea. Obviously every country has their own form of astrology, but do I believe an American Gemini and a Gemini living in Sudan have some intrinsic connection? Not really. It’s easier to find the similarities in people who grew up in a similar situation

[@morningdoow2027]

True

[@user-kx6fw8ub9g]

That's the western media interpretation of what astrology is, and designed for people who doesn't have an idea abouy how deep astrology is rooted in culture and history. I'm pretty sure the Babylonians and the Egyptians didn't look at astrology that way.

[@shakeriddleandroll939]

Ian was so respectful about the astrology question. I think astrology is a lot of fun but it sure as hell isn't real.

[@Proudtman]

Exactly 💯

[@RikuVA]

Tommy is such an icon for not only walking off set for the pizza question, but for also _absolutely throwing it down_ when he got back haha

[@dopeknuckles5374]

Ian never disappoints he's the most logical person in the room

[@noface3641]

some smosh members seem like extremely kind people, but if I wanted a thought provoking conversation with someone I would actually enjoy speaking to, I would probably go for Ian. or Shayne actually. even after YEARS in the industry, Ian is more down to earth than most people I know. you can really tell his roots in the "industry" have started in the purest way and not from connections or wanting to become some famous nobody. he is a super grounded person. once in a while you will get to hear a real opinion of his and realize just how much

[@sweetembrace6706]

contrarian doesn't mean logical btw

[@dopeknuckles5374]

@@sweetembrace6706 he was tho

[@jolenetheredhead9761]

@@sweetembrace6706 He's just basic millennial; contrarian can be completely logical. I understand people believe in a 2000 year old cult, that changed in 200+ ways over that time; that people fight over? You do you.

[@GeekProdigyGuy]

​@@sweetembrace6706 Ian wasn't being contrarian, though. He stood on agree bc he understands astrology is fairy tale stuff, not bc he's trying to be edgy by disagreeing.

[@yeahno3896]

The silence after Olivia's statement with stars and the moon will always get me

[@dheavenn]

I agreed with every point that Ian made he’s very socially knowledgeable and he seemed to have gained a ton of wisdom more and more over the years, we look up to you Ian!!

[@ehtlamzone2525]

Wait so because you agree that means he is socially knowledgeable and has gained a ton of wisdom.

[@teabagginganthills]

How much did he pay you to write this

[@1li6na]

@@ehtlamzone2525 yeah that’s what they said

[@stephhalal9908]

@@ehtlamzone2525omg you can read! Astonishing!

[@gangamel5979]

"sometimes people line up with their descriptions" when you assign the same vague description to literally millions of people, you're going to get it right sometimes. Doesn't make it less bullshit.

[@Harathor]

Thats called Barnum effect, or forer effect

[@CaptHayfever]

@@Harathor Or the Nostradamus effect.

[@dugoo3405]

I also think that by looking at "your description" you may start to fullfill that expectation. Meaning it only fits because you start to act like what you're told to act like.

[@6MikeJones9]

Wait so I'm not an asparagus rising?!?!? It said I was a nice and smart person 🥺

[@dugoo3405]

@@6MikeJones9 Did it say you taste like grass?

[@VM13TV]

The astrology thing is such a major red flag. Ian had to hold himself back so much to prevent the argument get out of hand. I genuinely wish Shane and Damien were here coz I’m certain they’d agree with Ian.

[@pissum420]

The people who said it was real didn’t even know what the fuck Astrology is and that makes it so much worse

[@dirtspoon6876]

Fr lol I have a hatred for people that legit think astrology defines who you are and bullshit like that

[@mauricioraigosaclavijo8833]

Shayne and Damien are the voice of wisdom

[@JudojugsVtuber]

I literally just got into an argument about how astrology has zero scientific backing and how there is zero evidence that people are psychologically impacted via gravitational pull.

[@imnotverysocial.]

depends on how "into" it and how they take/preserve it imo, but it CAN be a major red flag like you said

[@johnsmith2875]

I’m sorry but Courtney being like “it’s not based on planets” just shocks me… like it’s entirely based on studying planetary movements and trying to figure out how it affects people?

[@jacforswear18]

@@Sc4recrow44 I mean, that isn’t true. Astrology is a defined word. This is like saying that gravity isn’t real because someone can’t give you a scientifically accurate definition. Her misspeaking is exactly that: her misspeaking.

[@GalactoseGalaxy]

@@jacforswear18 there is a definition for astrology, it's roughly "the study of planetary movements". just because humans "study" it doesn't mean it exists. the way it's studied does not follow traditional scientific research techniques and when they're applied it's debunked immediately. there is more evidence that it's a human construct and you can find people that can tell you all about the art of tarot card reading and similar tricks that make you look like a psychic by saying blanket statements like Kimmy mentioned. it's really harmful to society to split people up into groups and make judgements on them based on when they were born and planetary movements, very similar to how humans are grouped into skin colors and are judged based on that. yes birthdays and skin colors exist, no it doesn't affect our personality :)

[@HOVNA]

@@jacforswear18 Yes but astrology isn't real because it just isn't. It's feel good stories that replace your personality if you don't have one 😂

[@TheBleuWolff]

Yeah, it literally is in the name, but then again, it's difficult to explain bs.

[@trinifernandez8870]

I would say that it is the other way around; it's more a study of patterns than causation. Like, when an economist says "hey, a recession is coming", he doesn't cause the recession, he just knows what to look for in the patterns. Astrology (as I understand it, at least) is similar; It's not "Neptune is making you sad", but more of a "huh, when mercury does his little dance, it seems like everyone becomes a fucking mess"

[@lukefarrell1453]

Watching them try to explain how astrology is real has made me 200% more sure that it’s fake lmao

[@meyeneetuks4680]

Fr. That junk made me want to throw my phone

[@racheleden9008]

@@meyeneetuks4680 it was so fucking funny to me lmao my older sister and younger brother are into this stuff and i think its honestly hilarious

[@meyo3]

fr bro, the descriptions for the signs are way to vague on purpose, and there's actually a 13th sign that people who like astrology deny exist bc it messes up everything they once believed bc it changed a lot of people's astrology sign. Look up what Ophiuchus is, that's the 13th sign. Neil DeGrasse Tyson also talks about it really well.

[@biancabrooks280]

Like no. 420. lol.

[@TheMaestro1275]

@@biancabrooks280 I kinda get Keith's explanation the most, like the more you look into it, the more it just makes sense, but everybody else's explanations were trash

[@jacforswear18]

“Pretty privilege” is a researched concept. It’s not just that eurotypical conventionally attractive people get more opportunities in entertainment, it’s a day to day reality. They are more likely to get pay raises and more likely to be helped by strangers or believed/trusted by peers. Its not really an “agree or disagree” topic 💁🏾‍♀️

[@alliebonesVODs]

I assume "eurotypical" means Caucasoid, but conventional attractiveness is determined by the society you live in, and Caucasoid features aren't the ideal the world over.

[@gskate117]

@@alliebonesVODs yea no shit.

[@cass12234]

If some of these people weren't "conventionally pretty", they wouldn't have there jobs

[@jjaust]

​@@alliebonesVODs in places like India and Korea or China being light-skinned is seen as more attractive, people will even have surgery for it

[@noface3641]

10000%.

[@adriennemurphy7080]

“Mercury is in microbraids” may be my favorite line to come out of Smosh in a minute

[@joon1306]

Kimmy’s explanation of astrology signs was the most valid argument.

[@hannahkarver892]

FR, this is what broke me away from it as a kid. My dad cut the sign descriptions out without the titles, put em in a big hat, and challenged us to pick our signs accurately. It.. didn't work :P Everything is just vague enough to apply to most people, and confirmation bias made it feel stronger. Kinda like cold reading with psychics, but on paper. (thanks for being awesome Dad ^^)

[@hakuboii3996]

I forgot what the phenomena is called but things such as astrology and personality tests involve categories that may seem different from one another but actually have general and sometimes synonymous descriptions.

[@cassiefraser2069]

@@hakuboii3996 Its called the Barnum effect I think is the one you’re thinking of

[@hakuboii3996]

@@cassiefraser2069 So that's what it was called.. Thanks!

[@kalliedoscope]

But…I’m super into astrology and almost never read horoscopes? You are SO MUCH more than your sun sign. I was so resistant to astrology until about 2-3 years ago, and now I’m all in. But it certainly took actual study of it rather than just reading a generalized horoscope every day.

[@tramethozeine]

Keith's point on social media is important. Social media for influencers is so parasocial. They're not your friends, but they are relatable. You'll never really know them.

[@markwallace8924]

I’m with Ian on this one, the date your parents decided to have sex does not effect the babies personality.

[@zenkofox7894]

I have never been more frightened by a comment but yet my first instinct was “aye….he right though”

[@karinisvetcool]

I think the month you are born does affect your personality. But not in the way horoscopes claim lol

[@FineUser]

@@karinisvetcool How then lol

[@ismingo4264]

Yeah i find it stupid to believe that when you are born actually effects who you are as a person majorly. Yeah mayby the birthday during the summer thing is true, there is science behind that, But i refuse to believe that me being a Capricorn has anything to do with my personality

[@ryusozan_132]

If the moon can affect the tides and shit, I think it can at least affect your brain a teeny bit 🤷🏼‍♀️ I don’t think horoscopes do anything, but I firmly believe that personality is partially affected by when you’re born.

[@freethemg1]

Courtney's explanation of astrology made me believe in it even less if that's possible.

[@Masterfighterx]

It's literally a load of bs..

[@galev3955]

Tommy had a point tho. Not that I believe in astrology, but at least he provided a plausible explanation to why there might be correlations between personality and date of birth.

[@margaret_adelle]

Honestly, the more I try to learn about astrology in general, the more ludicrous it sounds.

[@elizabethdragonclaw2916]

@@galev3955 well yeah, if your birthday falls around a really busy time their personality may reflect how their family treats their birthday, but that's not what astrology is. It's not the fact that you were born under a specific constellation that shapes your personality, it's how your parents raised you

[@Lamefoureyes]

​@@galev3955 It seemed like he was talking about some sort of science of demographics (behavioural anthropology?) rather than astrology though. You could just as easily use a different set of names and designations and anything making generalizations about people being in the same environment would be just as accurate as astrology, because sometimes you can tell how people are similar and different in broad strokes.

[@bigsoulja73]

I actually completely refuse to believe 5/6 people have never blamed another person on a fart

[@lifewithmesarahmarie]

I feel like with THESE people it’s not surprising at all. 🤣

[@justusshed3009]

It's weird that they asked that acting question without Damien, Shayne, or Noah. The three who have been in the biggest acting roles of everyone on Smosh

[@LyncanShepard]

Totally. I go far as to say that none of them are actually actors. They are 'personalities' that occasionally do skits, as opposed to those three that are actually professionals. Ian could maybe get a pass with his decades of experience.

[@Theholyone999]

@@LyncanShepard and being in movies dafuq

[@pennyroyalT]

@@Theholyone999 The Smosh movie doesn’t count.

[@Ender236]

@@pennyroyalT they are in movies, have you watched any of the Smosh content except this. 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️ smh

[@chendror872]

@@pennyroyalT Ian literally played and voice acted in movies before (and definitely not just the Smosh movie) they literally made 2 videos about exactly that

[@chelseasears9807]

If You’re defense for astrology is “people don’t always line up with their descriptions” then you’ve automatically proved the people who don’t believe in astrology’s point.

[@Triairius]

Yeah... she was on the side that agreed with 'astrology is fake.' It was not a defense at all.

[@jellynellye]

@@Triairius Courtney is on the disagree side with Keith, Olivia, and Tommy.

[@laurabernardo1232]

i think what she meant was the sun sign, because a lot of people think astrology is just their sun sign, she elaborates further saying "you have your rising sign, moon sign..."

[@evin3806]

Ian correctly describing astrology Them: No that's not it 🤦‍♀️

[@cjthenarhwalking1378]

Also Tommy's take on astrology is not actually astrology that's just how birthdays work

[@jmab721]

He did not correctly describe astrology at all. He gave the usual strawman often used by bullies like you folks to criticise astrology.

[@Mayzmayz]

@@jmab721 Describe astrology correctly then

[@jmab721]

@@Mayzmayz Astrology, 95% of times, gets extremely misrepresented. Not to mention that it's an open for all subject, so it attracts majority folks who don't know how it works. Then those folks go on to represent it, which furthers the misrepresentation. Newspaper horoscopes, for example, are actually considered BS by people who actually have knowledge of astrology. Another strawman used by condescending sceptics is the *"pReDiCt mY fUtuRe wiTh yOuR aStrO bS & pRoVe iT'S rEaL"* thing, which is super inaccurate. Sensible/knowledgeable zodiac field people will tell you that birth chart is just a rough blue print & not some *pReDicTiOn dEviCe* which it is often claimed to be & no it's not gonna give you some magical solution to fix your life problems, it only guides you & makes you introspect better. There's lot of leeway & freewill within the overall themes that dominate your chart, ultimate change & decisions are still very much your own, not the stars.

[@angelomendoza6666]

@@jmab721 that’s the usual crybaby’s defense

[@Whateverworksman93]

Watching Tommy defend astrology and realizing everything he said has nothing to do with astrology and just American society and timelines lmao

[@alliebonesVODs]

lol right? I was like "oh, that's an interesting point... that is completely unrelated to astrology, but interesting nonetheless!"

[@yeastofthoughtsmind9623]

Yeah his point seems to be more that the time of year you are born affects your childhood, which can shape your personality.

[@spaghetti6292]

“People line up with their descriptions” Yeah because they’re all so incredibly vague that they can fit anyone. Also, half the population would self-identify as ‘crazy’ and because people are reinforced by what they’ve read, they’ll just think “oh, I’m a Gemini, therefore I’m meant to be crazy”

[@jamer2010]

Yeah, I'm a little bit of everything. I can be crazy and spazzy, but also calm. I also self-identity as analytical and logical, but like to write short stories and draw. 🤷

[@brianblessednn]

Rainbow statements, they're sometimes called. How many people say they're an "extroverted introvert"? No shit, everyone has elements of both. It's this same fallacy that astrology exploits.

[@youtubefan8646]

Yeah, I definitely side with actual psychologists.

[@what._._._]

*THE BARNUM EFFECT* The Barnum effect is manifested in response to statements that are called "Barnum statements", meaning general characterizations attributed to an individual are perceived to be true of them, even though the statements are such generalizations, THEY COULD APPLY TO ALMOST ANYONE. Such techniques are used by fortune tellers, astrologers, and other practitioners to convince customers that they, the practitioners, are in fact endowed with a paranormal gift. The effect is a specific example of the so-called "acceptance phenomenon", which describes the general tendency of humans "to accept almost any bogus personality feedback". A related and more general phenomenon is that of subjective validation. Subjective validation occurs when two unrelated or even random events are perceived to be related because a belief, expectation, or hypothesis expects a relationship. For example, while reading a horoscope, people actively seek a correspondence between its contents and their perception of their personality.

[@noface3641]

and that is, ladies and gentlemen, what we actually call 🎆science🎆 well put. sounds like real scientists have done more research on astrology than astrologists ever have

[@TheDynamicDiDi]

I LOVE seeing Kimmy say "Ay naku". Girl your Filipino is showing and I love it

[@lillyem3037]

When?

[@epiccael9871]

Searched the comments specifically for this 😂

[@simpayshenaides]

Oh my god its just a small things of course you are proud about that

[@patdeang]

time?

[@melanmask7653]

@@lillyem3037 6:10

[@brittlecharm]

"Spaghetti is basically tangled pizza" is really messing with my head and deserved to be noticed during the taping for a good laugh.

[@hopelesslydull7588]

It's a great line but as an Italian, I fundamentally disagree with it. Mouth feel, different kind of flour for pasta vs dough, how it's cooked, how thick the sauce can be. 🤌 Betch

[@gingerinajacket8519]

I mean when you drill down to it, the combination of shaped pasta or bread, plus a tomato sauce, plus a dairy topping, plus any ingredient you want as long as those base three are there, is a pretty slam dunk catchall By the same token, tomato soup with grilled cheese sandwiches and lasagna also fit this bill.

[@hopelesslydull7588]

@@gingerinajacket8519 A taco is a hot dog is a sandwich, right?

[@friedrichpianezzola]

I heard it and was going mad Tbh pasta and pizza pretty much have the same soul, you put every ingredient you wish along with them and you can create a good dish to eat, they're both a white canvas that you can paint the way you want, but they're definitely a different way to approach food

[@gingerinajacket8519]

@@hopelesslydull7588 Taxonomically no, They are both part of the U-Shaped bread family. But ingredients and formation are two different ways to categorize a food.

[@brocksells197]

At first I was surprised they included the astrology question, as it's something that is far more controversial than any of their other topics and sparks heated debates. But then reading the comments made it obvious why they'd include it. 100's of comments arguing about it getting engagement sky high. Great job to whoever thought to include that question!

[@PhotonMonkeygames]

Outside of America most western nations don’t care about astrology so I was really surprised to see this in here too.

[@vivimos_en_una_sociedad7758]

​@@PhotonMonkeygamesoutside of america most people dont believe lol

[@GeekProdigyGuy]

​@@PhotonMonkeygames most of their audience is probably US tho

[@-Offstar]

Ian: "if you're telling me that where Mars is millions of miles away is gonna affect who you are more than the house that you're living in and the people you surround yourself..." Olivia, Courtney, Keith: "It's not about that" Me: Oh my god they believe in astrology but don't even know what astrology is. It's literally about that, one of the biggest things in astrology is how Mercury being in retrograde affects you. Like Astrology literally says that when Mercury goes into retrograde it will throw your entire life into chaos. And yet they're like nah nothing to do with planets and hell Courtney even says that astrology has nothing to do with changing you yet THAT IS THE ENTIRE BASIS OF ASTROLOGY. The basis of astrology is that your star sign decides who you are as a person and that Mercury in retrograde and stuff like that will throw your life into chaos and change you. On top of that her explanation of astrology LITERALLY disproved astrology and she didn't even realize it. Cause that's all astrology actually is, it's making large generalized categories that apply to as large of a population as possible. And icing on the fucking cake is after they're like planets have nothing to do with it and Keith goes "I heard Mercury is in micrograde" and they ALL agree with him like you all just said planets have nothing to do with it yet are now saying a planet has something to do with it. Sometimes I can't help but question the intelligence of people that believe in astrology, you have 4 people here who all believe in astrology yet none of them actually know what astrology is and all of them have a completely different belief on what astrology is. That should tell you something about astrology.

[@ignaciopaz3737]

Was pretty chaotic to read, but you are very right Sir hahaha

[@dimilton3166]

Honestly, FREAKING BLESS!!! Love your valid argument

[@PoshPenguino]

it's just people with void personalities wanting to feel special.

[@prernap3104]

It’s weird - people treat it like faith which means it’s individualistic yk? I feel like people define it differently, especially since it’s a HUGE part of many non-Abrahamic religions. I know in my culture it’s superstition based - like a lucky number or a lucky day. It’s not that your fate is written into the stars (though some believe that) it’s that there may be patterns in the universe. But it’s different for everyone and the astrology today is veryyyyy surface level.

[@CJDaBomb69]

I totally agree

[@cassiefraser2069]

Courtney: “It would be nice to have factual evidence” Also Courtney: *believes in Astrology* 🤣

[@rickyricardo9710]

the thing that gets me is we have factual evidence AGAINST astrology. It's wrong all the time.

[@cassiefraser2069]

@@rickyricardo9710 literally - like if it makes you happy then go for it, but the fact that people literally refuse to be friends with certain people or do certain things because of their starsigns is so insane to me.

[@shatteredreality_513]

@@cassiefraser2069 Right?? Just like any other religious/spiritual/esoteric discipline, feel free to use it as a guide through your own journey (because shit gets hard sometimes and only rational thinking won't cut it), but never force others into it!

[@Alex-lw2be]

@@cassiefraser2069 I actually had a friend of mine who told me, completely serious, that she cut off all of her Gemini friends after she had a bad encounter with one. When I asked her whether any of them actually did something to warrant cutting them off, she said not really, they were just geminis. Honestly my jaw was dropped, I never knew people like that actually existed till then.

[@jacforswear18]

Spirituality and science work together all the time. They are not even remotely mutually exclusive.

[@andreponniah9900]

Courtney being overconfident in her dumb Astrology argument, and then being unconfident in her really smart every other argument is on brand.

[@drea94]

why are y’all so offended by astrology 😭 I’m not even into astrology but some of y’all are being weirdly aggressive about it

[@melodys9188]

@@drea94 no actually like i dont believe in it, but like why would i care if other ppl do ykno if theyre not hurtin anyone

[@1li6na]

@@drea94 nobody’s offended it’s just dumb

[@sweeteunias]

@MamaWuf but then again. who cares, im going through comments and i really don't think it's that serious, like y'all are just bashing them in the comments because of their opinions 😭😭

[@witcherye]

​@@drea94 right? sometimes people who comment are so annoying about subjects that are not that deep

[@hannah_sen_]

Tommy's take on pizza, yes. Pizza is great, versatile. But it is a little weird how obsessed people are with it like having it printed on heaps of clothing and other products. It became a sort of cultural symbol of laziness/comfort. So yeah it's not bad at all but sometimes it's a bit much.

[@thejest69]

Bacon and Cheese have had similar moments, where a certain food become a symbol for both indulgence and the mundane, providers of almost universal joy but also a key aspect to the individual personalities of the people who really like them. (and slapped on an ungodly amount of cheap trend-chasing products)

[@randomenvelope]

Yeah for sure, the worship is unecessary but it did help alot of poor people when it was first invented, just bread with all kinds of crap on it, kept life more interesting. Tho the main hero here is bread, bread is worship worthy

[@FormalFilmsProductions]

I a thousand percent agree, but it will always be my favorite food

[@angelomendoza6666]

I think it’s the fact that pizza is a food that can be enjoyed by anybody of any price range and super versatile toppings/ingredients; that definitely contributes to its wide popularity. Sure, it’s definitely weird how much people idolize it and make it into a defining part of one’s self, but I’m really more interested on why exactly that is

[@becauseimbatman1391]

I genuinely don't get what you all mean about pizza being a personality trait. I've seen shirts with pizza on them sure, but it's just a food. Is this some kind of American thing I'm too European to understand?

[@lawrencefosterjenkins8216]

"I don't care if you're a bottom rising..." --ian hecox, 2022

[@aberrantAnalyst]

It is absolutely the cutest thing that Kimmy said "Ay nako, ay nako". I'm glad she's learning more and more Filipino!!

[@eggled1566]

The dog talking opinion reminded me of one of Jack Handey's deep thoughts: “If trees could scream, would we be so cavalier about cutting them down? We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason.” And at this point, I would remind you that Huskies exist.

[@--Danni--]

Oh my god. Why is this so profound 😭

[@kato8832]

Didn’t one person showed that their dog became depressed because he became more aware since learned how to communicate?

[@emilythomson418]

Courtney’s comment about knowing it’s bad, but constantly having that feeling that everyone hates you and those types of thoughts was so relatable because i, up until literally two minutes ago didn’t know what to call the feelings I’m feeling, also definitely have imposter syndrome and it can be draining sometimes

[@codynoth4183]

Unfortunately those are typically symptoms of being a liberal.

[@victoriasewell1924]

[@Very_Okay]

for what it’s worth literally everyone experiences this to some degree or another (unless they have like, the confidence of a god or the ego of a devil lmao). everyone always is just faking like they know what they’re doing. everyone worries that their friends don’t like them or that their input isn’t valid or whatever. to some degree or another at least. you got this :)

[@coltenbystrom9973]

Yeah, overthinking can be a huge struggle for all kinds of people in all kinds of scenarios with all kinds of mental health struggles. It is a common factor in causing stress and is just one of those things that humans have to train themselves to control, even if it gets really rough.

[@monster-enthusiast]

I saw a tiktok of a girl basically explaining that astrology is just pattern recognition. It's correlation, not causation.

[@SoothinglyUnbenounced]

Ian could've just said, that we have Psychology, an actual science of the mind, to cover personality traits accurately. Instead of basing off their traits on hilariously made up, star patterns.

[@codynoth4183]

I utilize the Myers Briggs Type Indicator for clients in therapy to help give them a sense of self if they have real no idea of who they are or struggle with understanding themselves. That being said I always warn them of the "horoscope" or "astrology" effect that they shouldn't just throw all meaning into whatever result they get, but to use it as a guide to understand themselves.

[@ignacioaguirre9689]

@@blazehaze233 yup, it's astrology 2.0

[@DefaultName-du3kr]

@@blazehaze233 Myers Briggs Is too generalized but the architypes are real. It's just that the online tests for them are bullshit.

[@eoincampbell1584]

@@blazehaze233 It was but apparently Cody sees some worth in it as a tool for helping a person gain a better sense of self. Doesn't mean it's not fake, but just means that it can be helpful in treating individuals depending on their mentality. As they say in psychology: all models are wrong but some are useful. Just like how Rorschach tests don't really tell us anything consistent about the human mind, but can still be a useful tool in therapy to start a conversation with a client.

[@eoincampbell1584]

@@abducteeofearth1703 I wasn't talking about that dude

[@optimistic_cynic]

Wait so you're telling me that NONE of the Smosh cast has ever blamed someone else in their childhood for their farts? Like that was peak kiddy lying through teeth.

[@Scrofar]

Tbf, I never did that in my life. In my household, we farted with pride and credit

[@peterrichards6944]

I blame my son for farts all the time.

[@marvinmatias2024]

I heard Kimmy saying "ay nako" when picking sides to "wish I could read minds" but then I just remembered she was a Filipina 😂

[@mariambande49]

I really like that Ian is more involved in front of the camera again.

[@Quesadilla117]

the most objectively correct take on astrology is that it's scientifically not provable but it's harmless if people buy into it UNLESS they use it as a means to judge other people without even knowing them. It's a fun way to introspect about yourself but as soon as you bring other people into the mix it gets messy.

[@isais207]

Yes... Like religion or something

[@whoknowsnotme]

It is scientifically provable though as it makes falsifiable claims, the problem it has is that those claims have been disproven.

[@rafael3646]

People try to put astrology in the same category as religion but it's actually very far from it, it's not culture based on mystical being and whatever, it's missinformation and pseudo science

[@merp3373]

i mean yeah that’s the most objective take on any unprovable belief anyone has

[@mickidymac7144]

Its a game, people need to realize it’s just a stupid game. Treat it like the fantasy it is and we can all get along

[@shinlee3045]

Courtney: Astrology makes sense to me. Also Courtney: "It's nice to have some factual evidence." What.

[@handlerone5172]

She's not the sharpest tool in the shed lol

[@cass12234]

Queen of hypocrisy...it's not surprising. She's also a gemini...they care about that shit the most 🤣

[@MV-pn4vq]

Kimmy saying "Ay nako" made my Filo heart warm 🥰🥰

[@desta7661]

What time did she said that?

[@kimemasal]

notice it. hay nako nagulat aq dun a.😆😆😆

[@keonizane8506]

Same!!

[@diGeetalTravel]

@@desta7661 6:10

[@angelomendoza6666]

Napansin ko rin hahaha

[@leoramizz]

the way Courtney is wrong about astrology is impressive. She said to Ian "Is not about that" when is literally about that. Don't even know what astrology rlly is.

[@NagaFTW]

i have so much more respect for Ian just off that one astrology part. Ian is a king

[@edwardcompton9890]

While I dont agree with Tommy, I respect his conviction. That walk was powerful.

[@nocturnalizzie]

"Is astrology fake?" Yes, it absolutely is. Nobody will ever convince me that my birthday has anything to do with my personality.

[@NeonGeminis]

Tch, classic Taurus.

[@primaryone3468]

I think it is possible for your birthday to have an impact on your personality (like Tommy's suggestion of someone who has their birthday on a holiday) but the location and movement of distant celestial objects have no tangible impact on someone's personality beyond what their beliefs self-fulfill about themselves.

[@nullcheck]

@@NeonGeminis tch, classic DERP.

[@shannonplunkett931]

Idk bro theres no way that the positioning of the stars and gravity of that day didn't affect me at all like... thats suspicious.... thats weird

[@fiadhearthpony6177]

@@shannonplunkett931 the stars that are so far away they have no gravitational effect on the earth

[@eLeLhusband]

Ian being my spirit animal for like 20 minutes

[@noahdonoghue8697]

Courtney:" Astrology isn't that!"....*describes how it is exactly like that*

[@maxamillion6042]

Literally, she explained how it “sometimes” works so it’s gotta be accurate, like bro all of them are the same thing

[@artnodescc]

Astrological signs should be treated similar to what your Hogwarts house is, which is only tell when asked. People who based their own personality on birthdays should get their life together.

[@6MikeJones9]

@@blazehaze233 yes but categorizing people how? Exactly how Ian said, based on positions of astrological bodies at the time of their birth. Which is just laughable. I can't believe anyone falls for that stuff still. It's like people who still buy in to pyramid schemes. I wonder where their brain is

[@RodrigoLefevre]

Is categorizing people a good thing now? Wasn't it the case that "stereotypes are bad m'kay"?

[@Masterfighterx]

I legit thought she had misunderstood Astrology vs Astronomy, but then went on to explain herself, and nope..

[@dragon_reborn1123]

"its not about where the moon and planets are, its about a calendar." So where the moon is?

[@stantheman1797]

it’s funny because astrology is literally based on the LUNAR calendar

[@peterrichards6944]

I LOVE Smosh, followed since it’s infancy, but The astrology thing was one thing I kinda hated to see lol but I agree 100% with Ian about astrology. There’s way more physical things that impacts someone and how they act. Not a star alignment. I never blamed stars and planets for a bad day at work. I blamed the people that caused it. To me astrology is up there with some religions.

[@Scrofar]

Throwing out some prompt suggestions because I really enjoy this series a lot: - The original version is always the best - The art can be separated from the artist (ie if they're a bad person per se, but you still enjoy what they make) - You can't judge someone based on their past actions - Everyone is worthy of forgiveness, regardless of their actions - Food is still edible if you pick off the spoiled parts - First impressions are everything - Spoilers ruin the whole experience of a story - Selfishness isn't a bad trait - Christmas is the worst holiday of the year

[@mr.moviemafia]

This is my favorite new series of their’s because it truly just lets their unique personalities shine and leads to interesting conversations.

[@Floninjalo]

Smosh cast doesn’t understand what astrology is. Ian was the closest and was shut down for some BS.

[@ChiliSainz]

6:10 You know it’s a tough question when Kimmy just starts speaking Filipino

[@icemanfresh]

I do think horoscopes and astrology are a bit fun, even if I think it's fake. What bothers me is that some people take it *way* too seriously

[@mickidymac7144]

It’s a game lol, but there are always people that take games waaaay too seriously

[@JW-frog]

A huge fear of mine is that other people can hear my thoughts. I would never want to deal with hearing people's intrusive thoughts.

[@Aryaa._.B]

Astrology is fake.Ian this is your time to shine😂😂😂take the stage my guy 😅😂

[@nullcheck]

I know right. You might as well believe in fairies and pixie dust. What is wrong with you adult human beings? Grow up.

[@Aryaa._.B]

I see astrology as things written to motivate my ass and give me false hope when I’m down😂😂😂😂

[@piccoloatburgerking]

@@nullcheck Well most people in the world believe in fairies, pixie dust and divine magic so this astrology thing shouldn't surprise or faze you.

[@syrobellum1966]

@@nullcheck just say you're sad and move on

[@tonywoods4270]

@@syrobellum1966 you don't have to be sad to know that god doesn't exist....its called common fucking sense.....the position of the stars and horoscopes doesn't correlate to anything, there is more proof that god didn't create shit, than there is proof he did.

[@pugnaciousbanana]

kimmy: ~talks about blaming farts on dog because they can't defend themselves~ kimmy later: dogs are so innocent, i would love everything they say if they could talk

[@yan_dj]

I actually FULLY expected everyone to be like "lol of course it's fake" at the astrology question, how only 2 💀💀

[@calliph]

Bruh, they're California actors. Where you think all the rich hucksters live?

[@mauricioraigosaclavijo8833]

I hoped they at least had one brain cell or two, but they share the same one

[@ZchinoZ94]

@@calliph at this point I wouldn’t doubt if they buy rocks and believe they get energy from them or whatever

[@slipstream5762]

@@ZchinoZ94 Wait, they have the seven Chaos Emeralds?

[@meyeneetuks4680]

@@slipstream5762 no one should obtain that much power

[@travisgarmon9285]

I think the endless comments of people being “omg you’re giving total fire sign energy” “I’m a water sign lol” Shows how not real astrology is.

[@AlexHoltkamp]

My respect for Ian after this video 📈📈

[@jellynellye]

Thank god for Kimmy and Ian.

[@ripley4884]

i am with ian and kimmy on the astrology stuff lol

[@chestersnap]

I'm fully on board with Tommy on the pizza question. I've managed to find some combinations that I somewhat enjoy nowadays but I grew up hating pizza and so frequently just didn't get food at any celebratory thing at school. It's over-rated Edit: YES! THAI GREEN CURRY IS SO FUCKING GOOD 🔥 🔥 🔥

[@Judgement_Kazzy]

I love how the justifications for astrology always revolve around making it sound as vague and broad as possible and going "well sometimes people do line up with some of the things it says"

[@Lennus19]

In the 'astrology is fake' question, I would have behaved just like Tommy in the pizza question. I agree so much I would have walked to the other end of the building 🤣

[@raginggamer7207]

I would have walked so far, I would have been in Arizona by dinner time.

[@CJDaBomb69]

@@raginggamer7207 same

[@jacobwhelan45]

To be fair, Astrology itself is real. It’s whether or not you believe in it. Real concept but definitely untrue in its studies. I disagreed at first until I realized what the question was actually asking

[@raginggamer7207]

@@jacobwhelan45 well, its not real. That WAS the question. The moon affecting ocean tides and the moon affecting whether Im an asshole in July are completely different arguments.

[@Suo_kongque]

@@ThatScrubWolf Even if that was the case, all of the members answered the question as if your alternate form of the question was asked. If you took the time to actually listen to what they were saying, you would know this already.

[@johncarlosanchez7841]

Hearing Kimmy say "ay nako" just... perked my Filipino ears up

[@kaleighmagnant]

Is it bad that when Ian was talking about pretty privilege I thought he was gonna say "They weren't watching for the comedy, they were watching for Anthony" 😂😂

[@Jrod316x]

That astrology one says a lot about the smosh cast

[@vluigil]

LOL ☠☠☠

[@creatio_ex_nihilo0]

Is it just me or is Olivia always standing in the front regardless of her actual feelings on the matter?

[@psyber6469]

It gives her the most camera time and eclipses the other personalities, which wins her the competition.

[@tetrahenix]

wins her the competition??? There's no fucking points in a game like Agree to Disagree @@psyber6469

[@Cruzin105]

I paraphrase JME on his views on astrology: “If you believe that somebody, not even somebody, _everybody_ on the planet born at 11:59pm and everybody born at 00:01am the next day, they all have different traits, you’re a donut!” I gotta agree; how does everyone born on a certain ‘month’ have exactly the same traits, but once it ticks 00:00 onto the next ‘month’, somehow, everyone born then will have the exact same traits as each other and have nothing in common to the people born a minute before?

[@tigerlily2576]

This. And when it comes to people being born like how does it work if you've been growing in the womb for 9 months? Why does your conception have nothing to do with it but just being born does? What about natural births versus c-sections? As much as I love the woo woo stuff I've never really put much stock into astrology tbh.

[@baydiac]

Okay so I'm not die-hard for astrology buuuut... cusps are a thing. Someone born at 23:59 and someone born at 0:00 the next day isn't expected to be that different. To me, believing in astrology isn't done using scientific basis. If someone argues against it with science they're missing the point, just like they would if they tried to dissuade a superstitious grandfather from smoking out a house with sage. I'm usually most irritated with people who go the "enlightened atheist" route. Y'know, the types who just HAVE to tell people of any religion that they believe in fairytales etc. It's just antisocial behavior at its core. Newspaper horoscope columns are as fake as psychics who offer to help find missing people. But aside from that topic I try not to steamroll other people's belief systems too much.

[@baydiac]

@@tigerlily2576 I was a C-section who would've been born a Libra naturally, but instead was a Virgo. I was also an egg donation, so basically a test tube baby! Each day I wonder how much this scientific/human intervention meddled with whatever my natal chart is "supposed" to be.

[@bingbongalong]

@@baydiac It's not antisocial to criticize people for spreading illogical beliefs. Following beliefs and stories instead of evidence and logic is very harmful, especially when it inevitably leads to judging and categorizing people based on no proof ("they're a Gemini", "they're a sinner", "they're in the low caste", etc.). Sure, astrology might not yet be as divisive and harmful as other theologies, but less harmful doesn't mean harmless, and the more people follow it the worse it'll get

[@baydiac]

@@bingbongalong Nah, you lost me there. I have an extremely strong distaste for _anyone_ who shoves their beliefs down other people’s throats-being atheist doesn’t make someone immune from my dislike when they do the same thing. Just respect people’s differences and move on. No one wants to hear the spaghetti monster spiel.

[@jakehill8690]

I like how Ian described astrology literally exactly perfectly and called out how fake it is and Courtney just says "that's not what it's about" like, yes. It is. You dummies believe the gravitational pulls of the moon and other planets along the positioning of stars is what makes you who you are. That's literally the definition of astrology.

[@mayle2010]

Don't get me wrong, there is some evidence talking about the effect of the moon but Astrology in modern times is definitely more about being "on trend." Heck, an article came out talking about how the astrological calendar is off due to a month being removed when it was standardized. Like Kimmy said, you can pick any one sign and it's ambiguous enough to apply to you.

[@FormalFilmsProductions]

Exactly

[@drea94]

Calling people dummies over a fun youtube video is crazy. It’s not that serious 😭

[@1li6na]

Why are u so mad it shouldn’t effect u this much

[@JonazDrumBrain]

@@mayle2010 the thing is, like Kimmy points out, the descriptions for the Zodiac signs, and the Horoscopes themselves are deliberately written extremely vaguely, so that any person can find it connecting to them in some way. It’s a form of trying to categorize people that’s really only effective if you’re accepting of it. You could however easily read the horoscope for any other sign and find that it has something to say about you at any moment because of how vague it is. Same as the Personality Trait thingy, that’s also written really vaguely so that when you take the test and get the results you accept it because of how it seems to be defining you perfectly, but if you take the time to read the descriptions for the other traits that weren’t assigned to you according to the test, you are bound to find certain aspects of each trait that corresponds to you. The thing with these things is that they are trying to categorize people into a certain amount of categories, so that it’s easier to say “this person is this, and this person is that”, when in reality, it’s impossible to categorize people in this way since everyone has it’s own personality that’s impossible to pin down to just four or five letters, or one Zodiac sign. We all have a certain amount of each trait within us and it’s impossible to just set it down to those certain things. Of course you can to a certain extent say which traits are dominant within us, but we still have some aspect of the rest of them as well, and each person has it in differing levels

[@joannecendana]

kimmy’s hair 😍 kimmy’s pants 😍 kimmy’s everything 😍 ang ganda nya ✨ also ian really is the dad of smosh. i love it ❤️ and ian’s reaction to courtney trying to explain astrology is me with astrology in general (as a born-again Christian who used to be big on astrology)

[@bahananahana3381]

I may be a cynical bitch but I gotta stand by Kimmy and Ian. You believe what you wanna,but I gotta say astrology's quite a bit of hogwash.

[@Masterfighterx]

Quite a bit? It's as made up as religion is..

[@notimportant1659]

That's putting it nicely

[@GoggledAgog]

Not to mention a bucket of bullcrap and a hatful of horseshit

[@michaelcolon3940]

@@notimportant1659 That's the way u say it to 10 yr olds who believe in it

[@childoficarus5334]

its left purposefully vague so it applies to more people, like if it said "you will come into some money soon" when is soon, how much money, are the two vague components, could be a week from now, could just be a quarter

[@ExecutiveChrist]

Tommy is easily becoming one of my favorite members of smosh

[@echo8083]

Me after the astrology question: "I never imagined I'd like Ian more than Tommy and Keith." 😂

[@Suo_kongque]

Idk. I’ve always liked Ian

[@MadaraUchiha-.._]

@@Suo_kongqueyeah das why echo was talking about themself

[@iMightyRose]

Kimmy's little "ay nako"s are so cute 😭

[@lebronmauriciobarlow3327]

omg yess HAHAHAHAHAH

[@dremzki]

I thought I misheard, and it really was "ay nako"! So fun ahaha

[@ErdTirdMans]

Well, after seeing their answer to the astrology question, I'm no longer surprised by how badly they perform on Beopardy and other trivia

[@lalaparmz8987]

Kimmy feeling confused where to go and speaking Filipino is the cutest! 😍😍😍

[@Caleb-lu3zl]

The astrology question was basically like do you understand how science works or not lmao

[@mickidymac7144]

Unfortunately we saw the answer. Too many people out here not understanding basic logic and science

[@Caleb-lu3zl]

@@mickidymac7144 I agree

[@Q_LeLeqteur]

I love these videos. You know it's good when as a viewer, you actually enjoy hearing both sides, regardless of what your own opinion on the take is

[@vagenaut69]

This show is so weirdly deep and comical, you guys should do it with guests or theme the questions.

[@Chilledmocha_]

im glad tommy is still in videos hes a treasure

[@RoastedPheasant]

Agree to Disagree: 1. When you're leaving a hotel room, you should tidy it up. 2. You tip your waiter, regardless of service. 3. You should always tell your significant other they look good. 4. Respect your elders. 5. If someone is offended by what you said you should always apologize.

[@sunvaarah6505]

1. I completely agree, don't make the lives of the cleaners harder. 2. Only one exception being directly disrespctful treatment. You shouldn't feel obligated to pay someone extra if they are rude and/or aggressive. 3. Agree. 4. Elders don't always deserve respect. 5. Completely disagree, context is important. It isn't your responsibility to manage everyone's emotions.

[@lareso9911]

1. Absolutely. Hotels actually charge people for destruction. 😂 2. YES. They might have had a bad day! 3. You should always support your s/o, but it is 100% okay to tell them if they don’t look good. If I’m wearing something that might not look nice or flattering, I want my husband to tell me. He would also want me to look my best and vice versa. ❤️ 4. For me, it’s part of what I believe. Sometimes, it’s hard to give respect because they might demonstrate a bad trait or unkind words, but never disrespect them to their faces. 5. ALWAYS be okay with apologizing. Swallow that pride and APOLOGIZE.

[@vicious_cycle]

1: Agree, clean up after yourself, make things easier for housekeeping. Not saying you have to dust or vacuum, but don't leave trash everywhere. 2: Disagree. You don't deserve a tip if you're rude. It's fine if you're having a bad day, but don't let that effect how you treat other people. 3: In between. If you don't like, for example, an outfit or hairstyle, you're free to say so, as long as it's not in a way that will offend your partner and you let them know it's just your opinion and they can do as they please. And if you do like the outfit/hairstyle/etc, absolutely tell them. But if they ask you and you don't like it, don't lie and say you do. 4: As long as they don't disrespect me. 5: Depends on what they're offended by. If they're being homophobic, for example, and are offended by being called out on it or argued with, nope, no apology for them.

[@johnnymermaid2446]

1. Yeah ofc, obviously youre not obligated to deep clean it and make the beds etc, but i always get any trash out and put everything back where it came from. 2 . Yes always tip your waiter, if you can afford it. They would have to be a total douchebag to make me mad enough to deny a tip, which has never happened to me and ive always had the money to tip and still be able to afford food etc. 3. No not true, you should be able to tell the truth to them rather than lying to them. If my s/o got super fat and asked me if they looked bad i would probably say yes. 4. Yes respect your elders , but i wouldnt take flak from a random old person because theyre just as , if not more susceptible to being crazy than youth. 5. No ,false. people being offended shouldnt effect whether i apologize. People get offended by alot of things. If i said something just with the intent of being offensive, and without provocation, then id apologize

[@alliebonesVODs]

1. It's a kindness, but not obligatory. 2. I'm too poor to be charitable, but I also don't eat out for that reason, so 🤷 3. You should always lift them up, but you can also be honest about whether you like their fit/cut. 4. You don't automatically get more respect because you're older, but you should give common respect to everyone. 5. Yes - if you upset someone, even on accident, it's common decency to apologize. That doesn't mean you have to retract your opinion or that you did something wrong, just that you acknowledge they were hurt and that's not a good thing.

[@johncharitidis8906]

At the astrology part, Ian's face is me

[@vel5785]

Ah shit here we go again-

[@yahboijei]

Kimmy's "Nako. Eh, nako" on a difficult question resonated with the Filipino in me.

[@ZynntaX01]

samedt here

[@patrickrabulan5622]

Came down to the comments to find my people! "hay nako" communicates so much

[@chinoposadas4645]

Yeaaahh haha

[@meganmccurdy1299]

Can we get an astrology real v. fake debate pleaseee cuz I’d also love to see what the crew and other cast thinks. B/c I agree with Ian, it’s totally fake

[@georgelloydgonzalez]

I'd like that too, but I don't want a civil war

[@DavidSSabb]

I don't care if people enjoy it as a hobby but people who literally judge people's character on it piss me off. Like I'm a Gemini so I'm a duplicitous piece of crap apparently?

[@dugoo3405]

I also think that by looking at "your description" you may start to fullfill that expectation. Meaning it only fits because you start to act like what you're told to act like.

[@pigwindow]

It’s not even a debate, like it’s proven fake. It’s all the Barnum effect, a self fulfilling prophecy. People can believe whatever they’d like, it doesn’t cause harm so go nuts. But it’s definitely fake lol

[@dugoo3405]

@@pigwindow Exactly mate. "a self-fulfilling prophecy"

[@SarahsSnakeShop]

The pretty Privilege... I LOVE Ian's answer, its so true lmao

[@Very_Okay]

asking youtube commenters to leave their controversial opinions is an incredibly bold request

[@SupremeLeaderKimJong-un]

Yeah I side with Keith when it comes to telling someone if they want to go into a career. If they wanna become an Imagineer, train driver, architect, politician, lawyer, voice actor, etc then they should go for it. As long as they believe in themselves and never give up on their dreams, you will go far

[@pixlpotato69420]

Kim Jong un!?

[@josemacalintal1915]

Loved that little Filipino moment of Kimmy during the Reading Minds question. "Hay nako hay nako"

[@dfhdf4214]

good job to everyone having the necessary good attitude to play this game and somehow making it feel wholesome despite differences

[@daltonhosford5135]

Tommy’s extreme confidence strut on the beginning 😂😂😂😂