Kishore Mahbubani argues American democracy is failing its people in favour of big business 7/8

  Рет қаралды 40,476

OxfordUnion

OxfordUnion

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 337
@ArunachalamUdayan-py4of
@ArunachalamUdayan-py4of 6 сағат бұрын
In the true sense, USA never had ever been a democracy! It has always been an oligarchy and plutocracy!
@NormarlinaTaib
@NormarlinaTaib Сағат бұрын
As confirmed by President Biden
@cryptorenegade1406
@cryptorenegade1406 37 минут бұрын
248 years of slavery is not democracy
@mistman5640
@mistman5640 Күн бұрын
Kishore is on something. America was never a democracy but always an empire.
@TacticalMayo
@TacticalMayo Күн бұрын
No it isn't. Just tankies say that.
@drugrixhspaz9982
@drugrixhspaz9982 Күн бұрын
lol this comment shows your stupidity
@accountantthe3394
@accountantthe3394 Күн бұрын
​@@TacticalMayoI'm sure UNC's Ceo would beg to differ. Cope 😊
@TacticalMayo
@TacticalMayo Күн бұрын
@@accountantthe3394 actually coping's what we're not going to do. What we're going to do is go to Taiwan. 😉
@accountantthe3394
@accountantthe3394 Күн бұрын
@TacticalMayo Oh you're very welcome to Taiwan, better prepare your bodybag for what comes next though ;)
@normantan7796
@normantan7796 22 сағат бұрын
Democracy my foot, it's gangsterism in both parties. There should be 10 parties to contest not 2 mafia , who ever the voters choose is no different.
@walterwu164
@walterwu164 11 сағат бұрын
Absolutely! North Korea, Iran, China are the best and the most democratic countries in the world. There is no gangsterism since there is not contest.
@franko1904
@franko1904 7 сағат бұрын
Americans, like Trump, are good at what Singaporeans will call "Talk Cock Sing Song, Sie Beh Gao Sian". Americans "Kenna Kan" by Trump and the rich, will still happily sing "Halleluja".
@chrisfernandes3353
@chrisfernandes3353 8 сағат бұрын
I found out about Kishore Mahbubani because I had subscribed to the Lee Kwan Yew school of public policy KZbin channel. Kishore's peers were giving him an homage as the pioneering dean of the school, and Kishore mentioned one of his books was available for public access. I immediately downloaded the PDF, and was stunned by his insight on past and upcoming global politics. It should be known that Kishore once wrote a scathing op-ed on LKY, likening him to a dictator. LKY met Kishore, and after fierce debates the two became confidants. Kishore Mahbubani is a gem, and for someone from the banana republic of Goa, India Singaporean visionary governance is almost alien
@Butterfly_daydreams
@Butterfly_daydreams 6 сағат бұрын
Any idea why he sucks up so hard to China, but not India?
@VickyYadav-qj6kv
@VickyYadav-qj6kv 3 сағат бұрын
Lee was capitalist, people use call him autocratic Nd Dictator like they call Modi. Who introduced Socialism in our country go read don't make sweeping statement.
@chrisfernandes3353
@chrisfernandes3353 Сағат бұрын
@VickyYadav-qj6kv whatever, India is dead weight to Goa. #CorruptionIsMyBirthrightAndIShallHaveIt 🇮🇳
@mjmf1430
@mjmf1430 6 сағат бұрын
USA is at once a plutocracy and a kakistocracy, the latter is a country governed by the least competent or suitable citizens of a state.
@ringuanung1876
@ringuanung1876 Күн бұрын
What about USA 🇺🇸 a champion of democracy is conducting Coup in Syria, Bangladesh 🇧🇩, invade Iraq 🇮🇶 , etc.?..😂
@walterwu164
@walterwu164 11 сағат бұрын
Would you give up your citizenship and migrate to Syria, Bangladesh and Iraq?
@pefsgk5092
@pefsgk5092 4 сағат бұрын
​@@walterwu164Your point is totally irrelevant to the statement above.
@Kratos321-i8r
@Kratos321-i8r Сағат бұрын
​@@walterwu164I would not migrate to the degenerate west but when it conducts a coup and removes a socialist democratic leader in my country? what choice do i got but to migrate the degenerate immoral sex hungry west?
@accountantthe3394
@accountantthe3394 Сағат бұрын
​@@walterwu164If 🇺🇸 stops engineering regime changes and coups there? Sure! 😀
@cryptorenegade1406
@cryptorenegade1406 30 минут бұрын
​@@walterwu164why not?
@Darkmatter321
@Darkmatter321 41 минут бұрын
I live in a subdivision in Manila. There are 2 Home Owner's Associations. They are always fighting and trying to persuade us to support one or the other. Although we pay our HOA dues on time, our street is now completely dark. Trash got collected today after 2 weeks. Streets are dirty without any one cleaning them for long periods of time. And when we ask them why, they say it's the other HOA's fault. Isn't this exactly how the US politics work??
@anthonychuan7279
@anthonychuan7279 6 сағат бұрын
America's elite politicians says - let them eat cake.
@Dihorse371
@Dihorse371 6 сағат бұрын
America has only 1 political party, just 2 marketing campaigns. GOP & Dem are one & the same. Both are filled with right-wing neoliberal candidates with 95% of the same policies compete to see who can get more billionaire donors to be anointed CEO/commander-in-chief of the empire. Agnotology is the study of wilful acts to spread confusion and deceit. One tactic: "Balancing Act - seemingly two opposing views".
@sweelim5473
@sweelim5473 21 сағат бұрын
BRILLIANT speech by Kishore👍👍👍
@skanthaadsigns
@skanthaadsigns Күн бұрын
Democracy was just a Drama front….
@walterwu164
@walterwu164 11 сағат бұрын
Communism is the best. North Korean, China are the best countries to migrate to. No need to vote, no drama front....
@cryptorenegade1406
@cryptorenegade1406 27 минут бұрын
Many people also don't vote here in the west, they've given up
@liteo57
@liteo57 20 сағат бұрын
A major problem with the American political system is the amount of funding required for campaigning. I often joke that each administration is only effective during the 1st 2 years of each term, the remaining 2.years of each term is dedicated to raising funds for the campaigning for the next election. And because of this fact, cnadidates fall prey to lobbyists, the wealthy. Once you accept the funding, whether you win or not, you are obligated to assist these companies and individuals, ignoring the interest of the majority!
@twells138
@twells138 4 сағат бұрын
a fraction of a fraction of a fraction of GDP., and determining the next government is serious business and requires function because it is worth it. We spend 10X that on advertising for consumer products. The whining about how much we spend on elections do not understand scale, and especially scale in the US>
@Ilaab1995
@Ilaab1995 Күн бұрын
When one looks at surveys that evaluate democracies on an international scale, one finds the US always raking close to the bottom. I have seen the US ranked number 28 and I have seen it ranked number 36 (next to Israel). However, the US always invokes fighting for democracy when it goes to war, see Ukraine where the US is supporting a neo-fascist regime while claiming to be supporting Ukraine's freedom and democracy.
@raymondtay9442
@raymondtay9442 11 сағат бұрын
As a Russian analyst once said - the US preaching democracy is like a mistress of a brothel teaching morality to schoolgirls.
@ninaslifejourney
@ninaslifejourney 6 сағат бұрын
Excellent insight but two goons sitting at the back should not be allowed inside such a serious debate.
@kimhoongloh6417
@kimhoongloh6417 22 сағат бұрын
Logically & succinctly well argued.
@larrysherk
@larrysherk 2 сағат бұрын
Well put ! We are not a democracy but an oligarchic police state.
@duinay3
@duinay3 3 сағат бұрын
I love that he called our elections a "ritual" - I'd like to call it a "waste of time " 😂
@yongchoonfong1940
@yongchoonfong1940 7 сағат бұрын
He dared to challenge US failings 😊
@KwisatzHaderach01
@KwisatzHaderach01 22 минут бұрын
Not a big thing. These academics can say anything about the US. Im not sure if they can say the same thing to Beijing.
@gohwhatsing1521
@gohwhatsing1521 9 сағат бұрын
The tax structure in America is destroying the middle class which is critical for a vibrant democracy.
@phillipfoo4305
@phillipfoo4305 Күн бұрын
Terms such as democracy, socialism, communism & especially “freedom”are widely misused these days for geopolitical purposes.. America isn’t a true democracy nor practices “freedom” that it constantly touts & preaches to others as evidenced from the widespread discrimination & disenfranchisement against its own citizens particularly the minorities which are structural & institutionalized for example.. it’s become a dysfunctional state.. they have stricter traffic laws than gun laws for example. Likewise China isn’t a true socialist/communist state.. it’s the leadership of the countries & vested interests that set the tone & narrative against the other in line with their intentions. We can either rise together and accelerate progress for humanity or waste resources & more importantly time, confronting each other whilst stunting essential progress in fields that require urgency in addressing.
@CalvinK-the_old_fogey
@CalvinK-the_old_fogey Күн бұрын
To me, China is a more effective democracy. Although the country is governed by one party, the ruling apparatus is subject to regular elections and the potential leaders have to prove themselves and climb the power hierarchy. Voting is restricted to cadre members and these are the insiders who know the working behind the scene. This eliminates the power of one-man-one-vote system which is easily manipulated by social media. If we compare Xi Jinping v Donald Trump, the former strives for the common prosperity while the latter is concerned with enriching himself and his rich friends. A one-party system like China’s communist system limits the power struggle within the party but allows long term planning for progress. A two-party system like USA’s or UK’s will see a regular government change so that politicians are forced to be short-sighted and make plans only for the next 4-5 years.
@Cuhsidy
@Cuhsidy Күн бұрын
a true democracy does not care about minorities, America is failing because they prioritise too much on the minorities rather than the majority.
@micosanopatrick6550
@micosanopatrick6550 12 сағат бұрын
Yes, they are fraudulently misused in particular cases. However just do research and investigate an issue before arriving to the unreasonable less well thought but more argumentive conclusions😮
@walterwu164
@walterwu164 11 сағат бұрын
@@CalvinK-the_old_fogey I believe you do not fully understand the Chinese Communist government. Common prosperity is just another nice term for communism.
@CalvinK-the_old_fogey
@CalvinK-the_old_fogey 9 сағат бұрын
@@walterwu164 you have been fooled by western media to blindly adopt simplistic narrative of communism bad, democracy good as if life is in shades of black and white only. Consequently, you are stuck with George Orwell’s Animal Farm type of Communism mindset. Since Deng Xiaoping era, China has uplifted their people and the result of ‘common prosperity’ is plain to see. However, please don’t take my words for it, do your own research about conditions in China. Better still, visit China.
@jamesteh829
@jamesteh829 16 сағат бұрын
Well said, Prof Khishore of Singapore 🇸🇬. He is awesome and speaks truthfully. The other shall be Prof. Jeff and Prof. Wolff ❤❤❤
@walterwu164
@walterwu164 11 сағат бұрын
Prof Kshisore, Jeffrey Sach and Wolff are spokesperson for the Chinese Communist government. Please do not confuse opinions with truthfulness.
@VickyYadav-qj6kv
@VickyYadav-qj6kv 3 сағат бұрын
People who don't have food, water, cloths r not thinking about democracy or of this shit. I don't support Communism nor flawed Democracy who is making people more suffer... I believe in a Right government with capitalism+ targeted welfarism....who stand for there own interest.Not like imposing so called democracy by US nd also toppling government.
@Aditya-hn8jj
@Aditya-hn8jj Күн бұрын
China: one party system . Usa : 2 party system. No third option..no collation govt.
@mistman5640
@mistman5640 Күн бұрын
@@Aditya-hn8jj USA has two parties but 1 establishment, or 1 aristocracy. The Election of Trump and Musk changes all of that. There is a new establishment and an old one.
@Andy-P
@Andy-P Күн бұрын
I​@@mistman5640It has changed...... could change again
@MrEL28
@MrEL28 5 сағат бұрын
And the sad truth is in China's one-party system, if the people are too pissed off, they'll overthrow the CCCP. But in the US, if one party does a piss-poor job, they'll just vote the other party into power regardless of whether it can do the job better than the other party.
@PhiloSurfer
@PhiloSurfer 4 сағат бұрын
USA: One uni-party. One party, but with 2 brand names - two cheeks of the same backside (courtesy George Galloway).
@Qiushishuo
@Qiushishuo 4 сағат бұрын
Actually China has multiple parties, they can negotiate with CCP in each level of government and some of members are high ranking officers in Chinese government.
@mechislander
@mechislander 20 сағат бұрын
Democracy is not failing. *_The_* *_US_* is failing. Two different things.
@seeyian
@seeyian 2 сағат бұрын
what about the EU so many homeless?
@pr0newbie
@pr0newbie Сағат бұрын
It is failing. Look at western countries. Democracy that we see today is a relatively new 20th century implementation.
@dennisluk8833
@dennisluk8833 20 сағат бұрын
Non-restricted freedom allows the President to pardon his son, good friends and the criminals who put in large sum of support
@mikewilson2332
@mikewilson2332 20 сағат бұрын
what about trump ? you left out the biggest crook and baddest con man on planet earth !
@yhyau235
@yhyau235 12 сағат бұрын
Message is clear, focus on substance over form.
@kathri1006
@kathri1006 14 сағат бұрын
Access to free health care, education, living free of fear of crime, access to affordable housing and food/ clean water, these are the basic human rights. Any political system needs to be judged on how successful it in deliveri g these to its people and nothig else. The rest is mechanics of delivery, different in different societies. Giving countries this freedom to choose its system it a form of democtratic thinking, of ideas.
@h-kesh5043
@h-kesh5043 Күн бұрын
It is interesting, a small proportion of a country's population gaining more than the bottom. Not only that, but, the bottom having a smaller share of the country's wealth over time, sounds very much like what the collective west scorns about dictatorial countries. It seems like in some countries, the dictator has a proverbial "public face" and countries that essentially run as a plutocracy have a hidden dictatorial face - but with a facade of a democracy..... Not sure which one is worse....
@twells138
@twells138 4 сағат бұрын
NO, its a misuse of statistics. Ail economic strata in the US have had standards of living continuously moving up. People like to focus on relative gains between the upper part and lower part, without actually looking at what the number mean. It's like complaining about the other diners in the restaurant who had twelve orders of crab cakes when you yourself have a whole plate.
@pr0newbie
@pr0newbie Сағат бұрын
@@twells138 No, why do you think Trump has been successful with his rhetoric?
@rwksasc
@rwksasc 9 сағат бұрын
The U.S. cannot allow all to be lifted up. The U.S. criticized China when China attempted ‘shared prodperity’.
@KwisatzHaderach01
@KwisatzHaderach01 20 минут бұрын
Shared prosperity? Like in South China Sea?
@urimtefiki226
@urimtefiki226 Күн бұрын
With plundering of my invention the oligarchs have multiplied their wealth and have not paid one dollar to me, they did not give me one normal salary to support my family. All my suffing is a curse for them, they stole my invention I will take them their soul, we will see who will triumph in this world.
@daning9764
@daning9764 10 сағат бұрын
👍👍👍
@PepsiCola-f1d
@PepsiCola-f1d Күн бұрын
Kishore ❤❤❤❤
@nirmalanarayan6688
@nirmalanarayan6688 Күн бұрын
Mr Mahbunani, sorry for getting his name spelt incorrectly.
@teeteetuu94
@teeteetuu94 Күн бұрын
??? He is Mr Mahbubani. That's his name.
@johnmichna8732
@johnmichna8732 7 сағат бұрын
Quite the speech
@Glumclam
@Glumclam 13 минут бұрын
It’s not failing we never had a democracy.
@patrickkhaw2547
@patrickkhaw2547 Сағат бұрын
In the US, parties change but policies remain the same. In China, the party remains the same but the policies change to meet changing circumstances and challenges.
@KwisatzHaderach01
@KwisatzHaderach01 50 минут бұрын
Well if that so, why American covid recovery is much more dynamic than China?
@whatzupdudes7
@whatzupdudes7 4 минут бұрын
Kick out the 2 disrespectful goons. They are great examples why democracy is failing 😂 not paying attention to this master piece by Mr Kishore
@acmkamos
@acmkamos 13 сағат бұрын
Says a guy from singapore which is the epitome of freedom and democracy
@PhiloSurfer
@PhiloSurfer 4 сағат бұрын
What exactly does Kishore says that you find unconvincing? I am not an Olympic swimming champ, but I can see that those who have purple faces after the swim in the Paris Olympics are on dope.
@bridgeroad9758
@bridgeroad9758 44 минут бұрын
Excellent insight
@urimtefiki226
@urimtefiki226 Күн бұрын
I know you want to be rich, invent something and do whatever you want with your invention. Not only stealing but I was interrogated like a was in police station and insulted my pride, totally schizophrenic people.
@DBENTLEY369ig
@DBENTLEY369ig Күн бұрын
The bigger issue is the pursuit of women's equity and wanting to a HOLY ROMAN force
@gyadre
@gyadre 19 сағат бұрын
In China women cannot be a leader or manager. See the Chinese leaders and polit bureau members since the founding of the PRC in 1949. All are Men. China mix of communism with Confucianism has resulted in huge gender discrimination.
@entertainmentjoke2871
@entertainmentjoke2871 4 сағат бұрын
CHINA is to be blamed. -USA logic
@KwisatzHaderach01
@KwisatzHaderach01 29 минут бұрын
Not even a word of him mention China yet you bring this up. Americans rent free in your head
@rajfc
@rajfc 10 сағат бұрын
I don’t always agree with Kishore but he is spot on here
@roro-v3z
@roro-v3z Күн бұрын
the guy in background has attention span of a sparrow 😂
@seeyian
@seeyian 2 сағат бұрын
American democracy?why are there so many laws? "suka suka" implement laws without debates?
@malgudidays3311
@malgudidays3311 3 сағат бұрын
Bye, bye miss American pie, drove my Chevy to the Levy but the levy was dry...
@lv9657
@lv9657 13 сағат бұрын
Let ot fall only after that you realised your problems.
@DBENTLEY369ig
@DBENTLEY369ig Күн бұрын
I hear you it was like you are watching the text BIGBANG INSTANT APPEARING CIVILIZATION by POWHATAN
@brianliew5901
@brianliew5901 57 минут бұрын
If Kishore keeps irritating Uncle Sam with his speeches, he might find himself in the company of Huawei as a national security threat. 😂😂😂😂😂
@pdmeq4332
@pdmeq4332 8 сағат бұрын
Yep
@neil9381
@neil9381 7 минут бұрын
Sir indian democracy?
@AlgoNudger
@AlgoNudger Күн бұрын
FYI. There's no west or east for elite ... today, all they want is your data, rights, privacy, and freedom. 😂
@ReveredWizardBob
@ReveredWizardBob Күн бұрын
Money runs the world unfortunately we're a slave to a bunch of paper notes and numbers on a screen...
@charmaine8512
@charmaine8512 Күн бұрын
Asia is napping and not aware what the Anglo Saxon governments are upto.
@zacharycohen9985
@zacharycohen9985 20 сағат бұрын
@@ReveredWizardBob so we are ruled by money, which is governed by greed, which is a essentially human nature
@TacticalMayo
@TacticalMayo Күн бұрын
We would never accept number two.
@betafish2990
@betafish2990 Күн бұрын
Then be in no. 3 or 4 or 78. 😂😂😂
@TacticalMayo
@TacticalMayo Күн бұрын
@@betafish2990 how about Armageddon?
@blinkkkkk4890
@blinkkkkk4890 Күн бұрын
In some years you have to accept whether you like it or not.its the truth.
@TacticalMayo
@TacticalMayo Күн бұрын
@@betafish2990 remember that is what we 🇺🇸 will choose
@peanut0brain
@peanut0brain Күн бұрын
Be #1 bully
@Jojo_KokoUK
@Jojo_KokoUK 21 сағат бұрын
Thats why US Gov BAN TIKTOK.....Security threat to the Oligarchy😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@gyadre
@gyadre 19 сағат бұрын
So many Chinese social media are allowed in US and Western democratic countries. But CHINA doesn't allow any foreign social media service and free press in China. So stop the crap about TOKTOK BAN. Hate people promoting NIMYBYISM.
@wf645
@wf645 6 сағат бұрын
@@gyadre firstly, FB was used as a platform for XinJiang terrorist to communicate and coordinate terrorist attacks in XinJiang. FB and Google did not want to abide by local laws to have their server place in China etc Hence they withdrew from China. Similarly, Tiktok had placed their server and abides by US law ... go figure ! Tik tok was ban cuz they tore down the veil and showed the US / West and Israel's facism ! esp the destruction of Gaza by Israel !
@liongjiahwong5478
@liongjiahwong5478 Сағат бұрын
No you are wrong.. daylight robbery, the Biden Administration plans to delete TikTok and sell it to Americans not the Chinese. This is stealing TikTok Technologies with RnD. Very sad !
@urimtefiki226
@urimtefiki226 Күн бұрын
YOU MUST RESPECT THE WISDOM. I do not care what kind of system you live or you like, one think is of the uppermost important which is MUST for everyone living in this planet. One inventor is much more important than all oligarchs of the world, they are just nothing for the genius, I see them as rats.
@angteckhuat8209
@angteckhuat8209 Күн бұрын
Amazing that at his age, he doesn't need reading glasses LOL
@CHRISdiary77264
@CHRISdiary77264 Күн бұрын
Yes
@kynismos
@kynismos Күн бұрын
Probably had cataract treatment and his lenses replaced.
@ajaybabucherukuri1813
@ajaybabucherukuri1813 52 минут бұрын
Why Oxford union not conducting debates on its own countries present awful extreme leftism. Clean you country before you preach somebody else's.
@DBENTLEY369ig
@DBENTLEY369ig Күн бұрын
Planet is a fail-safe with perpetual balances between spirits humanity. You know UNIVERSAL STUDIOS?? University 1st taught itself and should reteach true meaning of Mayan Calendar. Meaning of Derek
@DBENTLEY369ig
@DBENTLEY369ig Күн бұрын
America is 30 years behind in green energy production because wind turbines halfass design. Same with TeslaMotors halfass design 4 wheels return productions into a 2nd battery no charging stations or cord
@rashidbagewadi1006
@rashidbagewadi1006 Сағат бұрын
And failing superpower.
@NormarlinaTaib
@NormarlinaTaib Сағат бұрын
Will u meet Donald Trump so that he can clear the mess in America itself .....rather than buying Greenland
@bertrandrussell3422
@bertrandrussell3422 Күн бұрын
tiktok and zuckerberg says hi from 2025.1
@ImSaneperson
@ImSaneperson 19 сағат бұрын
Guy looks like george soros
@HDK2024
@HDK2024 Күн бұрын
Democracy will succeed only when 1. The asset/savings of individual dissolve to Null(zero), as soon as the death of person. Make sure assets/money doesn't transfer from parents to kids 2. Bring equality in all sectors health, education, voting right modification etc
@Freespeech1947
@Freespeech1947 Күн бұрын
That’s communism - and that philosophy has never worked for the many - just for the few. It drains people of ambition, drive , striving for self improvement. These attributes are in very short supply anyway.
@commonsense2826
@commonsense2826 Күн бұрын
😂 can sell esky’s to eskimos !!!
@RR_reunificationRights
@RR_reunificationRights 3 сағат бұрын
votes dopes senators, senators doped nation.
@Hujjathullah-fz7qh
@Hujjathullah-fz7qh Күн бұрын
I am no fan of Kishore, but the last few sentences he professed here are gems not just to admire but to treasure. Still, as a Singaporean he should first realise that there is no social "equality" and there is only debatable freedoms within even Singapore itself BEFORE going on to nit-pick on the US in these regards ! By the way, the U.K. is a good theatre to extoll that even minority Indians can intellectually dominate at the Oxford Union, no less ! But then, is this a better advocacy of the democratic ideal in a equally hollow constitutional setting ? 😅 🎉
@keffinsg
@keffinsg 22 сағат бұрын
The debate motion is not on Singapore.
@parnamsaini4751
@parnamsaini4751 21 сағат бұрын
Really??
@zacharycohen9985
@zacharycohen9985 20 сағат бұрын
As a born and raised American having worked in Singapore for decades, and have now returned to my native Brooklyn I would encourage you to try living and working in the US as middle class to better juxtapose living in Singapore as middle class. Understanding the nuances of social equality and freedoms in Singapore, it's important to acknowledge the significant strides the country has made in areas such as housing, healthcare, and education. While certain freedoms may be restricted in pursuit of stability and economic growth, many Singaporeans appreciate these trade-offs for the relative safety and prosperity they experience. Comparing these aspects to the United States involves different historical, cultural, and political contexts. The U.S. champions democratic ideals but grapples with inequality and political polarization, whereas Singapore navigates its unique governance model to balance growth and stability. Highlighting the intellectual achievements of minority Indians at the Oxford Union serves to underscore the value of diversity and intellectual prowess in various settings. However, it doesn't necessarily equate to a complete reflection of democratic principles or the effectiveness of various governance models. Both the U.S. and Singapore have distinct approaches and challenges, making it essential to consider the broader contexts when discussing their respective merits and shortcomings.
@kitkat253
@kitkat253 Күн бұрын
There is almost certainly a very understandable explanation for the small decline in the average life number, which is that the US population has doubled past 70 years, and most came from a lower socio economic background. Surprising a veritable genius like Mahbubani, upon whose every syllable uttered, millions gawk and gape in total wonder, did not examine this aspect. It's also the case that human greed has reasserted itself to wild proportions, a fire out of control, and the US, being the place where rewards are the highest, is most prominently impacted. When remuneration began to be bonus based, the hitherto system vanished overnight, and annual take home, including stock options, now touch 100 millions each for many. Trump, who gave a huge tax break last time to the rich, has been reelected by the non rich, who presumably don't understand any of this, and modern society is utterly fascinated by audio/video systems, so the talking, moving image is now truth. As to democracy, probably the Scandinavian nations are the only ones closer to attempting to distribute its benefits to the maximum number. Lastly, these goals are targets towards which the human race moves, in fits and starts. Given the choice I would always choose the failing systems of the west, not the US, though, rather than, say, China,(despite the most wondrous and admirable achievements they have produced past 40 years), for whom as many know Mahbubani is the most fervent acolyte, bar none, and presumably is, handsomely rewarded by that country. Perhaps he may wish to go and live there. Sadly, uneven societies are not going anywhere. As to suffering populations, of course the billions under dictatorships, are, on a level of suffering, altogether on a different plane to that in the US.
@GoutamDAS-ls1wb
@GoutamDAS-ls1wb Сағат бұрын
One cause of the disparity is the loss of jobs due to offshoring.
@ChinnayyaPillaiThanasekaran
@ChinnayyaPillaiThanasekaran Күн бұрын
Pro china and American guy.
@jakebob8116
@jakebob8116 19 сағат бұрын
Truth hurts
@ChinnayyaPillaiThanasekaran
@ChinnayyaPillaiThanasekaran 13 сағат бұрын
That's his opinion. He has been preaching china all his life, that doesn't think people must accept it as gospel truth.
@mrj475
@mrj475 8 сағат бұрын
His been bribed by China
@donaldjoseph3903
@donaldjoseph3903 7 сағат бұрын
Kishore is both right and wrong. There are 2 sides to a coin. Same for China, or any country for that matter.😊
@garyleow70
@garyleow70 Күн бұрын
Life expectancy declining could be due to health issues associated with overindulging in consumption of unhealthy food that only rich America could afford?
@mrmanny1
@mrmanny1 Күн бұрын
Why is a non American debating this lol.😅😅😅
@Chew81
@Chew81 Күн бұрын
And you have no problems with Americans poking their bloody noses at everyone else?
@LIBRAcantalk
@LIBRAcantalk Күн бұрын
Well indians are smarter than native people LOL
@CHRISdiary77264
@CHRISdiary77264 Күн бұрын
Because America 🇺🇸 don't accept they are failing democracy in thier country
@freemanol
@freemanol Күн бұрын
why not? it's obvious as an outside observer. americans can't see their own predicament within their own bubble
@hokonglim
@hokonglim Күн бұрын
Simple answer: USA impacted us all countries geopolitically and economically...
@alanho4432
@alanho4432 Күн бұрын
Mahbubani didn’t like to say that there are more legal and illegal immigrants just want to work and live in the United States of Democracy than what democracy he was muttering. I rather listen to those immigrants than from him.
@keffinsg
@keffinsg 22 сағат бұрын
They are there for Dollars, not Democracy.
@walterwu164
@walterwu164 11 сағат бұрын
The amazing thing about American democracy is its ability to self-correct from time to time when the system seems not working. All democratic and capitalist countries favour big businesses including Singapore. The Prof is generalising that the Amercian democracy is failing its people as American is not as homogenous as he assumed to be. American is made of united states.
@wf645
@wf645 6 сағат бұрын
Despite federal policies, however United States does NOT mean its Homogenous ! as each state is governed locally by the respective Governors. If federal does really govern, that will mean, a swift control and extinguishing of the current LA fire disaster ... compare that to the swift and organized action of China to Tibet's earthquake ... the comparison is stark ! The so call "self correct" of the US system does not mean its good for the system. Simply put, the ROTI Prata policies of each party and sitting president would mean policy shit every 5 to 10 years and hence geopolitics risks to the world etc. Which result in the Oligarchs that are really leading and influencing the policies of US, through their legalised bribery of contribution to election campaigns and lobbying ..
@phongy45
@phongy45 20 сағат бұрын
how??, usa is still very rich!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@colinchia5318
@colinchia5318 4 сағат бұрын
Kishor,look at ourself.tell whatever you have spoken to the PAPs.
@EasternKalogeros
@EasternKalogeros Сағат бұрын
What talking you darling... Do you care to elaborate??
@PP-vf1kx
@PP-vf1kx 8 сағат бұрын
… a question for Kishore … would you rather USA or China take the lead in world affairs? 🤨
@user-ggyy34wsk575
@user-ggyy34wsk575 7 сағат бұрын
The answer is none 😂
@comchadelalora
@comchadelalora Сағат бұрын
What a waste of time. Politics is a thing from the Greek and Roman era. Nowadays, executives, professionals who actually do things and obtain results. Not useless debates about "democracy" like we licensing world in which we have all the time to debate... Waste of time.
@DBENTLEY369ig
@DBENTLEY369ig Күн бұрын
Jesus's bible stories are true however God is a boldface lie of elders of Original Clan (white lies) The 7s??? The bible stories repetition is how 7 became a lucky #
@gyadre
@gyadre 19 сағат бұрын
Kishore will bever talk about democracy in China but democracy in the most demcractic country in the world ie, United States. He is a hypicrite to the core.
@davidlai6385
@davidlai6385 17 сағат бұрын
You missed the whole premise of the speech. Read the details please.
@cyansadventures
@cyansadventures 15 сағат бұрын
China doesn't use democracy as an excuse to invade or sanction other countries. China has lifted over half its population out of poverty and raised incomes fourfold in the past 4 decades. What has the US done? Sky-rocketing drug addiction, crumbling infrastructure, more mass shootings per year than days, trillions spent on wars benefitting only the MIC. Not even a comparison.
@nobodysfool-c7y
@nobodysfool-c7y 11 сағат бұрын
He doesn't talk about democracy in China because China is NOT a democracy. What confuses you? Get some sleep.
@franko1904
@franko1904 7 сағат бұрын
Americans, like Trump, are good at what Singaporeans will call "Talk Cock Sing Song, Sie Beh Gao Sian". Americans "Kenna Kan" by Trump and the rich, will still happily sing "Halleluja".
@atul3009
@atul3009 3 сағат бұрын
China is not democratic, so why we need to talk about that
@walterwu164
@walterwu164 11 сағат бұрын
Singapore democracy is also failing its people as the opposition parties had 40% of the peoples' votes but only have 10% of the parliamentary seats to represent them. In other words, the ruling party had only 60% of the votes but dominated 90% of the parliament.
@wf645
@wf645 6 сағат бұрын
40% of the votes DOES not mean 40% of the parliament seat. You do know the parliament seat goes to the MP in the constituents that won right ? ruling party though 60% of votes but they won most of the constituents 51% is a win, hence the seat for that constituent goes to the winning party duh ... Similarly in US, Trump winning the election does not mean that the senate or house is controlled by him/Republican. The senate / house representative have to fight for their seat each term too ...
@senjan8782
@senjan8782 16 сағат бұрын
Trump brings back the greatness of America. MAGA !!!
@franko1904
@franko1904 7 сағат бұрын
Americans, like Trump, are good at what Singaporeans will call "Talk Cock Sing Song, Sie Beh Gao Sian". Americans "Kenna Kan" by Trump and the rich, will still happily sing "Halleluja".
@krishnagondhea7428
@krishnagondhea7428 4 сағат бұрын
Let’s see. No guarantee
@hindustanimusic8447
@hindustanimusic8447 23 сағат бұрын
Look at democratic British economy which is struggling. Even India is doing better. America will remain a beacon of hope and prosperity.
@krishnagondhea7428
@krishnagondhea7428 4 сағат бұрын
Struggling? We have a left wing horrid government in power.
@fern8580
@fern8580 Күн бұрын
Kishore not understand that we prefer to give "piloting" to an entrepreneur rather than to a bureaucrat civil servant... Normal, as a civil servant Kishore has always prospered on the backs of private companies.
@PepsiCola-f1d
@PepsiCola-f1d Күн бұрын
Kishore ❤❤❤❤
@Andy-P
@Andy-P Күн бұрын
Kishore the CCP spokesman
@cyansadventures
@cyansadventures 14 сағат бұрын
Visit China, see what they have done for their people, and go and look hard for those "atrocities". You might become a CCP spokesperson yet.
@Gamla123
@Gamla123 Күн бұрын
The solution is Trump!
@aruna.p6654
@aruna.p6654 10 сағат бұрын
Kishore is a Singaporean. His country is ruled by the same PAP government since independence in 1963. What democracy does Kishore know ❓❓❓
@yongkangwong5917
@yongkangwong5917 8 сағат бұрын
Your point being?
@Dihorse371
@Dihorse371 6 сағат бұрын
US has only 1 political party, just 2 marketing campaigns. GOP & Dem are one & the same. Both are filled with right-wing neoliberal candidates with 95% of the same policies compete to see who can get more billionaire donors to be anointed CEO/commander-in-chief of the empire.
@mrj475
@mrj475 8 сағат бұрын
He is so funny while Singapore is a dictator country, he should not talk and lecture others 🤣
@yongkangwong5917
@yongkangwong5917 8 сағат бұрын
Lol maybe. Just curious what is your definition of “dictator”
@franko1904
@franko1904 7 сағат бұрын
Americans, like Trump, are good at what Singaporeans will call "Talk Cock Sing Song, Sie Beh Gao Sian". Americans "Kenna Kan" by Trump and the rich, will still happily sing "Halleluja".
@1995Prayag
@1995Prayag 19 сағат бұрын
Indian Democracy is failing its people too
@johnsnow2911
@johnsnow2911 Күн бұрын
He is a Chinese in the guise of Indian
@MdFirdausAlam-x8m
@MdFirdausAlam-x8m Күн бұрын
He is a Singaporean citizen with Sindhi heritage.
@aadilansari5997
@aadilansari5997 Күн бұрын
Singapore the democratic dictatorship is giving lecture to USA😂😂😂. Singapore is a uni oarty state with PAP ruling there from forever , with 82 MPs in a house of 85 MPs.
@CHRISdiary77264
@CHRISdiary77264 Күн бұрын
You converted muslim don't know then stay silent 🔕😶
@goonhoongtatt1883
@goonhoongtatt1883 Күн бұрын
Because Singapore doesn't pretend to be some kind of protector or beacon of democracy like the US does.
@WilliamLionCity
@WilliamLionCity Күн бұрын
82 MPs in a house of 85 MPs? How many decades ago was that?
@amberjewelkoh7023
@amberjewelkoh7023 Күн бұрын
Speaking as a born and bred singaporean, i have no problem with that. No gun shooting, no drug abuse, no homelessness here. So all good, keep your liberal democracy.
@keffinsg
@keffinsg 22 сағат бұрын
Yes, they are reelected every 5 years by a population that approves of their performance.
Konstantin Kisin: Woke Culture HAS Gone Too Far - 7/8 | Oxford Union
9:20
My scorpion was taken away from me 😢
00:55
TyphoonFast 5
Рет қаралды 2,7 МЛН
The Best Band 😅 #toshleh #viralshort
00:11
Toshleh
Рет қаралды 22 МЛН
Арыстанның айқасы, Тәуіржанның шайқасы!
25:51
QosLike / ҚосЛайк / Косылайық
Рет қаралды 700 М.
“Don’t stop the chances.”
00:44
ISSEI / いっせい
Рет қаралды 62 МЛН
A 91 Year Old Prime Minister Shares His Best Life Lessons
16:03
Professor Jeffrey Sachs + Q&A | Cambridge Union
1:21:40
Cambridge Union
Рет қаралды 725 М.
Is China an alternative to Western democracy?
13:43
TheNexusInstitute
Рет қаралды 390 М.
My scorpion was taken away from me 😢
00:55
TyphoonFast 5
Рет қаралды 2,7 МЛН