Amazon’s new $100 video cards are weird…

The first 1,000 people to use the link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare skl.sh/oztalkshw04233
Amazon retailers are here to save the day.
The GPUs
AISURIX: www.aisurix.com
$120 Option: amzn.to/41v1whi
$140 Option: amzn.to/41SJ0PM
$170 Option: amzn.to/41V3OGh
The links above are affiliate links. I get a small percentage from each click and sale at NO extra cost to you.
0:00 Intro
0:40 Current options
1:29 AISURIX & the GPUs
2:31 Are they ACTUALLY new..?
3:24 QA & Warranty & Customer Service
5:16 Installation, temps, thermals
5:56 Performance
6:41 Performance per dollar (value)
7:27 Final thoughts
8:16 OzTalksMerch?
8:37 Generative Art
9:10 Free Skillshare Trial! Thanks Skillshare!
10:08 Bye bye :)
Website: www.oztalkshw.fun/
Instagram: / oztalkshw
Twitter: / oztalkshw
OzTalksHW
/ oztalkshw

[@OzTalksHW]

I’ll have the article on how to properly test the video card on oztalkshw.fun tomorrow even. Please check out Skillshare! Link the description. Enjoy the video 😊

[@shaunhall960]

I followed the link and checked out those builds... Wow! Very nice!

[@epecwokhay]

I'd question the long-term legality of these cards in terms of IP (intellectual property); I doubt AISURIX are authorized partners of Nvidia and AMD; you never know if Nvidia or AMD may sue them and/or put a stop to this. The fact that AISURIX has a physical location in a western market (Australia according to their website), makes it more easier/likely Nvidia and AMD to clamp down on them in a legal context versus other companies that are strictly located in China. It's highly likely the GPUs were salvaged off of old/malfunctioning/dead cards and re-manufactured with a new PCB, fans, etc. A similar practice to this which is relatively common in Shenzhen would be those companies who've salvaged old enterprise/server/workstation chipsets and soldered those on to new PCBs and re-marketed them as new Intel X79, X99 motherboards. I'd suggest you contact Nvidia and AMD just to confirm on how legit this is.

[@namnnamn1911]

I ave that but after 9days the gpu died but at the very least they are willing to change the gpu but you will shoulder the shipping fee back to them

[@dreams_of_dido]

I included this RX 580 to my first build (in which I mixed parts from your 2 previous 500 and 400$ builds). I put everything together last week. I am VERY HAPPY with it. Been playing GTA V, Cyberpunk, RDR2, etc. on it at very decent settings and very decent FPS. Thanks OZ for your amazing guidance and good vibes !!!!!!

[@budgetking2591]

i had a rx470, basicly a lower clocked rx580, bought it for 50 euro in 2017 and used it for like 4 years!

[@WSS_the_OG]

The RX 580 and RX 480 are incredible value at the moment.

[@OzTalksHW]

Nice!!!! I love hearing stuff like this. Enjoy the build man I’m so honored I helped

[@dreams_of_dido]

@@OzTalksHW Thanks again for your wonderful content! Cheers!

[@katnerd6712]

The RX580 and it's variants are kind of legendary. I swear this card has had the longest relevant lifespan of any GPU ever. It simply will not die. I've contemplated buying one and building a living room Steam console PC using HoloISO (the OS the Steam Deck uses but customized to run on a desktop, it's not compatible with Nvidia GPU's).

[@bignspicy984]

A whole company that actually capitalized on the terrible state of the gpu market in a positive way.

[@OzTalksHW]

It's really cool to see. Not perfect, but I hope they continue for another few generations. It's really cool

[@Lavendy7731]

​​@@OzTalksHW hey i just wanted to know if i should build your 400€ 2023 march PC or are there any specific PCs that are good for playing minecraft WITH mods? Thanks if you respond me

[@shaunhall960]

While other channels complain about how miserable things are, you are finding positive solutions to our hobby. Thank you! Things are not good but it really boils down to what you do with your time.

[@p.chuckmoralesesquire3965]

this is a 6 year old card shaun

[@aboveaveragebayleaf9216]

That is true, but it's still a pretty capable card for its age. I would only get one used though.

[@loowick4074]

@@p.chuckmoralesesquire3965 still better than new cards so irrelevant

[@p.chuckmoralesesquire3965]

@@loowick4074 no sir but its a good price at least

[@mechmancannon]

I picked up a MSI-3060-GAMING-X-12G for $380. 12 GB Vram and 40% faster than the $170 1660 super you show. I am starting to like MSI, but that limits possibilities. Oh, and I like the calm demeanor you have. You are much more pleasant to watch than a lot of the computer guys on youtube. Subscribed.

[@OzTalksHW]

Have fun with the 3060 :) and thank you!

[@WSS_the_OG]

I totally agree, this card is an amazing bargain at the moment. Price to performance is unparalleled. Incidentally, I picked up a used RX 480 8 GB for $50 CAD (about $37 USD), perfect condition, not a miner card, and it works like a charm. It's not in my primary system, but for secondary lighter duty gaming system when friends over, and for media playback, it's superb! Great video.

[@jessragan6714]

Wherever you're shopping, I want to go too.

[@DerrickRG]

@@jessragan6714 It's called eBay....

[@AjrAlves]

Snatched a ASRock A750 for 199, pretty happy with it's performance.

[@OzTalksHW]

Enjoy! I enjoyed my a750's performance too

[@micahottaway8455]

It's technically an RX 570 that was originally sold as an RX 580 in China as a GPU. Putting these old chips on new PCBs isn't a bad idea as AMD and Nvidia aren't really paying attention to the budget market anymore.

[@loowick4074]

Especially nvidia who seems will gladly kill off the consumer base before even considering reducing prices.

[@philscomputerlab]

It's great, but also sad, to see these old RX cards being such good value. Time have changed 😅

[@OzTalksHW]

Yea...6 years later and this is the best we can do 🙃

[@mariohernandez645]

I have had the 580 for about 2 weeks and I must honestly say, this GPU is great! No issues with the FPS and the temps are good, running pretty cool.

[@TruckingShooter]

Glad they're doing this. I might combine one of their cards with an am4 mb cpu combo and get a nice refresh to my aging pc.

[@supremerulah420]

This sounds great. However they should up their support services as they may see an uptick in purchasing due to the current price gouging practices.

[@whitneyadamsiii6314]

loving this fresh content we are getting! definitely my fav channel

[@JonaTechVillage]

I've just started watching your videos and your voice is so chill and calming. Great videos watch while winding down in the evening! :)

[@Tech.Closet]

rx 580 2048sp is a great budget card, amazon 30 days is a great thing too, lack of warranty on the used market is a big blocker for many people.

[@stephanhart9941]

It is So Great to see you uploading more often!!! You are the most friendly tech tuber ever!

[@rusticlogcabinlife9443]

Oz, Your video style is Superb, Always look forward to your videos plus you do things I can Afford. Thanks,BigT

[@nhojleahcim47]

i had bought a 5500xt from these guys that started going bad within a week. I got a refund and sent the unit back and they are now forcing me to remove the bad review that I posted and changing it into a 5 star review. This is probably what they do to everyone who ever gave them a bad rating. Needless to say, that 2 star review stays on

[@voteDC]

I wouldn't remove the review either but did you edit it to add that you got a refund?

[@nhojleahcim47]

@@voteDC yes i added that detail and i also changed it into a 2 star review after i got my refund (from a 1-star).

[@OzTalksHW]

Woah sorry about that. Glad you got a refund. Hearting this and liking so people see that it’s not all rainbow and sunshine

[@wyterabitt2149]

Well, your "bad" review is a lie to be honest. You can't get better than a service that immediately makes right the times when a product unfortunately was defective. Your experience is a 5 star one. It's a 5 star one that involved you getting an unfortunate defective product (as will happen with every company in existence occasionally), but still unquestionably a 5 star one.

[@nhojleahcim47]

@@wyterabitt2149 the issue with me is the fact that they are claiming the product is brand new AND that the reviews posted online are not accurate. As consumers how will we know what's happening if all possible bad reviews are being changed? they even offered to pay me to change it.

[@sebastianchavez5445]

cant wait for the art bro keep it up!

[@Dry1nk]

Love this content, keep it up!

[@IRCAA2]

Thank you! Just discovered the channel and this video pops up, exactly what i was searching. I'll get this card in a few months!

[@jupitertheplanet2030]

I used to have one of these RX580s. It worked fine for two months, then it refused to give any image to the monitor. I returned it back to the store and bought an RX580 from MSI. Yeah it's a bit more expensive, but feels more secure.

[@ardazgames]

Great vid Oz🎉 saw this brand and I'm glad it was reviewed my pick one up for my son's build.

[@y2adre]

I have been a subscriber a while. I love your content. Keep up the great work.

[@jreen58]

He is great

[@smtek]

I have a 1440p panel on my main rig, but in my living room, I have a 1080p projector. I bought a refurbished RX 580 from Aliexpress for $80, paired with some old parts, and it's pretty awesome. Even the most recent titles, such as Hogwarts Legacy, run just fine on this card, although with reduced settings and some upscaling. However, older AAA games can run on high or even ultra settings without any issues at 1080p!

[@lazarjanjusevic3]

I've been running MingZhou GTX1660 Super 6gb for about 6 months in my rig. (it was around 110$ usd on aliexpress, and used cards were about 200$ in my country) It is an Aliexpress card (probbably a used mining gpu chip, but on a brand new PCB board). It works great for now, performance is there, and it is cool, never gets over 70c under load. I only changed the chinese thermal paste for a cooler master one (not super high end) and that's it. I had a used Asus 1070ti, and an XFX RX580, they all died after 3 moths of use.( demolished with mining by previous owners)

[@Eleganttf2]

Thanks for the info, but why do you change the thermal paste btw ? Is it necessary ?

[@lazarjanjusevic3]

@@Eleganttf2 from my previous experience with chinese electronics, they just use poor quality thermal compound, they probbably get it in bulk very cheap...i changed it just to be safe...i used cooler master esentials 3-4$

[@grapepapa]

This dropped right as I was looking for a new card, thank you so much! ❤

[@dimitrijejovanovic5939]

Thank you for bringing so much positivity to this community

[@vekdwarf6731]

oz oz please please do another calming pc build guide. It helps me go to sleep. TY!

[@bigpapab]

I have bought and used these cards personally, in new and used builds. Have not let me down. Thanks for making this video Oz!

[@poshuwog9181]

My boy uploaded again!!!

[@atoo7yt490]

1660 super/ti is also slept on considering its a newer and more power efficient alternative to 580/5500xt and you can get a reputable AIB version on the used market, 8GB polaris can be price gouged sometimes so the 1660super or 1660ti with 6gb vram and better perf is worth a look

[@Uno943]

Chill PC video with Oz on a chill Sunday.

[@Craven.craven]

Thanks for the video

[@BalaenicepsRex3]

Good vibes, Oz ❤

[@Zecuto]

Thank you for the video, it is informative and a joy to watch.

[@ntzt2150]

That really is a good deal, if you live in the US that is. Maybe also for people paying shipping+import but thats tricky.

[@richardbently7236]

I love this channel, it's like the Bob Ross of pc channels but so much better.

[@suvetar]

So good that you have alerted people to this Risk! Thank you for doing the good lords work 🙂

[@leonardo25gabriel]

Got one of these in november from aliexpress for like 85US$, it was a real fever here in Brazil, a lot of channels did videos on these RX 580 2048sp cards, until now it has worked like a charm, never had any problem with it, and I hope it stays like that. They're literally just an RX 570, but coming from a gt1030, they're perfect for me (even more that I'm still using a Haswell i5 lol), never thought I could have this performance for the price I paid, I play all games on high using 900p because of my monitor, and I even play some games in 1440p/4K when I hook it up to the TV (4K is only playable with FSR), all modern games run perfect for me, from RE4R to Cyberpunk, the only one that didn't run was Forspoken (but that game is trash anyway).

[@GrayXephyr]

I’m using the RX5500 XT right now lol. It’s pretty amazing! Cyberpunk 2077 at 1080p on medium, sitting very comfortably at 60fps! At High it sits at around 30, but if you’re comfy with lower resolution you can consistently get 60fps at higher settings. I don’t know a lot about computers but it feels really good!

[@ShawnMeira]

This is really cool honestly!

[@shaneeslick]

G'day Oz, nice to see a few regular videos lately, hope you are doing well adulting. As long as they are listed correctly I think these Recycled GPU dies & Motherboard chipsets parts are a good compromise for those on a tight budget but are scared of buying used from Ebay or Local Trade Sites, but yeah they also have to be willing to look after those trying to communicate with them about their products not ghosting them.

[@OzTalksHW]

Thanks Shane! always nice to see you in the comment section

[@POLARIS12345]

People forget about workstation GPUs, AMD Pro WX series and Nvidia Quadro series using gputechbench is pretty good way to find workstation GPUS that can still kickass today

[@damien8540]

Does this mean you are going to be back here on KZbin consistently? Missed you for a while and loved to see when you would come back here and there.

[@markallison8108]

I like it too and hopefully it will help drop prices of the brand name products. 👍🏻

[@casstelles]

I'm using an RX580 while typing this comment right now. IMHO, it's a great budget card with decent performance. It won't run rings around the new stuff, but the games I use are DirectX 9c. So, this card does more than what I ever really wanted need.

[@R3TR0J4N]

love the intro and the 3minutes portion of securing the cards are legit. seeing people do worry seeing their price point. yep they works seeing that it runs New World 😆

[@OzTalksHW]

Thanks! That was my biggest concern with these cards. Are they...yknow, legit? I wanted to hone that in first

[@akula625]

I love it and I hope they start doing it to other cards like the rtx 2060

[@WhiteWalls666]

I actually purchase this not to long ago, and it performs very well. I took a chance but did research and I was surprised on how well it runs. Seeing you upload a video about the cards, I was relief and satisfied because it made me feel I made the right choice lol.

[@Foottube710]

These amazing videos deserve a sub

[@onlyfacts3502]

Talk about age all you want my old ass 980 is still crushing it 🤷🏽‍♂️! No plans to replace it until I upgrade from my I5 8500. Great video as always Oz!

[@michaelthompson9798]

I think this rebuilding of a GPU from an older and functional die with new vram, pcb etc is a great thing and if it can offer a vg GPU at a great price ….. it’s a win for gamers so I’m all in!🥰🥳🤩💪

[@chunchunmaru115]

thanks for this video i actually was trying to do a bunch of research for something for a small upgrade but also a working card as i have a rx 580 from my brothers co worker but it crashes every now and then and its weird cuz its not during anything specific maybe during after hours of gaming or even after minutes of turning on so im at a loss and wanted to buy a gpu around under 200. was giving the 1660 super a look and might go with that, after i might go to a 3060 ti. i was also wondering if you think you can maybe do videos about when cpus start to bottle neck the gpu? that would be nice i dont see alot of videos basically saying " this is the max and best gpu you should get for "x" cpu other then that itll be bottlenecked"

[@flaminqhorizon5070]

The only KZbin that actually finds value over expense close to his heart

[@marcc5768]

it's a similar concept behind using older x79 or x99 xeons on fresh new Chinese made x79 or x99 motherboards. I have a e5-2650 v2 used xeon on a Kllisre x79 v2.82 mobo for a Linux Mint rig as my daily driver, not for gaming. I built this back in Oct of 2021. Runs great, and it's speedy enough for my needs. I don't have issue of companies filling that gap in the GPU market that AMD and Nvidia are disregarding. I'm looking in the near future to change up my evga gtx 960 4gb card to something with 8GB down the road. I might be looking at this concept GPUs of used GPU chip on new PCB.

[@lordseptomus441]

I bought my friend a 1660s for his birthday a few weeks ago. these old cards are still great

[@oOZellzimaOo]

Is it me or does this video sound very quiet? Audio sounds kinda muffled?

[@flintfrommother3gaming]

+1

[@orl2222]

I still am running a 1650. The card survived a house fire, took alot of cleaning. I built a new computer with a B550 Vision mother board, 64 gigs of creator menmory, new case power supply, SSD etc. I tried a 380 Intel card, but would not enable HDR on my TV, used as a monitor. I have been waiting to get a newer card, but these prices are insane. I'm not a gamer, but love to do video encoding, and my music files, some of which are DSD albums I bought years ago. I'm old 62, always built my own computers. I do have a mac mini M1 as my stable every day computer for tasks such as online bill pay etc. It is sad that the everyday people can't get into this hobby because of greedy PC parts vendors.

[@SianaGearz]

I once fished a computer out of a dumpster that smelled like fire, it was 2001-ish. The PSU has caught fire and killed off most of the components, but the mainboard, CPU (fresh, Athlon 750) mainboard (MSI, fairly nice) and RAM were alright. HDD, ODD and videocard were toast. Didn't care for the videocard, it was just a Rage, which is a perfect name, this is the emotion you experience when dealing with its driver quality. Anyway absolutely loved the thing after i rebuilt it, carried me a while. Kept the case as well, a Codegen bigtower i think, just washed it a bit. I had an FSP PSU in it, a Maxtor DM80 80GB, a random ODD or two, and an ELSA TNT2 at first and then an ELSA Geforce2mx. Driving a nice 20" Mitsubishi CRT. I've done video capture and editing on that PC, edited in Ulead Pro, with 3ivx intermediate, so smooth. With a random bt848 for capture. Printed the results to VHS.

[@jonhadley8387]

you could also get a gtx 1080 or 1070 ti used for around the same price used

[@rw5096]

Great video I watch a lot of tech channels and I haven't seen anyone cover these. I think it's very interesting. I also feel that if this company continues to make out of print cards with higher vram on them at a decent price it will be interesting to see how a heavy vram game will react to them. I picked up Dec a 6750xt 12gig model two fan card for 450 which still is better then the 4070 which is wild to me. Love your vibe new subscribe here.

[@FallacyAsPraxis]

I've come to realize that many of those tech channels are mere shills for the big companies that sell overpriced hardware. They're never going to talk about stuff like this.

[@3k.in4k]

I'm surprised you didn't talk about the rx 580 sooner

[@stronkveak5917]

RX 580 here, solid entry level gaming gpu, can be had for 80-100 euros used, I am at an 1080p 60hz monitor, and haven't even overclocked it.

[@HuntaKiller91]

Funny thing is this brand is selling 5600xt for this price aswell Maybe nxtyr we'll hv 5700xt with refurb brands be around $100++ aswell

[@DiamondDepthYT]

I found an rx 6600xt for $160. Should I get it? I'm planning on saving up to upgrade my mbo, cpu, and ram, as right now, I run an i7 4770, 32gb ddr3 1600mhz ram, and a gtx 1660 6gb. Should I wait until after I upgrade my other components, or get it now?

[@crapmoviereviews1878]

Great content.

[@NCrdwlf]

I hate to say it but I’ve had horrible luck with MSI . I just got a X570 board back and it’s finally working correctly. The turnaround was good , but this is my 3rd MSI board that has had to be sent back over the years . I’ve had a doa card as well . I’m going to give this brand a try .

[@jakefarmer]

just bought a rx 5500xt that has the same shroud as this card but a different backplate and is from a different manufacturer (51risc). hasn't arrived yet but from the pictures on newegg it's the same shroud just with different stickers on the fans and a different backplate.

[@PinePizza]

I dig budget setups, even if I'm not using them myself. Today it's not a question of if something will run, it's about how it will run so even older GPUs are usually fine. The only exception are some AAA games with terrible optimization and those are rarely relevant to justify any upgrade. I noticed this trend or hardware companies acting as if 4k is the new hot stuff, but so many people play at 1080p and it's totally fine while maybe 1440p is the sweet spot if you have more budget. For 60Hz gaming so many GPUs are more than enough and with AM5 getting more and more things out AM4 will only get more affordable.

[@madmax2069]

Im still stuck with a 1660 Super from when i built my system back in Feb 2020.

[@Randomness662]

Honey, there's a new Oz video!

[@h0rk3d]

that looks like an active guitar, what do you play Oz?

[@BigSac420]

Hey man I would love to see you build a home gaming server! I have been running them on the same computer for a couple years and would like some guidance for home gaming server hardware. I know they are nothing special but it would still be cool.

[@playboihaim]

i ran an rx 580 until december when i got an rtx 3060 ti, great card

[@nintendoatarikiller]

Man it feels like yesterday we couldn't even get a video card at msrp.

[@StevenReviews]

The GTX 1060 6g I'm running is 296% faster, A normal small 550 goes for $54 while the 1060 goes for around $100

[@peregrin_e]

RX 580s for 100$ have been really common lately

[@oOZellzimaOo]

Back before Covid, I could find 2nd hand 580s for 90 to 120 bucks. That was back in 2018.

[@flintfrommother3gaming]

580 doesn't support DirectX 12.1 Feature Levels so you won't be able to play the new games without patches like DXVK.

[@R3TR0J4N]

was it the 2048SP ?

[@WHF.Resale]

I bought 4 asrock rx 580s for $82 each recently.

[@drewdane40]

​@@R3TR0J4N It's an RX 570 that they call an RX 580. They were built for mining, but they missed the mining boom

[@mecca6801]

If you get modified drivers, you can play modern games like Robocop or starfield

[@Joshyboy_on_60hz]

I want to know if you would need the same graphics driver as normal Rx 580 with the aisurix card

[@EzBreezy750]

Double Oz videos 😮

[@Pixel-tl6fo]

Have you thought of checking out the mi25 cards?

[@_dev_null_]

This channel is amazing. Nice to see someone making budget rigs, and saving perfectly usable PC's from the junk pile of planned obsolescence.

[@aaldrich1982]

Please can you do a follow up quick video where you test how well the VRAM will OC? If these chips have been mined on then it's usually the RAM that takes a beating. I'd be interested to know if that has been refreshed or if it's the same VRAM that - if it's a 580 - has potentially been through both of the mining GPU droughts.

[@OzTalksHW]

I unfortunately can't do a video, but I did overclock the VRAM on the RX 580 using AMD's Adrenaline software. Here are my settings :D 1350 Mhz Core @ 1100 mV | 2250 MHz VRAM @ 850 mV | +50% Power Limit

[@aaldrich1982]

@@OzTalksHW appreciate you taking the time to reply. Those OCs don't sound too bad so hopefully these cards will last new users a while. Polaris just refuses to die.

[@dorion9111]

The GPU chip could be new from partners that have never made cards from them and had left over stock which is now going down the line to lower end card makers... It's cheaper to find unused GPU's that are left over in warehouses then de-solder and sell as good as new which requires extensive tests and so on...

[@franksred1]

the ads say the cards support 8k display 😂

[@boredzoomer]

can you check out sjs they seem to do the same thing with old gpus?

[@lomax1919]

Dude, with that calm voice and approach you should be on a radio station as you could help and teach people with road rage to take it easy ;-)

[@icebladesamurai]

What CPU and RAM did you use for the benchmarks?

[@maronndabasol7160]

I bought one Aisurix RX 580 2048sp for $87 USD equivalent here in Philippines. Best deal price to performance. 1080p gaming Med-High setting. This is perfectly fine for me because I only play: Nier Automata - lock at 60fps 1080p high Nier Replicant - lock at 60fps 1080p high Dota 2 - average 180fps 1080p best looking I don't play AAA games. Nothing beats the Nier Automata narratives and soundtrack. It's a masterpiece!

[@eggflavoredegg2591]

BTW on Newegg that same GPU is around 70 USD

[@StayPuft209]

I think the catch was something about the bandwidth or memory speeds being halfed from a standard 580 cause it was a mobile chip or something. Seen toasty bros use one of these.

[@givemyhatback]

My RX 480 8gb playes Hitman 3 at 2k + Quality FSR settings at 60fps and 4k + performance FSR settings at 30-45 fps! The RX 580 is just the 480 with a slight clock boost.

[@TheGOAT-fx9wx]

bought the same for just $71 and works great

[@MrTurbored21]

hey right now on newegg the MLLSE "same card from what i understand" rx580 8gb are on sale for $69.99 after tax and expedited shipping i paid $88 !

[@airmicrobe]

Rx 6500 XT 4gb 80 USD, just find a seller who regret buying it already. But missing codec was no problem and it was proven to be a good value card. X 264 software encoding with cpu power it had no problem in my usages

[@a_riptide7697]

bro this is definitely the video ever

[@silvere4gle648]

I know it might sound stupid but could you try pairing it with another 580 and see if it gains any performance

[@Minezerp]

Here in asia region, it costs 80$ with the same brand. It's a win-win for sure

[@R3TR0J4N]

fr tho "Are they ACTUALLY new..?" timestamp is really comforting, i already trust them since i bought one back 2019 it works.

[@ipoopmuffins]

i saw some rx580s for around $90 on either amazon or newegg a few days ago. that blew my mind, sure its not an amazing card by todays standards but its still a damn good card for 1080p. Edit : just double checked and found an rx580 for $69 (nice) on sale. dont know if i trust that particular brand but damn.

[@OzTalksHW]

Woah, that's a killer price if it's "new"