P.T. [10 YEARS LATER]

[@yoshifan3077]

Didn't Konami tried to delete this game a long time ago

[@GameGrumps]

Yeah but we had a PS4 that hadn't been connected to the internet in 10 years. Konami can't take from us what they cannot reach.

[@jaboopyfuddles4864]

Minor spelling mistake. I win.​@@GameGrumps

[@MKDDFS]

@@jaboopyfuddles4864nerd

[@Rsixsix]

It doesnt delete it from your console if you have it connected to the internet, you just cant redownload it if you ever do delete it.

[@barachurch9724]

@@GameGrumps how on Earth did that happen or is this japes

[@dland25]

Doing a “last time on game grumps” from an iconic one-off 10 years ago is CRAZY GOATED

[@XanadudeFilms]

So true. Now they gotta do tungulus again.

[@Jayfive276]

Things aren’t iconic just because you remember them.

[@bingonight1504]

​@@Jayfive276ok man

[@ShtikMahn]

​@Jayfive276 it's literally the most watched gameplay video on the channel.

[@LinuxUs13]

a nice bow to the history of the ggs

[@inugamidalton8270]

I love how much Dan simultaneously hates this game so much he yells at it and is fascinated by it to notice all these little touches he doesn't remember or didn't notice from the first time. Meanwhile Arin sounds like he's trying to figure out how to get to the airport parking or something.

[@yufi305]

😂Omg Yeah he does, lol

[@4aw50fGold]

It’s great to see how Dan is growing a deeper appreciation for horror games. His growing character arc of 11 years XD

[@jolynelovemail]

That’s ngl how I am with most horror. Experiencing horror often provokes a strong reaction in me but I’m so fascinated by themes and small details that I continue to experience it

[@Smurfman256]

OCD vs ADHD. And what seems like unmedicated ADHD at that.

[@Colonelloki]

@@Smurfman256try having both at once! Constantly getting distracted by small details

[@Mayhemzz]

I like how it took all of 6 minutes for Dan to go from "We've changed as people, horror's come a long way, we'll be fine!" to "I am no longer in control of my emotions."

[@Cobalt360Degrees]

Honestly? Same. I was so sure I was going to be fine. And I was absolutely _not fine_ at almost the exact same timestamp.

[@zeroraptor_]

The theory that Arin alluded to is that you cross time and space during the events of P.T. So when you see the bathroom door rattling at one point, that's actually you in another point in time trying to open the door. And when you look through the peephole from the bathroom, the eye you see on the other side is your eye looking back from another point in time. Given the quote at the beginning of the game and that this is a phenomenon that happened in previous Silent Hill games, the theory is strongly believed to be true.

[@arowace498]

Oh cool! I'm scared all over again!

[@brookejon3695]

The only me is me. Are you sure the only you is you?

[@Finkster5]

That's cool as shit. Really freaky, weird concept that I love for horror, or just any surreal/existential story.

[@GothicOctopus]

I never even thought of that. That’s awesome.

[@jblen]

Especially given the whole thing is a loop, and the time never changes, that theory makes a lot of sense

[@kaisawatson]

The fact that they don't remember certain conversations, and repeat them almost word for word several years ago is so funny to me. Good to know that Dan still has the same 7 days tolerance to people puking on him, even after all this years.

[@TheOwnometer]

...and they did this while playing a game, again, ten years later. It was just...*chef's kiss*

[@Bluechief6]

One time they played Hollywood Squares twice and made the same Seinfeld joke almost word for word.

[@natering5215]

They are dumb in so many ways as characters; but super consistent.

[@MuffinTBaggins]

I thought I was fucking crazy. Thank you.

[@punkfluff3395]

It's been10 years.

[@Crim_5009]

I can’t tell you how many times I’ve rewatched the PT playthrough, I’m so happy right now

[@thelostone7512]

I thought i had clicked on the old PT video at first lol

[@indigo_glasswing]

same!!! it’s one of my all time favorites

[@TheAbbyNormal]

It's weirdly one of my favorite comfort watches

[@alliphx]

@@TheAbbyNormal SAME! 😆

[@Zaque-TV]

Seriously. I can hear Dan screaming in my head 🤣

[@shiftychaos]

16:45 dan catching that second voice saying "umbilical cord" is so damn vindicating for me. i heard that the first time i watched someone play this, and i swear NO ONE else heard it at the time.

[@DannyScratch]

Never heard it but I'm glad her caught it. There's something about the imagery that fascinated me.

[@riakun]

My friend caught it the first time we played it (I didn’t though), but I had forgotten about it until rewatching this game

[@TypeHoeNegative]

@@DannyScratch🤨🤨

[@zombieslayer02gjustzombies85]

Idk it was pretty easy to hear I believe, especially back when the volume of KZbin recordings or phones was much louder to hear something quieter like that

[@riakun]

@@zombieslayer02gjustzombies85 I didn’t hear it. My friend did though. It seems to be easier for some people to understand more than others

[@thaddeushamlet]

"Norman Reedus and the Funky Fetus" just made me realise that Hideo would have taken some of his silent hill plans into Death Stranding 😂

[@PanAndScanBuddy]

Even Guillermo Del Toro!

[@GreatWightSpark]

"It's a metaphor" 😂

[@eIailio]

he definitely did 😂 this was the last thing he did regarding silent hills and he took his whole idea to his own studio and made DS. totally worth it

[@ElFreakinCid]

@@PanAndScanBuddy Shame he couldn't bring Junji Ito along, apparently he was set to do art design for Silent Hills.

[@benw1544]

The PT house would be an interesting zillow listing. 0 bed 1 bath, infinite square feet. Bit of a fixer upper with real potential, mild roach problem

[@vcutler4735]

Still 2 million dollars and they won't let you do an inspection first

[@BambooAcrobatVerte]

Shared bath with Jellybaby

[@benw1544]

@BambooAcrobatVerte in today's economy a roommate is nothing to be ashamed of

[@ShadowEX7]

@@benw1544 Mildly haunted, but the ghosts pay rent!

[@ExtremeSquared]

It's just House Of Leaves.

[@BambooAcrobatVerte]

12:31 "He's fine! His two hearts are beating just fine!" *Jewish grandmother voice* "MY Jellygrandson has TWO hearts...and four stomachs. He's like a cow!"

[@eepyknight]

MY grandson is a wizard!!

[@BambooAcrobatVerte]

@@eepyknight he can turn YOUR grandson into a Jellybaby...ohh he already is! Nevermind.

[@Yakshimara]

"If he'd only get out of the sink and take up his father's job at the pharmaceutical company. Maybe meet a nice lady with minor thyroid issues and get to having great Jellygrandbabies. Not that he even bothers to call his sweet granny with that super sensitive mother of his turning him against me!"

[@DustinHorvath1987]

@@eepyknight lol I still keep thinking of that every couple days and cracking up. "MY grandson is a warlock!"

[@MaGiKRat420]

"how many hearts and stomachs does YOUR grandson have?"

[@Insaneian]

10 years later, P.T. is the 270th game the Grumps have beaten! Congrats, boys! 59:00

[@Aqueous92]

The universe is in balance (well except for punch out, like 3 Sonics, the second dlc of botw, etc)

[@butterflyknivez]

how do you know this

[@miguelnewmexico8641]

@@butterflyknivez it is his power, it is his curse, let us pray he never uses it for evil.

[@Insaneian]

@@butterflyknivez haven't you asked me that before? 😅 I know this because I keep a running talley of all the games the Grumps have beaten, on a spreadsheet!

[@NewsmanMickson]

So close to 666

[@Randinator]

A thunderstorm just broke out while I was watching this. It wasn’t even forecasted. The power went out too. This game is truly cursed

[@LAURA---]

I wouldn’t sleep for a week if that happened to me whilst watching this video 😂

[@krbthewitch]

It's kind of amazing how a game that never came out was so influential on horror games moving forward. The atmosphere, the sound design, the knowledge that something terrible happened but only a skewed version of events from someone we don't even know the identity of. It's influence and disappointment backstory all still infamous to this day.

[@drudle]

Honestly, I'd put it up there as one of the top five influential horror games ever made. And it wasn't actually made.

[@eepyknight]

So well put honestly. It terrifies and excited me with the atmosphere and the story. I really wanted to know more of the story and where it was going to go which makes me still incredibly sad

[@joshuahoward4556]

The sound design is so good in this. Like, it has someone doing a terrified scream. Hearing creepy crying or footsteps is so often used that it kind of gets bland unless used really well. But someone doing a genuine sounding scream or plead for mercy, that'll make your hair stand on end. And it did for me during that one moment of this game. And I don't even blame indie or AAA games for not doing it because, as far as I know, it's not an easy thing to do or set up properly.

[@drudle]

@@joshuahoward4556 Honestly, all levels of production on just this demo really set us up for how amazing the game was going to be. Like, "If this is what an hour is like, how will all of it be?!"

[@Cvillain626]

Seriously...it's kind of wild, P.T. completely changed the course of the Resident Evil series for the better

[@Pianodanmusica11y]

It’s beautiful to see that Arin has all but completely forgotten everything about this, while Danny remembers the trauma with almost photogenic precision. Edit: @askthepizzaguy caught me, I used photogenic instead of photographic. But I'm gonna chalk it up to a Freudian slip when writing about Dan.

[@zeldadonkey1]

For Dan the day P.T scared him, it was the most important day of his life. For Arin, it was Tuesday

[@askthepizzaguy]

Photograhic, unless this is a reference to something. Photogenic means looks great in pictures.

[@kenzierasmussen442]

Hate to be that person but don’t you mean photographic?

[@saltedpretzels]

​@@askthepizzaguy You heard what the man said. Dan's terrified trauma looks good on celluloid.

[@Pianodanmusica11y]

Man’s attractive, and I’m not too proud to admit that.

[@irishdlt8066]

New STARBOMB and PT 10 years later on the same day. Grumps are giving us throwback Friday!

[@Ashen_Hiro]

Gotta throw it back on throwback fridays

[@TheGenomario]

When did they mention Starbomb

[@TheHellreaper25]

@TheGenomario they didn't but they just released a new music video

[@mariorezar1438]

​@@TheGenomario they will be givinng us a new album 10/25/2024 for now its just a one song out

[@CONTACTLIGHT2]

I remember watching the first game grumps playthrough of PT with my girlfriend, we both screamed at every jumpscare and then laughed so hard at Dan being even more scared than us. Game grumps was such a big part of our time together, we'd watch it after work and cry with laughter together. She died last year. I know she would have loved this, thanks for everything you do guys, this re-visit means a lot. Also it's still hilarious!!

[@omegapuppyttv]

i'm so sorry for your loss

[@jackbassindale4336]

Oh man that's heartbreaking. I'm sure she's at peace now

[@thewritingfreak6569]

IM SO GLAD DAN PICKED UP ON THE UMBILICAL CORD LINE! It's my favorite little creepy thing in this whole experience

[@jsag2001]

i never noticed that holy shit love this game

[@animelover4allanime]

I’ve watched what must be 20 playthroughs of this and I never picked up on that, can’t believe PT is still masterpiecing all these years later

[@yikes8317]

What is it in specific?​@@animelover4allanime

[@animelover4allanime]

@@yikes831716:39

[@jolynelovemail]

@@yikes8317on the phone call, when it says the man hung himself with a garden hose (I think), a second voice over it says “he hung himself with the umbilical cord”

[@JonSudano]

Woah did I just sh t my pants? No, it's PT 10 years later!

[@graphicsgod]

I shit my pants and it's P.T. again!! Yay!!

[@kantackistan]

PT of course stands for Poopy Troubles.

[@emanuilspasov3678]

You should check anyway

[@yufi305]

Nice throwback reference 😂👍

[@scorpion0498]

but also yes!

[@Penquinn14]

For the record: you can see her in the game as she's following you. She's basically slowly chasing you through every room and if you take too long she eventually catches you, kills you, and you restart from the last "checkpoint" that is the loop you're currently on

[@GreenCorgiQueen]

Ooh is that why they got killed during the ep?

[@Colonelloki]

@@GreenCorgiQueenpossibly? Look up Lance McDonald’s video on Lisa’s unseen behaviors. It’s beat

[@ClassyCrustatio]

No she does not slowly move towards you, she is just attached to the player so her twotching shadow is seen but she isn't. It's just to put the player at unease. She will NOT attack you ni matter how long you wait.

[@cornbredx]

Nah. She almost always catches you once. I've never seen a complete play through without this happening, but other than that one time she won't do anything but follow you. Some runs I've done she never shows up at all. Some (like this game grumps one apparently) she shows up in every spot she is able to (I've never seen that happen before- it's crazy they got all of those in one video to me). Her behavior is pretty crazy (random), but they're all scripted moments that are supposed to happen. She's not technically "chasing" you because her "catching you"- while random (it can happen anywhere)- is a scripted moment just like you being able to see her standing in the alcove, or outside the window, etc. It's just another one of her visible haunting states. It's not really a game over because this game doesn't have real fail states. Technically.

[@John_1-1_in_Japanese]

@@GreenCorgiQueen When she's stalking the player, she normally stays right behind you but if you turn the camera around too fast she'll attack.

[@aw3zom3zauc39]

although the game was never made, you can tell that PT had such a huge impact on the horror gaming community. the hyper-realism, the first person perspective, and the looping aspect became a trend in mainstream and indie games after this was released. everyone wanted to recreate the experience that was PT, but i don’t think any game will ever be able to come close to it. PT’s just THAT good!

[@taterboob]

It practically created a new subgenre of horror games, with stuff like Layers of Fear, Visage, and Madison following in its wake, and I would imagine that Resident Evil going first-person was partly inspired by PT, and the early marketing for REVII was very much inspired by it. Before we knew who Mia was, she was just "the creepy lady from the Kitchen demo".

[@wiggelzz11]

Do you have any examples?

[@drinkmydamntea1068]

@@wiggelzz11 The Park comes to mind. there's an entire section near the end of the game with the 'looping hallway that gets worse' motif. the game came out only a year after as well.

[@tangentartists6876]

I love that this time around Arin is weirdly fond of Jellybaby as opposed to 10 years ago when he wanted to punt him like a football. He's truly embracing his "Daddy" phase.

[@jessamyseeds6066]

Wasn't it Dan that hated jellybean? Arin kept callin it his babe

[@GabbyEspo123]

Arin screaming for 30 seconds followed by silence making him scream for ANOTHER 30 seconds killed me 😂😂

[@joshneubrand4048]

Hey Dan. Fun fact for you, if you didn't know: They simulated the game from start to finish and did an "out of body" run. Guess what they found out. She's behind you, just out of view, from the moment you wake up in the roach room. (Wish I was kidding, but it's true)

[@shadowboy2818]

think arin already told him that. But still interesting nonetheless.

[@lunarskys2645]

Is there a video? Cuz I wanna see that

[@miguelnewmexico8641]

@@lunarskys2645 i think Boundary Break showed it.

[@lunarskys2645]

@@miguelnewmexico8641 ty man

[@Seffyzero]

They didn't simulate anything. They just used a mod to have a third person camera and a free mode camera.

[@crystaldollhouse]

“What if I threw up on your lap, would you be upset?” is Arin’s version of “Would you still love me if I was a worm?”

[@ScutchMcDuck]

Ten years ago, I watched the game grumps for the first time. This was my introduction to my favorite KZbinrs. Thank you guys, I love you

[@coffeeguyd]

ME TOO!

[@Dark_Jeff]

Arin- "I dont remember any of this Dan- *SWEATS IN TRAUMA*

[@vigilantScrivener]

The tree remembers what the Arin forgets

[@bugdomrulez]

ill be forever pissed about this game. konami would have literally printed money with this thing, not to mention how amazing it was to have junji ito, guillermo del toro, and kojima on one project. the fact this is a DEMO and is as good and influential as it was...

[@Mykasan]

JUNJI ITO participated in this ?! wtf konami

[@arisperwinanya9641]

Junji Ito?! THE horror manga guy?! Oh my gosh Konami is stupid! Guillermo del toro too?! and Kojima?! Konami took a rocket launcher, turned it around, and blew themselves up with that. So disappointing.

[@kotarodesu_23]

Corporate greed at its finest

[@hannahmellon9141]

B-b-but it wouldn't print money as fast as their precious dumpware mobile app slot machines!!!

[@kotarodesu_23]

@@hannahmellon9141 Yup. Wasn't that business model suggested by a former intern too? All that trust and effort put into the company only to be usurped by some greedy greenhorn.

[@AshleyHavener]

I legit thought this was "hypothetical" 10 years ago, but nah, this is a LEGIT 10 years ago. This was played when I was 19. Today I'm 29. Holy moly. Yes, today, 8/17, is my birthday.

[@dominokore]

Happy birthday! 🎉

[@bianca1506]

I hope you had a great birthday! I was 15 and now I turn 25 this year! 😂 time flies!

[@AshleyHavener]

@@dominokore thank you!

[@AshleyHavener]

@@bianca1506 I did thanks!

[@zombieslayer02gjustzombies85]

I was 12, and you better believe my stupid ass watched markiplier or some nonexistent KZbinr play it at night and stay up being terrified even after being hyped af by the teaser to silent hills

[@benedictscarafiotti2902]

Plot: A man called 'Dan' is trapped in a hell of his own creation. His only escape? Another man named 'Arin' has to focus his attention on something for at least 10 seconds. There is no hope for Dan..

[@z-beeblebrox]

spoken in the radio voice

[@Omegaflaire]

"Not like you can die in this game"...10 years later and 20 minutes in and it finally happened...Arin finally f'd around and found out!

[@miss-tessbess]

The amazing thing is if you recall, Arin at least had a good knowledge of what was happening in the first video (the bathroom door, for instance). This time, though, he forgot about all of that, but Dan didn't, so Dan's the one helping him remember some things. Also YESSS THEY GOT THE JUMPSCARE!! Thats the one thing that was missing last time!

[@blueflare3848]

Doesn’t everyone get the jumpscare?

[@miss-tessbess]

@@blueflare3848 They don't! I don't remember the specifics of how it's triggered, but if you watch their old playthrough, they didn't get it! They did see Lisa in the hallway at the end of the episode run towards them, but that's it! It's super cool to see them react to more of her, as before they only got scripted encounters, minus that one hallway run.

[@jordynozymandias374]

​@@blueflare3848nah there's one where Lisa grabs you and takes you down. They didn't get it on their first somehow. I thought it was unavoidable.

[@Ergand]

I vaguely remember reading back then that there's a jumpscare triggered by turning too fast at a certain point. I also remember Arin very obviously stopping and quickly turning around a lot like he was expecting a jumpscare, and I always assumed he was trying to trigger it on purpose, but failed.

[@ShoppingAttic]

​@@jordynozymandias374UNAVOIDABLE CHIN MOVE

[@smidgen7773]

love that they revisited the "how many days in a row could i throw up in your lap before you get really mad at me" question

[@ExposerPro]

"Don't touch that dial now, we're just getting started" still gives me goosebumps

[@maximuffin6395]

They didn't get started

[@GreatWightSpark]

Player, beware! You're in for a scare 🧟

[@elysej91]

That was the ✨moment✨ that I got started!!

[@Road_to_Dawn]

I still think about that line damn near every day, even ten years later

[@adamzapplezzz]

@@elysej91if i had to trace back to the very 🤏Moment🤏where i got Started.. it would be That.

[@anti_honey]

0:04 I still remember first seeing this like it was last month

[@James_Stan808]

That long ago?

[@J--Dubs]

IKR

[@mage1439]

Dan claims to remember the playthrough well, but somehow he keeps thinking they haven't gotten this far when they finished it the first time.

[@dumbbumsc5329]

I’ve watched it multiple times and it really feels like I just watched it a week ago. I’m so happy

[@Wizardofslimes]

Me too…because I first watched it a month ago

[@TrulydaMoosey]

Fun (yet traumatizing) fact: That nice lady that charges at you? They decided that wasn't enough, so she's actually following behind you. The entire game. Yup.

[@missswiss6498]

Ohh. That explains the twitchy shadow in the reflection

[@ShooprDoopr]

@@missswiss6498 Exactly! I remember reading somewhere that the game code shows you that she's actually behind you the entire time. The shaky shadow is so freaky! Fun that this game is 10 years old and there are still little details like that to find

[@sydc3667]

Oh, so like the two roaches that you see crawling around about four minutes in, one directly behind the other. Damn.

[@shadowboy2818]

aww she likes us and is feeling lonely...what a sweet lady...

[@MEZOMEZO2011]

Do you see her if you go back?

[@supershasha]

I’ve never actually *seen* gameplay of someone beating PT and after 10 years of not finishing it, this is so satisfying. You guys are great ❤

[@tuckerniklas7616]

10 years... that's insane to me... I was 30 watching them... Now I'm a 40 year old geriatric watching Arin terrorize Dan once again.... What a great time to be alive!

[@Jennilynne]

I was also 30 and now I'm a 40 (almost 41) old lady. Hopefully neither of us has a heart attack watching the spooks

[@Tardisntimbits]

I'm 44 man, if you two are "old", then I am closer to being dust lol.

[@darkunykorn404]

same brother, i was 29 turning 30 and now i'm 39 turning 40 what a day

[@RichardPrieto-jx2dv]

I am also reporting in for the "Just turned 40" club! I dont watch the Grumps as much as I used to back when they had their full lineup, but this is still a blast from the past!

[@agun4080]

I was 6 that feel cool on your old bones

[@maymaymar27]

Message pops up. Dan: What does that mean? Arin: I don't know. It's fucking italian or something 10 years ago: Message pops up. Dan: Oh, good! You fucking put it on italian! Arin: What, no, that's not italian. That's just the words...

[@alexh3158]

It translates to (then his index finger slid on my hand) it is Italian

[@alexh3158]

Sorry the first one translates to that the other one is kinda hard to make out the wording of

[@BeanSparrow]

one of the messeges i saw was in german too

[@na_marie]

its mama’s ragu recipe from dangan ranpa

[@CrazeeAdam]

Btw!! The numbers that are randomly said 240863 is Hideo Kojima's birthday. Nothing more. He's born August 24th, 1963

[@WillzeeWoo]

*24th August 😉👌🏻😅

[@CrazeeAdam]

​@@WillzeeWooI think most people do say the month first. Even if written day first? Although maybe some places do say the day first?

[@jo3473]

@@WillzeeWoo both ways of writing the date are right. correcting someone to your own personal preference is dickish. 😉👌😅

[@Jenny-hz1wy]

*204863, not 240863. There are a number of fan theories about the number, but it probably does just refer to Kojima's birthday, as you said.

[@stevendemayo3631]

@@WillzeeWoo you're a clown

[@DemonicNightmare]

Honestly, it's really amazing to see how much Dan *has* grown more of a tolerance for these games, considering the first time he flat out left the room for a few minutes. It was really cool to see them play this again, and I loved seeing their reactions to the end reveal :D

[@MrsCurioCheerio]

It’s so incredible to me how this game, which is only a demo, still remains to be one of the most iconic horror game experiences

[@z-beeblebrox]

These guys made a proof of concept just to demonstrate how cool their take on Silent Hill *could* be, blew everyone's minds with it, fundamentally altered the entire landscape of indie horror for an entire decade, and Konami looked at all that and said "nah"

[@Rsixsix]

20:22 with Dan unable to hold back his screams of terror as Arin drives straight toward destruction is so funny.

[@DarlingDreadful]

Thank you for this timestamp 😂

[@Three60Mafia]

Cant believe how hard Konami fumbled the bag with this and Kojima. This little demo basically set the template for every horror game of last 10 years... and they earned exactly 0 dollars from that.

[@smellylorenny]

It’s one of the biggest tragedies of the decade it STILL gets me so unbelievably infuriated and depressed like I genuinely can’t get over the fact we could have had the most unforgettable and star studded silent hill comebacks ever. Instead we got… Norman reedus astronaut babysitter simulator.

[@SyndicateOperative]

@@smellylorenny "star studded" is awful. No one wants TV show has-beens in their games.

[@SxfetyPin]

​@@SyndicateOperative Your first grade teacher just called. You need to go back! Your reading comprehension needs some serious work.

[@jakobstaley5712]

It finally happened. I'm one of the Jacobs. I was falling asleep when Dan told me he was watching. My dreams have come true.

[@virgil2461]

don't worry, it was Jacob with a C, you're safe 👍

[@lmmmmmmm]

Ive never clicked so fast in my entire life

[@TheNarwhalGasper]

True😭✨

[@TheWallsaretalking1]

Yo same

[@ScottyFang]

Dude same

[@piplup10203854]

Right! Same :D enjoy!

[@kingbear283]

Same here dude! 😊

[@MegaVidFan1]

7:25 "I cant believe they never made this game!" Dan realizing about 5-years posthumously that PT basically died before it could be borne into a brand-new Silent Hill franchise inflicted so much emotional damage I was NOT ready for. Me too, Danny... me too...

[@keithshaughnessy1730]

P.T. might not exist as a full game, but Kojima is making a new game with Jordan Peele that during the announcement used P.T. style imagery, so we may get something close to what Silent Hills was going to be... maybe with 10 times more cutscenes though

[@Vanity0666]

All of the assets and ideas eventually ended up in Death Stranding, the street section at the end during the reveal is the main through street in Port Knot City

[@Necromagenvi0n]

@@keithshaughnessy1730 You're referring to "OD", is it?

[@dowfreak7]

@@keithshaughnessy1730 Given how Kojima handled Death Stranding, it's very unlikely he'd make a good PT nowadays. It's just gonna have 50 billion "I made this game" texts everywhere, will be filled with "haha, le random" cutscenes and feature terrible gameplay.

[@keithshaughnessy1730]

@Necromagenvi0n no apparently. There's a third game that the only thing known so far is Jordan Peele is involved and he walked out of the P.T. door to be revealed... unless I misunderstood that Game Awards segment. Edit: Jordan was wearing an OD shirt so I was probably incorrect about it being a third game. Oops

[@ShadowAnimist]

13:10 fun fact, that's not your shadow 😉 the developers made that ghost woman follow you the whole game but made her invisible to you.

[@AlkalineOrion]

21:00 If that scene triggered during the 2014 playthrough, Dan would still be screaming now

[@wyv3rn1]

that part got me so good hotdamn

[@charlesschneider7769]

Holy crap I screamed 😂

[@RashiiKitsuke]

The game didn't even get me that good when I played it. The magic of game grumps lmao.

[@PanAndScanBuddy]

It did! Just in a different part.

[@MidgarMerc]

I'm so confused cause I always thought the ONLY time Lisa can kill you is if you don't gouge out the eyes and go to the next loop. I guess she'll kill you if you get attacked during a haunt but I've literally never seen it and I've played this thing like 10x

[@jhknightmare5131]

I went from cry laughing at Dan calling Arin a “saucy bitch” to scaring my cat when I involuntarily yelled when the lady grabbed them Thanks grumps for giving me emotional whiplash 🤣

[@haegtesse]

10 years ago I was watching this at the gym and in a loveless relationship. Since then I got dumped, started over, met a new guy, got a master's degree, changed careers, bought a house, and got married. 1st anniversary coming up. It's great you guys are still doing this show and tracked down a copy of this! Edit: I genuinely screamed watching this TEN YEARS LATER WTF

[@internettevarolanadam]

Damn. How did you buy a house?

[@Ghost_emoji]

Wow GG

[@augustlewen]

Damn! Good for you! I haven't gotten anywhere in either my love life or career since 10 years ago xD

[@internettuffguy1197]

aren't you a Man?

[@DirtyCasual36]

7:28 Fun Fact: That's because of the fact that Konami were earning way more money through Silent Hill Pachinko than actually making games (I know, it's stupid). But in the recent years, Japan changed their Pachinko laws to regulate them so the odds of winning were fairly decent and have to be inspected, thus GREATLY reducing companies' profits from unfair pachinko odds. That's why Companies are starting to make games again with their IP's (SNK with Fatal Fury/KOF, Capcom with DMC, SEGA-Sammy with Sonic, and now Konami with Silent Hill and MGS)

[@zid9611]

Yup burnt all there gaming bridge for gambling. Gambling get too lucrative so gov stepped in. And they think gamer's will come back. Na. Konami name is mud. And never be fixed.

[@Smoking_Gear]

I adore that they have the same energy as the initial playthrough. Arin nonchalantly doing his thing, Dan freaking the fuck out. My favorite of their dynamics!

[@s_napps]

arin knowing about the whole lore around pt but remembering nothing about the game itself

[@myounakami]

The more things change, the more they stay the same.

[@OriionCygnus]

For anyone wondering, Ship of Theseus is a thought experiment where you replace the damaged boards of a ship one by one until you have replaced every component of the ship. At what point does it stop being the original ship? Its like how human cells are constantly dying and being replaced and at a certain point your body contains zero cells that it contained when you were born, so physically you are literally not the same person you used to be right down to your very skeleton.

[@ShtikMahn]

Its the climb - Miley Cyrus

[@andrewlatty]

Well, your neurons that comprise your brain won’t regenerate if they die. So, they’re the same ones you were born with unless you’ve had some form of trauma or hypoxia which killed them.

[@OddCanuck420]

@@andrewlatty drugs, lots of drugs

[@deejaepjs]

Honestly, that thought experiment is terrible...It's still the original ship; Ur just doing maintenence to the ship and keeping it new; Unless your giving it NEW PARTS, (like adding a new mast with a mermaid on it or something), then it wouldn't be the "original ship", but if your like replacing one of the boards or something, then ur just doing maintenance on it and just keeping it new; It's still the same ship...

[@thespacemarine247]

@@deejaepjsThe name stays the same, if every component is replaced, no, it's not LITERALLY the same ship. It is the same ship as in you haven't changed the name. A retrofitted ship is still the same ship in name, but with new parts.

[@AdeptusCaeiusIII]

Honestly, the fact that- even after all these years- Arin still has the uncanny ability to instantly pick up on Dan being freaked out about something and make it A LOT WORSE is a true testament to their friendship. People who can really, truly make life Hell for you are the ones you trust the hardest. It's nothing malicious, for sure, but it's just really funny that seemingly without really paying attention, Arin can screw with Dan THIS HARD. He did it the first time around, and he did it this time.

[@robertzurface9042]

Fantastic insight!

[@LagunaX1]

10 years and not one clone of this demo ever came close to it. The sound design, lighting and atmosphere are on a level only industry veterans can pull off. Such a shame the full game never happened.

[@krisma3526]

Check out a game called Visage, inspired heavily from this game and does a pretty good job at carrying the horror atmosphere. Very underrated game

[@GiuseppeGaetanoSabatelli]

Considering this was 2 years into development and was canceled another year later, there's a very real chance that Silent Hills is more or less complete and just locked away on Konami's servers somewhere. I wonder how Kojima dishonored them that they would be this vindictive. It's like the rumor that Sony Pictures canceled Amazing Spider-Man 3 because Andrew Garfield was late to an event once. 😅 Japanese companies are wild.

[@snowbelle3066]

Man hearing Dan say "Why are we doing this?" At ALMOST the same exact time as the last video is insane

[@grimpitbull]

The game is a lot scarier once you know the systems in place I think. Like how at a certain point she's just following behind breathing on your neck but you can never turn around to see her

[@ytmndan]

Dude. That second set of footsteps really got to me.

[@stoodmuffinpersonal3144]

It sounds like if scoony doo was actually a horror movie lol

[@ArxMagnum]

You can actually see her behind you in the mirror during that part.

[@jackuval9362]

it's the twitching shadow Dan points out at 13:07, learning that fucked with me (in a fun way) nevermind Arin said it

[@jolynelovemail]

Didn’t someone go into the files and find out that after a certain point/throughout the game her model is just right behind you, impossible to be seen without cheats

[@saulitix]

This confirms that Kojima and Del Toro are working with Game Grumps to finally complete Silent Hills

[@aaronmoore6275]

And they're using the House Party house.

[@graphicsgod]

..Also Half-life 3.

[@bleakautomaton4808]

PT still scary and Konami still sucks

[@saulitix]

​@@bleakautomaton4808That's why it's good that GG stole the IP from Konami. No, do not check this on Google, trust me, is real.

[@HenriqueRaposoHenryClaro]

The best never-finished Grumps playthrough of the best never-finished horror game making a comeback was the best unexpected news of my week - words can't describe how instantly hyped I was when I saw the video thumbnail!

[@thelexicon7294]

“Where were you 1 PT ago?” is going to be my new unit of measurement

[@aceghost1074]

I've watched this probably 8 times over the years when I need a giggle. You have NO IDEA how stoked I am rn

[@AliaOfTheKnife10191]

Holy shit. 11 years ago I was going through an awful breakup. It was y first adult relationship, and I thought I'd never find anyone who would love me again. Watching Game Grumps and NSP videos was a huge part of my healing process. I started seeing a new person, and we bonded over our shared love of GG. I remember watching videos from this era together and falling in love. We're celebrating our 10 year anniversary this year with a trip to LA and a cruise. I couldn't have imagined then what my life would be like now. Thanks for being there for me, Arin, Danny, Suzy, Barry, Ross, and Jon, too. You're in my heart.

[@coldnightmare199]

No one gives a shit

[@alexh3158]

That’s so beautiful

[@eepyknight]

That's so insane dude congrats

[@wrenzachary]

This was so incredibly cathartic-them returning with an understanding of the lore, catching horrible details, and actually finishing the game 😭 until this episode I was sadly accepting of the reality that we would never see their end of this game.

[@skeletaltrees]

NO FUCKING WAY

[@Bloodshotistic]

Fucking GUEY, dude. Fucking GUEY!

[@jbmp1390]

Butterscotch dipped?!

[@LisaaP.T.]

Mmmm . . Butterscotch . . ​@@jbmp1390

[@vigorouslethargy]

Way.

[@opaunz]

dude i said the same thing out loud

[@thelostone7512]

"Oh I've seen this one, its a classic!" "What do you mean you've seen this, its brand new."

[@tiffanyr9975]

Well, yknow, I saw it on a…rerun…

[@BambooAcrobatVerte]

*laughs in Crispin Glover *

[@eth_ann]

“Arin Hanson, the actor?!“

[@drudle]

"Then who's vice president? Dan Avidan?!"

[@miguelnewmexico8641]

i absolutely love you all.

[@spazzyp725]

3:53 when Arin mentioned the ship of Theseus and Dan asked “the ship of Theseus?”, I was expecting Markiplier to bash down the door and scream “HaVe YoU hEaRd Of ThE ShIP of ThEsEuS?!?!?!?”

[@breadcrusader06]

I'm glad to see a felllow Distractible listener/watcher

[@chicabear]

I specifically heard Wade's wobly robot voice saying it

[@tangentartists6876]

Same, bruh

[@tiffanyd269]

I was too 😭🤣

[@bearrock13]

its like a sleeper agent activating within me to respond this way

[@Kierbear101]

I finished middle school, graduated high school, graduated college, and got my dream job in the time between PT play throughs. Insane.

[@lakoper478]

NO WAY THIS IS MY FAVORITE PLAYTHRU OF ALL TIME

[@miguelnewmexico8641]

it's no Goof Troop or Dennis the Menace, but it's up there.

[@DroWarriorOfLight]

There's something funny but exciting of finally seeing the reveal 10 years later given the context of what happened

[@tylociraptor8131]

38:00 "I think we've talked about this before" yep and it was almost the exact same conversation last time lol

[@andreseh87]

And you really think that wasn’t staged 😂

[@mzmzmzmzmzmzmzmzmzmzmzmzmzmz]

@@andreseh87???

[@KiraKamiya]

The way Dan called Arin a saucy bitch is sooo similar to how he called him a stupid bastard in that other horror game they played.

[@mishpoth]

God it's like listening to your dad tell you a story you've heard a thousand times but never get tired of

[@Blobby90]

God this really felt like an older game grumps episode. The 'Would you get mad if I puked on you X times' bit was hilarious

[@MrSkysenGames]

I love how Danny started out mostly chill about it, just playing along and joking, then immediately switched back to panic mode when spooks happened.

[@andreagourley]

So did I 😭 started out feeling all nostalgic and happy having forgotten how much of a nightmare this is and now I wanna die lmao

[@Ktetsumaru]

Dude, their consistency with that throw up scenario is immaculate. Danny sticks to getting yakked on for 6 days until concern arises...something inspiring about that.

[@zombeef3074]

This "last time on Game Grumps" is some high schoolers elementary school memories

[@Azreal231916]

*cries in old*

[@nickdubie6179]

The Shattered Memories SH and Outlast plugs are dated but cool af lol

[@BTOptimizer]

@@Azreal231916 *cries in almost 30*

[@FidgetTheRat]

More like some adults high school memories 💀

[@crimsonvampyre602]

This comment should be illegal

[@bluetailtailfly]

I literally rewatch PT every year on Halloween and I still remember when it dropped, it's an all-time favorite Game Grumps episode for me. What a satisfying walk down memory lane!

[@quriline]

16:45 Dan was really excited to tell Arin about the guy saying the killer hung himself with an umbilical cord 😭

[@OHG_Fawx]

Just to clarify, you have to manually delete PT from your ps4 to lose it forever. You did not have to disconnect your console from the internet. I still have it and I never disconnected.

[@jaketri3]

Thank you for shouting out to me Dan. As a Jacob I feel heard and scared. In my 10 years I got my bachelors degree and served almost a decade as an EMT then Paramedic and am now applying for Med School. I was just out of high school when this came out.

[@PanAndScanBuddy]

Thank you for your service, Jacob.

[@gods-2nd-silliest-goose]

Thank you for your service Jacob!

[@eddlp2293]

Thank you for your service, Jacob!

[@jaketri3]

You are all very kind and thank you for the appreciation

[@funnimonki7234]

Cheeseburger

[@ProgidyTaco]

When the original video came out I was living with my parents with no full-time job, about to go to college, had one dog, and didn’t really know what I wanted to do in life. Now, I own a duplex with my brother, have a cat, work as a shift supervisor at a pet store, and after graduating college with a a degree in theatre, I do community theatre primarily acting in plays. Crazy how so much has changed yet the Grumps are still here ❤

[@DustinHorvath1987]

It's good to have certain touchstones in life. it keeps us grounded LOL.

[@zyxavier]

PRO TIP: If the video ever gets too scary, just play "Yakety Sax" while also watching Arin crack jokes at some of the most unsettling shit imaginable as Dan crushes his prostate into a diamond.

[@artbk]

Funny, I started whistling The Entretainer to lighten the mood a little

[@yukiepants]

clenching more and more until the cushion of his chair is like [ * ]

[@mandalabee]

@@artbk This works so well, but instead I use Masafumi Takada's The Entertainer remix. Its jaunty keyboard mix is appropriately goofy playing alongside this video.

[@l.b8896]

That is the best “What the fuck are you doing Arin!?!?!?!?!” I’ve ever heard. I think that’s my new favorite one.

[@maryhursen7222]

I love that you can hear Dan hiding behind a pillow at some points

[@badwolfe44]

Holy fuck, i was half watching/listening while working and the "we're watching you Jacob" bit actually freaked the hell out of me for a sec!

[@jacoblariz5709]

Bro same. the way my head whipped towards the screen...

[@egrygius]

Same here lol

[@frontiercomics]

I hereby order this meeting of the Jacobs

[@jacobfield5227]

@@frontiercomics im here for the meeting

[@jacobsaunders8537]

Represent XD

[@cs285o]

the moment arin started screaming at 51:00-ish the light in my kitchen started to flicker and i just wanted to mention that i feel VERY normal about it 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂

[@elusivefaerie6942]

Blink twice if you need help

[@antigrav6004]

This game absolutely nails the feeling of a fever dream / nightmare you can't wake up from.

[@fladdius]

23:23 me, a Jacob, high on the couch fuckin JUMPED when Dan growled at me

[@Kuhnonthecob]

Dude me too! It freaked me the fuck out. I know Jacob is supposed to be a popular name, but seems kind of a niche name to just randomly throw out lol

[@DesertDog]

It's super popular

[@oddcrafter1270]

@@Kuhnonthecob If you can find it on a souvenir keychain, it's a popular name.

[@FieryVigil]

I graduated high school, dropped out of college, did an entire tour in the navy, and went back to college between these two playthroughs. Thats wild.

[@JuanJimenez-lh4be]

That 10 years ago card really put into perspective how long I’ve watched the channel. From 11 years old to 21

[@jewelleaston9048]

Same here, blew my mind.

[@ThwipThwipBoom]

From 15 to 26 for me. lol

[@bloodyfloorboards]

12 to 22!

[@WizardManStan]

23 to 33 club.

[@CharlieBrooke125]

At 11 years old this game was the scariest thing I had ever seen. Now 21 not very much has come close. Slept with the light on then, might have to do it tonight 😂

[@VueiyVisarelli]

I always imagine that with these kinds of really scary games, Arin & Dan are sitting next to each other on the couch, Dan with both his arms _and_ legs wrapped around Arin, tightening every time he gets scared, until Arin can just _barely_ see between Dan's hands and arms wrapped around his face.

[@oddcrafter1270]

Not far off from how their first PT playthrough is depicted in animations! XD

[@JaySay]

OMG! You guys actually went back to it! Huge thanks to Dan for a massive sacrifice of his mental well-being, and to Arin for forcing Dan to agree to sacrifice his well-being!

[@kicksyo2171]

That's so true! Thanks Dan!

[@Mossy_Lungs]

23:27 No, not the best time to watch Game Grumps while stoned sitting in your living room in the candlelight while it's beginning to storm.. woke me up and gave me chills to hear Dan say my name out of nowhere 🫣😱☠️

[@tatltails3923]

NO THEY ACTUALLY GOT YOU??

[@shelbs6973]

This is my official request for them to play "Visage" during Ghoul Grumps.

[@honeyklutzzz]

Please oh please oh please oh please

[@kelseyjaffer]

freaking wild that i watched the original playthrough in my dorm room at the beginning of college, and now watching this one 10 years later, i'm married, have a dog, and am full-on working my dream career. thanks, Grumps!

[@rosemfountain]

New Starbomb ANDDDD P.T. ??? What a day

[@maninthebox420m]

The fact they're playing a game that is essentially lost media at this point is crazy! Arin, that PS4 is extremely valuable! Do not lose it!

[@Hermititis]

5:30 Dan's nervous laughter 5:37 the game mocking him

[@LisaaP.T.]

I'm laughing at him . Not with him .

[@Hermititis]

@@LisaaP.T. , clearly!

[@shidonidoni5704]

Referring to the mating cockroaches as one "super-roach" gets me every time