P2 - Real Questions! Hashim vs Christian Lady l Speakers Corner l Hyde Park

[@ImamMurrahTheTimeTraveller]

I like this lady's sincerity

[@love-sk7rb]

I really like this style of brother Hashim may Allah S.W.T bless him and his loved ones.

[@tajolariffin6147]

24/7 love yea because the woman is sincere and we can see she’s not there to intentionally wants to just argue..but look what happened to the other people who was just there to argue, Hashim is kinda agressive when it comes to these kind of people, but i don’t blame him, so far i’ve seen him still able to control and be calm if the argument is heated up.. may Allah gives him patience like Mansur 😊

[@azmagaref]

Such a respectful lady, may Allah guide her to the truth.

[@musaislam1861]

That is strange, an RE teacher that taught some basic form of Islamic literacy, yet she was unaware of Islam's stance as Jesus (alayhi salam) as the Messiah. I wonder what the curriculum is for these RE teachers?

[@0073D]

I had the exact same thought lol

[@MSA_madi]

this is like my teachers in history, basically they are only giving a introduction to Religion then it's up to you to do the rest. also She's maybe just only starting as RE teacher, only Allah knows.

[@Tayibah2003]

The GCSE RE text books aren’t very good. I was shocked to see under Islam the first page taught the Sunni and Shia split rather than the 5 pillars and Islamic creed.

[@cuezed]

I went to roman Catholic school. These RE teachers only know the 5 pillars of Islam

[@lilekoe1]

Bro, i went to a secondary school in Kent outside London, basically all white. In my GCSE RE classes one time it was taught that we believe in terrorism etc just before our mocks. I was mad shocked and took it too the head of RE. Guess what.. my class mates understood my concern but were all saying that they'll still mention it because they want to get the marks on the test. I dont know if the school has corrected it. The ignorance is unbelievable mate. We should be surprised but then we should question why in our own life we know grown people with silly misconception. It all starts from education in all facets. Crazy.

[@huzaifamajeed8345]

Ma Sha Allah . One of the best conversation I have heard . May Allah bless you Hashim.

[@LittlePetunia100]

May The Almighty guide this beautiful lady to the straight path Aameen

[@hahahehe4495]

i wish every talk is like this. slow and easy to learn and know each others opinion

[@athallahfathur]

unlike hatun and the gang

[@myheartwillstopinjoy8142]

Ikr I hate when a brother or sister is explaining a point and they cut him off with another question, when he tries to answer they cut him off again with a 3rd question

[@hahahehe4495]

Yup. even if they dont want to listen give others who are willing to listen the chance by not cutting them so the answer wont be hanging without an end

[@myheartwillstopinjoy8142]

@@hahahehe4495 that's it! The point isn't to fight but to learn

[@arshatarifin7442]

@@hahahehe4495 that's what their true intention..they want to disturb the dakwah by our brothers there and some of them are paid to do just that.

[@linkup901ify]

This is exactly the kind of conversation the Christians hate as it gives out clear backed up information, dispels lies against Islam, and gives this sincere lady a chance to learn and ponder rather than heckling etc. This is br. Hashim at his best, teaching Quran/Islam in a easy and clear manner.

[@myheartwillstopinjoy8142]

Mashallah, the lady also was very sincere and intelligent. God bless her, she is sweet

[@shujakhalid6364]

What a comprehensive statement about believer at time 16:28. May Allah bless you with more Knowledge and Hikma sir.

[@pessimistkai5569]

Amazing discussion! :)

[@tiziouazzou7625]

Thanks brothers very much

[@zambot264]

I like the openness of this lady. Very reasonable. I really enjoyed this

[@easyak]

May allah guide her she has good manners.

[@dwikykasih3781]

Imagine if Hatun speaks the way this lady speak. . . . . . . Impossible

[@myheartwillstopinjoy8142]

She was misguided into a lie by malicious people, but she is polite and sincere in her speech, I don't see what's wrong?

[@fahad055]

jazak Allah khair brother Hashim .

[@jakeguard9099]

Lol thanks for fixing the mic mate!

[@acei7341]

part 3 please :-)

[@ramz_0.0]

Very beautiful, polite and wise lady.

[@user-zc6mi5hx2f]

ᴄᴀʟʟ ᴛᴏ ᴡᴏʀsʜɪᴘ ᴏɴᴇ ᴛʀᴜᴇ ɢᴏᴅ “And verily, We have sent among every Ummah (community, nation) a Messenger (proclaiming): ‘Worship Allaah (Alone), and avoid (or keep away from) Taghoot (all false deities, i.e. do not worship Taghoot besides Allaah).’ Then of them were some whom Allaah guided and of them were some upon whom the straying was justified. So travel through the land and see what was the end of those who denied (the truth)” [al-Nahl 16:36] “And We did not send any Messenger before you (O Muhammad) but We revealed to him (saying): Laa ilaaha illa Ana [none has the right to be worshipped but I (Allaah)], so worship Me (Alone and none else)” [al-Anbiya’ 21:25] ‘Eesa will bear witness to this call against his people, as Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): “And (remember) when Allaah will say (on the Day of Resurrection): 'O ‘Eesa (Jesus), son of Maryam (Mary)! Did you say unto men: “Worship me and my mother as two gods besides Allaah?”’ He will say: ‘Glory be to You! It was not for me to say what I had no right (to say). Had I said such a thing, You would surely have known it. You know what is in my inner‑self though I do not know what is in Yours; truly, You, only You, are the All‑Knower of all that is hidden (and unseen). 117. ‘Never did I say to them aught except what You (Allaah) did command me to say: “Worship Allaah, my Lord and your Lord.” And I was a witness over them while I dwelt amongst them, but when You took me up, You were the Watcher over them; and You are a Witness to all things’” [al-Maa'idah 5:117]

[@Reeue]

جزاكم الله خير

[@acei7341]

Nice!

[@LittlePetunia100]

Aww what cute dog ❤️

[@trextor23]

She's really sweet and seems to be honest about her belief atleast

[@waterfiltratin]

جزاكم الله خيرا. نحتاج ترجمة

[@aliahmadzai3649]

Very nice conversation

[@barbarossa589]

Hashim explains everything so easy

[@Zya98]

The dog is cute and especially silent...hatun must learn from it

[@auliaakbar4066]

"you see what i mean"

[@KefasFX]

Here in Indonesia Christian used to say Insyaallah, alhamdulillah and astagfirullah.

[@amsamsamamsamsam8022]

Very nice interaction between Bro and this mature lady, the only comment I have is that, the sound quality is some time isn’t clear, so u can’t hear the lady properly and clearly, my hummable suggestion is to have a 2 mike, each of them should have equal mike. Jazaak Allah Khair.

[@myheartwillstopinjoy8142]

Or a mic that is not attached to brothers suit

[@erfaanisaacs2699]

Lady is very respectful

[@shahirrazali1042]

part 3 please..

[@bushraomar6004]

سلام عليكم نريد ترجمه للفيديوهات الجديدة و جزاكم الله خير

[@shahidafwan1102]

Jazakallah

[@mozuka5129]

16:56...That cute dog is getting nearer to Hashim...

[@mustafare9729]

May Allah give her hidayah!!!

[@asfiah1740]

part 3

[@thothtrismegistus929]

part 3 pls

[@heroldyousuf8750]

That cute dog is like "poor lady confused as hell..trinity is bullshit! " :D

[@totallynotthefeds]

What a lovely lady... I really admire the Irish, especially how they stand with Palestine.

[@saffu87]

Br. Hashim has an admirer now ☺️

[@alexmehdiu4203]

Love ❤️ the doooogggggggg.selam

[@aksyed99]

there are many examples like this in western world who are new to Islam or non Muslims teaching Islam. Its unfortunate to see speackers like this in Masjids the whole lecture will be finished without a sinlge ayat or hadith.

[@zulfikarsfamily]

Masya Allah.. This lady is very polite, hopefully she will get hidayah. Insya Allah..aamiin..

[@paradigmaofficial4555]

Really sincere

[@thegroove2000]

Saviour Son of God The saviour is the only true Son of God. The belief that a saviour is the only Son of God is one of the most common beliefs amongst ancient civilizations and religions it is a "universal myth" predating Christianity by at least 2,000 to 2,500 years. The evidence of this belief being common amongst a wide variety of cultures and religions spanning thousands of years is overwhelming. From thousands of coins recovered from the age of the Roman Empire to temples and recovered ancient texts all point to the title "Only son of God" and "Son of God" as commonplace. Official Title known as "The Son of God" Saviour/God Culture/Religion Year of Origin Hesus Druid 2200 BCE Baal Syria 2100 BCE Attis Turkey/Anatolia 2100 BCE Tammuz Syria 2000 BCE Shamgar Mari, Syria 2000 BCE Horus Egypt 1900 BCE Adad Assyria 1850 BCE Mithra Persia/Babylon 1650 BCE Dionysus Phoenicia/Syria 1500 BCE Krishna Hindu 1140 BCE Heracles/Hercules Greece 690 BCE Buddha India 620 BCE Prometheus Greece 580 BCE Odin Scandanavia 500 BCE Bacchus Rome 500 BCE Quetzalcoatl Mexico, Hopi 400 BCE Adonis Greece 400 BCE Indra Tibet 350 BCE Christos Hellenism 250 BCE Jesus Christianity 44 CE The discovery of the oldest known Bible in existence called the "Sinaiticus" a verified copy of the official Nicene Bible of Eusebius from the mid 4th Century provides an indication of the heresy of all subsequent massive re-edits of the scriptures of Christianity since. On forensic comparison of just the New Testament between the Vulgate created by Jerome and the Sinaiticus Bible (almost certainly an original of the official Constantine Nicene Bible), there was discovered approximately 14,800 editorial alterations. Importantly, the first official Bible of Christianity describing Jesus Christ as "the son of God" do not appear in the opening narrative as they do in today's editions (Mark 1:1). This can only mean one thing- not only is the concept of the "only son of god" a universal myth borrowed by christianity, but it was inserted sometime after the first and official New Testament was promulgated by Emperor Constantine in the 4th Century CE. Any reference, including the alleged Nicene Creed that claims otherwise is a transparent fraud that is untenable when challenged by even a modest amount of the existing evidence. It is also probably one of the first heresies against the foundation of christianity. Only one conclusion can therefore be drawn upon this overwhelming factual evidence that key elements of scripture were deliberately added well after the 4th Century. No credence can be given then to the accuracy of any of the stories within Bibles edited and published since the 5th Century.

[@sahibzadamanan626]

Lady voice is very low. Next time please provide one mic to other person.

[@armageddon2520]

That dog had been very well mannered

[@craigndayday]

jheesse Hashim looking fresh out here!

[@DoronTuber]

Hashim, In order to truly understand the Tanach there is one essential thing you need to know well - Hebrew. The language of the Tanach. There are a lot of different translations to the Tanach, written by different people with different understanding/agendas/knowledge, but there has always been one Tanach and specifically one Tora with one language for millenniums which has the real truth in it. If you prefer to read the translation or hear opinions from ignorant(regarding to the Tanach) people, go ahead, you can also read Moby Dick and find that Muhammad appears in there someway or another. By the way, the new testament and the Quran as well, they both have slightly different versions. How come? Truth is one with no versions, and that's the Tanach. Peace..

[@maspiko]

6:11 Whats wrong with those two guys? :))

[@anotherhadith9951]

Asalaamu alaykum

[@Moses-jo5ox]

Alhamdulilah, I know they don’t like this.... Alhamdulilah!!😂😂

[@bladerunner8948]

Translation arabic plz

[@Mo8585El]

She probably doesn't know what Messiah means......

[@cammedramprocharged4927]

Who is Jesus Christ Latin Name ? He came for Bani Israeel with a Latin Name ? Really ? 🤦🏻‍♂️ Born of a virgin with a Latin Name ?

[@chelseacountryman-bartyzel3962]

It's so sad. Latin my ass. Do u know how to pronounce his real name , no u dont . How many " Christians " in the world know how his mother pronounced his name , none !!!!. Its not " jeee-zus" , or " hey-zoos" . So how the hell do u know someone if u dont even know his real name ? Its cuz you don't know him. So u can take that Latin shit somewhere else.

[@AbdullahAmine]

I can't hear the lady

[@user-zc6mi5hx2f]

𝐀𝐭𝐭𝐫𝐢𝐛𝐮𝐭𝐞𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐀𝐥𝐥𝐚𝐡 (𝐂𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐭𝐨𝐫) Allah.There is no god but He,-the Ever-Living, the Self-Subsisting, Eternal. (Surah Al-Imran, 2) He it is Who shapes you in the wombs as He pleases.There is no god but He, the Exalted in Might, the Wise. (Surah Al-Imran, 6) Say, “He is Allah, (the) One. Allah-us-Samad (The Self-Sufficient Master, Whom all creatures need, He neither eats nor drinks). He begets not, nor was He begotten; And there is none co-equal or comparable unto Him.” (Quran 112)

[@athallahfathur]

My Biq Question why jesus also had name imanuel ?

[@mokhan999]

No body called him jesus Emanuel his mother , friends, etc. Matthew 1.22 copy Isaiah 7.14 using GREEK TRANSLATION rather then HEBREW TO fit the prophecy for Jesus. PROPHET Isaiah, addressing king Ahaz of Judah, promises the king that God will destroy his enemies; as a sign that his oracle is a true one, Isaiah predicts that an almah ("young woman") will shortly give birth to a child whose name will be Immanuel, "God is with us" This happend that time in time of king Ahaz but Christians say it's a dual prophecy one for Jesus also.

[@ayoubidhssaine8968]

Hashim vs Christian Lady??? First of all, This is not a debate so why using the VS mark??? this is rather meant to be an an educational discussion. the so called christian lady isnt even devbating or trying to debunk his claims, rather she's just listening to what he is saying. Please @SCdawah, remove the VS mark. You don't even know what is a debate??? Salam

[@thegroove2000]

Saviour Resurrection The Lord Saviour was crucified, died and after 3 days rose from the death and soon after ascended into heaven. The belief of a saviour being crucified, dying and then rising from the dead three days later, ascending into heaven is an ancient myth that predates Christianity by at least 2,100 years and is found in identical stories of much older original scripture than christianity in no less than five (5) other religions. Considering the intricate arrangement of facts concerning the death and resurrection story, the commonality between all six (6) religions that refer to this myth proves overwhelmingly that its symbology is borrowed by christianity. Saviour crucified, died, rose from dead after 3 days & ascended physically into heaven Saviour/God Culture/Religion Year of Origin Attis Turkey/Anatolia 2100 BCE Tammuz Syria 2000 BCE Krishna Hindu 1140 BCE Quetzalcoatl Mexico, Hopi 400 BCE Indra Tibet 350 BCE Jesus Christianity 44 CE The significance of the story is to be found in its astronomical significance concerning the death and rebirth of the sun - an event of prime significant to ancient humanity who relied heavily upon the position and movement of the heavens in their religious affairs. The fact that the death and resurrection story, including the specific description of crucifixion is not unique to christianity does not necessarily mean that the actual person we know as Jesus Christ did not suffer an event in which they were crucified. It merely means that all claims of actual death and defying the laws of physics by returning to life cannot be considered as credible, nor original to christianity.

[@Moses-jo5ox]

Hashim!!!😂😂😂😂

[@akkhan2856]

This dog is intelligent😎

[@mokhan999]

Generally the RE books are rubbish I read them and learned nothing I wonder how they can be printed. The RE teachers have very basic knowlege of Islam and other faiths.

[@ميودةميودة]

cute and quiet may God quide her to the truth

[@adamel-falou7581]

just comment, the prophet only killed who faught him him in the of mecca

[@shariefgl291]

ترجموها للعربي

[@abdulrazikshaikh1692]

She actually want to learn n think it's call peace talk

[@__________461]

السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته دين الاسلام سلام (حرام ) في الحرب ، قتل النساء والبنون والشيوخ وقطع الاشجار وووووووووو ______ هذه الآيه لم تذكرها لها لذالك كتبتها هنا ﴿إِنَّ مَثَلَ عيسى عِندَ اللَّهِ كَمَثَلِ آدَمَ خَلَقَهُ مِن تُرابٍ ثُمَّ قالَ لَهُ كُن فَيَكونُ﴾ [آل عمران: ٥٩] ______ In Islam ((( Haram ))) in the war kill women’s and kids and big people and and and in Islam and haram cut tree and and in the war in Islam this is Islam peace ____ Islam In the war you must no way kill women’s And kids and and and ...... this is Islam the peace 💌 ________ Now I want toke about ( Essa Jesus) peace be upon him ﴿إِنَّ مَثَلَ عيسى عِندَ اللَّهِ كَمَثَلِ آدَمَ خَلَقَهُ مِن تُرابٍ ثُمَّ قالَ لَهُ كُن فَيَكونُ﴾ [آل عمران: ٥٩] Indeed, the example of Jesus to Allah is like that of Adam He created Him from dust; then He said to him, Be, and he was.

[@canamotion]

Why do people lie ? Saying that you have read the Quran but you didn’t see what Muslims read is a lie. You are funny to me. I am another witness.

[@shaami8622]

Whos lying here, Us or you?

[@ahmadirshaadi2007]

I respect that christian lady

[@brar12zhinzai]

The most patient being in the dialogue is the dog

[@Hashim4x]

Jesus will not come again

[@arshatarifin7442]

I respect ur opinion..tq

[@xXxFirewalkerxXx]

@@arshatarifin7442 I had a some question regarding the point brother Hashim made and sincd you agree with brother Hashim. 1. In Surah Al Maidah 116-117 Allah swt asks Hazrat Isa as on the day of judgment regarding this matter if he was the one who told the people to worship him or his mother as gods besides Allah swt to which he replies that he never said anything of such sort. Infact if he had, Allah swt would have known since Allah swt is all-knowing. And he confirms that he was witness and aware of the fact that the people followed tawheed aslong he was among them but when Allah swt took him, only Allah swt knows what happen. If Hazrat Isa as returns in his 2nd coming, breaks the cross and kills the dejjal. By that time there is no way he is unaware of the fact that he is beeing worshiped as god. He will know that he is beeing worshiped, breaks the cross, lives for many years and then dies like all the other prophets of Allah swt. Then how come is lying on the day of judgment ? Shouldnt he reply that he was witness again? 2. The arabic word which is translated by Sahih International or Mushin Khan says he was raised, however tawaffaytani does not mean raised. It means to take in full. According to corupus quran, tawaffaytani in Verb (form V) means to pass away, to die. So why is it translated into raised? What is there to hide ? I mean do the translation correctly at least. 3. I do understand that tawafa happens at the time of sleep or death but according to Az Zumar vers 42 it is the Soul which is taken. So basically if Allah swt does tawafa on a human beeing, the subject is the Soul, not the Body. So why make Hazrat Isa as more then just a human beeing ? 4. And even if we say that no, Hazrat Isa as was not killed or crucified so he was raised to Allah swt physically and therefore in 5.117 tawaffaytani can only mean raised phyiscally, well you would have to apply the same logic to prophet Mohammed saw. Prophet Mohammed saw was not killed or crucified, but do you dare to say that our beloved prophet Mohammed saw who is khatam an nabiyin was not raised by Allah swt ? Infact, Prophet Mohammed saw used this ayat for his own death according to Imam Bukhari in Vol 6, Book 60, Hadith 149. To say the context is different cannot be true either since both prophets are in the presence of Allah swt on the day of judgment and the arabic word kama is used. If there was a difference in the context, prophet Mohammed saw would surley say so just as he did with many other hadith where the arabic word kama is used. However this is not the case with this though. Another example is Surah Al Imran vers 59, kama is used and the context is ''be and he was'' despite the fact that Hazrat Isa as was born of a mother while Adam wasnt. So the context is the same for Hazrat Isa as and Prophet Mohammed saw. Both prophets passed away by Allah swt taking their soul and do not know what happen afterwards.

[@arshatarifin7442]

@@xXxFirewalkerxXx with respect..Go to any mosque or any Islamic centre and ask them face to face regarding the answers to ur questions..I don't want to type too many words here and the English u were using in presenting ur questions were quit bad I might say..have a good day ya even if u r just a troll.

[@xXxFirewalkerxXx]

@@arshatarifin7442 well ya might be right coz english isnt my first language. However the question I made was quit simple and easy to understand. On the day of judgment Hazrat Isa as does not know that he was worshiped as God. So to say that he will come back, break the cross, live for 40 years and is unaware of this weird doctrine called trinity does not make any sense. Either Hazrat Isa as is lying on the day of judgment or the hadith contradicts the Holy Quran.

[@Mukeet-Khan]

She seems kind and open minded, may she be guided to Islam. She can trade in her Dog 4 a nice Cat.

[@zk116]

some RE teacher....... doesn`t even know that we accept Jesus as the messiah.

[@myheartwillstopinjoy8142]

I don't think it's her fault, they are taught wrong things. The only fact that she's there listening to the brother shows she is open to learning. Also, she seems young, maybe she's a new teacher?

[@asfiah1740]

first

[@myheartwillstopinjoy8142]

Mashallah :)

[@mosalah5215]

The second coming of Jesus is already here Messiah and Mehdi, Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad a s The Chosen one from Allah tallah

[@HoeAlpha]

The two guys exposed and embarrassed you

[@xXxFirewalkerxXx]

I had a some question regarding the point brother Hashim made. 1. In Surah Al Maidah 116-117 Allah swt asks Hazrat Isa as on the day of judgment regarding this matter if he was the one who told the people to worship him or his mother as gods besides Allah swt to which he replies that he never said anything of such sort. Infact if he had, Allah swt would have known since Allah swt is all-knowing. And he confirms that he was witness and aware of the fact that the people followed tawheed aslong he was among them but when Allah swt took him, only Allah swt knows what happen. If Hazrat Isa as returns in his 2nd coming, breaks the cross and kills the dejjal. By that time there is no way he is unaware of the fact that he is beeing worshiped as god. He will know that he is beeing worshiped, breaks the cross, lives for many years and then dies like all the other prophets of Allah swt. Then how come is lying on the day of judgment ? Shouldnt he reply that he was witness again? 2. The arabic word which is translated by Sahih International or Mushin Khan says he was raised, however tawaffaytani does not mean raised. It means to take in full. According to corupus quran, tawaffaytani in Verb (form V) means to pass away, to die. So why is it translated into raised? What is there to hide ? I mean do the translation correctly at least. 3. I do understand that tawafa happens at the time of sleep or death but according to Az Zumar vers 42 it is the Soul which is taken. So basically if Allah swt does tawafa on a human beeing, the subject is the Soul, not the Body. So why make Hazrat Isa as more then just a human beeing ? 4. And even if we say that no, Hazrat Isa as was not killed or crucified so he was raised to Allah swt physically and therefore in 5.117 tawaffaytani can only mean raised phyiscally, well you would have to apply the same logic to prophet Mohammed saw. Prophet Mohammed saw was not killed or crucified, but do you dare to say that our beloved prophet Mohammed saw who is khatam an nabiyin was not raised by Allah swt ? Infact, Prophet Mohammed saw used this ayat for his own death according to Imam Bukhari in Vol 6, Book 60, Hadith 149. To say the context is different cannot be true either since both prophets are in the presence of Allah swt on the day of judgment and the arabic word kama is used. If there was a difference in the context, prophet Mohammed saw would surley say so just as he did with many other hadith where the arabic word kama is used. However this is not the case with this though. Another example is Surah Al Imran vers 59, kama is used and the context is ''be and he was'' despite the fact that Hazrat Isa as was born of a mother while Adam wasnt.

[@abbacartoons]

Isa (as) is not going to fight all Christians that worshiped him in his second coming Aman, Christianity is around now for like 2000 years. He will only fight the Christians at the time. On the day of judgment, all Christians will be present there, I mean all people that observe this Christian belief. Then Allah will ask Isa (as) if he tell the people to worship him (past Christians who did not witness the second coming) if he is the one who made them worship him.

[@xXxFirewalkerxXx]

@@abbacartoons Thanks for the reply. The point isnt about all christians. What Im saying is this. Hazrat Isa as came to Bani Israel to spread Injil. He was witness over them as long he was among them and knew that they worshiped only one God. But after Allah swt took him, ONLY Allah swt is witness what happen afterwards. Point is this. He came with the message of tawheed - knew as long he was among them that they are following tawheed - was taken by Allah swt - People went away from tawheed and made him into god - Dajjal comes and does havoc - Hazrat Isa as breaks the cross and kills the dajjal. By that time, its obvious that he knows that he is beeing worshiped as God, that is why he breaks the cross - lives and dies - on the day of Judgment he does not know that he was worshiped in the first place. He will without a doubt reply ''And sufficient is Allah as a witness between us and you that we were of your worship unaware.''