P2 - Who Crucified Him!? Hashim & Christian l Speakers corner l Hyde Park

[@salaam1st]

Dynamic duo hashim and shamshi

[@Peace4Free]

This gentleman is very kind and faithful. He acknowledge the truth even if it's against his beliefs, unlike Godwin, Liz, Hatun and the other blind faith gangs

[@thetraffic849]

Dipo Salaam: i totaly agree with you. People shouldnt be critizing or mocking this man. He is honest in what he is believing even though he is wrong. Very kind and respectfull person who tries to learn and just want to know the "other side". People who say "he didnt answer the questions"...well its not a match or competition. He just anwers it how he believe it is even though he doesnt have proof for what he is saying. But its ok to answer how a person believes it is. We as muslims should be glad with these kind of persons. Im tired to watch verbal fights who is right. Its not competition. Its bringing the truth and then its up to the christian how he reacts to the truth. There is no need to see discussions as personal matches.

[@RayhanulSumon]

yes agree

[@PictureThisNewMedia]

Dipo Salaam he's a very nice Christian brother. InshAllah he will become Muslim

[@MotivatingMemers]

So the Christian gentleman rejects the science of hadith even if there are proofs but accepts bible even the writers are anonymous. This is bias at max. May Allah Guide him.

[@PictureThisNewMedia]

Shahbazz Ali gotta admit he's very respectable in the dialogue compared to other Christians at speakers corner.. we should all learn this is a proper dialogue from both hashim & Christian man

[@sajidstar007]

Ernest L. Peña if shabbaz think he is bias then it is his view, now you tell me what it is wrong he said.

[@PictureThisNewMedia]

sajid what? I'm not sure I understand what you are asking. I didn't say anything about anyone being wrong or about shabazz thinking he's biased. What are you talking about?

[@ami6179]

We love you brothers. .may Allah gives you jennah all of you..jezakuallah kheyra

[@walidaitaissa6196]

Ameen

[@sakiamran11]

I wish I could be like them. Mashaallah. ❤️❤️🇧🇩

[@farooqsatt3986]

U can....

[@syednaveed8906]

U can Inshaallah...

[@aristomalawat]

Wow.. moeslim dynamic duo.. assalamualaikum akhi.. Indonesia like you..

[@yusufmusa2701]

Alhumdulilah my dear brothers,waiting for part 3

[@daskeleng]

Yusuf Musa yes, me too. The conversation was not over yet.

[@ousamamuhammed5483]

Peaceful discussion masallah

[@trumpetfriday8971]

Most of these Muslim speakers don't need any material from any of the holy scriptures.Ma Sha Allah they are so well versed in all of them, that the only thing they carry is their cup of coffee or water..may Allah bless our Ummah with these kind of debaters/ speakers until the last day.

[@zaidmunzir1116]

They do not want to take a leap of faith. Even if it doesn’t make sense logically, historically and rationally.

[@shukria7392]

we want to see this kind of conversation that is more meaningful and clear understanding . please brother keep on but do not shout and arguing please. assalamu alaikum

[@bintumarrah912]

Was alaikumu salam

[@PictureThisNewMedia]

Just got done listening to part 1. Very good dialogue. The Christian brother was very respectable in the last video. InshAllah his niceness carries on to part 2

[@destinyinfinite7116]

Wow my brothers u are guys amazing Alhamdulillah

[@ewantaharin6354]

Good dawah br hashim and br shamsi may god reward you.

[@-zTo-]

Go to the video titled "Christian asks Sincere Questions To Shamsi & Hashim | Speakers Corner" and go to the 22:30 mark, and you will see the continuation of this conversation.

[@balloballballoball9501]

Thank you I really want to hear them till finish. God bless you

[@brahimaxDz]

good good, P3 please

[@Reeue]

جزاكم الله خير

[@yusufmusa2701]

God is infallible, so how can the Christian guy say Allah is capable of making a mistake by saying God regretted a decision He made,it's like saying Allah is not all knowing. Allah is all knowing, meaning He knows everything from the beginning to the end so anything Allah pleases to do there's nothing to be regretted. Regret is not one of Allah's attributes. Alhumdulilah

[@MadMaxNado]

shamsi and hachim toghter LOVE my brothers

[@invitationtoislam6062]

Shamsi promotes division and sectarianism.

[@destrokes1534]

@@invitationtoislam6062 ur ignorant

[@tokkingsairel]

🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ YOU BRO HASHIM

[@razwanarana-kimutai9145]

2 Lions of Speakers Corner, together. MashaAllah. Nice. May Allah always unite all the Da'awah Brothers.

[@kaashee]

22:52 shamsi just lay it down for him I really respect shamsi

[@ISLAMICPREACHERAPOLOGIST]

kaashee AS SALAMU ALAIKUM , HOPE ALL IS GOOD MY MESSAGE TO MUSLIM DEBATERS HELLO BROTHERS, HIJAB, SHAMSI AND BROTHER MANSUR kzbin.info/www/bejne/aHPFqXevZ8mMb6M

[@kream2624]

There are people (ulemas)alive who have their chain of teachers upto Bhukhari(PBUH).They got their knowledge which came heart to heart from Bhukhari (PBUH).

[@ubuntuafrique5802]

Allahu Akbar

[@nonidido5191]

The best ever bro shamsi.and bro hashim my allah bless you brothers

[@strangerreplay2156]

Hamdoulilah Hashim and Shamsi complement eachother

[@suhendrobaskito8268]

It is indeed peaceful n fruitful interfaith discussion. No shouting, screaming n interruption. This christian guy is more civilized with rational mind. He acknowledged the truth of Islam, although its against his beliefs. Hope he will someday convert to Islam.

[@stonezzrollerr5445]

"Those whose efforts have been wasted in this life ,while they thought that they were acquiring good by their work?. (QS Al Kahfi: 104)(QS Al An'aam:43)

[@ahmedhanif911]

Where is part 3?

[@nirmomesna9467]

Where is the rest of the video if there is any plz

[@stillhere7193]

Is there a p-3

[@thofi1176]

I love those two humble brothers

[@invitationtoislam6062]

Shamsi is humble to the Jews. (Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah ; and those who are with him are tough with the disbelievers, merciful among themselves.) Qur'an 48:29 Shamsi, Ali Dawah, Muhammad Hijab are all doing the opposite.

[@olivegreen6587]

waiting for part3

[@soleil3gs]

Part 3 please!!!

[@athallahfathur]

the most important thing is you have to dare to step, if that makes sense to you why do you refuse?

[@catlovers5877]

I couldn't find the part 3

[@ThePrinceatti]

Where is the next part?

[@adelraad891]

God is not stupid to contradict him self by becoming a weak creature like a human being it's illogical So logic say it's not that he can't become human it's that he wouldn't

[@nornizarmohamed8228]

Brother Hashim is genius. But when come to football, Pep Guardiola is genius.

[@arifhakim1261]

To all my brothers and sisters pls support this channel and others islamic channel by watch all commersial till the end. At least we did something for islam. Tq.

[@islamaroundtheworld]

2 lions of Islam!!!

[@LanternV]

Christian guy seems reasonable, "supercharged" after prayer haha

[@rina1592]

If the xtians believe that Jesus Christ PBUH came to die for their sins, then why didn't his companions kill him for that matter?, would today's xtian kill him if he/she was at that time of Jesus Christ PBUH if they really love him?

[@abangkacak6006]

Wow shamsi...

[@NoName-ic9fi]

Was the Roman named Pilot present ? Was the Judah Tribe of elders present? And who crucified him , forget that who carried the cross Jesus or Simon? How do you know it was Jesus being crucified ? Was Judas present during the crucification ? Who was there? Now how do you know ?

[@NoName-ic9fi]

This story about crucification is not relevant since no one knows if it was in fact Jesus who was crucified , lastly why would God choose to be a man when in fact a woman is better then a man , this is to argue the fact that the men that wrote the bible had a political objective to make sure man didn't rebel against the state and women remained oppressed in conjunction to men. Go read The Prince ; these were the people who invented torture and rewrote the bible to suit their own needs from humanity!

[@NoName-ic9fi]

Now the story i understood as a Muslim who attend Catholic school for 4 years;Judas betrayed Jesus for forty pieces of sliver provide by the Jewish Rabbis ; Pilot plea with Jesus was to rebuke that he was the messiah against the angered elder Jewish high Rabbis who demanded he be put to death for declaring he was the messiah. After stating to Pilot that he wouldn't he was sentenced to death. Now the problem arises with the forty pieces of sliver ; who wrote it and how did this information come about. How can you account for Judas and the forty pieces of sliver but not know if in fact it was Jesus who died on the cross and which day did he rise. What im saying is ; you put your trust in words that you cannot assert if they came directly from God. Now if i had an answer to why ; i could easily solve all of the political crisis's all over the world . The story of Jesus pbuh is sad and what I learned is that people who doubt God look for easy and quick answers to explain Why , when in reality the situation is difficult. All I can say is that Jesus is a man ! No evidence points to me that Jesus said worship me and pray to me , when he was a role model for people living at that time. It indicates that the morals of this being were not in order with the morals of the people living at that time. Now how can you trust what they say about him; if they are responsible for his death; why would i get my enemy to write about me when that enemy never knew me like my companions. Lastly The Church and Jesus are two different wings flying away from each other; one going up and one falling down. Jesus was a prophet like all other prophets before him ; which came with a message to worship only God alone and was rejected.

[@NoName-ic9fi]

The Quran details the rejection of God (from the disbelievers)or the idea many times thru many different prophets , the people of Lot ; they were warned but did they listen! The people of Moses were taken out of Egypt and driven out to a promised land ; did they worship God first or did they return to the idol worship they knew in Egypt with the golden calf. Time after time people rejected truths provide by their Lord of Mercy (الله) and time after time the people denied and chased or hurt the prophets.

[@NoName-ic9fi]

My question to you all is ; why did Jesus love his mother PEACE BE UPON THEM so much if he was God instead of a man AND why didn't the church adopt this into their teachings about the mother of Jesus , why is Jesus looked upon as the shepherd but his mother doesn't get a equal role?

[@NoName-ic9fi]

If so why did the Church hurt women and children if they loved Jesus ?

[@youneskhouloud2504]

the christian asking who are the people of the chain of narration of hadith while he believes a book with anonymous narrators

[@L4AH4N1889]

He's asking you what do I need as a Christian to be better ! Please explain to him that the oneness of God is the main need to any Christian. Oneness of God negates any associates and semi gods. Then explain that all the bliss and benefits of this concept is found perfectly in the teachings of Islam as the final message to humankind and therefore you need to believe in the prophet of Islam PBUH as well ! I think brother Hashim has explained part of that in the beginning, but the other brother Shamsi couldn't get to the point at the end of the video.

[@ahmd5]

Muslim is the name of person who collected these Hadeeth, NOT a title. You can still find people named Muslim even today, just like you find people named Christian.

[@aishaarshadalam3412]

In the first part the man asked if God can send His spirit and put it into a man. The question isn't can God do it. God is able to do all things HOWEVER because He is God there are some things He will not do. God will never lie. God will never share His sovereignty with another. God will never die. Its like the question of can God make a rock that He can't lift? Its the wrong question. God won't do anything that will limit or go against what makes Him God. Why should God show weakness? He is all powerful and it does not befit His majesty to show weakness or be weak. It's a silly argument.

[@sahliabdelaziz7226]

how can i contact hachi i be you all say to hachim the way the coran and hadith was muslm used oraccusted to it way there only goal o theire the best thing to look for to be hapy like ourway to day to ow mony or a job ust not foret it is their best thin to ow is aknowle and success in this way tha they know it as we kbow what we love siple it is ther hobi sory m weakenlish to ow ay or hadith as we look today for love

[@torontoyes]

Look at the way the Universe functions, the water cycle, the creation of the human being, the physics, the laws of this universe, and. you feel this same creator, can make an error in judgement? If God can make an error in judgement, then how is God Almighty going to judge us on the day of judgement. It might be, that he makes an error whilst sentencing a person, and that person will correct God. This is what this Christian is saying about God "Regretting" with Saul.

[@dasprinklingman9811]

Salamualaikum brothers, you are doing really great but note also that the bible also laid the same falsification test like the Qur'an...that no mistake or so. The bible says the following. Proverbs 30:5 Every word of God is flawless; he is a shield to those who take refuge in him. This bible verse states that God's word is contradiction and mistake free.

[@ibnumar2387]

Why br hasim dint tell about imam ahmad imam hanafi imam hambali and imam shafi'e? Its that just because this christian men just know sahih bukhari and sahih muslim only?

[@blitzer25blitz62]

beauty of Islam Word of God(Quran) that is infallible differs from Word(and doings) of Muhammad(Hadith/Sunnah)that can be filtered out which is valid and which is weak whereas confusion happen in Christianity where sayings of multiple people(mixed valid and corrupted verses)(Jesus/Mark/Luke etc) are all the Bible!

[@mdnkader1753]

where jesue s grave.

[@Sir_Valentino718]

Y'all contradict yourself all the time when someone talks about the Koran and take one verse out of it y'all tell other people we don't understand and we're taking out of context but in your argument about the Bible y'all take one verse and not three versus above or three verses after. That's why I cannot take Muslim seriously how can God Yahovah not preserve the Jewish scriptures which is the old Covenant and also not preserve the New Covenant which he made a promise in Jeremiah 31:31 I will make a new covenant with my people I will write my laws statutes and Commandments and their hearts and that's what he did on the day of Pentecost. Preserve the Koran that makes no type of sense he chose the nation of Israel for reason to be able to preach to the nation's but they fell and started to follow the other nations. Don't you think God will Preserve the Torah and the Gospels because they came first God does not change and I'm talking about the truth I'm not talking about mainstream Christianity. The scriptures I wish I was there but y'all was still not even listen because y'all are indoctrinated by your believes and that the truth cuz according to the word of God in Psalms 119 the law is the truth

[@SM-ly5tf]

The Christian was not able to put it into context, because the verse is clear cut. Why don't you try and put it into comtext?

[@A1.4U]

🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️😂 ur not sincere brother drop ur ego n desire Jesus peace be upon him didn’t not preach trinity or him been da level of God wa u hav now is not God’s words it’s da Romans scriptures🤦🏾‍♂️ they changed everything even bible scholars can’t even take these scriptures seriously they either leave Christianity or they become atheist 98% of them dats why Islam is da fastest growing religion on da planet of earth brother come back to worship one God da God of Jesus moses Abraham Jacob job Adam Mohamed peace be upon them all may God guide you to straight path one day I will day u will meet ur lord infront of him do u believe a book da send by God would hav self contradictions??

[@Sir_Valentino718]

@@A1.4U The word of Yehovah Elohim says those who hear will hear and those who refused to hear other rebellious ones. Blessings

[@A1.4U]

David Eleonora ur bible has lots of contradiction errors missing scriptures do u believe God will send a book like dat🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️

[@jaavidkazi]

Christian brother's voice is not as good as muslim brother.

[@alfonso201]

Is this is supposed to be from god [2 Samuel c24 v1(And again the anger of the LORD was kindled against Israel, and he moved David against them to say, Go, number Israel and Judah) 1 chronicles c21 v1( And Satan stood up against Israel, and provoked David to number Israel.] How can any christan still believe in the bible is beyond me.

[@alfonso201]

James Walker dude srsly a book that has contradictions,errors and unknown authours will save me bruv faith wont help you alone use your head and read the bible

[@mrk3815]

MoEz sgc So the Quran was written by Allah and not men?

[@mrk3815]

AlF onSo There is no contradictions in the bible I can give u all the answers u want and u will still deny it an Say it's nonsense because your not interested in Christianity

[@alfonso201]

MR Bolo written by men authoured by allah

[@alfonso201]

MR Bolo answer the op how can you reconsile it?

[@ahmadamiruddinmohd3451]

The bible is the fierce n worst enemy for christianitiy.

[@fiqipraramadhan]

God's not so godlike in the bible.

[@Sir_Valentino718]

See you said it wrong once again I feel like y'all talk to people that do not know the word of God when God said in Genesis where he rested on the 7th Day that word means to stop ceased in the Hebrew.

[@christopheroneill7498]

GOD rested on the 7th day is not a perfect GOD so why in the QURAN it says no fatigue overcame him ? Why did JESUS sais even Abraham rejoiced to see his day ?

[@whyz63]

Hashim does not need assistant, spread along the park brother, find your own debate

[@muhammadiqbal-em2tw]

It is up to him, sir. They both are brother. So doesn't matter at all in doing so.

[@riefaatibnharoon6393]

Shami is lije man can u believe the words coming outta ur mouth makes no sense in believing