Padam or Paaadam? 🥵😰 Propaganda Movies | EFX Debate

[@expertfx]

Mega Year-End Sale is now here!🥳Get 40% Off using CODE: FEST40 🤯 🎥Enroll Now to Become a MASTER Storyteller✍: efxshop.in Gift your loved ones - Do not miss the opportunity! ❤

[@satyapa5701]

Bro please react to song 222 it has some great vfx

[@feelandvibe7384]

@@expertfx Art form theriyamala oru padam eduppanga Art te illama caste support, movie eduppanunga atha kekkamattanunga athu flim industry kedukkatham , oru naalu padam makkal avalanilaiya ennava irunthuthu nu katittanga Cinema ve kettupochi nu soldranunga Open sollunga bro entha movie ya la thamizh cinema kettu pothunu

[@intothekumaranslife]

Bro list la songs and bgm vittuteenga. Adhukagave oduna padam ellam iruku namma oorula.

[@MithunKKS]

Are they attacking viduthalai 2?? 😂😂 Lol. If you don't like it, just don't watch it. It's Vertri's art, he loves it. We, some audience love it. We resonate with the art. There shouldn't be a grammar or syntax for art.

[@pandipandi4954]

Kadaisi vivasayi decode pannunga bro

[@aesthetic_pro1510]

Cinema is the emotional and psychological experience that is told to another person - Martin Scorsese

[@akash-pz6ql]

Ithu mattume cinima illa nu ennala debate panna mudiyum. oru director sonna art ku adhan full form nu eduthupeengala. Maththa directors la edhuvume sollalaya bro cinima voda definition la.

[@sspivitaltalks370]

Cinema has no definition

[@dineshdv2092]

I actually don't even know a more political filmmaker than scorsese and you guys are using him like a fancy quote generator..

[@atwunz]

​@@akash-pz6qlart is subjective.

[@manikrisn6679]

Director Bala is best in showing all emotions fear,anger,sadness,disgust,happiness,shame,love,excitement,empathy……………..etc

[@AkashJ]

@11:17 Great example in our industry Manivannan sir 💯

[@Price88-z5m]

Hi bro

[@vijayaprabu6669]

Manivanan last movies were kuppai... Dialogue sarakku theenthu poi .. He totally got outdated...

[@nandakumarsubash]

My real concern about movies is normalising toxic cultures in the society like Animal, Pushpa

[@kuganesofficial.8519]

Cinema va cine ya parunga broo atha intha vdo oda motto ve

[@nandakumarsubash]

​@@kuganesofficial.8519 Agreed, bro, that's for the mature audience. I am talking about adolescent kids who still can't need age to process this kind of content. EFX bros also talked about how the censor board is partial, and many politically incorrect movies are getting U/A certificates. I strongly believe that movies can subconsciously shape society in the long term.

[@bloodsons5449]

Pushpa la open ah... oru community aalu innoru community aala adikura maari scene vaikuranuga... atha politics ah paakama celebrate pandraga...ana namba oorla intha scene ah vachu irutha toxic ah adichitu saavinga...

[@sharan8710]

That's why Kollywood is still struggling to make 1000cr...

[@90480]

sutha moodu bro nee,,,,,

[@abd4195]

This is what called elitism , i agree with you in movies like thangalaan, vazhai , natcha thiram nagargirathu to a certain extent kaala and viduthalai 2 this is less than 25 percent of the 3 director, since i follow national stream , none of the film industries have the guts to put a character from downtrodden community as a lead in a commercial movie , not saying abt actor but character. But Pa ranjith changed the landscape with kaala , kabalai which to this day couldn't be digested by ao called elites. Yes the karuthu movies are wrong, but was it started now , no this is from the time of 90s itself, but why suddenly cuz the commerce directors have gone dry with heavy losses and these moves are making gud collection

[@GaneshSrinivas-y4l]

Avan thaan Karanam pa Ranjith. Avan thaan start panaan . Last few years Malayalam, Telugu. Athala pathalathila iruntha kanaada industry kooda national level la perusaaiduchu . South la ye Perusa iruntha tamil industry ah mudichi vitaanunga. Ranjith and Avan produce panra directora

[@richen2255]

Modha nenga support panra onnuku edhira inoruthanga opinion sona avanuku oru peru tharadhey neruthunga. There are ton of films which has a downtrodden lead but ratio of those films are low. Why? Because making movie is a business it's a commercial product people will always choose which has avg return rate product. It has nothing to with guts even if you're producer you will think twice before investing in a film.

[@aravindsamyr9365]

@@GaneshSrinivas-y4l pushpa eduthu dhan pan indian hit kudukanum na.. thevaye illa da matti

[@abd4195]

​@@GaneshSrinivas-y4l brother thanks for your opinion , I am not a supporter of Ranjith or mari selvraj , yet they aren't the only reason for our situation. Telugu industry ivlo perusu aaga egapatta factors iruku bahubali nu oru movie landscape a total a change pannirucu , yet other actors anga famous aaga reason go and visit goldmines hindi channel , telugu cinima voda mass masala movies a UP , BIHAR , MP , JHARKHAND la irukara movie watching population pudhusa iruku nu like pannanga , mosta andha movies dhan telugu actors ku familiarity create pannuchu , that's why pushpa one was hit in telugu but surprisingly blockbuster in hindi , kannada industry idhu varaikum 3 periya movie dhan kuduthu irukanga , malayalam movie mosta small scale content rich movies dhan iruku . Why Ranjith and gang mela vanmam na indha year ivlo directora flop kuduthapayum some of their movies were making revenue . Problem is with our commercial directors ecosystem not with them , If they make unrelatable bad movies surely they will be out of industry , and will be rejected by audience eg.Natchathiram nagargiradhu , mamannan 2nd half la oore adichudhu . And don't think our movies can't be again in top our commercial directors like shankar , ARM , Venkat Prabhu , Hari , GVM were not able to catch the pulse of commercial audience but surely they will do , then we will get commercially brilliant films . Lokesh , nelson and h Vinoth then and there was able to catch pulse of audience but innum set aagala , I am sure the new wave of direct will give sure shot success . Pa Ranjith made movies with same ideology before 2018 , during 2018 ( during pan India cinema rise) and post 2018 , so he can't be reason for this relative downfall. So let's wait for our commercial directors to rectify our mistake 👍👍👍

[@abd4195]

​​@@richen2255 sorry I didn't want to lable them purposefully , may be their frustration could have made them use the word propaganda, which is wrong . To answer your question,Yes brother make movies is a way of commercial aspect , true . Idhuku munnadi downtrodden heroes a potu padam panna thayakam reason , yaru paaka poranga nu , cuz adhuku munnadi indha maari character a hero va potu edutha padam edhuvum odala , but pa Ranjith showe that commercial success is possible even with these characters, that what I said.i am not blind supporter of him , whenever he makes a preachy movie like natchatiram nagargiradhu or Kabali , we can bash him , but we have to support movies like sarpatta and madras . No kanniyisam , but yaaro oru director karuthu vacha odidum nu solranga nu ivangala target panni propaganda nu sonnadhala nan ivangala apdi sonan

[@HareKrishnaHareRama101]

கருத்து என்பது opinion. அது இருக்கலாம் இல்லாமலேயே போகலாம் . ஆனால் morality நிச்சயம் இருக்கணும் . ஏன் என்றால் நாம் ஒவ்வொருவரும் பார்க்கும் விஷயங்களில் இருந்து மிக ஆதிகமாக influence ஆகிறோம்.

[@DonaldTalku476]

Thambigalaaa! Elitist mindset la irundhu veliya vaanga. Pa. Ranjith and Mari Selvaraj ah dhan mean panreenga nu theriyudhu. Neenga solra cinematic language and techniques lam Karnan la yum irukum Sarpatta Parambarai la yum irukum. Vetri ah mean panna Vadachennai la irukum. Balu Mahendra and Balachander lam idhuvum pannaanga adhuvum pannaanga nu lam compare panna mudiyadhu. Yen na avanga commercial reasons kaga cinema ku vandhanga. Ivangaloda CAUSE eh vera. Appadi irukurapo nee idha pathiye pesaadha or ippadidhan pesanum nu sollura urimai yaarukum illa. 'Enaku idhu mattum dhan theriyum' 'Idha sonna dhan en vandi inga odum' maadhiriyaana statements lam beyond disgusting

[@girinathgirinath7612]

💯

[@Pravin2609]

Well said ❤🎉

[@rkgaming8642]

Athelam irukatum oru reply video podalmla anney😂 😁

[@msqheartfwc]

Absolutely right

[@rkgaming8642]

Oru shorts oda scripta ipdi comment la potu waste panitiye anna

[@Tamizh_777]

Art is political ❤

[@akash-pz6ql]

OrNaan oru katturai leveluku reply panna nee oru varthaila Thiru vaarthaiya sollitiye pa 😅

[@Tamizh_777]

@@akash-pz6ql 😎🤝

[@sathyanarayanae]

I didn't expect this from you guys. This is a Narrow minded thinking.

[@MrNiceGuy0891]

Unakku thaanda arivu ille. Victim-mentality liye saavu

[@Mackv823]

To be honest you are the narrow minded one. If you mind is really broad as you imply, you would have taken his criticism as constructive and moved on rather than backbiting.

[@kratos_in_leeds]

@@Mackv823 This video would be there if they did the same moving on instead of backbiting.

[@sathyanarayanae]

@@Mackv823 There is no 'one way' of making Karuthu padam. Everybody has their own ways. Art is subjective. Inga ivanga karuthu padamna ippadi than edukanu, appadi than edukanumnu rule potukutu irukaanunga. Athu than narrow minded thinking.

[@7Lucky007]

Forcing your views on others or not respecting others point of view is called narrow mindedness 😂😂😂😂. So u know who is narrow minded.

[@Ash-vp8xd]

I know just three directors who prioritize ideologies in their filmmaking. Two of them have said that they chose cinema as a medium to talk about their struggles. If not for cinema, they would have chosen something else, like writing books or even addressing people directly on the streets. The third is Vetrimaaran, whose recent film didn’t work out, so you might have made this video based on that, I guess. Additionally, Thangalaan might have been a trigger point as well-I couldn’t connect with that either. But does it make sense to say that the entire Tamil cinema industry is failing because of ideology, just because of three filmmakers who have collectively made around 20 films? Do you think mixing all 24 crafts together is easy? The film industry is inherently uncertain. Even making videos online would have shown you how unpredictable creative work can be. For instance, Leo didn’t convey any ideology, but it didn’t work out as an art form either. Vikram isn’t a particularly great story; it’s mediocre. Kanguva didn’t do well. Goat didn’t go well. Kotukkali was good, but it didn’t perform exceptionally. On the other hand, Aranmanai, which arguably has the weakest ideology, became a huge success. Indian 2 didn’t work out. Rathnam had flaws in its screenplay. Each film has its reasons for not working-sometimes the director doesn’t update themselves, sometimes the screenplay doesn’t connect. But blaming ideology as the reason for failure is a lame excuse. Three directors don’t control the entire industry. There are budding filmmakers who prioritize ideology in their work, and some have succeeded. For example, Blue Star and Labbar Pandhu performed well. But their success doesn’t mean every filmmaker who focuses on ideology will succeed. It’s about being true to what your film is trying to say. Today, with 100 movies releasing every year, not all failures are because of ideology. This perspective might be valid in just one case, but it’s not valid in 100 others. Moreover, your video might end up becoming a tool for dominant caste online personalities to abuse Ranjith. From my heart, I’ve seen them doing this before-they will cut your video at some point and use it as propaganda to favor their narrative. Don’t take this personally, but I’ve seen this pattern in 1,000 instances. A Dalit has to be so perfect, just like a Black man in America must be flawless in order to survive among the elites. Lastly, we live in a society where a boyfriend was killed this morning in Tirunelveli just for visiting his girlfriend. There are layers of challenges and complexities that films alone can’t address. I hope you guys understand this point.

[@dinesh6489]

Bro 🥺🥺👌👌👌

[@Parthiban00000]

Entertaining is not a problem you can see Leo for entertainment not for story but for that ideology director they do the thing called emotionally provocative topic and framing a certain community people as a enemy whole but today we are changing and evolving but this kind of movie bringing us backwards and igniting the problem

[@Pravin2609]

​@@Parthiban00000 so you say that there are no honour killings, caste violence, discrimination, vandalising the properties of other communities. Right?

[@Pravin2609]

Can you explain what is that emotionally provocative topic?

[@Parthiban00000]

@@Pravin2609 like criticizing one present community as a whole for their past generation actions

[@karthickvasudevan8759]

13:41 Yeah, we can understand this you telling all this to Ranjith, Vetri and Maari. All these peoples have their specific cinematic language thats why they sustaining for this long. Eg Viduthala 1 train accident shot, sarpatta dancing rose match fix and fight sequence, Pariyerum perumal. They have their own style of cinema language which connects audience. But you guys never questioned the Karuthu that saying in Amaran movie. Not created this video on that time. Conveniently ignored for your own interests. Art is subjective. Most of the people okay with their film making with social responsible movies. If karuthu alone is enough means why indian 2 is flopped? These directors have their own style of cinema language that why succeeding. It is not their problem, when other directors not make audiance engage.

[@feelandvibe7384]

Bro seruppala adicha mathiri kettinga aana ithuku pathil solla mattanunga . Karuthu solli padam edukkurathum edukkathathum avanga edukkura mudivu ,pakkurathum pakkathathum Nama edukura mudivu.

[@karthickvasudevan8759]

@@feelandvibe7384 ivanungaluku karuthu mukkiyam ila.. antha karutha yaar soldranga.. ivanga karuthuku ethir ah iruntha dhan prachana..

[@diMO1933]

விஜய்சேதுபதி சம்பளம் முப்பது கோடி வெற்றிமாறன் சம்பளம் 10 கோடி ஆனா லைட் மேன் 750 ரூபாய் மேக்கப் ஆர்டிஸ்ட் 1000 இதுல எங்கடா சமத்துவம் கம்யூனிசம் எல்லாம் .... மக்களே உங்கள் உணர்ச்சியை தூண்டி காசு பாக்குறானுங்க .... திமுக ஆட்சியில இவ்வளவு அநியாயம் நடக்குது எதாவதுக்கு விஜய்சேதுபதி வெற்றிமாறன் வாய் துறந்து பார்த்துயிருக்கிங்களா

[@Joker-et6ph]

Gammu iruda..adhey VJS BJPnala nadakura issuekudhan pesala manipurku apo enna soluva?? Komali sanghi gammunu irungada​@@diMO1933

[@dineshdv2092]

​@@diMO1933bro seriousah sorry but kiruku pundha maari pesatheenga..communism na elaarukum orae sambalam kodukanumnu ungaluku yaaru sonnangalo avangakitta itha sollidunga👍

[@dinesh6489]

Simple bro, #Animal movie ya India le #Kerala and #Tamilnadu la thaan first criticise pannanga. Ithu laam enna ?? Politics and Movies play the vital role. 💪💪

[@jesusjesus9148]

Animal la positive ah sonna per thaan athigam tamilnadi and Kerala la

[@dinesh6489]

@@jesusjesus9148 Yaaru da nee , nee ethod alien maari paesura

[@HariKrishna-lk5wx]

​@@dinesh6489both animal and pushpa are hit in tn😭🤣🤣 activism is only in social media

[@RM-wy1pi]

Bro thinks quoting tarantino, nolan against vetrimaaran, pa ranjith and mari Selvaraj Sums up they've no idea of how a social background of an artist influences their art.

[@achuthambi28]

Adipoli mollywood: 1. Manjummel Boys- All Time Blockbuster 2. Premalu- Blockbuster 3.Aadujeevitham- Blockbuster 4.Aavesham- All Time Blockbuster 5. Lucky Baskar- Blockbuster 6.ARM- Blockbuster 7.Marco- Blockbuster 8. Bramayugam - Blockbuster 9.Guruvayoor ambalandayil- Superhit 10.Varshangalukku Shesham- Superhit Tamil industry - 🤮🤮🤮😣🤢🤢🤢🤢 Tamil industry want paasam😂😂😂

[@jesusjesus9148]

​@@achuthambi28😂 correct thaan.intha entha padathulayum political illa

[@AjithKumar-xq9si]

Such an elite buluthii mindset..

[@MrCapricornGOAT]

@@AjithKumar-xq9si avanga crt ah thaan solranga

[@riyassha6090]

Why is your Thumbnail is misleading then? As a Audience, i feel that this whole video is about maari selvaraj. If thats the case. Vaazhai is a Better film, in this international way presented with root stories, visually compelling. Thumbnail couldve been anyone in cinema , even Vetrimaaran.As Viduthalai 2 has very less cinematic shots but Why Maari?. I dont remember B/W used in such sense in any cinemas for a long time,likewise in Vaazhai and Maamannan. Cinema is also about untold stories. Even the Vetrimaaran dialougue 3:58 you have attached in the beginning is itself a answer to your whole video. Ranjith has explored a sports film and par Magical Realism . Doesnt these stories and techniques didnt bat your eye. A Techinically non compromising Maari in Thumbnail worries me. Ranjith always tells not to compromise on the craft and we can see those in his movies.These things contradicts your whole video. Have some clarity and do your research.

[@ddusyanth1848]

Super brooo...nalla tharkuri maathirii pesuninga❤

[@aravindhmohan3442]

*16:32** Shawshank Redemption...* 😍❤️‍🔥💝

[@Hikari_3301]

Bardhwaj Rangan was heavily trolled when he expressed his opinions on Jai Bhim, without even taking his constructive points just because it was a movie with a “message”. But unlike other social commentaries, this movie was weak in being a “movie” in almost all aspects.

[@Wstoic]

that was more like a biopic rather than message movie

[@Amalrishi666]

Its not a message preaching films its have good screenplay with thriller zone.why br trolled he likes bigile more than kaithi&annathe more than jai bhim so people's who watch his content on KZbin disappointing

[@sooriyaharesh2002]

BR was trolled because he was complaining that the movie was over dramatic. But in reality the actual incident was more brutal than what was shown on screen.

[@louiz0]

I think this is the problem in our society.. Open ah discriminate pannama... Ipdi oppression discrimination pathi voice out panravangala criticize panradhu is also a way of subtle discrimination.. we can understand the true colours of people who are supporting this video .. nool ,sanghi ellam maatuvan ippo...

[@àbsolultimate]

Bro this is just a filmography just try to understand

[@àbsolultimate]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYqVm5WAipZggZYsi=n0zEwPp2ZXYObJ5X

[@louisantony6005]

Cinema is the most powerful art .. We can't ignore just like that brother..

[@chatwithme2367]

Tolstoy+ martin scorcsese+ schilnderlist+ kubrick +Qt= art, Avalodhan. Puluthis starter package.

[@FICTIONTALK2107]

ivanuha oru naal peru therinju vechukitu athuthaan art nu solranga. athe hollywood la black people rights ku padam pana Spike lee la kanuku theriya matanga.

[@bbapplesam]

😂😂😂lol

[@NissarfasilJ]

Art - "Something that is created with imagination and skill and that is beautiful or that expresses important ideas or feelings" Grammar- "Is the set of rules for how a natural language is structured, as demonstrated by its speakers or writers." Come on, guys. The audience is mature enough to accept a roast of a bad movie, even if it has a good message. It's up to them to decide whether the film is worth it or not. Why be so insecure about it?

[@MuthuKumar-ol2qf]

Karupu alagu illa soniga , Dalit neet ah iruka matanga soniga, Ipo karuthayum alaga solanum ... Inga ethumey punitham kedayathu - mari Selvaraj ❤

[@thalart8665]

என்னோட மனசுல உள்ளத்தை அப்படியே சொல்லிட்டீங்க

[@VaishuAravind-n6p]

Elite Puluthees vanmatha kakka start pantaanunga 😂😂😂

[@venkatesh6803]

Dai Elite jaathiveriyans😂😂

[@VaishuAravind-n6p]

@ Yaaru naanga Jaadhi veriyan ah 😂😂😂 Seri kadharu

[@àbsolultimate]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYqVm5WAipZggZYsi=n0zEwPp2ZXYObJ5X

[@inventionworld1706]

Please Ari Aster oda Midsommar movie analysis podunga... One of the finest horror films with bright colour palette and extraordinary Cinematography

[@dinesh6489]

*Pa. Ranjith* - Attakathi, Madras , Sarpetta Parambarai & few movies for his ideology. Vetri Maran - has given diverse movies - last 3 movies are political (based on novels). Mari Selvaraj - He has explained very clearly all the movies are from his LIFE experiences. *TJ Gnanavel* - He is the reporter first and he did movies based on the things happen. I know u guys are targeting the above 4 directors directly/indiectly. Etho oru tharkoori sonnathuku oru video vaa ?? Namma orula neraya schinders list katha eruku, avalo panni erukanga CASTE BASED discrimination. Bro, these are few directors are the only hope in the film industry who can showcase the dark side of the Tamil community who dont want to listen/know what they have done to suppressed sections. Yes at the end of the day they make movies which may be hit/flop, but there should have atleast 3/4 directors who can make movies that ensures socially correct, i think thats the difference between Tamil and other languages. VOICE for Voiceless.

[@leanboy3810]

@@dinesh6489 itha sonna kadikka varanunga. These people are silently spreading venom

[@FBcommenter]

bro ivaroda insta bio parunga aprm theriyum yaaru propoganda nu ivaru vaitherichal la

[@Hariharan-hy2gv]

@dinesh6489 well said 💯👏🏻👍🏻

[@IamGroot87]

Well Said brother💯 Pa Ranjith, Mari maari directors dhn Kollywood ah spoil panranga nu oppari veikuranunga...

[@shanthakumar6127]

They have created KZbin groups , first they will act nice , once they became famous. They will show true colour. Liked cooked , sarigama and trendloud corporates , vikkal . Few insta influences. Just post 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 for haters . Just express with emoji don't waste valuable emotions.

[@a36saransubramaniyan90]

Tamil cinema make many directors But, best character, best director, best entertainer 👑 KAMAL HASSAN 👑

[@appuabhimani01]

Best director lam solladha So many directors are better than kamal

[@abd4195]

Bro ranjith , mari selvaraj , vetrimaran sort of film makers have always been coexisting with directors like shankar , hari , lingusamy , lokesh , ARM, KS Ravikumar , h vinoth and experimental makers like thiyagarajan kumararaja , madonne ashwin , vikram kumar . Just because the commercial directors are out of form and none of the commercial directors have produced good movies , you cant scould mari selvaraj ,ranjith, vetrimaran .

[@VictorOne-i4v]

Gurubaai 😂

[@nishquest]

Then what about movies like RRR and kalki where craft is good and stuffed with Toxic propaganda ??

[@rajakr2096]

A mild retaliation to amukkuraan pithukuraan types.

[@akash-pz6ql]

Evano oruthan pocherichalla ketta kelviku badhil solrenu oru video potrukeenga. Vetri, Ranjith, Mari ku la film a Art form layum morattu cinimatic language layum eduka theriyum. Adhuvum seekram makkal ta kondu poi sekka theriyum. Ithu varaikum vandha padatha la vida better screenplay writing la kuduthrukaanga. Book padika solreenga padika theriyathavanta epdi poi solluveenga. ovvoru aalta poi book padinga nu solluveengala. Yen comedy, fantasy , science, fiction ellathukum dhan book iruku adhayum bookaa padika solla vendi thana. paamaranta oru visayatha theriya paduthurathuku than appove nadaga tamil nu literatures kondu vandhaanga. Kadaisi varaikum avana malumattaya paakanumnu sila per aasa paduraanga. Ippo indha padangal varuvadhu avasiyam. Makkal konjam konjama maritu Vara time la avanga sariyana paathya noki than poraanga nu avangaluku remind panrathuku indha padangal avasiyam. Neenga indha directors a mention panrathukaaga video poteengala nu therila. Ana naan andha kelvi kettavaruku solra badhil. Viduthalai 2 hit anathula mana ulaichaluku aalagirukaaru😂.

[@Gowthamm175]

Bro, Pls talk about story writing 1) How to get ideas for a story 2) How into convert our ideas into script 3) How to overcome inferiority complex - when am doing my 1st short film or future film 4) Pls do a video about this whole process, like 1hr or 2hr tutorial because we have lots of tutorials for design, ai, coding, camera, editing, etc but when it comes teaching script or story, the tutorials are very less so pls take it as a request, i'll hope to see you the upcoming story & Script writing tutorial

[@mrnishedits8239]

Yes bros we needed

[@thendhuruvam4686]

Ideas for your story comes from anything oru book ah irukalaam oru painting ah irukalaam engyo paakra photos and padathula vara oru frame oru charector ah sketch pantu avuna kondu poi oru prachanaila niruthi Anga irundhu kadha yosiklaam... For example engita oru payan internship vandhaan Avan kita Avan appa enna vela seiraarunu ketadhuku Avan therla nu sonaan...so what if he follow his father one day to know about him nu oru phrase vetchu start panna... 2) how to convert it : Most personal is the most creative... Ungalukey theryaama different aana charectoristic ungaluku irukum adhulaam unique ah irukum take it from u to sketch a charecter...inum andha charector kooda connect aagi eludhlaam I am not talking about every films...I am talking about for ur first film.. maximum debut la jeichavanga avangala represent panra maari avunga charector ah vetchu tha eludheerpaanga...

[@mrnishedits8239]

@@thendhuruvam4686 romba thanks bro/sis

[@dossm992]

Your last few words about cinema hats off guys.CINEMA IS A WORLD OF ARTS

[@vijayaganesh4574]

This video is not educating and bad example.If you don't define a movie as a good movie if it is educative based on the definition of cinema you made leave it as it.I would preferably define it as treasure.People those who are well brought up may or may not need those educating aspects.But those treasures represents the economically and socially weaker people and tells them what to do in their life like "kadu irutha pudinkikuvanga...".In the aspect of book also you are saying not to read self help books and to read fictions. You are having knowledge in cinema you can say that cinema is good or bad.when you are saying that as good cinema people go and watch that out of 100 1 person may change the mindset .I am such a person changed my mindset by watching those cinemas support those cinemas will improve us a society.Educative cinemas makes people socially educative.

[@Cinema0917]

'Enaku idhu mattum dhan theriyum' 'Idha sonna dhan en vandi inga odum' So disgusting, Madras la appdi irukum sarpatta sollavae venam Vetrimaran visaranai, aadukalam, vadachennai thukki saptu iruparu Marai also cinematic aa karnan eduthu iruparu Ivangalaku stuff illai sollura mathri iruku.. Ethachi sonna engala attack pannuranga nu solluvinga.... Screenplay and character design la ranjith and vetri mathri eluthavae mudiyathu... Oru 3director tha cinema matha director aa qus panna kudathu irukiranga Ks jigarthanda double x la poltical la tha eduthu irupan Sila director horror mattum edupanga Sila peru gangster movie crime edupanga athu avanga choice... Neenga sollura nolan tenet nu oru padam black aa hero vachi periya budget la edutharu athucae anga poltical movement mathri peasunanga... Cinema is the emotional and psychological experience that is told to another person - Martin Scorsese

[@rajprabhakar2084]

Last night, only me and my friend were discussing the Birdman (2014) film because of the lighting aspect. Today is your video. The same thing happened to 12 Angry Man (1957). Catch our minds's voice lol:). Thank you for your efforts, all your videos and advise our audience in the right way. By the way, I am an aspiring filmmaker, studying and watching from the UK.

[@uniqueness8068]

Good work team! I felt that lubber pandhu became a good success, coz it was purely entertaining among those karuthu movies that were released.

[@dmsact5485]

Lubber pandhu padamae neraya karuthu and ideologies pesuchu 😂😂.. adhalam varumbodhu kanna moodikita pola ?? 😂

[@rajeshkannanE]

Those are not propaganda type. Part of movie and the movie doesn't concentrate on that. Summa pathil sollanum nu solla vena... Most of the vijay movies are karuthu movie only... In comments no body talked about it...

[@venkatesh6803]

Don't compare lubber pandhu with propaganda movie shits. Lubber pandhu movie core is cricket not politics.

[@sharnmuthu5504]

As you have said in this video i dont see some one to make movies to just only educate or play victim using cinema.here the directors whom you have said are profound in craft ,they know cinema they are using this as tool to convey what their thoughts are ,this is just an another era of cinema not end of cinema😢

[@m4pearl]

Nalla karuthu ulla padam lam NALLA PADAM KEDAYADHU.

[@Editorofblackmadras]

Yen Bro #Kashmir_files or Kerala_Story Varum Pothu mattum Unga Karuthu, Opinion or Cinema language lam yen bro varamatinguthu? @expertfx #justasking

[@appuabhimani01]

Adhellam biggest piece of dog shit😂

[@இரா.சத்திஸ்குமார்]

1:26 Yethanaale padam great nu enaku solle terile..but as a viewer ahh 2or3 hours padam pakkurappe entertainment ahh irukanum and kudukura kaasu kum worth ahh irukanum..avlo than ☺️

[@antionettrayan6646]

EFX bros cannot talk about who they really criticize because they are in same film industry . But they criticize the ideology , nice strategy.

[@Benzo210]

Dir Chimbu devan pathi oru video pannu bro because tamil cinema la enaku therunju different kind of comedy, adventure and fantasy yarum ipo andha alavuku pannala

[@Vignesh6480]

bro number of screens pathi, distribution n exhibition system pathi oru video.. producer CV Kumar said if we have lot of small small screens in every area old people will go and watch rather than sitting alone in home at least for timepass(ig it's for many billion ppl in India) India and China have the same land area (habitable) and same population but they have 80000+ screens and we have only 10000 plus screens.. Rajamouli also said maximum we tap only 5 to 6% of the audience we shld aim to increase it to atleast 3-4% this will change many things from the production value of the film and as a whole film Industry

[@positivity6626]

Neenga city ya thaandalenu nalla therithu... 😂😂

[@sharan8710]

ena bro nasikutanga😂la

[@wayne_edits_Bruce]

Fact u

[@dr.ramvideos4404]

Neenga rendu perum ethavathu saathichitu ithelaam pesalammm 😊😊 no one is controlling industry here its heroes choice to whom to work with ,evano oru aravekaadu ad onnu solitaanu filmmakers ideology ya thapa pesuringa

[@kowhamkrishnan7480]

சினிமாவுலையும் Mind Voice Use பண்ணலாம் ஆனா Serial-ல பண்ற மாதிரி Over React பண்ண கூடாது..... Best Mind Voice Film - Example- MEMENTO 🔥

[@appuabhimani01]

Adhu voice over murugesa😂 Memento la

[@kowhamkrishnan7480]

@appuabhimani01 Dei தற்க்குறி ஒரு மன.நலம் பாதிச்ச Patient-டோட Mind Voice-யா அது.....Voice Over-னா அந்த Chatacter-க்கு சம்மந்தம் இல்லாத Voice-ல Narrate பண்றது.....Example குஷி படத்தில Opening Sequence-ல S J Suriya அந்த முமூ Story-யையும் Narrate பண்ணுவாரே....அது தான் Voice Over......😐

[@appuabhimani01]

Memento voice over narration dhanda🤣 Vena Google la podu da tharkuri🤣​@@kowhamkrishnan7480

[@sharan8710]

​@@kowhamkrishnan7480yaanai padathula director hari opening la pannuvare adhana 😂😂

[@user-ku7yt4sh7z]

Super bro naanum idhey dha think pannitu iruindhen viduthalai 2 paathumudichadhum! Super! Directors should use the cinema medium effectively and more visually.

[@swaminathananthiraikili2664]

I personally felt Viduthalai movie degraded all other communities except SC.

[@girinathgirinath7612]

@@swaminathananthiraikili2664 Where ?

[@s.bharathibharathi3443]

​@@swaminathananthiraikili2664Athenna SC , oppressed nu sollu,ithu jaathi ya buththiya iruku,maththa community yaa degrade laam pannala , society yepdi irunthaangalo atha thaan sonnaru ,vanthurathu ,vanmatha kakka....

[@yashkasi94]

Hello elites.. Inga irukka Tamil cinema onnum apdi marala. Karuthu sonnale padam lam odala... Arasiyal pesa cinema va tool ah use panravanga velai vera.. Commercial aspects kaga cinema ku vanthavanga vera... Neenga technical aspects la nalla padam nu example sonna padangale enakku connect agatha kuppa padamavum irunthuruku.. Neenga yara kuri vachu solriyo avanga solra film language enakkum connect agiruku. Athe ideology pesurenu padam eduka theriyama eduthu serupadi vangunavangalum intha industry la paka thaan seirom. So inga neenga kuri vachu pesura atkal avanga arasiyala cinema la pesurangana antha film language pudichu atha pakaravanga thaan avanga audience

[@Saravanaguru1994]

Im a true cinema lover. Ennoda bayamum ithe than. Apdiye sollitinga. Thanks guys ❤

[@secaccnt9931]

Ranjith and mari make two films max out of the 200 tamil films that get released every year. They don't set out to make 1000 crore films or with box office returns being the ultimate motive. If tamil cinema can't make money, it is on the commercial directors and not these guys.

[@cartoonbaby5711]

Good analysis bros. theses kind of directors spoils Tamil industry 😢.

[@balajikumar6158]

Vera level Bro16:30 Naanum Oru CINEMA 📽️ 🎥 Lover than Indha year la 300 filns paathuruppen next years um Many types of movies, series, Animation,Anime Paathu neriya vishayam Therinjikkanum Interest irukku.❤❤🎉🎉I Love CINEMA 📽️🎥

[@SachinSachin-ow2uz]

Bro cinema is not only for entertainment.. It's also need to educate people and make people understand the reality.. There are number of directors to make commercial, entertainment movie . But some direction like Vetri, Ranjith, Mari making reality movies.. Because of making karuthu movies it's not like they don't know to make other jorner movies.. They just want to be unique among others.. Also ealla audiance um same ila.. oru oruthavangaluku oru jorner of movies pudikum. If you don't want to watch a karuthu fully loaded movie just avoid it.. There are many people like to watch this kind of movies...

[@feelandvibe7384]

Well said bro

[@SachinSachin-ow2uz]

@feelandvibe7384 ❤️✨

[@MushroomPuffs]

It'll be a joke if you are supposed to mean the men who made SARPATTA, VADACHENNAI & KARNAN are not aware of these film languages and literary devices. If this video is not about them then fine! But why do so many people in the comments try to spread an agenda against some of the greatest filmmakers in Indian cinema? 🤔

[@expertfx]

Vetri sir oda speech a dhan example a ve podrom regular a, even in this video. Thangalan oda mysticism a appreciate pani avlo view pona video nambaldhu dhan. But eppome namba solla vara core a yaarume purinjika maatanga. Both the sides. Let's see indha comments laam enga kondu vandhu ududhunu! 😂

[@feelandvibe7384]

​@@expertfx Safe play pannathinga Neenga onnu solla varingana opena sollunga illana sollathinha neenga oru vishayatha sollitu illa na ippadi sonna neenga thappa purinchikitinga nu soldrathu apdiye plate ta mathurathu Athuku Peru enna therima ----------*

[@Hariharan-hy2gv]

I have one question to expertfx. 15:05 intha second la....neenga enna solla varinga....eathuku intha illatha bayatha manasula vidhaika pakuringa?

[@alanmurugesan7956]

​@@expertfx Vetri speeach ah dhan quote panrom, Thangalaan ah praise pannirukom - idhalam ok dhan... Idhu endha directors ah target panni solringa open ah solla vendi dhane...Cinema mela iruka love nala dhane indha video apo open ah sollalam la...Video la mattum Mari, vetri, Ranjith nu edhukku aprom katringa avangala sollalana? aana efx debate nu potutu rendu perum ore view ah support panni pesringa paaru😂😂😂

[@karthickvasudevan8759]

​@@alanmurugesan7956perfectly summaries my thoughts

[@maniraj4676]

Suber bro 👍 Lighta ipotha feel aguthe?

[@sharfaraazs9367]

Vadachennai Review video venum, yaar lam support panringa ❤❤❤❤

[@bibinjohnpui7881]

Finally someone talk about this

[@sakashtukastagalu481]

gabbar u cried 😂😂

[@dhayanandh2003]

"book uh kana art form and cinema kaana grammer irukanum" - ❤

[@Alots]

Cinema is simply a medium of entertainment, best enjoyed during our free time or when we are get feeling bored. The story isn’t always the main focus, what matters is whether it entertains us, makes us happy, or make awareness, like Mr. Bean but now a days people are watching movies late at night or early in the morning shows they addicted to it which negatively impacts sleep and mental health. I’m not trying to sound boomer, I’m just sharing my opinion.

[@user-ku7yt4sh7z]

Super bro naanum idhey dha think pannitu iruindhen viduthalai 2 paathumudichadhum! Super! Directors should use the cinema medium effectively and more visually. 14:20

[@kanakaraj6037]

My pov oru 3 hours vera ethaum pathi think pannama namma celebrate pani entertainment panurathu than cinema

[@HelloHi-kj5lu]

Exactly

[@kanakaraj6037]

@HelloHi-kj5lu 🙌🏻

[@billythesupe-butcher3747]

Exactly oru karuththa oru thadava sollalaam,oraayiram thadavaya solrathu

[@baranitharan3652]

Evano pora pokkula sonnadha nambi oru video potrukaanunga... Social message is the director's wish. If the producer is Ok with it no one stop them. But a separate video to avoid social message in a movie is a pure vanmam from EFX. Tamil film industry having different genre of director and movies. High budget and Comedy genre directors are failed to give hits. Adhuku social message solra director movie pannaradha avoid pannanum solradhu is a Pure Vanmam. Grow up guys.

[@Stephenaquilla23]

First understand what cinema is🤦🏻‍♂️

[@mickymack5229]

Daii entire filmography films ah social message ore theme la movie edutha. Yarum movie paka matanga.

[@baranitharan3652]

@@mickymack5229 If you don't like those movie then don't watch it. Simple!

[@Stephenaquilla23]

@@baranitharan3652 then don't comment defending them if you don't like our opinion🙂

[@perarivalans9451]

we need Game of Thrones analysis

[@kishorekking2286]

Someone talk about now is going in tamil cinema ideology solradhuku padam edukradhu yes they're visualizing morally good things, they're not another style of storytelling or film language, still recently i am very tiring feel when i saw viduthalai whatever it is good ideology, vetrimaran direction but end of the where is storytelling just taking letcture what is communism and same film style repeats i worrying about why my idol make film like this even scorecese also have same issue then he is also changed is style why because audience are expecting from him so the audience don't encourage your favourite idols average works expect from them that make cinema good and kudos to you bros ❤️ day by day your content is become more valuable 🔥

[@VR471]

Vidudhalai 1 was decent. It didn't feel preachy but I keep hearing Vidudhalai 2 feels like a lecture. I will still watch it for Vetrimaran but I'm not that hyped for it.

[@Wstoic]

the intense raw . ideological movies are essential for some people in our community, cinema and sports arent a separate entity in our country , all the things are intensified greatly

[@SURYA-dm2yz]

Noolu noolu noolu

[@Happy-times431]

Pesa pesa niraya varukirathu! Thodaranthu valaraungal...❤

[@onlygames5478]

Instead of Blaming ""karuthu"" directors, why dont you blame the heroes who take up 95% of the budget and commercial directors to actually make some watchable movies? This whole video is just a shade at Pa Ranjith and Mari Selvaraj and its not their fault they are actually making engaging movies

[@akak-x4y]

They already made video for that bro.. chill

[@Tamizh-Arasiyal]

@@akak-x4y Yedhu Shankar ku nalla vaai pottanungale andha video va?

[@Praveeno0-07]

You guys are creating a revolution with your innovative ideas.❤

[@ZOI-nh4ib]

Someone has to speak about most of the Tamil cinema which is clearly not working and don't worry about those people who drop negative comments in this video who don't have any knowledge or language to know what Western cinema is like in comparison to most of the Tamil cinema 🤣🤣🤣

[@Praveen_6_4]

Bro's vera mari video. Unexpected one from you guys. 🔥❤️

[@Blenderdudes-cr2xt]

Viduthalai 2 is nice film, it is even better then ur guys film.

[@yogeshwaran8284]

12:35 Maari Selavaraj , Ranjith , Mohan G, Muthaiya , தாக்கப்பட்டனர்.

[@KumarKumar-jh3ij]

Lokesh😂

[@yogeshwaran8284]

@KumarKumar-jh3ij I mentioned caste vachu mattum padam edukura directors. Lokesh Drugs vachu mattum padam edukuravan. Siva Sentiment vachu mattum padam edukuravan.

[@PrasanthkumarKumar]

Ranjith mari Selvaraj avanga padathula caste parumai panirukangala aanda parambarai nu solirukangala oru samugathai elivu paduthi padam yaduthurukangala solunga...

[@TheRagul90]

​@@PrasanthkumarKumar nee sonna last sentence vachi thaan avanungaloda mukka vaasi padam oduthu. Nasukuranga pithukuranga nu soldrathu laam yaaru. Ivanga keel saathi yaam. Ivangala eppithum mel saathi nasukurangalaam

[@n.ajanthan629]

❤ someone said

[@sainath.0]

16:44 these words makes me to feel goosebumped bro's continue this type of dedication until your last breath ❤

[@GokulGokul-gp4hc]

Bro I am 18 years old I write 5 story 1 time travel story 2 one love story 3 avatar like movie 4 parts 4 full action story 5 Bagubali like story 3 parts And I come change the industry My brother also helped me in writing all these stories I am more interested in making and he is more interested in writing. My brother's name is mari my name is Gokul

[@LN555.]

Congratulations bro❤😊

[@saiprasath276]

Super bro 🔥💥

[@GokulGokul-gp4hc]

@@LN555. Thank you bro

[@GokulGokul-gp4hc]

@@saiprasath276 thank you bro

[@dinesh6489]

​@@GokulGokul-gp4hc Why can't u make a film TRIBAL movies ?? U would say there are people to do that. The same goes for u. 😂😂

[@dopedrip3491]

Bro, I don’t know if you’ve thought this through, but art is about expression and about conveying what you feel. To make it clearer, think about how hip-hop as a genre was born. It was created by marginalized communities who used it as a platform to express their anger and opinions. You can’t just dismiss it by saying, ‘Make pure artistic music for the sake of art.’ Different people use art to express themselves in different ways. The same applies to cinema. Political films are often made with genuine intentions, rooted in the filmmakers’ experiences, and there’s plenty of artistry in them too. If their political ideas irritate you, that’s fine, but why not also acknowledge the artistic expression on screen? Why is it so hard to see both sides? Honestly, I don’t know if you’re even aware of this perspective. To make more clear I will say from your pov. As you said art is subjective so they are (PERIOD)

[@gopalakrishnan5766]

Exactly this is what I felt after viduthalai 2 because it's vetrimaran film.

[@Albin_Devasia]

Goosebumps while watching this video❤

[@ravichandrans4564]

I can see the growth and the quality content from you guys. Great and thanks 👍....

[@Youtubersfunnyvideo]

Happy Christmas guys🎉❤ love from thiruvarur

[@prashantprashant1814]

I want to become a director like Steven spielberg 😢

[@appuabhimani01]

Rule no 1 don't be like him Rule no 2 forget that idea bcoz of tamil industry 😂 they want only cringe not innovative 😂

[@prashantprashant1814]

@appuabhimani01 no i will change

[@appuabhimani01]

Vaipilla raja😂 oru idea irukku Nee panam earn panni padam pannu adhu dhan best​@@prashantprashant1814

[@mohandass143]

They targeting Vetrimaran, Ranjith and Mariselvaraj movies.

[@Tzuyu-vc5wx]

Yes. Because they are worst directors.

[@wjhfxcvwy]

nasukittaga pidhukittaga nu soliye dhan padam edukanuma! padam nalla ila nu sonna paint dabba thookitu vandhuruviga

[@harshuvarshan2k22]

@@wjhfxcvwynasukitan pidhukitaan solala.... naangalum padichi muneruvoem engala rowdy ahh kevalama sitharicha cibema la naangalum r😂form aguvoen nu anti caste solli... unna maari echa naai laam jadhi veri marachi inga vayir eriya vechqn laa.. andaiya amuki pidhuki... adhan ranjith vm maari oda mass 😂😂😂 thu orama po

[@appuabhimani01]

​@@wjhfxcvwysecond show video reviewer kadichi vachiruvan😂 Indha video paathu indha 2 perayum jaadhi veriyan nu muthirai kuthuvan😂😂😂😂

[@appuabhimani01]

Vetrimaran versatile bro Mathathellam jaadhi dhan😂😂😂

[@Mr619a26]

Srinath ranganatha Srikanth ranganatha 😂😂😂 Neenga oodhave venam moment 😂😂😂

[@mickymack5229]

Neenga aduku oo***u venaam bro

[@gopalakrishnan5766]

16:31 this is you guys, waiting to watch your movie on the big screen ❤

[@LDangelx]

Parithabangal Fans Assemble !!! Parithabangal Fans Like here

[@PremKumar-iw4ud]

Super bro good video keep it up🎉❤

[@Manoj_kumar_19]

Yenna bros Midnight Upload 😅

[@expertfx]

Day and Night work 😅

[@rkvignesh2802]

?@@expertfx😂

[@Karthi-q5y]

11 mani midnight aha Ryt raa

[@DeoxyGamer__7-cr4hs]

Mostly Bro's audiences are Batman, so this is perfect timing to see this video before going out to save the city. I need to go now, the city calls me 🦇

[@HdhshDhsjsj-nq7ty]

Paisa venum athukku

[@user-ku7yt4sh7z]

16:34 fantastic lines 🙇‍♂️🙏🔥

[@Pravin2609]

Do you know how much movies tamil cinema has given us as of dec 2024 ? List out the karuthu movies as you say which were released in this year.

[@dmsact5485]

Solla maatan because they know only maari , vetri and Ranjith 😂...

[@duraibalan7483]

Kudos to you guys for showing the audience the difference between Fiction and Non fiction also very very thanks for this video and your effort make us realise this message😀😀😀

[@ErenJaegerAoT]

We just want a entertaining film not a politicaly crct one

[@harshuvarshan2k22]

appo shankar padam la enna mostly ??? appo idha vai en shankar padathuku varala ?

[@ErenJaegerAoT]

@harshuvarshan2k22 entertainment comes first.his movies entertained...pa. Ranjith movies too...but maari movies is just documentary type

[@gamelonedoc3845]

@@ErenJaegerAoT Nool lead na entertainment ah?

[@ErenJaegerAoT]

@@gamelonedoc3845 yes

[@balajib8655]

Semma topic bro

[@Parthiban00000]

Don't delete this video bro some fake murpokku and keyboard warriors kadharatum 😂

[@coffeetoffee8827]

“You said cinema, I heard Kamal Haasan”

[@Mukesh-nn6mn]

Uu

[@Mukesh-nn6mn]

Poda loosu koo🔥

[@Vasanthakumarann]

Bro evlo naall yenga bro iruthaa nee... Semayaa panuringa bro big fan❤️❤️

[@n4r3n11]

they posting for past 12 years bro you just found them now!!

[@vaanamchannel1862]

😂😂😂ஜோக்கர் டா

[@gsganesh93]

Just my personal opinion, when movie is good with a social message or feel good movie I will prefer to watch at in OTT and if a movie is soo comercial with dance and fight spectacular screen play I would definitely enjoy it on the big screen. Is this the correct method??? What is your opinion guys because the cost of cinema is nowadays becoming huge for a common man to enjoy everything on the big screen and my opinion is that feel good movies has to targeted towards OTT as this is a new format of revenue for cinema which not available in earlier days... Irrunthu irrunthaal Anbae Sivam mathiri atleast yearly oru movie'yachu vanthu irrukum

[@VR471]

Nalla karuthu mattume irundha adhu epdi nalla padam aagum? It will only be a good lecture. Adhu cinema illaye. Oru movie oda basic requirement is a decent screenplay that is able to entertain us and/or make us really think about something. Our film makers think the audience is stupid and thus, lecture us for hours through heavy dialogues. Ultimately, movie ends up being preachy and boring. I don't mind movies with a social message aana adhu oru nalla padam ah kudukanum. That's where many of our film makers fail. Adhuku avanga kudukra excuse .. "oru kozhandhaiku marundhu kudukrapo honey la mix panni kudukra madhri dhan naanga edukra movies"... adhuku Mysskin romba simple ah oru badhil solli irupaaru.. "andha kozhandha eppovo valarndhu aal aaytaan nga.. neenga dhan innum avana kozhandhaya nenaikreenga. Avan valarndhutaan eppovo" 😂 This was in a Neeya Naana show with directors.