Pakistani Ex Muslim Abdullah Gondal

Pakistani ex-Muslim Abdullah Gondal's story of leaving Islam, how his family reacted, what he believes now, death threats from Muslims, and a personal loss.
Follow him on FB here: bit.ly/2vhGZ0j
💁🏻 Become a member now: / @abdullahsameervideos
👉 IMPORTANT: SUBSCRIBE TO MY NEW CHANNEL HERE: bit.ly/friendlyexmuslim 👈
► My blog: friendlyexmuslim.com/
0:00 Introductions
1:30 Abdullah Gondal's background as a devout Muslim in Pakistan. How meaningful was Islam for Abdullah Gondal?
5:31 How did Abdullah ended up being a hardcore Salafi? Did he ever doubt the teachings of Islam?
9:00 Parallels between the two Abdullahs' journeys as Muslims.
10:58 How was Abdullah Gondal's life affected by being a Muslim in Pakistan? Abdullah Gondal's anecdote as the head prefect at school.
15:05 How coming to Canada changed Abdullah Gondal's life and led him to leave Islam. Researching Islamic teachings in a bid to answer questions from friends and co-workers.
21:08 Can Abdullah Gondal go back to Pakistan as an apostate? Pakistan's Section 295 C and very low standards for blasphemy laws.
23:48 How did Abdullah Gondal come out as an apostate? What was his family's reaction like to this news? Genies and the evil eye.
29:30 Abdullah Sameer's anecdote about a Christian co-worker who told his wife about his doubts about religion.
31:16 Why is it women convert to Islam when the religious teachings are so biased against them? - The power of misinformation and indoctrination.
37:10 Did Gondal have to go through an exorcism? Abdullah Gondal's family folktale about their grandfather who managed to control two female genies.
38:58 Practices by various religions to cast out the devil and demons/genies - What is the explanation for such kinds of experiences? Human cognitive biases.
41:58 How is Gondal's family dynamic now?
43:25 What is Gondal's position now regarding the existence of a God and religion? Agnostic atheism. Why is it God never provided a proper channel/ medium for communication instead of using the most fallible method?
49:05 The problem of eternal punishment - can this be reconciled with the most merciful nature attributed to God? The opinion in some Islamic schools of thought that hell is a finite punishment.
51:01 Some of the torture in the Islamic version of hell. The fear of hell and how it keeps some Muslims from apostatizing. Does Gondal still have fear of hell?
53:32 Did Gondal try to reach out to his family after becoming an apostate? Gondal's experiences talking to his mother and father. Muslims using the defense that scientific facts keep getting amended but the Quran never changes.
1:01:52 Shout out to the Masked Arab for highlighting that Muslims only started criticizing the idea of the sun setting in a murky pond way later.
1:04:34 How did the community in Canada and in Pakistan respond when Gondal came out as an ex-Muslim?
1:06:36 Are the two Abdullahs' wives still Muslims?
1:07:52 Quran variants. Was the Quran perfectly preserved? Missing verses. The Qira'at and how they disprove the notion that the Quran is the perfectly preserved word of Allah.
1:17:30 Disagreements between the companions. Muslims scholars skew their teachings to ensure that Muslims do not end up doubting Islam instead of teaching all the facts regarding the religion.
1:22:50 Would Gondal ever consider coming back to Islam?
1:25:08 Abdullah Gondal's view on politics in Islam and religious tourism.
1:28:17 Is Islam to blame for the lack of progress in Muslim majority countries?
1:33:30 How people thrive in liberal democracies rather than Islamic systems. Quran 9/29 - Religious mandated intolerance.
1:39:20 Abdullah's views on Muhammad now that he is an apostate. Did Gondal always knew about Muhammad's atrocious acts or did he learn them after leaving Islam? How did he compartmentalize all of this?
1:43:22 How to counter the Muslim's argument that Muhammad's wives were not virgins except for Ayesha.
1:54:35 Quran on what Allah thought of non-believers.
2:02:18 Abdullah's social media handles.
2:03:00 Would Abdullah Sameer consider going back to Islam or going to other religions?
2:05:20 What does Abdullah Gondal think of alcohol and bacon?
2:06:25 What is Gondal's motivation to speak out against harmful Islamic teachings?
2:10:12 Final remarks

[@Beherenow121]

He is in Canada but still concerned about his safety. Shows to what extent extremists can go to hurt Ex muslims

[@gabrielmoses8505]

yep because so many fanatical muslim around the world.

[@mxxmauuhan3597]

Be here now Ex-Muslims are under greater threat from Leftists Liberals. Left/Liberals call anybody and everybody intolerant who criticizes Islam. Infact these people act as smokescreen for Islamists.

[@simeonyisrayiyl1501]

Canada is the ONLY WESTERN COUNTRY which pass law in favor to Muslim community and extremism, if a group of Muslim attack you, better to run into U.S, otherwise, the cop would help the Muslim to find a good reason to arrest you the one who got attack, so that they can preach the Canadian special strength called"diversity".

[@devilapostate4575]

@Embraer Bombardier man nailed it

[@talk2kumar]

what is Gandal in you name? it is not muslim name. there is a place in India in name of Gandal. it seems that you have some relation with Gandal, Gujrat, India. I am sure your origin is from old gandal state of British India. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gondal,_India

[@hatessmug]

I have one advice to abdullah. Don't ever agree to meet an anonymous person claiming to be an ex-muslim,no matter how persuasive the person is. You are very outspoken and many muslims won't like that. Let the exmuslim community grow bigger first, to the point where it is counter-productive for muslims to threaten or harm exmuslims.

[@Andersljungberg]

hatessmug Are you aware that ex Muslims are threatened to life. In Europe of relatives or neighbors

[@kanzawan]

Nice comment

[@onepurpleflower8910]

hatessmug 🖕

[@tamashbeen6610]

Totally agree with you. Remember the person who was killed using deceit on Muhammad's orders just because he had written a satirical poem. There are many idiots inspired by that story.

[@toxicmuscularity]

Right Bro

[@bishnuparajuli5498]

Before people think Muslim culture is like beautiful swimming pool, but later they know "It is a Bermuda triangle".

[@hatessmug]

From what I understand pakistan is one of the most nuttiest places, interms of religiosity. After all osama found a safe haven here. I feel bad for apostates, atheists, non-muslims living there.

[@chetan_naik]

Internet is the graveyard of religions.

[@neel1761]

Every religion ????

[@Ragameiste]

@@neel1761 yes

[@Ragameiste]

@OTTO OCTAVIOUS Religion starts with a premise or an assumption which cannot be validated during this lifetime, what follows is a pile of anecdotal evidences mixed with historical, geographic and cultural truths that obfuscate the actual premise. Please start a youtube channel or a discussion group of some sort. I don't have the energies to debate or discuss at an individual level.

[@mark1448]

I have become more firm in my beliefs in Christianity from good youtube channels.

[@bellycurious]

@OTTO OCTAVIOUS, what do you want discuss about the Bible? It's just a fiction book. Nothing that is written there is confirmed by history.

[@prasadbinoy]

All we must say is that these two young men have gathered exceptional courage to analyze, comment and come out of Islam. They should be given enough security and protection in Canada, because there are dangerous people in Canada as well who can do them harm.

[@sureshpanikker2837]

Anq Guiter Indians are not cowards, it is basically the cowardly secularists and leftists who are anti Hindu and anti national who go soft on Islam. It all started with Nehru and Gandhi.

[@sureshpanikker2837]

Anq Guiter read the works of great Indian thinkers who criticized and exposed Islam such as sita ram goel, ram swarup, ect.

[@hugolindum7728]

The solution is not to protect them, the solution is to remove those that would harm them from Canada.

[@ihsanmb]

Lol analyze? In canada? Really. Lol debunking u guys just are just laughing stock. What makes u think u knew much about islam. Islamic contexts (al-Quran, hadith, etc) were intrepreted by ur own point of view and with baseless, wrong assumption of course. U didnt even bother to know what our scholar say and u think u r debunking islam.

[@ihsanmb]

@Satya Raja Thats why we have Ijma' (consensus) and Qiyas (analogical reasoning of al-Quran and al-Hadith) to neutralize this disagreement.

[@wadisanaa]

Not easy to leave the Mafia.

[@jaytee4482]

Zack Smith yes it is you can join in but you can't get out as the others will kill you, usually in those countries where the constitution is based on sharia

[@georgeissac7954]

Zack Smith some thing more than that.

[@jaytee4482]

Zack Smith ROTFLMAO you must have been reading the corrupt version then, if that's what you believe They wish you would disbelieve as they disbelieved so you would be alike. So do not take from among them allies until they emigrate for the cause of Allah. But if they turn away, then seize them and kill them wherever you find them and take not from among them any ally or helper. - Quran 4:89

[@ebrahimomar2056]

wadi gaji Islam is a big Mafia

[@mark1448]

The mafia came from Sicily which was ruled by Muslims for many years. I'm sure there was heavy influence of Islam upon mafia formation.

[@sashakta]

I am sure ....muslim will say ...he was not a proper muslim or never a muslim....

[@jaycherney5621]

Sashakta Singh There is a good chance the "alt right" might say the similair he's not ex.

[@aslamnawaz1857]

He is a Ahmadi qadyani but not muslim just as Jain and Hindu are not same... ....

[@jaycherney5621]

aslam nawaz And it begins.

[@sashakta]

aslam nawaz there we go....

[@sashakta]

aslam nawaz but u only have 1 quran......

[@fahdchoudry7763]

Very proud of you. But please be careful as there are a lot of extremists out there. Brave man

[@sorry6726]

As more and more people are listening to the critics of islam The end of islam is inevitable.

[@himdude9637]

Aslam Khan Islam ka one God dhong aur jahiliyat hai. Bahut hi simple soch walon k liye hai. Jo ki question na kare. Question Aur logic par bilkul khada nahi utarta. Aur Sanatan dharma ka ekeswarvad authentic question aur logic par har yug kaal time me khada utra hai. Arab ya Europe ka one God toh copy hai simple hai chhota hai aur Arab Europe k jahiliyat k daur me banaya gaya tha. Waha k bilkul hi murkh aur barbar janta k liye. Mai koi master nahi hu Sanatan dharma ka but mai in mazhab wale kisi bhi maulana ya padri ko 30 minute me nirutar kar dunga. Kyuki quran hadis me koi logic nahi blind faith wali Baat Hai. Jabki Sanatan dharma granth har vishya par vistar se charcha hai. Sirf ek maha granth Mahabharat hi ek lakh se zayada shlok hai. Isliye samajhdar ko jab pata chal jata hai ki jo doyam darze ki copy hum Bhartiya Muslims ya Christians follow karte hain wo toh hamare apne desh me lakhon salon se maujud hai par hame us se alag kar diya gaya kisi conspiracy ki wajah se. Toh kyu na hamara apna bahut hi uche darze ekeswarvad apnaya jaye aur desh duniya me maan samman paya jaye. Dusre desh dusre culture ka one God ek allah ka concept jo kachha pakka hai usko apna kar mazak bane, bezzati aur Maar kaat wali zindgi mili. Yahi soch samjh kar alim aur padri fir se Sanatan dharma me aa jate hai. Jab unko koi yah sach batane wala rasta dikha dete hain. Islam internet ka information age nahi jhel payega. Ab satya ko chhipaya nahi ja sakta. Internet ki wajah se Islam ka ant ho jayega.

[@sorry6726]

him Dude 3 sir wale brahma ne duniya banai . To brahma ko kisne banaya .shiv ko ganesh ka sir katne ke baad pata laga ki wo uska ladka hai. Aur tum shiv ke ling ko poojte ho . Snatan dharam me to door door tak logic ki kami hai. Lekin tolerance aur coexistence ke 10/10 no.

[@himdude9637]

Aslam Khan itni kahani batane k Baad bhi tu hathi ki punch pakad kar puchh raha hai sanp kyu pakda diya. Pehle ye pata hai ki Hindu parampra me 1400 kitab hai. Koi ek nahi. Tu bas ek puran ki kahani sun kar sawal puchh liya. Agar English padh sakta hai to ye padh. Fir sawal karega toh intelligent sawal hoga I would appreciate if there was awareness in people to call it Sanatan Sanskriti or Vedic Dharma. Sanatan Sanskriti is repository of knowledge with human evolution. This evolved with the time and yug (kaal). 1. The place between Himalaya in north to indu sarovar (Indian ocean) is called Hindu. Himalya Hi and Indu. Makes the word Hindu. Used for geographic demarcation. Hindu kush mountain Hindu river called as Sindhu river all indicated the sanskrit origin of the word. But yes doesn't indicate religion but Geographic. Hindustan is a pure sanskrit origin word. Read the puran. The muslim invaders tried to demean the word Hindu with many bad words to show them down and paint them as bad people. This is how racist jokes are created. 2. Since Dharma evolved and led humans from darkness to light from ignorance to knowledge. "tamso ma jyotirgamaya". There was no other religion to compete So there is no name, no rules for bashing other religion and concept of conversion. You can't bash criticize or compete non existent. 3. This is why got more than 1400 books scriptures on various topics helpful in material and spiritual life and this knowledge evolved with time. 4. Ayurvda, Medicine, Vyakrna, Natyashashtra, state crafts, yagya hawan ritual, philosophy, astrology, Jyotish, poetics, sangita shastra, yoga, Veda,Vedanta, Puran, Mimansa architecture mathematics to name a few. Books are available on every aspect of human brain can imagine in such a detail that only one book Mahabharat contains one lakh shlokas. 5. In short Dharma is celebration of the diversity of Human knowledge. Celebrating life and Nature is integral part of Sanatan sanskriti. Hindu celebrate Holi Diwali Chhath Pongal Vaisakhi Sankranti alongside numerous smaller celebration round the year. 6. We as a layman only know about Dharma as a blind man knows about elephant after holding the tail of the elephant. 7. Most of us are only able to know what we see on daily basis like nature and creation worship. And on the basis of this we criticize and appreciate dharma. But Dharma criticize none. Dharma don't give scope for criticism but enlightenment and seeking truth . 8. There is so much more to know. Since I am born in a Dharma followers family. Therefore I celebrate the diversity of human thoughts with ease. Dose not mean i know everything. But once you will know Dharma out of the set criteria of Abrahamic religion for Dharma. You will find nothing to criticize like a blind man holding an elephant tail and saying why he is made to hold a snake. Instead of criticism You will question and seek answers. 9. For example when you see a survivor on discovery eating dead animal poo and pee either you appreciate or criticize this. But no one can deny that this human will survive the odd. And Dharma have a complete set of philosophy and practicing sect called aghori. However a few. To make sure that the human will survive the extreme. Human will not die out because of the certain dogmas made by the so called civilized society or religion. Dharma supports all accommodates all. 10. Religion ends at heaven and hell only but the Dharma gives to strive even beyond this. That's Moksha complete liberation. Gives emphasis on seeking, knowing your self deep within and finding your own path. This is the reason from Sanatan dharma lots of ism like Jain, Buddha, Sikh, vaishnava Shaiva, Atheism, came out without any conflict or blood shed. Can you imagine the same with Abrahmic religion? 11. If someone adopts Sanatan dharma way of life. He automatically fits into the either Varna Vyavstha Brahman, Kshatriya, Vaishya, Shudra according to their profession or Ashram Vyavstha Brahmacharya Grihasth Vanprasth and Sanyas. Together its called Varnashram Vyavstha for the benefit of the society. I can enlighten you on this vedic Varnashram vayvstha. Mail me Varna division start from us. Our head is our brahma to control our shoulders are our kshatriya to protect us our stomach is our vysya to feed us and our foot are our shudra to serve us. Another term division of profession. Which exists all over the world in different forms. And this is most scientific division of profession to avoid conflict in society. This Varna can be achieved by your Karma. To fit into Ashram one has nothing to do. Fits in naturally and can stay in any of the phase as long as he wants. Now it depends on us that we respect equally to our teacher and our toilet cleaner. Which Dharma clearly says respect each and every thing. This is why worship for all not only to teachers. So if you respect your teacher and toilet cleaner equally you are a great Dharmik person. Now where you see fault in this varna system. Lots of Rishi were not born in cast Brahman but respected worshipped. Cast seems a tribal identity with all the evils of Ego and depends totally an individual local social environment no support from Dharma 12. Sanatan Dharma allow an individual to seek truth, follow a path or make his her own path to reach the goal of 'Brahma" the energy and consciousness of the Universe. The feeling of अहं ब्रह्मास्मी, I am the consciousness makes one enlighten and तत् त्वमसी, so are you makes you a Guru. This is the reason encouraged many enlightened soul to find and make their own path. Thus Jainism, Buddhism, Sikhism, sant parampra like Kabir, Ravidas etc were born without any conflict. Dharma allowed them to propagate and flourish 13. Comparing Dharma with one book one prophet religion is not a good idea. Can only increase ignorance. Because books of mazhab are small simple and for that for the followers of that particular mazhab only. So better study the world's oldest surviving civilization based on Dharma with universal application, yourself. अहं बर्हमासमी l तत त्वं असी. सर्वे जना:सुखिनो भवन्तु. सर्वे सन्तु निराम्या:l वसुधैव कुटुम्बकम l

[@mohithraslana3838]

all dogmatic religions will inevitably die a slow death...because change is the only thing that survives

[@steviejongh3265]

but let it happen soon!

[@calevy7099]

These guys are awesome. And what a stark reminder of the grandeur of free thought. Protect Canada and her values!

[@wahdat-al-wujud]

Great Interview Abdullah!

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

+Farhan Qureshi hey Farhan we should do another panel discussion sometime 😊

[@wahdat-al-wujud]

For sure Abdullah, for sure

[@Hineni2362]

Brother Farhan, are you related to brother Nabeel Qureshi who just passed away?

[@talvindersingh3143]

Farhan Qureshi brother farhan I know and feel your a man of truth and justice. And I know you no about most religions and there ideology. However bro why don't you talk about the persecution my mazbi Sikh brother and sisters go through. The jatt high caste low caste system is mind numbing speak up my fellow brother in humanity . and expose jattism also known as sikhism. And by the way I love the gurus but us so called low caste mazbi Sikhs are leaving this demonic deranged devilish shite en mass . anyway bro ✌ peace and luv to you

[@eternityisreal1978]

​@@talvindersingh3143Any Sikh who treats another Sikh appallingly because of caste is not a Sikh. Guru Nanak exterminated the caste system. Sikhism is about compassion and treating other human being with dignity. Find good Sikhs and ignore these silly Godless Sikhs who are clueless. Do not blame the religion for the demonic people. It, along with Christianity does not preach anything dirty, questionable.

[@abulmaarri849]

This is great Abdullah and Abdul!! Special kudos to Abdul!

[@mdarifuzzaman8073]

Abul Ma'arri Give Abdul PR in Canada which he is looking for😅

[@cagedbird8673]

This is gonna be my story when I leave Pakistan and come out as an ex-Muslim

[@hammadisntreal]

be careful with posting info like this on the internet please

[@anarchistonsunsetdrive7813]

Please be careful. The blasphemy law there is a call to kill.

[@faza4023]

Just believe in Lord Jesus, don't worry

[@sista363]

Go to the west please. I wanna leave too

[@travelleryu]

Leave ASAP!

[@truthseeker000000]

Why would 'God' torture humans so horribly? It's because 'God' is a creation of man and only men will device incredible sadistic ways of punishing and torturing other men that 'fall out of line' in a community or society or nation - depending on how supertitous or illiteral or fearful the tribes were at that time. Remember, these Abrahamic religions developed in semi-arid and arid lands of the Mid-East where most oridinary people were illiteral. Try starting Christianity or Islam in 2017 with exactly the same detailed story line and a 'revealed', 'divine' in Niger, South Sudan or Yemen and let's see just how laughable Jesus or Abraham or Moses or Muhammed will seem to us in the digital age. It is a thousand times harder to start a cult or religion in 2017 because most people around the world have access to knowledge, especially scientific and astronomical data and evidence.

[@healthnexus24]

Hey Abdullah.. Salute to you and brave men like you. I would really like your thoughts on how can someone gently and somewhat unknowingly throw few facts to our close family members that can ring few bells in their mind. It's so hard to watch your loved ones spend their time and energy in nonsensical false belief.

[@ALC6501]

Sameer vishnu sharma A dalit hindu A gold digger Fake ex Muslim

[@ironmaidenkhan5890]

@@ALC6501 Yeaah man😂😂😂there many fake filths with moselem ID,s consider8ng us as fools as idiot blinds bhakts are enguaged for filth and cult😎⚔✴🤑

[@abhasingh215]

Nadeem qamar see mahendrapal arya masked arab christian prince videos and start asking them (your family) questions on islam to shake their faith

[@himdude9637]

@@ironmaidenkhan5890 Ab suno batata hu kaam ki baat. Arab turk Mongol ki jisko tum zabardasti ka baap batate ho. Islam unke tal war k jor par aur sufi ke taq qiya se faila na ki Islam ki achhai ki wajah se. Wo tumhare dadi nani ka ha lala bala tkar kar tumhare dada nana ko convert kar tum jaise Mullah yaha paida kar chale gaye apne desh. Arab turk mugal k mard e momin k saath arab se khabatin nhi aayi thi. Haram ki paidaish harami.

[@MasteIsIllmatic]

@@ironmaidenkhan5890 loooooooooool I hope you live long enough to seee the amount of undercover non believing Muslims come out. It’s more than 10% of the Muslim community.

[@sorry6726]

So long videos Abdullah make videos about 10 mins and talk to the main point directly. Keep doing interviews of ex muslims. 👍Gud luck

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

I have short videos too

[@talk2kumar]

why god give last book or 2nd book or 3rd book etc?? god was not perfect, did not know what he gave in 1st book at that time. what was the problem of people who did not receive last books? followed all false book 1st 2nd etc books? if all 1st , 2nd and last books are same then what is the need of last book or 2nd book?what extra exist in all 2nd 3rd and last books comparison to 1st book. last Quran book is more childish compare to previous books.

[@kikianasahmad2328]

Abdullah Gondal seems like such a chilled dude. I wouldn't mind chilling with him and lighting up a J and just talk about life. Cool guy.

[@roothogordie1451]

I found you through Jordan Peterson video tag. Great respect to you men, for your conviction and standing up for your own freedom and freedom of others. Thank you!

[@salmargreen3868]

You are so brave, intelligent and very inspiring. You will inspire so many to use the intellect that Islam claims to promote provided it does not question the foundations of the Islamic faith. Islam should encourage critical challenges. Why are Islamic promoters and 'scholars' on edge when they put in the position. Are they so frightened that people may start questioning or leave in droves. Another thing I've noted time and time again how Islamic promoters or those who feel they are qualified in Islam they ridicule, humiliate and use a childish snigger as you would when you remove a toy from a child and they throw their toys out of pram when a non believer or in particular an ex muslim questions their religion. They blame the west, TV, say it propaganda or say or they're we were never true to their faith in the first place. Leaving any faith is growing. It's a chose decision made by intelligence and much searching at emotional cost. If islam is a religion of peace...then let those who chose to leave or have a different faith and no religion live in peace. We are not coming after you..those who hold that believe we pity you. Abdullah Sameer thank you for being human. Thank you for your blogs.

[@muktarhussain4244]

Salma Rashid nicely said

[@himdude9637]

@@muktarhussain4244 😃👌

[@haniffhaniff5764]

Great discussion boys

[@aabstraction]

Loved this talk, thanks for setting it up!

[@arnnn9715]

This was a great and informational interview Sameer. It was so interesting to hear about Abdul's journey. I gives me great hope to see young people waking up.

[@Samar319]

Refreshing to hear young men from Pakistan can and are able to think for themselves. Mind you he had to come to Canada and interact with the people here to start looking for answers to the question put to him. The answers led him to disturbing facts which he never saw before.

[@zehravesile]

Nope 🤣🤣🤣....he just wanted 2 come 2 canada .....

[@miiiaaaow6923]

Abdullah! Hellooo! Great video - keep it up!!!

[@kokizzu]

i'm here because you made 13 minutes version XD and made me curious about the rest..

[@kokizzu]

related to hell's stuff: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpq8l2l_icyKmM0

[@kokizzu]

also about evil part '__') kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5qTmIOlpt2SmLM

[@uptothetime6348]

I left Islam but haven't yet talk to anyone about it. My lovely entire family are so devoted and i don't know how to convince them that we've e believe is basically not real.

[@happyeverydayeverydayokay3407]

That is so sad for both of you... indeed leaving islam faces difficult consequences. God bless you guys! Hope abdul hannan would meet his family soon.

[@andrewn8364]

What if a women convinces 4 men to accuse an innocent man of rape?

[@theflyingfox8204]

What's your point exactly? A man could do the same.

[@lenar.1691]

The Flying Fox I think he means that the islamic penalty for adultery is bullshit because you need 4 witnesses and if you can find 4 guys who lie for you, you can accuse an innocent person and win easily

[@hugolindum7728]

The woman won’t do that, as she is guilty of fornication, the penalty for which is death.

[@MB-tb6jy]

@@hugolindum7728 A rape victim isn't charged for adultery you liar.

[@whatsinaname2706]

Isma'il Muslim look it up

[@user-sm2yo5dc9h]

As a Buddhist, it so mindblowing for me that Ex-Muslims have to fear Muslims hurting them.

[@Taomeano]

Abdul is awesome.

[@gooner9439]

Barelvism and Deobandism are both subsects under the Hanafi madhab. But they are bitter rivals in South Asia. Barelvis are into veneration of Sufis and saints including graves. They also venerate Muhammad to god like levels they say that he was made with angel light and he is half human half nur. More of a folk Islam u can say based on elements of mysticism. Deobandis nowadays are a lot closer to South Asian Salafis. Deobandi extremists have blown up Sufi and Barelvi shrines in the past because they see them as committing shirk.

[@bigdogstatus83]

I am a Hindu by family but actually an atheist. Luckily for me atheism is widely accepted and even a school of philosophy in Hinduism. My girlfriend is a Muslim. I have slowly turned her atheist and have told her that if we marry and have kids, no way will they be Muslim or even know anything about Islam. It feels so good to slowly have shown her the light and turn her into an atheist. I will probably marry her now and her lineage of Islam in her family will stop since she an only child as well :)

[@lulm8767]

bigdogstatus83 This is exactly why muslims want muslim men to marry non muslim women but never want their muslim daughters to marry non muslim. Islam spreads like aids tbh

[@johnsmith-gr3rr]

bigdogstatus 83 Is your gf's family conservative? You do know that under islamic law you cant marry a muslim girl right? How do you think her family will react if they know that her daughters is marrying a non muslim/athiest?

[@bigdogstatus83]

john smith Her family is open and liberal.

[@lulm8767]

bigdogstatus83 Moderate muslims, good thing they dont live under Sharia or in a devout muslim community, or you all would be in deep shit lol

[@hugolindum7728]

Be careful that your family isn’t killed by her family.

[@dsbdsb6637]

This was a nice Discussion Abdullah, thanks for introducing us to Abdul Hannan.

[@F00ls44]

very interesting information thanks for posting and well come to the club Abdul Hannan

[@zahrajawadsajwani1382]

Can't thank you both courageous men enough for this.

[@anshikarushdie1968]

Thank you to both of you guys, i found similarity between me and you guys. in my country i think islam is not too fundamental (indonesia), so it will be hard to make people realize because they not live their live directly according to quran and hadits, they prefer follow ulama that has processed the quran translation somehow so it can survive at this modern era. it has its own advantage and disanvantage. i think the best way to conquer this ideology to people is to show the positive side of this ideology first (example : zakat), then we show them the negative side. we must get rid this ideology totally with peace and insightful way :)

[@stuarthastie6374]

Anshika Rushdie I travelled through Sumatra Java and Bali in 1979 and very pleasant it was compared to say Pakistan. However 15 years later, a friend lived in Ache and came back with tails of Islamo Fascism. Can you explain ?

[@akshayrathore2882]

is rushdi your family name or you have taken it yourself?

[@ashokathegreat4534]

Isnt there sharia law in Aceh(Indonesia)?

[@valeriavagapova]

Sound gets better @4:54 y'all! I almost gave up on this interview, glad I waited a bit:)

[@wade2bosh]

your best interview!!!!!!!!

[@ziipeak3953]

I enjoyed this chat a lot but how does he not sound like most Pakistanis considering he grew up there

[@hannan4518]

Star Viola went to an English school and have had 4 years to practice in Canada :-)

[@hannan4518]

John Smith it falls flat on its first claim that it was preserved. I briefly demonstrated that in the stream hence it's not the word of God. No need for quraniyoon

[@UtkarshSingh]

John Smith Not really unique. The Hindus say the same about the Vedas, and they were written much before.

[@tomelectronics3215]

+Abdul Hannan deed you shared this video on facebook with your teachers friends and relatives may be they will become open minded and accept you back

[@YoLninYo]

John Smith are you suggesting there are checksums in them there surahs? 😂...

[@leklektan1358]

Two very knowledgeable persons reviewing what is friendly true about the religion .you can learn alot from their discussion.

[@yehiaelyamani6943]

concept of testing man is like testing "unbreakable" glass cup by smashing it several times and when it finally breaks you deem it fake!

[@ctgtraveller866]

May peace and blessings be with you brother Abdullah Sameer 💞💕 🇦🇺🇺🇸💞

[@redpeony]

Wishing you every good fortune Abdullah and Abdul- as is well said, Fortune favours the brave!

[@letechpreneur6767]

Did you just say Islam is ''bad idea'' ?Where's Ben Affleck when we need him?

[@jacobfrye510]

"That's racist"

[@lorenr3276]

BTW it can be the same way with christianity not just islam. Like with me I used to be christian but realized it was sort of a cult. Thankfully my family eventually accepted me and they are no longer christian (for the most part my mom still believes in jesus) So I believe my kids will be raised as non religious but I will teach them about other people's religion and how i used be christian

[@tamashbeen6610]

Gondal is descended originally from Chauhan Rajputs who gave brave resistance to Islam. Maybe Gondal can recover his ancestral faith through his blood line.

[@stuarthastie6374]

Gurjant Singh he has Learned to think. He is beyond your superstition. You can’t recruit him to RSS.

[@stuarthastie6374]

Indian man I spent several years in India. Superstition is around every corner and is highly entertaining, I love the place. It’s a religious Disneyland crossed with Marvel comics. Real fun parties and self hypnosis. You are relying on semantics. I don’t use the word creation except for the works of mankind. Like gods.

[@nurieko]

I started to tear up when he said his mother thought she was lesser than his father. I couldn't imagine my own mom saying that, it would hurt me to the core to think she thought she was of lesser value just because she was born a woman :'c

[@sonojah]

He was tearing up too but collected himself pretty quickly.

[@truesacha4534]

u great thanxxx

[@JolinHard]

Where can we reach him? Does he have youtube?

[@SR-mv2mf]

For a person who only lived in Canada since 2013, he has a very pronounced Canadian-North American accent

[@marinakhan7740]

I find Ghondal attractive!

[@rakkhnaka]

Marina Afridi You are probably from a similar culture that's why.

[@himdude9637]

Marina Abbasi are you a Muslim or Christian

[@aamersuhail123]

U are right , he is Cute n has innocent looks.

[@ALC6501]

All devils are attractive idiot

[@subratachakraborty9630]

Kedar Usman Ibn Ishmaeli brother please read Quran and Hadhish in your Mother toung then you can understand what is write there.

[@juliagardner1383]

interesting discussion

[@truthseeker000000]

Great dialogue guys! Abdul Hannan showed some amazing disparities in the Quran. He has compiled some great examples. Abdullah and Abdul Hannan should link up with Farhan and Introverted for a great, rational and intelligent enlightening conversation.

[@mainman7814]

Love and hugs brother...welcome to light and thinking...the creator shall be proud of you...you used your brain.

[@fi879]

Ok so his fb is no longer active right?

[@tamfat5891]

Bro stay safe where ever you are

[@zehravesile]

Yes cause if dey go back2 Islam ull b de ist one 2 kill dem🤣

[@godless_heathen_]

Deep respect to Abdullah Gondal for having courage to leave his religion with so much in stake. I'm Indonesian and just recently deconverted from Catholicism at 50 yrs of age. However my circumstances were so much easier. I'm single and only have my mother to support financially. When I announced my atheism of course my mother objected but she couldn't really do anything against it. Even with this little resistance I felt uneasy period of time dealing with other family members and friends. So I cannot imagine the struggle Abdullah Gondal had to deal with at that time. Respect.

[@thetinker2884]

Good video!

[@amyl2096]

Thanks again for the enlighten discussion. For all those people who wanted to convert into Islam please come to listen to these two brave ex-Muslims, Abdullah Sameer and Abdullah Gondal. Even for those Muslims who didn't bother to read or understand the Quran, their revelations will open your eyes about Islam because lot of the Muslims in the know won't tell you about the dark sides of Prophet Mohammed and Allah.

[@rebaz7256]

You are doing great guys, keep it up

[@emlym3048]

God bless you Abdullah sameer n Abdul Hannan 💝💝💝

[@gyancurious6751]

This boy has a head over his shoulders.

[@evangelinsamantha5777]

❤️❤️❤️

[@md-ec7bz]

Bhai hats off to you... U r brave ...I am not enough brave

[@JolinHard]

Amazing interview.

[@confirmjannati]

Watching for the second time ✌

[@rudypunkass8588]

Strange that Sameer has an Arabic French accent and Abdul has almost no accent at all for someone whos been i Canada for 5 years..

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

It's a sort of Kenyan accent I have

[@jipjohn3875]

Abdul Hannan another hero!!! Keep up the good work, look forward to watching videos and hearing more!!!

[@lorenr3276]

I think a similiar problem is in the US but its not major like europe or canada. A lot of Arab guys work at gas stations or small stores. But nearly all of them are no longer muslim. I think their families are fine with it though because we live in a pretty liberal western country.

[@hhssoo6579]

loren roberts trust me most of them Christian's or Hindus they look like middle Easterns but they not Muslims most Muslims are not rich in the west and no Muslim will sell liquor it's forbidden

[@freelanceopportunist559]

What was being said at 48:00....where it comes to God trusting humans to communicate for him..... As a student of aviation, you're taught that as a pilot, you effectively become part of the aircraft......but the weakest part! So in situations where, for example, you can't see the horizon because you're in cloud, and you lose spatial awareness because of turbulence or whatever, sometimes it can feel like the plane is doing something that its not- like rolling over.....and many people have died because they trusted their instincts and sensations....and didnt simply check their instruments. So, in short, the very people who you trust to fly your planes, are taught that if you have to trust human intelligence with all its technical training and professionalism.......or a simple mechanical device ( i still fly planes with dials😀).......99% of the time, the simple mechanical device will be correct. THATS HOW FALLIBLE WE ARE

[@stuarthastie6374]

Freelance opportunist there was a sound problem at about 47. 50 and echo after 48.00. I also missed a few words. I think you supported his theory nicely. God should have supplied some instruments and a manual written permanently across the sky in appropriate languages.

[@KT-or5lp]

Stay safe !

[@jasonvoorhees8899]

1:12:47 how does it change ?

[@wsktbgs8066]

Studying, questioning & examining the histories very seriously & honestly. You could find the truth. History would always tell the truth for mankind.

[@stuarthastie6374]

Wskitobgs76x Histories are stories full of factoids. Study anthropology and archeology to make sense of the past.

[@bobnordstrom5944]

Rejoicing in Heaven every time a Muslim see's the light .

[@vijgokondkar7628]

Religion is just a thought process,not your LIFE,your SELF.Know it so,and you are free.

[@shivamsangwanarya3311]

Sameer bhai have you heard the name of pandit mahendra pal arya ??

[@sunnysharma-wk3xs]

Keep it up.

[@smilingisntharam4115]

bruh u got no accent. u really fresh fob like that bruH?

[@hannan4518]

Smiling Is nt Haram studied in an English school and had 4 years to get better at it

[@Andersljungberg]

They are not talking about repressing religious minorities in Pakistan and only getting simple jobs with low wages. For it is true that one believes that a Hindu or Christian can not be a ruler of a Muslim

[@nodiahmed1]

Interesting to see a 're-hail', traditional Quran holder at the right side of the interviewer... Good to see that some remnant of cultural Islam in his life... Maybe this could be his connection back to the Truth... My Allah have mercy on him and help him back to guidance and forgive him...

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Lol it's my mom's not mine

[@Tai91827]

Muslims dont even celebrate eid on the same day because they argue on what Mo said 14 centuries ago.

[@zehravesile]

N dats freedom honey.....u are not awakend u are still asleep..... 😂

[@zr8547]

I've found generally good answers for all the points raised..... I think it's generally easy to find answers on these topics...... But it's your exploration.... You have to do it.....

[@gsingh5402]

You are trying to cover the holes in Islam. They are too deep to cover

[@shandanakhan2424]

Is tjis guy abdullah gondsl or abdul hannan?

[@ebrahimomar2056]

Congregation To lift the Islam

[@naimaali6929]

Who so ever ALLAH SWT guides no one can miguide them and he who ALLAH SWT leaves astray their is no one to guide them.

[@stuarthastie6374]

Naima Ali Al Lah is a type of jinn, a malevolent guide who passes in your ear and guides you to piss in your children’s ears.

[@himdude9637]

Tum garib musalman ho kya? Matlab allah k sataye hue, muhaamd k mard e momin k halala balatkar ki paidaish arbi gulam Bharat pakistan Bangladesh k musalma?

[@caragat7620]

I like your topic, don't agree with a lot of your precepts and or concepts toward the end but that's alright we don't have to agree 💯. However you do say "Like" an awful lot which was a bit distracting! Off to a great start though! Keep talking about it!

[@AbulkalamAzad-qz1vv]

audio quality from SAMEER side is very bad

[@talk2kumar]

why god give last book or 2nd book or 3rd book etc?? god was not perfect, did not know what he gave in 1st book at that time. what was the problem of people who did not receive last books? followed all false book 1st 2nd etc books? if all 1st , 2nd and last books are same then what is the need of last book or 2nd book?what extra exist in all 2nd 3rd and last books comparison to 1st book.

[@sneha8732]

So proud of guys. U r doing a Nobel work. The world wud be so good without Islam. The problem is not in the muslims,but in the book nd the religion. If they convert,they can lead a happy nd peaceful life.

[@utubetruthteller]

Religions should be local not global because conditions around the world is different so should be religions. One size doesn't fit all.

[@tamanawilson9265]

I was also looking at his beautiful eyebrows 🧿 he has a classic Desi beauty

[@isaacmintman2413]

Have you heard the case of Hamza bin Walayat? Pakistani humanist who was denied asylum in Britain because he didnt know Plato www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/jan/26/philosophers-urge-rethink-of-pakistani-humanist-hamza-bin-walayat-asylum

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

+Isaac Mintman sad issue

[@stuarthastie6374]

Isaac Mintman it is the norm for the Home Office to reject asylum claims with unsound reasoning. 40% of these refusals are overturned at Judicial Review.

[@Andersljungberg]

Should you put higher demands on a religion than on a political ideology. An ideology is based more on opinions than scientific facts. Even national economists are usually accused of being guided by their views

[@kevinmoloney19]

A co - worker one morning said to me. I was shown you in a past life in a dream last night. You were a military officer. You were wearing this blue hat and it was you. I told him yes that the blue hat was part of my military uniform. What I did not say was my name at that time period. I was married in my uniform. I died in a battle and I know exactly where that occurred. In 1987 I had experiences that taught me many things. An out of body experience. Experience with the light and sound of God. I met a woman. I was shown her past. As a girl, she lived in a house with her grandparents out upon a dirt road. They loved her very much. I was shown that later her husband, a young blonde haired man and young blonde haired niece died in a car accident due to his drinking alcohol. Two coffins were buried upon a grassy hill. One large coffin and one small coffin. She agreed that that which I was shown was indeed true. I told her about her husband standing behind her while she is seated at the dinner table. Do you ever feel him there? Her reply was " yes ". I went further back into her past lives and was shown one of her as a nun. An embodiment for minutes, hours or years be that male or female does not guarantee escape from revolving in and out of the physical embodiments. " Soul " is that which we are. We do not have a soul as we are " soul ". After having the out of body experience I wanted to know of people who knew about this. I was told by a man at a Metaphysical bookstore that Eckankar knows about being out of the body. I traveled to an Eckankar center and borrowed some books. I found that Eckankar taught about the experiences I was having. Past lives, the light and the sound of God and more was in the teachings. ECKANKAR-The Path of Spiritual Freedom.

[@Ash17030]

What about belief in a creator without the use of religion?

[@stuarthastie6374]

Ash Brown what about it ?

[@mgnwill]

The concept of Hell seems a bit pointless to me. Once you’re dead, you cease to have any physical feelings due to your nerve endings no longer existing. Just a thought.

[@amitnair4137]

Very much interested to know what you guys think of your race... is it indian or Arab...?

[@hannan4518]

Amit Nair we both are of Indian ethnicity

[@dyawr]

1:48:00 _"It is the most non-sensical concept I've ever heard."_ (concerning how you can re-marry the person after saying Talaq a 3rd time) It not only bizarre & non-sensical, in a kind of *ridiculous* manner. It is also extremely humiliating & most likely traumatising, for the woman that has to go through that... And afterwards how will the husband look at her, without remembering she was with another man for a night - especially if they're quite conservative, religious people? Chances are, this whole thing *damages* their marriage/relationship even further...

[@Broken-Nation]

I'm an pakistani Christian and I know first hand that how hard it is to be a part of any religion oustside of Islam in pakistan or any other Muslim country. I have respect for these courageous men who left the cult of Islam and took a tremendous hate from their people and foremost their families. They are at more risk than anyone.... Jesus Christ words are the truth. Mathew 16: 24-26 "Then said Jesus unto his disciples, If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me"

[@humairjahangir8749]

dear... thanks to mention your truth about what you feels about islam...now i will beware of every christian around me...in any corner...because i also belongs to pakistan, karachi...thanks for informing me what you think about islam and muslims...!! with whom you live...i can also use severe words about christianity especially about the concept of trinity...but i will not...because i work in the college running under the catholic board..and there we all live and work with peace..we share our thoughts our beliefs in meetings to discuss ...but now...you have changed my mind...now i will be careful about any christian...because you have shown the view of hate for the muslims ...

[@home4life505]

humair jahangir - in all seriousness...why do Muslims claim Christianity is polytheistic when the koran distinquishes between monotheistic faiths - People of the Book (Jews, Christians, etc) and other polytheistic faiths? Muslims men are allowed to marry Christian women, but not polytheistic followers. You have to ask yourself why do you have to lie in order to prove islam is the true religion?

[@humairjahangir8749]

muslim men can marry to any women on a bet that she should convert to islam....and accept islam by heart...if she do so...then man can marry her..same condition applied to women also...she can marry to any men if he converts to islam..no matter whether he or she belongs to polytheistic faits. because the fundamental condition to be a muslim is to follow only one God...and islam clearly mention in the last chapter and last paragraph which is considered to be the conclusion of whole book ..that God has no son or daughter.. and .because the GOD's son or daughter itself will be a God...which will violate the basic element of islam...if any one follow that faith then he or she is allowed to marry..

[@humairjahangir8749]

well....it seems like that you got anger on some thing and split your frustration over beloved prophet...you don't follow islam...its okay...its up to you which religion you follow or not...but dear...all my comments above did not blame any religion on something and i didn't used harsh words against any beliefs..so why you....? your comment of hate...has nothing to do with my comment..neither i was talking to you...if you want to give any comments then...you are welcome to do so for this video....!!! :-D

[@Broken-Nation]

humair jahangir not frustration of any nature my muslim friend, its the facts that muslims dont like .. get at me with substance, not emotions. God Bless!

[@liberator275]

great story of using one's own intellect to discover what is wrong with the practice of the prophet.