Partition, Pakistan & Populism | Syed Muzammil’s Hard Hitting Talk in Lahore

[@prateekpatra5410]

Hi i am from India, the points you are putting are so true, i think you are a gift to people of Pakistan, hope that you are successful my friend in educating ppl of Pakistan through your videos. God bless you. ❤🙏

[@7x.Indian777]

*Muslims Hindu's Ke Friend Nahi Ho Skte* *From India* 🔥🥂☠️🌪️🇮🇳👑💪🏻

[@kalidasswaminathan4341]

​@@7x.Indian777tumhari hi baat ho rahi he.

[@7x.Indian777]

@@kalidasswaminathan4341 *Sath Me Tere Jaise Pro Paxtani Ki Bhi Kar Raha Hun* 🗿

[@rakeshmaskare5050]

fancy words =/= intellectual.

[@unknown.145gvgugbj]

@@7x.Indian777 chhod de bhai ye sb koi acchha kaam kar rha appreciate kr

[@arshadabueshaal]

ہم لیڈر سے محبت کریں گے تو اس کا احتساب نہیں کر سکتے یہی ہمارے زوال کی اصل وجہ ہے

[@shoaibshahzad9165]

Wo qabar prasati sikhye Islami touch Dy Deen farosh ho be,Deen ho tab bi yeh paltu Jo banye Hain wo nahi bolty 🎉

[@arshadabueshaal]

@@shoaibshahzad9165 ٹیریان کے بارے خاموش اور عدت کے دوران بدکاریوں کو نکاح کہہ کر اسکا دفاع کرتے ہیں

[@asifmahmood8245]

السلام علیکم اپ کا تجزیہ حقیقت پر مبنی اور حقائق کے عین مطابق ہوتا ہے جو کسی وی لاگر کے پاس اتنی انفارمیشن نہیں ہوتی جتنی اپ کے پاس مصدقہ انفارمیشن ہوتی ہے زبردست❤

[@28aasif]

What an extremely informative talk... Loved it Muzammil! Respect from India ❤

[@FkuIlu]

Which religion take 30% land of India in 1947?

[@ShikharMasseyMusic]

i am from india and after listening to him i can easily say that pakistan is a mine of diamonds

[@RakshitTathev]

Love u bhai. Your are one of few brighting star of our Indian Sub Continent.❤❤

[@7x.Indian777]

*Tu Yaha Love You BHAI, Bol Raha Hai Aur Isi Comment Box Me Muslims Hindu's Ko Bura Bol Rahe Hai, 😂🤣😂🤣 Tum Jaison Ki Jarurat Hai* 🤣🤣🤣

[@RehanHanif-tn8un]

Muzammil ny video ki quality ki bjay , video mn ki baat bht interesting hy 👍🏻

[@Mr.Jupiter-l9g]

Respect for muzammil sir❤❤

[@rmnair90]

A philosopher for today's South Asia. 👏👏👏

[@Medhatullah]

Who wants Muzammil and BookBuddy to have a podcast?

[@m.abdullah9010]

Me

[@SubhanSiddiqui-jb9il]

I want to faisal warriach and syed muzammil podcast

[@Tariq-ox8tc]

​@@SubhanSiddiqui-jb9ilI want them Three ❤

[@lovereachable]

Me

[@BOOKSHELF007]

muzamil and qaisar raja

[@rajeshagnihotri3845]

Best guy to tell the truth on all subjects. BRAVO Mr. SYED. 👍😊💐

[@arvindersingh107]

Well said

[@basitawan5959]

Ethnic Background of Generals in 1971 Indo-Pakistani War. During the 1971 Indo-Pakistani War, the number of Generals in Pakistan Army was 14. One was Commander-in-Chief of Pakistan Army and 13 were Lt Generals. Four were posted at the GHQ/CMLA HQ, Four were corps commanders. Four were governors under the martial law. One at the CENTO HQ in Ankara, Turkey. Out of 14 Pakistan Army Generals in 1971 Indo-Pakistani War; 1. General Yahya Khan (Pathan) was the Commander-in-Chief, 2. Lt General Abdul Hamid Khan (Punjabi) was the deputy C-in-C, 3. Lt Gen S.G.M.M. Peerzada (Muhajir) was the PSO CMLA HQ in Rawalpindi, 4. Lt Gen Gul Hassan Khan (Pathan) was the Chief of General Staff (CGS), 5. Lt Gen Khawaja Wasiuddin (Muhajir) was the Master-General of Ordnance (MGO). 6. Army's Eastern Command was under Lt Gen A.A.K. Niazi (Pathan). 7. 1 Corps was under Lt Gen Irshad Ahmad Khan (Punjabi). 8. II Corps was under Lt Gen Tikka Khan (Punjabi). 9. IV Corps was under Lt Gen Bahadur Sher (Pathan). 10. Governor Punjab was Lt Gen Attiqur Rahman (Punjabi). 11 Governor Sindh was Lt Gen Rakhman Gul (Pathan). 12. Governor NWFP was Lt Gen K.M. Azhar (Muhajir). 13. Governor Balochistan was Lt Gen Riaz Hussain (Muhajir). 14. Lt Gen Muhammad Shariff (Punjabi was sent as Permanent Representative to the CENTO HQ in Turkey. The GHQ posts of QMG and AG was under the rank of Major-Generals. Hamood-ur-Rehaman Commission recommended Public Trial of the following Officers: (1) General Yahya Khan (Pathan), Former Commander-in-chief. (2) General Abdul Hamid Khan (Punjabi) ex Chief of Staff to the President. (3) Lt. Gen. S.G.M.M. Pirzada (Muhajir), ex PSO to the President. (4) Lt. Gen. Gul Hasan (Pathan) ex Chief of General Staff. (5) Maj. Gen. Ghulam Umar (Muhajir), ex Second-in -Command of NSC. (6) Maj Gen A O Mitha (Muhajir), ex Deputy Corps Commander. (7) Lt. Gen. Irshad Ahmad Khan (Punjabi), ex Commander 1 Corps. (8) Maj Gen Abid Zahid (Muhajir), ex GOC 15 Div. (9) Maj. Gen B.M. Mustafa (Muhajir), ex GOC 18 Div. The Commission recommended Court Martial of the following officers: (1) Lt Gen A.A.K. Niazi (Pathan), ex Commander, Eastern Command. (2) Maj Gen Mohammad Jamshed (Muhajir), ex-GOC 36 (ad hoc) Division. (3) Maj Gen M. Rahim Khan (Pathan), ex-GOC 39 (ad hoc) Division. (4) Brig. G.M. Baqir Siddiqui (Muhajir), ex COS, Eastern Command, Dacca. (5) Brig Mohammad Hayat (Punjabi), ex Comd. 107 bde. (9 Div). (6) Brig. Mohammad Aslam Niazi (Pathan), ex Comd 53 Bde (39 Ad hoc Div). The Commission recommended Departmental Action against the following officers: (1) Brig. S.A. Ansari (Muhajir), ex-Comd, 23 Bde. (2) Brig. Manzoor Ahmad (Punjabi), ex-Comd 57 Bde 9 Div. (3) Brig. Abdul Qadir Khan (Punjabi), ex-Comd, 93 Bde. 36 Div. The Commission observed that the suitability of the following officers for continued retention in military service would not be justified: (1) Maj Gen M.H. Ansari (Muhajir), GOC 9 Div. (2) Maj Gen Qazi Abdul Majid (Muhajir), GOC 14 Div. (3) Maj Gen Nazar Hussain Shah (Punjabi), GOC 16 Div. (4) Maj Gen Rao Farman Ali (Muhajir), ex Adviser to the Governor of East Pakistan. (5) Plus 19 brigadiers.

[@DDDIQ100]

Very interesting history 👍🏽

[@asadaziz6429]

Appriciate your efforts to this report. The peoples only blame Punjabies for the fall of defeat in East Pakistan only and totally spare the peoples responsible of other nations. The Gernals are responsible for Win or Defeat of war the force under the command of Gernals are not responsible or blame the force under the command of Gernals.

[@segfault4568]

But saaar Punjabi Army saaar.

[@rizacramson9416]

Thank you for such a detail input

[@tughral]

What is your point in writing all this non sense.

[@Free1thinker]

Support Atheist movement of pakistan 🇵🇰🇵🇰 ❤❤❤

[@hassanmurad5]

Name one other person who can talk like this with such clarity in Pakistan. Maza aa gaya muzammil bhai 👏

[@TaimurRahim100]

Great job!

[@MuhammadAbdulRab]

mine was first view bro love from pak

[@furqanalikhan6986]

Thank you Muzammil bhai.

[@basitawan5959]

Up Cp lucknow elite wants a seperate country because they were afraid of democracy otherwise not a single punjabi,sindhi, baloch, pastun were interested to divide india.

[@rabiashafi6500]

Voice is good , like always

[@GajendraParmar-dj6rq]

Partition - Pakistan - Populism Allahtala - Army - America

[@2010anilshukla]

Pakistan was created in the name of religion and will have to live with a religious state. It was not a partition of India but a partition of Punjab and Bengal on the vote of Muslims of UP and Bihar who stayed back because the British wanted such a state as a buffer against communist Soviet Union.

[@asadaziz6429]

Appriciate your histricial knowledge and understanding the histricial events with it's back ground. Also admire your courage and intellectual honesty. Thanks.

[@SheksgemWhepdo]

@@asadaziz6429 😂

[@afrazamjad1644]

Afghanistan was already available as a Buffer zone

[@arifsaleem5467]

With the exception of the buffer state part, I agree with the rest of your conclusion.

[@Politican_1]

Muzzamil, sir. Best thing about your work is that you avoid tough Academic Jargons even a laymen can understand. Love from India Love from JNU

[@vishalpundir31]

jnu भारत से बाहर है के ?

[@QuantumNinja1.9]

​@@vishalpundir31 nahi delhi me h. Tujhe kaun bola bahar h

[@bhimjikaklotar5315]

"J"@हील जिहादी "N"@लायक "U"त्पादन केन्र्द

[@GajendraParmar-dj6rq]

JNA ka J(@)N(2)

[@shoaibashraf3636]

There's a difference between Populism and idealism. Unfortunately, there's no idealism in so called populists of Pakistan

[@zainabkhaann]

Muzammil please try to do more podcasts (i know you have a busy schedule). That is the format where you are at your best.

[@muhammadakifnaseer7834]

Excellent talk

[@shivrajtyagi8037]

As always honest and historic discussion well served dear Syed Muzammil Shah ji. Keep it up. Dr Tyagi, Boston, USA.

[@bhimjikaklotar5315]

also lisn.. * apka akhabar * vijay sardana insight * the jaipur dialogue * the alternate media * rang de basanti-rajiv choudhary * har har shambhu-abhilipsa panda n jeetu sharma * aktk * bhardwaj brother * arvind sahara * arif aajakia * tag tv....thanks...vande mataram...jai shree ram

[@nickysinha8818]

Ufff its a delight to listen to you sir !❤

[@par_annoyed6880]

Muzammil ..u r doin a great job..keep doing that bro...love from delhi

[@bradmayer1639]

Education elevates our understanding of a phenomena, not how we approach reality or how we feel about things ---- very cool Syed.

[@SumonShil-h8h]

Muzammil Bhai ham Indian We are wait for your videos❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@saqibiqbal4427]

happy to see you here

[@bradmayer1639]

Syed Muzammil is a force of reason, I would love to see him lead Pakistan from extremism to a progressive nation. Support SM for Prime Minister of Pakistan.

[@AniRafi-y2]

I love intellectuals. So you know sir❤

[@ranaahmad2781]

You may agree or disagree with this man but you cannot ignore him. Glad to see him presenting alternate point of view.

[@rajsinghji-84]

What was the point he made? All I heard was blah, blah, blah and some more of that.

[@alichaudhry345]

He was describing the current state of affairs ​@@rajsinghji-84

[@arifsaleem5467]

​@@rajsinghji-84 If that's what you heard then you are at the wrong place.

[@rajsinghji-84]

@ And the current state of affairs is….?

[@rajsinghji-84]

@ I am in India. So his words mean different in different countries? Okay.

[@NahidaNahian]

Dear Fakistan, if u can, make this man as your President. For your own good. I'm just a well wisher from Bangladesh.🇧🇩

[@tughral]

We have nodpubttgat you are a well wisher of Pakistan and Pakistanis. Bro,you need to understand that we are not independent.

[@o.o.o.o.s.s.s.s.]

Well done. It's the need of the hour.

[@fasihakamal-vw5zq]

Good analysis

[@althea_is_smokin_hot]

Sirs,the beginning of india's partition was 1857 when East India British Co finished off Mughal Sultanate in Delhi. Indian muslims could never live in peace under hindu government. Even now after 77years of partition,muslims in india, Pakistan,and bangladesh nurture extreme enmity against hindus. The conclusion is partition did not bring peace to entire muslim population of indian subcontinent. All 3 muslim congregations have been living in fear of hindus. And there does not seem to be a way out of this paradoxical situation of muslims of indian subcontinent.

[@7x.Indian777]

By the way this fear felt good* 😜 😂🤣😂🤣🗿🔥🥂☠️🌪️🇮🇳👑

[@FkuIlu]

MUSLIMS know combine Pakistan Indian and Benglesh 65 crore 50% MUSLIMS in BRITHS INDIA 1947 20% Muslims in 1858 10% MUSLIMS in 1757 5% MUSLIMS in 1657 2.5%

[@aghayounis4765]

I'm like two journalists in Pakistan who are out of bonding, both of them you ❤, you are the courage of facts in the new generation in pakistan.... If they

[@NikhilBhagat-r5t]

Voice is very low

[@saachibatieen3699]

Voice is fine

[@raju1950]

Voice is good

[@anowmel]

Theek hai yaar sunne wala sunne legaa agar sunna hua to

[@muhammadbinriaz1409]

Change your device

[@dendaGulliLapoch]

Kuch bhi

[@supermangap1]

Such an insightful video…..the take on the major issue in Pakistan very well defined. FYI Needed better audio quality, lot of ambience in sound

[@harendrajha3797]

Guys like Muzammil should be in Pakistan politics to bring stability to the country…

[@imtiazdar7787]

*آپ ٹھیک کہہ رھے ہیں اصل قصور وار سیاستداں ہیں*

[@sahilchahal7761]

Invite Ex-Muslim Sahil on your show

[@anarchicdrifter]

very relevant for the entire sub-continent

[@quranaasmanifakekitabhai5734]

اگر ختنہ 4 سینٹی میٹر کے بجائے 4 انچ ہوتا تو پوری دنیا میں امن اور ہم آہنگی ہوتی، کون متفق ہے؟

[@bhimjikaklotar5315]

लाजवाब...😅..

[@FkuIlu]

Best comment

[@Nasriacademy]

Some KZbinrs use background music. You need not to do so because, your voice is enough to attract audiences.❤

[@AsifBugti454]

I think he should be a politician because it is high time to grow the collective intellect of masses. If not this then what else can be called nation building and ultimate empowerment of people.

[@rakeshmaskare5050]

The thing is populism is true democracy. The term was coined to discredit the candidate that you(who coined it) don't like and have won.

[@sharmayogendra17]

Mr Muzzamil, you're a highly talented person bur wrong side by country. You are welcome to come to India.

[@mppolo]

Bohob khob sir, keep going

[@adilmukhtiar1096]

Proud of you sir ❤

[@Chatrugurjar878]

Love you sir🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤🎉🎉

[@Jaat____ff_gaming]

pak 1 st person nice ur grea8

[@shammikumar7800]

First view mujammil Bhai

[@ajesha15s40]

The biggest populist was prophet Mohammed. All your arguments suits the best to him if you think about it. And yes.. Isliye to jo asamani book diya tya uspe sochna ya critical thinking mana hai. Think about it.

[@mritunjaysharma573]

Masha Allah! I support a united Bharat. You are looking very good brother in this suit. So handsome! ❤

[@MeenaDevi-fz6uz]

सैय्यद मुजम्मिल जैसे लोग को पाकिस्तान में कम भारत मे ज्यादा सुना जाता है। ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤सैय्यद मुजम्मिल

[@nikhildeshmukh6221]

Bro sharma ho to andhbhkt to apke state me hi sabse jada he

[@FkuIlu]

You are a fool India already have 24 crore Jihadi

[@I6eeikahdu38]

Sir always eager to listen your public discussions from India🇮🇳

[@naveenyadav8839]

Good video

[@indosanct-rn9sr]

soon headlines in pak will be "youtuber syed muzammil goes missing presumably dead because of hurting jehadi sentiments"

[@tughral]

Very bright chances are

[@sewaligoswami781]

Too good 👍

[@eliotanderson6554]

❤ from kerala

[@vipulsardana]

Punjab was divided.. That's right....but we Junoobi Punjabis or Multanis have lost their identity because of their Dialect. They were moved to south portion of East Punjab which is now a new province, Haryana.

[@vipulsardana]

@syedmuzammilofficial7067 People are going to lose their Ethical identity because of the Partition.

[@asadsiddiqui1999]

🙌

[@aliwaheed906]

"Education elevates our understanding of phenomenon but not how we approach reality and what we feel about things." this statement was an eye opener for me.

[@KashifHussain-ir4mi]

❤❤❤❤

[@Ahmad-qy8ze]

love from Lahore

[@arizkhan1756]

مزمل دی گریٹ مین

[@007bingo]

Ek video bengladesh pe

[@DDDIQ100]

Compliments brother . Increasing the pressure on the peddle and the gas and the rubber is now hitting hot on the road 💪🏿💪🏿

[@Studentwork7617]

Hi Muzamil I'm from burewala district Vehari big fan of you

[@Studentwork7617]

@MAbdulRehman-is8hz same Here

[@mdsharifkhan5283]

Modest man

[@masia-in]

Listening to you sometimes feels like i am listening to a renaissance period European scholar.

[@rizacramson9416]

I played the video for muzamil knowing he is an unduly theoratical intellectual but realising who is the anchor "what a combination"!!!! An excessively biased hypocrite with a پڑھا لکھا باریک وارداتی Too much for me to handle.

[@jordanbalid2584]

I was riding around Malabar hills i don't see Jinnahs house anywhere

[@sudiptokumar986]

your views on "Freedom At Midnight" a sony liv original. heeramandi par bahut baat hui ish par v ek episode toh hona hi chaiye

[@AkaHansofficial]

Agree 💯

[@BilalKhan-vm5gz]

Good work

[@zohaibayyaz]

beautiful

[@Liam-yo5ex]

PHD wale agar India mae BJP ko support karte hain to sahi karte hain , hame Zakir Naik , Owaisi ya kanhaiya lal ke qatilo ko support karne wali congress nahi chahiye , Pseudo secularism ne Kashmir valley se hinduo ka safaya karwa diya , please listen to Syed Rizwan Ahmed , he is also Syed and ine of the best person in India to talk on these topics

[@karanDhawan]

I wish we had such a visionary speaker for India. We have a few KZbinrs but not really impressed with them. I disagree with you on Bengali comment because they are literally killing minorities in Bangladesh.

[@irfangowani8396]

He is pointing to Imran Khan although this is exactly happening nowadays from other parties.

[@hamzasaeed2944]

and never mentions GHQ, wonder why

[@asmatullah291]

Welldon bro

[@irfangowani8396]

He always talks about project Imran. He never talks about project Zia.

[@dheerajchoudhary9833]

He does...you obviously haven't seen his other videos

[@Wildfirecatty]

He had..... just watch some previous episode

[@JackJack007-x3t]

​@@dheerajchoudhary9833He never talk about his Abu (Army) 😂 that harsh truth. Jis din Bola us din gya ya 😅

[@JackJack007-x3t]

​@@WildfirecattyHe never, he even never criticise Asim munir today. 😅

[@Zee-wz7wc]

He just did the his previous video

[@SajidKamal-z7d]

Muzammil bhai ap plz koi instruction open karyn me umeed krta hun jo log ap sa knowledge hasil kryngy un ko or un ki waja sa bht sa logo ko faida hoga.

[@ravindramorey5433]

I truly respect muzzamils intellect but not his understanding. Majority is never a truth but will and understanding of the objective of the populace and leader is not the leader if he do not understand it.

[@santoshprakashsenwar3759]

Jay Hind sar main Santosh Prakash Jaat Jodhpur se Rajasthan aapka video bahut like karta hun sar aap ek Anmol Ratan hai kash aap Hindustan mein hote

[@sharoonriaz3788]

❤

[@madinasultanvlog6484]

Pro indian mindset.this man.

[@7x.Indian777]

*Like Dhruv* 😜😂😂😂

[@sanjayausekar3213]

Bhai yeh wisdom kisko de rahe ho ? Jo maante hain ke earth flat hain aur Sun ghum raha hain ? Rationale, logic, thinking, questioning is explicitly prohibited in Islam. Bhai you are breaking your head against a jihadi wall.

[@alamgirkhan6878]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Imranist2024]

Do you know psychology of leftist and secular people like Syed muzmmil.what is mindset behind leftist criticism and obsession with PTI ? Actually they are highly obsessed with European enlightenment and the revolt of Seculars in Europe against the church and decline of the catholic church Monopoly in Europe. They want to apply the same process in Pakistan but the issue is Pakistani public is not listening to them they have no public popularity,they cannot pull the public like PTI rallies and power shows. In Pakistan only PTI have revolutionary potential like European enlightenment and french revolution so that is why they people are envied for PTI.

[@shammikumar7800]

Punjab gurdaspur India

[@nareshkatyal8677]

Aap ka jawab nahi. From India.

[@imranm7628]

Is there an ideal or nearly ideal model that Mr. Muzammil can point to in the history of civilizations? Please draw a conclusion from your analysis by providing examples that nations like Pakistan can emulate.

[@ahmad4436]

Incoming indian saying I m form india , i m from india i m from india Like who cares😂😂

[@basitawan5959]

The partition of India in 1947 was one of the most traumatic events in the history of Punjab and its people. The partition led to the creation of two separate nations, India and Pakistan, and split Punjab into East Punjab (in India) and West Punjab (in Pakistan). This division had profound and devastating consequences for Punjabis on both sides of the new border.

[@piyushdas079]

Ab ye ekdum naya cheez bol diya tune 😅

[@mash6943]

You are forgetting Bangal

[@FkuIlu]

It is more bad for India because we still have 16% muslims

[@SubhanSiddiqui-jb9il]

Sir Kiya AP hamare comments parhtey Hein?please reply krey

[@RizwanLal-r4i]

75 salon se yahan ak b mukhlis nhi aya he,isliye to mulk siyasi yateem ho chuka he.

[@javeriaakhan]

It has been two months since I started trying to play your videos on KZbin. However, some of them never play, and others take at least a week to load. I have tried loading them multiple times, but the issue persists. I suspect that higher powers might be trying to control this. It breaks my heart. FREEDOM is a joke here.