Democracy vs Dictatorship Debate - Yousuf Nazar on why Pakistan needs a Gov of Experts -

[@abdulwaheed9905]

We strongly condemn the bad Sound quality and not putting Time stamp.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Dono mai say ek fix kardwta hoon mai masla

[@haristahir3472]

@@ThePakistanExperience I love democracy 🤣

[@CinemaCut-n2e]

Democracy 😂😂

[@zaidkhalid3743]

@@ThePakistanExperience awwe!

[@tonlon-en3se]

We as in United Nation?

[@arundhawan8574]

Fun Fact: India has 6X the population but spends 45X on education, on dollar to dollar terms.

[@piyush-_-]

Man, it must be depressing to be a Pakistani. Years on end, having the same conversations, running around in the same circle and having things worse every time is a cumbersome burden to have as a citizen.

[@NYN_000]

Other countries: Work hard to get it! Pakistan: Allah de dega! InshahAllah!

[@dugyan]

Forget about the blasphemy bs in Pakistan a Pakistani-origin lawmaker recently advocated on the floor of the House of Commons that Britain should have blasphemy laws. Imran Khan was trying to do the same internationally. Saari duniya ke thekedar bane hue hain aur tule hue hain ki poora world Pakistan ban jaye. Pakistanis should first of all learn to live within their aukat, which is minuscule.

[@curiousstrider]

Dude forgot to ensure his microphone is working and still goes ahead with the entire podcast. Thanks to the power cut, the system is reset and all the microphones are working.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

No When the power gets cut the audio file goes missing that’s why we lost the audio

[@UkAla-dz9dz]

@@ThePakistanExperience Do you have a UPS that can handle the power outage with your set up?

[@jugnuokaydais]

South Korea is developing due to US support while Vietnam is developing due to China support, but Pakistan isn't developing despite both supports.

[@Breakfasttime630]

We need to protest in D chowk for this audio

[@AbhayPeshin]

Underrated comment 😂😂

[@ThePakistanExperience]

😂

[@vaibhavrajput6594]

Kisi ek firke ka kehna ki hum hi sahi hain , Bilkul galat hai Kisi ek mazhab ka kehna ki hum hi sahi hain , YEH BHI UTNA HI GALAT HAI 😊

[@Bhaibhavb]

Allah teaches hate in quran Quran 9:73 O Prophet! Struggle against the disbelievers and the hypocrites, and be firm with them. Hell will be their home. What an evil destination! Quran 9:123- O believers! Fight the disbelievers around you and let them find firmness in you. And know that Allah is with those mindful ˹of Him˺. Quran 47:35 -- So do not weaken and call for peace while you are superior; and Allah is with you and will never deprive you of [the reward of] your deeds. Sunan an-Nasa'i 3097 "Whoever dies without having fought or thought of fighting, he dies on one of the branches of hypocrisy." 9:29- Sahih International: Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled.

[@rahulkapur687]

How in hell can a country made on the foundation of hatred ever work. Pakistan is a wreck, a country that is imploding! Thank you Jinnah for the partition 🙏🇮🇳

[@Mikujan]

Best Pakistani expert I heard Agree with everything he said no 2 opinion like democracy, how economy works, religion etc. Best on TPE Finally a right wing economic person

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@muhammadasaad2681]

جب ڈن ہل نہ ملے تو انسان کسان سیگرٹ بھی لیتا ہے آیڈیو نہیں تھی پھر بھی پوری سنی۔۔۔ شہزاد ایک نشہ ہے❤

[@rmnair90]

Countries of East and SE Asia that progressed do not owe their progress to whether their govts were capitalist or communist (or monarchical as in Thailand). They all had strong access to US markets and they devoted their energies towards creating stuff they could sell there - toys, tvs, walkmans, cars, ... In the 50s Pakistan could have done the same. Aumreeka ke yaar the. Par nahin. Looteron ki mindset wale aisa kaise kar sakte the. Ab phir chance hey. US aur West production Cheen sey nikaal rahe hein. Pakistan apne dost cheen se kahe "hamare yahaan factory lagaein. Hamare thru export kariye." Par nahin. Jinka looteron ka DNA hey woh kaise factory mein kaam karenge.

[@TradeRainmaker-xl6wr]

Mashallaha, Alhamdulliaha, Subhanallaha.... Paksitan aise hi, neeche ki taraf, tarraki kare... amen..

[@harishnaidu7593]

Summameen😜😁

[@majwad]

With all due respect to Yousaf Nazar sb, I disagree with most of this points.

[@Mba570]

A perfect clash of idealism and practicalism marvelous moments discussion a round of applause is due ❤❤❤

[@hemantgokhale830]

It sounds like,country and its grassroots were totally neglected for +75 years. Religious and political used uneducated people to develop heaters, War and good life for themselves. ( armchair, foreign citizen asking question why, because of old wounds).

[@SuperYoman100]

The guest doesn't seem to have the ability to listen to other people! Keeps cutting the host off, not allowing him to speak for more than 2-3 seconds.

[@UmerJawed]

I like how your guests with soo opposing views can have a discourse with you

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Manasroychoudhary]

Justice for Bangladeshi Hindus.

[@sajjadhussain9724]

Love the new logo! Some issues with voice. But great podcast! Sain khush raho.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@ThePakistanExperience]

It gets better after 80 minutes

[@uzairullah-4]

80 minutes 😮​@@ThePakistanExperience

[@sajjadhussain9724]

@@ThePakistanExperienceji sain meherbani 🙏

[@alihamza3209]

The content was really good and very engaging. However, I noticed that the voice quality could be improved a bit for an even better experience.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ThePakistanExperience]

We lost the audio for the first 80 minutes

[@prashantjaiswal6451]

U don't have to move forward u need to go back, re look u r history ,u have to accept that u r Indian, An Arab will say i follow Islam but he will say i am Arab

[@umayr2935]

'Shehzad has 20 years old mp3 player hidden beneath the table, and always remembers to press the record button, in case he forgets to check the mics 😂😂 and then patches the missing parts from there'

[@skippper2345]

Tum log nara lagao ...gustakh e rasool ki ek saza...

[@shatnermohanty6678]

Comment section khul gaya , aa jao sab 👋

[@ThePakistanExperience]

😂❤️

[@shatnermohanty6678]

​​@@ThePakistanExperiencebhai , chapters dal do I want to start with Audience questions ( as usual ) 😁

[@HesterDanesworth]

Arey chacha to political system full time China Ka ly k ana chahtey Hain

[@AnujKumar-wj3ju]

Islam 🐫 🕌 main 72 firke hai, kaun kaun se can you name them.

[@HistorywithShahrukh]

1:19:00 Audio Starts from here Thank me later

[@durgeshsingh5220]

Ye mulk bacha lo Nawaz Sharif, Allah ke karam se Nawaz Sharif, maula ke rehem se Nawaz Sharif.... Allah ke karam se.....maula ke rehem se.

[@manojchowdhary4208]

Sir - Pakistan should never worry. Pakistan is a nazriati mulq like Israel, formed during the holy month, and Waahid Islamic nuclear power of the world. Pakistan’s problems are caused by saazish of yahood o hanood o nissara though China is a trusted friend. Pakistan is also a leader of the Muslim ummah and provides security to them all over the world.

[@chaitanyakada1341]

Well said.. they should focus more on Kashmir and forget everything else..

[@anarchicdrifter]

why do you have to troll every video ? don't have anything intelligent to say ? even your trolling is unimaginative & a copy paste job everytime

[@shainpv]

The powers behind its creation meant it to be so.

[@RHRH-RL]

First time I hear the Pakistani speak about resolution to the economic issues in the country

[@CrishnaAnish-tm6wc]

How many times will this guy say "maaf kijiyega".

[@SIKG1995]

57:15 bohot achay, maza aya

[@globalsensemovement1022]

Podcast with Hafiz Saad Hussain Rizvi TLP 🇵🇸

[@Shrimpspiration]

1:30 in this day and age everything is available online. HBL has not been the largest bank in Pakistan for a long time, UBL is. UBL is worth $1.5 billion as per total shares and listed on PSX. HBL is $969 million King Khan is worth 770 million, you need 2 KK to buy UBL, still sad.

[@fahimms]

Wonder why host keep dragging irrelevant discussion and point scoring on PTI... Sounds a bit rigid from host.. hope he learns and stays on the topic without irrelevant jibe on personal political opponents...

[@tapasvibhardwaj]

Great work shehzad .....more power to you❤🎉

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️🙌

[@umangdesai4136]

The boy is losing interest!

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

Democracy or dictatorship it will have one solution to all problems in Pakistan . INSHALLAH

[@vijaysontyal2788]

Time stamp?

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Added

[@UkAla-dz9dz]

@@ThePakistanExperience Kharab kerdi hai aadatein tum nay humari

[@Shrimpspiration]

15:00 State should not be in the business of business. If I own a corporation in Pakistan and make pkr 100 profit. I will pay almost pkr 60 to the government as tax first and then get pkr 40 for myself. If I take that 40 and invest in growth, govt will always be my partner in profit( tax will increase when I make more money) but never in my loss. We know for a fact that govt companies become stagnated, uncompetitive and thus make far less in profit and are mostly in loss. We also know that each corporation in Pakistan can be dictated to produce for the govt in a war scenario. Why is the left so adamant on keeping govt owned entities when the math never maths?

[@ravindra7791]

Yousuf ko sab nazar aata hai...

[@HashimAtif-x9w]

Shehzad I hope that Pakistani should learn something from India its democracy, land reforms,tourism constitution , how's its economy is really growing becoming the world 5th largest economy, and most importantly how minorities live and coexist peacefully in comparison to pakistan

[@malice-towards-one-and-all]

Hoping against hope

[@Loganatha_K7]

Please add subtitles😊

[@marziabatool2425]

Hi Shehzad, I’ve been wanting to learn more about the history of the Indian subcontinent, particularly the partition and the creation of Pakistan. Could you suggest some books on these topics? Would really appreciate your recommendations!

[@tonlon-en3se]

Please seach for Professor Istiaq Ahmed's work..

[@normalhuman6260]

I thought who is this person interrrupting so much but then I saw he is an investment banker. Explained everything. On the question of democracy, he fails to realize that any system would require silent oath of agreeing to the terms of things like mandate etc. Democracy is self correcting even if it is flawed. Till you can have fair elections it would correct itself, no matter what. Even in India, the power of the ruling party was reduced because people were not happy with the performance but chose one over other because of lack of leadership in the opposition. You may need strong leaders to drive massive change but that is only a requirement if heavy changes are needed in a system.

[@kamaalmirani22]

you should've added the question of land reforms

[@SatyamGupta1328]

Sound quality😮😮😢😢

[@muddi900]

The whole Government of Experts debate reveals Mr. Nazar's ignorance. There are departments in OECD nations running on COBOL, a language older than the most African nation states. There are large corporations in Pakistan, top 10 market cap ones, that are using 2 ERPs for the past 10 years because SAP sold them an expensive package 10 years ago, and they are still integrating it. Japanese government just stopped using floppy disks this year. You can't just wave a wand saying "IT AI Hurr Durr ", and things happen. Processes and Systems do not just transform because you just bought computers. The suggestion that anyone can just transform FBR in 3 months is beyond ridiculous. It makes me take the speaker less seriously. It makes me doubt his expertise in any subject.

[@ahaanmisra4892]

Extremely engaging discussion!! I have felt for a long time that the number of people who have a property dealer mentality approach to life is rising unpropotionately across the world (the property dealers in the audience may please forgive me in advance)!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@sonachenab]

Great discussion. Thanks.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ahmadmujtaba6127]

Love the new audio filter 😂

[@azarkamal4477]

A better question would be that do we need a new social contract (a constitution) which reflects the complexity and respects the diversity of our society. The previous constitution was simply imposed upon us by a constituent assembly with an incomplete quorum since more than half of its members had split away due to fall of dhaka. Psychologically our elite and intellectuals are still stuck somewhere in the rhetoric of the Pakistan Movement 🇵🇰 and keep romanticising it as if it resulted in a great leap forward. Quite to the contrary due to partition and the holocaust that ensued we were cast away further in to the abyss and we slipped back in to the medieval age from which the British colonial government dragged us out at an unimaginable cost to all of us. The institution building and modernization measures were all halted as we started to rethink our place in the cosmos. The hell doors were kicked open and scores of its demons came pouring out in to the mainstream of our society where previously they weren't afforded much public space. The challenge seems to be now to somehow remove those encroachments but they seem to be quite well entrenched on the backs of populist sentiment. The only solution now left to save the body politic is a radical surgery to forcibly remove the cancer followed by steady doses of therapy to burn 🔥 the virus which ails the corpus populis. Cold press and panadol will not kill the fever! If we do not have it in us to perform or atleast bear this surgery then we should make solemn preparations for a grand funeral. We have procrastinated for far too long and this needs to end. We have over killed the topics related to reforms which have been long pending without which there will be no windfall of capital investments, industrialization, scientific progress, job creation, tourism etc or even population control. The tribalization of society must stop ✋️ to make way for the acceptance of and adjustment with the contemporary world so that we may finally be able to have a sane and normal life and society.

[@DrVJ-med]

I've heard several people say that Islam rejected the printing press and thus fell back. You have printing presses in Pakistan, I hope.

[@EforrEgo]

Bhai ek hee dil he. Kitne baar lootoge you comedian. Love from Kalyana. Mein membership le liyaa ❤.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@VenkataPradeep24]

Bro the old logo was lit, why did you change?

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I thought naya acha lagay ga

[@rafehhashmi4290]

Man! These discussions should be done as much as possible!! “Benchon ka mulk hai yeh benchon chala rahay hain” Im sorry I don’t know if this was deliberate or if I miss heard it. 😂

[@ThePakistanExperience]

It was. I am glad someone noticed 😂

[@lonereyan849]

1:19:00

[@saadmahmo0d]

There is something wrong with the sound quality.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

It’s fine after 80 minutes

[@ongoingness]

Jahiliyya is alive and well and living in Pakistan

[@NumberWorld]

The Word *ISLAMIC* in the name, has now become too much *ISLAMIC* for the state Pakistan, almost an impediment to road to development But, Gettring rid of it is also, now matter of *Life & Death, Law & Order, falling Government or Possibly Falling State even.* 🤣🤣🤣 *Such an Identity, that is Fatal to itself* 🤣🤣🤣

[@Mba570]

We want yousaf nazar x taimor Rehman on the same podcast plz like if you think so...

[@Vk-sk7nm]

Taimoor Rahman ignorant hai.

[@1503shur]

Every body gave different type of lecture but nobody say how to do that

[@mansatradingchannel]

Kerala se jo doctors and nurses aa rahe hain .. us ke wajah call from Indian govt to embassies in middle east hai .. they force them to not hire from pakistan .. is ka issue talent ka kami nahin hai ..

[@MrCheapwiskey]

Welcome to islamic republic of Pakistan

[@naveenasnani8720]

indias biggest HDFC bank market cap is 169 billion dollars

[@patmclaughlin107]

JP Morgan Chase Bank's market cap is 690 billion dollars.

[@RajPriyankar]

It is american bank not pakistani ​@@patmclaughlin107

[@AbhayPeshin]

​@@patmclaughlin107is this your comeback? Is JP Morgan a Pakistani bank? Youthia ho kya?😅 We indians are also imran supporters, he is our guy in your jail.

[@patmclaughlin107]

@@AbhayPeshin The point is: comparing anything Indian with anything Pakistani makes no sense because of the difference in the size of population, area and economy. Just like it makes no sense comparing Indian companies with US companies.

[@talhakhaliq5195]

Yar audio quality q low hy is video ki ????

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Audio file delete hogayee. It’s fine after 80 minutes

[@abdulmalik5852]

I totally disagree with the English education point. English should be learnt, yes. But the medium of instruction and books should be in the mother tongue, not even in Urdu. This is what Europeans, Japanese, China, South Korea and all other advanced nations do. Do not re-invent the wheel.

[@Sam-kd2dc]

Mother tongue is urdu

[@AbhayPeshin]

True, in India Modi has tried to do the same thing but it has not been super popular. Parents want their children to learn English like their mother tongue and study in English. Most urban educated Indians are trilingual!.

[@AbhayPeshin]

​@@Sam-kd2dccome back to UP then.

[@AmeerHamza-tu7dx]

​@@Sam-kd2dcJAHIL insan pujabio,pakhtoono,sindhio,balocho,Kashmiri Ka kB SE Urdu mother tongue ban Gaya.

[@Hassanelogs]

Everyone is talking about audio. Why your little mind is not able to listen what they are discussing

[@diwakarsingh873]

Bhai sound quality shi nhi hai

[@ThePakistanExperience]

80 minutes Kay baadh theek hay

[@diwakarsingh873]

@@ThePakistanExperience 😂😶

[@Bhaibhavb]

Surah 47:4: 'Smite at their necks when you meet the unbelievers. Jab ye soch ho toh kya hee kr skte hain. Quran 9:5- And when the sacred months have passed, then **** the polytheists wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful.

[@FF-jy7hn]

Thanks!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@aninditochatterjee2144]

Check your side mic sound

[@OyePapaJi]

32:30 exactly

[@yummyboii201]

Came after seeing new logo

[@Mba570]

ایک پوڈکاسٹ ڈاکٹر تیمور رحمان اور یوسف نظر صاحب کی ایکساتھ ہوجاۓ تو قسم سے دھماکے ہوجائینگے اگر شہزاد آپ یہ کرلو تو مزہ آجائے گا

[@mubeenshahid16]

Bilkul sahi baat ha hum samjhtay hum bilkul thek hain

[@Sam-kd2dc]

To kiya problems hein?

[@swapnilm1856]

In future, kindly use the Audio Video setup/settings used in your recent Adolf Hitler video. Dont experiment unnecessarily. Dont mend if it aint broken. And dont listen to experts😊 Thats always better. Keep it up !

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Light chali gayee thee

[@swapnilm1856]

​​​@@ThePakistanExperience Already accepted abt audio. But, my point refers to the future and includes video setup also. Drinks on table and complete mic in a frame are completely unnecessary unless you are advertising on them. Instead, you may zoom in and let the facial expressions be viewed better. ❤

[@dqvelish]

You back 👑

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@NomadsLost]

As much as I agree with Shehzad on 90% issues, I’m sick of him going against Urdu on every opportunity he finds!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Did I say anything wrong though

[@NomadsLost]

@ Urdu is a link language and a lot of words are closer to regional languages, so much easier to learn. Also, it has been around for almost 80 years formally and goes pre-partition as being the language of educated people. It is widely used in media industry in the subcontinent. My colleagues from Bangladesh talk to me in Hindi/urdu (again link language), patients from Iran/afghanistan speak broken Hindi (thanks to Bollywood) In addition, it is not the root cause of major problems of general population. That’s just my opinion. On the other hand, being fluent in English is still limited to rich or well off people. And lastly, if someone follows the podcast or agree with a lot of stuff, I or other viewers can still have their own opinions. I have heard you for last 2 years, and I still don’t agree with you on this point!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Disagreement sir aankhon par but I have no issues with Urdu as a language We don't have a problem with the Urdu language kzbin.info6yN0VYN2Wds?feature=share

[@NomadsLost]

@@ThePakistanExperience I agree with him and I loved that episode. He was much more reasonable than you in tackling this issue. But here (in this point in the podcast) you’re talking about removing Urdu as a language taught in schools and just English should be enough. I disagree with this statement.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I respect your opinion on this but Jami Chandio and my position is the same, if you agree with his position then you agree with mine. Kya Urdu ko as a National Language Pakistan kay oopar impose kiya gaya - Pakistan Lost - #TPE kzbin.info/www/bejne/q4CUdoNoirCBaac

[@autobotftwww]

A very minor thing that somehow always irritates me. Everyone uncritically repeats the assertion that there are 72 or 73 sects in Islam! It's based on a hadith and if you have a faith based adherence to that it's fine but people just quote it as fact; I think without realizing.

[@Omiamthat]

Who’ll bell the Cat

[@Studentwork7617]

This guest have less patience

[@mayankumar1312]

Are yaar ye log rote hi rehte hai. Koi achi khabar dedo bhai ab mujhe khud ko dukh hone laga hai rozz ka R rona sunke. Pls bhai

[@mansatradingchannel]

Let me ask from Yusuf Nazar - why there is only so much negativity in your thinking! Pakistanis have a good work ethic when directed properly. This arbi guy saying Indians have better quality .. grow up .. all nations have good and bad people. Dont be so depressing. People listen to these things and get more depressed.

[@nononsense89]

Please re upload Audio is bad

[@shashankethane]

I thought my headphones are not working properly

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙈

[@RaghbatTV]

good program

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@SJunaidi]

Don’t try to talk Shehzad, today is not your day 😂😂

[@ThePakistanExperience]

😂

[@naveenyadav8839]

Good stream

[@ThePakistanExperience]

😂

[@RohitSharma-oh8qm]

Mic kharab h bhaiya ji😊

[@user-rh5jp2sh4s]

Poor sound quality

[@MuhammadAwais-l8e]

Last hope TLP Saad Hussain Rizvi is King of Politics

[@MediaRepositoryHF]

TLP ki macroeconomic policy kya hai?

[@Studentwork7617]

Ye last option ha to phir tabah ha sab Koch

[@MuhammadAwais-l8e]

@@Studentwork7617 Bro i Can See your Pain

[@MuhammadAwais-l8e]

@@MediaRepositoryHF One Word Quran

[@hampeee3406]

Syria ki upar v video bonaiye janab....

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I don’t know enough about

[@osamawaqarbhatti4012]

dude what is wrong with the audio

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Light chali gayee thee 80 minute Kay baadh theek hay

[@Sam-kd2dc]

Democracy ka kiya achaar dalna hein? Democracy ka achaar, martial law ka saalan howa. Ab badshaht try kare?

[@Salman.Sma.]

Pani wali tanki jesi awaz ari hai but still awesome 😂❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

😂❤️