Peltier with Water Cooling VS Air Cooling, Performance test, Advantages & Disadvantages

[@m74w]

Good job. The result is obvious knowing water has a way bigger thermic energy capacity.

[@LawAbidingCitizen117]

I hope that you don't mind. This is my opinion. The experiment that you did is in favour of the water cooling because: 1. It has more surface area on the radiator. 2. It has two fans.

[@donnanorth7324]

Try this. Chill water in an aluminum tank with a couple of peltiers. Pump chilled water through an evaporator. Blow air across the evaporator with a fan and make chilled air. You'll have a 12v air chiller, mini A/C.

[@pidgevr8689]

hey! im working on a split unit water cooler thats works kinda like this! (the peltier is outside, with anti-freeze based liquid coming into an indoor radiator)

[@TravelTours-p5f]

doesn't work

[@timurkhasanov2572]

​@@TravelTours-p5f why doesn't?

[@DRAINTVofficial]

Too much loose of energy cooling the water in tubes. Tried it

[@AkashSingh-km9iw]

Good idea but using aluminum water in air cooler can be toxic for health. It may lead to too much aluminum toxicity in the person inhaling. An alternative would be to keep a fully sealed Stainless steel box inside a air cooler water cavity, and pump the cool water inside that box through water pumping attached onto the water block fixed to the peltier coolside, and let the SS box cool down rest of the water inside the air cooler

[@jec_ecart]

Excellent experiment. What's the temperature of hot sides?

[@davidteichman3102]

Thank you so much for how through you were, I'm having trouble with the same exact experiment and it helps me to compare slight system differences and outside environmental variables. :) keep posting on any project

[@carlyoukilleditbeats]

This is exactly what I was looking for

[@countmorbid3187]

No, it is not. This is BS. Look up the capacity of a TEC and what happens when it cannot dissipate the heat.

[@carlyoukilleditbeats]

@@countmorbid3187 oof so whats a good alternative? I still haven't built this though i have all the components

[@countmorbid3187]

@@carlyoukilleditbeats Depends on the purpose. But with a 10-15% efficiency there's not much use for them apart from a simple little car fridge. Around 2000 I used a TEC with water cooling to OC a Celeron 300A to 450. That was epic. But not possible that way anymore as when the TEC can't handle the heat it starts to act like in insulator.

[@manniejavilla466]

this is nice....how much current does water cooled and fan cooled syatem draws?which is more efficient between the two?thanks

[@szymon2243]

The hot side radiator in the air cooling system is poorly chosen because it has too few fins compared to the water cooling system. Moreover, the water cooling radiator itself is larger and has two fans, so the modules are cooled more effectively.

[@1empyre1life]

What about using the water cooled Peltier with the lines connected to some copper pipes under your bathroom floor tiles. Have a heated floor and cool off your water!

[@healerwicas1627]

Hi can u give me the link of water cooling peltier? i need to order for thesis purpose

[@MrEagleeye58]

FOr water cooling you can try CAR GREEN COOLANT, I think better cooling . Car use water long ago. change to green coolant and results could be very shockingly good

[@neobreaker91]

No! That will eat through the tubing. There's a big reason they don't use antifreeze for computer cooling

[@Stealthsilent1337]

Water has a higher heat exchange rate and heat capacity than a water mixture.

[@Bharatbhisham]

Nice experiment.. 👌 Do you have data of temperature of water at the starting of experiment and after around 1 hour/ end of experiment (how much time)? And also total electrical energy consumed?

[@omari3059]

Do you have a link to the radiator and the peltier number please?

[@sedtoi]

which thermo panel used ? what is the serial number ? TEC1- ???

[@jeremiahbenton7907]

Use copper pin heatsinks for over 60% better thermal conductivity with super high airflow fans

[@vision3231]

tower fan for cpu should work much better. total differnece will be around 3-5 degree.

[@nemem02]

where you can get that water pump?

[@cevikertan4030]

Thank you very much ❤❤❤❤ very beatiful make video

[@leonardsmalls2758]

Thank you for your work and your information. Great job😊

[@juizel8008]

you can convey heat to distance outside of room by pipe

[@rsmolkin]

Hi, I'm trying to do the opposite, load a cooler with ice and use it to cool off the air in a camping tent, but still with a water pump and and a radiator. I found some other videos, but none have found a way to put a radiator inside of a duct line going from a fan through a cooler...

[@watervase]

This one? kzbin.info/www/bejne/ena1iqaBo9F-sKM

[@Ravikalavidh1259]

Can we reduce the time of temperature down from 50 minutes to 5 minutes

[@amirkabiri5440]

متوجه نمیشم. در دیتا شیت اختلاف دما هفتاد درجه است. در صورتی ک اختلاف دما کشما نشان دادید بیشتر از هشتاد درجه است

[@cmg955]

Felicitaciones y gracias. Que diametro tienen las mangueras por favor?

[@elkrakengamer507yt9]

Cuantos peltier uso en el de agua?

[@abbu8779]

But air cooling needs big and large heatsink with high power fan

[@Erwinerfolg]

싸이피아 유툽 채널도 있었네요 ㅎㅎ 맨날 쇼핑몰만 이용하다가 알고리즘덕에 보고 구독하고 갑니다 ㅎㅎ

[@pctrashtalk2069]

You could use the heat to pre-heat the home hot water tank and save some energy heating the water.

[@73charaka]

LoL

[@thejesusjunky]

radiator used to cool the water where was it from

[@hakaipurnama4851]

kalau bisa diterjemahkan, test suhu bagian yang panasnya juga. terima kasih

[@ege6347]

Biggest difference is noise insulation. Air coolers are so noisy and inefficient. On the other hand, energy efficiency is also important

[@rekogoolgo5959]

HI I WANT TO CREATE BIG PC CASE WITH PELTIER COOLING JUST LIKE :AIR CONDITIONER BUT FOR PC CASE I WANT TO COOL PC CASE AND PROCESSOR AND GPU AND SSD AND RAM AND ALL INSIDE WITH A LOT OF CHIPSET OF PELTIER. IS MY IDEA POSSIBLE

[@BatanShorts]

Peltier cooling struggles to cool down a constant heat source

[@zakiynabil9504]

Linus LTT had done that test, its better to stick with the conventional one like common water cooling or fins

[@이영우-d9v]

공부 잘했습니다. 감사합니다.

[@aliusta2020]

Thank you . Good job bro

[@자연채-j8v]

수냉식 묘듈 모델좀 알수 있을까요?

[@indianb1918]

Really good video.

[@premchandgupta3965]

Water cooling is best 👌

[@Onceuponajuan]

Amazing content

[@jaimerosedelacruz9744]

You should have used 2 fans for the and bigger fins to move hot air in the other as well.

[@BYOLlife]

두개의 방열판이 열용량이 다른데 실험이 되나 이게?

[@chanm01]

I'm dumb. I watched almost the whole video thinking this was a test of a water-cooled TEC vs an air cooler (rather than an air-cooled TEC) and spent most of that time trying to figure out how the air cooler was making it's box colder than the room. 🤦‍♂

[@secondfirstsecond]

You should change the title: comparing the cooling of 2 different power required.

[@amry_enk]

water is the best

[@adriancabezas4562]

Son distintas celdas Peltier

[@cmg955]

Pareciera que en el whater tiene 2 y en el air tiene 1 verdad? Igual el whater gana siempre

[@felixjaramillocastillo4403]

@@cmg955 Sabras donde se puede adquirir ese enfriamiento

[@Be_ashutosh]

this test is unfair. the radiator of liwuid cooling vs the radiator of air cooling is just not comparable. use a cpu air cooler to compare between air cooled or liquid cooled.

[@bbmlukastudio]

ビール缶をいくつか入れて楽しみましょう🤣

[@64-bit63]

Water cooling doesn't actually exist. Water doesn't cool something it only transports heat.

[@countmorbid3187]

Very energy inefficient and only works on cooling limited volumes with a limited delta T.