Huge Roblox Drama

[@zeparxaphan839]

“Kids should not be chasing pedophiles down in their own game.” That is literally all that needs to said.

[@vb2832]

Wtf i just got to this comment when charlie said that line, stop hiding in my walls WeirdChamp

[@michelletran8242]

Yeah it was hard to watch these kids who are obviously very angry and hurt about predators on their site but have no options to get rid of them other than to resort to yelling at them in game

[@Kennot_B]

@@vb2832 monkaW he's stalking you

[@adolfogarzachaires394]

those kids are like batman they are the hero the game needs, but doesn't deserve they hunt predators with a vpn while playing counter blox

[@jamesmoses4066]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4nIZ6qmeKijnKc

[@Goat-on-a-Stick]

I thought this would be about _DRAMA_ drama in Roblox, like youtube drama. No, this is way different. This is a whole new way to exploit kids and its disgusting.

[@SomeFreakingCactus]

This is Roblox extortion.

[@lillexus5589]

@@SomeFreakingCactus Roblox terrorism at that

[@weevul764]

oh this has been going on for at least a decade. it isn't new.

[@lukesucksballs1069]

Fr I thought denis got caught doing something 💀💀

[@FancyBilly]

bro ur here??? i thought you were just a joel haver fan

[@hornedgamer7909]

"Kid's should not be hunting pedophiles in their own game." well said.

[@0blitzer04]

Read this as he said it.

[@AnimeFan9833]

"Maaaaaaa these kids are harassing me on roblox" "Jared for fucks sake you're 32!"

[@Gerald-of-Riviera]

Imagining a clan of young children making it their sole purpose to destroy any pedophiles within their game is hilarious. Like Kids Next Door except beating the shit out of pedophiles.

[@A-Classic-Blunder]

15:05 well said

[@hurricanetortillla]

@Tom Boy no matter how much you promote your video, its still gonna be shitty

[@matthewbergeron3641]

"Jack is learning unity now" Man, Jack cannot catch a break

[@BobbyJimmy-zm2he]

I feel that

[@connorconnor1631]

bro is probably learning assembly

[@TheRealGuywithoutaMustache]

What's insane is the fact that it's nigh impossible to win lawsuits against such a big company, even if what they're doing is blatantly against the law.

[@forsakenfish]

Ruben Sim moment

[@hazahae]

hi sir jobless

[@dookie9973]

Yea

[@fica1137]

What law are they breaking?

[@anarcanetemplar4807]

I know right?? Roblox has billions (Worth more than Nintendo themselves) and yet they refuse to spend a penny on making their platform fair to practically everybody

[@TrueUnderDawgGaming]

I'll never understand why people defend megacorporations instead of their fellow players. I simply can't comprehend what mindset that is...

[@flainYT]

they think if they side with the ones with power, they will be spared if they do something wrong in the eyes of the people in power. this is extremely flawed logic.

[@harhardave7648]

You'd be surprised.

[@davidbrewer1368]

@@flainYT Nah more like the megacorp is whats giving people pleasure and games to play. They lose sight of the fact that there are other real people and focus in on whats fun or whats the next best thing.

[@Capnsensible80]

@@davidbrewer1368 This. People just care about themselves and their own fun, and without a personal connection they forget that other players are actual people. They also think if it hasn't happened to them yet, that it WON'T happen to them...ever.

[@MaelPlaguecrow6942]

Humans are a hierarchical creature. So it makes sense.

[@Scott...]

“Jack’s learning Unity now” People like to shit on Unity as an engine but at least it doesn’t have a body count.

[@bestgun9994]

Since when? It's literally the single most popular game engine by far.

[@vlusky_husky]

@@bestgun9994 its a good engine but because of the overabundance of cheap rushed games (with possibly some cash grab elements) with the "made with unity" splash screen they put on the lower tier versions unity sort of got a bad rep. not unity's fault, really. but a bad rep nonetheless.

[@growdot1961]

@@vlusky_husky I think they should remove the splash screen on free versions, but also lock console exports behind the paid version.

[@SaadTheGlad]

@@growdot1961 that’s a terrible idea wtf

[@VieneLea]

@@vlusky_husky ...what? That's stupid.

[@crimsonDestroyer]

It's amazing how Charlie goes from joking about the item stock market to genuine horror at the sheer amount of money these actual kids are burning for the sake of having a funny new hat.

[@ChiefJab]

What kids??? The feature is 13+ and requires a premium membership.

[@jqpser181]

@@ChiefJab anyone under 18 is a kid and i know 3 year olds who have spent money on items in the game

[@ChiefJab]

@@jqpser181 13 is old enough to understand the concept of money dude

[@jqpser181]

@@ChiefJab THEYRE NOT ALL 13+ HOW SLOW ARE YOU

[@jqpser181]

@@ChiefJab also is it really? i mean the average 13 year old doesn’t understand how much a few thousands of dollars could help them out hence the reason they hold onto these items and don’t sell

[@giantpinkcat]

I love how Roblox exploits children but everybody acts like it's the children's fault. As if 8-14 year olds know if they're being exploited, or even know what exploitation means.

[@dreamisugly]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/epTRpYKlrp6LqNE

[@LocketInThinePocket]

I've seen a lot of comments already telling those who were exploited "It's your fault, get a contract next time". They have no idea how contracts OR exploitation works. The stupidity is astonishing.

[@manlymemez]

they will learn young

[@danielmunoz7712]

@@manlymemez more like they'll be traumatized young

[@giantpinkcat]

@@manlymemez You want to teach 1st graders about contracts, companies, exploitation and economics? When you're a kid, you have a lot of time to have fun, so why should we give them the harsh truth of reality at such a young age?

[@Donked.]

Glad Charlie is covering this serious problem, it needs more attention

[@kimberlyalexadra3666]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NUDE.YOUNGGIRLS.TODAY/sunnyleone 💜 MAKE ME YOUR S*X SLAVE KZbin: This is fine Someone: Says "help" KZbin: BE GONE History : deleted Phone : yeeted Body :heated Holy water : needed #Чо #эт #делает #на #2 #месте #в #тренде #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #垃圾 #ライブ配信の再編ありがとうです！#この日のライブ配信は、#かならりやばかったですね！１#万人を超える人が見ていたもんね（笑）#やっぱり人参最高！#まさかのカメラ切り忘れでやら1かしたのもドキドキでした！#今後は気を付けないとね5). . !💖🖤❤

[@dreamisugly]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/epTRpYKlrp6LqNE

[@ArMentorLazada]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bquQmJt7qcmjgJo

[@user-rj2jx8sh9q]

Pablo is the only sane person in this responses

[@gowther-_-7766]

@YeaMan can't even spell page correctly, no thanks

[@maksrblx]

I feel terrible for Jack man. He sounded like he was going to cry when he said his parents would have been proud.

[@popelidups9217]

@Logical Onion [First Hatched] why are you stuttering while typing, just type correctly

[@koalasarecool7823]

@@popelidups9217 easier to convey emotion over text that way

[@hamIindigo]

@@koalasarecool7823 it's so cringey

[@vandoz]

@@hamIindigo emotions are cringe - an idiot robot who blew his cover

[@smore-monster]

Time?

[@landonniles2509]

“Jack is learning unity now.” Poor Jack.

[@thelastchannelonyoutube]

I can’t believe that Charlie had to tell someone that letting children mess with thousands of real world dollars on a simulated stock market is a bad idea

[@dumbanimenerd4169]

If you're talking about real cash from their parents or their own wallets, thats on the parent. If you're talking about cash earned from a roblox game its iffy because it is revenue they earned for themselves. This system although not perfect has set some devs up with futures , given them the ability to go to college with the revenue they get. Like bruh.

[@lawrencescales9864]

@@dumbanimenerd4169 yikes

[@curatedmemes9406]

@UCCVUUJVAcPhMVzbOHJezsYA i do think that roblox has to treat their developers more fairly, but it should be the parent's responsibility to watch over what their child does online

[@Cecilia-ky3uw]

@@curatedmemes9406 theres still the question of how each parent treats each child differently

[@taureaurouge3315]

@@lawrencescales9864 saying yikes isn't a valid argument lol

[@catherinesharpe6956]

I am a preschool teacher.. what Charlie said about kids is 1000% true, I entertained them with a scotch tape game once for 2 hours

[@Tethshen]

how does the game work lmao

[@thatoneguy9582]

-tell us the game op-

[@catherinesharpe6956]

@@thatoneguy9582 it was a relay race, you have long piece of scotch tape and fold it in the middle (hamburger, sticky side out) and stick one half to the wall, they blow the dangling half on the wall, if it sticks they reposition the tape to blow on it, tag in a team mate and the first team up the wall wins

[@catherinesharpe6956]

@@thatoneguy9582 the kids innocently named the game "tape worm racing"

[@raccoonchild]

@@catherinesharpe6956 This is actually brilliant.

[@bogypotet4870]

"Kid's should not be hunting pedophiles in their own games" Hell, why doesn't roblox do anything about this.

[@lunarsprinkle6580]

Well roblox isnt doing much about it so the people affected gotta do it for them. God roblox is stupid

[@givemeanameiwillhate9525]

Well roblox is absolutely dogshit, their website is also dogshit, how do you think they'd act

[@neoxpro12]

@@givemeanameiwillhate9525 "sues a youtuber 1 million dollars" despite having billions of money they used their dogshit fame to sue a person but cannot improve moderation

[@givemeanameiwillhate9525]

@@neoxpro12 exactly, they're asking for more when they have 10 times the money Ruben has, they are trying to hide the fact that they are a terrible website, and even if they hadn't gotten any trouble from the "roblox exploits children" bullshit, their moderation is hilariously awful. No recovering from that, unless they managed to pull something out

[@neoxpro12]

@@givemeanameiwillhate9525 they never tried to improve even after the people make games video the only thing they have done is cover everything up which is very unsucessful since the damage have been done the only way to make up for their dogshit decisions is to improve

[@douglasbluebells3117]

Fun Fact: David Baszucki, the CEO of Roblox, was exposed for Tax Evasion (this isn't even a joke)

[@strykebolten4485]

But he has so much money tho

[@avathorman5781]

Did he write down that he payed everything with one coin or dollar or something?

[@Sobxdz]

@@strykebolten4485 he really doesn’t if you actually look in how much Roblox is making they lost about 400 million USD in net worth lost or smth like that

[@strykebolten4485]

@@Sobxdz oof

[@gibbonbasher8171]

He used a legal loophole to avoid paying taxes; technically he didn’t commit tax evasion. It’s just immoral.

[@mirceadraculov6515]

"Kids should not be hunting pedophiles in their own game" When I was in sprinkler Sophomore year of highschool, a bunch of guys got together and jumped one of our old teachers back at the Jr High for sexually harassing one of my buddy's little sisters over social media. He was too scared to tell anyone what happened, so we never got caught. There's some places in America where kids hunt pedophiles offline too.

[@mistahchad220]

Hey, if you're telling the truth, thank you and your friends for teaching that shitstain a lesson. It always brightens my day to hear of vigilante groups taking out the trash, especially considering how often the justice system gives them a slap on the wrist or less.

[@emrahalien2972]

I wish they were wearing costumes so it was even more freaky.

[@mirceadraculov6515]

@@emrahalien2972 Nah, there's a special way to tie a bandana that gives it a brim in the front. When you roll down that brim, it covers both your hair and your face, and with a thin enough bandana you can see straight through the fabric without being seen.

[@emrahalien2972]

@@mirceadraculov6515 Oh I dont care about hiding there face I just thought it would be funny if the SpongeBob gang beat up a pedophile.

[@mirceadraculov6515]

@@emrahalien2972 nah, we just all looked like we were wearing cloth versions of the masks from Assassin's Creed revelations.

[@Chaseroony]

you cant dev ex money earned from selling rare items/limiteds btw, to get real money out of those expensive hats youd need to do it through the black market which is super against tos

[@comicstanz2990]

Im actually surprised that your comment doesnt have a bunch of replies and likes

[@phoenix1782]

@@comicstanz2990 lmao its still 6 hours ago wait for people to come blasting like the FBI on a raid

[@somebodyfaraway]

how does the black market work in roblox? how would that selling process go?

[@ytadams]

@@somebodyfaraway hah the black market of roblox

[@zeno9794]

@@somebodyfaraway people use 3rd party websites to list their limited items for real money, if someone buys it they receive the real money and trade the item to the buyer for an item worth almost nothing (since you cannot complete trades if the other person doesn't offer something)

[@thnead]

As someone who played Roblox for almost my entire childhood up until I was 16 (a year ago), it is scary how many actual adults there are that play games on the site and run the "stock" market now. The game has gotten way more serious than just a silly kids game in a lot of instances. I got involved in some discord servers and games that were full of literal adults who enjoyed acting like children and playing with children. Super weird.

[@vincentawauh6160]

A full grown adult acting like a child is weird

[@mergat2970]

Maybe they want to relive the good old days lmao

[@sartexir9285]

I barely talk in roblox discord servers because I do not like getting involved with younger people

[@whatthehell4644]

@@mergat2970 yes 😂

[@Mizikame]

This is the exact reason why adults need to stay off made explicitly for kids online platforms as Active Users. Too much depravity in the world for that to ever be a good idea

[@greg4587]

Roblox's "by kids for kids" schtick worked fantastically in 2007, where the most you could do is make a cool car and then pretend it actually drove with absolutely no financial incentive. The platform already had a long history of garbage moderation (the admin panel got leaked several times and mass hackings were just the norm) so introducing monetisation was the killing stroke.

[@nova14414]

Sadly true. I played roblox for ALONG time by now, and seen some of the worst of the worst... I still play sometimes for kicks and giggles and to take a walk down memory lane, but other times I to try to protect these kids from creepy fucking perverts! I was playing Dragon Adventures at one point, and during an event someone said they were "giving away" a free dragon. I knew something was up and luckily no one said they wanted it. So I said I would take it, and they said they wanted nudes (obviously they couldn't actually say that but you knew what they ment).... I'm fucking glad I was there and saw them before a kid did... I know how desperate kids get on this game to get some rare item. Also I knew something was up beacuse at that point, you could not trade the dragon they had, you could only buy it through in game auctions or win it from the event itself.

[@9rebel9blood9]

@@nova14414 Ngl i agree but you can't blame roblox for the perverts. They make so many words tagged. Having perverts in a kids game is surprisingly normal. Tik tok is mostly just kids and adults beating to girls dancing 💀. Also icl that story seems kinda fake. A person just asking people to take a free item that's untradeable then randomly asks for nudes?

[@nova14414]

@@9rebel9blood9 if you chose to think that then fine, but unfortunately it's not. There is alot of dumb gullible kids on that game. I see alot fall for everything from trust trades to crosstrading (against their rules beacuse its easy to get scammed), even after being warned. And at the time alot of kids didn't know that it was locked behind very specific requirements to get the dragon (had to get "charms" to increase odds of getting the other two season dragons and then you got the 3rd free) or through buying it for anywhere between 1-2 million coins. I can't count how many kids would run over and ask to offer for mine, and then I had explain why they cant only for them to not understand.

[@TenmasSchoolOfThought]

"by kids for kids"? That's a literal the Onion slogan.

[@-SP.]

I have been saying this for awhile. Another thing is that Roblox is getting kids addicted to gambling at a young age. Everyone rips EA for their loot boxes but no one says anything about Roblox. The biggest game on Roblox is called adopt me, where players open up surprise eggs for pets, which have different rarities. Since Adopt Me brings in a lot of money, many other developers have implemented similar loot box mechanics into their Roblox games. Roblox doesn't care because they are making tons of money from Robux which kids buy to spend on these games.

[@michaellivingston6768]

not to mention that Roblox also got rid of the free currency tix to get more people to spend money on robux. Roblox is extremely scummy

[@chippy82577]

Man, my sisters go crazy over Adopt Me. Luckily we don't have money for then to siphon, but if we did, they absolutely would spend every last dime. They're always talking about how the need Robux for legendary, neon flying unicorns and rats and what not. They have friends in game though who sometimes buys them these things though. It's crazy how addicted they are.

[@codewallette]

I hate them more now

[@colorblockpoprocks6973]

literally, that game got my friend addicted and i had to escape that shit right quick. she spent actual money on that shit, i had to nip my spending at avatar decor lol

[@Cecilia-ky3uw]

@@colorblockpoprocks6973 My dude how is she now

[@patentedfish2358]

Finally! Some exposure for this video. Roblox needs to be held responsible for their actions.

[@jayblueguy9932]

Yeah

[@user-jh8sd5hk1j]

It's finally here kzbin.info/www/bejne/h3XFk6yqfsmmhdk Yes.

[@autisticbluesloth5244]

alot of points in the video dont hold up especially the gambling part which is completley false its not gambling and you need a subscription to access trading

[@burn2436]

Time to be the first real human comment

[@theventedruby]

@@イズミちゃん-k4h what the hell

[@user-qi9qu6xm9l]

I love how Charlie uses his platform to highlight moral issues like this. First the hamsters video and now this one. Refreshing to see a youtuber give a damn about things

[@randomcanadianguy9740]

the hamster video? i think i miss this one

[@PoppyUr]

@@randomcanadianguy9740 It was a Hamster Squid Game where hamsters were forced to go through an obstacle course and fell down a large height without padding underneath. Animal abuse basically

[@randomcanadianguy9740]

@@PoppyUr HOLY FUCKING SHIT! That was real!?! Oh my god

[@currybread5298]

Let me guess, ppl were like OMG SO CUTE !!!!!1. I hate humanity

[@PoppyUr]

@@randomcanadianguy9740 Yeah, it was. The creator tried to cover it up by making a “behind the scenes” video of the hamsters supposedly falling on padding, but it was of a different hamster and the OG video didn’t have padding in any angle.. Messed up what people will do for views

[@barthotymous]

the fact that this game is legal and still relatively thriving after all these years will never cease to amaze me

[@vespirbelmont3131]

"Kids will play anything" is such a true statement. When I was in college for game development we had a few public school open houses. It could be anything from 5 year olds to 17 year olds about to graduate high school. Even my worst games that even I knew were buggy as hell (usually older projects I threw up on computers because why not) and they played it up! My favorite game project I made was a survival based synthwave space shooter that had upgrades as you went along and a huge stats list at the end. This one kid played it for 5 HOURS! He asked my professor and his parents if he could stay there longer to play it. I gave the kid a USB with the game on it and have his highscore saved on a picture somewhere. Which is wholesome but like I played the game less and I had to make it which included playtesting. They'll play anything and sometimes it's a refreshing thing for devs lol

[@tonoto24]

Sounds cool

[@elementallobsterx]

awesome man. im also a dev and getting someone to play your game that long STRAIGHT is a big W

[@textbots2257]

The only flaw about that statement is that other roblox players aren't kids anymore. A portion of the players will choose a roblox game that has cool vfx, building designs, and graphics

[@RadioMan2023]

So like far cry 3 blood dragon?

[@heathernd3532]

what game is that i wanna play

[@smasanomas]

Just watched this video. It's absolutely fucked, and while I respect Roblox as a game, this needs as much attention as possible to force the company to take action and truly speak out

[@necromancer9220]

Why so much bots

[@ayametheepic]

@@イズミちゃん-k4h shut up Gebby

[@DannyGz99]

how do you respect roblox as a game? theyre a pretty scummy company in my eyes.

[@RampagingFlippy030]

...by sueing him and probably getting his family murdered?

[@aaahaaah699]

The 30 minute video in 11 minutes?

[@ErnieC3]

17:23 Imagine Charlie's reaction to Roblox's cut they take on UGC items...

[@LuisPerez-ow7sz]

@MGTHREE Entrepreneur do u like canned burger

[@oblexoblexoblack4804]

@MGTHREE Entrepreneur bro???

[@kornonthekob713]

@MGTHREE Entrepreneur just some kid who wants attention

[@kuszanz6553]

@MGTHREE Entrepreneur you still only have 26 subs just stop

[@bunnygirl893]

@MGTHREE Entrepreneur You really think you're a funny bunny huh

[@matthiasstammler4641]

14:35 "Patriot Prime" is the best desription i heard in a while.

[@malomalovids]

The problem is that nobody really ever takes ROBLOX seriously. Because it's a "LEGO game for kids." This statement is despite ROBLOX's increased spending on campaigns to market it to older teens, and the implementation of a voice chat system that requires photo-ID verification. The fact of the matter is, there are serious development companies who put out either a massive amount of shit or genuinely fun and well-structured games. Some of these CEOs genuinely do make upwards of a million dollars every year. It is not 2006 anymore, ROBLOX has changed. Companies with upwards of 100 staff members are producing content on the platform now. ROBLOX Corporate shut down the official forums and is allowing unregulated communication through third parties, and anyone who gets swept up in it is thrown under the bus if they are somehow mistreated. That being said, ROBLOX already mistreats its developers with the sorry state of the conversion rates between Robux and USD on Developer Exchange. There's not much to hope for, but maybe some affluent altruist will come along and bring up a case against ROBLOX after *their* child is subject to this unregulated bullshit.

[@TwonklerBlue]

Wanna know a fun fact about the Voice Chat and the Chat Filter in general? Somehow it's still all third party despite roblox themselves being a multi billionaire company who can damn well afford this shit on their own.

[@malomalovids]

@@TwonklerBlue it’s for liability purposes. If there’s an info leak, the responsibility falls on the third party company, not on ROBLOX and their precious billions.

[@TwonklerBlue]

@@malomalovids well yes obviously they're already too greedy to risk any of that

[@cact-0793]

Roblox to me is just cool math games, but shitty and money hungry

[@Scotch20]

The thing Charlie's missing is that you aren't allowed to take money out of the roblox nft market, they won't let you transfer unless it's from game dev. You have to do robux money laundering.

[@sabinajoh]

Wait seriously? I thought you just had to have atleast 100k robux?

[@Kjubb]

@@sabinajoh You have to be a developer to trasnfer those 100k robux through Dev Ex

[@serg331]

@@sabinajoh what you have to do is make a group with very expensive clothing, then buy that clothing so the group gets most of that Robux. Then sell the Robux to people by doing a payout when they join it. Roblox goes for half price like this and almost every game dev sells theirs to a site that does this

[@light-pr5yr]

which is why you sell those robux thru blackmarket their rates are usually 5 dollar per 1k robux

[@Kjubb]

@@light-pr5yr yup

[@katawatenshu]

"kids should get payed for their work!" Kids aren't even 'allowed' to work

[@heatsdawn7862]

china be like "wait kids aren't allowed to work?"

[@alexmini123]

Bit ironic, a kid assembled your smart phone.

[@reflection6401]

HeatsDawn China: bro kids get paid?

[@reflection6401]

alexmini123 by unethical means really , 24 cents a day, longer hours than double 7 hour shifts, and terrible environment

[@NetralFN]

@@reflection6401 for real just touch the comment youre gonna reply

[@Anglebert_Humpledink]

"Surely, there's a better way than going into roblox with a traffic cone and a halloween costume to confront patriot prime" Charlie, 2022

[@Anti_lorax14]

the patriot prime part made me chuckle

[@sillyboyethan]

this made me giggle so hard

[@clarksontaylor5202]

this guy is honestly handling the cases lightly. there are monitors that have been caught with thousands of reports of pedophilia abusive reports.

[@ogunclearnoldgaming1790]

Nice pfp best yonko commander

[@Firenamer2]

@Mnet Cepop I know these are just bots, but i'm going to use context from the comment they replied to. Did you give us that video / channel to report it has a Pedophile in it?

[@deadpool-zw4mq]

@@Firenamer2 It is just random Indonesian guy visiting places and doing tourism stuff 💀

[@TheDankEngineer]

@@deadpool-zw4mq Every time someone uses the 💀 emoji my mind substitutes it with a church bell ringing.

[@themalaysiandude3903]

@@TheDankEngineer true 💀

[@streetpunkstreams4730]

Its fucked up man, being sexually harrassed on the internet as a kid was and still is a lot more common than youd expect

[@lomp87]

As an ex habbo user I can’t agree more. Being introduced to mature subjects by anonymous adults avatars online is something I wouldn’t wish on anyone. More needs to be done to stop it

[@sonnydarnell9545]

We need someone with the skills of jim browning to just spend all his time finding these mfs and ruining them, cause sadly most of these people get away with it and will never be caught unless someone with skills and knowledge is actively trying to find them

[@thetreeofclues]

they are fucking animals man. it's so disgusting

[@thegreatrussianbean_]

Mate idk if it's a touchy subject but u sound like ur talking from experience,although if I'm wrong plz correct me

[@spartan11payne]

@@thegreatrussianbean_ its definitely a touchy subject.

[@theredscourge]

Fun Fact: The stock market values Roblox at $60 billion. This is almost as much as Ford Motor Company...for a piece of software and a website...

[@ItzPmacDoh44]

It's a whole ecosystem

[@ruffrack737]

well, if we ignore how its 20 billion lower then ford, yeah i can agree that 60 bil price on the stock market is ridiculous

[@myanriles3185]

because you dont have to build vehicles and sell them to make money. It's literally a money printer

[@5omebody]

fun fact: the stock market values alphabet (which owns google) at $2000 billion. this is almost as much as apple... for (mostly) a website...

[@MsMoonDragoon]

@@5omebody google is a multibillion dollar brand that spands out to websites, search engines, devices, tech comapnys, engineering companys, and navigational tools. try again.

[@theheavyfromteamfortress2723]

Can't imagine the dread you would feel after finding out the price of some of these items then remembering you traded it off.

[@yamashina69420]

Critical: kids are entertained by anything. Also Critical: Watching people slapping other people for money. *This is not hate*

[@tatami2256]

wdym, grown ups slapping around are entertaining

[@AAAAAA-qs1bv]

If you say it like that, then you get entertained by watching some specs of light moving around on a screen.

[@shadyshrimp4169]

Haha its like throwing a rock into the lake, very entertaining.

[@sywkiller4580z]

@@shadyshrimp4169 I get this reference. splash is good

[@JerryG2S]

@@shadyshrimp4169 male audience only !!!

[@FecklessandKekless]

That's actually lawyer BS 101. I read a recent story about some deplorable who became infamous. They got lawyers to reach out to a website hosting information about their crimes and they started with the exact same "you have made many errors in your understanding of our client". So glad that people are starting to see through that kind of shit and avoid being talked into self-censorship for Roblox's sake

[@burstness]

The worst part is that so many people in our community defends the 77% cut that Roblox takes on the developer exchange rate. They say "rObLoX hOsTS tHE sErVerS fOr Us" NO! Many games like Steam, Zepeto, Core, and even other services like KZbin does the same thing, yet they still pay their creators and developers a fair share and they only take less than 50% of their revenue.

[@ozzeryunarei1023]

And they're still worth billions despite being far less exploitative. Not saying they're morally sound though.

[@lracfilib]

Rare to see you here. You are a good person for telling us about new roblox promocodes.

[@lracfilib]

@Acid Drool wat

[@fica1137]

Roblox gives something much more valuable than platforms like Core. The playerbase. Roblox has bigger playerbase than Steam and unlike Steam users, Roblox players will play anything whether that will be rip-off of another game, "simulator" games or even basic obbys. I don't know how would you convince a Steam user to play a shitty Payday 2 or Minecraft rip-off, yet those games are very popular on Roblox

[@fica1137]

Also KZbin and fair share shouldn't be used in the same sentence

[@magentalizard1250]

"Kids will play anything" explains why there are literally thousands of low effort role-playing games. Saw some poor bastard playing a contentless game like he was an AI. Wandering around aimlessly and relentlessly attacking anything that got close while very slowly building a shitty house. I could see how painfully boring it was and yet he kept playing.

[@rivulet5417]

Rain World 😳

[@IPlayDB]

When I attack things while building a shitty house, it's usually in Minecraft. 👽

[@Laureldroid]

Off topic, but yooooo! Rainworld fan?

[@rivulet5417]

@@Laureldroid *Based world

[@blakethesnek1]

As a Roblox Player myself, who frequents RP games you are extremely correct. Even games like Starship Roleplay: HCR-146 Emmissary (For Context, basically a Star Trek inspired Game.) or Neon District (Cyberpunk themed) Are usually swamped by these types of people. I've met a bunch of extremely interesting players with even more interesting characters, and then we have "Jacob/Angel/demon/god of creation/taken/engineer".

[@nawt9529]

that's crazy how Doc is literally double sarah's age and he's still wildin over her

[@raine8015]

yeah what a creep

[@michelletran8242]

ikr like the fact that he tried to play it off as a joke like why would you say "Im gonna fuck you so hard" TO a 6th grade child as a joke ?????????? 🤢🤢

[@nawt9529]

@Airi Aiya can you leave me alone you've been on my last two comments consecutively

[@crispywings9066]

@@nawt9529 it’s a bot

[@fairybebbiesuwu366]

@@nawt9529 its a bot

[@ALTEMERI]

The most baffling thing about this situation is how hands-off ROBLOX is about everything. The only thing they contribute to the site is shitty updates to counter hack clients and exploits, as well as banning players who are a danger to their image and supply of cash. I'll be shocked if ROBLOX even gives a blanket, half-assed response to these issues on their platform.

[@-SP.]

They don't care as long as they are making money. That's why they let games like adopt me get away with their loot box system

[@anoob1271]

They don't really update their anti-cheat, as exploits are already really limited. Also, they did respond, which is shown in this and the original video (around 1:28).

[@klasrem]

yeah, but the moderation isnt even roblox its the youtubers moderating, konekokitten has made videos helping his viewers get unbanned for dumb bans. then you also got the updates that literally have 0 point in them, catalog to avatar shop, library to creator marketplace, and develop to create.

[@dragontrack0588]

@@klasrem Konekokitten is a horrible source of factual information. Most commentary channels are the same, because their whole deal is to express their opinion on a topic, not provide factual info. Channels like PMG are better in the sense that they start as a news/journalist group.

[@TheMartyandy]

@@anoob1271 Their "response" amounted to gathering links from non-affiliated posters and sending them in an email. That's exactly what a half-assed response is.

[@supe4701]

The funny thing is that the second part (this video) still doesn’t even scratch the tip of the Roblox Iceberg. There so much scummy practices that are either caused by Roblox or is a result of their actions that you could easily make a 10+ video series about it.

[@alissaswan5060]

You aren't allowed to link to outside website yet Roblox allows it yet you will get banned if you do but you can use discord

[@supe4701]

@@alissaswan5060 just don’t say it ingame dude, roblox just doesn’t want some spam bot linking a website ingame. That isn’t scummy, it just moderation

[@xsp1160]

F to pay respects to rueben sim

[@Grim-c8n]

19:45 "Jack's learning Unity now." Poor Jack can't catch a break...

[@RaylaEclipse]

Charlie going through the people that owned the red bandana was like that scene from the Incredibles where Mr. Incredible finds out all of the superheroes have been terminated.

[@trill4184]

This has been going on for a long time on Roblox. Not only does Roblox have terrible moderation, sites issues, and issues with manipulating their young developers. One issue that hasn't been brought up is that Roblox offers no kind of anti cheat to the popular games that developers make on top of already taking a large cut of their money. Roblox actively does nothing about the exploiters on their platform. There's even a youtuber with over 132k subscribers called Sakpot, and all he does is teach children how to inject exploits/hacks through an executer. And who knows what these executables contain. And you can't even play popular FPS games on Roblox like bad business or phantom forces without there being an exploiter in every server. Even your squid game video was bombarded with exploiters trying to ruin the stream. Roblox rakes in all the cash and the developers are left without much protection of anything. Developers have even made their own anti cheat, but it still isn't enough.

[@hawkshot1025]

while this is true they did atleast add a feature called filtering enable that doesn't allow people to inject whatever they want into the game including porn and shit which was doable on pretty much every game many years ago. it's mostly just limited the client and server side so you can only really manipulate your own clients view and values of stuff

[@gyrthez246]

Fun fact; Phantom Forces have the best anti cheat on Roblox as they hire(d) developers of popular exploits to help develop the anti cheat detection.

[@trill4184]

@@gyrthez246 I've heard of this time and time again and it almost sounds like sarcasm. Either way the the anti cheat for pf is mediocre at best. I play it frequently and had 6 exploiters in a single game just the other day. If roblox had developed better anti cheat mechanisms then developers wouldn't even have to hire people that make popular exploits. It's absurd that developers had to even go to such lengths to try and prevent them. It just proves how terrible roblox is in implementing an anti cheat. For roblox to be valued in the billions as a company, they need to do more in preventing cheaters exploiting games on their platform.

[@reaperking2121]

They aren't raking in the cash Tho. That why their doing it. Roblox is actually in debt because believe it or not offering a entire game engine for free, running severs, moderating users, not allowing outside adds AND having a player base of small children isnt a good model to earn revenue.

[@casgirlsam]

my partner told me they banned their oldest from playing roblox for all the issues they saw (my partner is a gaming nerd too and the dad is too and also he works in IT so yeah they know what theyre doing). absolutely insane.

[@Ryudante17]

I feel like Charlie thinks Roblox only takes 25%, and then compared it to Steam and thought it wasn't that bad...when they opposite is true. Roblox TAKES 75%, only gives the devs 25%.

[@gage8787]

They take 30%

[@maxdragonsoul5553]

@@gage8787 they take 30% from game revenue, but the rate they pay to exchange robux for usd is nearly 70% less than buying it, hence the 25% devs receive

[@stfu562]

@@gage8787 they take 30% robux and 70% usd

[@TheArbinator]

@Airi Aiya ???

[@darkmatter9643]

@@TheArbinator it’s a bot

[@thomasdavis8722]

20:06 "Jacks learning unity now" well that didn't age well

[@tearlesstrout]

Poor guy can’t catch peace for 5 whole seconds💀 i feel so bad

[@spiralspark8523]

Jack learns that the game development industry is somehow almost as evil as the medical industry

[@codym5352]

This shit is insane. this is why I've always been against microtransactions but I had no idea ROBLOX is THIS terrible

[@user-jh8sd5hk1j]

It's finally here kzbin.info/www/bejne/h3XFk6yqfsmmhdk Yes.

[@jayem8075]

@YeaMan Paige

[@kimberlyalexadra3666]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NUDE.YOUNGGIRLS.TODAY/sunnyleone 💜 MAKE ME YOUR S*X SLAVE KZbin: This is fine Someone: Says "help" KZbin: BE GONE History : deleted Phone : yeeted Body :heated Holy water : needed #Чо #эт #делает #на #2 #месте #в #тренде #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #垃圾 #ライブ配信の再編ありがとうです！#この日のライブ配信は、#かならりやばかったですね！１#万人を超える人が見ていたもんね（笑）#やっぱり人参最高！#まさかのカメラ切り忘れでやら1かしたのもドキドキでした！#今後は気を付けないとね5). . !💖🖤❤

[@heyolorenns]

Omg these fucking bots

[@babaloons4887]

@YeaMan bro been doing this for 5 months and got over 1k comments but youtube does nothing 💀💀

[@justlixian293]

I like how chaelie isnt even mad or making fun of the kids, he's just feeling bad how this money will change someone's future.

[@Xeodez]

@The TacoCat ill check *if i give a fucking shit* which im not.

[@user-mz6wb]

could not have said it better

[@ShozubonGG_2426]

@@Xeodez comments like these are from bots, it's much better to not interact with them.

[@slowsubaruBL]

The crazy thing is that this has been going on for over 10 years. It only just now started coming to light. Imagine how many children have been scammed and ripped off.

[@yesyes-om1po]

It hasn't, and what do you mean by "scammed" and "ripped off"

[@slowsubaruBL]

@@yesyes-om1po Kids working like slaves for their roblox games while a big fraction of what their making (if anything) goes towards roblox, that's only one part of it. There's so many malicious scammers which I know roblox can't control but its really infected the website

[@yesyes-om1po]

@@slowsubaruBL Sure, but that is the cycle, you benefit roblox by making a game that entertains people, and you make robux, the option to cash out robux was an afterthought, you aren't obligated to make the game, you can go without making one, you don't have to cash out.

[@sonnydarnell9545]

@@yesyes-om1po yah but these are also children, and 99% of the time they dont know of the risks before they start making games, and when shit starts happening their little 10 yr brain is thinking these games are all i have and they end up in compromised positions attempting to hold onto it, because they are children who dont know better

[@Chickennuggetfreeslime]

@@sonnydarnell9545 children don’t make Roblox games my guy

[@maddymaeee]

"How did you become so rich?" "Oh un Roblox. When I was nine I bought something that looked cool and now I have two million dollars"

[@sonicbelmont300]

Absolutely unreal that they can release an item, make it limited to increase its rarity and value, and then take 30% of any future transactions on the artificially inflated item being traded amongst children. This is unimaginably scummy and I have no clue how they haven't faced legal action.

[@hotwater0]

Littrally money farming

[@emeraldb1690]

most traders dont sell though, they trade the items, there is no selling for profit

[@JonyGoldz]

@@chunkycheese5247 actually I used to trade a ton, people would snipe limiteds that are being sold for about 25% or more then sell later to make profit. So it was still possible to make profit from selling just crazy hard

[@Person_Dude]

I mean but what can they do at this point remove it then what about all of the money they owe people?

[@Cecilia-ky3uw]

@Jojoforpres how is this the case, honestly libertarians would immediately ask, where is the damn competition and the parents actually doing the decisions, because capitalism relies on actually rational people, not people whod accept whatever shit product they get

[@RakisDerra]

I'm so glad Charlie is making a video on this! Roblox can easily get away with things as they are such a big company. They can easily abuse their power...

[@wellusee688]

Show Time kzbin.info/www/bejne/q5u1qpuFlsythpI A.a

[@ryanbadgett5113]

they still can even if charlie does something lol

[@RakisDerra]

@@ryanbadgett5113 Very true, but at least it gets some recognition from KZbinrs with big platforms. Better than nothing😕

[@ryanbadgett5113]

@@RakisDerra but I see other things wrong snd am too lazy to type and added a different comment

[@jayc7171]

@@ryanbadgett5113 copy/paste

[@superjam5433]

It's pretty depressing how the platform looks squeaky clean but rips off all their players.

[@yes-kd1qf]

Wdym by ripoff?

[@realryleu]

Valve’s justification for the 30% steam cut is their discoverability and their amazing developer tools.

[@lad4411]

Im so happy charlie is talking about this and bringing it to the light. This has been a problem for a long time, But hopefully since more people and parents see this Maybe something will be fixed.

[@someyeeterontheblock2421]

No nothing will happen

[@d_shuffles]

Big maybe.

[@omegaonion7500]

unless tons and tons of people speak out about this, nothing is gonna happen

[@lad4411]

Like I said guys hopefully

[@lockerbuddy2039]

Man, Jack's story is the saddest shit. Guy made money but foolishly spent it cuz he didn't understand it, then got scammed and his work fucking nuked. I came to joke and shit, but fuck, I hope Jack's doing well. In the interview, he sounded okay. Still, god that hurt me and I can't even relate like that.

[@thomasjhun3700]

His story hit close to home for me. I used to sell VIP tshirts for the original build to survive creepers/Nyan cats when I was like 12 and I made almost 400000 robux, but I spent it all on catalog items and I seriously regret investing it or trading it on Devx... I literally resold all my limited items I bought to buy more customization for my character. I was such a naive kid lmao wish someone was there to teach me financial skills back then!

[@thomasjhun3700]

OMG and I also just remembered when Roblox had the robux/tix exchange for some reason in my stupid kid brain I thought trading robux to tix then back to robux gave me MORE robux and I kept doing that, but luckily my dad was in the room and asked what I was doing instead of playing games and he explained to me I was losing robux before I traded a lot more of it. Thank goodness they didn't let you trade all of your currency at once, kids really should not be allowed to manage large amounts of assets at such a young age!!!

[@Miscelanou]

I had an account falsely deleted for something someone else did. He got away with all of the money he made Meanwhile I, someone who didn't do anything breaking the rules, got my account deleted. I tried to get an appeal stating that they could check literally everything in my account and they wouldn't find any money being transferred without me receiving something Edit: forgot to mention; my account got deleted for USD trading but I never did. I paid robux for another players midnight blue sparkletime fedora. I paid 500,000 robux for it via a group t shirt, which was stupid, but I didn't know better and it was a good deal. At the time the fedora was worth around 800k. Edit: kinda did somewhat break a rule but it was a dumb rule. He said he was wanting funds to pay developers for a game and it would save him 30% because tax. I lost my account and all of my items for nothing I did.

[@PashaGamingYT]

They way you should compare the platform’s cuts for marketplace, Steam takes 5% while Roblox takes 30% And for games, Steam takes 30% while Roblox takes 77% THATS INSANE

[@xaddox7524]

The difference is that roblox provides the game engine, server hosting, the website, advertising, a way to discover games, and much more. They got thousands of employees all working on their service. All of that is at least double the cost of what it costs to run steam, which is pretty much only a way to discover games.

[@zhanibek8384]

@@xaddox7524 watch the first video made by People make games (creators of the original). It paints completely different picture to what you just said.

[@piggywink333boyfriend6]

@@xaddox7524 *"Roblox provides the game engine"* there are many free game engines out there argument invalid *"server hosting"* alright this makes sense *"the website"* 1. the website is mostly promoting their own assets 2. websites aren't hard to make and you can find free website creators / hosts *"advertising"* you have to pay even more money to advertise *"a way to discover games"* laughingstock of the community, the game discovery system is shit. all the games that ever get "discovered" are popular games. *"thousands of employees"* tbh all i ever see these guys doing is making roblox china, feel free to prove me wrong

[@mene6465]

yeah Charlie didn't get that, he thought they took 23%, not 77%.

[@yesyes-om1po]

This is not an actual tax, the tax is put in place to make trading and selling of robux more difficult to do, if there was no tax in place you could easily transfer robux to anyone using this system, this whole argument is an oxymoron as it was put in place to make black market trading and account phishing more difficult to do.

[@aubreyskys]

when I was about 10, I was scammed out of about 6 limited items that I had no idea were worth roughly 5k combined. looking up the price of those items today was heartbreaking.

[@yt_phasma]

I played the game when I was younger, and came back once to check everything out, but it's always been bad. I've never been involved with the controversies, but I made the silent observation that the shop system was messed up. I play Fortnite, which I'll let you make fun of all day, but that's not the point. The items in that game are only sold by Fortnite itself, and have a pricing pattern based on rarity and types of items. Roblox, on the other hand, is dominated by items that are priced according to users, not the game itself. The problem here is as it was discussed in the video, many of the users are children who do not have a definite concept of money, prices, and stock.

[@bartekoklol]

wtf do you mean by "dominated by items that are priced according to users, not the game itself"

[@yesyes-om1po]

the game is 15 years old, many have grown up with the site and the people who these stocks and whatnot prices are directed to are to the older players, kids are not appealed to the items since they are typically older, fortnite sells soulless cashgrab "skins" for money, they never have value after that, atleast in roblox you can actually sell them.

[@JackTheripper911]

@Flyin' Steve ah yes, less than bare minimum and we're supposed to be grateful for that. Not not a corporate simp here at all folks.

[@JackTheripper911]

@Flyin' Steve im sorry but a corporation literally doing *less* than the bare minimum isnt even worth acknowledging, regards of how much "better" it looks conpared to another corporation. Everything else said is fine though.

[@yesyes-om1po]

@Flyin' Steve fortnite makes "skins" to sell to kids because they know kids are guilliable and will buy up stupid shit like "skins" for a ridiculous amount of money that has no real value.

[@ARG0T]

As a long time player (dating back to 2010) this depresses me to see how greedy, exploitative and money hungry ROBLOX Corporation has grown. The game itself has improved drastically since then, but with the money earned from how large their game has gotten, they are a shell of what they used to be

[@ExpldgN]

The engine is better but the entire company is terrible now. They aren't good at managing the engine, let alone the entire platform

[@dot558]

Same, I remember when they removed tix. Which is probably when they grew more money hungry

[@burp2019]

it all changed when erik died and shedletsky left

[@burp2019]

@@dot558 i could be semi-rich on roblox if tix hadn't been removed

[@nothappeningmate9402]

Old mid 2010's roblox was the peak

[@Rainjojo]

I miss the days when roblox wasn’t money hungry and gave everyone a way to enjoy the game. Those were the days when tickets were still a thing to buy things out of the shop and the tag system wasn’t down everyone’s ass 24/7. It’s impossible to make a full sentence without something being tagged and banned right after because it’s somehow offensive but doesn’t tell us what is when there was no bad intent 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@ohhkennny766]

I got temp banned for saying "Wazahhh" to my friend while playing PF fucking stupid

[@dez112701]

I had 13k tickets back then and then they removed them I was so mad bruh

[@pristenx4710]

PlayStation is very similar they are so sensitive now.I miss last year when i wasn’t so close to getting perma banned for saying gay or retard.

[@taylxn]

tix removal was an international catastrophe. easily the worst this world has seen

[@powerrangerblue8566]

I got banned for saying beach at like 2013-2015 on a popular hide and seek game on a beach map with me saying "I'm at the beach"

[@Godofpickles]

I have a Classic T-Shirt that says cost "999 M" Robux, and when Tix was around it was "11 M" back from 2009, but due to me not having builders club, but I cant sell it at all

[@roopkd]

@@dinogamer3297someone just straight up stole the red shaggy from my brothers account cuz Roblox got so popular at one point, that there was barely any security to it

[@bda14me]

you can sell it by creating a shirt with an equal price on a different account, the consumer will by the shirt and then you give them the account with said shirt you want to sell.

[@biddinge8898]

I like how he showed a list of players banned in the community despite the fact taht they probably have 70 alts.

[@ArMentorLazada]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bquQmJt7qcmjgJo

[@sansgaster9868]

“You fool. I have 70 alternative accounts!”

[@brickabang]

_-Dr RoboFatNik_

[@user-uo8ny1kj4c]

nah, a good chunk of them quit over a decade ago.

[@Thirzy]

Charlie: "there is a community of people that take action against roblox" Ad: " the kingsman agency silent but brutal"

[@abby_babber]

Hey I just noticed you're using an edited version of my profile picture. I happen to be the person that made it. May I ask where you got it from? Kinda crazy seeing it on someone else's profile considering I made it for myself and haven't really done anything that would warrant it being spread around that easily. Edit: Just as a random tidbit, I made this profile picture for personal reasons and it holds sentimental value for me. I wouldn't expect you to understand what the meaning behind the profile picture is, but I thought I'd just let you know.

[@wrongteous]

@@abby_babber Well actually, it's just a coincidence they look similar, your pfp has straight lines and goes diagonally to the left. OP's pfp goes diagonally to the right and the lines look like they were drawn in Microsoft paint, as they're incredibly uneven and the colours are not as fairly distributed as yours. In conclusion, don't be surprised when you come across someone with a pfp like that because it's really easy to make.

[@abby_babber]

​@@wrongteous I was thinking the same thing after I realized it. Turns out it came from a meme that Thirzy made and it was just a wild coincidence that they used the same color palette. I also considered that they could have edited the original image. Really weird that we both ended up with something so similar though. Edit: May I also add that I made my pfp with a really specific color palette in mind (the colors are directly taken from specific characters). While it's not incredibly unbelievable that someone could have used a similar palette, the fact that the colors are arranged exactly the same way (just in a different direction) and in the same order is absolutely mind boggling.

[@Founderschannel123]

@@abby_babber well i meant alot of people may have the same palette as you or have the same design as you.

[@rabbid3433]

@@abby_babber or you know.. its just a coincidence that should be dropped?

[@mikeymike9926]

As a long time player, just wanna clarify, with these stock items or limiteds is what roblox calls them, there is something called RAP, now when you see the price, thats just the asking price. I can dig up some dirt and say its worth a billion robloons but in reaility its worth nothing, that's where RAP comes in, which is basically the average of all purchases of something. While the hat you showed was worth 600 mil, players who trade on roblox would only see it worth around 500k since thats the RAP. Insane prices on low rap items just means no one wants to sell, so they throw it up for millions cause you know, jsut in case.

[@katietran2989]

like nft’s but also not

[@Firstconfiguration]

This

[@grxntdraws9209]

14:08 chris hansen goes in with a batman roblox skin to save the day

[@Icecakei]

I really respect PMG (the makers of the video) for not caving in to roblox and making another video instead.

[@RampagingFlippy030]

dear god, why is so much spam here.

[@grelkie]

Yeah lmao I'm sure he was hankering for your respect bro

[@kimberlyalexadra3666]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NUDE.YOUNGGIRLS.TODAY/sunnyleone 💜 MAKE ME YOUR S*X SLAVE KZbin: This is fine Someone: Says "help" KZbin: BE GONE History : deleted Phone : yeeted Body :heated Holy water : needed #Чо #эт #делает #на #2 #месте #в #тренде #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #垃圾 #ライブ配信の再編ありがとうです！#この日のライブ配信は、#かならりやばかったですね！１#万人を超える人が見ていたもんね（笑）#やっぱり人参最高！#まさかのカメラ切り忘れでやら1かしたのもドキドキでした！#今後は気を付けないとね5). . !💖🖤❤

[@obscure_alternatives]

@Christofer Pezet's Eye your owner got zero subscribers 💀

[@chimichangas1432]

i'm a roblox game developer myself and I wholeheartedly agree. kids definitely get taken advantage of on the platform and I only get a small sliver of the actual profits the game makes, about 20% of the initial purchase after the 30% tax and the DevEx rates. edit: you can't DevEx robux that has been earned through hat selling or trading. only profits from your game can be converted into real money. edit 2: you also have to be 13+ to apply for DevEx and need to submit tax forms and government identification.

[@wrongteous]

You really think kids need their own government identification or whatever in order to get DevEx? They'll probably take their parent's credit cards and licenses and then start rolling in a couple of pennies because they spent all their robux on a hat.

[@chimichangas1432]

@@wrongteous doesn't work like that, sorry.

[@z0x]

You can still sell Robux without DevEx.

[@chimichangas1432]

@@z0x you are correct, there are illegal robux trading websites and stuff. where money is to be made people will find a way around the system.

[@Space_Australian]

"Doc was 24 and he KNEW that Sarah was 12" Ah shit, here we go again...

[@kate_martinez795]

Sounds like roblox...

[@ChiefJab]

@@kate_martinez795 sounds like every online game ever…..

[@jackcraft7official]

Sarah shouldn't have even been on Discord the min age is 13

[@Msp-bw3zg]

@@jackcraft7official im currently 13 years old but i had discord when i was 10 years old💀

[@mayooo1516]

@@jackcraft7official and the guy shouldnt have been a pedo

[@cursedcat6467]

Roblox ads make it seem like there are high quality games but they do it with avatars that look like their body parts we’re randomly selected

[@N.o.r.m]

There's not a single damn reason why in-game items should cost this much

[@EplaVAL]

those are just resale prices set by players themselves. I could go take any collectible item and sell it for a billion robux but it doesn’t mean the item is worth said price or that anyone will actually buy it for that price.

[@xrefed]

It's probably the resell value set by players

[@BlueRGuy]

**Looks slowly towards Valve**

[@しげお-h4i]

Well when roblox takes 30% off everything theyre prob gonna up the price on their own items to even get anything

[@blehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhl]

@@BlueRGuyThe Golden Frying Pan may actually be cheaper than some Roblox limited items.

[@KozyCL]

Steam: Takes 30% of revenue from developers. Roblox: Takes 75% of revenue from developers. How is that even ok in any sense? I mean Roblox has gambling, NFTs, and they still need 75% of developer revenue? Edit: Just remember you have to buy Robux which is a non-refundable in-game currency in the first place to buy anything in Roblox including things made by developers. So it is technically much higher than 75% of profit they make.

[@dumbanimenerd4169]

Roblox doesn't really have gambling systematically developers implement gambling but its mostly trading. But yeah I get what you mean. I just hate that they refer to it as a childrens game when its really teen / adult based now almost half and half with the amount of children on the platform. And if your argument is under 18, doesn't know what they're getting into , thats on the parents.

[@ihtasham9237]

They handle server hosting, moderation, providing a huge audience, a platform where in game transactions can easily be made. They also have to handle the 30% in app purchases fee for the appstore

[@hugohickman7694]

is more becuse of other shit that thy have

[@brendanrisney2449]

@@dumbanimenerd4169 Let's say 50% of the playerbase is 12 and under, being considered kids, while the rest are above. That means that teens, young adults, adults, and even the elderly, all put together, just come equal to the amount of kids playing. And you don't think it's a children's game?

[@DustySiren]

roblox does not have their own official nfts

[@bluetacticalistaken]

roblox was really all about making games back then, as a builder its upsetting to see roblox have been exploiting kids for years by profiting over their parents money instead of funding it on moderation

[@wizzotizzo]

@vrikxoo more moderation does not equal bad moderation

[@n646n]

no it wasn't lol, it was the same, they just had better PR and hired people to make the company seem more "wholesome".

[@panca2500]

this feels like a movie. corrupt government collecting taxes or something while contributing literally nothing and exploiting workers while crime runs free in a world with no hope

[@gushko]

terrible idea

[@TweakinOnColeslaw]

It's sad; being a game developer with almost no revenue. It's not really the fact that my game is terribly made (although that's really your opinion): the problem is how easily people on the website can judge games/hats/anything that has some value based off of the demand for it. Such as Roblox Stock and Commissions. The large cut that's taken from my game + the lack of many players has only led to almost an non-purchasable amount of money. I have almost lost profit from my game; as it takes money to advertise, market, etc. This is more of a selfish rant, but this is a way to show one of the bad sides about roblox. And sure, some kids may be sexualizing games on roblox with the lack of mental capacity and not thinking of consequences, but this is very rare compared to what I have said above. Thank you for reading this.

[@ruinhem]

I made a game in 5 minutes, a week later I got a bunch of robux from it, so no idea what you’re talking about. If you'd like to start a real career though, roblox would certainly be one of the worst places to do so

[@ruinhem]

I made a game in 10 minutes once, a week later I got a bunch of robux from it, so no idea what you’re talking about. If you'd like to start a real career though, roblox would certainly be one of the worst places to do so

[@LozeiiYT]

just dont make a roblox game then

[@9rebel9blood9]

who tf goes to roblox to make money? It's a game where only the best of the best people get money. You gotta be kinda famous or advertise your game hella crazy to get rich off of roblox or you just get extremely lucky

[@falsely9523]

As a very young person who has been in this community since 2013, it is insane how normalized most of things said in this video including pedophilia.

[@shoobzy3431]

Because the reality of it is that this shit has become normalised. Not digging at the creator of the roblox video but corporations exploiting kids has never been a new thing in gaming as a whole let alone roblox. Most games these days have micro transactions that are literally designed to exploit dumb kids into buying their crappy currency. Even the employees that create games for triple A studios ever receive a fraction of what the actual game makes and those games usually make a lot.

[@mrehatt2582]

yeah, i started on this game when i was 7, i didnt know things like this happened until now.

[@babaloons4887]

@@mrehatt2582 ur either extremely lucky or started playing on 2019 or something

[@edward7434]

@@babaloons4887 LOL then he'd be only 9 years old now. I'm guessing you're a little kid too. But why 2019 anyway? Why such a specific year? Why not earlier?

[@Paulblartlover]

It makes sense now as to why people were always asking about my age in roblox back in 2013. Luckily I was too stupid back them to get groomed or tricked

[@doihaveto2688]

I just have to say Roblox’s moderation is the equivalent of somebody looking at a blank page and deciding your fate off that. I once got a warning for making a slightly political joke with no real intention to be political. Then there are the people in servers bypassing the chat filter and shouting racial slurs, and in Roblox’s eyes, this is perfectly fine. My friend wanted to make a realistic game, and there was a female character in it. There was nothing sexual about this character or model, and his account - with $100 worth of Robux got banned. And also, they made voice chat where you have to put a driver’s license in to have it, and people can search up former president’s Brack Obama drivers license, and you can use it and Roblox will allow it. Then there are games like build a boat where you can make your creations in game, and people can make the p hub logo, and tell people to search up the website. It truly baffles me how kids can be safe on this website, a website with scammers, and other malicious people, while being safe. Anyways my rant about Roblox is over.

[@uglybeast650]

the moderators only look at your chat logs when someone reports you, so if someone doesn’t report someone else they will never get banned

[@vanitasz]

Once I drew a drawing for a decal and got banned for a month, it wasnt even inappropriate

[@qwertyuioplkmjnhbgvfcdxsza]

@UglyBeast a scammer reported me because i tricked them into thinking i was gonna get scammed by them. And roblox gave me a warning, which isnt to bad but like. WHY?

[@Lanascherrycola]

Yeah I agree, I like this game but they really need to do better, they allow the stupidest things and then ban you for things that you shouldn't even be banned for....and yeah, you can litterally say anything In voice chat..which is definitely not good for kids, and why should you need to show your ID or driver's license 😅 idk it's just not a safe game even though it's targeted for kids....

[@Lanascherrycola]

@@uglybeast650 yeah but people are getting banned for dumb reasons, and roblox allows alot of bad stuff, that's the point. And why allow voice chat if they don't even allow swearing and such..it just makes no sense

[@stardustspeedway4232]

In middle school I had an extra class where we learned about a whole bunch of stuff and one of the projects we did was to learn about the economy and how the stock market works and they used something called the stock market game, which basically involved tons of different schools and would start up and end throughout the year, basically you were given 3 million fake dollars to spend on stocks and the idea was you were supposed to well, play the stock market. And at the end of the game (which typically lasted around 3 months per each game) whoever had the most money accumulated by selling their shares and stuff would get like $300. Honestly it was really fun and was super informative.

[@MadJack122]

wow, that's depressing as fuck. When most kids are in middle school they're busy being inspired and enjoying art and growing up socially with friends, instead of being "informed" in stocks and capitalism. What a joke.

[@stardustspeedway4232]

@@MadJack122 ehh the whole class had stuff like that, it was honestly really fun. They managed yo do all the stuff in a fun way somwhow

[@tworad4315]

@@MadJack122 Its an optional class, those kids chose to take Econ 101

[@jimbosfunzone8292]

@@MadJack122 so you can’t enjoy art or hang out with friends because you’re interested in the stock market? I don’t get what you’re saying here.

[@tobiwonkanogy2975]

@@MadJack122 No better time to learn about how the world actually works . Taxes and home skills should be taught in schools, financial responsibility and their role in the family should be explained to them. The fact the child who won received a cash prize is where it gets depressing. Money is when shit gets real sad. Reinforcing to those watching that nothing matters but first place and winning . That's simply not the truth

[@NedreddDwr]

I knew a guy who i used to play with who used to look for p*rn games on Roblox. He insisted to me than it was 18+ people ONLY, but the fact that he was looking for that sht on ROBLOX of all things was something i was not standing for and i no longer talk or interact with them.

[@UnfortunatePolo]

Good choice

[@tragsFIN]

"Jack's using unity now." was the funniest ending to a sentence after the story he told.

[@darthschradergg]

Aged like cheese

[@ss3nm0dn4r8]

@@darthschradergg cheese is good aged tho?

[@darthschradergg]

@@ss3nm0dn4r8 You probably smell like onions

[@cryogenical_]

The gambling stock market reminds me a lot of Valve's response to gambling in CSGO and DOTA2. It was something along the lines of "We do not determine the value of these items therefore we are not responsible for underage gambling with our items" to try to separate themselves from having to do anything about the gambling sites.

[@turmspitzewerk]

"good job valve, sticking it to the evil gambling sites!!!" lol they just wanna make sure they take all the profit off their own gambling

[@MsDestroyer900]

@@turmspitzewerk they don't profit from them tho. The gambling is entirely between the sites and the players. Valve only makes money off the community market and games.

[@ari3903]

kinda scummy but not as scummy as roblox taking 30% of the share

[@zhanibek8384]

@@ari3903 not sure if I am confusing things but some ex Valve employees said that they never expected the prices of digital items to go that high. The popularity of a 3rd party trading platforms was unexpected as well. Valve initially thought that the vast majority of transactions would be done within the system where it is impossible to convert Steam $ into a real cash.

[@bigblackstick]

Valve did shutdown a CSGO gambling site, leading to a youtubers homicidal suicide

[@microwaveable2loud469]

something to take note off on the ultra commando, the owner who originally had it gave it to a known trader because he was quitting roblox and he wanted the item in circulation instead of it being trapped into his account.

[@olive1274]

hearing all this legit bummed me out ngl

[@kalebh3419]

As someone who was THERE when Gaia Online fell, watching the same damn thing happen to the new generation is so surreal

[@kayumitchi4468]

ah gaia.. i like super mega miss when they made their own version of oregon trail but with airships it was spectacular and no other like it has been seen. zOmg was good too tho just short

[@burnttoast6974]

Bro you can’t just fling me back in time like that, I wasn’t ready for flashbacks

[@PokemonOnlineSupport]

"Did not give us a straight answer" that's roblox's classic for you, don't tell you important details

[@wellusee688]

Show Time kzbin.info/www/bejne/q5u1qpuFlsythpI Q Q

[@kimberlyalexadra3666]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NUDE.YOUNGGIRLS.TODAY/sunnyleone 💜 MAKE ME YOUR S*X SLAVE KZbin: This is fine Someone: Says "help" KZbin: BE GONE History : deleted Phone : yeeted Body :heated Holy water : needed #Чо #эт #делает #на #2 #месте #в #тренде #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #垃圾 #ライブ配信の再編ありがとうです！#この日のライブ配信は、#かならりやばかったですね！１#万人を超える人が見ていたもんね（笑）#やっぱり人参最高！#まさかのカメラ切り忘れでやら1かしたのもドキドキでした！#今後は気を付けないとね5). . !💖🖤❤

[@GiGitteru]

Why are bots plaguing every fucking comment

[@The_Andromeda_Galaxy]

Thats every large company.

[@irapelolisforaliving]

@@GiGitteru people that create these bots need to suffer eternal damnation

[@sampan04]

The saddest part is, you cannot convince these children because they are so brainwashed into following them. An example of this is when Roblox went offline. People went mad, so imagine a world where you try to convince these kids to not play the game they've so thoroughly become attached to

[@YouKnowImOnMyPeriodYah]

I play Roblox occasionally for the same few games I like but I had no idea an outage even occurred until weeks after restoration Pretty funny and sad people became that attached to a Lego game. The amount of adopt me addicts crying over their log in streaks

[@ruinhem]

If anybody thinks the term "brainwashed" applies to video games they are just out of this world

[@ruinhem]

If anybody thinks the term "brainwashed" applies to video games they are just out of this world

[@blakethesnek1]

@@YouKnowImOnMyPeriodYah Same here, I've frequented roblox a lot, but during the outages I just.. move on to another game. Once the outage was over, so many people were acting like they'd been deprived of water for the last week.

[@mastermeat3590]

"Jack's learning unity now." This didn't age well

[@jesuschrist7833]

Watched this yesterday. The entire black market shit is insane. Imagine a company that says they’ll convert your ‘robux’ to cash yet barely do it. So 15 year olds create underground money exchange groups. Trade your in game currently for real cash cause roblox doesn’t want to pay children devs.

[@exotic1405]

Top devs use the underground as well. Nobody really follows roblox rules

[@kimberlyalexadra3666]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NUDE.YOUNGGIRLS.TODAY/sunnyleone 💜 MAKE ME YOUR S*X SLAVE KZbin: This is fine Someone: Says "help" KZbin: BE GONE History : deleted Phone : yeeted Body :heated Holy water : needed #Чо #эт #делает #на #2 #месте #в #тренде #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #垃圾 #ライブ配信の再編ありがとうです！#この日のライブ配信は、#かならりやばかったですね！１#万人を超える人が見ていたもんね（笑）#やっぱり人参最高！#まさかのカメラ切り忘れでやら1かしたのもドキドキでした！#今後は気を付けないとね5). . !💖🖤❤

[@fica1137]

@@exotic1405 No they don't

[@Z_Tier_King]

Ayeee the Beta Jesus, leeeets gooooo!

[@averyepicguy]

WHO THE FUCK ISN'T A BOT?! SERIOUSLY BRO!

[@thejadedcommenter7371]

The problem with Roblox is simply that there’s too many interactions that _should_ be legally enforced, but they all happen with minors and zero moderation.

[@pokes9025]

I feel bad for the devs that actually put time and effort into games on roblox because of how little they’ll get in return

[@meaningless5898]

ya

[@eemeli7093]

Ikr

[@kimberlyalexadra3666]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NUDE.YOUNGGIRLS.TODAY/sunnyleone 💜 MAKE ME YOUR S*X SLAVE KZbin: This is fine Someone: Says "help" KZbin: BE GONE History : deleted Phone : yeeted Body :heated Holy water : needed #Чо #эт #делает #на #2 #месте #в #тренде #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #垃圾 #ライブ配信の再編ありがとうです！#この日のライブ配信は、#かならりやばかったですね！１#万人を超える人が見ていたもんね（笑）#やっぱり人参最高！#まさかのカメラ切り忘れでやら1かしたのもドキドキでした！#今後は気を付けないとね5). . !💖🖤❤

[@jammyjammich]

I decided to make a game about 5 days ago, so far ive put in 60 hours and im not expecting ANY money when im done. itll take me months to make myself. but its more of a fun passion project since im a SAHM and have nothing to do anyway

[@reaperking2121]

I would just like to offer some counter points. 1 I know and have spoken to an actual roblox dev (The dude who created the roblox squid game) while roblox may be taking a large sum of the profits he himself stated that with only roughly 10,000 concurrent players on you can easily make more then enough money to live off of roblox alone (Upwards of 50,000). The creators of Jailbreak are millionares so you can't argue that roblox is taking so much of their money they still do pay and they pay enough that you can become wealthy off the platform. 2 Roblox is unique as a gaming company because unlike all other services like Steam and such they run your overhead. They maintain the game engine for you, pay for your servers, and run the overhead this costs money and that money is hard for roblox to make the entire platform is free almost all game are free and the player base is kids. What this means is that the paying audience is tiny for the size of actual users. In short roblox has been struggling to make profits and has already been taking losses every year to keep the platform going so their is a legitimate reason for them to be taking such a large share of the profits. I'm not defending roblox. I'm just sayiing their is another side of this picture and straight up vilifying them because of one report is rather dumb.

[@marlienaking3049]

i tried to get someone who was harassing me and my friend banned...... ROBLOX IGNORED IT

[@Matrixorial]

bro

[@MyFunkymonkey7]

I’m always amazed at how Charlie reads some of the dumbest shit ever said from twitch chat (like the dude who said Roblox teaches kids about the stock market so it’s a good idea to let them gamble with millions of dollars) and doesn’t just ass blast them into another universe. I can hardly manage to read KZbin comments without getting upset at some of the dumb shit being said.

[@playergamezd8573]

Fr tho I can tell some of the people in his chat are saying misleading things

[@Cecilia-ky3uw]

how the fuck does this teach the stock market, it just teaches basic supply and demand with real fucking money, cant they just show the prices of diamonds and why it is so expensive(because of the high demand and artificially lowered supply)

[@L30GH05TDUD3]

Ever since the Ruben Sim lawsuit and the claims i started to raise an eyebrow to Roblox because of first, how stupid many of the claims were and two, that people haven’t really proved many of the following to be real. Also everyone know that Roblox had a grudge against him for exposing prior shady things they done in the past, not just the head of moderation. And this practically confirms my suspicion. Ruben was basically the catalyst of a series of ongoing events on Roblox going ahead and censor and extort anyone who brings up and exposes Roblox’s shady and even illegal tactics and things they have done before and still doing in their site and users. Because of course no shady and greedy company would ever want to be exposed of being shady and greedy. I hope Ruben wins the case, but with prior cases of similar incidents that occurred the chances are very slim, and so is our right to speak freely against Roblox. This will leave a dark precedent in our community and im sad for it.

[@Bruhm0nk3y]

“Takes a 30 percent cut” Jesus that’s even more than Lester would take

[@echonuim]

30% is bad, but roblox takes 77% and thats at best as covered by people makes games first video

[@crimson-foxtwitch2581]

@@echonuim I did the math, it’s worse than that. Roblox takes 91%.

[@viperion3930]

91%??

[@crimson-foxtwitch2581]

@@viperion3930 Yep.

[@spudz2186]

@@crimson-foxtwitch2581 N I N E T Y - O N E ! ?

[@justmagdalenadownhere]

i never thought i'd hear the words "kids should not be hunting paedophiles." i feel like that should go without saying...

[@Thisisthegreatestatofalltime]

I just remember playing this game when the free currency was still a thing and the only thing that made up for the jank was the creativity of the games. The game seems to be alot more sketch than it used to be it seems.

[@aksls3199]

6:23 i love how he says “robox” instead of “roblox”. gives the video some extra professionalism lol

[@LaurentiusTriarius]

"Kids will watch anything" I spent part of my childhood watching the microwave oven platter turn. Quality time.

[@ShaniaT.]

i used to befriend grasshoppers and praying mantises. Oh god, the amount of bites.

[@red_again]

heh same until the microwave gave up and broke in around 2016

[@-drome]

this is one of my favorite comments in recent memory

[@mosalah11thegoat]

same but with an oven and i watched the food cook 💀

[@broskinie7168]

What makes it even worse is that if you do have a limited worth millions.. you can't devex it.. it will never be anything but robux