Pentatonix Makes the BEST Christmas Music! Bass Singer Reaction (& ANALYSIS) | "O Holy Night"

[@camillep3631]

Kiss From A Rose will melt your mind

[@FayolaOnline]

Pentatonix is the master of vocal theatrics, maybe next to Dimash. But for a whole group to be so stunning without drowning each other out is ridiculously impressive.

[@tamaraengelberger5928]

This is my latest Pentatonix obsession. I absolutely LOVE Matt's part in this, SO good!

[@NiaMeg]

Agree! And there’s something special when Matt and Mitch sing together.

[@lizziefrances]

We Pentaholics hold no statute on when their Christmas music is appropriate. Waiting a whole 12 months to release your reactions is not so much delayed gratification for us as manipulative withholding by you!!! Wishing you a wonderful silly season✨

[@LisaG64]

I can listen to their Christmas music all year long 30:58

[@cellokimmy]

I appreciate your analysis. Also, thanks for stating that Matt is a bass, just not a profundo. Based on comments on other posts there’s a whole faction of people that needed to hear that. Also, yes, Kirstie wins the fashion award here. That goddess dress is stunning.

[@jcs1025]

Exactly. Avi was an anomaly, and Matt is awesome without the stupid comparisons. It’s been almost 7 years FFS. 😊

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

So glad to see you reacting to them again! Always such good analysis! As always, love how much of a Matt supporter you are without feeling the need to embellish and proclaim him as the lowest of the low. You celebrate him for what he is!

[@bridgethaines7127]

Scott's voice has matured so much since Covid and making his own album. I'm astonished every time.

[@traveltym]

Matt’s voice continues to give me chills.

[@raleighwells-larsen5008]

Scott deserved the pit viper status in this one ngl

[@sylvia9049]

If you want to hear a "new" Pentatonix listen to their cover of "Kiss from a Rose". It was a surprise.

[@sosarahb]

Kirstie's last two belts are honestly my fave that she's ever done. I've followed the group since their Sing-Off days and the amount of growth with all of them is indescribable!! Even Matt has grown as well! Love your analysis videos!

[@abigailhorton5370]

Pentatonix (including Ben Bram) just keep outdoing themselves! What a stunning song. And your reaction was excellent, as always it makes me appreciate them even more. SO glad you are friends with Matt! He seems like a beautiful human. Hope you can catch their Christmas concert next year, they do a wonderful job.

[@rebeccaashmore7025]

I love the depth of your knowledge of each singer's capacity, growth, development and choices.

[@randycraft5895]

Pentatonix are the Royal Court of Christmas music!

[@tersommers]

Always enjoy your PTX reactions! They just did a Vevo live version of Kiss From A Rose (not Christmas normally) and Vevo live version of Pure Imagination/Christmastime is Here (Pure Imagination not Christmas normally)! Would love to see your reaction to either one!

[@SweetSlytherinGirl-Jennifer]

All-time favorite Christmas song since I was a kid. And after 45 years of music and singing (my mom was a music teacher and still is a church children's choir director), this is the best, most epic version I have ever heard. I am so glad you got this reaction out, I was very interested in hearing your analysis of it!

[@stephaniem2007]

We all listen to Christmas music 24/7/365. I was hoping you would do Kiss from a Rose Live by PTX

[@CurtisPoppenhouse]

I've always said "Beware when Pentatonix sing all in a single line), because get ready for the famous Pentatonix "wall of sound".

[@vmcgriff]

Stunningly Gorgeous!! This is one of my 4 favorites from them this year - probably just nudging over the top of the other 3… - Kiss From A Rose - Powerful! - Pure Imagination/ Christmas Time Is Here - Beautiful!! - Please Santa Please - So fun!!! Love your reactions!! ❤

[@MaryG0725]

Kiss from a Rose please!❤

[@celiachristman104]

That is so cool that you and Matt have connected. He is so awesome, and awesome in this song. You can release PTX music any time of the year as far as I'm concerned. Your breakdowns are so educational, I'd love to hear the other ones you broke down even though it's after the holidays.

[@Gwennedd]

Yes!! I'm not sure I can wait a full year before getting more awesome breakdowns on PTX from Pete.

[@billiemchone6683]

I can't stand how beautiful and exciting this is. Mitch, Scott, Kirstie, Kevin Matt how can you all be so wonderful!

[@billiemchone6683]

Matt that was heart "bursting." My God. !

[@shaylla_]

I really appreciate your analysis and insight-thank you!! We’ve missed PTX on your channel; you truly do enhance the experience. They released another song during the holidays that is not technically a Christmas song - Kiss From a Rose - so hopefully you can check out their VEVO performance of that one next. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you! 😘

[@lleldridge1]

Love your breakdown of this one. My ears recognize how stunning it is, but you've provided the reasons why and I appreciate it, thank you! Sorry to hear you won't be releasing your PTX bundle until next year. 🎄

[@kathycarias1271]

Pentaholics love PTX Christmas songs all year round! Love your reactions!!

[@Tark-qs4mu]

Thank you, Peter. I hadn't noticed the non-standard suspension in the start of the song. I also agree that, yes, the part with the, as you called it, "fake out" was cool, but I hadn't really paid attention, not the way you can, to WHY it was cool. If you're looking for some bassy fun, just something to enjoy and have a really good time with, check out Scott Hoying I'ma Tell Yer Mamma On Ya, if you haven't already seen it. I think you'll gain a new appreciation for Scotts lower range. I know I did.

[@joyrobinson4585]

If we can have only one PTX Christmas offering this year this is a spectacular choice! Thank you. You are special to me Peter. I wish you a very Merry Christmas!

[@thechomiji]

Nothing about Kirstin's amazing held notes at the end, just before Scott's near-whisper solo finale? She sounds so totally filled with religious exaltation. Note that for the most part she and Mitch are using their strong mid-ranges here, so that the gut-feel is power rather than the silvery delicacy that they both often display (see, for example, Pure Imagination/Christmastime Is Here).

[@edsartistry]

PTX is so good with the emotions of a song. And they ALWAYS take you for a ride. Love Matt's part, so soulful and powerful. Mitch... wow... is so ... clean, clear and EPIC ! Kirstie angelic, love her lower register and of course her sense of style (clothing) and ...my, my, her vibrato is just other worldly. Yehhhhh, WOW, Scott ! The emotions, dang Dude!! Yup, their usual "rollercoaster ride". ! Love Scott's grit and belting. Then Kirstie and Mitch come in with those high notes in combination and just send you rocketing into outer space. OMG !!! Could we want for anything more!?!?! WOW ! What a performance, as always. Thank you Peter, love your reactions and breakdown and can't wait until next year. For now, Have a very Merry Christmas ! and hope you get to take a little well deserved time off to celebrate.

[@mel3268]

Simply stunning. Have always wondered why I can so easily hear the individual voices. Great, informative reaction as always. (And Scott’s “grit” has been increasing exponentially these last few years. Check out his Mars Choir Version if you haven’t already. It showcases that side of his voice and it’s crazy good.)

[@JaniceDAgostino]

Love the cut off of the word “night” by Matt. I appreciate your analysis.

[@neetgupta1]

I was so excited to see your reaction to Pentatonix again. I LOVE your reactions as they are so informative. I loved your interview with Matt who really impressed me when I saw them live in May. He and Kevin are awesome together. I genuinely think their relationships are what makes the Pentatonix magic. They are so tight - it's genuinely a family. I think they are all unbelievable vocal talents but I will always fangirl for Mitch. He has a truly unique, once-in-a-generation voice. It's so clear and piercing and it grabs my heart each time I hear him.

[@janeramirez8767]

I love Matt's hand on his heart at the end.

[@donnastohr]

Great reaction and review. Thank you for explaining why I can always hear the singer on camera over the others. This always mystified me, and a prime example is the video of 'I Can't Help Falling in Love With You'. At the tender age of 75, I am always happy to have life's little mysteries cleared up one by one.

[@Badger77722]

That was one of the best analysis videos I think I've seen you do! So much detail, not just for the bass part but for everyone, and so much enthusiasm for one of my favorite a cappella groups! Thank you!

[@lindakennamer2850]

Thanks!

[@maia.t]

Yayyyy more pentatonix!! Thanks for coming back to them! Great analysis of this amazing cover, I noticed so many intricacies I hadn’t noticed before. What a cool arrangement. You should totally check out their most recent live Vevo performance of Kiss from a Rose, it’s soooo good. Can’t wait for ptx Christmas week next year!

[@shelbychesnut99]

I am so glad you are back to PTX. While I appreciate all their earlier work, their sound has matured so much, it it amazing. I saw their concert last week. It was magical.

[@PtxXtp]

You're a dedicated friend. I think I would drop my friend in a heartbeat to see ptx live. Especially with tickets from Matt.

[@creationsbychancecan]

Thank you for doing this one Peter. It is such a beautiful carol and Pentatonix does it so well. I would love you to react to their version of Come All Yee Faithful. It is an iconic carol that they completely change but also keep the original in the mix. This one will blow your mind as only Pentatonix can

[@rondileem3111]

Thank you so much for all your insight into this amazing performance/arrangement! I really learned a lot. I do NOT want to wait a year for the 5 others! Can we get them after Christmas? A year is too far away!!!

[@pjb3583]

Ooh, “cascading belts” needs to be the name of something. Loved your reaction, as always, thanks. Peace …

[@tyghe_bright]

I feel the same way about Mitch. I love the whole group, and love each of their voices, but Mitch's is really spectacular and so beautiful.

[@HH-yo2bs]

Thank you so much for this! You know, the Christmas season runs through to 6 January, so feel free to release the rest of the videos as they clear! ;-) In any case, I'd love to hear your analysis of their mash-up of Pure Imagination x Christmastime is Here. After The Prayer, maybe Mitch's best performance yet? :)

[@shilohauraable]

I totally agree 👍

[@donnastohr]

I thought it ran until Valentine's day myself.

[@chrispavlich9656]

@@donnastohrAll year where they’re concerned! Lol

[@savannahgary6351]

Chills there towards the end...love, love, love Pentatonix! Thank you for such an excellent analysis, Peter..💜

[@terriepurkey708]

I've missed your PTX reactions and analysis; they're always interesting and informative. This arrangement is so powerful it still brings me to tears. Merry Christmas Peter and I'm glad this one dropped before the holiday!

[@redredlulu1]

Thank you for this reaction to this wonderful Christmas Carol, it’s not just a song. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

[@noelpauley5381]

I got to see them live in September, they are just so amazing. I love them all, but Mitch is truly something special! ❤

[@pamelakgarrett993]

Peter, thank you so much for this reaction! I do love their arrangements! They are truly amazing!

[@elizabethtucker6026]

Sad to wait a year to hear your Christmas analysis, but I shall anticipate next year. Lovely reaction.

[@JerodM]

The copyright blocks are brutal at times. With them being automated with ai, it doesn’t make room for fair use initially. It requires disputing and hopefully getting it released. Unfortunately, even with fair use, monetization is gone. So Patreon truly is the best way to help support your favorite reactors if they have one. Thanks Peter for diligence. I understand the challenge.

[@Eileen_in_Vegas]

Awesome start to Christmas weekend! Great R&A as always.

[@dohraime140]

Aww, there are 12 days of Christmas… you can release all 5 videos now ! 😁 Really enjoyed this, thank you. Lots of treats to pay attention to.

[@vidsorama2]

Thank you for this awesome reaction and analysis of Pentatonix beautiful "O Holy Night" video. I enjoyed it very much and I learned a lot.

[@ambergarner8471]

I'm so disappointed you couldn't get those 5 videos past the YT powers that be! It's so awesome to see you do PTX again. Such an awesome analysis.

[@patriciahanson5479]

no many how many times I listen to this song I find myself holding my breath at the end after Kristi's high belt. pewwww!

[@susanpeterson9947]

Wow! Wonderful song, wonderful reaction! But you’ve broken my heart telling me that we have to wait til next year for more! 💖🎄🎁💙 Merry Christmas, Peter!

[@Dawn54811]

Really enjoy your reaction and explanation of what is going on with the voices. This is my favorite Christmas song. Thank you for sharing your talent.

[@madenabyss6981]

They upgraded their upgrade love this version so much ❤

[@karaquick395]

My fav. PTX X-Mas song is "Silent Night" live in a church or monastery it looks like. Its like the Heavens opened up and angels flew overhead singing! Beautiful.

[@carriekovach797]

I so appreciate you reacting to PTX again. I’m so in love with this arrangement and performance. Thank you and Merry Christmas Peter! 🙏🏻🎄

[@bonniepalmer5286]

You have to check out their cover of Pure Imagination/Christmas time is here. It is stunning.

[@davephillips7209]

Great analysis man, enjoyed. That was amazing!!!

[@debrawalkermeyer9109]

Excellent reaction as always! Your detailed musical reaction is valuable information. This is in the top 5 Pentatonix performances of all time to me. ❤. They all shined. They all supported each other fabulously when they shined. Their harmonies and emotions shine through. They are at the top of their game. They are on a great path for 2024. Scott’s start. Wow for Matt. Mitch and Kirstie shined and back vocals were amazing. Kevin slayed it. And that end from Kirstie gave me goosebumps. The swirling visuals of them all at the end takes it to a new level. In my opinion the silence at the start shows them reverently taking place to sing this praise. ❤❤❤❤❤

[@melindahancock8518]

This was the best one to post! ❤ Looking forward to the next years PTX extravaganza! Merry Christmas wishing you all the very best!

[@beccaHbell]

Was really hoping you would give your insights into this song. Thank you!!!

[@ShinyElfriend]

Thank you for breaking this gorgeousness down! It just fascinates me. I’m sorry you couldn’t make Charlottesville. It was a magical show!

[@CapriUni]

Merry Christmas Eve eve! You got this one in on time (and it's a great one). I appreciate the context you're able to elucidate after watching a bunch of PTX, and noticing details of their style.

[@verinhajor]

Thank you to comeback to PTX again!

[@mertynmarshall8894]

You should really do Kiss from a rose!!!

[@MsMoonlightPrincess]

You could release them for Christmas in July!! I can't wait a year!!!

[@leslieholland7843]

This gave me goosebumps. Thanks, Peter!❤❤

[@shilohauraable]

I'm so excited for your reaction to this beautiful video! 💖

[@elizabethbuerke7854]

Historically speaking as a religious holiday, the Christmas season actually begins on Christmas Day and continues for a couple weeks afterward. The time before Christmas is called Advent. So technically you can still release the Pentatonix videos for this Christmas if you want.

[@jenniferworley7115]

All the 💐💐💐 to you for your in depth analysis. PTX just continues to keep me on the edge of my seat. Merry Christmas to all !!! God willing I will be waiting for your PTX bundle and interview next Christmas. Peace, love and blessings to all.✌🤗🙏

[@isaacstain7784]

This was such a great analysis video! Peter, you are definitely one of the BEST reactors on KZbin! I had so much fun watching this video and listening to you break down the vocal techniques! I felt like I was in music class! PTX definitely went to church with this song! Way to end not only the Christmas season but the year 2023! We look forward to seeing your next reaction and analysis videos! Until then, have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! 🎉🎉🎉

[@lkayh]

Much as I appreciate PTX and this song I’m so glad you got it done before Christmas. By the 26th I’m more than ready to quit hearing Christmas songs again for another year. LOL. Hope you have a happy Christmas tomorrow-always love your reactions/analyses!

[@jankates1274]

Thanks for the great analysis Peter. Merry Christmas

[@DennisKavanaugh-u8t]

Excellent reaction!

[@Qlassyone]

Matt shines in O Holy Night and A Kiss From A Rose. Scott and Mitch let Matt and Kirstie shine in this song. And Kevin is exquisite as usual.

[@lovesmusic0845]

Love the analysis. I’m sitting here in June and enjoying this song no matter the season. I’m a longtime PTX fan, since the first night on Sing Off. I love their artistry in all its variations. This arrangement really does give you that push pull feel throughout the entire song. I like the bookend silent seconds in the video. The vocals were stunning and the arrangement really allowed everyone to give us both softly beautiful and powerful moments throughout the song. Kirstie’s belt at the end was powerful as was the surrounding background vocals. One of the things I love about PTX is how they make me feel, when they sing. The emotions they convey in their performances are one of their great strengths. I listened to Matt’s interview and have recommended it on several other channels. It was a wide ranging interview that gave me a greater understanding of Matt’s background and his commitment to his performances. Matt is such a good fit for PTX vocally and personality wise.

[@LisaG64]

I can listen to this song over and over and over any time of year! 31:17

[@kellytressler7671]

Why not do Christmas in July? Then we all don't have to wait a whole year? Love what you do here Peter, you are very interesting to watch. ❤

[@drekfletch]

I like the suspension at the start of the second verse. Talking about how the World lay, for a long time, "in sin and error pining." The lyrics talk about ongoing unresoved dissonance of the world, and the music reflects that. I absolutely adore when composers do stuff like that.

[@putibuhok]

Had goosebumps when i first saw mitch here. I thought for second that it was Freddie Mercury. did any one else think so?

[@davidbangtson3109]

That was a phenomenal reaction and analysis of what I think is the best version of this song ever done! Perfection from you and from PTX!

[@ruth2141]

About PTX bass parts. I've always thought that one reason PTX arrangements don't usually call for super deep bass parts is that it can throw off the sound of the arrangement. The same reason Scott shows restraint in where and when he adds riffs, and Mitch doesn't always sing his highest notes. In terms of entertainment, it can be fun to hear a super-deep bass note, but it's distracting from the overall effect of the arrangement. So it's a musical choice.

[@lindawarden-burglund9603]

Spectacular! Thanks, Peter! Merry Christmas! 🎄🎄🎄

[@colleendonahue2529]

Pentatonics always nails it🎉🎉

[@marcgoodwin4899]

So good - thanks. Always love your breakdowns.

[@ehcimocs2364]

You would really enjoy reacting to PTX with Kiss from a Rose. They threw lots of surprises in their variation of this classic. They are spectacular. Thanks for reacting

[@brianmccleary6278]

I clicked just for the thumbnail…that face!

[@saras6281]

No matter how many times i listen to this i get so many goosebumps in that moment of silence between Kirstie taking it out the galaxy and Scott's last line. One thing i love about all your explinations are the little details you pick up on that explain why their songs sound so flipping amazing which none singers like me wouldn't hear without it being pointed out.

[@anonymousblah4486]

So happy to see you react to ptx again! Have missed this! Highly HIGHLY recommend their kiss from a rose PLEASE :D IT’S LIKE NOTHING THEY’VE EVER DONE BEFORE! Would love to hear your thoughts on it :)

[@Andyvan92110]

Christmas runs until January 6 (12 days of Christmas). So, bring them on!

[@jenchem42]

What an amazingly insightful reaction! Thank you for putting out the musicality of the chords, as well as the patterns that you've noticed in their arrangements. I LOVE that this one continually keeps the listener guessing on what's coming next. Subscribed! 🙂

[@nicoros2236]

A sensational reaction to an even better performance; thank you for that!

[@elainedavis9053]

Oh My --WOW - I just loved your reaction / analysis Awesome - Thanks so much!

[@karannewton3481]

So love your reactions! I'm an instrument musician and so do hear a lot of what you are discussing....but my ear is not trained as a vocalist AND no where near the level of your training. Love hearing the break down you provide, as it really shows off how truly amazing this group is.