What If Plo Koon Raised Luke and Leia

[@yarokiduncan9788]

Ahsoka not seeing Plo before his death was criminal

[@JCardo2502]

There was actual plans to bring back Plo Koon instead of Luke in the Mandalorian, which makes me believe that Plo could be alive

[@yarokiduncan9788]

@@JCardo2502 I meant in this lol

[@0BI-WAN.KENOBI]

​@@JCardo2502Even if they make new movies plo could still be alive because i am pretty sure plo's species can live for a couple hundred years.

[@StellariaEclipse]

​@@JCardo2502Not quite, they had an actor dressed as Plo fill in the spot for Luke so that members of the team making the show wouldn't be spoiled on Luke returning before they were able to see the episode for themselves.

[@fordoslegacystarwars]

@@0BI-WAN.KENOBIthey are also fire retardant. Basically plo’s species are fire extinguishers. I have no doubt he survived. As fire doesn’t harm their species. He may have gotten injured by the shrapnel though

[@locoarticwolf2181]

Papa Plo, saving the Galaxy once more.

[@marikam2998]

Yeah, Plo Koon is great in this story. Although, he's always great in stories like this.

[@brokenbridge6316]

Papa Plo. I like that.

[@garrettadyns3927]

This is all I needed to see ❤😂😂😂

[@ELICARIO12345]

All that's missing is Plos Bros 😢

[@Fox45_]

Papa Plo is okay if they call him by " Uncle "

[@skyj5606]

21:40 "The traitor who intentionally bombed an orphanage" Plo's expression is the same when ahsoka left the jedi. Plo: Whoops

[@Coffeeandaverse]

Honestly buddy you made me cry with the ending and peace he found felt connected as a fellow dad

[@develdragon13]

same

[@dianesinger9729]

love Plo and how he raised the triplets, I was sadden by his death but glad he left his legacy behind for this students and Kanan and the ghost grew.

[@marikam2998]

I too am saddened by Plo's Death but, may he always leave his legacy alive than dead. He, too, as a Character, always deserves a better fate.

[@brokenbridge6316]

I felt that the way Plo Koon went was very Jedi like.

[@rathion1]

Glad he took down Sidious but was so sad he died.... Do wish Ahsoka could of seen him before passing though

[@dianesinger9729]

Yes @@rathion1 I would I think that would have given Plo a little bit more joy seeing his little 'soka again

[@y.n.tryone4683]

18:05 I think Caleb would feel much safer with PLo as this isn’t long after he witnessed his master being killed , and plo would have motivation to complete his training and make him a knight in a couple of years

[@samlambert7133]

Plo became like master shredder lol. I loved this story. I wish Plo survived.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" The Jedi before the Clone Wars discovered that the Dark Side Nexus under their temple on Coruscant was draining their strength in the Force?

[@erikakerblom2900]

Noice as always Pente! Day: 74: What if Talzin raised Maul? Day: 5: What if Darth Plagueis trained Maul?

[@Fracture_.]

Ahh my favourite prequel Jedi, training Luke and Leia, love to see it. What if Darth Zannah was a Jedi? Either she refrains from killing the Jedi who originally comes for her, or another Jedi takes her instead soon after, assuming Bane doesn't find her or a twin of some kind exists. She undergoes training until she becomes a Jedi Knight or perhaps even a Jedi Master. Then, she receives one of two visions. The first vision portrays Anakin or Luke as the chosen one. She believes in the prophecy and enters stasis, intending to train them to confront Palpatine during the Clone Wars or the time of the Empire. The second vision involves Palpatine himself, maybe as the Emperor. Believing that she is the chosen one due to this, she enters stasis until the Clone Wars, awakened by the Force or some other catalyst. To fight him herself. To maintain her characterization as the Zannah we know and love, she excels as a master of Form Three and is proficient in Jedi Alchemy or sorcery, perhaps even both. I think the second vision would make for a better story, as training Anakin/Luke videos are already abundant on your channel. (Day 41)

[@brokenbridge6316]

I have a high amount of respect for Plo Koon. He's number 6 on my list of favorite Jedi. Also still love your story idea.

[@Yetigaming420]

Your decision is… abmeral

[@Achuidian179]

During a poll with The Star Wars Galaxy, Plo was my second favorite Jedi. First being Ahsoka. So the fact that you made an animation with Plo and Palpatine was AMAZING!!!! Day 32 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@Falcon_Primal]

Right on my birthday too! Spending it alone unfortunately but this really made my day. Thank you PPSW.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I hope you have a wonderful birthday!

[@Falcon_Primal]

@@PentePatrolStarWars Thanks mate! Turned 29

[@adamk9303]

What if Plo koon adopted Ahsoka Tano

[@darthjadus9015]

What if Savage Opress was found by the Jedi from an early age, trained by Saesee Tiin, became best friends with Obi Wan, rescued Satine, survived order 66 and trained Leia. Honestly Savage pre transformation is just a better version of Maul in every aspect, he has a higher midichlorian count and I don't see why he would be considered less intelligent or anything. He was very caring towards Feral and quick to react against any of Ventress her attacks without any force training. He only turned into a dumb, emotionless brute after the transformation but if he never had that, he would've been more powerful than Maul, kee in mind, everything he learned he leraned in a few weeks whilst Maul was trained by Sidious for two decades. I feel like Master Tiin is the perfect Master for Savage, he is one of the orders finest duelists pushing mace in a sparring, he is great with the force and most importantly a telepath. He could help Savage develop into a fine Jedi Master and if the Jedi never did one of their typical mistakes like lying about his Family Savage, trained as a Jedi from an early age would, as far as I believ chose the Jedi over his biological family, with them being his new Family. I would really love to see him develop and not just a Maul 2.0 with a double bladed Lightsaber etc, after all he is more powerful in the force and his very own character. How cool would it be, if he and Master Tiin would've bren stationed somewhere else during order 66 and someone else would've replaced Tiin like Eeth Koth or whoever. A full potential Jedi Master Savage would've easily sirvived order 66 with his former Master, regrouped with obi wan and Yoda and could've been a great Master to Leia whilst fighting for the Rebellion as one of the finest pilots like his former Master and a highly capable Jedi Master in my eyes more powerful than Maul once he reached his full potential. He could be the Master of Djem So like his best friend Obi Wan would be the Master of Soresu

[@JediMaster_PloKoon]

We need this!

[@darthjadus9015]

@@JediMaster_PloKoon I'd love to see it, let's hope he reads this comment and makes a what if on Savage if he was trained by Saesee Tiin and survived order 66 as a Jedi Master to train Leia🔥

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Kinda this one, definitely not the exact same thing as you suggested, but you might like this: Maul & Savage Jedi: kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z5LTk3urhtdoZsk Shaak Ti Train Savage: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p6mofZyffJ2ka5Y

[@darthjadus9015]

@@PentePatrolStarWars Yeah I have watched it and it's really great but Savage is always in Maul his shadows in those stories whilst in reality he became incredibly powerful in weeks whilst Maul trained for two decades. Every source, dispite there not being actual quotes state that Savage has a higher midichlorian count and quite significantly and I would really love him to reach that full potential and not as a Maul 2.0 but as his own person. That's why I suggested this and you surly have a lot of projects but I have no problem with waiting and obviously you could make whatever changes you like but I would just love Savage as a Jedi Master with his full potential surviving order 66 and training Leia.

[@darthjadus9015]

​@@PentePatrolStarWars Besides, Savage had a really caring persona pre transformation trying to protect Feral as long as possible, fighting intelligent and ready to sacrifice himself. In what ifs he is also depicted as someone maybe like Anakin who is extremely close to maul even on opposite sides but I feel like his entire clone wars persona pre transformation is protecting the ones around him and if he was trained from a young age and if he only knew the jedi order his entire life even if he knew Maul was his brother, which the Jedi, if they aren't stupid, would tell him, he would make a correct and jedi like choice and siding with the Jedi, that's why I'd also love to explore the probability of Savage going to save Satine with obi wan who could very well be a close friend from their youngling years. I think he would make the right choice and it's actually sad that clone wars never explored Savage his true potential because that only episode pre transformation is one of the greatest characters in the show. That however is only my humble opinion. Hey man, I love your content, if you ever have time for that, I'd absolutely love it

[@brokenbridge6316]

This was a seriously cool video. Plo Koon going to Lothal was great to hear. It would've been a great place for the Jedi to exist on. And where the story went was awesome. Plo Koon's end felt cathartic. Well to me it was. Loved this video PP. Plo Koon is a character I have a high amount of respect for.

[@benjaminparker671]

What If Shaak Ti left the Jedi Order with Ahsoka

[@brokenbridge6316]

Nice suggestion

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

Plo Koon was a Jedi with a back bone in this fanfiction I LOVE IT 🔥

[@ARMY14jm]

Lol I LOVE the Coppenheimer part at 50:17!! 😂🤣

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

What if Yaddle was a Sith Lord. What if Tyvokka survived and fought in the Clone Wars. What if Satele Shan fell through the World Between Wolrds into the Clone Wars. What if Jedi Revan was imprisoned in carbonite and freed in the Clone Wars.

[@darthjadus9015]

Uhhh love the Tyvokka idea, after all he really was one of the most powerful Jedi of all time and I don't mean that by physical power. And his ability to see the future, I always thought that the force allowed him to not see the future this one time as possible could've prevented order 66 and thus interfere with the natural timeline, that's just my explanation but it would make more sense than just one of the most powerful jedi that was famous to see the future better than any other Jedi dying from friendly fire, like what the hell😂

[@brokenbridge6316]

These stories idea's are all great. I hope they do become video's one day.

[@JediMaster_PloKoon]

What if Plo Koon trained Cal Kestis?

[@brokenbridge6316]

Now that is a very in story idea

[@trollofduty007]

That little animation of the fight between Plo and Palpatine was REALLY cool!

[@y.n.tryone4683]

2:40 yoda didn’t really lose to sidious , in the ROTS book it was stated that yoda beat sidious in lightsaber duel and after their battle with the pods they were both flung , and yoda found sidious had vacated the building so he retreated . He failed in killing sidious but he wasn’t beaten

[@jeremywatters2295]

The still won😂

[@titansmashproductions5001]

I… didn’t expect that to be that good.

[@LewsThernTelamon]

What if The Republic at their strongest. Vs. The Empire at their strongest. Vs. The UNSC at their strongest. (They have all Their tec, personal and knowledge from before and after the human covenant war.) Vs. The Covenant at their strongest. (They too have all their tec and personal.) Note, there can’t be any internal conflict until one faction reigns supreme, or the flood enters the conflict.

[@mrghostly1118]

Humans also have resistance to force and in the blood (white cells and anti-bodies) destroy it completely.

[@diamondman307_]

*Choppenheimer* Edit: HE GOT ACCESS TO THE HYPER VELOCITY CANNON

[@NikoDiohulkmaker]

This is the first ever pente patroll star wars what if vid that made me cry.

[@colethelin9203]

What an excellent Video Pante Patrol Star Wars.

[@brothers_of_nod]

I really love Plo Koon content.

[@Exaris79]

Plo should had made a holocron and archive what he learned from the Baran Do Sages so that the Twins can learn from it. In the Dark Empire comics, Palpatine gave partially dark side Luke access to the Imperial ships override codes and the self-destructs. With R2D2, Luke was able to commandeer the World Devastators but the local Imperial crew can override the ship if it wasn't a self-destruct.

[@ox8833]

Awesome as usual. I think it would be cool to see Kurkruk in one of these.

[@gergernzero6904]

Plo storys are always so good

[@mrghostly1118]

Saving someone as tragic as darth vader is crazy, imagine the pain and regret inside..

[@RodrigoCen7456]

WHAT IF: a good chunk (lets say 1/4 to 1/3) of the jedi joined Dooku and the separatist in the early stages of the war. Dooku wasn't a full blown sith and he (and the CIS) did have valid political reasons for fighting against the republic. In attack of the clones he tried to get Obi-Wan to join. What if he sent a galaxy wide recording explaining why he's fighting against the republic and a lot of disgruntled/CIS sympathiziers joined Dooku. Unintentionally forming an opposing "jedi order" that fought for the separatists.

[@bonic6254]

New what if idea……. double down on Chopper’s streak. ‘What if Chopper destroyed the Empire?’ Or ‘What if Chopper destroyed the Star Wars universe?’ (In the same vein as Deadpool)

[@TheMimiSard]

I imagine Kanan wwould have been more stable and sure of himself, for being able to spend a year with Plo before going out into the stars, and knowing Plo was there for years after that. By the time Plo finally faded, Kanan had Hera and the Ghost Crew, and the triplets headed out with him, and knowing the hidden Temple was somewhere they could go... Well I watched a video at one point about how good a Jedi Kanan was, and one of his biggest issues was a lack of confidence. This story, I think he would have had more stability.

[@TheMimiSard]

Aside, I imagine Skoll and Hati ended up in the Order, with Baylan finding Shin and bringing her home with him. In that environment, he has less cynicism and thus more willing to see the restoration of the hidden Order. So when the mention of the bokken Jedi in the battle, I am imagining Baylan being one of the powerhouses in the fight, with a young Shin zipping around.

[@TheMimiSard]

Addendum, with the Order being up around 14,000 by the time the Empire fell, that means the Order kept sending out people to pick up Sensitives, and bringing in people like Chirrut and Baze. I like the idea they have a contingent of non-Sensitives who came with, like Baze, who took up support roles. I'd liek to imagine surviving Clones filtered in, like Rex comes in at Ahsoka's side, maybe the Bad Batch eventually found there way there so Omega grows up amongst them, maybe building on her roles as Nala Se's asistant by going into the sciences, maybe as part of the Healers. Maybe Wolffe was brought in by Rex and got to hear Plo survived to raise the Triplets, and lived long enough to see his statue raised.

[@bradleybailey8893]

I got to say man. I think that was one of your best. So good!

[@Aquos-Storm]

one of the best What If's from Star Wars I've seen so far.

[@undertaletimetravler3635]

45:46 jabba the hutt?!?!? Was there a hutt on the ghost crew i somehow missed? Or is he just joking around?

[@dimitrigaribay6135]

Yay finally getting your post notifications

[@GAJake]

Dude that animation was amazing!

[@reeceemms1643]

Continuing with my ideas day twenty-one of asking. 1) what if the Sith Empire returned during the High Republic era? 2) what if Avar Kriss and Elzar Mann had a child? 3) what if Starlight Beacon was saved? 4) what if Jyn Erso survived the battle of Scarif and went on to meet and fall in love with Luke Skywalker? 5) what if Luke and Leia found out they were siblings earlier? 6) what if Han was saved from Jabba but Leia failed to kill Jabba and was left behind remaining a slave? 7) what if Padme was enslaved during the Clone wars? 8) what if the Combine from Half-Life invaded the Star wars Universe? 9) what if the Daleks invaded the star wars universe? 10) what if Rey became a slave? 11) what if Luke was put in charge of the Rebellion? 12) what if Din Djaran and Bo-Katan fell in love and became joined leaders of Mandalor? 13) what if Leia finished her Jedi training? 14) what if the Cybermen invaded the Star wars universe? 15) what if Cal and Merrin had a daughter (Jedi nightsister hybrid) 16) what if Luke and Leia weren’t separated at birth? 17) what if Ahsoka found Shin Hati before Baylon Skoll? 18) what if Kylo Ren and the Knight of Ren didn’t destroy Luke’s Jedi order meaning that the Resistance and New Republic had the Jedi during the war with the first order? 19) what if the ones survived? 20) what if the Aldani heist went off without the Empire knowing. Some of these I would make on AO3 but I don’t know how I am doing 1, 2 and 4 and I plan to do 15

[@wehave2teeth]

I like how chopper is just this mass murder

[@RyanAvellino18]

this shit genuinely warmed my heart. almost made me sob

[@iloveowls90]

you know your a rebels fan when you get who Jabba the hut actually is , good one Pente!

[@neofulcrum5013]

What if Steela Gerrera survived and led the Partisans?

[@brokenbridge6316]

Nice story suggestion

[@neofulcrum5013]

@@brokenbridge6316 I’m still holding out for that to be made

[@brokenbridge6316]

@@neofulcrum5013---And I hope that it does get made eventually.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Obi-Wan tried to bring Dooku back to the light instead of Yoda?

[@someonlinedouche6992]

The one MAJOR criminal thing in this great story is the lack of Ahsoka until the end. She would have found Plo Koon much earlier and would have been there for him. Otherwise, it's a great story without complaint.

[@edwardsolomon1951]

The best yet.

[@woolph58]

45:45 What is Jabba the Hut doing there, when did he arrive???

[@stuartpendley]

Absolutely one of your best 🤙

[@cameronclophus7998]

This was beautiful and awesome. I'd pay to watch this movie

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell . Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis

[@jadesabrexiv]

I have an oddball idea for a timeline: What if Artoo and Threepio raised Luke and Leia? Just think of how oddball the Twins would be if one of their Mentors was the rolling Embodiment of WTUFF?!? that is Artoo.

[@padmeSkywalker]

What if Obi Wan decided to freeze Anakin in carbonite on mustafar? Perhaps the events will go on the same way they fight, but Obi-Wan came prepared because he refuses to lose his brother. So when Obi-Wan jumps to the higher ground, he lands in a way that he know Anakin will jump so instead of chopping Anakin, he uses the force to slam Anakin down in the carbonate and freezes him until he’s ready to release him. The events will play out the same. Many years will go by and obi wan has statue Anakin hidden in his lodge on tatooine. When Obi-Wan realizes that Palpatine won’t be looking for Anakin he gets Anakin out of the carbonate. Anakin still being darth Vader emerges, the only thing he recalls is mustafar. What he doesn’t know is that many years go by and obi wan is older

[@rallerul2237]

This would be a awesome story

[@justinokraski3796]

Make it so Luke releases him from the carbonite one day while visiting Old Ben

[@JediMaster_PloKoon]

That would be interesting.

[@karithomas5064]

I need to stop being laaaatte! Can you please do these videos for me? •What if Anakin vowed loyalty to the Zygerrian queen? •What if Dooku didn't go to Zygerria and Anakin couldn't escape? •What if Ashoka fell in love with Anakin, but he didn't fall in love with her? •What if Ezra and Leia fell in love? •What if Anakin trained Ezra during the Clone Wars? •What if Ezra save Mace when he was trying to save Ashoka (World Between Worlds)? •What if Vader killed Ezra when he tried to kill Ashoka? •What if Anakin didn't fall in love with Padme, but she was OBSESSED with him? •What if Anakin was a full blood Sith? •What if Ashoka pulled Anakin (from the clone wars) through the World Between Worlds? •What if Anakin was accused of the bombing at the Jedi temple? •What if Barriss' goal was to kill Anakin instead of bombing the temple? •What if Padme adopted Anakin •What if Maul killed Anakin during the Phantom Menace? •What if Riff Tamson killed Anakin and Kit Fisto (but Padme, Ashoka, and Prince Lee Char live) •What if the Son took and turned Obi Wan instead of Ashoka? It would make my day if you just say that you will do some (hopefully all) of these videos. Thank you so much😊😊

[@raww_dogg_1876]

This was by far the most enjoyable movie This was the perfect length 😊

[@redemption101caleb]

A good one would be “what if the Jedi saved the Night Sisters from Grievous?”

[@marikam2998]

What If Jasen Solo Was Never Turned To The Dark Side? What If Xanatos Was Never Turned To The Dark Side? What If Anakin Solo Was Survived? What If Mare Jade Skywalker Was Survived? What If What if Count Dooku Was Survived? What if Depa Billaba Was Survived? What if Siri Tachi Was Survived? What If Anakin Was A Obi-Wan's Son. And Satine? What If Anakin Was A Obi-Wan's Son. And Siri? What If Obi-Wan Secretly Arrived On Tatooine. And Stopped Anakin From Committing The Tusken Massacre? What if Jenza Was Survived? What if Bail Prestor Organa Was Survived? What If Shmi Skywalker Wasn't Anakin's Mother?

[@Bigdan678]

I love this episode

[@boydbeasley3751]

What if Rahm Kota trained Anikin? What if Chewbacca was a jedi?

[@brokenbridge6316]

Nice story suggestions

[@Dexterseditz]

The Baby Twins are so cute ☺️☺️☺️

[@john98765333]

45:54 Wait, Jabba the hutt was there?

[@Yetigaming420]

What if: anakin never fought obi wan on mustafar. This idea is a stretch but hear me out. When anakin sees obi wan he doesn’t over react and not choke padme. He instead attempt’s to choke kenobi

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Sabine Wren discovered that she was Force-Sensitive at the same time Ezra did in the SW: Rebels series.

[@thewarllama5635]

What if Anakin was given Barriss Ofree as a padawan. It would be interesting if she would still fall to the dark or if Anakin could inspire her anew since he wasn't as strict as Luminara.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Metra Surik didn't go to find Revan after defeating the Sith Triumvirate?

[@jonahstirbis3408]

Master plo koon helped change the galaxy yet again and managed to kill Palpatine like a true jedi.

[@teedepefanio4974]

Awesome story.. SUBSCRIBED ❤

[@Kane-qf8dn]

Fantastic!

[@Greetings_2]

plo was acting like his mantal health was hit by a truck in the beginning

[@rhydonbeacham]

Probably a bit of a stretch, but could you do a video where Aayla Secura survives Order 66 and raised the Skywalker twins, please?

[@Dexterseditz]

Day ??? What if Anakin Skywalker fell in Love with Yaddle

[@AnthonyPosi]

Dealing with this and never finding ahsoka before trade is the saddest.

[@mikekochendorfer7965]

"What if obi wan told luke about anakin's exotic alien apprentice"

[@MrQuest321]

Bravo 👏👏👏👏 excellent video.

[@StarlightWillow]

And jabba the hut 💀💀 I love Ezra sm

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Qui-Gon's lover didn't die?

[@HunterDrone]

you'd think palpy would be smart enough to realize that maybe trying to solo the guy who just curbstomped vader and the grand inquisitor at the same time is kinda dumb.

[@AryehKrauss]

Do tis bak at 7 pm

[@mikecotto1167]

One small error: there are 12 seats on the high council, not 13.

[@Alexrocks2024]

Plo Koon, going to Lothal, the home planet of Ezra Bridger.

[@titincat172]

I didn't expect a fanfic about suicide dang

[@rodgerscott8808]

What if someone brought Satele Shan through the world between worlds to help the order when the Sith returned?

[@shelledcrane0177]

What if Palpatine destroyed the Jedi by addicting them to death sticks

[@qeskill2224]

Holy shit plo koon was 385 years old when he died

[@J.M.Savage]

I'm not crying, you're crying 😢

[@TonyAncom]

What if the USS Enterprise NCC 1701-E, alongside a federation fleet (Star Treks federation), were transported to the Star Wars galaxy in the middle of the clone wars? Would be interesting as the Federations values would align with the Jedis in most circumstances.

[@InvaderMedia420]

OK this is the second time I’ve seen this animation I think the first time was the story what with Plo was the grandmaster but it’s a great animation

[@nicholas_gurr]

What if Barriss Offee joined Count Dooku and the Separatists instead of Bombing the Jedi Temple?

[@itz_beavis7674]

I love r2d2. But chopper has a special place in my dark little heart.... Love that lil war criminal...

[@noturaveragedad]

What a great movie!!!

[@orcslayer0485]

Wait a minute. I remember this. This is just an old video re-uploaded

[@joesturgess5906]

Fantastic

[@brianvernon249]

The Exile. Pls take ownership of her. No one else has. Make her your own. I have faith/force with you.

[@coreysteward9817]

Excellent story

[@Alexrocks2024]

The way Anakin or Vader sacrificed himself.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Sidious, Vader, and Luke all died on the Second Death Star?

[@simonschmidt5888]

What if Anakin, while burning on mustafar, realized, that he killed Padme, and when darth sidious came to retrieve him, he launched darth sidious into the lava?

[@zelouskight24]

You and those damn onions.

[@marionmcdaniel347]

What if Mace Windu killed Palpatine before Anakin arrived?