Breaking a Guy's Heart

[@Tranquility32]

I can’t believe the defendant’s smug arrogance at smooching a kiss to the Judge when the Judge commanded her attention. Wow. The lack of respect and decorum is astounding.

[@maryburke7850]

Right! I wish she would have thrown her out and gave her contempt of court!

[@sisteryaya24]

Yeah, I was wondering when the Judge was going to respond to her nasty attitude. That sweet guy should be really glad that he didn't marry her. She doesn't have respect for anyone!

[@jocelynoliverio585]

I was shocked that Milian didn’t call her out!

[@amira2736]

@@jocelynoliverio585 she missed it

[@trekgirl65]

And they do this in real court rooms also, thinking charming a judge will get them brownie points. Never works out that way in the end.

[@acz6017]

This dude dodged a bullet. You deserve someone better, props to you for not giving up and dragging her to court.

[@carolyndavis6657]

That’s exactly my thought. He seems like a nice person but her, yikes a piece of work.

[@lala95j]

He dodged a bullet. She pawned that ring

[@Ze_Moose]

She had no evidence of where that ring was

[@p1n3apple21]

Came here to say this

[@madmel128]

That's exactly what I came here to say... he dodged a big time bullet.

[@acz6017]

😂 he almost took one for us. Wishing best of luck to the other dude who is with her.

[@billmoran3219]

How you think her and ex went to Florida.

[@Perla_says]

If I was her mom I’d be dying of embarrassment, she’s nuts!

[@hottuna2006]

Apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

[@Marcus616]

The mom walked immediately away during the outside interview. I want to believe she was probably embarrassed, but more likely, she was upset at the outcome. I mean, she did raise her daughter to be the way she is. Smh! Raise your children to be good human beings and not snotty trash!

[@diva70smusic]

​@@Marcus616 Ditto!! My thoughts exactly!!

[@A_Demon_Doggy]

@The overthinking community was** is the correct usage, but nice try lol

[@SRFAA]

@@A_Demon_Doggy I think most say was, but were is correct. "If I were in your position..." vs. "If I was in your position..."

[@maryburke7850]

Wow!! She’s a piece of work! It’s the law lil girl! KARMA is REAL! Keep your head up young man you didn’t lose anything! 😊

[@thomas2732]

Omg buddy! What were you doing w that piece of trash!?

[@CandidLy1]

Not always- some come in to act as narcissistic perpetrators. They’re playing a role.

[@alissonvonderlane862]

Keep your head up and please wash it. Respect starts with yourself.

[@lesliemassey-or6cv]

In his recording, she never denied taking the box and never defended herself by reiterating that she left the ring where she said she did so…. She is definitely a very disrespectful user! Young man, she did you the biggest favor by breaking off that engagement!

[@Kayla-rd5jd]

that’s what i thought! most people would deny it if they knew they didn’t take it. regardless, she’s a nasty person & it’s just wild that she treats people like that especially a judge who’s deciding on her case. you’re also just a shitty person if you break off your engagement and keep the ring you didn’t buy. i’m sure he’s happy to be rid of her now

[@TheZogie]

User? I didn't get she was a user.. I feel like people are skipping past the fact that this 22 yr old was engaged to this man and he was never home at some point. I dont think she used him. I believe she loved him, but he loved his music gig more

[@bunji_beans]

@@TheZogie Being a musician is a job for some people and going on tour can take a while (2 months in this case). A lot of jobs require you to travel. But even if it was just a hobby, people are allowed to do what they love. The defendant came off as being too immature for a serious relationship. I mean, she couldn't even maintain one with her beloved chinchilla.

[@saramichele7366]

Exactly! That part!

[@ashrene4429]

It’s a shame that people are raising their children to become such little snots as adults. She kept that ring and thought so highly of herself that she wouldn’t have to return it.

[@RunninUpThatHillh]

Typical female of her generation. Entitled luddite.

[@gan-ban6083]

Just imagine what their kids will produce.

[@axl8653]

She's not a snot, she's a total b.

[@r1verman]

If she kept it, then she's a thief; if she did leave it, then she's an idiot. Either way she's responsible.

[@layahYasharahla]

I DONT THINK THE JUDGE CAUGHT THAT KISS BUT THANK GOODNESS I WENT TO SCHOOL TO TEACH LAW AND NOT PRACTICE IT, BECAUSE I WOULDVE LOST IT ALL AT THAT MOMENT😂

[@TopherGrant]

You called it right! Uncontrollable emotions have no place in law.

[@layahYasharahla]

@@TopherGrant I agree , yet police prove everyday that it is . But for the last 14 years , my temper has been working just fine . I guess it would have to be , to teach a bunch of freshmen. 📚🥴😉

[@KPbouj]

I’m 2 semesters away from law school and I’m trying to figure out how to “fix my face” because it tells everything 😂 maybe I will be better off just “looking mean” all the time like I used to do.

[@axon130]

@@layahYasharahla What? Policemen are heroes. Be grateful that they work to protect us.

[@KrazyVideoChick]

What would JM could have done? Yell and throw her out of court? I think she caught it and picked her battle and knew the case was already over so he bother addressing it

[@damnnerves24]

I love the way the plaintiff conducted himself in court even though he was heartbroken over the breakup. He came across honest and sincere unlike the defendant. His mom was right about being glad to be rid of her! He dodged a serious bullet!

[@LynneJordan11]

I bet his mom did not like her from day one!

[@Jsarmy87124]

he gonna write a good song

[@mamacindyrogofsky495]

Damn it! The plaintiffs mom should be proud. He opened the gate first for his mom. What a sweet boy. 😅😅

[@samanthamiller5298]

Not me rewinding to go back, and see 😂😅❤ he did 🥰

[@azrael723]

Watching her lose the chinchilla AND have to pay the ring back was GLORIOUS!😂

[@ChrisMayek]

I'm shocked the defendant wasn't kicked out after making that kissing sound

[@MichelleLeah]

Oh she would have been if this case was in front of judge Judy

[@christophernunn77]

@@MichelleLeah I think of Judge Judy often when watching the People's Court. lol.

[@nikkirene00]

I think the judge was just done with her.

[@christianWilliams-pc4jn]

I don't think the judge saw it. If she did she would have went off on her.

[@aaronwilliams9685]

Judge Judy wouldn't have let that shit slide!

[@kimberlyadorno280]

Yuck. He really got out in time. She's disgusting. If she can't control herself in a "court setting" on national television(especially considering the judgement doesn't even come out her pocket), she's just a nasty individual. Plus, leaving him for an ex? She'll reap what she sowed. She only asked for the chinchilla back in retaliation after receiving his court documents. Pathetic.

[@kiarifuller51]

Not gonna lie the defendant was full of crap 😂 she know she took that ring and used it to pay for her an her exes' trip to Florida 😂 trifling

[@CoopyKat]

@kiarifuller51 Remove "Not gonna lie" from your vocabulary. Why WOULD you lie giving your opinion about strangers you don't even know? The defendant was disgusting. Her disrespect to the judge and overall attitude will get her nowhere in life. She did sell that ring, one way or another. She's a liar and a thief. I'm glad she didn't get the chinchilla back either.

[@Nandi-jh6ll]

Milian let her get away with that sarcastic little kiss??!!!!

[@christianWilliams-pc4jn]

I don't think she saw it. She probably looked down right at that second or looked to the side.

[@badstate]

What a duplicitous little shrew. Jumped at the opportunity to get back with her ex and lies to keep the ring.

[@WWRNC]

I love when a self centered person receives their comeuppance from a courtroom. Dude dodged a bullet. Maybe even a bomb.

[@brittneyjake2010]

A nuclear bomb

[@samsamsek]

Wow, she’s a piece of work. I feel so bad for the guy.

[@Itsmyrap]

Karma is definitely coming for that woman. You just don’t treat people like that

[@CJ37.125]

Normally I feel bad when comments are made about the plaintiffs/defendants thinking that they’ll be reading it online. But damn. She needs to see how disgusting and disrespectful she was making faces and kissing noises?? at the judge. Shows her true colors. Not bright.

[@lcam9241]

Yes. I agree with your entire comment!

[@christopherchance4860]

if only!, I wish they had to sacs to come into these comments

[@jewdd1989]

Unfortunately most defendants/plaintiffs with that kind of audacity, narcissism and ignorance refuse to ever inquire on what the public or another period think because then they’d have to face another perspective! And that’s partly the problem with individuals like her and society, no one will say the truth so sadly the ppl who need it most (which we all need harsh facts at times because we’re human) continue to feel victimized and justified even when blatantly wrong

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

I don't think she has the self-awareness to process these comments even if she reads them.

[@brandonmoskos9149]

Seems like a nice dude. I like this guy. He is smart. She really tried to play him, he played her right back. Lmfao

[@barbaraellison1095]

That plaintiff is very fortunate to not get stuck with that girl.

[@oreolover9321]

I love the mom comment " im glad shes out of our of life"😂

[@unclebrother6244]

The plaintiff is too good for that arrogant, lying brat. I wish him the best moving forward.

[@KittyLewinsky7]

The plaintiff dodged a bullet he should be thanking God! Defendant has no loyalty or respect.

[@MJ-yw6uw]

I love when the jiudge's accent comes out. 😊 how did she miss the kiss 😂. I was waiting lol

[@SocalpoolboysLLC]

Mom so embarrassed she stormed by Doug 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@nicki8520]

Defendent's mom was embarrassed at the blown kiss to the judge hahaha that's why she walked off! 😂😂😂

[@BryRod]

The plaintiff is so handsome and took a huge step down dating her especially because her personality brought her down to a 0. I hope he finds someone that values him. She pawned that ring.

[@pickles5132]

He will be snapped up and make a wonderful husband to hopefully a lovely young lady.

[@namenamr4460]

There will be a nice girl who wants a nice guy like that. Thus girl is vile.

[@namenamr4460]

​@@pickles5132I hope he realizes he deserves someone who treat him right. Don't waste your time with this nasty girl.

[@JRico831]

Mom dukes is like “I never liked that harlot”

[@familytv9585]

I felt offended when she blew the kiss at the judge. I was disgusted it was as if it penetrated through my screen.😅 I felt like I wanted to wipe my cheek. 😫😖

[@TeeBradd]

When she did that kiss face to the Judge that’s when her true character started to show ! She was trying to play sweet all the way until that part smh

[@jamesmahlon8520]

Dude, you're lucky to be rid of that little boy girl and she has a horrible attitude and the judge must have missed that little kissing motion at the end cuz he should have charged her $5,000 for that. Good luck young fella!

[@markbrandon7359]

dude took a huge step down dating her

[@GoddessPower777]

She is something else. She knows she didn’t leave the ring and really thought she’d be able to get the pet..

[@missy67]

The plaintiff dodged a bullet with this one. The defendant was disrespectful to the judge. His mother made me laugh when talking to Doug - "I'm just happy to be rid of her"! haha; Her mother seemed very happy to leave and didn't want to talk to Doug!

[@TG-hp8og]

How can people not understand the difference in a present/gift ,and a engagement ring?? Huge ! Its not a gift, at all!

[@nikkirene00]

That guy should thank his lucky stars.

[@mirsan6705]

I'm glad plaintiff won and I hope the best for him. There are still worthy ladies out there. Best of luck man👍🏻 Almost everything in life is a lesson!

[@naiboogieb6587]

The judge shouldve told her off for that kiss 😂😂😂😂

[@LadyTShow]

She blew an "attitude kiss" at Judge Milian 🤨?? Too bad she couldn't be held in contempt!!!!

[@kietero]

1. Obvious she cheated on him. 2. He's dodged a bullet!

[@cnwil4594]

The chinchilla, "Hell no I am staying with Paul."

[@monikachrobak1823]

Wow she really showed her true colors over not getting her way

[@WolfamongSheep626]

Masculine, aggressive and condescending on national television, I can imagine how she is in private, he didn’t dodge a bullet he dodged an artillery shell.

[@mirsan6705]

She seems like a hothead, easy to piss off on the tv, cant keep her cool well. Can't imagine how she is in private lmao

[@laravelerrors]

why would you keep an engagement ring...what kind of respect you expect from a 22 year old baby

[@nativeroscoe64]

His mom, "I feel great, just happy to be rid of her." Say it straight... Hahaha.!!! 😆

[@arianefr78]

He's lucky he found out what she is really like before they had children together, he's well rid of her, but I bet when things go wrong with the old boyfriend, she'll be calling him trying to get back with him, he has to be strong and say a firm NO WAY...

[@darylrichardson8567]

She so pawned the ring & went on that vacation with buddy.

[@Marcus616]

Bro dodged a major bullet! Good for him. Based on her behavior in the court and with the judge, you can tell what a toxic person she is.

[@filmtorres]

The plaintiff dodged a bullet. She's a real piece of work.

[@Dizzyfingers2]

Wow. Did her true colors show when things went against her at the end. Nasty. Vindictive. I am 1000% sure she was already hooking up with the ex while the fiancé was on tour. Poor guy. She never deserved him.

[@glenncurley680]

He dodged a bullet getting away from that entitled Brat!

[@poshpearls23]

Yea, I would have made her go to the slammer for a weekend after that incredibly flippant kiss. I can't believe JM didn't address that. Guy dodged a life time of misery for sure. Wow. For my anxiety sake, I'm going to assume that the judge didn't see it. Lol

[@CanuckTony]

Her mom must be so proud of her raising of such a class act

[@ConcertoInD]

I imagine what would've happened if she smooched a kiss to judge Judy...

[@marystar6021]

😂😅😂 Judge Judy's famous stare alone directed towards her would have been permanently sealed in that girls mind! 😂😅😂

[@jayden4606]

I am shocked that she blew a kiss to the judge! I am going to assume that JM didn't noticed that?!?! She should have gotten kicked out!! So disrespectful!

[@Mbheather88]

You can tell the judge wanted to tell her she looks older than 22 lol

[@michelehemlokhexwhite4310]

😂😂😂

[@christianWilliams-pc4jn]

True she looks about 43

[@yung1717]

She doesn’t look that old

[@eyeeluna6684]

At first I thought she was a he

[@riggamorrischan]

@@eyeeluna6684 weirdo

[@prockjohn]

100% that girl is abusive

[@josephcatsanchez6590]

GREAT DECISION!!!

[@peterlafayette5595]

Fellow you dodged not a bullet but a Hand grenade, kidd! She's trouble.

[@doliveirajapan]

she took the ring to a pawn house and got like 100 bucks for that hahaha what a lucky man, he escaped a dark room with that ending

[@michellehard83]

Dude dodged a bullet

[@elliebellie7816]

Put your hand down. You'll get your turn. That is so annoying.

[@sammhammiam]

I would have thrown her out of court after the kissy sass.

[@ericamichelle99]

I love it when people who are always used to getting their way finally don’t.

[@wideawakeanimal1]

Did she blow a kiss at the judge?! I love how she got wrecked at the end. THIS IS JUSTICE!!! lmao

[@JEMustang]

I could have this wrapped up in 30 seconds. Defendant - give back the ring or pay him what he paid. Boom done.

[@erica8165]

Short haired, combative, leaves a 4.5 year relationship, good luck with future relationship. Not a recipe for success.

[@marystar6021]

I hope Paul is in a happy solid relationship today. There's al types of Amber Heards out there, and he definitely dodged one. Her display of arrogance doing the lip smooches spoke volumes of her character.

[@8thhousealchemist600]

The Defendant looks like a 12 year old boy. He definitely dodged a bullet 😅😂.

[@686JM]

The defendant chick is probably in the closet or has already came out with a wife. 🤣

[@alexrossi4464]

I don't understand why any women would wanna keep the ring after the marriage didn't happen. It would just be a bitter reminder. The girl that said she'd keep it after he cheated! Wow! Just wow! I also think forcing someone you supposedly love to spend 3 months salary on a 💍 ring is absurd and old fashioned. If people wanna live with modern ethics why hold on to antiquated customs? You shouldn't get your cake And eat it took.

[@malikshabazzbaker2868]

He dodged a huge bullet

[@Orcl1100]

The plaintiff was/is a nice guy. I’ll bet the chinchilla is happier with the plaintiff

[@mrshappilymarried1]

She's taking that lie and the ring to the grave...💍

[@billmoran3219]

Well the rings probably at the pawn shop, but I get what you are saying 😆

[@MikeNelli-uq2wl]

Her parents should be proud because she acts just like them. Who the f blows a kiss to a judge. Wish there was a fine for that

[@GloryStephane]

Good for him!!!!!

[@PHOENIX1699]

"With that other "boy"?" If a Man accidentally said "girl" she'd spilt a blood vessel. lol

[@SamuelGSherman]

BEST DAY EVER FOR PAUL

[@CoopyKat]

WHAT did the plaintiff see in HER? She was SO disrespectful to the judge when she was giving her ruling by kissing at her. The defendant is obviously a very spoiled person with no morals whatsoever. I'm disappointed that Judge Millian did not call her out on that sarcastic kiss, maybe she looked away and didn't see it.

[@johnmarin9369]

Can you imagine being married to THIS?

[@stayfocusedJV]

She did him a favor. Women well be with a guy for years while the guy they really want is out doing what he wants. Then soon as he pops back up in her life can't control themselves either run off or mess around with him until he's tired of them.

[@kennethbaker5223]

I feel bad for anyone that has to be within 10 feet of her.

[@tourissajoseph1378]

Can’t believe judge didn’t see her make that lil kiss at her 😂

[@namnack]

- But your honor, the pawnshop only gave me 750 for the ring. This is not fair!

[@Copanina]

EXACTLY!!!!!

[@kristin0408]

Whew, she is a piece of work.

[@thesource8509]

He's lucky he didn't marry her, he dodged a bullet.

[@melodiejohnston9528]

Good riddance to bad trash. The defendant is arrogant, entitled, and rude. Bet her parents are proud. God bless the plaintiff and God help the new boyfriend. IMO

[@wphill2]

Translation: I got back with my ex while you were away on tour.

[@DorothyCrowell]

Precisely* she's scjm

[@scotthewitt258]

I can totally understand a cheater not understanding principle.

[@larryblankenship8180]

Paul got lucky and didn't realize it

[@SAV1080p]

That defendant is a rude little boy. Smh

[@landonmiller5882]

She's a liar and the judge sniffed her out.

[@JeremiahLOsborne]

Those true colors sure came out pretty quick, didn't they? Too bad she lost. 💋

[@ebonyswope]

She took the box so she could own the ring. Her new boyfriend should be very concerned😂

[@NellieKAdaba]

Yes

[@iamthomasgreenman]

22 and a lot to learn.

[@ohshesglamorous]

He doesn't know how lucky he is to have dodged this bullet, hope he never goes back

[@eliyahudbenperetz1615]

Mom said it all, I'm sure after she said " I told you"

[@mrkh8627]

good on ya boy

[@Hotwingzlover84]

The Defendant sucking her teeth was disrespectful on so many levels.