Performer React to SHINee "Your Number" + "Sherlock" Performance Videos [Semi-First Reaction]

➫ FOLLOW JEFF
PATREON ‣ / jeffavenue
INSTAGRAM ‣ / jeff__avenue
TWITTER ‣ / jeff__avenue
DISCORD ‣ / discord
OTHER ‣ jeffavenue.carr...
➫ HI!
I am an actor and content creator with Hollywood credits including roles on Lucifer (Netflix), Starlight Christmas (Hallmark), JT Leroy (Universal Studios), etc. In this channel, I offer insight to Kpop performances using my 10+ years of training in dance, acting, singing and overall performance. In dance, my forte are contemporary and musicals and have done most of my performances in theatre. Although my channel is mostly known for dance analysis, I am currently inactive in the dance community.

[@CRISTINE8804]

Tmi: jonghyun was once chen and baekhyun vocal trainor back then and Sherlock was one of SM’s most expensive production.

[@phoenixspirit2503]

Also Taemin's as he has similar vocal techniques as Jonghyun who he learnt from...I love both

[@BunnyRea13]

I'm glad someone mentioned this. Some people don't realize how big of an impact Jjong had on other idols.

[@kundans9265]

@yummiwatch yeah, mostly Kyungsoo. That's why jonghyun and D.O sing and float with their vocals like it's nobody's business 🖤

[@nathaliasantos6778]

@yummiwatch I think was The One, who was also Taeyeon's vocal teacher

[@nathaliasantos6778]

@yummiwatch I didn't know that Jonghyun also trained D.O, thanks for let me know

[@milindawilson9175]

The way to honor Jonghyun's memory is to watch him in everything he did throughout his career and to react to his music and listen to his songs. So, go ahead and react to as much SHINee content, and even Jonghyun's solo work, as you can. It's OK if it makes us a little emotional sometimes, but the way to get to know him and SHINee better is to really spend some time getting to know them as the amazing performers that they are. All Jonghyun ever wanted was to make people happy through his work and to influence the world with his songs and lyrics. So, honor him by discovering what an amazing person he was and seeing exactly what he wanted people to remember him for. Yes, it's sad, but you don't necessarily have to make it that way if you just appreciate his work for what it is and live in the moment. His final words to the world were "Tell me I did Well." And that is what we fans try to do. By continuing to watch and listen to his and SHINee's music and appreciating the hundreds of clips of him we are lucky enough to have with SHINee as a group of 5, we are showing Jonghyun that, yes indeed, you did well and your life will forever be meaningful to thousands of people. You will never be forgotten Jonghyun, you did well.

[@JeffAvenue]

This is so touching! I agree. Appreciating his work, his passion and celebrating the life that he had is better and what he’d want.

[@user-fo1ni8wz7f]

Absolutely!

[@user-fo1ni8wz7f]

Jonghyun was brilliant, everyone should be aware of him!

[@jhsuperiors3435]

Well said💕

[@2MidnightBlue]

Diphylleia grayi of his makes me weep. It’s so hauntingly beautiful.

[@neowave2412]

THE WAY I SCREAMED WHEN I SAW THIS. SHINEE ARE MY TOP GROUP ALONG WITH NCT. THEY HAVE IT ALL.

[@berryweather]

OMG SAME! ❤️❤️

[@hanifahzakiyah4915]

ME TOO💙💙

[@wp8268]

BRO SAME

[@kete.C]

Shawolzen here too!!!

[@ffupelffuh5230]

Yh,, tbh now when i watch Sherlock's dance it will always reminds me of nct dancing to them in the weekly idol show hhh

[@sorrynotsorry6356]

fun fact: sherlock was choreographed by tony testa, who choreographed for michael jackson, britney spears, and janet jackson

[@JeffAvenue]

The flex 💪🏽

[@aviatorcap]

I remember the days where SM hired Tony to do every other choreo! Those were some fun times! I think he did workshops with NCT while they were still trainees too?

[@sorrynotsorry6356]

@@aviatorcap yup! i'm not sure if this is what you're talking about, but there's a video of him teaching them ask rookies: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aJPbZ2uaf7uBhKs they looked so small hahaha

[@aviatorcap]

Sorry Not Sorry yes! Tiny baby Jisung gets me every time hahaha, he’s so cute!

[@winwin-tk2kw]

aviatorcap He is Tony! oh my memory... thank you so much

[@nauraanindya4314]

That everysing ad is every early SM stans' nightmare.

[@aeri1633]

omg that ad was rly rly annoying

[@honeybeez4ever1]

😂😂 They were so bad.

[@karstinevillahermosa6813]

that ad was so annoying back then hahahaha

[@oOPrettywinxOo]

IT MAKES U THINK U CAN CLICK IT AWAY BUT U CAN'T

[@milindawilson9175]

"Sherlock" is a special song that combines 2 songs from SHINee's album "Clue" and "Note." That's why the title says "Sherlock (Clue & Note)" If you were to listen to the album you would see that they are two separate songs, but when you watch the MV the 2 songs are combined to create "Sherlock". SHINee debuted in 2008 and "Sherlock (Clue & Note)" came out in 2012, so SHINee had been around for almost 4 years and Taemin is 17 in "Sherlock." You might feel like Taemin's singing style is different here, but that's in part because he is still growing and maturing and his voice is evolving. However, one thing you have to take into account is the fact that Taemin's style as a member of SHINee is different than his style as a solo artist. As a member of the group, his voice is meant to blend with the rest of the members, but, as a solo artist his voice has no one to compete with or rely on so he has learned to cover a more full range, etc. Taemin didn't debut as a solo artist until 2014. The choreography for "Sherlock" was created by Tony Testa, a very well-known "Hollywood"-famous American choreographer who has also worked with some of the most famous artists, productions and dancers in the world, including Michael Jackson. "Sherlock" was the first time SM (or pretty much anyone in the Kpop industry) had ever used a famous choreographer, and at the time, it was the most expensive Kpop production ever. Once again, SHINee were trendsetters and because of SHINee's skill level, SM became one of the first to see the value in using a well-known choreographer to help create their dances and to strive for a level of choreography and video production that surpassed anything that had ever been done before. Today it's common place for Kpop companies to have really famous in-house choreographers, and to seek out people in the industry who are really making a name for themselves to choreograph for them, but SHINee was one of the first. There is a dance practice video for "Sherlock." One of the very first Kpop dance practice videos was from SHINee for their song "Lucifer" in 2010. So several of SHINee's songs that came out after 2010 have dance practice videos. In the "Sherlock (Clue and Note)" MV the boys are Sherlock-like detectives who are looking for clues in the spooky mansion. If you watch the regular MV, you will see that there is a "ghost" girl -- who is played by Jessica Jung, the former member of Girls Generation, which is SHINee's senior sister group, also under SM Entertainment -- who helps SHINee solve a mystery by leaving them clues. At the end they realize that the girl they have been seeing and chasing after all day is actually the girl that was originally involved in the mystery when they find an article talking about her from many many years ago and they discover that they must have been seeing a ghost. This was the era of Taemin with long hair. Although, in the MV, Taemin's really long hair was a wig. If you watch the regular MV you will see that he only has long straight hair during the dance breaks, but during the story sections (and as you see during the dance practice) his hair is much shorter and kind of curly. However, he really did grow his hair long for a while. Taemin with long hair is one of his most iconic looks and many in the fandom were really sad when he cut his hair. I didn't really like Taemin's wig look, but Taemin with naturally long hair is one of my favorites. Many people thing that Taemin with long hair made him look pretty like a girl, but I actually thing it's kind of a masculine look on him. It also made him one of the most popular of the members with their Japanese fans. The Japanese culture really embraces men with long hair and this was the era of when SHINee really started to solidify themselves as Japanese artists, so Taemin's look had Japanese fans gravitating to them.

[@JeffAvenue]

Thank you for all this info! I could do my own research but existing fans would know best! 😁

[@zscar_]

Some other k-pop choreographies Tony Testa (Sherlock) has worked on: -SHINee: Dream Girl, Everybody, Married to the Music -TVXQ: Catch Me, Something -EXO: Wolf, Overdose -NCT: Firetruck, My First and Last, Cherry Bomb -Super Junior: Mamacita, SUPER Clap -SNSD: Lion Heart

[@user-fo1ni8wz7f]

Tony is brilliant

[@Jojo-gf1el]

Damn, I like him

[@winwin-tk2kw]

I know him oh my

[@alyssaa.6484]

I LOVE ALL OF HIS CHOREOGRAPHIES!! Everybody will be forever be iconic!

[@xuanlu4554]

its TVXQ's Something got me into Kpop

[@cake6787]

shinee is honestly the perfect group for me theyre so insanely talented/charismatic even while off stage + their discography is perfect on top of it !!! they’ve got the best vocalist and dancer in the group too it’s just a given

[@zhulin2531]

New groups are trained to reach high standards, but SHINee is just so fun to watch.

[@cake6787]

@@zhulin2531 so true i feel like these new groups are attempting to reach a certain standard while shinee set that standard naturally

[@natalieramirez8744]

*SHINee are legends*

[@floramorgan6112]

FACT ONLY

[@nickolettegatica708]

yessss!!!!! i love them so much 😭💖💖

[@estellev795]

As a Shawol, I am so grateful that you reated to this and I completely understand what you might have felt while taking this reaction on. Time and again, I have mentioned this here that what you do is just some great work and thank you for all your sincerity, Jeff. I just want to say this here that I really want everyone to please understand that even though Jjong Oppa's name has become somewhat of a torchbearer for the topic of mental health in the K-pop community and even I want to support and protect the artists who are facing the same thing as him, I really want his name to be associated more with the work he has left behind for us to cherish. Please keep his memory alive as not just someone who suffered but as the artist that he deserves to known as. He was the first artist in SM to have full creative power for his album. He composed so many beautiful songs and there is so much to cherish him for. Let's remember the Jonghyun that was happy to see Shawols; the one who became a source of strenght for us. (If I said anything wrong, please feel free to correct me. I am just your little sister here.) Jeff, this is my request as a hardcore Shawol, please please please react to SHINee- Everybody(Tokyo Dome concert version) and SHINee- Excuse Me Miss.

[@phinesam7145]

I agree😁😁😁

[@lintangya]

ONLY AGREE also please react to excuse me miss

[@kazza3282]

Well said!

[@serionbee8586]

And Evil Seoul concert version!

[@micahm2177]

Strongly agree! I watch Excuse me miss like every other week haha!

[@kym4540]

Thanks for reviewing SM Royalty: SHINee. They are one of the first groups I was introduced to when I started listening to K-Pop almost 10 years ago. I also think they really changed the game in terms of how people view choreography in K-pop.

[@JeffAvenue]

Yes quite revolutionary huh? Like now kpop is best known for their intricate choreography 👍🏽

[@analubarb.2106]

And You need Excuse me miss live performance is so LEGENDARY

[@carlamhaetalagtag5450]

EVIL TOOOO

[@floramorgan6112]

EVERYBODY TOO

[@mariposasabia]

Omg it's so good, one of their best if not the best stage performance

[@daysjours]

@@carlamhaetalagtag5450 There is a concert version of Evil - maybe a fan cam...? - where Jonghyun goes well beyond the choreography. He is in another zone -- it's such a joyful performance because he looks like he is at last a free man :-) - he let's it rip.

[@celestialsilver2065]

SHINee are actually the group that got me into Kpop! The first ever Kpop song I heard was their song Lucifer. After that I just fell in love with them. SHINee has a special place in my heart because of that and I will forever remain a proud Shawol of a fantastic group of men❤️I’m so happy to see their legacy still thriving. Also! Key’s tone sounds different because he’s actually a Baritone! His vocal type is VERY rare in Kpop vocalists. But despite him being a Baritone, he can hit insane high notes. We stan an inhuman vocal range.

[@cristaljoseph290]

Same! I saw an article from a famous magazine in my country that was directed to teen girls, and there was a KPOP dedicated part, in which they showed pics of some MV´s and general information about them. The first one I read about was SHINee and the Lucifer track. I thought that that was an interesting name for a song and was kinda scare to watch it but did it at the end haha, I loved them since. (This was back in 2012). Jjong was my bias from the start and SHINee will forever have a special place in my heart and I will continue to support them. Its almost 12 years from the debut! Let´s have a nice anniversary fellow Shawol!

[@aniumar5964]

Shawols r keeping his memory alive...the fans n d members always think of SHINee as 5...n we r going to carry on support SHINee once taemin's hyungs r out of d military n wen they hv their first comeback. 25th May...is SHINee 12 yr anniversary...so i m taking this as an early celebration...watching ur reaction.😊✌

[@JeffAvenue]

Oh wow 12 years! Congrats Shinee!! Happy anniversary 😁

[@taeminsgf4275]

You should watch “stranger” by Shinee live Jonghyuns high note was immaculate 🙌🏽

[@Vonnie1490]

*chef’s kiss*

[@reign3004]

and also sherlock concert ver. 😊

[@calie7813]

Yes!!!

[@rainrain123]

I loved your reaction and I understand about you feeling uncomfortable and cautious. If you voice your thoughts on something there will always be people who will be against it. I am more into honesty. I mean obviously I love to hear good things about our boys. But I don't want people to look at SHINee as a sad group who needs validation from them to make them feel better. A reaction where people talk about dancing, singing, performance in all is much more satisfying than people who do fake reactions for views. That's why I like your reaction cause you talk about all that. Plus I too think Jjong and Chen's voices and singing ways are kinda similar. 😊 Will take the anime thing as a compliment. 😂

[@JeffAvenue]

Honesty is always key! 😊 And yes definitely a compliment 😁

[@kellytsai3]

Jeff Avenue I think it’s fine to react to SHINee’s music and performances. His life’s work should be enjoyed and not swept under the rug. The sad thing about being an idol is when their every action and spoken word is scrutinized by the public. Kpop idols in particular seem to have a much harder time being forgiven for being human and making mistakes, even the very minor ones. If Western artists were held to the same standard, there would be a lot less of them still working in the entertainment industry.

[@sheilavaidy]

Every member has such a unique vocal tone, and yet they all work so well together. Shinee really is THAT group

[@JessicaLopez-wc4oh]

Me: Wow he is reacting to SHINee!! 5 secs later: This must be a surprise huh

[@neowave2412]

By the way a lot of the members have done musicals. Onew also did Opera. Jonghyun is* my favorite member from SHINee and it was so hard listening to music (his music especially) when it happened but in the end we (fans) want him to be remembered for his music and his talent not what happened to him. * I mean he is my favorite member because despite his absence he really lives in through his music. Just to clarify that sentence. I’m thankful that you decided to react to SHINee and that you opened up about your thoughts. Being a performer sounds so exhausting thank you for the art you guys (artists) create 🙏🏼 Also: this is a live version of Sherlock (it’s so amazing) even if you don’t react to it I hope you watch it because it’s incredible: kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2XTeoGXnaeiiLs

[@JeffAvenue]

Ohhh nice! Glad they’ve also embraced that side of the entertainment industry. And i totally understand how you feel!

[@dewinurmayati6808]

Key and Taemin also did musical.

[@sarahparrish2927]

Please react to SHINee’s Everybody!! The choreography is so insane! like will not be disappointed at all!

[@moemoekaillaan]

yesss ^

[@safetyseftianin6563]

Up

[@daysjours]

Mind blowing!

[@shafiraauliaputri1974]

exactly!!!

[@mithrilg2286]

I'd rather people listen to Jonghyun's music and say they don't like it than never listen to it at all

[@stephanieylanan5545]

Jeff to Onew: his smile is very contagious Me: *yes jeff, your smile is very contagious too*

[@JeffAvenue]

😁😁

[@sallyahmad3581]

The shockth when you know that the long hair is TAEMIN himself that did MOVE before 😂😂😂😂😂💪♥️♥️

[@cindyhuang6399]

Lol I cackled when Jeff was flustered with the permanent included ads in old sm mvs😂

[@stephaniehu8489]

I'm so happy you decided to try to get to know this group! Their style and sound is always changing, so there may be some times that some songs appeal to you and others not so much.

[@JeffAvenue]

Something for everybody then! 😁

[@analea10]

@@JeffAvenue Yes you can say like that, actually is very rare someone that understand music don't appreciated SHINee, some songs maybe isn't your cup of tea but at least you can notice how talent they are how powerfull their voces are, each of them are different and powerfull in solo but when they are together they really shine, you can see they don't fight for spotlight they push the other to light, I don't know if I made undersatand my English is not good. You know ,once a reporter said that he never see in this industry someone give to other to shine, but when he ask to Jonghyun about the song he did for SHINee he explain why each member have that part ,because he knows their voices and because of that he was able to give to them what was best for their vocals, I think the reason SHINee still exist today apart of their amazing talent is because all of them put SHINee in first, for them SHINee and Shawols come first.

[@stephaniehu8489]

Since you mentioned Lucifer, I can't wait for you to check out that dance practice lol. I'm pretty sure that video popularized dance practice videos, even if they're not the first to post their dance practices.

[@worldcitizen6542]

This!

[@crftieph]

It was the first one I watched when I was young. I didn't really know it was kpop back then because I just really liked dancing. But when I got into kpop I found out it was Shinee! 😅 Taemin's iconic shirt

[@floramorgan6112]

yesss they popularized dance practice !

[@raoreok3032]

shinee made the dance practice trends 😤 legends yall

[@dotonboritakoyaki]

@@crftieph omgosh u reminded me of that legend shirt again lmao. i prob watched it 10 times a day in lucifer era sjjdksks

[@jadynyamakawa9434]

lol the evolution of taemin's hairstyle is truly amazing

[@analydglez]

So glad you reacted to SHINee! They are a fantastic full package group, their vocals got me but I stayed for the chaos, they are a fun group. To get the full experience, I recommend you watch, "Married to the Music" (the performance video) and their live performances of: "Excuse Me Miss" (very RnB influenced), "Odd Eye", "Dynamite", "Picasso", & "Like a Fire" to get you started. Thank for reacting, I look forward to seeing more from you. Ta-ta!

[@06Nyx]

Imagine my delight in seeing a SHINee reaction! I’ve been a fan for... 10yrs (omg where has the time gone?!) and it’s always fun seeing people learn about them nowadays. SHINee is such a talented group, I hope more and more new Kpop fans give them a listen. When it comes to Jonghyun, I hope that people see him as more then his tragedy. He was so much more then that, he was soooo talented, sensitive, bold, thoughtful, sexy, funny as hell... just flat out awesome ❤️❤️ I hope that with more reactions you can see how amazing these guys are~

[@lauurzagaste4292]

Alright, this is my first comment and will be long. Might be weird specially since I've been silently following your videos for a while now but I need to put this out. As a Shawol (the fandom name of SHINee) I highly prise you for doing this. For years now there's been two options for people when it comes to SHINee. Some of them have been hesitating on reacting or even referring to them when cause they don't wanna be disrespectful. The majority tho, and sadly, took the second option of referring to the group and making sure what happened was highlighted or centered as the only thing that matters in order to get attention or whatever. Kpop used to be different years ago and just a few of the previous generations' groups keep working as hard and faithful to themselves in other to keep their dream a living truth. SHINee decided to do exactly that, get themselves together, stand up and give honor to Jonghyun by doing what he wanted to for them. But I keep feeling that this kind of thoughts restrict their light among a now forth generation that grows mainly cause of youtube and communities sharing and creating content of them. I'm tired of people referring to it as if the end would be more important than the whole journey. I want people to set their minds out of the bloom and actually accompany SHINee into a new path. SHINee as a group and every single member deserve to have brave people out there that brake the silence and rub their talent on all our faces again. No fears attached, no side intentions but enjoying a great SHINee performance freely. Thank you so much for doing exactly that. With all that said. A couple of fanfacts. Before Lucifer, kpop groups' dance and choreographies where not meant to be powerful or stunning. They set a new spotlight for dance. AND Sherlock was choreographed by Tony Testa and remians as one of the most highly invested comebacks for SM. You're doing a great job, keep it up.

[@JeffAvenue]

Thank you for your continuous support even if it was silent 😊 i totally get it now after a long reflection. It has always stayed in the back of my head and I’m glad I finally did this. Just enjoying talent like I initially set out to do 👍🏽

[@sage5515]

Well said my friend

[@estellev795]

Before I watch this reaction, thank you so much Jeff for reacting to SHINee. They are the reason I am a K-pop fan. They have been pioneers of so many trends for the K-pop world and have been given the title of 'Princes of K-pop'(Wikipedia). They are one of the best performers out there.

[@myqwertymind]

Been waiting for your Taemin reaction, never thought and surprised that you reacted to SHINee instead.. you said before that you already quite knew SHINee and because of Jonghyun you're not going to react to them anymore except for Taemin. I already accepted that, but thank you so much for such a great surprise today.. It's like an advance SHINee 12th year anniversary (May 25th) treat for us, Shawols. Hopefully you could react to Taemin on the 25th. Thank you again, Jeff.

[@fernandaandradediaz3506]

He reacted to Taemin before (Move), but he doesnt like it, i dont relieve he will react to him anymore. But for me it was a surprise too

[@aniumar5964]

@@fernandaandradediaz3506 he did react to taemin japanese song...famous...the practice n live performance...i think he appreciate taemin nw...i love our maknae...🥰he has so many different sides to him...

[@bitchesproofbarbie]

You know Jeff got a very good impression of SHINee when he decided to focus on the vocals instead of the choreography and the dance! He literally talked about their vocals 80% of the video 😂😂

[@haebaragijangmi4505]

First of all I would like to thank you for reacting to SHINee. You dont have to be worry on us shawol. Some people might be a bit sensitive, but over all, we are a very calm fandom and I hope you can react to SHINee just the way you did to other. That would be great just like this one. No need to worry too much 😊 we are all good .

[@isitnewyears]

It makes me happy when people react to SHINee still because Jonghyun would have been devastated to think his passing would make people look at his group differently. He loved being in SHINee so much and I think it was the main reason he managed to keep going for as long as he did despite how hard he was having to battle against depression. For other suggestions, I think my favorite dance practice is the one for ‘everybody’. Their live performances are also incredible and definitely worth a watch, especially any from their Tokyo dome concerts.

[@cake6787]

2:01 do you see jungwoo and taemin’s resemblance? it’s insane how alike they are even in dancing + mannerisms (if you don’t see it literally google side by sides they give me whiplash to this day)

[@JeffAvenue]

OMG 😳

[@xuminghao_oney2572]

SHINEE'S "EVERYBODY" CHOREO IS A BOMB ! 💯💯

[@milindawilson9175]

That's SHINee for you, pure greatness. And pretty much no one will argue with you on that fact. LOL :D SHINee are one of the top groups that are known for the fact that they all can do it all. They are a group of 5 amazing vocalists, 5 impressive dancers, 5 visuals, 5 rappers, 5 top actors, and 5 of the most talented and unique voices in all of Kpop. As I often tell people, once you get to know their voices you will always be able to pick them out of a crowd just by the sound of their voice. I can tell who is speaking or singing within 1 second even with my eyes closed with them standing in a crowd of people. Each of their voices are that unique -- there is no one with a voice like any of their's. And that is also why they are known as one of the group with the best harmonies. Their perfect 5 part harmony is one thing they are known for. That is why they are "The Princes of Kpop". BTW, did you notice that "Your Number" was one of SHINee's Japanese songs? So they are actually singing in Japanese. SHINee are some of the most popular artists in Japan, even more popular than a lot of Japanese artists. Most Japanese people don't even consider them foreign artists. SHINee spends about 50% of their career promoting in Japan. So they are all fluent in Japanese.

[@tejesviniramesh525]

I really love it when anyone appreciates shinee the way they deserve 💎 💎 💎 💎 💎

[@theabruun1028]

"His face just makes me smile, it's so contagious." This is a perfect description of how it feels to be Onew-biased. You smile just from looking at his smile.

[@daysjours]

Agreed. Taemin too has a smile that is so warm & embracing. Onew's smile is adorable.

[@that_one_vampire4371]

I'm so happy that you're reacting to SHINee but man I cried I'm not going to lie I miss him so much. but you still brought a smile to my face so thank you for that

[@artistblue18]

You have to listen to watch Shinee’s Live Performance of “Excuse Me Miss” . They are in all white outfits and every member is blonde during that performance. I would say it is definitely one of the best performances I’ve seen from Shinee. I’m sure others have probably already suggested it.

[@pumpuiish]

I would like to recommend you to watch shinee's concert stages! it's really fun and they perform really GREAT! search shinee vi concert and enjoy! :)

[@LynxKT]

These two videos are my most watched of SHINee ... they really show off their vocals and dance skills and overall charm!

[@margaretyoung9488]

Sherlock is the song that got me into Shinee!! All of them are ACE!!

[@ayaerika]

SHINee just give u straight out talent and good vibe thats how i started stanning them 7 years ago and im still proud of them

[@julyanasanchez2137]

AGH JEFF YOU REALLY FED ME THIS WEEK WITH MONSTA X & SHINEE🥺😭 my two ult groups! I’m glad you were able to do this video!

[@JeffAvenue]

I read your mind 😉😉

[@julyanasanchez2137]

Jeff Avenue we’re intellectuals & we love to see it ahaha

[@devakibhagwat6146]

I can't help but smile when you say that Taemin's sound is so different now. That's his personal style that he mainly uses for SHINee songs. All the members of SHINee have this was of changing their personal styles up when they are performing as a group so they still maintain a distinct sense of individuality while also blending so well as a team. They are so different outside of the group but as a group, they are an impeccable collection of teammates. They are actually known for not overpowering each other and being a seamless unit!

[@notur_cass]

Yassss I'm so happy that you reacted to SHINee. They're my ULTIMATE group

[@bluesmon7904]

shinee was the first group to break stereotypes in kpop, regarding music style, dance, fashion, and hair styles, they broke through many barriers, and kpop is largely because of them today. thank u for react to them, I hope you'll do it more often 'cause worth it

[@kete.C]

SHINee just makes me smile every time

[@ikaokta5142]

As a SHAWOL we always feel greatfull if anybody could react to SHINee especially to celebrate their 12th anniversary..maybe you could also give a reaction to OUR PAGE n FROM NOW ON also their UNPLUGGED MEDLEY where all their voice so so so beautifull..hope you can always supporting SHINEE 😊😊😊😊

[@eyla107]

OMG YESSS DO MORE OF SHINEE 🥺

[@SUNGMISH]

ive been listening to Sherlock for years, this song never gets old i love the everything about it especially jonghyun's golden vocals NO ONE WILL EVER BEAT HIS AMAZING VOCALS P.S: CHECK f(x) THEY ARE A DANCE GROUP SISTERS OF SHINEE ID recommend RED LIGHT/ 4 WALLS/ NUABO/ THEIR ALBUMS

[@juliacaesar3450]

SHINee legends!!! Please love SHINee!!!! 💙💙💙💙💙

[@phinesam7145]

I love “your number” soooo much. Jonghyun’s fate is what it is. Sadly he is gone from us, away in Heaven and watching over us now. But seeing him in the video makes all of us happy and remember when he was by our side. It gives many of us hope. Shawols are happy to see your reactions since it gives them attention and makes us happy to see other’s opinions on it😁 Thank you 🙏🏻

[@Linanid]

Oh what a pleasant surprise!! I was planning on going to sleep (it's 7:30 AM where I'm from and I haven't slept yet) but then you decided you react to my ult fav group so lol sleep who idk her

[@JeffAvenue]

This sounds like me recently- Staying up all night 😂

[@Linanid]

I mean, this quarantine got our sleeping schedules messed up haha. Anyways, let me first say that I'm so happy you decided to react to them and I totally understand why you were hesitant at first. But the thing is, we don't want shinee to be pitied or to only be remembered as "that group" bcuz of the tragedy. Instead, let me tell you how AMAZING of a person/musician Jjong was. He wrote and produced a bunch of songs for other idols. When Taemin asked him to give him one of his songs "Already" he gave it to him in a heartbeat and in fact told him if he had told him from the beginning that he wanted it he would've altered it to make it fit within Taemin's vocal range. He also wrote a song with taemin called "Pretty boy" in which he sings with Kai from EXO replying to haters who used to call Taemin feminine because of his looks and hair, he used to tell him to be proud and embrace himself. He was Baekhyun and Chen's vocal trainer at some point. Shinee was SM's treasure and they've achieved so much that even President Obama loves them. Sorry for the long comment, I hope I didn't bother. Thank you for all of your hard work Jeff!

[@supreeella5935]

My first kpop group. I was 10 when i stanned them

[@rouaace5936]

jonghyun will stay 4ever in our heart we will remember him nd his music

[@itsMizaa]

I used to listen to Sherlock and Shinee’s song every day. Wow, can’t believe i’ve been a Kpop fan for so long.

[@avnimisra6950]

2nd gen kpop music will always remain timeless, and so will shinee, along with everything Jonghyun worked hard for. thank you for doing this reaction and being so genuine

[@sjames1955]

I love Shinee. Their live concert performances are where you can really see how amazing they are. Try Evil from SWC III. Another level.

[@bouirbouir5033]

i love shinee soooo much, they're one of the most versatile groups i know (with red velvet ofc)

[@eveslyra4889]

you can't imagine my happiness whenever jeff points out key, i love the way he dances

[@LiaLucina]

I’m glad you’re reacting to them! Like you said I think it’s nicer to keep appreciating the art and even if there is critique, it’s ok as long as there’s no ill intent (which there isn’t from you so 🤗) It also took me some time to get into SHINee for personal reasons but I’m so glad I gave them a chance Maybe you could check out the live for excuse me miss, I love that performance ✨ (the Sherlock live is also amazing btw 🥺✨)

[@gabsmoon_]

honestly, I'm so grateful to you for the way you did your reaction. I personally do not mind if people react to SHINee after what happen because I want more people to listen to their music and discover the amazing world of SHINee as well as their solo music. What I don't like is when reactors go on half a video saying "omg rip jonghyun the voice we lost uwu uwu" like we know believe us we know! I'm not going to watch a reaction for them to remind me of what happened I'm going to watch it because I want to see what they have to say about a group that I admire and love. So I thank you for doing that for giving your professional view on two of my favorite choreo of them and also for sharing a part of your journey which is similar to the journey our jjong went through to become an artist. I hope you react to more SHINee in the future or to some of the solo stuff each member has done ^^

[@li_xirui]

OMG I came here so early!! I'm so excited to see this bcs SHINee is my favourite group

[@shrusti]

Tbh all SHINee songs are timeless, I can go back to Replay and jeep dancing to it even in 2050 and further..

[@eve_ss7780]

SHINEE EVERYBODY IS A MUST! PLEASE 🙏 THANK YOU FOR THIS REACTION btw ❤ PS: SHINee basically started the trend of Dance Practice videos in Kpop ❤ STAN LEGENDS 💚

[@codebrker24]

You should watch the entire concert of Shinee. They are LEGENDS! Thank you for doing this. The respect you have shown all the Artists' that you have reviewed is much appreciated and respected. I find your take on the tech aspects of what they are doing very informative and insightful. Thank you for your great work.

[@fionam3904]

YYYAAASSS!!! I've been wanting to heat what you had to say about shinee for awhile. I would recommend everybody, 1 of 1, and good evening

[@geli233]

thank you for reacting to them. jonghyun is still here. he is in the music and the people who still love and feel something when they listen to his music and watch him perform. its okay to get emotional because it is a sensitive topic. but shinee continued as a group because jonghyuns mother wanted them too. please continue to support, listen, and love shinee. its what jonghyun would have wanted.

[@jessielee6423]

Yo should watch some of the live hard performances of Sherlock, Stranger, Everybody, Picasso, Evil, etc. They are just insanely great 💕 Thank you so much for this reaction. I'm looking forward to watching more reactions to SHINee. I also think that's a good way to remember the great job that Jonghyun did along with SHINee ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@katiaichigo8778]

Okay, now I want more SHINee reaction videos ! maybe the live of "Excuse me miss" which is epic ! I'm happy whenever I see ppl still admiring them, because they really deserve it, they are great performers and they sing really well during lives !

[@PaulineDuhadinLife]

Omg I'm so happy that you're covering the shinee topic. Because let's be clear everyone. SHINEE LEGENDS, GODS, DANCE MACHINES, VOCAL KINGS, KPOP TREND SETTER.

[@bouirbouir5033]

jonghyun was just playing with his middle school band on the streets when the sm recruiter saw him, he wasn't even singing but HERE WE ARE

[@HiHello-kg8fe]

Thank you for reacting to SHINee and we would like to see more of them

[@TheHekateris]

The truth is that SHINee have been teh trendsetters from debut. Where SHINee goes, everyone follows, no joke. I highly recommend their dance practices! And as you watch SHINee, you'll understand Taemin better, too. All members are soloists, btw! And honestly, SHINee are much better live - they're called CDnee for a reason... One more thing: please take care of yourself, too. We all feel for our Moon Prince, and he was always open and supportive of people's feelings. He would love you reacting to SHINee, and understanding what he (and Sulli and Goo Hara and far too many to others)went through. ♥

[@Shanana529]

Yaaaaaaas SHINEE they deserve the attention and love. Shinee everybody choreo is amazing 👍also more Taemin solos 🙏 press your number, drip drop, sayanara hitori. Shinee is known for their amazing live vocals as well it's worth checking out.

[@718pjm]

you dont know how happy i am right now truly im so happy that you thought about it and give it a change... gave shinee a chance... sherlock is such an iconic song and i recommend for you to react to their live performances!! i think mvs are amazing but their live performances are just on another level cause shinee always gives their 200% to show their best to the fans and audience!! 💗 and also give it some time... the first few reactions will be nostalgic and kinda sad but you will get used to it... as a shawol i tell you when it happened of course it was so hard to listen shinee music and jjong’s solo work but with time it’s not that hard anymore... i remember him with a big smile on my face now without any pain... of course i miss him but it doesn’t pain me as much anymore i think but anyways looking forward to your shinee and their solo work reactions :D

[@rosechan670]

your number is one of my favorite shine songs and I wasn't expecting this omg my day has been made

[@di2taws932]

Just try to see their live performance.. it’s amaizing.. sherlock, everybody, dream girl, excuse me miss, dynamite, evil, etc and also there’re a lot of live dance performances of SHINee’s japanese song.. like dxdxdx, picasso, wanted, and many more..

[@Decayedf]

FINALLY SHINEE TIME!

[@adir5805]

Sherlock is my favorite SHINee choreo it's just so unique! It's all about the confidence. Whenever other groups perform it it is just never the same. SHINee makes those moves their own every time it's amazing. Thank you for doing this!

[@kaitlint05]

Hi, Jeff! I understand and respect your reasons behind not wanting to react to SHINee sooner and it wouldn't be fair for you to do something you're uncomfortable with (it really resonated with me when you highlighted that fact how lonely the industry is, despite outer appearances). However, since you've reflected upon and changed your decision, I want to share how this video made me feel. I became a fan of your channel mainly because of your NCT reactions, however, I've been a long time Shawol even before I was a Czennie. In general, it's become more rare to see SHINee reaction videos for reasons that include (but are not limited to) respecting what happened with Jonghyun, and their inactivity as a group/not releasing anything new lately (mandatory enlistment for Onew, Key, and Minho). So, it personally makes me so happy to know that people like you allow SHINee's music to live on for the people that hold these songs close to their hearts and want to celebrate SHINee's legacy! Additionally, it's also a really great way to show (newer) fans of, for example, Taemin if they found him through SuperM what kind of a performing history he comes from. Thank you 💙

[@JeffAvenue]

Thank you for this and for understanding where I was coming from 😊 So happy to have made so many people’s days today with this video 😁

[@ninaaleethbustamante7038]

Thank you for reacting .. I've been waiting for this reaction .. SHINee is my first true love in kpop. They introduced me to love kpop. It was really sad as to what happened to Jonghyun. He is one of the best vocalist and songwriter of kpop. Its really our loss as Shawols .. But the positive comments and encouragements of people like YOU means a lot to us. God bless you more. Amd please do react more of SHINee ..and NCT as well 🥰 -- a subscriber and a kpop follower from the Philippines 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭

[@cybersunnie]

AAAAAAAAAAAAH YOU REACTED TO MY KINGS 5HINee ❤️ I HOPE YOU REACT TO EVERYBODY AND SHERLOCK (CLUE+NOTE) AT TOKYDOME THE BEST💕

[@twidlings327]

Sherlock is a timeless masterpiece! I still love the choreo to this day! And Taemin has a very versatile voice and has sang in this style for quite a few Shinee songs especially in this era, like Why So Serious. You should check it out!

[@samanthaspain6130]

Shinee's Hello is my favorite song by them, I wish Jeff could react to that song. Jonghyun's vocals in that song are my favorite besides Lucifer.

[@Jossjoestar1]

SHINee is NO JOKE, KINGS OF KPOP

[@breckencarter5069]

Please react to more SF9!! Now or Never, RPM, Enough, K.O., Good Guy, Fanfare and Jungle Game are all amazing! Chani has some MJ inspired moves in Now or Never.

[@hasseylivinepark6157]

Finally!! Someone mention Sf9!!😉😉

[@Karabintree3]

I love new Shinee songs, "Good evening" is the first song they put out after Jonghyun. And I feel it is very beautiful song, not only in the visuals but the emotions of each member, and the tone of the song.

[@hshamilt2]

You did an amazing job. Seeing you react to SHINee made my heart really happy. I finally subscribed.

[@JeffAvenue]

Aw thank you! Welcome officially! 😁

[@atsuminatsume2492]

THANK YOU JEFF!! SHINee are my childhood idols because i grew up listening to their music when i was 4 (2009) and up to now, so seeing you react to them means alot! You reacted really respectfully so don't worry about it! I actually found your views on their music and dancing really nice to watch ^^ you did them well Jeff! Thank you for reacting to my childhood idols!!

[@arriekim952]

Wow! I love SHINee that I click it fast when I saw you reacted to them and your reaction was great, commenting every second in detailed I really appreciated it, thank you for that. Hope you keep on reacting to their performances, have a great day 💎❤

[@thekeytomyheart_]

So happy Key is getting his recognition as a dancer. Key is considered the lead dancer after all. I think both Taemin and Key are at the same level but just different ways of dancing to the choreo

[@lori4021]

I'm so glad that you changed your mind and made this reaction to SHINee. I've watched several of your videos before and enjoyed your dissection of each performance or MV. Hence, I was sad when you said you will not be reacting to them because they're the reason I'm finally listening to Kpop. Thank you so much Jeff. This is a very detailed reaction, one that is much appreciated. I hope to see more of SHINee in your channel. Keep safe and healthy.

[@renzacris]

I was surprised seeing this video and it almost made me cry. Thank you for checking them out. You took a lot of courage. You'll not regret it, I guarantee that.

[@Quinton_Phambam]

OMG I LOVE THIS SONG, NEVER EXPECTED THIS TO POP UP IN MY NOTIFS

[@desynatalia298]

oh my god ive been waiting for this! thank you Jeff for doing this, on SHINee's month too! you really should check out Excuse Me Miss from SWC IV, you'll be blown away (the whole concert is a masterpiece to be honest). again, thank you for this, i'll be waiting for more SHINee reaction from you :)