Perpetual Motion Machine (Sept2014)

Perpetual Motion Machine
A desktop free energy device based on the principle of electrostatic asymmetry. (Response to this video seems to have polarised into two camps, those who understand and those who don't!)

[@100roberthenry]

The onlly way to prove this works is to build it from scratch With independent witnesses, and on independent witness cameras....otherwise everyone will say there is a battery Inside it etc....come on, update it...

[@robertpowell2225]

Finally an intelligent and fully functional scientific apparatus. this demonstrates static electricity principles and they have been shown to work and other types of devices. this is a straightforward honest attempt to show that you can have electricity static electricity move objects . this has no real torque or power but it is an excellent fun device that anyone could build to have something to watch and talk about.

[@xFlairniv]

+Robert Powell I don't know English, use translator on the Internet, you could write how the author explains it.

[@HitAndMissLab]

+Robert Powell Can't agree more: straightforward and honest.

[@thequixotryworkshop2424]

@@xFlairniv Hey Igor. Did you managed to replicate what Mark did here? Please let me know. Christoff.

[@xFlairniv]

@@thequixotryworkshop2424 Unfortunately, I don't need to let you know what I'm doing or whether I've done something like that.

[@mrspockyt]

This is a fantastic presentation. A very well done. You deserve alot more than 374 Subs come on people hit that button. I look forward to seeing your future work,

[@MarkWaller]

Thanks. You can see more of my zany stuff at "MarkWaller99"

[@Hutch5321]

Very nice. Thank you. A. D. Moore would be very proud!

[@MarkWaller]

Proud or cross - I am not sure which!

[@rockerape]

Hi, I want to build one of those. Could you make a tutorial please or post the materials. Thanks in advance.

[@Lechoslowianin]

regardless of how this is done, it is done very well and looks credible

[@charlie_a_2406]

Very impressive static motor, kinda reminds me of a Holtz electrostatic generator. If only we could power a model boat with it! I would Love to see it running on static from an antenna during a thunderstorm. I'm thinking of making a "corona motor" over lock down (no pun intended). Thanks for the inspiration.

[@haroldkline4898]

Nicely done! What an original approach! I am going to replicate this immediately! Thank you!

[@thequixotryworkshop2424]

Hey Harold. Did you managed to replicate what Mark did here? Please let me know. Christoff.

[@tedyfanita1]

??? 😂I’m going to try it anyway

[@anasqai]

So as u can see it spins continuously, so at the sides will generate heat which can be turned into Electricity, means this is already a Power Generator, i call it: Free[]Energy.

[@smokyatgroups]

Would connecting the stationary metal strip through a load resistance to the sharp points allow a small current to flow? If so would this current be reaction-less?

[@maherfallaha7404]

Someone said that there might be a fan above the wheel that causes the rotation however if this true you might try to make the weight of the wheel as light as possible and the two pins too close to the wheel.

[@MatrixLeTV]

is there a capacitor in or a charge on the axle? it would only take button cell if not I'm very curious yet impressed...use truth to hide deception or is it real perpetual motion? well done either way

[@DisneyGymGirl]

This is pretty cool but I would love to see you do an experiment where you place your device on a 5 to 10 dollar rc car, (super light weight) using some sort of capacitor and get it to move. Then you would have something awesome to show for it and possibly even patent. The car wouldn't move very fast and may be jerky but at least you could show that it actually generate usable power.

[@davidvalentin7694]

Love the idea, the concept is a little beyond my electro-static understandings. I would love to build one of these machines in my machine shop. Could we by chance open up correspondence on your idea? I would love to prove that this machine works. Maybe we could talk and I could get a better handle on what is going on with your machine.

[@min2oly]

Examine the V holders on either side would you imagine those to be something trying to be friction free - or something trying to GET friction.... It's the latter. There is either one or two pager motors right before your eyes in the axle. They or it is/are activated when he places the wheel in the V's he never really shows it spinning long enough I imagine it would spin out of control. Cheers - Patrick

[@notmuchluck]

If you watch closely you can see the v's move into the poles they are in, like a switch.

[@HitAndMissLab]

Mark, bravo. Both for intelligent machine and for scientific explanation. Try to scale it up.

[@OverlandOne]

There is an electrostatic device producing energy off camera.

[@danu4886]

WoW! ^^ itz super awsum!!! Thank u for showing us annnnd explaining it

[@kelvinsparks4651]

A very interesting build , well done. I have to give this a go at building myself. I love to read the negative comments on perpetual machines, I think in general they can't grasp the concept that perpetual is not meant to generate power out side of what it takes to run itself lol .

[@thequixotryworkshop2424]

Hey Kelvin. Did you managed to replicate what Mark did here?

[@kelvinsparks4651]

@@thequixotryworkshop2424 unfortunately not yet , things have been so hectic of late I've hardly had time to even think about it lol

[@prathambhandoria6038]

@@kelvinsparks4651 do you make ?

[@kelvinsparks4651]

@@prathambhandoria6038nojjt yet but definitely going to give it a go

[@zeffur7]

This must be a trick of some kind. Waller's explanation doesn't jibe with electostatic theory. Static charges lose charge as they are influenced by other charges to reach a state of equilibrium.

[@consciousenergies]

My guess would be a wire connecting the bearings through the chassis. Basically a homo-polar motor with a small battery and magnet in the axis of the wheel. The reason I say that is because you notice towards the end of the video when he lifts the apparatus. It begins banging on a brush. It seems to express a decent amount of torque and continues with adequate speed. I guess one never knows until one tries though. If anybody has replicated or knows of a replication video I would enjoy watching. Unfortunately, I don't have the time to do one.

[@zeffur7]

Diadon Acs The disc is thicker than it needs to be also. So are the uprights for the 2 posts. Perhaps a nice place to hide magnets & electronics....

[@erlendse]

Could be electrostatic, but would require a supply not seen at all in the video. Its a pulse motor or usual dc motor somewhere. Not very worthy the time.

[@zeffur7]

It appears that he may have magnets embedded within his rotor along the circumference of the rotor. If that is true, then all he has to do is provide a pulse magnetic field to his conductor posts with battery power to cause an emf that will rotate the rotor.

[@wizgang0]

Have seen a few of the "fake" videos and it seems that they are not creating it per the specs shown to us here. Will be trying to build one this weekend.

[@IronLilix]

I would like to know about the two conductor, what type of material are made? Plastic, metal or what?

[@theDaftman]

so after analysing the audio of this video and removing your voice can you explain the very quite fan funning in the background then.

[@youeffohs]

Plans? Thank you!!!

[@user-ym2in5sk9p]

Where can download a text file description of the English language ?

[@valveman12]

I am awaiting for the reveal video showing how it actually works. The description makes no sense.

[@Trunkswr]

Automatic clocks certainly had you beat good Sir! First *electric* perpetual motion machine maybe?

[@naokikashima9349]

Awesome video, brilliant if real, not brilliant if faked. It is simple enough to replicate.

[@michaeltaylor8075]

A homo-polar motor with the battery hidden in the axle?

[@innovator1998]

Scientists and engineers accept the possibility that the current understanding of the laws of physics may be incomplete or incorrect; a perpetual motion device may not be impossible, but overwhelming evidence would be required to justify rewriting the laws of physics. Any proposed perpetual motion design offers a potentially instructive challenge to physicists: we know it can't work (because of the laws of thermodynamics), so explain how it fails to work. The difficulty (and the value) of such an exercise depends on the subtlety of the proposal; the best ones tend to arise from physicists' own thought experiments. Because the principles of thermodynamics are so well established, serious proposals for perpetual motion machines are met with disbelief on the part of physicists, which makes a discussion of the merits (if any) of the proposal difficult if not impossible.

[@beforebefore]

Interesting... Care to demo it outdoors?

[@FIntel-nk2bs]

At 58 seconds it looks like the axle is spinning. The axle looks the size of a micro motor. But still a good performance.

[@anasqai]

I think, at the side add copper wire to connect, then this copper wire, loop a normal electricity wire = Electricity will run into the Wire and Just connect the end to anything u want to provide electricity. There is 2 Point of the Wheel, so both ways can create Electricity. The thing to discover is: if bigger/more copper = more electricity or fatter wire = more electricity(but i discovered that, fatter wire can Hold more Electricity, means i discover can make a "Sudden Fullcharge").

[@clayscreations9300]

Seems like static electricity how long does it run

[@anasqai]

Magnet in the wood right?

[@fathicoltd6774]

I'm really curious about the physics of what you've made. May i ask about explaining a bit more? because in my idea it seems possible. And I want to make a really big one.

[@fathicoltd6774]

And I'm an Electronic engineer, skip the simple stuff!

[@graemx]

Hi Mark, I'm based in Oxfordshire, how do I contact you? I'm an engineer and wish to run something passed you. Many thanks

[@frank0067]

umm your ON KZbinand perpetual motion has been accomplished by number of folks for a long time

[@anasqai]

This Free[]Energy Method of my Discoveration is by "Heat of Friction".

[@pugalstech]

Very nice project

[@roland999100]

Dear professor , please confirm if its fake or not? you were good teacher , we need to understand this lesson. Thank you & Best regards

[@joetherocku2ube]

Mark, I made a machine like yours. It doesn't work. Did you use foil on one side of the disk? What material did you use on your studs?

[@danielassayag1484]

what if there was a fan blowing air outside the frame of the camera?

[@childrenoflight3010]

He used a fan some mate holding it for him

[@theprinceosama1]

I don't see any small generators?!

[@domestead6923]

Hi Mark, this is fantastic! You never mentioned who the inventor was, did you invent this?? Kind regards

[@MarkWaller]

My creation. (And, by the way, no fan involved!)

[@domestead6923]

@@MarkWaller Your creation is genius Mark, I have no doubts about its working. After all, we are living in an electric field. What are your plans for the concept?

[@viktorvan3342]

Hola Mark, buen video... pero ya paso mucho tiempo como para que nos expliques si es Fake o No y como lo realizaste.....Saludos!!!!!

[@user-du2hy9do9y]

Интересен принцип работы, а я к сожалению не знаю вашего языка.

[@RODOLFO.M.S]

LEGENDA 😭

[@andel68]

You'll never ever can reach enough electrostatic charge in this way to turn the wheel

[@wizgang0]

This i amazing!

[@charly71072]

0:39 La struttura è pesante e nasconde delle batterie. Quando appoggia la struttura di legno sul tavolo è evidente, dal rumore che fa, che pesa troppo..

[@user-du2hy9do9y]

Если автор показывает себя, значит он не обманывает.

[@philippebertel1779]

.............bonjour........... Judicieux très bon.... Courant statique effets d'oppositions siclique de la roue BRAVO clap clap clap

[@sachinsutar-ses2189]

I need formula and what are materials is required for this project, please guide

[@andreasschmitt2307]

You need just a fan.

[@RODOLFO.M.S]

🇧🇷👍🙏🏼 Legendas 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@oudotcom]

Or he just uses 2 micro mobile phone ringer vibrator motors for the axis and gets the current in via the 2 axis connect points and in the stands are just 2 button cells. The axis really looks like 2 of these tiny motors...

[@philipnelson7613]

Direct question to you mark. Why?

[@antoniofidanzio16]

con le ruote si puo creare il moto perpetuo ma non e applicabile a qualche attrezzo meccanico io ho fatto il moto perpetuo con un sistema di leve con qualcosa che non posso dire parto con un motore di 1.5KW che faccio funzionare le leve (6)dove ottengo i stessi giri che inserisco 40 e in uscita collego un generatore che mi da 13KW dopo aver aumentato i giri a 1600 l'attrezzo lo si puo vedere su KZbin scrivendo moltiplicatore di potenza

[@damonmangrum5805]

Is that middle thing a motor

[@MarkWaller]

Er.... Yup!🤦‍♂

[@luishernandez-kb8jm]

There must be some air pushing the disc. Why you do not enclose it in a acrylic box ? Answer is simpke, this is a scam.

[@user-ku6nl5lr2w]

complimenti molto interessante , io sono italiano e mi piacerebbe averne 1 costruito da lei, chiaramente pagando

[@wbeaty]

Let's see. I've built many such electrostatic motors. If I had to guess, I'd say that this is an "Electrophorus cake," and it self-powers in the usual way that Electrophori always do. I bet it won't work if the wood is replaced with plastic. Where electrostatics is concerned, wood is a resistor: a connecting wire.

[@HitAndMissLab]

+wbeaty Hi, why would you want to make it so it doesn't work? Did you try to replicate this machine?

[@wbeaty]

+HitAndMissLab several others have built this and found that it doesn't work. (Search for their videos, and the comments for each.) But, this failure is expected, since there are NUMEROUS hoax videos for free-energy on youtube. KZbin is famous for fake free-energy. Maybe someday there will be a genuine discovery posted here. But nobody will believe it, because of all the fakes. However, the motor in this video might be an INTERESTING fake, and not just using some hidden batteries, or drive belt made of black thread, or wind from a hidden fan, or ion-beam from a VandeGraaff machine off camera. If it involves Dielectric Absorption or "soakage" of the insulating black disk, then the disk will behave like a leyden jar. But it would become a weird leyden jar which only can discharge very slowly. Capacitors with charge trapped inside the dielectric will "self-recharge" if not kept shorted with a wire. This "self-recharge" might be used to power an electrostatic motor. It might run this disk motor for quite some time, perhaps many minutes, before needing another re-charge.

[@HitAndMissLab]

+wbeaty Thanks! I've checked more than half a dozen videos that tried to replicate this one. In 90% of cases they haven't included metal plate on the back of the disc rotor, that's clearly shown here. They've only done tape-overs. Of course its not going to work, because the metal back plate is there to increase the amount of charge on the tape-over. Other guy connected it to the Van der Graaph's generator and it claimed it doesn't work. Which is clearly a luck of understanding. As long as the charge Q is of the fixed quantity it works as perepetum-mobile. In the above example Mark Waller clearly shows that he applied a certain fixed amount of charge to the device. Its not that YT is plagued by free-energy fraud. Its plagued by curious, but ignorant people, who expect to invest one hour and get Nobel. On YT people make claims before they made an effort to understand the phenomena. You seem to know more than the rest, so I appealed to you to possibly replicate this. Because you can at least explain it properly, how fields work etc. I am going to replicate it as well, its not that hard to make. One can use the old CDs because they are already perfectly balanced.

[@Felixwurth2405195709]

sehr schon ! neue physik fliehkraft . felix würth googel de

[@mehdiautisme5587]

Hi if its reall why there is no replication that can work properly

[@koaladude4912]

mehdi autisme the reason why is because they don't do the trick behind the scene.

[@anasqai]

Oh maybe u melted screws and nuts then that one is not aluminium. So its the screws and nuts(silver colour).

[@Spaceon84]

Он будет работать если диск электрет!

[@childrenoflight3010]

We can't see the hair dryer blower or your mate holding it

[@teslapark3406]

Hey we just got through telling the other guy this is not perpetual motion it is electrostatic even it won't run forever when you get high humidity in the air they will stop and restart that's because it's static electricity, static electricity was known before batteries were, Nikolas Tesla stated that when we learned to hook to the will worlds of nature. Can you just started learning that! Good job

[@MarkWaller]

In the (almost) ten years since I first posted this video demonstration of 'perpetual motion,' I have never claimed that it would solve the world's energy problems. One reason for this is indeed that static electricity performs poorly in damp conditions. Anmyone with a basic knowledge of science will underrstand the other reason.

[@jshaw4757]

​@@MarkWallerCan you make a bigger one mate and see what power u can actually get I'm not sure how you would harvest any power too turn too electric but would be very cool if you could try....people seem too get very uptight on such videos and hung up on the idea off complete free energy when too me it's about creating ways too improve energy usage which in a way is still free energy if you improve efficiency you are gaining extra energy surley...maybe I'm misunderstood but my project is salt batterys and I'm trying too find ways too improve the ampage if u have any ideas be much appreciated...cheers

[@giannineve]

Come mai lo divulga sena brevetto? C'è una batteria

[@HikikomoriDev]

You are a funny man.

[@acepilot2067]

There. Is. No. Such. Thing. As. Perpetual. Motion.

[@Mateo-vl3zv]

I tryed to make it and it doesn't work.WHY?

[@aukemichels5182]

Because you forgot to install the tiny motor that moves the disk.

[@sultanalkharraz6807]

you need someone with a tube to blow air on it ;-)

[@aukemichels5182]

You're right... there's another video demonstrating that :)

[@the101dad]

Then it’s not perpetual motion, it is using outside forces to continually turn. And violates the laws of thermodynamics….

[@leonardoleonardo1285]

ciao Mark waller aonon un italiano quello che ho visto in questo video è molto bello me en potresti costruire uno che funziona come questo e lo vendi?

[@user-du2hy9do9y]

Видимо для того чтобы узнать принцип работы. Согласен с вами.

[@larrybacacao9504]

he painted one side black

[@trailgaze]

Ok so this is a simple electrostatic motor. it still requires a static charge to run so its not free energy. Nice try.

[@samchamas1896]

hint, caps.

[@user-du2hy9do9y]

Жаль что нету объяснения на русском языке, а этот генератор имеет место существования.

[@artofnoly9754]

Build one before you knock it... cheap enough, surely.

[@reyalicea]

Electrostatic motor.

[@MrMichaelnev]

IS ONE SIDE OF THE WHEEL GOT A FOIL COATING

[@IronLilix]

I tried to replicate the prototype, but it does not work, need any more details unless it is a fake. Best regards

[@unitittii]

The Axis is totally perfekt done.

[@IronLilix]

This axis is perfect, the problem is that there is no difference of electrostatic charge !! and everything stays in balance !!

[@julienmarre4836]

Emanuele Ferralasco Hi, of what did you make the pointed conductors? Regards

[@IronLilix]

Julien Marre Hello I tried before with a plastic tip conductors like these: www.myo.it/myoShop/prodotto/prodotti-ufficio/accessori-per-scrivania/articoli-vari/puntine-per-pannelli-in-sughero-o-feltro-39751 Tthen with all-metal conductors pointy like these: lavoretti.crescebene.com/lavoretti-con-materiale-reciclato-la-panchina-con-gli-sci/chiodi/ But it takes no electrostatic charge !!!

[@witcheddoctor2720]

Well study physics and enginerring

[@192kHz32Bit]

And if U understand elekrtomechanism the explained technic has NO funktion here.

[@baddinosaur1548]

It would be very nice if we could put people that make scam videos in JAIL.

[@GGCGAGSG]

Wait…. Conductors have charges? What? Hahahahaha. How do you keep a straight face?

[@nateh32]

Allow me to be the first to comment. You are generating energy from charge outside the machine itself, so it is not a perpetual motion machine in the traditional sense.

[@zeffur7]

N Hanna Perpetual motion means it runs perpetually without providing an external power source. If one could tap into zero-point energy (i.e energy from within the vacuum of space, then that would drive a perpetual motion machine--it would also mean the owner wouldn't have to pay any electric company for power...)

[@user-ul5pm2lx2g]

А есть объяснение на русском.?

[@MarkWaller]

English?

[@user-up3hp7yf3m]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqSbh5-KbbqhfLs

[@user-bg3oi8yx9q]

@@MarkWaller Это не обязательно , достаточно подробных чертежей чего старательно избегает автор. Очередной фейк не более.

[@Elnufo]

Nice build, but its fake.

[@silverwiskers7371]

im going to have to call this out, its impossible, no way it can work, NO WAY IN HELL

[@viktoria33]

Жалко что он говорит на непонятном для меня язьіке. Видимо он рассказьівает как и с чего собрать...

[@mediaguardian]

Sigh.. There is no such thing as a perpetual motion device. Thermodynamics 101. Even if you are not providing it direct energy, it is still getting its energy from somewhere else. Which means it is not perpetual motion. A true PMD must be self contained with no power source coming from outside.

[@techstuf4637]

Where's the fun in that? Dodgy blighters in the establishment science community are always adapting their con games. The moment a gravity powered perpetual wheel us truly revealed, the intellectual cowards will say "It is powered by gravity, which comes from outside the device, so it's not perpetual motion" trying (yet again) to dodge any truth that embarrasses their pasty and petrified egos.

[@user-xy3jt6nw5o]

This is nothing fake twists

[@mariusnegrau7395]

Pierdere de timp si.........

[@Suproxus]

The fact that people think this is real is so stupid

[@MarkWaller]

Agreed!

[@Suproxus]

@@MarkWaller YOURE LITERALLY THE CHANNEL CREATOR WHO SAID THSI IS REAL THE F*CK DO YOU MEAN

[@Suproxus]

@@MarkWaller PERPETUAK MOTION IS A LIE

[@AntonioFidanzio]

e unmoto perpetuo figurativo non serve a niente e solo figurativo come dire ANCHIO HO FATTO IL MOTO PERPETUO che non serve a niente quando lo si fa con le ruote INVECE fare il moto perpetuo con le leve (6) con qualcosa che non posso dire ottengo la rotazione 1 a 1 con yna maggiore potenza PARTO con un motore di 1.5KW che da 1400 giri che li riduco a 40 che sono uquali in iscitadove collego un generatore dopo aver aumentati i giri a 1600 che ottengo 13KW che e anche èiccolo per lo sviluppo che mi da l attrezzo tutto questo lo potete vedere su KZbin scrivendo MOLTIPLICATORE DI POTENZA

[@CallsignAS]

"electrons"

[@texjarhead]

He actually shows his face in this fraud.Absolutely no shame.

[@bs-phd131]

Totally agree, we all know its fate; All can see it’s just a paper weight 🤪👍

[@bacckko1]

fake!!!

[@baddinosaur1548]

Show us the air pressure that you're using to spin the wheel. Scammer

[@bobyno976]

100% fake -1

[@celsoneves2368]

Total fake

[@djemi3etelminigeekandhacke343]

Faaaaaaaaaaake