Perpetual Motion Video

A perpetual motion machine based on the design by Mark Waller.
In my video, I disprove the use of a fan blowing on the disk.
My version does not use a fan.
Please watch Mr. Waller's video, first, at
• Perpetual Motion Machi...
Then watch another video where someone tries to discredit Mr. Waller's design.
• Perpetual Motion Machi...

[@larryscott3982]

Happy April Fool’s Day

[@danieleberselli5332]

Complimenti.. è possibile acquistare un modello a scopo didattico/dimostrativo ?.. grazie infinite

[@ArtLieberman]

L'unico valore educativo sarebbe guardare il video e cercare di capire come funziona. (Spero che questa traduzione sia corretta.)

[@fleischflote2761]

This looks fairly noice :) does it matter what material the nails are? or just something else than copper? or maybe best something that is far away in the Galvanic series ? :D very interesting :D thank you for the food for thought :D

[@ArtLieberman]

The choice of materials does not matter. Iron, copper, aluminum, ...anything. Keep thinking.

[@YML1357]

Obviously fake. Jump cut the video to show a diagram of a transistor an then holding the wheel from spinning cause it was turned on

[@ArtLieberman]

@@YML1357 No, nothing changed about the wheel when I cut away. (I should have made the video without the graphic.)

[@YML1357]

@@ArtLieberman please make a video again

[@garygarner3940]

Did you say you used copper strip's and not alumium

[@ArtLieberman]

Yes.

[@garygarner3940]

@@ArtLieberman thank you--i'm starting to work on mine now

[@garygarner3940]

Can you tell me where you aquired your copper strips

[@ArtLieberman]

@@garygarner3940 simply search Amazon for copper tape. However, you should keep in mind that it is impossible to build a perpetual motion machine.

[@garygarner3940]

@@ArtLieberman Thanks---going to work on it

[@goranz9446]

What kind of material is the disc and is wood sutable for material?

[@ArtLieberman]

The disk is PLA plastic. Yes, it could be made from wood.

[@goranz9446]

@@ArtLieberman Do you guarantee that this device works, because lots of people made it and said it didnt worked.

[@MehmetBoysal]

I think best will to use a rigid polystyrene foam

[@goranz9446]

@@MehmetBoysal Did you make this motion making device?

[@MehmetBoysal]

@@goranz9446 you asked: Yes that's exactly what I meant. You asked, "What kind of material is the disc, and is wood suitable for the material?" so my answer to you was: I think the best will be to use rigid polystyrene foam, for the wheel only of course.

[@JustMe-im8ch]

Woww, looks like an amazing scam

[@ArtLieberman]

Ah, but how?

[@JustMe-im8ch]

@@ArtLieberman bcoz there are batteries hidden somewhere

[@ArtLieberman]

@@JustMe-im8ch If batteries were part of the answer, then I think it would need more than just batteries.

[@Hutch5321]

It's almost like a self-powering variation on the Wimshurst Machine. Years ago I was in contact with Dr. Antonio Queiroz from Brazil, following his extensive work with electrostatics. I was going to recommend that he look at your page and Mark Waller's, but unfortunately he has passed. I think he would have been fascinated with it. Thank you for your work, Art. Excellent!

[@AntonioFidanzio]

fare il mote perpetuo con le ruote non a nessuna applicabilita perche non a nessuna potenza invece fare con un slstema di leve (6 ) con qualcosa che non posso dire(SEGRETO) ottengo la rotazione 1 a 1 con una maggiore potenza questo lo potete vedere su KZbin e scrivere moltiplicatore di potenza che con un motore di 1.5KW che fa 1400 giri che li riduco a 40 chr sono uguali in uscita dove collego un generatore che mi da 13KW a 1600 giri dopo collego altri attrezzi ( allinfinito)e fare una centrale elettrica a costo zero

[@garygarner3940]

Very nice indeed !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! there's always going to be trolls that cant stand somebody doing something that they can't

[@andreasschmitt2307]

The obvious difference to the fan powered original is the huge rotor. There are dozens of possibilities to hide your engine and batteries there, I'm sure it's enough room for the radial engine of an RC plane...

[@khushwantmistry1031]

😂 shaft of wheels have micro motor which used in mobile vibrator, these motor connect to small lithium battery

[@ArtLieberman]

(Is there a way I can contact you privately?)

[@jameslacey858]

At 44 second mark of your timer the speed suddenly changes after you place something on the table ?

[@ArtLieberman]

Hi, James. I promise I'm not doing anything tricky, there. It's not speeding up or slowing down. It's just the effect of the frame-rate of the video, the blinking rate of the light bulbs in the room (yes, incandescent bulbs produce a strobe effect at 60Hz), the spacing of the copper strips, and the speed of the wheel. Do you ever notice in commercials for cars that sometimes it looks like the wheels are turning backwards? Same thing. Basically, it's a stroboscope effect.

[@HannsGruber]

Here's a suspicious cutaway to something unrelated as I get up, don't worry about how my wheel changes from a matt finish to a glossy finish. It's totally the same wheel, guys!

[@chodechotchney5331]

Bazinga

[@nikoverde4735]

Something happens to the speed at 21 second from the start and from 33 second

[@ArtLieberman]

Hi, Niko. I promise I'm not doing anything tricky, there. It's not speeding up or slowing down. It's just the effect of the frame-rate of the video, the blinking rate of the light bulbs in the room (yes, incandescent bulbs produce a strobe effect at 60Hz), the spacing of the copper strips, and the speed of the wheel. Do you ever notice in commercials for cars that sometimes it looks like the wheels are turning backwards? Same thing. Basically, it's a stroboscope effect of the video.

[@delburtphend6016]

I set up two wheels as in ‘wheel and axle lrn fzx’ right by each other. I used the wheels as Atwood’s with the same extra 20 g mass added at the 35 mm dia. One of these two Atwood’s machines accelerated 120 g at the 35 mm diameter and the other accelerated 40 g at 105 mm diameter. The 120 g was a string with 60 g on each side and the 40 g was a string with 20 g on each side. The strings were draped over their appropriate diameter of the pulley. I ran the two Atwood’s at the same time and they accelerated at the same rate. That means that the 40 g was accelerated to three times the velocity as the 120 g by the same input energy.

[@ArtLieberman]

Please watch Mr. Waller's video, first, at kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6PIdH16q66LaLM Then watch another video where someone tries to discredit Mr. Waller's design. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hYKTfoGNdpaLq7M

[@VesuviusAntaria]

At 1:50 he turns the wheel and it immediately stops spinning. He then shows another video for distraction. When he turns the wheel again at 2:23, the wheel suddenly continues to spin. The camera remains in the same position. He does not reveal what is hidden behind it. There is no such thing as perpetual. It's still a fake video!

[@ArtLieberman]

I promise that there are no tricks in the video. Further, there is nothing behind it. I probably should remake the video.

[@VesuviusAntaria]

@@ArtLieberman Thank you very much for your message! If what you say really works. Why can't other people copy it? If it is actually a perpetual then you are really the first to give everyone a head start in technology. And then you get all the credit for being the first to do it! According to the laws of physics it turns out not to be possible. The same thing that water doesn't fall up, or that Snow White comes to visit me.

[@ArtLieberman]

@VesuviusAntaria In a few weeks I will post a better video. But you are correct, perpetual motion IS impossible.

[@VesuviusAntaria]

@@ArtLieberman Thank you very much!

[@tedyfanita1]

Impressive!🤔 static charge, foam, plastic,nails and aluminum 🤔🤔🤔

[@sandorkurucz2989]

Gratulálok.Ez biztosan nem csalás!.Kár,hogy nem lehet energia termelésre használni,de kétség kívűl legyőzi az ébredő surlodási és egyéb vesztességeket!

[@ArtLieberman]

Ne légy ilyen határozott. (Remélem helyes a fordításom. Magyar?)

[@david-pb4bi]

If it’s so good why aren’t we driving around in it?

[@teslapark3406]

Your video was okay perfect I would subscribe to your channel to see future videos. But there is a few issues with your point you were trying to make, perpetual motion means something that will run forever we know in this universe will run forever not even Stars called the sun. So try using the word indefinite motion indefinite means that we don't know exactly when it'll stop but run a long time. Perpetual means that you will run forever without any other source of under its own power. You measure that against light not even light lasts forever. Second I can tell if your video was fake so you didn't need to go to the extremes even though I enjoyed that you did, your motor is using electrostatic the atmosphere. And will run definitely, meaning that it will run until there's not static electricity in the this would Tesla was talkin about using the wheel works of the world to power your, if you keep going down this path you will discover a world in which they don't want you to know about. Suggest you learn how to take that motor and draw power from, the easiest way to do that in the way you designed it is to turn it into acourse you're not going to get a lot of power from it but you should be able to take very small motors and draw something from. Keep in mind we've have done these experiments here because we work for a company called Media Library which is an actual Library. We will be doing similar experience in the future so if you go to his website you'll be able to see what you did is not only true it is factual and they knew this long before they even created batteries. Will also give you where we got our information from and proof where you can get it too, just to let you know high humidity will make that motor stop😢 but we'll start as soon as they humidity is gone. Here's the channel to Media,: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bX-0gIWEeK1oiZY Particular video I chose for you will show you how to increase the power of your little device , you should be able to hit the subscribe button from. Hope this helped you and good video 👍

[@ArtLieberman]

My machine is not affected by humidity in any way.

[@robertparker1662]

Nope! Perpetual Motion Devices are not possible. The reason this spins, even under glass, is that there is a high-voltage generator, be it Van de Graaf or Tesla Coil running in the background.

[@ArtLieberman]

No, there are no external forces. But keep thinking.

[@MehmetBoysal]

First of all thanks so much Art for answering lots of questions below. But one thing no one has mentioned here or elsewhere. I wonder if the mental intention of the person affects the electrons to accelerate and rotate the wheel or get stuck and do nothing? Those that failed to achieve success seem to be angry or bitter and those that achieved success are delightful happy people. Art, what is your thoughts on this, thanks. 🙂

[@ArtLieberman]

I love your comment! I view myself as a delightful happy person. But it doesn't come from creating perpetual motion.

[@MehmetBoysal]

@@ArtLieberman LOL, yeah of course not. I like your answer too. Maybe electrons respond to inner joy, who knows.?

[@lindaellison899]

cool!

[@jeffburtard2386]

Very interesting, I would like to see the backside once you started it turning. You as a magician could have a motor hidden on the backside and switched it on when you pushed the wheel. Redo the video with multiple camera angles to prove your point. Thanks

[@ArtLieberman]

The video does show the other side. I promise you that there is not a motor on the other side. The two sides are identical.

[@eastky1901]

What does your version use? If it isn't a fan, then there must be a spinning magnetic device under the table, turning it by Lenz effect. Or induction

[@ArtLieberman]

@@eastky1901 No magnets. Nothing under the table.

[@goranz9446]

​@@ArtLieberman So whats the catch then, dont leave us in uncertainty? What is the hidden power source for the wheel spining?

[@madsen6320]

That's awesome

[@THEMFORMATION]

God bless you sir. This is why they banned mercury

[@goranz9446]

How, why mercury?

[@THEMFORMATION]

@Goran Z Because when a + - current over a ring magnet is applied to bowl of Mercury it produces rotational movement in the form of a vorticee

[@goranz9446]

Of course, what did you expect, thats show electric motor works, nothing spectacular. Mercury is restricted not banned because is extremely toxic.

[@ArtLieberman]

@@goranz9446 I use to play with mercury when I was a kid. Freezing it with dry ice. Shining quarters with it. Maybe that explains a lot about me!

[@goranz9446]

@@ArtLieberman Not realy. But you did not confirm will the wheel work if I make it?